Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 20 of 2019
Sri Tushar Kanti Datta,
son of late Birendra Kishore Datta,
resident of Arya Colony, P.O & P.S: Belonia, Dist: South Tripura
---- Appellant(s)
Versus
1.
Sri Pijush Kanti Datta,
son of late Birendra Kishore Datta,
resident of Arya Colony, P.O & P.S: Belonia, Dist: South Tripura
2.
M/S Maa Kali Brick Industries,
situated at-Village-Chittamara, P.O-Chittamara, P.S. Belonia,
District-South Tripura, represented by the partners namely:
3.
Smt. Anju Datta,
daughter of Sudhangshu Bhusan Datta,
resident of Arja Colony, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
4.
Sri Radha Raman Datta,
son of Sudhangshu Bhusan Datta,
resident of Bankar, P.S-Belonia, District-South Tripura
5.
Sri Gopi Dev Roy,
son of late Amar Krishna Roy,
resident of Bankar, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
6.
Sri Prahlad Datta,
son of late Premomoy Datta,
resident of Chittamara, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
7.
Sri Kamal Sarkar,
son of late Bhagaban Chandra Sarkar,
resident of Hrishyamukh, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
8.
Sri Radha Ballav Datta,
son of late Premomoy Datta,
resident of Bankar, P.S-Belonia, District-South Tripura
9.
Sri Sanatan Pal,
son of Sri Sunil Pal,
resident of Bankar, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
10. Sri Babul Majumder,
son of late Subal Chandra Majumder,
resident of Shaltilla, P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
11. Sri Narayan Bhowmik,
son of Khetra Mohan Bhowmik,
resident of Village & P.O. Krishna Nagar, P.S. Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura.
---- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
Ms. S. Nandy, Adv.
Date of hearing and
delivery of
judgment and order
:6th January, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
:NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Judgment & Order(Oral)
06/01/2022
(S. Talapatra, J)
Heard
Mr.
Samarjit
Bhattacharjee,
learned
counsel
appearing for the appellant as well as Ms. S. Nandy, learned
counsel appearing for the defendant No.1 and Mr. Somik Deb,
learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents No. 2,4 to
9 and 11.
[2]
This is an appeal under section 96 of the CPC from
the judgment and decree dated 30.04.2019 delivered in M.S. 03
of 2016 by the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No.1, South
Tripura, Belonia.
[3]
By the said judgment, the Civil Judge (Senior
Division), hereinafter referred to as the trial Judge, has
dismissed the suit by holding that the plaintiff is not entitled to a
decree of declaration that all the defendants are jointly or
severally liable to him for an amount of Rs.16,75,000/-. It has
been further observed by the trial Judge that the plaintiff is not
entitled to a consequential decree for recovery of the said
amount from the defendants by way of attachment of their
properties etc.
[4]
The plaintiff instituted the suit for recovery of
money to the extent of Rs.16,75,000/- which was purportedly
taken by the principal defendant meaning the defendant No.1
from the plaintiff for investing the said amount of loan in the
business of the other defendants. To be precise, the reliefs can
be described in the following manner:
[5]
(a)
a decree for declaration, declaring that the
defendants are jointly and severally liable to
pay back a sum of Rs.16,75,000/- with
“statutory interest” thereon,
(b)
a decree for attachment of properties and
moneys for securing the debt of the plaintiff,
(c)
a decree for damages and/or for mesne profit,
(d)
cost of the suit, and
(e)
interest @12% per annum w.e.f. 01.11.2013
till the realizing of the said sum.
From the narrative as laid in the plaint, it appears
that the case of the plaintiff is that the defendant No.1 and the
plaintiff are full blood brothers. In the year 2013, the defendant
No.1 spelt an impression on the plaintiff that the defendant No.1
along with the defendants No.3 to 9 had been carrying on a
business of bricks under the name and style of “Maa Kali Bricks
Industries”. Sometime in the month of November, 2013, to be
precise, on 01.11.2013, the defendant No.1 persuaded the
plaintiff for providing some money for smooth running of the
brick kiln. The defendant No.1 at that time had assured the
plaintiff that no sooner the „accredited‟ moneys began to flow in
the coffer of the firm, he would repay the said amount.
Thereafter, the plaintiff has asserted that he had demanded
“registered
indentures”,
but
on
“assassination
of
the
psychosomatic emotion of the plaintiff”, a sum of Rs.4,00,000/was
loaned
out
to
the
defendant
No.1
on
01.11.2013.
Subsequently also, the plaintiff made payments in different
installments
on
07.11.2013,
02.12.2013,
06.12.2013,
13.11.2013,
07.12.2013,
29.11.2013,
09.12.2013
and
12.12.2013. The total amount according to the plaintiff that he
paid to the defendant No.1 is aggregated at Rs.20,00,000/-.
