Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.16 of 2017
1. Sri Surajit Majumder,
Son of late Rakhal Chandra Majumder,
Kacharghat, Kailashahar Town, P.O. Kailashahar,
Unakoti, Tripura
2. Smt. Sujata Majumder,
Wife of Sri Arup Dey,
Ramnagar Road No.4, P.O. Agartala,
West Tripura
3. Smt. Nibedita Majumder (Kar),
Wife of Sri Subhas Chandra Kar,
Ranima Apartment (2nd Floor), Flat No.T1, 1/167,
Naktala, Kolkata-700047
(1 to 3, L.Rs of Late Gita Rani Majumder)
4. Smt. Saraswati Biswas,
Wife of Sri Hiranmoy Biswas,
Nabadarsha Housing Society, Plot No.J-11,
P.O. Birati, 24 Pargana, Kolkata-700051
5. Smt. Rekha Biswas,
Wife of Late Monoranjan Biswas,
Jolaibari, Belonia, South Tripura
----Defendant-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. LRs of deceased Nani Gopal Ghosh
1a. Sri Partha Pratim Ghosh,
Son of late Nani Gopal Ghosh,
Resident of Swarupananda Sarani,
P.O. & P.S.- Kailasahar,
District- Unakoti, Tripura.
1b. Smt. Gouri Ghosh Chowdhury,
Wife of Pradip Chowdhury,
Daughter of late Nani Gopal Ghosh,
Resident of Joradighir Paar,
P.O.- Banamalipur, Agartala.
1c. Smt. Ruma Ghosh Adhikari,
Wife of Radharaman Adhikari,
Daughter of late Nani Gopal Ghosh,
Resident of College Road, near G.C. College,
P.O.- Silchar, Assam.
Mobile No. 9485009448, 9862595036
----Plaintiff-respondent(s)
2.
Sri Jayanta Ghosh,
Son of Late Jawhar Lal Ghosh,
C/o M/s. J.L. Ghosh (Petrol Pump)
P.O.- Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura.
3.
Smt. Lila Rani Choudhury,
Wife of Sri Pranesh Ranjan Choudhury,
4, S.N. Mukherjee Road, Uttarpara,
Dist - Hoogly, West Bengal.
4.
Sri Rana Dasgupta,
Son of Late Sukhendu Ranjan Dasgupta,
Kailashahar Town, P.O. - Kailashahar,
Unakoti, Tripura.
5.
Smti. Tanushree Sengupta (Roy)
Wife of Sri Partha Sarathi Roy,
P.O. - Rahara, Haldar Bagan,
Khardah,24-pargs, West Bengal.
6.
Deleted by order dated 10-04-2019 in I.A. 4/2019
7.
Deleted by order dated 10.04.2019 in I.A. 4/2019
(4,5, 6 and 7, LR of Late Rama Rani Dasgupta)
8.
Sri Monojit Majumder,
Son of late Rakhal Chandra Majumder,
Office of the Deputy Director of Agriculture,
Ambassa, Dhalai, Tripura.
9.
Sri Subha Ranjan Sinha,
Son of Late Pulak Ranjan Sinha,
10. Sri Priya Ranjan Sinha,
Son of Late Pulak Ranjan Sinha,
11. Smti. Debolina Kundu,
Daughter of Late Pulak Ranjan Sinha
12. Smti. Madhulina Jana,
Daughter of Late Pulak Ranjan Sinha
13. Smti. Shyamalina Pramanik,
Daughter of Late Pulak Ranjan Sinha
Respondent No.9 to 13 are residents of Ramchandrapur,
C/O Subha Ranjan Sinha,
P.O. – Sankrai, District- Howrah, PIN-711313
(9,10, 11 and 12,-- LRs of Lt. Purnima Sinha)
14. Smti. Gouri Deb Choudhury,
Wife of Sri Anil Baran Deb Choudhury,
Kailashahar Town, Kali Dighirpar,
P.O. & P.S. – Kailashahar,
District – Unakoti
15. Smti. Sandhya Rani Pal,
Wife of Sri Rohini Kumar Pal, Kazirgaon,
P.S. – Kailashahar (Near Panchayet Office),
District – Unakoti.
16. Sri Nikhil Chandra Das,
Son of Late Monomohan Das,
Vill : Kazirgaon, P.S. – Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
17. Sri Sunil Chandra Das,
Son of Sri Hara Kumar Das,
Vill : Maguruli, P.S. – Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
18. Smti. Sabita Shil,
Daughter of Sri Sitesh Chandra Shil,
Vill : Bilashpur, P.S. – Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti)
19. Smti. Swapna Dey,
Wife of Sri Biswajit Dey,
Vill : Kamrangabari, P.S. – Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti)
20. Sri Dulan Miah,
Son of Cherag Ali,
Vill : Gobindapur, P.S. – Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti)
21. Sri Amulya Kumar Das,
Son of Late Adhar Chandra Das,
Vill : Pabiacherra, at present Vill : Kacherghat,
P.S. – Kailshahar,
District – North Tripura (now District –Unakoti)
22. Sri Dulal Chandra Banik,
Son of Late Akhil Chandra Banik,
Vill : Pabiacherra, P.S. – Fatikroy,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti)
23. Sri Amit Kumar Dey,
Son of Late Chitta Ranjan Dey,
24. Smti. Shila Dey,
Wife of Gouranga Dey,
25. Sri Pranesh Ranjan Dey,
Son of Late Jamini Dey,
26. Sri Sourabh Dey,
Son of Sri Harendra Chandra Dey,
27. Sri Hrishikesh Dass,
Son of Late Ratish Datta,
28. Sri Basudeb Datta,
Son of Late Pranesh Datta,
29. Sri Raghu Nath,
Son of Late Debendra Nath,
Secretary, Ramthakur Seva Ashram,
Sl. No.23 to 29 are residents of Vill : Pabiacherra,
P.S. – Fatikroy,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
30. Sri Jagadish Pal,
Son of Late Radhika Pal,
Of Ashram Palli (Kumarghat), P.S. Fatikroy,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
31. Sri Milan Kanti Das,
Son of Late Bhupendra Kumar Das,
Vill : Kazirgaon, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
32. Sri Bibhas Kanti Das,
Son of Late Bijoy Krishna Das,
Vill : Chandipur, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
33. Sri Chanchal Kumar Kar,
Son of Sri Chitta Ranjan Kar,
Vill : Chandipur, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
34. Sri Shyamal Dey,
Son of Sri Lalit Mohan Dey,
Vill : Sreerampur, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
35. Sri Sujit Kumar Deb,
Son of Late Shashi Mohan Deb,
Vill : Latiapura, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
36. Sri Binanda Debnath,
Son of Late Dinamoni Debnath,
Vill : Samrurpar, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District - Unakoti).
37. Sri Gopendra Chandra Gope,
Son of Sri Gopal Chandra Gope,
Vill : Mohanpur, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
38. Sri Bibhas Deb,
Son of Late Bidhu Bhusan Deb,
Vill : Boulapasa, P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
39. Sri Mrinal Kanti Pal,
Son of Late Makhan Chandra Pal,
Vill : Gobindapur (East), P.S. Kailashahar,
District – North Tripura (now District – Unakoti).
----Defendants-Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. G. K. Nama, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. A. Debbarma, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
29.01.2024
07.02.2024
YES/NO
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
The
defendant-appellants
namely
Sri
Surajit
Majumder, Smt. Sujata Majumder, Smti Nibedita Majumder,
Smt. Saraswati Biswas and Smt. Rekha Biswas are before
the High Court. They have preferred this appeal under
Section 96 of CPC challenging the judgment and decree
dated 06.04.2017 in connection with Case No.T.S.(Partition)
38 of 1999 delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Unakoti District, Kailashahar.
