Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.14 of 2021
1. Shri Tapan Dey,
S/O. Lt. Rasaraj Dey,
Resident of A.D. Nagar Road No. 9,
P.O. A.D. Nagar, P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Agartala.
2. Shri Shyamal Kalyan Dey,
S/O. Shri Tapan Dey,
Resident of A.D. Nagar Road No. 9,
P.O. A.D. Nagar, P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Agartala.
......Defendant-Respondent-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Shri Biswanath Dey,
S/O. Lt.Rasaraj Dey,
Resident of A.D. Nagar Road No. 9,
P.O. A.D. Nagar, P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura, Agartala.
2. Smt. Anjana Rani Dey,
W/O. Shri Ranjit Dey,
D/O. Lt. Rasaraj Dey,
Srinagar near Ramthakur College,
P.O. A.D. Nagar,
District- West Tripura, Agartala.
3. Smt. Chameli Rani Dey,
W/O. Shri Chandan Ghosh,
D/O. Lt. Rasaraj Dey,
East Dukli, P.O. East Pratapgarh,
Agartala, District- West Tripura.
4. Smt. Rita Rani Dey,
W/O. Shri Anup Sutradhar,
D/O. Lt. Rasaraj Dey,
A.D. Nagar, Surjya Para,
P.O. A.D. Nagar, Agartala,
District- West Tripura.
……Plaintiff-Appellant- Respondent(s)
5. Smt. Ratna Rani Dey,
W/O. Shri Tapan Dey,
D/O. Lt. Rasaraj Dey,
Bhati Abhoynagar, Hrishi Para,
P.O. Agartala, District- West Tripura.
…… Plaintiff-respondent- Respondent(s)
6. Smt. Swapna Rani Dey,
W/O. Shri Sambhu Ranjan Datta,
D/O. Lt. Rasaraj Dey,
A.D. Nagar Road No. 11,
P.O. A.D. Nagar, Agartala,
District- West Tripura.
…… Proforma Defendant Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. T.D. Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. D. Kalai, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Sarkar, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
29.11.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
14.12.2023
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES/NO
:
HON‘BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This Second Appeal filed under Section 100 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908 against the judgment and decree
dated 17.04.2021 and 13.05.2021 respectively passed by Ld.
Addl. District Judge, Court No.02, Agartala, West Tripura in
connection with case No. Title Appeal No. 26 of 2016
allowing the appeal of the plaintiff appellants and setting
aside the judgment dated 20.02.2016 and decree dated
27.02.2016 in connection with case No. Title Suit No. 132 of
2011 passed by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court
No.02, Agartala, West Tripura, dismissing the suit for
partition amongst the plaintiffs and defendant Nos. 1, 3 and
4 in equal share and also for declaration of purported
Registered WILL Vide No. III-103 dated 25.03.2008 to be
illegal, void ab-anitio and not binding upon the plaintiffs
(respondents).
02.
The facts as would be necessary for appreciating
the challenge as projected in the Second Appeal may be
noted at the outset.
03.
That the suit land as mentioned in Schedule A of
the original plaint was owned by one Giribala Ghosh(since
dead). She executed a Gift Deed in favour of Rasaraj Dey
(that is father of plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 and 3 and the
grandfather
of
defendant
No.2
in
the
original
suit).
Subsequently, the suit land was mutated in the name of
Rasaraj Dey and Khatian was prepared in his name Vide No.
