The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 05.2022. Whether fit for reporting: No. JUDGMENT AND ORDER(Oral) (S. Talapatra, J) Heard Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and also heard Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the respondent. [2] By means of this appeal, filed under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, the judgment dated 17.01.2020 delivered in Title Suit (divorce) 09 of 2019 by the Judge, Family Court Udaipur, Gomati District, has been challenged. [3] By the said judgment, the matrimonial suit instituted by the appellant under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 has been dismissed by returning the finding that even though pressurizing one’s husband to be a resident husband may amount to mental cruelty, but such cruelty has been condoned by the appellant as he resided and lived with the respondent for a considerable period at the parental house of the respondent. According to Section 23(1)(b) of the Hindu Marriage Act, cruelty is condonable marital offence and such condonation is an absolute bar in granting any relief based on the conduct which has been thus condoned. It has been further observed that the appellant has committed matrimonial misconduct and thus he is not entitled to a decree of divorce. [4] Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the appellant tried his level best to make their matrimonial life sai…
1. 6.2016 having been driven out by her. From that day, he has been living with his widowed mother. In para 12 of the petition being Title Suit (Divorce) 09 of 2019, it has been further stated that the appellant was arrested by the police and detained in the R.K. Pur Police Station, however, on the following day the appellant was released from the Police Station on personal bond. At that time, the respondent tried to implicate the appellant in a police case on allegation of theft. It has been also asserted that the respondent filed a complaint under Section 12 of the Protection of Women from the Domestic Violence Act, 2005 being C.R.03 of 2018 in the court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gomati Tripura. The appellant has further stated that there were numerous complaints against him. Even the initiative taken by the family elders for reconciliation of marital discord has been foiled by the respondent. [7] Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel has taken us to the thick of the evidence, recorded by the Family Court. The appellant testified in the trial as PW.1. While giving testimony in the said Court, it appears from his examinationin-chief filed under Order XVIII Rule 4 of CPC, he has laid his response in respect of the written statement filed by the respondent herein. It may be noted that a very short written statement has been filed by the respondent wherein she has denied all the …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Mat.App. No 09/2020
Sri Tapas Goswami,
son of late Manilal @ Mihirlal Goswami, Chanban, Udaipur,
P.O. and P.S. R.K.Pur,
District - Gomati Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
Smti. Nanda Saha (Goswami),
wife of Sri Tapas Goswami,
daughter of Sri Bibhuti Bhusan Saha of Madhyapara, Udaipur,
P.O. and P.S. R.K. Pur,
District- Gomati Tripura.
-------- Petitioner(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. A. Acharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
Judgment & Order
:
19.05.2022.
Whether fit for reporting:
No.
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(Oral)
(S. Talapatra, J)
Heard Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
and also heard Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the respondent.
[2]
By means of this appeal, filed under Section 19(1) of the Family
Courts Act, 1984, the judgment dated 17.01.2020 delivered in Title Suit (divorce)
09 of 2019 by the Judge, Family Court Udaipur, Gomati District, has been
challenged.
[3]
By the said judgment, the matrimonial suit instituted by the
appellant under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 has been
dismissed by returning the finding that even though pressurizing one’s husband
to be a resident husband may amount to mental cruelty, but such cruelty has
been condoned by the appellant as he resided and lived with the respondent for
a considerable period at the parental house of the respondent. According to
Section 23(1)(b) of the Hindu Marriage Act, cruelty is condonable marital offence
and such condonation is an absolute bar in granting any relief based on the
conduct which has been thus condoned. It has been further observed that the
appellant has committed matrimonial misconduct and thus he is not entitled to a
decree of divorce.
[4]
Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the appellant tried his level best to make their matrimonial life sail
smoothly, but for conduct of the respondent, he has failed to lead a peaceful
conjugal life. It has been categorically alleged that the respondent used to
pressurize the appellant to live as the resident husband (ghar jamai in local term)
in her paternal house, even sometimes, she used to demand money but as he
was not employed at that point of time he had failed to make such demand.
[5]
The appellant tried to make the respondent understand that her
conduct is not conducive for a peaceful conjugal life but her cruel treatment did
not stop and his efforts went in vain. It has been categorically stated that the
appellant used to be mercilessly beaten by the respondent.
[6]
The appellant left the parental house of the respondent on
1.6.2016 having been driven out by her. From that day, he has been living with
his widowed mother. In para 12 of the petition being Title Suit (Divorce) 09 of
2019, it has been further stated that the appellant was arrested by the police
and detained in the R.K. Pur Police Station, however, on the following day the
appellant was released from the Police Station on personal bond. At that time,
the respondent tried to implicate the appellant in a police case on allegation of
theft. It has been also asserted that the respondent filed a complaint under
Section 12 of the Protection of Women from the Domestic Violence Act, 2005
being C.R.03 of 2018 in the court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gomati
Tripura. The appellant has further stated that there were numerous complaints
against him. Even the initiative taken by the family elders for reconciliation of
marital discord has been foiled by the respondent.