02.
Before entering into the merit of the appeal let
us revisit the subject matter of the dispute for which this
present appeal has been preferred. The respondent-plaintiff
Nani Gopal Ghosh filed one suit against the defendants for
partition of the suit land mentioned in the schedule of the
plaint
and
accordingly
the
suit
was
numbered
as
T.S.(Partition) 38 of 1999 before the court of Learned Civil
Judge, Senior Division, Unakoti District, Kailashahar. In
delivering
the
merit
Learned
Trial
Court
framed
following issues:
(i)
Is the suit maintainable in its present form?
(ii)
Is there any cause of action for this suit?
the
03.
(iii)
Are the parties entitled to get the partition as prayed for
in the pleadings?
(iv)
Are the parties entitled to get any other relief/cost?
After conclusion of trial Learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division by judgment dated 31.03.2008 decreed the
suit. The operative portion of the judgment of the then
Learned Civil Judge runs as follows:
“4. Considering all aspect I hereby decide that parties are
to bear their own costs. Accordingly issue No.4 is
decided.
In view of the discussions made above I am of the
opinion that the suit should be decreed on contest
without cost.
5. Hence the suit is decreed on contest without cost and
plaintiff, defendant Nos.1, 2, 3, 4 will get one-fifth share
each in “A” schedule land after deducting “D” schedule
land being declared as personal land of plaintiff and in
doing such partition the land described in “C” schedule
will equally fall and be calculated within aforesaid shares
of defendant Nos.1, 2, 3, 4 as the “C” schedule land was
sold by them from the joint property. I also decide that
each of the plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 & 2 will get onethird share in “B” schedule. I also decide that “D”
schedule land is declared as personal land of plaintiff.
6. Prepare preliminary decree accordingly.
7. Parties are to cause partition in terms of preliminary
decree amongst themselves within 60 (sixty) days from
the date of preliminary decree failing which survey
commission will be appointed on the application of either
party to cause partition in terms of preliminary decree
and on receipt of report of survey commission final
decree will be prepared.”
04.
Challenging that judgment the defendants of the
original suit preferred one appeal before the High Court and
the High Court after hearing in Case No.RFA No.06 of 2008
by judgment dated 08.02.2016 partly allowed the appeal
and remitted back the case record to the Learned Trial
Court with the following observations:
“19. Therefore, the appeal is partly allowed and the
matter is remitted to the learned trial Court for only
deciding the following issues:
(i) Whether the relinquishment deed dated 9th
February, 1965 was not executed by the four
sisters namely, Rama Rani Dasgupta, Rekha
Biswas, Gita Rani Majumder, Purnima Sinha?
(ii) If it is proved that the relinquishment deed
was executed whether the relinquishment deed
was not acted upon by the parties and is not
binding upon these four sisters namely, Rama Rani
Dasgupta, Rekha Biswas, Gita Rani Majumder,
Purnima Sinha?
In case issues (i) and (ii) are decided against four
sisters then they will have no share in the
properties.
(iii) What is the share, if any, of the plaintiff and
defendant Nos. 1 to 8 in the suit property?
(iv) Whether the land forming part of „D‟ Schedule
is part of the joint holding or is exclusive land of
the brother?
20. After determining the shares of the parties in the
property the share of Pannalal Ghosh shall be divided
between Nani Gopal Ghosh and the four surviving sisters
in equal shares in view of the finding given by this Court.
21. The learned trial Court is directed to issue notices at
the addresses given in the plaint and written statement
to the parties by registered speed post. The matter is
remitted to the learned trial Court only for the purpose of
determining these issues. The findings given by this Court
on other issues are binding on the trial Court and it shall
proceed accordingly. The learned trial Court is directed to
dispose of the suit at the earliest and in an event not
later than 31st December, 2016.
22. The parties who are represented before this Court
through counsel are directed to appear before the learned
trial Court on 1 st March, 2016. On the said date, the
learned trial Court shall issue notices only to the brothers
and sisters, who are not represented or their legal heirs.
Notice shall be sent by registered speed post at the cost
of the plaintiff to the addresses given in the
plaint/written statement and in case, the notices are not
received back within 30 days, it shall be presumed that
they have been served and the matter shall be proceed
accordingly. The sisters if they want to lead evidence can
do so and they shall be given at the most two
opportunities to do the same and thereafter, the plaintiff
Nani Gopal Ghosh will have two opportunities to lead his
evidence.
23. CRP No.47 of 2008 arises out of Title Suit No.25(P) of
2001 filed by Pannalal Ghosh and others i.e. his sisters
for partition of the suit property, which is virtually the
subject matter of dispute in Title Suit No.38(P) of 1999.
This suit was withdrawn. Though liberty was sought to
file a fresh suit, liberty was not granted and this revision
petition has been filed challenging the non-granting of
liberty. In the application filed for withdrawal of the civil
revision, it has been stated that the plaintiffs need to
withdraw this partition suit (on condition to re-file)
because another partition suit Title Suit No.38(P) of 1999
between the same parties is pending in this Court. The
second suit itself was not maintainable in my view.
Pannalal Ghosh is dead. The sisters have been given a
right to raise all the disputes in T.S. 38(P) of 1999 and
therefore, this petition is dismissed.”
05.
Thereafter Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Unakoti, Kailashahar after compliance of the direction of
High Court by an elaborate judgment dated 06.04.2017
again decreed the suit and passed preliminary decree
accordingly
and
challenging
that
decree
the
present
appellants have preferred this appeal before the High Court
again.
06.
Heard Mr. G.K. Nama, Learned counsel appearing
for the appellants and Ms. A. Debbarma, Learned counsel
appearing for the respondents. After hearing both the sides
and after going through the records of the Learned Court
below we have decided to formulate the following point for
just decision of the appeal:
Whether
the
06.04.2017
judgment
passed
by
and
decree
dated
Learned
Civil
Judge,
Senior Division, Unakoti, Kailashahar is perverse?
07.
In course of hearing of arguments Learned
counsel for the appellants submitted that the judgment
passed by the Learned court below suffers from various
infirmities as because the Learned court below did not
consider the exhibited documents relied upon by the
defendant-appellants before the Learned court below and
passed an erroneous judgment which cannot be maintained
in the eyes of law. He further submitted that for the
convenience of the court the defendant-appellants have
submitted one written argument which may be taken into
consideration at the time of delivery of judgment. Learned
counsel further submitted that at the time of delivery of
judgment on 08.02.2016, this High Court formulated four
issues and a direction was given to the Learned court below
to decide those issues after taking evidence on record of the
contesting parties. But the Learned Court below failed to
appreciate the evidence on record of the parties led by them
before the Learned court below and came to a wrong
observation about the actual entitlements and share by the
respondent-plaintiff No.1 and further submitted that the
respondent-plaintiff No.1 during his lifetime by different
registered deed of sale transferred huge quantum of land to
different
persons
but
those
were
not
taken
into
consideration by the Learned Trial Court below. Learned
counsel for the appellants further submitted that Exbt.-5 i.e.
the deed of relinquishment was not duly proved and
registered and not acted upon. But the Learned court below
came to a finding that the deed of relinquishment was duly
proved and registered and it was duly acted upon and came
to a perverse finding detrimental to the interest of the
defendant-appellants.
08.
