Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP No.33 of 2023
Sri Tapas Giri,
son of Maran Giri,
resident of Tutabari Purba Kalyanpur,
District Khowai, Tripura.
(Owner of Truck bearing No. TR-06-A-1753).
………. Appellant
Versus
1.
Smti. Sarubala Debbarma,
Wife of late Khelan Debbarma.
2.
Smti. Tripurani Debbarma,
Daughter of late Khelan Debbarma.
3.
Smti. Raima Debbarma,
daughter of late Khelan Debbarma.
All are presently residing under
C/O. Sri Upendra Debbarma,
Rabicharan Thakur Para,
P.S. Radhapur, District West Tripura,
Permanently residing at Bairagi Para,
P.O. & P.S. Kalyanpur, District Khowai, Tripura.
4.
Magma HDI General Insurance Company Ltd.,
Block 3B, B201-202 ECOSPCE Business Bank,
Ambuja Reality Campus, Action Area,
110 North Twenty four Paraganas,
West Bengal, (State Code-19), PIN-700156
(Insurer of Truck bearing No. TR-0A-1753)
As per Honble Court‟s order dated 21.06.2023
The local address of the respondent no.4
be also indicated in the array of parties.
Building of Divine Digital Colour Lab,
2nd floor or Nivash, Netaji Chowmuhani,
Landmark: Above HDFC Bank Limited,
Agartala, West Tripura, Pin: 799001
5.
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd,
Sreeji Towe, 3rd Floor,
C/O, Guwahati Tea Ware Housing Pvt. Ltd,
adjacent to Mahindra Show Room,
near Ganesh Guri Fly Over, Christian Basti,
Guwahati-781005, Assam
(Insurer of Scooty bearing No. TR-06-5931)
……….Respondents.
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv,
Mr. S. Majumder, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. C. Roy, Adv,
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
07.05.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
10.05.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 173 of M.V. Act is
preferred
challenging
the
judgment
and
award
dated
20.01.2023 passed by Learned Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala, in connection
with case No.T.S.(MAC) 63 of 2020.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh, representing
the appellant and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S.
Chakraborty
representing
the
Insurance
Company
and
Learned Counsel, Mr. D.C. Roy representing the claimantrespondent Nos.1 to 3.
03.
Before conclusion of this appeal, let us discuss
about the subject matter of the claim-petition. The claimantrespondent Nos.1 to 3 filed one application under Section
166 of M.V. Act seeking compensation for the death of one
Khelan Debbarma, husband of the respondent-claimant No.1
and father of respondent-claimant-petitioner Nos.2 and 3
who expired in a road traffic accident involving a truck
bearing registration No.TR-06-A-1753 and the scooty bearing
registration No.TR-06-5931. According to the claimantpetitioners, on 11.02.2020 morning, the victim Khelan
Debbarma was proceeding towards his school at Utabari S.B.
School from his residence by riding his scooty bearing
registration No.TR-06-5931 and when he reached near the
gate of his school at 7 a.m., suddenly, one truck bearing
registration No.TR-06-A-1753 came from his back side with
high speed, rashly and negligently dashed against him for
which the victim fell down and sustained fatal injuries. He
was immediately brought to Kalyanpur Hospital from where
he was referred to GBP Hospital. But at GBP Hospital, on the
same day, the victim succumbed to his injuries. Thereafter,
postmortem examination was done over the dead body at
GBP Hospital. Accordingly, a police case was registered at
Kalyanpur Police Station vide P.S. Case No.12 of 2020.
According
to
the
respondent-claimant-petitioners,
the
deceased
was
an
Under-Graduate
the
Teacher
under
Directorate of School Education, Government of Tripura. His
monthly salary was Rs.47,475/- and he was 53 years old at
the time of his death. It was further submitted that the
respondent-claimant-petitioners Nos.2 and 3, being the
daughters of the deceased were fully dependent upon his
income and the claimant-petitioner No.1 is a Government
Servant, as such she was not dependent on the income of
the deceased and the father of the deceased namely,
Ramchandra Debbarma died long years back. So, he was not
depending upon the income of the deceased. So, the
claimant-petitioners claimed compensation to the tune of
Rs.65,00,000/-(Sixty five lakhs only) in total. The O.P. No.1
being the owner-cum- driver contested the case by filing
written statement wherein he stated that he is the owner
cum driver of the Mini Truck bearing registration No.TR-06A-1753 (Tata ACE Gold) which met with an accident on
11.02.2020 at about 7 a.m. near Tutabari S.B. School and
due to accident one Khelan Debbarma was riding a scooty
sustained fatal injuries.
It was further submitted that at the time of
accident the vehicle was duly insured with the Magma HDI
General Insurance Company Ltd. covering the period of
insurance from 30.05.2019 to 29.05.2020 and he had valid
driving licence at the time of accident. So, according to O.P.