546 under Mouja, Badharghat. Said Rasaraj Dey died on
22.03.1999. His legal heirs executed a Registered Deed of
partition Vide No. 1-5314 dated 21.07.2007. On the same
day, by executing another Registered Sale Deed vide No. 15315 dated 21.07.2007 the plaintiffs and the defendant
Nos.1 and 3 of the original suit (T.S. 132 of 2011) sold out
their share in favour of their mother Gita Rani Dey. Said Gita
Rani Dey expired on 04.02.2009 and accordingly her legal
heirs became the owner of the suit land as mentioned in
Schedule A. No Khatian was prepared in the name of said
Gita Rani Dey. Gita Rani Dey was a literate woman could
read and write Bengali and due to illness she was admitted
to TMC Hospital, Hapania, Agartala on last 04.03.2008. She
was taken to I.C.U, and oxygen mask was placed on her as
her condition was very critical. She was unconscious or in a
coma
position
not
understanding
the
circumstances
surrounding her. According to the plaintiffs of the original
suit, the defendant No.1 made a conspiracy with defendant
No.4 to deprive the plaintiffs from their share as mentioned
in Schedule A and created a fabricated WILL of the Schedule
B land. The defendants of the original suit managed to get
forged, thumb impression on the said purported WILL when
Gita Rani Dey was lying in the hospital bed. The contents of
the WILL were not read over and explained to her and the
WILL was not attested properly. Gita Rani dey was not aware
about the existence of the said WILL as it was in the custody
of defendant No.1(of original suit) beyond the knowledge of
other legal heirs or co-sharers of the suit land. In the opinion
of the plaintiffs (of original suit), the WILL was illegal, void
and not binding upon them and the defendant No.1 was
trying to grab the share of other legal heirs. It was the
further case of the plaintiffs in the original suit that the suit
land as mentioned in schedule A was their ancestral property
but, the same was wrongly mutated in the name of
defendant No.1 in collusion with the mutation authority. The
plaintiffs of the original suit came to know about the
existence of WILL on last 24.08.2011 but the defendant No.1
of the original suit was trying to sell the suit land on
14.07.2011 to some other person for which injunction
petition was filed against the defendant for restraining him
from changing the nature of the suit land. The plaintiffs of
the original suit demanded partition of the suit land as
mentioned in Schedule A on last 12.09.2011. But the
defendant No.1 refused to make partition of the suit land as
mentioned in Schedule A of the original plaint, nor did the
defendant No.1 file any prayer for probate for validity of the
WILL. So, the plaintiffs prayed for declaration of WILL vide
No. III-103 dated 25.03.2008 as void one as well as
preliminary decree for partition of the suit land as mentioned
in Schedule A. The suit was contested by the defendants of
the original suit and finally the Learned Trial Court below
dismissed the suit with costs. The operative portion of the
order dated 20.02.2016 of the Learned Court below was as
follows:
―In the result, this suit stands dismissed on
contest with costs.
Plaintiff has failed to prove the suspicious
circumstances for declaring the registered WILL
vide no.III-103, dated 25.03.2008, as void and
hence plaintiffs WILL not get any partition share
of the WILL property which is now exclusive
domain of defendant nos. 1 and 2 as because
finally published khatian is also prepared by the
settlement
authority
after
observing
all
formalities.
As the defendants contested the suit for last
5(five) years to get relief, so the costs is imposed
against the plaintiff in this regard.
Thus the suit is disposed of on contest with costs.
Prepare decree accordingly.‖
04.
Challenging that judgment the plaintiffs of the
original suit (T.S. No. 132 of 2011) preferred appeal before
the Court of Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala
and the case was numbered as T.A. No. 26 of 2016 and after
that Learned Addl. District Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura,
Agartala by judgment dated 17.04.2021 and decree dated
13.05.2021 was pleased to set aside the judgment of the
Learned Trial Court passed in T.S. 132 of 2011. The
operative portion of the order of the Learned First Appellate
Court is reproduced below:
―In the result, the appeal succeeds. The judgment
and decree so passed by trial court in TS 132 of
2011 stands set aside.
The registered WILL bearing No. III-103, dated
25.03.2008 being surrounded by suspicious
circumstances stands cancelled and delivered up.
The suit land as described in Schedule A of the
plaint in TS 132 of 2011 stands liable to be
divided / partitioned amongst the appellants,
respondent Nos. 1,3 and 4 in equal share.