Learned counsel also submitted that from the
evidence on record it appears that all the subject matter of
issues which were raised by the defendant-appellants and
others before the Learned Trial Court were not duly
considered by the Learned Court below and ultimately
decreed the suit, misinterpreting and misconstrued the
directions issued by the High Court. So the appellant urged
before this court for interference by way of setting aside the
judgment and decree of Learned Trial Court with a fresh
direction to remit back the case to the Learned Trial Court
for de novo trial of the suit.
09.
Per contra, Learned counsel for the contesting
respondents i.e. the respondent-plaintiff No.1 has fairly
submitted that in pursuance of the direction of the High
Court of Tripura passed in RFA No.6 of 2018, Learned Trial
court took evidence on record after informing the contesting
parties and thereafter rightly and reasonably delivered the
judgment decreeing the suit after taking into consideration
all the oral and documentary evidence on record and
Learned court below as per direction of the High Court came
to reasonable finding that Exbt.5 i.e. deed of relinquishment
was duly acted upon. So the Learned counsel appearing for
the respondents submitted that there is no scope to
interfere with the judgment passed by the Learned court
below and submitted before the court to upheld and affirm
the judgment of the Learned court below dismissing the
appeal and relied upon few citations.
10.
It is on record that to substantiate the case both
the parties have adduced their witnesses in support of their
claim over the suit land. For the sake of convenience, let us
revisit the relevant part of the evidence on record of the
parties. The respondent-plaintiff No.1 Nani Gopal Ghosh
before the Learned Trial Court submitted his examinationin-chief by an affidavit and he also relied upon some
documents which were marked as Exbt.1 series (documents
as per firisti dated 11.11.1999), Exbt.2 series (documents
submitted as per firisti dated 11.11.1999), Exbt.3 series
(document submitted by firisti dated 26.02.2008) and
document submitted as per firisti dated 26.02.2018 marked
as Exbt.4 series. During cross-examination by the principal
contesting defendants in the original suit he submitted that
his father expired on 15.12.1964 leaving behind his mother,
six daughters and three sons. He also stated that they are
businessman and there is no service holder in the family
and none of their brother was in service. He conducted the
entire business and property remaining with his father.
Cloth business ended in the year 1950 and also deposed
that at the time of death of his father he had one Petrol
pump
at
Kumarghat
and
one
Kerosine
business
at
Kailashahar. He had huge landed property. He further
deposed that he was unable to say the exact quantum of
land left by his father. It may be few hundreds drone. He
further deposed that his father had number of suits for
recovery of possession regarding land. On 09.02.1965, he
got power of attorney from his mother, six sisters and two
brothers to conduct the suits and cases. He further deposed
that he put some decrees in execution and some not and
regarding those cases his brothers and sisters subsequently
filed suits and cases and in those cases they made him
disclaimer. Also he deposed that he did not bring the land of
those suits as the land in the instant suit. His sister Rama
Dasgupta, Gita Rani Majumder, Rakha Biswas, Purnima
Sinha executed registered „Nadabi Patra‟ in respect of their
claim in the paternal property in the year 1965. He further
deposed that the reference under Section 30 regarding
acquisition of land for the purpose of District Judge‟s
quarters ended in compromise and they got the respective
shares of their award in compliance with the decree and the
decree they got after the execution of said „Nadabi Patra‟.
He further deposed that regarding „Nadabi Patra‟ executed
by
him
in
favour
of
Sushital
Dhar
and
his
father
subsequently his brothers and sisters filed T.S. 30/1973 for
land measuring 14.30 acres in which he got decree up to
High Court and it is still pending in Supreme Court and the
„Nadabi Patra‟ executed by him earlier was set aside and
that 14.30 acres of land is not the suit land in the instant
matter. He further deposed that in Misc. L.A. 38/82 though
he claimed one-tenth share. His co-sharers got their
respective shares. He could not say the exact amount of
agricultural and non-agricultural lands left by his deceased
father. Further deposed that Jawahar Ghosh, Gita Rani
Majumder,
Rakha
Biswas,
Purnima
Sinha
and
Rama
Dasgupta made registered gift deed in his favour regarding
the land where he constructed Petrol Pump at Kailashahar
on behalf of Purnima Sinha, Rekha Biswas and Saraswati
Ghosh he executed gift deed as their attorney in his favour
to avoid litigation. After one year his father made a gift
deed in favour of Panna Lal Ghosh regarding the same land.
His mother died in his custody. In the mortgage suit about
4/5 acres of land incorporated and their entire joint property
was incorporated in the suit. He further deposed that his
mother had 20 acres of personal land. She died in the year
1986 and her left estate was not incorporated in the present
suit. Upto 1972 his three brothers and his mother remained
in the same mess.
11.
PW-2, Ayesha Begam is a staff of Sub-Registrar
office, Kailashahar. Being summoned she appeared to
depose as a witness. She identified the sale-deed vide No.1449 dated 22.04.2015 executed by Panna Lal Ghosh as
attorney in favour of Shyamal Dey was marked as Exbt.8.
She had identified another certified copy of registered saledeed executed similarly as attorney in favour of Sujit Kr.
Deb vide No.1-454 dated 22.04.2015 which was compared
with the original document was marked as Exbt.9. She
identified another certified copy of sale-deed executed by
Panna Lal Ghosh as attorney in favour of Bhibas Das vide
sale-deed No. 1-452 dated 22.04.2015 marked as Exbt.10.
She identified copy of sale-deed executed by Panna Lal
Ghosh as attorney in favour of Chanchal Kr. Kar vide deed
No.1-451
dated
22.04.2015
marked
as
Exbt.11.
She
identified another certified copy of sale-deed executed by
Panna Lal Ghosh as attorney in favour of Bhibash Kanti Das
vide deed No.1-450 dated 22.04.2015 marked as Exbt.12.
Further she identified certified copy of sale-deed executed
by Panna Lal Ghosh as attorney in favour of Mrinal Kanti
Paul and others vide deed No.1-448 dated 22.04.2015
marked as Exbt.13. She identified certified copy of sale-
deed executed by Panna Lal Ghosh as attorney in favour of
Binanda Debnath vide deed No.1-453 dated 22.04.2015
marked as Exbt.14. She identified certified copy of saledeed executed by Panna Lal Ghosh as attorney in favour of
Milan Kanti Das vide deed No.1-447 dated 22.04.2015
marked as Exbt.15, she identified certified copy of sale-deed
executed by Panna Lal Ghosh as attorney in favour of
Gopandra Ch. Gope vide deed No.1-455 dated 22.04.2015
marked as Exbt.16. She identified certified copy of saledeed executed by Lila Choudhury as attorney in favour of
Sajal Bhadra vide deed No.1-226 dated 26.08.1986 marked
as Exbt.17. She identified certified copy of rectification saledeed executed between Panna Lal Ghosh @ Manik and
others as attorney in favour of Anil Baran Deb Choudhury
vide deed No.1-1900 dated 30.06.1981 marked as Exbt.18,
she identified another certified copy of rectification saledeed executed in between Panna Lal Ghosh @ Manik and
Girija Kr. Bhadra vide deed No.1-1901 dated 30.05.1981
marked
as
Exbt.19.
She
identified
certified
copy
of
rectification sale-deed executed in between Panna Lal Ghosh
@ Manik and Sudhir Kr. Banerjee vide deed No.1-1902
dated 30.05.1981 marked as Exbt.20 and she identified
certified copy of sale-deed executed in between Panna Lal
Ghosh @ Manik and Rajendra Ch. Deb vide deed No.1-1899
dated 30.05.1981 marked as Exbt.21.