No.1, i.e. the owner, if any liabilities arise that should be
borne by the Insurance Company. The O.P. No.2, the Magma
HDI General Insurance Company Ltd. in their written
statement denied the name and father‟s name of the
deceased, address, occupation, income etc. and submitted
that the claimant-petitioners are to prove the same by
adducing oral/documentary evidence on record. It was
further submitted to direct the owner to produce all the
original copy of valid driving licence, insurance policy,
permit, fitness, tax token, registration number etc. It was
also submitted that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of the scooty bearing registration No.TR06-5931 by the deceased himself. O.P. No.3 in their written
statement denied the age, occupation, monthly income of
the deceased and submitted that the petitioners are to prove
the case by adducing specific documentary evidence. It was
further submitted that the claimant-petitioners in their
petition submitted that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of the vehicle bearing registration No.TR06-A-1753 Truck, as such the owner is liable to pay
compensation to the petitioners. So, the O.P. No.3 was not
liable to pay any compensation for the accident.
04.
Upon
the
pleadings
of
the
parties,
Learned
Tribunal below framed the following issues:
Issues :
(1) Did deceased Khelan Debbarma die in a
road
traffic
accident
occurred
on
11.02.2020 at about 7 a.m. near the gate of
Utabari S.B. School under Kalyanpur P.S.
out of use of vehicles bearing registration
No.TR-06-5931 (Scooty) and TR-06-A-1753
(Truck) due to rash and negligent driving
by the driver of Truck vehicle?
(2) Are the petitioners entitled to get
compensation as prayed for and if so, to
what amount and who is liable to pay the
same?
(3) To what other reliefs the parties are
entitled?
05.
To substantiate the case both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record:
Petitioner‟s Witness:
PW 1: Smt Tripurani Debbarma
Respondent‟s Witness:
O.P.W 1 : Sri Tapas Giri
Petitioner‟s Document:
Exbt.1 : FIR
Exbt. 2 : Ejahar
Exbt. 3: Seizure Memo along with Seizure
List
Exbt. 4: Post Mortem Report
Exbt. 5 : Final Report
Exbt. 6 : Salary Certificate
Exbt. 7 : Post Mortem Certificate
Exbt. 8 : Death Certificate
Exbt. 9 : Survival Certificate
Exbt. 10 : Admit Card
OP-Respondent‟s Documents:
Exbt. A : Driving Licence
Exbt. B : Vehicle Particulars
06.
Finally,
on
conclusion
of
argument,
Learned
Tribunal below by judgment and award dated 20.01.2023
allowed the claim-petition. The operative portion of the
order/award runs as follows:
“It is, therefore, held that the petitioners
are entitled to get compensation of
Rs.49,69,500/- (Rupees Forty-nine Lakh
Sixty-nine Thousand Five hundred only)
with interest @ 7% per annum with effect
from 13.05.2020 i.e. the date of filing of the
claim petition till the date of actual
payment. The O.P. No.1 Sri Tapas Giri, S/O.
Sri Maran Giri, resident of Tutabari Purba
Kalyanpur, P.S. Kalyanpur, District Khowai,
Tripura
will
pay
the
amount
of
compensation with interest within 30 days
from today.
Out of the awarded amount of
compensation inclusive of interest, the
petitioner no.1 will get 40% and the
petitioners no.2 and 3 will 30% each. Out
of the respective share of the petitioners
no.1,2 and 3, 50% each of their shall be
kept in fixed deposit scheme in their
respective name in any Nationalized Bank
of their locality for a period of five years
each and the remaining 50% shall be paid
to them through their respective bank
account. No loan or withdrawal shall be
permitted from any of the fixed deposit
certificates without prior permission of this
Tribunal. The petitioners no.1, 2 and 3 shall
however be at liberty to withdraw monthly
interest from their fixed deposit account to
meet their day to day expenses.
Supply copy of this award free of cost
to the parties.
The claim petition stands disposed of
on contest.”
07.
In
course
of
hearing
of
argument,
Learned
Counsel for the appellant, Mr. S. Lodh submitted that in this
case, the appellant before the Learned Tribunal below
contested
the
oral/documentary
proceeding
evidence
on
both
by
record
and
adducing
proved
the
registration certificate as well as driving licence of the
offending Truck. But according to Learned Counsel, Learned
Tribunal below came to an observation that the offending
vehicle was a “goods carrying vehicle” and the driver had the
licence to run a non-transport vehicle, as such the owner
cum driver had violated the terms and condition of the policy
document, although the policy document was not exhibited
but according to Section 2(21) of the MV Act, the offending
vehicle comes under the purview of “light motor vehicle” and
as per registration certificate, the offending vehicle had
unlaiden weights of 840kg. So, the appellant was duly
authorized to run the offending vehicle on the day of
accident. But the Learned Tribunal below came to an
observation that the owner cum driver had broken down the
terms and conditions of the policy of the Insurance and as
such fastened the liability upon the appellant-owner-cumdriver and urged before the Court to fix the liability upon the
Insurance Company.
