Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 41 of 2018
Sri Tapan Kumar Deb
alias Sri Shilan Kumar Deb
son of Shri Sailendra Chandra Deb,
Of Ramnagar, P.S. - Panisagar,
North Tripura District.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Shri Radha Ranjan Paul
son of Late Ramesh Chandra Paul,
of Ramnagar (Janata College),
P.S. - Panisagar, Norht Tripura District.
2. (a)
Smt. Jayanti Rani Paul
wife of Late Rama Kanta Paul,
resident of Ramnagar (Janata College),
P.S. - Panisagar, North Tripura District.
(b)
Sri Raj Paul (Minor)
son of Late Rama Kanta Paul,
(c)
Sri Rintu Paul (Minor)
son of Late Rama Kanta Paul,
All minors are represented by his natural guardian mother
namely Smt. Jayanti Rani Paul,
All are residents of Ramnagar (Janata College),
P.S. - Panisagar, North Tripura District.
3. Smt. Chaturi Singha
wife of Shri Banamali Singha,
of Bilbari, P.S. - Patherkandi,
District - Karimganj.
4. Sri Chitta Singha alias Singh
son of late Ramkrishna Singha,
of Chirakuti (Choudhury Para),
P.S. - Kailashahar, Unokoti, Tripura District.
5. (a)
Sri Birendra Das
son of Late Bipin Chandra Das,
(b)
Sri Nagendra Kumar Das
son of Late Bipin Chandra Das,
(c)
Sri Rabindra Kumar Das
son of Late Bipin Chandra Das,
All are residents of Village and P.O. - Deocharra,
P.S. - Panisagar, Dharmanagar, North Tripura.
-----Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
: Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
: 17.02.2022
: 21.02.2022
: Yes
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 100 read with Order XXII
Rule 1 read with order XLI Rule 1 of the CPC against the judgment
dated 09.02.2018 and Decree passed on 20.02.2018 in Title Appeal
No.18
of
by
the
Learned
District
Judge,
North
Tripura,
Dharmanagar upholding the Judgment dated 28.06.2012 and Decree
the dated 02.07.2012 passed in Title Suit No.24 of 2006 passed by the
Civil Judge, Jr. Division, Dharmanagar, North Tripura dismissing the suit
of the appellant.
[2]
For the sake of brevity the parties are referred to as in the
title suit. The brief fact of the plaintiff’s case is that the plaintiff is the
owner and possessor of the landed property measuring about 12 sataks
under Khatian No.113 pertaining to present C/S plot No.400 under
Mouja and T.K-Ramnagar, Dharmanagar as described in the schedule of
the plaint as the plaintiff purchased the aforesaid landed property from
one Chaturi Singh through registered sale deed No.1-1848 dated
12.07.05 and since then he has been possessing the said land. It is also
mentioned in the plaint that the said landed property was in the
possession of Bipin Chandra Das being the permissive possessor under
the said Chaturi Singh and one Ruhini Singh against monthly tenant of
Rs.50/- for starting a business. It is also pertinent to mention that
Chaturi Singh (pro-defendant No.1) of the suit is the owner and
possessor of the property measuring about 0.62 acre under khatian
No.113 Hal khatian No.105 along with her co-owner Ruhini Singh and
the said Ruhini Singh died long back leaving his only son namely Chitta
Singh (pro-defendant No.2). Thereafter pro-defendant No.2 left the
place since long and the suit land along with other portion of the land
came under the absolute ownership of Chaturi Singh and as per the
mutual settlement between Chaturi Singh, Ruhini Singh and Chitta
Singh, Chaturi Singh became the owner and possessor of the landed
property and being the owner he sold out the suit land to the plaintiff.
The defendant No.1 on 15.04.1997 took lease of the hut against
Rs.100/- from said Chaturi Singh and has been staying there with a
condition that he would vacate the said land measuring 12 sataks as
and when asked. The plaintiff purchased the land measuring 12 sataks
from Chaturi Singh through the registered deed and within the
knowledge of the defendant and became the owner and possessor of
the landed property against valuable consideration and thereafter the
plaintiff applied for mutation but due to non-availability of ROR which
has been send to Agartala for computerization, the petition for mutation
is pending for disposal. On 01.08.05 the plaintiff requested the
defendants to vacant the premises under the possession but the
defendant refused to vacant the same and told the plaintiff that he may
move before the Court if he so desires. The defendant also told to the
plaintiff that he will not pay anything against this possession as earlier
because he does not take the plaintiff as owner so the plaintiff finding
no other alternative means filed the present case with a prayer for
granting decree for declaration that the plaintiff have right, title and
interest over the suit land described in the schedule of the plaint for
recovery of khas possession of the suit land by evicting the defendants
from the suit land by removing all the obstacles created by
the
defendant if any and also along with the costs of the suit.