During
cross-examination
by
the
contesting
respondent-defendants she stated that Exbt.6 to 14 were
registered as per judgment and direction of Hon‟ble High
Court of Tripura passed in connection with case No.W.P(C)
48 of 2003 and there is no signature of her in any of the
certified copies exhibited.
12.
The principal defendant No.1 of the original suit
being the younger brother of the respondent-plaintiff in
original contested the suit by filing written statement. He
also appeared to the Learned court below as a witness. In
his examination-in-chief in affidavit he has asserted the
grounds stated in his defence filed in the written statement.
But in course of cross-examination by the respondentplaintiff he deposed that he has got power of attorney
executed by his sisters in his favour in this suit. He further
deposed that in that power of attorney he was empowered
to depose as a witness. He further deposed that besides the
instant suit land the other land in suits related to their
paternal estates and records are being prepared in the
names
of
different
persons
by
virtue
of
different
transactions. He further deposed that he did not sell any
land from their joint property in between 1973 and 1999.
He admitted that he sold some land which fell into the
shares of his sisters by virtue of their power of attorney due
to the result of family arrangement. He could not say the
exact quantum of land sold by him. He further deposed that
once upon a time in the year 1970 he also executed Power
of Attorney in favour of Nani Gopal Ghosh and prior to that
he did not take any paternal estate and he was not aware of
the Power of Attorney executed in the year 1970. He also
deposed that after the death of his father so many
litigations cropped up and most of the cases were pending
and those cases he was involved but he did not contest
those cases by engaging any lawyer. His father had Taluk
and Jote land. He deposed that litigations were pending with
the property of his mother and the property of his mother
was recorded in her name. In his written statement he did
not give particulars of the estate left by his mother. At the
time of death of his father, his two sisters remained
unmarried and the expenses of the marriage went from the
joint family property. As Nani Gopal Ghosh did not furnish
account of the joint family income so they filed account suit.
In the year 1973 the power of attorney was executed by
them in favour of Nani Gopal Ghosh was cancelled and
before that they did never demand account of joint family
income to him. Again he deposed that he has got no
objection in causing partition.
13.
DW-1, Rana Dasgupta in his cross-examination
by way of affidavit deposed that he is the defendant No.5(a)
of the suit and he is one of the legal heirs of his mother
Rama Rani Dasgupta (since dead) who was the eldest
daughter of late Akhil Chandra Ghosh. He further deposed
that she cancelled the Power of Attorney executed in favour
of Panna Lal Ghosh and Nani Gopal Ghosh on 27.07.1974
and as such the written statement dated 15.03.2000 filed
by Panna Lal Ghosh on behalf of his mother was without any
authority and beyond knowledge of his mother. He also
deposed that his mother late Rama Rani Dasgupta was the
exclusive owner and possessor of land measuiring 0.820
acres recorded under Khatian No.4399 of mouja Kailashahar
appertaining
to
R.S.
Plot
No.4124,
4125,
4126,
4177/10386, 4128 by virtue of registered deed of gift No.12917 dated 07.07.1977 executed by late Priya Bala Ghosh
i.e wife of late Akhil Chandra Ghosh from her share of land
inherited after the death of late Akhil Ch. Ghosh and
accepting the gift by his mother entered into the possession
of the said land and by presenting deed of gift for
registration while it was attested by Nani Gopal Ghosh,
Pannalal Ghosh and Rakhal Ch. Majumder and he inherited
the said gifted land with his other sisters after the death of
his mother where he has got his homestead and building
over the said land. ROR of the same is standing in the name
of his mother. He further deposed that the plaintiff wrongly
included the said land in the suit land recorded under
Khatian No.804/5 and 805/6 of mouja Kailashahar under
“A” schedule land of the plaint which could not be the
subject matter of partition. This witness further stated that
his mother jointly with Smt. Rekha Biswas , late Gita Rani
Majumder, late Purnima Sinha executed the registered deed
of relinquishment dated 09.02.1965 in respect of all the
properties left by late Akhil Chandra Ghosh which was never
cancelled by any of the executants of the said deed. As
such, it is still in force and was acted upon and most of the
khatians are still standing in the name of late Akhil Ch.
Ghosh as the „Nadabi‟ was acted upon. He also deposed that
he could identify the signatures of his mother over the said
deed and also could identify the signature of his father as
one of the attesting witness of the said deed. But none of
the executants of the said deed except Rekha Biswas is
alive. He also deposed that the plaintiff Nani Gopal Ghosh
and late Panna Lal Ghosh obtained a registered Power of
Attorney from all legal heirs of late Akhil Ch. Ghosh for
management of the properties and for convenience on
09.02.1965 some properties were sold on the strength of
the Power of Attorney by Nani Gopal Ghosh for marriage of
Saraswati Ghosh (Biswas) and Lila Choudhury while they
had been residing in the family of Nani Gopal Ghosh.
From the year 1973 Panna Lal Ghosh had been
managing all the properties left by late Akhil Chandra Ghosh
except “D” schedule land which fell to the exclusive share of
Nani Gopal Ghosh by virtue of registered deed of dissolution
of partnership dated 14.10.1974 while he came into
exclusive
possession
of
entire
“D”
schedule
land
on
01.05.1973 to the knowledge of all the heirs of late Akhil
Chandra Ghosh and started to possess the said land as
exclusive owner. Further this witness stated as stained
relation and dispute cropped up between Nani Gopal Ghosh
and Panna Lal Ghosh his mother along with Gita Rani
Majumder and others executed the registered deed of gift
on 22.07.1976 in respect of “D” schedule land in which Nani
Gopal Ghosh was already in physical possession of land any
running his Petrol Pump and Kerosene godown. Pannalal
Ghosh subsequently manufactured some anti-dated gift
deeds on the basis of Power of Attorney but he never came
into possession of land under the purported gift deeds nor
his deeds were acted upon in any manner. He further
deposed that he can identify the signature of his mother on
the said gift deed dated 22.07.1976. He again stated that
the finally published khatian of the “D” schedule land was
also recorded in the name of Nani Gopal Ghosh finding him
exclusive owner and possessor “D” schedule land. He
further deposed that Pannalal Ghosh during his life-time and
management of properties left by Akhil Chandra Ghosh on
the
strength
of
registered
Power
of
Attorney
dated
09.02.1965 beyond the knowledge of legal heirs of late
Akhil Chandra Ghosh sold out valuable land measuring
27.10 acres of mouja-Pabiacherra left by late Akhil Ch.
Ghosh in the year 1981 and all the lands were acquired by
the Government for construction of Railway line before filing
of the suit. Again he deposed that Pannalal Ghosh during
pendency of the suit as attorney of his sisters except his
mother sold out most valuable land of Kailashahar town
measuring 0.234 acres by registered sale-deeds in the year
2002 which is front portion of “A” schedule land under
Khatian No.804/1 and 804/2 of mouja Kailashahar. Thus,
Pannalal Ghosh had left no share of properties and L.A.
Collector made awards in L.A. Cases in the name of all legal
heirs of late Akhil Ch. Ghosh in the khaians of acquired land
were standing in his name, but in need of money on the
request of Nani Gopal Ghosh and Panna Lal Ghosh his
mother
and
others
received
compensation
money
on
compromise.
14.
Before the court on oath he further stated late
Priyabala Ghosh wife of late Akhil Ch. Ghosh was his
grandmother i.e mother of his mother. She gifted one plot
of land measuring a bit more than 2 kanis falls under Aschedule land described in the plaint. He stressed upon his
claim to that particular plot of land. Again he stated that he
has got no other claim apart from this in connection with
this suit. His mother Rama Dasgupta died on 05.02.2005.