Accordingly, the appellant Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 (plaintiff
Nos. 1, 3, 4 and 5 in TS 132 of 2011) respondent
Nos. 1, 3 (defendant Nos. 1 and plaintiff No. 2 in
TS 132 of 2011) and 4 (defendant No. 3 in TS 132
of 2011) are entitled to get 1/7th share each over
the suit land.
The parties to effect partition of the suit land as
per their share as declared herein above within
four months. Failing which each party having
share in the suit land, as declared herein-above,
shall be at liberty to approach the trial court to
have the final decree in accordance with law.
To feel contrive for their (parties) reproachable
conduct there is no order as to costs.
Prepare decree.‖
05.
Challenging
that
judgment,
the
principal
defendant Nos.1 and 2 of the original suit (T.S. No. 132 of
2011) have preferred this second appeal as stated above.
Before this Court at the time of admission of the second
appeal
the
following
substantial
question
of
law
was
formulated by order dated 16.11.2021.
―Whether the judgment and decree passed by the 1st Appellate
Court is perverse?‖
06.
Mr. T.D. Majumder, Learned Senior Counsel,
appearing for the appellants very categorically submitted
that if the oral testimonies of the witnesses of the parties
before the Lower Court are consciously scanned by this
Court, it would be very clear that there were no suspicious
circumstances to disbelieve the WILL executed by Gita Rani
Dey in favour of defendant No.1 i.e., the appellant No.1 of
this present appeal. He further submitted that the WILL was
duly proved as per provisions of Section 63 of the Indian
Succession Act, read with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence
Act and the evidence of one of the attesting witness was
very much trustworthy and the testator was found to be in
sound state of mind at the time of execution of WILL, by
commission. More so, the evidence of deed writer and also
the evidence of the staff of the office of Sub-Registrar were
very much convincing and satisfactory and to counter the
case of appellant No.1, the respondents of this present
appeal could not adduce any convincing oral as well as
documentary evidence on record to discard the evidence of
the present appellants. But the Learned First Appellate Court
did not appreciate the evidence on record properly and came
to a wrong conclusion that the registered WILL bearing No.
III-103 dated 25.03.2028 was executed under suspicious
circumstances. It was fairly submitted by Mr. T.D. Majumder
that the ‘WILL’ was prepared in the month of February 2008
but that could not be executed and registered at that time,
rather, the same was executed in commission when the
mother of the parties, Gita Rani Dey was admitted in TMC
Hospital. But on the body of the WILL it was written that the
same was prepared in the residence of the mother of the
appellant No.1 and other respondents and in this regard, due
explanation was given and there is no contrary evidence on
record that the Testator, Gita Rani Dey was admitted in I.C.U
and was in coma and she was wearing mask and was not in
a position to execute any WILL and due to her weakness and
trembling, she put her thumb impression without putting her
signatures on the body of the WILL. It was further submitted
by Mr. T.D. Majumder that there was no contrary medical
evidence on record that said Gita Rani Dey(testator) was
totally incapable to execute any WILL and further more the
present appellants before the Learned Trial Court have
proved all the aspects regarding due execution of the WILL
as per the requirement of law. So, according to Mr. T.D.
Majumder, Learned First Appellate Court ignoring the oral
and documentary evidence on record came to a wrong
finding that
the
WILL was
executed under suspicious
circumstances and ultimately cancelled the WILL and thus,
reversed the judgment of Learned Trial Court. Learned
Counsel, Mr. T.D. Majumder also referred two citations in
support of his contention.
07.
On the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel Mr. D.R.