[3]
On the other hand, the defendants contested the suit by
filing a written statement denying all the allegations of the plaintiff in
the plaint and also stating inter alia that the proforma defendant No.5
was the owner and possessor of the land measuring 0.20 acre
appertaining to R.S Plot no.399 corresponding to CS Plot No.415 under
khatian no.127 of Mouja and Tehsil –Ramnagar, Revenue Circle and
Sub-Division- Dharmanagar. The proforma defendant No.5 sold out the
land measuring 0.02 acre of principal defendant No.1 and 2 through
registered sale deed bearing No.1-2429 dated 20.05.1985 and after
that the principal defendant no.1 and 2 started living jointly by
constructing the home stead thereon. The suit land measuring 0.12 acre
described in the schedule of the plaint is situated adjacent south of the
aforesaid .20 acre purchased land of the principal defendant and the
predecessors of proforma defendant No. 3 and 4 were the owners of the
said land measuring 0.12 acre as per the schedule of the plaint. The
proforma defendant No.3 is married and living at Patharkandi, Assam
and the proforma defendant No.4 is also residing at Kailashahar since
his birth. So, the proforma defendant No. 3 and 4 never possessed the
suit land and the suit land was lying vacant. The principal defendant No.
1 on 01.01.1992 finding the suit land interest of the owner i.e. proforma
defendant No.3 and 4 and the principal defendant No 1 and 2 has been
possessing the suit land adversely continuously from 01.01.1992 till
date peacefully. The principal defendant No. 1 by construction bamboo
fending over the boundary of the suit land and by including the suit land
within the boundaries of his purchased land has been possessing the
same by producing valuable tress and after few days of the taking of
possession they constructed homestead by digging pond and also a hut
measuring 10 cubits x 6 with bamboo structure and tin roofing for the
purpose of staying there with his family. Prior to the adverse possession
of the suit land by the principal defendant No. 1 the suit land was lying
vacant and the name of Sri Bipin Chandra Das (proforma defendant
No.5) has been wrongly entered in the 24th column as permissive
possessor in respect of the suit land under khatian No. 113 but the said
Bipin Chandra Das never possessed the suit land being the permissive
possessor but one Ranjit Ranjan Paul in the year 1978 constructed a
hut for the purpose of manufacturing tiles in the suit land and he
stopped the business in the year 1981 and the said hut was demolished
and the suit land was lying vacant. The principal defendant No.1 has
been possessing the suit land from 01.01.1992 adversely denying the
right, title, and interest proforma defendant No.3 and 4 within the
knowledge of the owners and the world at large and the plaintiff without
taking possession of the suit land purchased the suit land through
registered Kobala bearing No.1-1848 dated 12.07.05 and hence till date
the ROR in respect of the suit land has not been issued in the name of
the plaintiff. The principal defendant No.1 has been possession the suit
land adversely beyond the period of prescription and as such right to
file the suit against the principal defendant No.1 has been extinguished
and hence the suit instituted by the plaintiff is liable to be dismissed.
The defendant also answered in their written statement that the right,
title and interest of the proforma defendant No.3 and 4 over the suit
land has been extinguished and as such they are not entitled to sell the
sit land to anybody else and so the registered sale deed No.1-1848
dated 12.07.05 executed by pro-defendant No. 3 is fraudulent and
liable to be dismissed.
[4]
After considering the pleadings and submission of both
sides, the trial court has framed the following issues for discussion:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
Whether the plaintiff in its present form?
Whether the plaintiff has got right, title and interest over the
suit land?
Whether the defendants have dispossessed the plaintiff from
suit land?
Is the plaintiff entitled to the decree as prayed for?
To what other relief/reliefs the parties are entitled to?
Is there any cause of action of the instant suit?
Is the suit barred by limitation?
Whether the defendant No.1 has been possessing the suit
land since 01.01.1992.
[5]
While deciding the issue No. II, the trial court has stated
that as per deposition of the plaintiff’s witnesses the said fact has not
transpired that the suit land has been mutually settled between Chaturi
Singh and Ruhini Singha or it was partitioned between them so that
Chaturi Singh became the exclusive owner and possessor of the suit
land. So, without any cogent evidence the trial court cannot believe that
the plaintiff had the right, title or interest over the suit land because
except the sale deed no other materials or evidence has been submitted
by the plaintiff to prove that he is the owner and possessor of the suit
land as per the existing documents submitted before the trial court. The
trial court was of the opinion that the suit land still exists jointy in the
name of Chaturi Singh and Ruhini Singh.