He was acquainted with the hand writing and signature of
his mother and identified her signatures in the gift deed
dated 22.07.1976 executed by his mother and others in
favour of Nanigopal Ghosh marked as Exhbt. 3/2, 3/3, 3/4,
3/5, 3/6 & 3/7. He also identified the signature of his
mother in the deed of relinquishment in two pages marked
Exbt.5/1 and 5/2. He further stated that he was acquainted
with the signature of his father who expired on 26.08.1991.
He also identified the deed of relinquishment marked as
Exbt.5/3. The “D” schedule land described in the plaint was
under the possession of Nanigopal Ghosh since 1973. One
dispute arose in between Panna Lal Ghosh and Nani Gopal
Ghosh. He did not submit any written statement in this suit.
He further deposed that in the year 2000 his mother did not
execute any Power of Attorney in favour of Panna Lal
Ghosh. In the year 1965 his mother and others gave one
Power of Attorney to Pannalal Ghosh and Nani Gopal Ghosh
for the purpose of conducting the suits left pending by his
grand-father Akhil Ch. Ghosh. The said Power of Attorney
was cancelled by his mother in the year 1974. He also
stated that he has no claim over “D” schedule land and the
deed of relinquishment was never cancelled by his mother.
After execution of the deed of the relinquishment his mother
or her sisters did not individually sale any land left by Akhil
Ch. Ghosh. In the year 1981 Pannalal Ghosh sold 27 acres
of land left by Akhil Ch. Ghosh and in the year 2002 again
he sold out 12/14 gandas of land which is adjacent to Girls‟
School, Kailashahar. There is one case pending in the
Revenue Court regarding ceiling in respect of the property
of Akhil Ch. Ghosh. He and his mother did not receive any
sale proceeds of the land sold by Pannalal Ghosh. A
considerable part of the property was acquired but the
benefit of the same was not given to his mother.
In
the
cross-examination
by
defendant
Surajit
Majumder he deposed that he was not present when Exbt.3
and Exbt.5 were executed. After the death of his mother he
himself and her other legal heirs were not substituted and
they were not made party of the suit. There are two suits
pending in respect of property of Akhil Ch. Ghosh before the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India. He submitted two affidavits
in respect of those two suits. Nothing more came out
relevant.
15.
DW-2 Surajit Majumder in his examination-in-
chief in affidavit submitted that his mother defendant No.7
Gita Rani Majumder was the party of this suit and after her
death her legal heirs were substituted as defendant 7(b to
e).
Said Gita
Rani Majumder filed one
joint
written
statement along with other defendants on 15.03.2000. After
the death of Akhil Ch. Ghosh the plaintiff became Karta of
the
said
family
and
he
manufactured
the
so
called
registered deed of relinquishment on 09.02.1965. But the
deed of relinquishment was never acted upon as the plaintiff
himself accepted their registered deed of General Power of
Attorney
on
the
same
date
i.e.
09.02.1965
for
administration of their joint property and conducting their
litigations etc. He also stated that the plaintiff sold out
several
joint
properties on their behalf without
their
consent. The deed of relinquishment never acted upon and
it is evident from several cases such as Civil Misc (LA) 38 of
1982 in the court of Ld. District Judge, Kailashahar and in
Civil Misc. (LA) 01 of 1998 in the court of Ld. District Judge,
Kailashahar in which Gita Rani Majumder was made party.
Said plaintiff made solemn statement on oath in proceeding
relating to the property in Civil Misc. LA 38 of 1982 that all
the legal heirs of late Akhil Ch. Ghosh including Gita Rani
Majumder had equal shares in the properties of late Akhil
Chandra Ghosh. So according to him the relinquishment
deed dated 09.02.1965 was not acted upon. He further
stated that the plaintiff himself stated that the defendants
No.3, 6 and 8 put his signature as executants and the gift
deed dated 22.07.1976 was prepared by plaintiff in favour
of himself. The plaintiff also admitted this fact in his crossexamination on 25.03.2008. The executants and the socalled recipient of that deed seems to be the same person
and it was made collusive which according to this witness
cannot be made effective in law. The defendant No.4 herself
and defendants No.3, 6 and 8 through their appointed
attorney Pannalal Ghosh executed one gift deed in favour of
their mother Priyabala Ghosh on 21.07.1976. Later on,
Priyabala Ghosh executed another gift deed bearing No.12951 dated 14.07.1977 in favour of Pannalal Ghosh. So
according to this witness the plaintiff cannot become the
exclusive owner of the “D” schedule land. He further
deposed that on 26.02.2014 the plaintiff in collusion with his
son fraudulently mutated “D” schedule land in his name just
placing preliminary decree of TS 38 (P) of 1999 and
collusive gift deed dated 22.07.1976. A new khatian was
posted in the name of Nani Gopal Ghosh bearing No.5809
(Petrol Pump) and 229/1 (Kerosene godown). He also
stated that the plaintiff has intentionally suppressed the
potential facts as per law and rule of ceiling limit under the
TLR & LR Act, 1960 and the plaintiff has already reached his
optimum
as
per
decision
of
the
competent
Revenue
authority vide order dated 08.06.1976 passed in Ceiling
Case No.01 of 1976 and this order was passed by the then
District Collector S. Narayanan. The plaintiff at that time
having four members (one wife, two daughters and one
son) and the same still reduced later on with the death of
wife and marriage of two daughters and he cannot held
more than 10 acres of land by him but it was observed in
the order that he was holding 10.212 acres of land.
16.
In support of his examination-in-chief he also
relied upon some documents which were marked as
exhibits. The certified copy of decree dated 31.08.1988 in
TS 01 of 1988 passed by the Learned District Judge, North
Tripura, Kailashahar containing 19 sheets of paper marked
as Exbt.A as a whole (with objection). He submitted original
registered gift deed No.1-3668 dated 28.08.1976 executed
on 21.07.1976 in three sheets marked as Exbt.B (with
objection). He also relied upon another registered gift deed
No.1-2951 dated 14.07.1977 executed on 14.07.1977 in
three sheets which were marked as Exbt.C (with objection).
He submitted original Power of Attorney dated 18.02.2016
executed by Smt. Saraswati Biswas in his favour in seven
sheets
marked
as
Exbt.D
(with
objection).
He
also
submitted certified copy of registered general Power of
Attorney dated 10.10.2012 executed by Smt. Rekha Biswas
in favour of Ashok Lal Gon in two sheets marked as Exbt.E
(with objection), submitted computerized copy of khatian
No.5809 of mouja-Kailashahar marked as Exbt.F, submitted
computerized
copy
of
khatian
No.229/1
of
mouja-
Kailashahar marked as Exbt.G, submitted certified copy of
order sheet of revenue proceeding No.9 of 1976 dated
08.06.1976 in three sheets marked as Exbt. H. H/1 and H/2
(with
objection),
submitted
certified
copy
of
written
statement filed in L.A. Case No.1(Kai)/1981 in five sheets
marked as Exbt.I (with objection), submitted certified copy
of evidence of petitioner in L.A. Case No.38/1982 in five
sheets marked as Exbt.J (with objection), also submitted
certified copy of judgment & decree passed in L.A. Case
No.38 of 1982 dated 11.10.1985 in twenty two sheets
marked as Exbt.K (with objection), submitted certified copy
of order sheet dated 26.02.2014 in MR. Case No.169 of
2014 marked as Exbt.L (with objection), also submitted
report of mutation in MR Case No.169 of 2014 in two sheets
which were marked as Exbt. M & M/1(with objection),
submitted certified copy of order sheet dated 26.02.2014 in
MR Case No.164 of 2014 marked as Exbt.N (with objection),
submitted report of mutation in MR case No.164/2014
marked as Exbt.O (with objection) and submitted certified
copy of mutation notice in MR case No.20140164 marked as
Exbt.P (with objection).