Chowdhury, representing the respondents of this Second
Appeal, quite emphatically submitted that Learned First
Appellate Court rightly delivered the judgment setting aside
the judgment of the Learned Trial Court cancelling the
purported WILL. He further submitted that from the body of
the WILL it would be clear that there was no time given in
the WILL when the same was executed. No medical officer
was produced to substantiate that Gita Rani Dey was in
sound state of mind and more so on the body of the WILL it
was clearly mentioned that the WILL was executed at
residence. No step was taken to make correction of the
WILL. But later on the same was executed in the hospital on
commission. Mr. D.R. Chowdhury, further submitted that on
the body of the WILL there was one recital that the present
respondent No.2 of the second appeal would be permitted to
stay on the suit land but said respondent No.2 contested the
case by filing written statement denying the claim of the
present appellant No.1 and also submitted that the deed was
executed at the instance of appellant No. 1 beyond their
knowledge which cannot be acted upon. More so, as per law
it was the responsibility and the duty of the propounder to
satisfy the Court about the genuineness of the WILL which
he has failed to discharge in the case. So, according to
Learned Senior Counsel, Learned First Appellate Court has
rightly delivered the judgment setting aside the judgment of
the Learned Trial Court and submitted that there is no merit
in the Second Appeal and prayed for dismissal of the same
and also relied upon some citations regarding suspicious
circumstances and also submitted that the principles of the
cases are very much relevant for decision of this present
appeal and since the present appellants have failed to show
that the testator was sound to execute the WILL on that
relevant point of time and regarding preparation of the same
sitting at residence could not be clearly explained by the
present appellants i.e. the propounder of the WILL. Hence,
Learned Senior Counsel prayed for dismissal of the Second
Appeal with costs.
08.
From appreciation of the rival contention the
pertinent questions as surfaced for consideration by this
Court are:
1. Whether disputed WILL was at all executed by Gita
Rani Dey, the testator.
2. Whether the testator was in sound testamentary or
disposing mind at the time of execution of the
questioned WILL?
3. Whether the execution of the WILL is attended by
any suspicious circumstances?
09.
The
parameters
for
ascertaining
the
proper
execution of the WILL have well been recognized by various
decisions of the Apex Court and High Court.
10.
course
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. D.R. Chowdhury in
of
hearing
as
discussed
earlier
referred
some
citations.
11.
In Yashoda Gupta, Petitioner v. Suniti Goyal
and Ors., Respondents reported in AIR 2002, Delhi 20,
the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has elaborately dealt on the
various
aspects
regarding
suspicious
circumstances
as
follows:
―101. There are, therefore, three things to be
kept in mind, in cases such as this:(i) The propounder of a Will has to prove its due
and valid execution.
(ii) If there are any suspicious circumstances
surrounding the execution of a Will, the
propounder must remove the suspicions by
cogent and satisfactory evidence.
(iii) The application of the above principles
depends on the facts and circumstances of each
case.
118. Considering the various authorities cited
before me, it is quite clear that whether a WILL is
genuine or not has to be decided on the facts of
each case. There is no mathematical equation to
determine whether a Will is genuine or not. The
authenticity
of
a
Will
depends
on
the
circumstances surrounding its execution and the
quality of the evidence that is led in respect of its
genuineness.‖
12.
In Gurdial Kaur and others, Appellants v.
Kartar Kaur and others, Respondents reported in 1998
Supreme Court 2861, Hon’ble the Supreme Court observed
as under:
―4. The law is well settled that the conscience of
the Court must be satisfied that the Will in
question was not only executed and attested in
the manner required under the Indian Succession
Act, 1925 but it should also be found that the said
Will was the product of the free volition of the
executant who had voluntarily executed the same
after knowing and understanding the contents of
the Will. Therefore, whenever there is any
suspicious circumstance, the obligation is cast on
the propounder of the Will to dispel suspicious
circumstance. As in the facts and circumstances
of the case, the Court of Appeal below did not
accept the valid execution of the Will by
indicating reasons and coming to a specific
finding that suspicion had not been dispelled to
the satisfaction of the Court and such finding of
the Court of Appeal below has also has been
upheld by the High Court by the impugned
judgement, we do not find any reason to interfere
with such decision. This appeal, therefore, fails
and is dismissed without any order as to costs.‖
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kabita Kanwar v.