08.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the
respondent Insurance Company, Mr. S. Chakraborty fairly
submitted that he reiterates the submission made by
Learned Counsel for appellant but submitted that since the
policy document was not exhibited and proved by the
appellant before the Learned Tribunal below, so, the case
may be remanded back to Learned Tribunal with a direction
to the appellant to produce the Insurance Certificate to
substantiate that on the alleged day the driver had valid
driving licence and his vehicle was duly authorized to run the
vehicle as per Insurance Policy. So, Learned Counsel further
submitted to remand back the matter setting aside the
award with a direction to the Learned Tribunal below to pass
a fresh award. The appellant also did not raise any voice
regarding
quantum
of
compensation
awarded
by
the
Tribunal.
Learned Counsel, Mr. D.C. Roy, appearing on
behalf of the respondent-claimant-petitioners submitted that
the claimant is satisfied with the compensation awarded by
the Learned Tribunal below and submitted
that the entire
responsibility for making payment of compensation be fixed
upon the Magma HDI Insurance Company Limited.
09.
I have heard the rival submissions of both the
sides. There is no dispute on record that on the alleged day,
the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of
the owner cum driver of the Mini Truck bearing No.TR-06-A1753 (Tata ACE Gold). From the relevant prosecution papers,
it also appears that the I.O. of the concerned Police Station,
after completion of investigation, laid charge-sheet against
the
owner
cum
driver
of
the
aforesaid
vehicle.
To
substantiate the claim-petition, the respondent-claimantpetitioners have relied upon certain documents and also at
the same time, the O.P. owner i.e. the present appellant to
substantiate his defence has also relied upon the driving
licence (Exhibit-A) and the vehicle particulars issued by the
Transport Department (Exhibit-B).
10.
On perusal of Exhibit-B, it appears that the
registration number of the vehicle was TR-06-A-1753 (Tata
ACE Gold) and its laden weight is 1550kg and unladen
weight is 840kg. Section 2(21) of the M.V. Act provides the
definition of „Light Motor Vehicle‟:
Definition of Light Motor Vehicle:
Section2(21):
“light motor vehicle” means a transport
vehicle or omnibus the gross vehicle weight
of either of which or a motor car or tractor
or road-roller the unladen weight of any of
which, does not exceed [7500] kilograms;
11.
From the aforesaid definition and also from the
relevant vehicle particulars, it appears that the offending
vehicle was a „goods carrier‟ and on perusal of Exhibit-A, it
appears that the owner cum driver had driving licence for
carrying „light motor vehicle‟ and by the said driving licence,
he was authorized to carry the offending vehicle on that
relevant day. But Learned Tribunal below, at the time of
delivery of jaudgment misconstrued the actual legal position
and came to an observation that the driver/owner had a
driving licence for non-transport vehicle and a driver having
a driving licence of non-transport vehicle cannot drove the
transport vehicle/Good Carrier.
12.
Thus, at the end of judgment, Learned Tribunal
fastened the liability to the present appellant, i.e. the owner
cum driver, which in view Learned Tribunal below wrongly
divided. More so, the owner cum driver i.e. the appellant
before the Learned Tribunal below could not take step for
marking exhibit of the Original Insurance Policy Certificate of
the offending vehicle and until and unless the document is
exhibited, there is very least scope to fasten the liability
upon the Insurance Company.
13.
Hon‟ble the Supreme Court of India of (2013) 7
SCC 62 in para Nos.15, 16, 17, 18 and 19 has pleased to
observe as under:
“15. In National Insurance Company Ltd. v.
Annappa Irappa Nesaria:2008 (3) SCC 464,
the vehicle involved in the accident was a
matador having a goods carriage permit
and was insured with the Insurance
Company. An issue was raised that the
driver of the vehicle did not possess an
effective driving licence to drive a transport
vehicle. The Tribunal held that the driver
was having a valid driving licence and
allowed the claim. In appeal filed by the
Insurance
Company,
the
High
Court
dismissed the appeal holding that the
claimants are third parties and even on the
ground that there is violation of terms and
conditions of the policy the Insurance
Company cannot be permitted to contend
that it has no liability. This Court after
considering the relevant provisions of the
Act and definition and meaning of light
goods carriage, light motor vehicles, heavy
goods vehicles, finally came to conclusion
that the driver, who was holding the licence
duly granted to drive light motor vehicle,
was entitled to drive the light passenger
carriage vehicle, namely, the matador. This
Court observed as under: (SCC p.468, para
20)
“20. From what has been noticed
hereinbefore,
it
is
evident
that
„transport vehicle‟ has now been
substituted for „medium goods vehicle‟
and „heavy goods vehicle‟. The light
motor vehicle continued, at the
relevant point of time to cover both
„light passenger carriage vehicle‟ and
„light goods carriage vehicle‟. A driver
who had a valid licence to drive a light
motor
vehicle,
therefore,
was
authorized to drive a light goods
vehicle as well.”