During cross-examination by the plaintiff he was
confronted with the registered gift deed No.1-3307 under
Exbt.3 series to which he admitted that the land under said
gift deed relates to the „D‟ schedule land of present suit. But
he could not surely say that whether the signatures in the
said gift deed are/were of his mother Gita Rani Majumder or
not. He identified the signature of his father in the said gift
deed as attesting witness and identified the same marked
as Exbt.3/1. He was confronted with registered deed No.IV21 dated 09.02.1965 to which he admitted that it is
relinquishment deed and was marked as Exbt.5 (two
sheets). But he could not surely say whether those were the
signatures of his mother in the said relinquishment deed or
not. He also stated that the deed was executed before his
birth. He further stated that probably in the year 1972 his
aunt Saraswati Biswas got married. Later on, his another
aunt Lila Choudhury got married but he could not say the
exact time and that time Akhil Chandra Ghosh was not
alive. His mother Gita Rani Majumder died on 13.08.2009.
He also deposed that his brothers and sisters are not the
legal heirs of deceased Pannalal Ghosh. He further stated
that probably no Power of Attorney was executed by his
mother in favour of Pannalal Ghosh in connection with the
present case and could not say whether Saraswati Biswas
had executed any Power of Attorney or not in favour of
Pannalal Ghosh. They have not submitted any written
statement for themselves as the legal heirs of Gita Rani
Majumder. His mother did not step into the witness box for
deposing as witness. His aunt Saraswati Biswas also did not
step into the witness box to depose as a witness. He further
stated that when the present suit was filed that time all the
brothers and sisters had their own family having separate
mess. Again he stated that once upon a time there was no
good relation in between Nani Gopal Ghosh and Pannalal
Ghosh and submitted that he did not submit any counterclaim on the basis of relinquishment deed. He also could not
say as to whether his mother executed any gift deed on
22.07.1996 or not. He could not say as to whether the gift
deed dated 22.07.1976 was cancelled or not. He could not
say from which point of time Nani Gopal Ghosh was
occupying “D” schedule land. He could not say anything
about partnership deed in between Nani Gopal Ghosh and
his two brothers. He has further submitted that Pannalal
Ghosh had one Petrol Pump at Kumarghat, Nani Gopal
Ghosh had one Petrol Pump at Kailashahar and Jaharlal
Ghosh had one Petrol Pump at Kamalpur. He also could not
say that whether Pannalal Ghosh was looking after the
properties or not except Petrol Pump at Kailashahar. He was
confronted with the certified copy of khatian Nos.229/1 and
5809 of mouja-Kailashahar to which the witness admitted
that the facts and also submitted that they have submitted
the same documents and the documents were marked as
Exbt.6 & 7, but volunteered that they have challenged the
aforesaid khatians before the Revenue Authority. He had
submitted that they have not submitted any document to
show that said khatians have been challenged before the
Revenue Forum. He also submitted that very recently a
building has been constructed over „D‟ schedule land but he
could not say who constructed said building. Nani Gopal
Ghosh was occupying the „D‟ schedule land. But he could
not say specifically from which point of time said Nani Gopal
Ghosh was possessing „D‟ schedule land. Again he stated
that since 15/16 years Nani Gopal Ghosh was running his
business at Kailashahar over „D‟ schedule land. He could not
say whether any step was taken for mutation of „D‟ schedule
land during revisional survey operation by his mother or by
Pannalal Ghosh. He has no claim over „B‟ schedule land. He
could not say as to whether any other has made any
objection to the revenue authority about mutation of „D‟
schedule land except him. He could not say whether
Pannalal Ghosh had sold out more than 60% of properties
left out by Akhil Ch. Ghosh or not. Again he stated that
Pannalal Ghosh was also the attorney of his mother and as
per Power of Attorney Pannalal Ghosh had sold out certain
landed property of „A‟ schedule land. He also stated that
sale-deeds had been registered during pendency of the suit
and there are several buildings standing on the said land
and those were the in front side of „A‟ schedule property.
They did not submit any document showing the receipt of
award in LA proceeding and further stated that on the basis
of Power of Attorney dated 09.02.1965 several litigations
were cropped up. One civil appeal is pending before the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in reference to the decree passed in
T.S. 01 of 1998. He also stated that Saraswati Biswas and
Lila Choudhury are residing outside the State of Tripura and
his brother Monojit Majumder was residing in Tripura. He
has further stated that there is one K. Oil depot at
Kailashahar market(west) situated within „D‟ schedule land
run by Nani Gopal Ghosh. Again he denied that the defence
of the plaintiff that Pannalal Ghosh on the basis of influential
power of attorney had sold out certain property of Akhil Ch.
Ghosh. He has further stated that Power of Attorney dated
09.02.1965 was executed both in favour of Nani Gopal
Ghosh and Pannalal Ghosh.
17.
DW-3, Atanu Roy was working as Computer
Operator in the office of Sub-Registrar, Kailashahar and he
appeared before the court being deputed by Sub-Registrar.
He identified the certified copy of registered sale-deed No.13103 dated 30.04.1968 in between Satyendra Kumar
Debroy in one side and Nani Gopal Ghosh and others in
another side.
He identified the said certified copy marked
as Exbt.Q (with objection). He had identified another
certified copy of registered sale-deed No.1-3104 dated
30.04.1968 in between Smt. Basanti Bala Debroy in one
side and Nani Gopal Ghosh and others in other side. After
comparison it was marked as Exbt.R (with objection). He
identified certified copy of registered sale-deed No.1-4852
dated 21.12.1970 in between Sri Makhanlal Mondal in one
side and Nani Gopal Ghosh and others in other side marked
as Exbt.S (with objection). He identified certified copy of
registered
sale-deed
No.1-3152
dated
22.05.1970
in
between Sri Abhinash Deb in one side and Nani Gopal
Ghosh and others in other side marked Exbt.T (with
objection). He identified certified copy of registered sale-
deed No.1-149 dated 16.01.1967 in between Nani Gopal
Ghosh in one side and Hashmat Ali and others in other side
marked as Exbt. U(with objection). He identified another
certified copy of registered sale-deed No.1-152 dated
16.01.1967 in between Nani Gopal Ghosh in one side and
Sekander Ali and others in other side marked as Exbt.V
(with objection). He identified certified copy of registered
sale-deed No.1-2126 dated 18.09.1992 in between Subodh
Kumar Majumder and other in one side and Ajit Kumar
Majumder in other side marked as Exbt.W (with objection).
Further he identified certified copy of registered sale-deed
No.1-1529 dated 21.10.1998 in between Nani Gopal Ghosh
in one side and Jyotsna Sarkar in other side marked as
Exbt.X (with objection). During cross-examination he stated
that it was not possible on his part to say who had written
the contents of certified copies of aforesaid documents and
also admitted that the certified copies were issued before
his joining at Kailashahar.
18.