[6]
The trial court after having examined all the records so
placed in the plaint and also after examining the written statement filed
by the defendant-appellant, depositions of PWs and DWs in support of
the claim, has observed by the decree dated 28.06.2016 as herein
under:
“In the result, due to the above discussions it has
transpired that the defendant has failed to prove the plea
of adverse possession in their favour i.e. the defendant
has failed that they have been possessing the suit land
since 01.01.1992. On the other hand, the plaintiff have
also failed to establish right, title and interest over the
suit land. So, due to the above ground the present suit of
the plaintiff is dismissed on contest. Considering the
nature of the suit I make no order as to the costs of the
suit and direct the parties to bear their own costs. Thus,
the present case is dismissed on contest.”
[7]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree passed in the original suit, the appellant herein preferred an
appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.18 of 2012 in the court of the
District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar. The said court has
observed by the order dated 09.02.2018 that it has been stated by the
principal defendants-respondents that Smt. Chaturi Singha and Sri
Chitta Singha were the owners of said 012 acre suit land and the
principal defendant-respondent, Sri Radha Ranjan Paul finding the suit
land vacant occupied the suit land and has been possessing the suit
land adversely continuously and uninterruptedly since 01.01.1992 and
the planted trees and also constructed huts. But from exhibit -3 which is
also proved as exhibit-C it transpires that Bipin Chandra Das was the
permissive possessor of land measuring 12 satak 049 acre which is the
suit land. It is also stated that name of Bipin Ch. Das was wrongly
entered in the 24th column as permissive possessor in respect of the
suit land under khatian No.113 of Ramnagar Mouja. But the principal
defendant-respondents failed to adduce any cogent documentary
evidence to show that name of Bipin Ch. Das was wrongly entered in
that Khatian.
It was further observed by the order dated 09.02.2018 as
follows:
“In the result, the appeal is dismissed being devoid of
merit. The judgment and decree dated 28.06.2012 and
02.07.2012 respectively passed by Ld. Civil Judge (Junior
Division), Dharmangar, North Tripura in Title Suit No.24 of
2006 whereby and where under Ld. Trial Court has
dismissed the suit or contest is hereby upheld.”
[8]
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree of the
first appellate court dated 09.02.2018, the appellant herein has
preferred this instant appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. At the time
of admitting this appeal, the following substantial question of law was
framed by this court by the order dated 28.01.2019.
“1) Whether the findings relating to issue No.3 that for
failure of the plaintiff-appellant to apply for mutation
makes his claim of title bad in law?
2) Whether the findings of both the Courts below are
perverse?”
[9]
It is the case of the appellant that the appellant is the
owner of the property and he has purchased the said suit property from
his vendor with the tenant. The tenant has been informed about the
said transaction and he is put to notice by the vendor who is also the
defendant. The vendor has accepted and has no grievance against the
appellant-plaintiff. But the tenant-defendant denied plaintiff as the
owner. The sale deed, the vendor’s right, title and interest is not in
dispute, it cannot be said that the plaintiff by virtue of the registered
sale deed who has the right, title and interest over the property cannot
be denied his legitimate right. The contention of the tenant with regard
to the validity of the sale deed on the ground that the sale deed is
defected cannot be accepted.
[10]
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, counsel for the appellant has relied
upon the judgment of the apex court in Suraj Bhan and Others vs.
Financial Commissioner and others reported in (2007) 6 SCC 186
where the apex court has observed as under:
“8. So far as mutation is concerned, it clear
that entry has been made and mutation has been
effected in Revenue Records by Tehsildar on the
basis of an application made by respondent No.5
herein and his name has been entered in Record of
Rights on the basis of the Will said to have been
executed by Ratni Devi. In our opinion, therefore, it
cannot be said that by entering the name of
respondent No. 5 in Revenue Records, any illegality
had been committed by Tehsildar. It is true that no
notice was issued to the appellants but the
Tehsildar had taken the action on the basis of Will
said to have been executed by deceased Ratni Devi
in favour of respondent No. 5. The said order has
been confirmed by the Collector as also by Financial
Commissioner. When the grievance was made
against the said action by filing a Writ Petition, the
High Court also confirmed all the orders passed by
Revenue Authorities under the Act. We see no
infirmity so far as that part of the order is
concerned.