Mrs. Pamela Mehta and Others reported in AIR Online
2020 Supreme Court 2614 further observed as under:
―24.4. We may also usefully refer to the principles
enunciated in the case of Smt. Jaswant Kaur v.
Smt. Amrit Kaur and Ors., reported in (1977)1
SCC 369: (AIR 1977 SC 74) for dealing with a
WILL shrouded in suspicion, as follows: –
―9. In cases where the execution of a
Will is shrouded in suspicion, its proof
ceases to be a simple lis between the
plaintiff and the defendant. What,
generally, is an adversary proceeding
becomes in such cases a matter of the
court's conscience and then the true
question which arises for consideration
is whether the evidence led by the
propounder of the Will is such as to
satisfy the conscience of the court that
the Will was duly executed by the
testator. It is impossible to reach such
satisfaction unless the party which sets
up the Will offers a cogent and
convincing explanation of the suspicious
circumstances surrounding the making of
the Will.
(Emphasis supplied) ‖
14.
In Timir Baran Ghosh, Appellant v. Dilip
Kumar Ghosh and Ors., Respondents reported in 2014 1
TLR 485, this Court was also pleased to observe as under:
―16. In Gurdev Kaur & Ors. vs. Kaki & Ors.
reported in AIR 2006 SC 1975 the apex court has
again considered the ambit and purport of Section
63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 and has
held as under:
―76. The High Court has clearly deviated
from
the
settled
principle
of
interpretation of the WILL. The Court
does not sit in appeal over the right or
wrong of the testator's decision. The
Court's role is limited to examining
whether the instrument propounded as
the last WILL of the deceased is or is not
that by the testator and whether it is the
product of the free and sound disposing
mind. It is only for the purpose of
examining the authenticity or otherwise
of the instrument propounded as the last
WILL, that the Court looks into the
nature of the bequest.‖
20. The element of exclusion of the legal heirs
while making the disposition creates suspicious
circumstances or not has been dealt by the apex
court in Rabindra Nath Mukherjee and Another v.
Panchanan Banerjee (dead) by L.Rs. and Others
reported in AIR (1995) SC 1684 in no uncertain
terms as under:
―4. As to the first circumstance, we
would observe that this should not raise
any suspicion, because the whole idea
behind execution of Will is to interfere
with the normal line of succession. So
natural heirs would be debarred in every
case of Will; of course, it may be that in
some cases they are fully debarred arid
in others only partially. As in the present
case, the two executors are sons of a
half-blood brother of Saroj Bala, whereas
the objectors descendants of a full blood
sister, the disinheritance of latter could
not have been taken as a suspicious
circumstance,
when
some
of
her
descendants
are
even
beneficiaries
under the Will.‖
―24. On such aggregate consideration on the
touchstone of law as decided by the Apex Court,
this Court has no hesitation to hold that even if it
is held that the execution of the Will has been
proved but the said execution is attended by
those
suspicious
circumstances
and
such
suspicious circumstances could not be removed
by way of adequate evidence. It is to be further
noted that at the same time the respondents have
failed to prove that the said Will is manufactured
or that their father did not sign over the
testament by adequate evidence. Even the
statement of OPW-2 for purpose of testamentary
state of mind cannot be wholly accepted in view
of his varying assertion in different parts of oral
testimony. Thus to prove the allegations as was
with the respondents has not been properly
discharged. Therefore, the contention that the
Will was not (sic) executed or manufactured by
the appellant is not accepted by this Court. But
since the appellant could not eradicate completely
those suspicious circumstances as catalogued,
the trial court has committed no illegality in
refusing to grant probate of the Will in question.
As corollary thereof, this appeal stands is
dismissed.
15.
Referring the aforesaid citations, Learned Senior
Counsel further submitted before this Court that even if it is
held that the execution of the WILL has been proved but the
execution
of
the
same
is
attended
by
suspicious
circumstances, which could not be removed by adequate
evidence by the propounder, so, there is no scope to place
any reliance on the execution of the purported ‘WILL’ as
genuine in the case.