[7]
Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel has taken us to the thick of the
evidence, recorded by the Family Court. The appellant testified in the trial as
PW.1. While giving testimony in the said Court, it appears from his examinationin-chief filed under Order XVIII Rule 4 of CPC, he has laid his response in respect
of the written statement filed by the respondent herein. It may be noted that a
very short written statement has been filed by the respondent wherein she has
denied all the allegations but has admitted that the respondent has been living
separately since 2016. In para 10 of the said statement, the respondent has
vouched that she is waiting for re-construction of the matrimonial relation but for
the appellant that did not come to restitute the same.
[8]
Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel has appeared for the respondent and
submitted that there is no reason to interfere with the findings of the Judge,
Family Court, Udaipur, Gomati District. Mr. Nath, learned counsel has pointed out
that the petitioner (the appellant) was arrested by the police as is evident from
Exbt.01 that the appellant “under influence of liquor in the house of the
informant”, created nuisance. The respondent was persuaded to inform the
police and accordingly the police detained the appellant under Section 90 (2) of
the Tripura Police Act and taken him to the custody. In the medical examination,
the doctor opined that the appellant had consumed the alcohol and was not in a
position to control himself. That apart, Mr. Nath, learned counsel has submitted
that it is correct that all the alleged misconducts of the respondent were
condoned by conduct and, as such, those episodes cannot be brought back for
the purpose of providing the grounds of divorce on cruelty and desertion. He has
further pointed out that the respondent is ready to re-construct their marital life
and she had openly stated that during her cross-examination. In the cross
examination, as pointed out by Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel for respondents, it
has been clearly stated by the respondents that “I want my husband to stay with
me at my parental home”. Mr. Nath, learned counsel based on the said
submission has stated that the respondent is ready to live with the husband but
the husband (appellant) is reluctant to re-construct the marriage.
[9]
On the basis of the rival pleadings the Family Court framed the
following issues for adjudication on this suit:
“(i)
Is the suit is maintainable?
(ii)
Has, the respondent after the solemnization
of marriage, treated the petitioner with cruelty?
(iii)
Has the respondent deserted the petitioner
for a continuous period of not less than two years
immediately preceding the presentation of the
petition?
(iv)
Is the petitioner entitled to get a decree of
divorce as prayed for?”
[10]
The Judge, Family Court having appreciated the evidence by the
parties returned finding separately on each issue and thereafter given the
concise observation why she was inclined to dismiss the said divorce suit.
[11]
We have scrutinized the records of the evidence and found that the
appellant (the petitioner, who instituted the suit for divorce) adduced 03
witnesses namely (1) Sri Tapas Goswami (PW-1), (2) Smt. Kona Rani Goswami
(PW-2) and (3) Sri Bimalpada Goswami (PW-3) and 2 documents viz. medical
prescription of one Dr. Anjan Kr. Chakraborty (Exbt.1) and extract copy of GD
Entry No. 5 dated 18.5.2016 (Exbt. 02). On the other hand, the respondent
examined 02 witnesses namely Smt. Nanda Saha(Goswami) (DW-1) and Sri
Suman Baran Saha (DW-2) . It appears that Issue No.1 has been decided in
favour of the appellant whereas Issue No. 2 has been decided against the
appellant. So far Issues No. 3 and 4 are concerned, those were decided against
the Appellant. While deciding the Issue No. 3, it has been observed by the
Judge, Family Court, Udaipur that it is well established principle that proof of fact
of separation, which is one of the essential ingredients of matrimonial offence of
desertion, does not consist merely in ascertainment of which party left the home
first. The rule is now well settled that a spouse may be guilty of such misconduct
as would render the continuance of marital relations so unbearable that the
other spouse is compelled to live separately. In such cases, the person whose
activities are responsible for separation is the offending one.
[12]
In fine, these findings have been questioned in this appeal as
according to the appellant, those findings are not based on fair appreciation of
the evidence. The appellant (PW.1) in his examination-in-chief has stated that
his marriage with the respondent was solemnized on 24.9.2002 as per the Hindu
Rites and Customs. In their wedlock, one son was born. On the day of filing of
the divorce suit, he was 12 years of age. It has been alleged by the appellant
that the respondent used to misbehave with his parents taking the advantage of
earning. The appellant has admitted that there was a meeting for mitigation of
the marital disputes but that did not succeed for the obstinacy of the respondent.
[13]
The appellant has admitted that by the order dated 17.06.2017
passed in the proceeding drawn up under Section 125 Cr. P. C by the Judge
Family Court, Udaipur, Gomati District he has been asked to pay a sum of
Rs.3500/- per month for maintenance of the respondent and his minor child. In
para 12 of the examination-in-chief, the appellant has made the following serious
allegation against the respondent.