[6]
It has been further asserted that initially the
plaintiff was reluctant to sign over the credit vouchers that were
brought in acknowledgment of the receipt of the said amount.
But being persuaded and also being satisfied, he signed later on
those vouchers. According to the plaintiff, it was agreed that the
defendant No.1 will refund the entire amount of Rs.20,00,000/within July, 2014. But the defendant No.1 did not make such repayment as assured. When he was asked to repay the said
amount, the defendant No.1 asked for extension of further one
year for such repayment. As the plaintiff is the elder brother of
the defendant No.1, he agreed to the said proposal and it was
agreed that by 15.07.2015, the said amount shall be paid.
It has been also asserted by the plaintiff [the
[7]
appellant
herein]
that
a
sum
of
Rs.3,25,000/-
out
of
Rs.20,00,000/- was paid and the remainder, Rs.16,75,000/-,
was supposed to be paid by the defendant No.1. Thereafter, the
defendant No.1 on one or other pretext deferred the said repayment with ill motive to defraud the plaintiff. The plaintiff had
attempted to file a complaint in the Court of the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, South Tripura, Belonia being C.R. case No.43 of
2015 for defrauding him. But, the cognizance of the suggested
offence
was
declined
as
according
to
the
Chief
Judicial
Magistrate, the dispute did not constitute any offence, rather it
was a civil dispute and accordingly the plaintiff was asked to
take appropriate recourse.
[8]
In Para 14 of the plaint, the plaintiff has asserted
that subsequently he came to know that the said partnership
firm had executed a power of attorney in favour of one Babul
Majumder and to another Narayan Bhowmik. According to the
plaintiff, the defendants were not the partners of the said
partnership firm as he was given the impression. But they are
running the said brick kiln through those attorneys.
[9]
It came to the knowledge of the plaintiff that the
defendants were selling the bricks from their stock-pile at a
much lower price than the prevailing market rate. However,
since the plaintiff did not get back his money, he had instituted
the suit urging the reliefs as noted above.
[10]
The basic allegations are against the defendant
No.1, who is the respondent No.1 in the instant appeal. The
respondent No.1 has categorically stated by filing the written
statement that he had never taken any loan from the plaintiff
and that at one point of time he had business relation with the
brick kiln but later on he had no interest or stake in the said
business. Similarly, the other respondents by filing a joint
written statement had completely denied the facts as pleaded in
the plaint and stated that no money has come from the
defendant No.1 in the coffer of their business.
[11]
On the basis of these rival pleadings, as noted
above, the trial Judge framed the followings issues:
i) Whether the Plaintiff has got appropriate cause of action in
this case?
ii) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for decree of declaration
that all the defendants are jointly or severally liable to him
for the amount of Rs. 16,75,000/-?
iii) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a decree of recovery of
the above amount from the defendants by way of
attachment of their property etc?
iv) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to get a decree of
damage or compensation or mesne profits from the
defendants?
v) Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to get an interest @ 12 %
per annum only from the defendant No. 1 until realization of
the total amount due?
vi) Any other relief(s), if the Plaintiff is entitled to?
[12]
It appears from the records that plaintiff adduced
four witnesses including himself [PW-1], Sri Shankar Prasad
Saha [PW-2], Sri Nandan Baidya [PW-3] and Sri Sankar Saha
[PW-4]. The plaintiff had also introduced in the evidence
documents including the credit vouchers [Exbt.4 to 12]. That
apart, the plaintiff has exhibited one partnership deed being
No.IV-114/09 [Exbt.01].
[13]
From the other side, the defendants had examined
three witnesses namely, Sri Sanatan Paul [DW-1], Sri Gopi Deb
Roy [PW-2] and Sri Jiban Debnath [PW-3].
[14]
Even though the defendants filed the examination
in chief of Sri Radha Raman Datta, but since he was not
produced for cross examination, his examination in chief was
discarded by the trial Judge. On evaluation of those evidence,
the trial Judge returned the said finding and dismissed the suit.
[15]
Being aggrieved by the said judgment, this appeal
has been preferred.
[16]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has criticized
the finding of the trial Judge that on perusal of credit vouchers
[Exbt.4 to Exbt.12] it appears that the credit vouchers are
numbered
serially
from
26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33
and
34,
transacted on different dates. It is very surprising that though
the transactions had taken place on different dates but the
credit vouchers‟ serial Nos. are continuous. The credit vouchers
are supposed to be maintained serially. It further surfaces that
no sign of tearing or taking out of the credit vouchers from the
books of credit vouchers. The credit vouchers bore the signature
of one Shankar Prasad Saha with the seal of Manager, Maa Kali
Bricks Industries, Chittamara, Madhya Bharatchandranagar,
Belonia, South Tripura.