16.
He further submitted that the Learned First
Appellate Court after taking into consideration all these
aspects came to the finding that the WILL was executed
under suspicious circumstances and as such rightly reversed
the judgment of the Learned Trial Court below.
17.
On the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. T.D.
Majumder for the appellants has very categorically referred
the provisions of Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act and
Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act and submitted that the
WILL was duly executed and was proved by the propounder
without any suspicion and from the recitals of the WILL, the
very intention of the testator was duly proved. Only the fact
of mentioning the place of execution of WILL at residence,
there is no scope to disbelieve its execution and submitted
that Learned Trial Court below rightly delivered the judgment
but the Learned First Appellate Court mis-appreciated the
evidence on record and gave an erroneous finding.
18.
Now for the sake of convenience, I would like to
refer herein below the relevant provision of Section 63 of the
Indian Succession Act, 1928 and Section 68 of the Indian
Evidence Act:
Section 63 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1928:
63. Execution of unprivileged wills.—Every
testator, not being a soldier employed in an
expedition or engaged in actual warfare, [or an
airman so employed or engaged,] or a mariner at
sea, shall execute his will according to the
following rules:—
(a) The testator shall sign or shall affix his marks
to the will, or it shall be signed by some other
person in his presence and by his direction.
(b) The signature or mark of the testator, or the
signature of the person signing for him, shall be
so placed that it shall appear that it was intended
thereby to give effect to the writing as a will.
(c) The will shall be attested by two or more
witnesses, each of whom has seen the testator
sign or affix his mark to the will or has seen some
other person sign the will, in the presence and by
the direction of the testator, or has received from
the testator a personal acknowledgment of his
signature or mark, or of the signature of such
other person; and each of the witnesses shall sign
the will in the presence of the testator, but it shall
not be necessary that more than one witness be
present at the same time, and no particular form
of attestation shall be necessary.
Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act:
―68. Proof of execution of document required by
law to be attested.–– If a document is required by
law to be attested, it shall not be used as
evidence until one attesting witness at least has
been called for the purpose of proving its
execution, if there be an attesting witness alive,
and subject to the process of the Court and
capable of giving evidence:
[Provided that it shall not be necessary to call
an attesting witness in proof of the execution of
any document, not being a WILL, which has been
registered in accordance with the provisions of
the Indian Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908),
unless its execution by the person by whom it
purports to have been executed is specifically
denied.]‖
19.
As referred by the Learned Senior Counsel for the
appellants in Meena Pradhan and Others, Appellants v.
Kamla Pradhan and Another, Respondents, Hon’ble the
Supreme Court observed as under:
10.(ix)The test of judicial conscience has been
evolved for dealing with those cases where the
execution of the Will is surrounded by suspicious
circumstances. It requires to consider factors
such as awareness of the testator as to the
content as well as the consequences, nature and
effect of the dispositions in the Will; sound,
certain and disposing state of mind and memory
of the testator at the time of execution; testator
executed the Will while acting on his own free
Will;
(x) One who alleges fraud, fabrication, undue
influence et cetera has to prove the same.
However, even in the absence of such allegations,
if there are circumstances giving rise to doubt,
then it becomes the duty of the propounder to
dispel such suspicious circumstances by giving a
cogent and convincing explanation.
(xi) Suspicious circumstances must be ‗real,
germane and valid‘ and not merely ‗the fantasy of
the doubting mind‘. Whether a particular feature
would qualify as ‗suspicious‘ would depend on the
facts and circumstances of each case. Any
circumstance raising suspicion legitimate in
nature would qualify as a suspicious circumstance
for example, a shaky signature, a feeble mind, an
unfair and unjust disposition of property, the
propounder himself taking a leading part in the
making of the Will under which he receives a
substantial benefit, etc.