16. The heading “Insurance of Motor
Vehicles against Third Party Risks” given
in Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 (Chapter VIII of the 1939 Act) itself
shows the intention of the legislature to
make third-party insurance compulsory and
to ensure that the victims of accident
arising out of use of motor vehicles would
be able to get compensation for the death
or injuries suffered. The provision has been
inserted in order to protect the persons
travelling in vehicles or using the road from
the risk attendant upon the user of the
motor vehicles on the road. To overcome
this ugly situation, the legislature has made
it obligatory that no motor vehicle shall be
used unless a third-party insurance is in
force.
17. Reading the provisions of Sections
146 and 147 of the Motor Vehicles Act, it is
evidently
clear
that
in
certain
circumstances
the
insurer‟s
right
is
safeguarded but in any event the insurer
has to pay compensation when a valid
certificate
of
insurance
is
issued
notwithstanding the fact that the insurer
may proceed against the insured for
recovery of the amount. Under Section
149 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the insurer
can defend the action inter alia on the
grounds, namely,
(i) the vehicle was not driven by a
named person,
(ii) it was being driven by a person
who was not having a duly granted licence,
and
(iii) person driving the vehicle was
disqualified to hold and obtain a driving
licence.
Hence, in our considered opinion, the
insurer cannot disown its liability on the
ground that although the driver was
holding a licence to drive a light motor
vehicle but before driving light motor
vehicle used as commercial vehicle, no
endorsement to drive commercial vehicle
was obtained in the driving licence. In any
case, it is the statutory right of a third
party
to
recover
the
amount
of
compensation so awarded from the insurer.
It is for the insurer to proceed against the
insured for recovery of the amount in the
event there has been violation of any
condition of the insurance policy.
18. In the instant case, admittedly the
driver was holding a valid driving licence to
drive light motor vehicle. There is no
dispute that the motor vehicle in question,
by which accident took place, was Mahindra
Maxi Cab. Merely because the driver did not
get any endorsement in the driving licence
to drive Mahindra Maxi Cab, which is a light
motor
vehicle,
the
High
Court
has
committed grave error of law in holding
that the insurer is not liable to pay
compensation because the driver was not
holding the licence to drive the commercial
vehicle.
The
impugned
judgment
is,
therefore, liable to be set aside.
19. We, therefore, allow this appeal, set
aside the impugned judgment of the High
Court and hold that the insurer is liable to
pay the compensation so awarded to the
dependants of the victim of the fatal
accident. However, there shall be no order
as to costs.”
14.
In view of the principle laid down by the Hon‟ble
Apex Court and after hearing rival submission of the parties,
it appears to me that this present case be remanded back to
the Learned Tribunal with a direction to give an opportunity
to the O.P. owner to produce the Insurance Policy for
marking exhibit and thereupon to pass a fresh judgment. If it
is found by the Learned Tribunal that the offending vehicle
was duly insured with the Insurance Company, then order be
passed
accordingly
fixing
the
liability
for
payment
of
compensation to the Insurance Company. Since, there is no
claim regarding the amount of award awarded by the
Learned Tribunal below and none of the parties did raise
their voice regarding the quantum of compensation awarded
by the Tribunal below, so, in my considered view this is a fit
case which be remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below.
15.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby allowed on contest. The judgment and award dated
20.01.2023 passed by Learned Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala, in connection
with case No.T.S.(MAC) 63 of 2020 is hereby set aside. The
appellant-owner cum driver is asked to appear before the
Learned Tribunal i.e. MAC Tribunal No.1 on 20.05.2024 and
to produce the Original Policy Document for marking exhibit.
The Learned Tribunal is also asked to allow the appellantowner cum driver to produce the document for marking
exhibit and thereupon to pass a fresh judgment as per law
on the claim-petition filed by the respondent-claimantpetitioners, keeping it in mind, the principle of law laid down
by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in the aforesaid case. The entire
exercise shall be made within a period of one month from
the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment/order. A copy
of this judgment/order be supplied to Learned Counsels of
the rival parties.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
order/judgment.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
2024.05.13 17:55:38
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
+05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review