9. There is an additional reason as to why we
need not interfere with that order under Article 136
of the Constitution. It is well settled that an entry in
Revenue Records does not confer title on a person
whose name appears in Record of Rights. It is
settled law that entries in the Revenue Records or
Jamabandi have only 'fiscal purpose' i.e. payment of
land-revenue, and no ownership is conferred on the
basis of such entries. So far as title to the property
is concerned, it can only be decided by a competent
Civil Court (vide Jattu Ram v. Hakam Singh and
Ors., AIR 1994 SC 1653). As already noted earlier,
Civil Proceedings in regard to genuineness of Will
are pending with High Court of Delhi. In the
circumstances, we see no reason to interfere with
the order passed by the High Court in the writ
petition.”
[11]
The defendant tenant has denied the ownership of the
plaintiff and his claim of adverse possession and relied on the ROR
revenue Records and claimed that the suit needs to be dismissed. It is
the case of the defendants that the revenue records do not support the
case of the plaintiff and ownership of the plaintiff has been denied by
the defendant as owner and claimed adverse possession and prays to
continue to occupy the same and prays to dismiss the RSA in view of
the concurrent finding of both the courts against the plaintiff.
[12]
Mr. S. Lodh has also placed his reliance on Section 44 of
Transfer of Property Act and further contended that there were two
owners originally and only one owner signed the sale deed and the sale
deed is defective and since both the owners have not transferred the
property jointly the plaintiff cannot claim any relief against the tenant.
[13]
Mr. S. Lodh, counsel for the respondents has relied upon the
following judgments of the apex court (i) Union of India and Others vs.
Vasavi Cooperative Housing Society Limited and Others reported in
(2014) 2 SCC 269, where the apex court has held herein under:
15. It is trite law that, in a suit for declaration of title,
burden always lies on the plaintiff to make out and
establish a clear case for granting such a declaration and
the weakness, if any, of the case set up by the defendants
would not be a ground to grant relief to the plaintiff.
16. The High Court, we notice, has taken the view that
once the evidence is let in by both the parties, the
question of burden of proof pales into insignificance and
the evidence let in by both the parties is required to be
appreciated by the court in order to record its findings in
respect of each of the issues that may ultimately
determine the fate of the suit. The High Court has also
proceeded on the basis that initial burden would always
be upon the plaintiff to establish its case but if the
evidence let in by defendants in support of their case
probabalises the case set up by the plaintiff, such
evidence cannot be ignored and kept out of consideration.
17. At the outset, let us examine the legal position with
regard to whom the burden of proof lies in a suit for
declaration of title and possession. This Court in Maran
Mar Basselios Catholicos v. Thukalan Paulo Avira reported
in AIR1959 SC 31 observed that
“20…….in a suit for declaration if the
plaintiffs are to succeed, they must do so on the
strength of their own title.”
18. In Nagar Palika, Jind v. Jagat Singh, (1995) 3 SCC
426, this Court held as under:
“The onus to prove title to the property in question
was on the plaintiff-respondent. ……..In a suit for
ejectment based on title it was incumbent on the
part of the court of appeal first to record a finding
on the claim of title to the suit land made on behalf
of the plaintiff. The court is bound to enquire or
investigate that question first before going into any
other question that may arise in a suit.”
19. The legal position, therefore, is clear that the plaintiff
in a suit for declaration of title and possession could
succeed only on the strength of its own title and that
could be done only by adducing sufficient evidence to
discharge the onus on it, irrespective of the question
whether the defendants have proved their case or not. We
are of the view that even if the title set up by the
defendants is found against, in the absence of
establishment of plaintiff’s own title, plaintiff must be
non-suited.
20. We notice that the trial court as well as the High Court
rather than examining that question in depth, as to
whether the plaintiffs have succeeded in establishing their
title on the scheduled suit land, went on to examine in
depth the weakness of the defendants title. Defendants
relied on the entries in the GLR and their possession or repossession over the suit land to non-suit the Plaintiffs.
The court went on to examine the correctness and
evidentiary value of the entries in the GLR in the context
of the history and scope of Cantonment Act, 1924, the
Cantonment Land Administration Rules, 1925 and tried to
establish that no reliance could be placed on the GLR. The
question is not whether the GLR could be accepted or not,
the question is, whether the plaintiff could prove its title
over the suit property in question. The entries in the GLR
by themselves may not constitute title, but the question is
whether entries made in Ext.A-3 would confer title or not
on the Plaintiff.