11. In short, apart from statutory compliance,
broadly it has to be proved that (a) the testator
signed the Will out of his own free Will,
(b) at the time of execution he had a sound state
of mind, (c) he was aware of the nature and
effect thereof and (d) the Will was not executed
under any suspicious circumstances.
12. Coming to the facts of the case, a careful
perusal of the relevant material on record and
applying the provisions and the case laws it is
evident tht the Will was duly executed by the
testator in the presence of witnesses out of his
free Will in a sound disposing state of mind and
the same stands proven through the testimony of
one of the attesting witnesses, namely, Suraj
Bahadur Limboo who was examined as PW-2 by
the Civil Court. This witness categorically states
that the testator executed the Will in question
and, both he and the testator signed the Will in
the presence of each other.
20.
Here in the case at hand both the parties of this
appeal have adduced their oral/documentary evidence on
record. The plaintiffs of the Original Suit (T.S. 132 of 2011)
have adduced 4(four) witnesses and relied upon some
documentary evidences which were marked as Exhibits 1 to
4. On the other hand, the contesting defendants of the
original suit i.e. the present appellants have adduced five
witnesses including the appellant defendant No.1 and also
relied upon documentary evidences which were marked as
Exhibit A to Exhibit I. The contesting plaintiffs i.e. the
respondents of the preset appeal thoroughly cross-examined
the witnesses of the defendant appellants. In this case the
main contention was that the WILL was executed by Gita
Rani Dey in favour of appellant defendant No.1 which the
plaintiffs respondents have challenged and it was asserted
that the WILL was executed beyond their knowledge and it
was executed when the mother of the appellant No.1 and the
defendants was admitted in the hospital and she was
admitted in I.C.U, having mask and was in coma. So, there
was no scope on her part to execute any WILL. To
substantiate the WILL as a valid one, the appellants have
adduced witnesses. DW1 in his cross examination stated that
at the time of execution of the WILL their mother was
admitted in the hospital and she was admitted in the hospital
on 03.03.2008. He further stated that Oxygen mask was
given to her mother when she was facing difficulties in
breathing and their mother was discharged from the hospital
on 14.03.2008. He further stated the WILL was prepared in
the month of February 2008 and also stated that the WILL
was executed in presence of Commissioner, Smt. Anjali
Debroy, appointed from Sub-Registry Office Pradip Kr. Paul,
scribe Indu Bhushan Shil and he himself. DW2, Dayamoy
Chakraborty
in
version
appellant
of
his
examination-in-chief,
defendant
No.1.
supported
In
his
the
cross-
examination he stated that the maker of the WILL was his
religious sister. In the month of June, 2007, Gita Rani
consulted with him with intention to make her WILL but that
time she did not prepare any WILL and she was in sound
state of mind having good health. Also stated that the WILL
could not be completed in the month of February 2008 when
she was fit and on 03.03.2008 Gita Rani was admitted in the
hospital for her treatment. That time, she was suffering from
illness but was not in dying condition. Also stated that WILL
was executed in the hospital and Gita Rani had writing
disabilities during her illness period.
21.
DW3, Pradip Kr. Paul, in his examination-in-chief
stated that on 11.03.2008 at the time of execution of WILL,
he went to General Ward of Tripura Medical College, along
with one Indu Bhusan Shil and at the time of execution he
was present and before execution the contents of the WILL
were read over to Gita Rani Dey infront of him when the
propounder Tapan Dey and other relatives of Gita Rani Dey
including Deed Writer, Debananda Choudhury were present.
He also stated that at the time of putting signature said Gita
Rani Dey told him that she will put her thumb impression as
she had trembling on her hand due to weakness. He also
stated that at the time of execution of the WILL the
executant/ testator was normal and capable to recognize
each and every person of her family and the witness
identified her signature on the WILL.
22.