[17]
On appreciation of the evidence of PW-2, the trial
Judge has further observed that it appeared that Shankar
Prasad Saha [PW-2] was his student. PW-2 has stated that he
worked as the Manager of Maa Kali Bricks Industries since
November, 2012 to 25.03.2014. To prove the fact, PW-1 and
PW-2 could not produce any oral or documentary evidence in
respect of the transaction. PW-2 in his testimony stated that he
did not have any document to produce that he had worked as a
Manager of Maa Kali Bricks Industries.
During cross examination, PW-2 has categorically
[18]
stated that he cannot say who the owner of the Maa Kali Bricks
Industries. He has further stated that he cannot say in whose
name the licence of Maa Kali Bricks Industries stood at the
relevant point of time. PW-2 has further stated in the trial that
Pijush Kanti Datta [the defendant No.1] assigned PW-2 to look
after Maa Kali Bricks Industries on verbal request. In the cross
examination, PW-2 had stated that he did not have any
document of ownership by Pijush Kanti Datta in respect of Maa
Kali Bricks Industries. Therefore, a doubt arises that if really
PW-2 served as the Manager in Maa Kali Bricks Industries for a
period since November, 2012 to 25.03.2014. If he was the
Manager of the said brick kiln or the partnership firm, how can
he say that he did not know who was the owner of the Maa Kali
Bricks Industries under which he claimed to be the Manager.
According to the trial Judge, that aspect has evidently shaken
the credibility of the said witness and hence, PW-2 was trusted
and
relied
manipulated.
on.
On
The
the
credit
basis
vouchers
of
the
observation, the suit has been dismissed.
also
appear
above
to
be
fundamental
[19]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has submitted
that there is no reason to disbelieve PW-2 as PW-2 has admitted
the credit vouchers which bear his signature as well as the
signature of the plaintiff. The issue that whether PW-2 was a
student of PW-1 is even not remotely relevant in the present
context and that cannot be the ground for distrusting a witness.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has submitted that if the
deposition of PW-2 is believed, the finding has to be intervened
by this Court allowing the suit.
[20]
From the other side, Ms. S. Nandy, learned counsel
has submitted that it has been categorically asserted by the
respondent No.1 [the defendant No.1 in the suit] that he does
not have any relation with that business and therefore he did
not have any authority to appoint anyone as a Manager of the
partnership firm. Therefore, the entire story as narrated by the
plaintiff is a cock and bull story and should not be given any
credence by this Court.
[21]
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel appearing
for the respondents No.2,4 to 9 and 11 has submitted that in
the partnership firm, no fund had flown in through the
defendant No.1 as claimed by the plaintiff. Moreover, the
defendant No.1 had no role in the business of the partnership
firm called Maa Kali Bricks Industries. Hence, the suit is
unsustainable against the defendants, represented by Mr. Deb,
learned senior counsel.
[22]
On appreciation of submissions of the learned
counsel appearing for the parties as well as the records those
have been placed before us, we are of the view that the solitary
question that falls for consideration in this appeal is whether the
deposition of PW-2, or for that matter the credit vouchers, can
be believed by this Court for granting the relief as sought by the
plaintiff.
[23]
The plaintiff, as is evident, is not consistent
because his entire reliance on PW-2 is fragile, as PW-2 has been
styled as the Manager of the defendants. Even PW-2, in the
cross examination, as carried out by the defendant No.4, has
candidly testified that he had no idea who the owner was, of the
said partnership firm. If this statement is believed, the liability
on the other respondents beyond the respondent No.1 cannot
be sustained by any stretch of interpretation or evaluation of the
evidence. The ancillary question that remains to be addressed
by this Court is that whether the defendant No.1 had any
interest in the partnership firm or business or whether the
defendant No.1 had at all taken the money from the plaintiff.
For that purpose, the evidence that has been introduced by the
plaintiff is the credit vouchers through PW-2.
[24]
We have verified the statements of PW-2 vis-à-vis
the credit vouchers. We find that PW-2 has categorically
deposed that an amount of half of the total amount to the
extent of Rs.10,00,000/- were collected as the share money not
the loan. But the plaintiff did not produce any evidence that the
partnership firm ever offered the plaintiff to be inducted as the
partner of the said partnership firm. This is an absurd
proposition, which makes the entire evidence through the
voucher, an improbable one. That apart, the fact of payment
that had been made, as claimed by the plaintiff, has not been
proved at all.
Having read the entire evidence together, we
[25]
consider that probability as inferred by the trial Judge is based
on preponderance.
[26]
As corollary, we do not find any merit in this
appeal. Accordingly, the same is dismissed.
Prepare the decree accordingly. Send down the
LCRs thereafter.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review