21. This Court in several Judgments has held that the
revenue records does not confer title. In Corporation of
the City of Bangalore v. M. Papaiah and another (1989) 3
SCC 612 held that
“5. …….It is firmly established that revenue records
are not documents of title, and the question of
interpretation of document not being a document of
title is not a question of law.”
In Guru Amarjit Singh v. Rattan Chand and others (1993)
4 SCC 349 this Court has held that
“2. ……that the entries in jamabandi are not proof
of title”.
In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Keshav Ram and others
(1996) 11 SCC 257 this Court held that
“5. ….an entries in the revenue papers, by no
stretch of imagination can form the basis for
declaration of title in favour of the plaintiff.”
[14]
Further, reliance has been placed by the counsel for the
respondents on another judgment by the apex court in Jagdish Patel
vs. Shivnath and Others reported in (2019) 6 SCC 82, where the apex
court has observed in the following manner:
44. In the suit for declaration for title and possession, the
plaintiffs-respondents could succeed only on the strength
of their own title and not on the weakness of the case of
the defendants- appellants. The burden is on the
plaintiffs-respondents to establish their title to the suit
properties to show that they are entitled for a decree for
declaration. The plaintiffs-respondents have neither
produced the title document i.e. patta-lease which the
plaintiffs-respondents are relying upon nor proved their
right by adducing any other evidence. As noted above, the
revenue entries relied on by them are also held to be not
genuine. In any event, revenue entries for few Khataunis
are not proof of title; but are mere statements for revenue
purpose. They cannot confer any right or title on the party
relying on them for proving their title.
45. Observing that in a suit for declaration of title, the
plaintiffs- respondents are to succeed only on the strength
of their own title irrespective of whether the defendantsappellants have proved their case or not, in Union of India
and others v. Vasavi Co- operative Housing Society
Limited and others (2014) 2 SCC 269, it was held as
under:“15. It is trite law that, in a suit for declaration of
title, the burden always lies on the plaintiff to make
out and establish a clear case for granting such a
declaration and the weakness, if any, of the case
set up by the defendants would not be a ground to
grant relief to the plaintiff.”
[15]
In view of the above discussion and in the light of the
judgment of the apex court, this court has no hesitation to opine that
the tenant since both the original owners of the suit land are sisters and
one of the sisters has alienated the property in favour of the plaintiff
and having knowledge about the said alienation the defendant cannot
deny the title of the plaintiff and further it is not for the tenant to
contend with regard to the validity of the sale deed. Once the tenant
always the tenant unless there is any change circumstances of tenant
becoming the owner by virtue of a legally recognized transaction. The
interest in revenue records do not prove title and they cannot have an
overriding effect on the sale deed. In the present facts of the case, it
cannot be said that the defendant was enjoying an uninterrupted
possession and can claim his right under adverse possession. In the
present facts of the case the Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act
cannot be made applicable. There is no dispute or protest from the so
called vendor of the property.
Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 is extracted
herein under:
“Where one of two or more co-owners of
immoveable property legally competent in that behalf
transfers his share of such property or any interest
therein, the transferee acquires as to such share or
interest, and so far as is necessary to give, effect to the
transfer, the transferor’s right to joint possession or other
common or part enjoyment of the property, and to enforce
a partition of the same, but subject to the conditions and
liabilities affecting at the date of the transfer, the share or
interest so transferred.
Where the transferee of a share of a dwelling-house
belonging to an undivided family is not a member of the
family, nothing in this section shall be deemed to entitle
him to joint possession or other common or part
enjoyment of the house.”
[16]
During the course of the argument, the counsel for the
plaintiff submit that the original land purchased by the vendors of the
plaintiff is at large extent and both the sisters amongst themselves had
an understanding and with the consent a portion of the said property of
the vendor has been sold to the plaintiff.
[17]
It is not a case for deciding the validity of the sale deed or
cancellation of the sale deed by the tenant. It is with regard to the
relation between the tenant and the land lord. The defendant being the
tenant, since the title of the plaintiff by virtue of the registered sale
deed has not denied by its vendors who are also party to the suit.
Tenant cannot enter into the shoes of the vendor and contest the
matter on the ground that the plaintiff is not having valid sale deed.
[18]
In view of the above discussion this court has no hesitation
to set aside the orders of the lower appellate court and the trial court in
TS 24 of 2006 and TA 18 of 2012 respectively, the present appeal is
allowed in favour of the plaintiff/Land Lord.
[19]
The tenant-respondents are directed to vacate the premises
and hand over the vacant possession to the plaintiff within a period of
two months from the date of this order.
[20]
Registry is directed to prepare the decree accordingly.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review