DW4, Indu Bhusan Shil, is the scribe of the WILL
who had drafted the WILL as per desire of the testator and
took permission for getting its execution through commission
on 11.03.2008 and identified the WILL. In his examination-
in-chief, he further stated that though the WILL was shown
to be executed in the residence of Gita Rani Dey on
11.03.2008 but actually it was executed while she was under
treatment in the General Ward of TMC on 11.03.2008. But
due to inadvertence he did not make correction as to the
actual place of execution of the WILL. Thus, no correction
was made in the WILL regarding actual place of execution.
During cross examination, he stated that after returning from
hospital Gita Rani Dey was alive for another eleven months.
Nothing more came out relevant.
23.
CW1, the Court witness Anjali Debroy in course of
her examination by the appellant defendants stated that the
WILL was presented on 11.03.2008 and execution was on
the same day but registration was held on 25.03.2008. The
testator, Gita Rani Dey bequeathed her property to her son
Tapan Dey and grandson Shyam Kalyan Dey and also stated
as the WILL was executed on commission, she went to
Ambedkar Hospital when the executant was identified by
Deed Writer, Indu Bhusan Shil. She examined Gita Rani Dey
in the hospital and found her fit and in sound mind for
making WILL at that time and she was further tested as to
whether the WILL was made voluntarily. She also stated Gita
Rani Dey put her thumb impression in the WILL because at
that time due to weakness her hand was vibrating. So, she
put her thumb impression instead of putting signature. Her
further
evidence
is
that
the
other
witnesses
namely
Debananda Chowdhury, Pradip Kumar Paul also signed in her
presence in the WILL after thumb impression of Gita Rani
Dey. During cross-examination by the plaintiff respondents
she further stated that at the time of making WILL Gita Rani
Dey was able to speak in the hospital and she was not
having any oxygen mask in her mouth.
24.
From the evidence on record it is clear that the
respondent plaintiffs by the art of cross-examination of the
witnesses of the appellant defendants could not create any
cloud or doubt regarding execution of the purported WILL
executed by Gita Rani Dey in favour of the present
appellants. From the exhibited documents of the appellants
before the Learned Court below further it appears that the
testator was admitted in the hospital on 03.03.2008 and she
was discharged on 14.03.2008 from the General Ward of
Department of Medicine. There is no any contrary evidence
on record that she was in coma and was also in I.C.U and
there is also no evidence on record that she was not in a
position to put her signature or thumb impression. So for
non-production of Medical Officer when the representative of
the Sub-registry Office who went on commission very
categorically stated that the testator was in sound state of
mind at the time of execution of WILL and there was no
scope to disbelieve the due execution of the ‘WILL’. It is also
on record that the testator expired after a further period of
eleven months after being discharged from the hospital.
From the recitals of the WILL it is very clear that the testator
very clearly in the WILL has narrated as to why she
bequeathed her share of property to the present appellants.
Only because the place of preparation of WILL is shown to
have been written in the residence, it cannot be said that the
WILL was doubtful and it was not properly executed as due
explanation was given by the Deed Writer who drafted the
WILL in course of his evidence. More so, on scrutiny of the
WILL, this Court does not find any ambiguity as regards the
disposition of the WILL and furthermore, it also appears that
in execution of the WILL Section 63 of the Succession Act
and 68 of the Indian Evidence Act have been duly complied
with. So, the observation of the Learned First Appellate Court
appears to be based on misconception of fact and law. The
principles laid down in the aforesaid citations are very much
relevant in a case of execution of WILL under suspicious
circumstances. But the said principles in my considered view
cannot be applied in this case as the appellants (defendants)
could prove the WILL as per the provisions of the Succession
Act as well as the Indian Evidence Act.
25.
In the result, the appeal succeeds. The judgment
dated 17.04.2021 and the decree dated 13.05.2021 passed
by the Learned Addl. District Judge, Court No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala is hereby set aside and the judgment dated
20.02.2016 and decree dated 27.02.2016 passed by the
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2, Agartala,
West Tripura stands affirmed.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2023.12.16
18:27:47 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review