Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.116 of 2024
1. Sri Swapan Sarkar, S/O Lt. Debesh Chandra Sarkar, Resident of-Kalikapur,
Ramnagar, Ward No.15, Agartala Municipal Corporation, P.O.-Boarder
Rampur, Dist-West Tripura, Pin-799002.
2. Smt.Rina Sarkar, W/O Lt. Mishan Chandra Sarkar, @ Mishan Sarkar,
Resident of- Kalikapur, Ramnagar, Ward No. 15, Agartala Municipal
Corporation, P.O.-Boarder Rampur, Dist -West Tripura, Pin-799002.
3. Sri Rajesh Sarkar, S/O Lt. Mishan Chandra Sarkar @ Mishan Sarkar,
Resident of-Kalikapur, Ramnagar, Ward No.15, Agartala Municipal
Corporation, P.O.-Boarder Rampur, Dist -West Tripura, Pin-799002.
4. Smt. Sampa Rani Sarkar, W/O, Sri Bimal Das & D/O- Lt. Mishan Chandra
Sarkar @ Mishan Sarkar, Resident of-Kalikapur, Ramnagar, Ward No.15,
Agartala Municipal Corporation, P.O.-Boarder Rampur, Dist-West Tripura,
Pin-799002.
5. Smt. Soma Sarkar, W/O Sri Biswanath Majumder & D/O Lt. Mishan
Chandra Sarkar. @ Mishan Sarkar, Resident of-Kalikapur, Ramnagar, Ward
No.15,Agartala Municipal Corporation, P.O.-Boarder Rampur, Dist.-West
Tripura, Pin-799002.
.........Appellants(s);
Versus
1. The State of Tripura to be represented by the Secretary, Revenue
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Building, Capital
Complex, Kunjaban, P.S.- New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura,
Pin-799010.
2. The District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura, Government of Tripura,
Agartala, Pin-799001.
3. The L.A. Collector, West Tripura, (Addl. District Magistrate & Collector),
Office of the D.M. & Collector, West Tripura, Government of Tripura,
Agartala, Pin-799001.
4. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sadar Sub-Division, Government of
Tripura, Agartala, West Tripura, Pin-799001.
.........Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. Saktimoy Chakraborti, Advocate General,
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
13/02/2025
Heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
Samarjit Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the petitioners and Mr. Saktimoy
Chakraborti, learned Advocate General assisted by Ms. P. Chakraborty, learned
counsel for the State.
2.
The learned writ Court by the impugned order dated 23.09.2024
passed in WP(C) No.604/2024 has refused to allow the main prayer of the
petitioner for a direction upon the respondent Nos.1 to 4 who are the State of
Tripura; the District Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura; the L.A. Collector,
West Tripura and the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sadar Sub-Division, Agartala
to release the award money of Rs.79,15,938/- in the ratio of Rs.39,57,969/- to
the writ petitioner No.1-Sri Swapan Sarkar and Rs.9,89,492.25/- each to rest of
the petitioners who are the legal heirs of Lt. Mishan Sarkar, namely 1) Rina
Sarkar (wife); 2) Rajesh Sarkar (son); 3) Sampa Rani Sarkar (daughter); and 4)
Soma Sarkar (daughter). The claim of the petitioner was based upon a plea that
they are recorded as permissive occupier in respect of the land acquired under
notification dated 02.08.2018 by the Land Acquisition Collector, West Tripura,
for development of Integrated Check Post (ICP), Agartala under Section 19(1)
of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter refer to as ‘Act of
2013’). The petitioners themselves asserted that Abdul Aziz & others were the
original owners of the aforesaid land notified for acquisition. But by an
unregistered Deed of Exchange dated, 30.05.1964, he left behind to the
neighboring country and, thereafter, Debesh Ch. Sarkar who is the predecessor
of the petitioner, took the possession of the land of Abdul Aziz and others at
Agartala. After his death his 2(two) sons namely, Mishan Sarkar @Mishan
Chandra Sarkar and Swapan Sarkar being legal heirs became absolute joint
owners and possessors of the said suit land. The L.A. Collector, West Tripura,
Agartala, had issued notice to Rayati- Abdul Aziz & Ors, permissible occupier
namely Mishan Sarkar @ Mishan Chandra Sarkar and Swapan Sarkar, who are
sons of Debesh Ch. Sarkar of Ramnagar, to vacate and deliver the possession of
the acquired land. The predecessor of the petitioners were also asked to appear
before the learned S.D.M, Sadar office on 20.07.2019 with all required
testimonial, bank details etc. to receive the awarded compensation of
Rs.79,15,938/-(Rupees seventy nine lacs fifteen thousand nine hundred thirty
eight) only against Apportionment Sl. No.03 in case No.L.A.01/SDR/18. They
were informed that without correction of the records, awarded money cannot be
disbursed. Therefore, the petitioners had approached the writ Court.
3.
The learned writ Court held as under:
“When this Court has pointed out that the petitioners
have to show the ownership document upon which they are
making claim-statement, learned counsel for the petitioners
has produced Xerox copy of an unregistered sale-deed of the
year 1964. It is settled principle of law that such unregistered
document cannot be considered in the eye of law to declare
the petitioners as lawful owners. The khatiyan which is
placed on record, is only a revenue entry and it is not a title
document. However, the petitioners are given liberty to place
any ownership document including the succession of the
property to the concerned respondents since the petitioner
No.1 is claiming that his father was the original owner of the
land in question. On receipt of such documents from the
petitioners, the concerned respondents shall decide the matter
on merits in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible
preferably within a period of three months.
With the above directions, the present petition is
disposed of. As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s),
pending if any, shall also stand closed.”
4.
