Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MFA(EC) No.02 of 2023
Sri Suhagan Sen, Son of Late Angshu Bimal Sen, Of Bhattapukur near Modern
Club, PO. A.D. Nagar, PS. West Agartala, District – West Tripura, PIN 799003
.........Appellant(s);
Versus
1. The Director of Census Operations, Tripura, Government of India, Ministry
of Home Affairs, Agartala, West Tripura, PIN 799001
2. The Union of India, Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs,
North Block, Central Secretariat, New Delhi, PIN 110001
.........Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate,
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, CGC.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing & Judgment: 16.02.2024
Whether Fit for Reporting: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Kawsik Nath, learned counsel for the appellant and Mr.
Biswanath Majumder, learned Central Government Counsel
for the
respondents.
2.
The claimant/appellant herein is aggrieved by the award dated
11.09.2019 passed by learned Commissioner, Employees’ Compensation, West
Tripura, Agartala in T.S. (E/C) 16 of 2012 whereby the learned Court has held
that the petitioner could not prove satisfactorily that he was an employee under
the opposite parties at the time of incident and as such, he is not entitled to get
any compensation from the opposite parties.
3.
The incident occurred on 26.01.2011 as per the petitioner’s case
when he suffered electrocution and sustained injuries while fixing campaign
materials i.e. banners at motor stand area, Agartala while under employment of
the opposite parties. He developed gangrene in the feet and both his legs were
amputated upto knee joint. He has been completely disabled and non-earning.
He was aged 37 years and would be getting Rs.5,000/- per month as wages. His
wife had also filed a written complaint before East Agartala Police Station.
After serving statutory notice on 12.04.2012 to the O.P. No.1 without any
response, he filed the claim for compensation of Rs.5,76,420/- against the
opposite parties.
4.
O.P. No.1 in his written objection has categorically denied that
petitioner was an employee. He was never in the cadre of any post or grade in
their department. He also denied fixing of any banner by the petitioner under
employment of O.P. No.1 and his electrocution. He further denied treatment of
the petitioner as well as the amputation of his legs and also the monthly wages
claimed by him. The following three issues were framed for consideration by
the learned Commissioner:
“4.
In the light of the pleadings, following issues are framed:
1. Was the petitioner Suhagan Sen employee of O.P. No.1?
2. Whether the claimant was electrocuted on 26.01.2011 in an accident
arising out of and in course of his employment under O.P. No.1?
3. Is the claimant entitled to be compensated under the provision of the
Employees’ Compensation Act? If so, to what extent and who shall be liable to
pay the same?”
The claimant adduced 3(three) witnesses including himself and also exhibited
certain documents such as original copy of G.D. entry (Exbt.1), certified copy
of particulars of patient (Exbt.2), certified copy of bed head ticket dated
26.01.2011 (Exbt.3), certified copy of investigation report dated 27.01.2011
(Exbt.4), certified copy of clinical haematology (Exbt.5), certified copy of
progress report (Exbt.6), certified copy of refusal of treatment (Exbt.7), original
discharge summary (Exbt.8), copy of legal notice (Exbt.9), photocopy of
identity card (Exbt.10), photocopy of handicapped certificate (Exbt.11), CT
scan report (Exbt.12), 41 nos. of prescriptions [Exbt.13(i) to 13(XLi)] and 44
nos. of cash memos and bills [Exbt.14(i) to 14(XLiv)].
5.
One Prasenjit Nath Chowdhury was examined by the opposite
parties, but no document was exhibited. Subsequently, petitioner proved one
certificate of O.C., East Agartala PS as Exbt.15. Based on the above set of
evidence, the learned Commissioner passed an award on 07.08.2018 granting
compensation of Rs.5,43,500/- fixing liability on the opposite parties for
payment.
6.
The matter was challenged before this Court in MFA (EC)
No.01/2019 which was disposed of by this Court vide order dated 07.03.2019
setting aside the findings recorded by the learned Commissioner to the limited
extent indicated therein. The relevant part of the observations and directions
contained in the order dated 07.03.2019 are extracted hereunder:
“8. Before this Court, it is reiterated by the appellants that respondent
was never ever in their employment or engaged to carry out the work in question.
While all this is a matter of trial and as the learned counsel for the parties jointly
pray, on a limited issue, the matter is remanded back to the Tribunal for framing
a fresh issue, limited to the extent of employer and employee relationship, further
enabling the parties to lead evidence with regard thereto.
9. As such, on this limited point, findings returned by the Tribunal are
quashed and set aside and the matter being remanded back for consideration
afresh, in the following mutually agreed terms:-
(a) The party shall appear before the Tribunal on 02.04.2019, on which
date, the authority below shall fix a date for framing a fresh issue, also dates for
leading evidence.
(b) Parties undertake to fully cooperate and not take any unnecessary
adjournment;
(c) Save and except for official witness, parties undertake to produce
their evidence at their own responsibility;
(d) For official witnesses, Dasti summon shall be issued;
(e) Not more than three opportunities shall be afforded to each one of the
parties to lead their respective evidence.
(f) It stands clarified that the appellant herein does not lay challenge to
the occurrence of the incident, injury sustained by the claimant as a result
thereof; disability sustained by the claimant and the quantum awarded in favour
of the claimant.