In
course
of
hearing
of
argument
Learned
counsel for the appellants submitted that Learned court
below failed to
appreciate Exbt.-5
and the
exhibited
documents at the instance of DW-2 and came to an
erroneous finding that Exbt.5 was duly acted upon. Learned
counsel further submitted that the Learned court below in
deciding the suit did not consider aforesaid exhibits Q R S T
U V W X by which the plaintiff had sold out a considerable
portion of the land which was part of suit land but the
Learned court below did not consider those exhibited
documents and came to an erroneous observation and
ultimately decreed the suit. Referring the evidences of the
parties
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellants
submitted that the Learned court below at the time of
deciding the suit could not properly appreciate or determine
the points as framed by the High Court in delivering the
judgment in connection with RFA 06/2008 and ultimately
came to an erroneous finding for which interference of this
court is required and prayed for setting aside the judgment
passed by the Learned Trial Court.
19.
On the other hand, Learned counsel Ms. A.
Debbarma appearing for the respondent-plaintiff No.1 has
submitted that the Learned Trial Court below as per the
directions given in case No.RFA 06/2008 took evidence on
record of the witnesses and after elaborate discussions of all
the points including the evidence on record and considering
all
aspects
has
reasonably
and
rightly
delivered
the
judgment and accordingly preliminary decree was passed
and there is no scope to interfere with the judgment at this
stage and prayed for dismissal of the appeal with costs and
relied upon some decisions.
20.
We have heard arguments of both the sides and
gone through the record of the Learned court below. As
already stated the respondent-plaintiff No.1 Nani Gopal
Ghosh filed the partition suit against the defendant Panna
Lal Ghosh (since dead), Jaharlal Ghosh (since dead) and
also against his sisters. Presently all the sisters are not alive
and their legal heirs have been substituted. In the plaint the
respondent-plaintiff No.1 given four schedules such as A B C
D. According to the original respondent-plaintiff (since dead)
out of his six sisters the defendant Nos.5-8 i.e. four sisters
namely Rama Rani Dasgupta, Rekha Biswas, Gita Rani
Majumder and Purnima Sinha had executed one deed of
relinquishment (Exbt.5) and gave up all rights and claims
upon the property left by their father Akhil Chandra Ghosh
(since dead) inherited by them. It was the further case of
said Nani
Gopal Ghosh that
he
himself, his brother
defendant Pannalal Ghosh, Jaharlal Ghosh, defendant No.3
Saraswati Ghosh (Biswas) and defendant No.4 Lila Rani
Ghosh (Choudhury) are the only persons entitled for share
of the property left by their deceased father Akhil Ch. Ghosh
including the share left by their mother Priabala Ghosh
(since dead) and the said property has been described in
Schedule „A‟ of the plaint.
21.
It was the further case of the respondent-plaintiff
that the land as described in the schedule-B of the plaint
was purchased by him along with two other brothers and it
was not their ancestral property. Further out of the property
as mentioned in the schedule-A of the plaint some portions
were sold by his brother Pannalal Ghosh (since dead) for
himself and on behalf of his sisters by dint of a Power of
Attorney and those properties has been described in
schedule-B of the plaint. Apart from that there was another
property consisting of land having one petrol pump and
kerosene go-down. It was the admitted position that the
ancestral business of the parties were divided amongst
those three brothers and initially it was a part of their joint
business but upon division amongst the three brothers the
business at Kailashahar went in favour of the respondentplaintiff No.1 Nanigopal Ghosh whereas business of similar
nature was given to Pannalal Ghosh at other places i.e.
Kanchanpur and Kumarghat and business at Kamalpur was
given to their brother Jaharlal Ghosh and those property is
described in schedule „D‟ of the plaint. In RFA No.06 of 2008
the High Court of Tripura observed that defendant Jaharlal
Ghosh of the original suit filed written statement supporting
the case of his brother plaintiff Nani Gopal Ghosh, now the
plaintiff-respondent (since dead). The High Court of Tripura
further observed that the purchasers of C-schedule property
were
made
proforma-defendants
and
some
of
them
appeared claiming to be bona-fide purchasers of the suit
property for valuable consideration and their rights should
not be affected. The principal defendant of the original suit
Pannalal Ghosh (since dead) totally denied the execution of
deed of relinquishment and it was submitted that the said
deed was never executed and it was never acted upon.
Rather he took the plea that those four sisters who are the
parties of the deed of relinquishment have their equal rights
in the property left by their property Akhil Ch. Ghosh and as
such the plaintiff Nani Gopal Ghosh along with other
defendants are/were entitled to 1/9th share of the property.
22.
Learned court below as per direction of the High
Court took evidence and finally gave the judgment. It was
the case of the defendant Surajit Majumder that deed of
relinquishment was a forged one but the defendants did not
take any step for cancellation of the document. The plaintiff
to support of his case has produced that document (Exbt.5)
in original from his custody which was more than 30 years
old and Learned court below came to an observation that in
view of Section-90 of the Evidence Act there was no scope
to draw any adverse presumption of the document being
more than 30 years old. The respondent-plaintiff exhibited
said document i.e. deed of relinquishment through the
evidence
of
DW-2.
Furthermore,
Rana
Dasgupta
the
respondent-defendant No.5(4) went to the witness box to
depose as a witness. He proved the signature of his mother
Rama Dasgupta who happened to be the sister of said Nani
Gopal Ghosh and Pannalal Ghosh being one of the executant
of said relinquishment deed in question. So considering the
evidence on record Learned court below came to the
observation that the burden of proof that the said document
was never executed lies to the defendants and moreso, no
evidence
whatsoever
was
adduced
by
the
contesting
defendants to prove that said document was a forged one
and none of the sisters even during their lifetime or their
legal heirs came forward challenging the validity of the said
document and sought for its cancellation. Even no suit
under Specific Relief Act was filed challenging the validity of
the said question. So in our considered view Learned court
below rightly came to the conclusion that the relinquishment
deed (Exbt.5) was duly executed by the parties i.e. some of
the contesting defendants. Secondly, regarding application
of the said deed of relinquishment Learned court below
relied upon the evidence of PW-3 Rana Dasgupta who is one
of the heirs of the executants Rama Dasgupta came before
the
court
and
on
oath
stated
that
said
deed
of
relinquishment was acted upon. Similarly the legal heirs of
another sister i.e. the defendant Purnima Sinha by filing
written statement on 27.07.2016 submitted that the deed in
question
was
acted
upon.
PW-3
also
in
course
of
examination deposed before the court that after execution
of the deed of relinquishment his mother and other sisters
did not sell any property left by their deceased father Akhil
Ch. Ghosh and that part of evidence was also not
challenged by the contesting defendants during crossexamination. DW-2 in course of his examination did not
specifically deny that the said deed of relinquishment was
not acted upon.
23.
Learned court below after receipt of the record
from the High Court recorded the evidence of DW-2 and
PW-3 and through whom the said deed was executed and
through their evidence signature of one of the party was
proved in the case. As already stated that although the
sisters of respondent-plaintiff filed their written statement
denying the execution of deed of relinquishment but to
substantiate their contention they did not appear before the
court to support their version in their written statement. The
defendants took the plea that Nani Gopal Ghosh in most of
the litigation impleaded his sisters indicating that the deed
of relinquishment was not acted upon and after execution of
deed on so many occasions they gave Power of Attorney in
favour of their other brothers which proved that the deed in
question was acted upon and after the suit being remanded
back the Learned Trial Court recorded the evidence of DW-2
and also recorded the statement of evidence of one Atanu
Roy to exhibit some registered sale-deeds alleged to be
executed by Nani Gopal Ghosh in favour of different persons
which were objected by the respondent-plaintiff.