Evidently the learned writ Court granted opportunity to the
petitioners to approach the concerned respondents who were directed to decide
the matter in accordance with law as expeditiously as possible. Petitioners
being aggrieved have approached this Court.
5.
Mr.
P.
Roy
Barman,
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
petitioners/appellants inter alia has submitted that appellants are the legal heirs
of one Debesh Chandra Sarkar who under an unregistered deed of exchange of
30.05.1964 have claimed compensation in lieu of acquisition of land by the
LAC, West Tripura vide notification dated 10.07.2018 in respect of land
measuring 0.210 acre, Dag No.4245, Class- Nal, under Khatian No.1263/1,4 in
Ramnagar Tehsil, MoujaRamnagar, Street No.2/P for the purposes of
development of Integrated Check Post (ICP), Agartala under the Right to Fair
Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 [hereinafter referred to as “Act of 2013”].
Petitioners/appellants herein approached the learned Writ Court on failure of
the LAC to release the award amount of Rs.79,15,938/- to the petitioner No.1
and Rs.9,89,492.25/- each to the legal heirs of his deceased brother namely Lt.
Mishan Sarkar alias Mishan Chandra Sarkar, another son of Late Debesh
Chandra Sarkar. The learned Writ Court however refused to grant relief. It
instead gave liberty to the petitioner to place document of ownership including
succession of the property to the concerned respondents who were directed to
decide the same in accordance with law within a stipulated period.
6.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, leaned senior counsel for the appellants has
referred to the provisions of Section 3(c)(vi) and 3(r) of the definition clause
under the Act of 2013 to submit that an affected family would also mean a
family residing on any land in the urban areas for preceeding three years or
more prior to the acquisition of the land or whose primary source of livelihood
for three years prior to the acquisition of the land is affected by the acquisition
of such land and that “land owner” under clause (r) includes any person whose
name is recorded as the owner of the land or building or part thereof in the
records of the authority concerned. It is not in dispute that appellants are
regarded as permissive occupier and not the land owner in the record of rights;
perhaps that is why the LAC did not disburse the amount in their favour.
7.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, leaned senior counsel for the appellants
further submits that in respect of acquisition of land under the same notification
in the same mouja, disbursement of compensation had been made to others who
are also recorded as permissible occupier having got the land through
unregistered deed of exchange from the same original owner Abdul Aziz who
later on left for neighbouring country. Since Abdul Aziz and others have left for
the neighbouring country, therefore, they could not fall in the category of
‘persons interested’ as per the Act of 2013.
8.
Additional documents have been filed pursuant to the order dated
28.11.2024 by the petitioners/appellants ascertain that a common award dated
11.08.2004 passed in Misc. L.A. No.84/1994 and Misc. L.A. No.47/1994 and
others by the learned L.A. Judge, Agartala, West Tripura, compensation had
been awarded to the respective claimants who are the permissive occupiers in
respect to acquisition of land from them for construction of the fencing road
Tripura-Bangladesh border. They also assert that pursuant to the award in Misc.
L.A. No.82 of 1994 passed in favour of Sachindra Biswas, Birendra Biswas,
Khitindra Biswas, and Shitendra Biswas all are sons of late Dignedra Biswas,
compensation has been enhanced by the learned L.A. Judge, West Tripura, in
respect of acquisition made towards C.S. Plot No.3440/p, 3442/p under Khatian
No.2376.
9.
According to the petitioners by virtue of the un-registered deed of
exchange dated 30.05.1964, the right, title, interest in respect of the land in
favour of Debesh Chandra Sarkar, the petitioners predecessors have been
crystallized the deed of exchange (Annexure-10). These documents have been
placed to substantiate the plea that the compensation has been awarded in
similar circumstances by the L.A. Collector or L.A. Judge, in favour of the land
loser though they might be in the same category as permissive occupier.
Therefore, the impugned order may be set aside and the respondent No.3 may
be directed to release the awarded amount in favour of the petitioners.
10.
Mr. Saktimoy Chakraborti, learned Advocate General appearing
for the respondent-State submits that the status of the petitioners even on the
basis of their admitted case is only that of a permissive occupier and that too on
the basis of an un-registered deed of exchange dated 30.05.1964 with one
Abdul Aziz and others, the original owners whose name still stands in the
record of rights and who left for the neighbouring country. In such
circumstances, the title of the petitioners on the piece of land acquired is not
established. The LA Collector will have genuine reasons not to release the
award in their favour. Therefore, the best course for the petitioners is to
approach the competent Court of civil jurisdiction for declaration of their right,
title and interest over the piece of land so acquired. The learned writ Court has
also while observing that the revenue entry cannot be treated as a title
document, given liberty to the petitioners to produce any ownership documents
including succession of the property before the concerned respondent to
establish their claim. Therefore, the impugned order may not be interfered.
11.
On consideration of the rival submissions of the parties and
relevant materials placed from record, the point of law raised by the learned
senior counsel for the petitioners also, we are of the considered view that on an
issue relating to the ownership of the acquired land in question, this Court in
exercise of writ jurisdiction or at the appellate stage should not enter into any
determination. Petitioners have been claiming compensation on the claim of
being permissive occupier on the basis of an un-registered deed of exchange
dated 30.05.1964 through their predecessor from a person who has left for the
neighbouring country. On the other hand, petitioners have placed certain
documents to show that compensation has been awarded in certain cases. It is
therefore, open for them either to approach the respondent No.3-Land
Acquisition Collector with such additional documents to establish their plea of
release of compensation on grounds of parity or to approach the competent
Court of civil jurisdiction to establish their title.
12.
Accordingly, the instant petition is disposed of. Pending
application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
(BISWAJIT PALIT),J
Munna MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2025.02.19 16:25:37 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review