”12. That it has come to the notice of me that the
respondent wife has also got engaged in
extraneous affairs with other person in which I
objected and actually over this issue I was ousted
from the house of the respondent after physically
assaulting me.”
It has also been stated by the appellant that he was arrested by
the police on the complaint of the respondent. It has been quite categorically
stated that there had been a well-designed conspiracy to frame him in a criminal
case for theft. The appellant has vouched before the Court that the respondent
(wife) had been living separately since 2012 and hence, the act of desertion has
been well proved.
[14]
PW.3, Sri Bimalpada Goswami has corroborated the substantive
part of the version of PW-1 (the appellant). PW-2 Smt. Kona Rani Goswami has
stated that the respondent used to misbehave with the appellant taking the
advantage of his poor income. PW-2 has also stated that in order to avoid
misbehavior of the respondent, the appellant had adjusted in order to continue
living with the respondent and tried to make the respondent understand that he
deserved a happy conjugal life, but there had been no impact on the respondent.
The respondent, titled as DW.1, has stated in the trial that the allegation of
extraneous affair with any other person as made by the appellant has been
designed to obtain the decree of divorce. It has been stated by her that on
17.05.2016, her husband, the appellant, came to her hut in a drunken condition
and without any reason, he committed physical torture on her. She had, finding
no alternative, immediately informed the police and the police took care of the
situation. She has clearly denied any attempt from the end of the appellant to
settle the dispute and take her back to the matrimonial home. According to her,
the appellant never tried to settle up the disputes. Till now, she has been waiting
with a broken heart to see the day when their matrimonial discord will be over.
[15]
Finally, she has stated that her husband has deserted her with ill
intention to derive a decree of divorce through the process of law. One Suman
Baran Saha (DW.2) has corroborated the respondent on every aspects. After
scrutinizing the evidence, we are persuaded to extract part of the statement
made in the cross-examination by the appellant. He has stated that though
several times his wife misbehaved with him but he is unable to give any specific
date of her misbehavior. Subrata Deb, who was the former Chairperson of
Udaipur Municipal Council, has acceded to the fact that he cannot remember the
date of the meeting held to mitigate the matrimonial dispute. Whenever, the
meeting was held, no written resolution was prepared but, he has finally
admitted that his wife did not lodge any criminal case against him with any
allegation, even though the appellant had made such allegation. In one part, it
has been stated that the marriage of the respondent with the appellant is the
second marriage of the respondent. In that background, the respondent has
stated that it is an incorrect statement and stated that she has not disclosed any
fact of her first marriage to the appellant as alleged. However, she has denied
the allegation of adulterous life as levelled by the appellant. She has categorically
stated in her cross-examination that she has not mentioned in her written
statement that she was beaten up by her husband and by her mother-in-law.
She has, however, admitted that during the period from 2011-2016, the
appellant lived in the parental house of the respondent. She has also admitted in
the cross-examination that whenever her husband used to ask her about
travelling with others, she used to beat her husband. We believe that this
statement has not properly been recorded. From analysis of the trend of
responses made in the cross-examination, it should also be treated as denied.
Finally, she has stated that she is ready to live with the husband (the appellant),
but at her parental home. DW.2, Suman Baran Saha has in his cross-examination
denied the fact that the appellant took any initiative for mitigating the
matrimonial discord. We have anxiously read the observations of the Judge,
Family Court who passed the impugned judgment and in our considered view
that such observations are highly mechanical. We find, even though, the
respondent is offering to live with the appellant but she has put condition that
the respondent shall live in her parental home. It cannot be denied that for last 6
years, they have lived separately and we do not find any attempt from the side
of the respondent for re-union.
[16]
We have gathered that the appellant was ready to live with the
respondent in her parental house, which he did not like at all. Our further
impression is that as the appellant was financially weak the respondent has
taken that advantage to force him live in her parental house. We have also
appreciated the position of the parties in the society. As such, we are also of the
view that this is not a case where we can straight way grant the decree of
divorce, but in exercise of the power given to this Court to provide alternative
relief, we think that a decree of judicial separation should be passed. This
inference has been drawn on the basis of the nature of the conduct and the
continuous and serious marital discords.
[17]
Hence, when we dismiss the petition (the suit) for granting the
decree of divorce on the ground of cruelty and desertion, but we have come to
an inference that the appellant and the respondent cannot live their matrimonial
life peacefully. As consequence, we declare that the parties shall live separately.
Hence, the parties are allowed to live separately.
[18]
Having observed thus the suit is partly allowed as we grant the
decree of judicial separation. Unless, the parties do start living together as
husband and wife with leave of the court, nobody shall interfere with their
respective life. We did not find any necessity to pass any order as regards the
access of the appellant to his son, as the son has attained the majority.
Decree shall be drawn in terms of the above. Thereafter, the LCRs be
sent down.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
paritosh.
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review