DW-2 although relied upon a series of documents but
those documents were marked with objection from the
other side and those documents were gift deed, sale deeds
and Power of Attorney. But neither the scribe, any attesting
witness, or any of the executants have been brought into
the witness box to prove those documents. Just by mere
marking of documents as an exhibits it is not sufficient to
prove the contents of any documents when there is
objection from the other side. The contesting defendants in
the original suit though proved Exbt. Q, R, S, T, U, V, W and
X i.e. the sale-deeds executed by the respondent-plaintiff in
favour of different persons. But the contesting defendants
before the Learned Trial court could not prove that those
deeds were executed on the basis of Power of Attorney
given by the sisters subsequent to the execution of deed of
relinquishment and it is also not proved that which plots
were sold by execution of those deeds and said Power of
Attorney was also not proved for exhibit by the defendants
before the Learned Trial Court.
24.
In pursuance of the direction of the High Court,
Learned Trial Court issued summons upon all the sisters but
none of the sisters appeared. Although some of them after
receipt of summons engaged counsels on their behalf but in
course of recording of the evidence none of them appeared
to substantiate their defence. It is the settled position law
that if a party to the suit does not appear to the witness box
to substantiate his case on oath and does not offer himself
or herself to be examined by the other side in that case an
adverse presumption can be drawn up against them. Rather
before the Learned trial court the respondent-plaintiff
proved deed of relinquishment and legal heir of one of the
contesting
defendant
Purnima
Sinha
in
her
written
statement specifically admitted that the relinquishment
deed was acted upon. The contesting defendants to counter
the same failed to prove or produce any Power of Attorney
as alleged by them. Although they relied upon some
registered
sale-deeds
but
those
were
marked
under
objection and this does not lead to mean that the deed of
relinquishment was not acted upon.
25.
Thus after considering all aspects it appears that
Learned Court below rightly came to the conclusion that the
relinquishment deed in question was acted upon and the
four sisters had no share in the property left by their
deceased father. As observed by Learned Trial Court the
relinquishment deed was executed on 09.02.1965 and the
dissolution of partnership was executed on 14.10.1974 and
by registered deed of gift the respondent-plaintiff No.1
transferred the share of defendant No.3, 6 and 8 in his own
name which was executed on 22.07.1976 and as the
relinquishment deed was decided to be valid and acted
upon.
So
the
sisters
concerned
were
bound
by
the
subsequent deed of dissolution of the partnership. Except
the aforesaid four sisters the rest two other sisters never
appeared before the court nor challenged the deed of
dissolution of partnership or the amicable partition of the
business properties amongst the brother.
The defendant in his written statement admitted the
claim of respondent-plaintiff No.1 over „D‟ schedule land and
at the same time the heirs of defendant No.8 Purnima Sinha
by written statement dated 27.07.2016 admitted the said
fact.
The
witness
Surajit
Majumder
DW-2
and
Rana
Dasgupta PW-3 in course of their examination before the
court did not say anything showing their claim in respect of
„D‟ schedule land. The deed of dissolution of partnership in
original was produced and exhibited before the Learned Trial
Court along with the registered deed of gift and the
signature of one of the defendant Rama Rani Dasgupta
(since dead) was duly proved by PW-3, one of the
executants and attesting witness. Exbt-D and Exbt.-E are
two power of attorneys executed by the sisters and in those
power of attorneys the sisters did not raise any claim over
the petrol pump and kerosene go-down at Kailashahar
which is within „D‟ schedule land and in fact they never did
any claim in respect of „D‟ schedule land. The contesting
defendant Surajit Majumder although relied upon Exbt.B
and Exbt.C i.e. the original gift deed on the basis of which
Pannalal Ghosh (since dead) on the strength of Power of
Attorney executed by the defendants No.3, 6, 8 and 4
transferred their share in favour of their mother and their
mother subsequently transferred her total share in his
favour i.e. (Pannalal Ghosh) through Exbt.C over „D‟
schedule land. But none of the sisters before the Learned
Trial court led their claim against the partition of business
amongst the three brothers. Thus Learned Trial Court rightly
came to the finding that the „D‟ schedule land is the
personal property of the respondent-plaintiff and not a joint
business.
26.
Finally Learned Trial Court below came to the
finding that in respect of land as mentioned in schedule-A,
sisters Rama Rani Dasgupta, Rekha Biswas, Gita Rani
Majumder and Purnima Sinha by execution of deed of
relinquishment left their properties and since it was decided
that the deed of relinquishment was found to be valid. So
the remaining sisters Saraswati Biswas and Lila Rani
Choudhury have/had share in the land as mentioned in the
schedule-A. In the meantime Pannalal Ghosh, principaldefendant died leaving no class-1 heir. So his property will
get devolved amongst the respondent-plaintiff and the
sisters surviving. DW-2 Surajit Majumder in his crossexamination specifically stated that he is not the legal heirs
of Pannalal Ghosh but he produced those some documents
after his death and in the process of proving those
documents he did not brought any executants or any scribe
into the witness box, neither prove any of the signature of
the witness. Even the Sub-Registrar was not produced.
Moreso, finally published khatian was found in the name of
the
respondent-plaintiff
No.1
in
respect
of
land
as
mentioned in schedule-D who appears to have been
possessing the same since 1973. From the oral evidence it
appears that the respondent-plaintiff was all along in
possession of the land in question as mentioned in schedule
„D‟ and DW-2 specifically stated that the respondent-plaintiff
was possessing the suit land since long back and running
business therein and DW-2 could not say the position prior
to that. Thus the plaintiff-respondent could prove his
possession over „D‟ schedule land since long back and till
today none of the contesting defendants could challenge his
possession, even the gift deed dated 22.07.1976. As the
Learned court below held that the relinquishment deed is
held to be valid and the said four sisters will have no share
therein. So the plaintiff-respondent defendant Pannalal
Ghosh and Jaharlal Ghosh succeeded by defendant No.2,
Saraswati Biswas and Lila Rani Choudhury will have 1/5 th
share in each of the A-schedule land.
27.
So finally Learned Trial court after hearing both
the sides came to the conclusion that the entire property
should be divided giving 1/5th share to the respondentplaintiff Nani Gopal Ghosh (now his heirs) and C-schedule
property as per direction of the High Court should be
deducted from the share of Pannalal Ghosh as he sold the
same from his share and the sisters on behalf of whom he
sold the property and after giving his 1/5th share to the
respondent-plaintiff (now his heirs) and deducting the
property sold. The remaining land is to be distributed
amongst the defendant No.1, 2(b), 3 and 4 and the share of
defendant No.1 (Pannalal Ghosh) should get devolved
amongst respondent-plaintiff (now legal heirs), defendants
No.3 and 4 (sister Purnima Sinha died after the record was
remanded back and her name was deleted as per order
dated 27.06.2016 and sister Rekha Biswas relinquished her
rights over the property of her father).
28.
So after hearing the parties and going through
the arguments and counter arguments filed, it appears to us
that Learned court below rightly delivered the judgment and
decree dated 06.04.2017 in the suit and accordingly drawn
up preliminary decree and we do not find any cogent
grounds to interfere with the same.
29.
In the result, the appeal filed by the present
appellants is hereby dismissed on contest with costs being
devoid of merit. The judgment and decree passed by the
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Kailashahar, Unakoti
District on 06.04.2017 is hereby upheld and accordingly it is
affirmed. Pending application, if any, also stands disposed
of.
Draw the decree accordingly and send down the
LCRs along with a copy of this judgment.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2024.02.09
A DATTA Date:
03:23:24 -08'00'
Moumita
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review