10. The aforesaid limited extent, findings returned in the impugned
award dated 07.08.2018 passed by the learned Commissioner, Employee’s
Compensation, West Tripura, Agartala in Case No.T.S. (E/C) 16 of 2012 is
quashed and set aside;”
A perusal of the order dated 07.03.2019 indicates that the matter was remanded
to the Tribunal on a limited issue of examining the extent of employer and
employee relationship. Upon remand of the case, issue No.1 was framed and
parties were given scope to adduce evidence. Petitioner examined one witness
namely S.I. Mangesh Patari (PW4) who produced the GD book of East Agartala
PS containing GD entry No.1268 dated 23.01.2015 and 518 dated 08.06.2011.
GD entry No.518 dated 08.06.2011 was marked as Exbt.16 and GD entry
No.1268 dated 23.01.2015 was marked as Exbt.17. Opposite parties adduced no
evidence. The learned Tribunal proceeded to decide the only limited issue of
employer-employee relationship. The relevant part of the findings of the learned
Court at para 9 is extracted hereunder:
REASONS FOR DECISION AND DECISION
“9.
As per direction of the Hon’ble High Court as mentioned above, now,
mainly the case is required to be decided on a limited point about the employeremployee relationship between the opposite parties and the petitioner. The PW4
Mangesh Patari deposed that under instruction of O/C. of East Agartala P.S. he
appeared before the court with necessary GD book. He proved the related GD
entry no.518 dated 8.6.2011 wherein it is mentioned that at about 10.30 hours on
8.6.2011 Gouri Sen appeared in the police station and submitted one petition that
on 26.1.2011 in the noon at about 1300 hours while her husband Suhagan Sen
was engaged in fixing of banners of government organization at Motor Stand, at
that time he was affected by electric shock from a transformer and fell down on
the ground and he was undergoing treatment at GBP Hospital. The GD entry is
not much readable but so far could be gathered, it was supposed to be written that
either his legs were amputated or were affected. From the GD entry No.1268
dated 23.1.2015 (Exbt.17) it appears that same was not at all in relation to the
incident of the petitioner rather following was written:“This time C/1367 Shibabrata Choudhury left P.S. for bike mobile duty
at P.S. area.”
He also on asking by the court replied that there was no indication in the
GD book that any enquiry was done by police about said incident. In his cross
examination he admitted that there is no record before him to show that Suhagan
Sen was an employee of Department of Census and Operation, Govt. of India.
Thus, it appears that the then O.C. of East Agartala P.S. in his report dated
25.8.2015 (Exbt.15) has without any basis certified that matter was verified
locally and said facts of incident was revealed in such verification. As it appears,
he also without any basis mentioned GD entry No.1268 dated 23.1.2015 in his
said certificate. PW4 could not identify who was the officer in charge of that
police station on 25.8.2015. In Exbt.1 i.e. the petition filed by Gouri Sen in the
said police station, it reveals that there was a signature of one person with date
11.6.2011 regarding acknowledgment of said petition. But GD entry No.518
dated 8.6.2011 shows that on 8.6.2011 one petition was filed by Gouri Sen in the
police station and not on 11.06.2011. According to PW4 there was no indication
in the GD book regarding any petition received in said police station from Gouri
Sen. Thus, it is also doubtful that any such petition (Exbt.1) was at all received
by said police station on 11.6.2011. Certificate of O/C., East Agartala P.S.
(Exbt.15) appears to be without sufficient basis and is not reliable. PW3 Rajesh
Sen in his examination in chief on affidavit stated that he found one Sri Pradip
Das, an employee under government organization for fixing census and pulse
folio leaflet at the place of incident but said Pradip Das was also not examined.
No other document is also proved by the petitioner to show that he was an
employee under opposite parties. Situated thus, the petitioner could not prove
that he was an employee under opposite parties. Therefore, it is held that he is not
entitled to get any compensation from the opposite parties.”
7.
The learned Tribunal found that the GD entry on which the
petitioner has relied related to the inquiry by the police about the said incident.
S.I. Mangesh Patari [PW4] who was examined by the petitioner in his crossexamination admitted that there is no record before him to show that petitioner
was an employee of the Department of Census and Operations, Government of
India. The learned Court found that the Officer-In-Charge in his report dated
25.08.2015 [Exbt.15] had without any basis certified that the matter was
verified locally and said facts of incident were revealed in such verification. He
also, without any basis, mentioned GD entry No.1268 dated 23.01.2015 in the
said certificate. PW4 could not identify who was the Officer-In-Charge of the
PS on 25.08.2015. The above GD entries created doubt in the minds of the
learned Court that any such petition [Exbt.1] was received at all by the police
station on 11.06.2011. The certificate [Exbt.15] of the Officer-In-Charge, East
Agartala PS was also without any sufficient basis and not reliable. PW3 in his
examination-in-chief had stated that he found one Pradip Das, an employee
under government organization for fixing census and pulse polio leaflet at the
place of incident, but the said Pradip Das was also not examined. No other
document was proved by the petitioner to show that he was an employee under
opposite parties. Therefore, he could not prove that he was an employee under
the opposite parties to be entitled to any compensation.
8.
Assailing the aforesaid findings in the present appeal, the appellant
has inter alia contended that Exbt.17 i.e. GD entry No.1268 dated 23.08.2015
should be called for to enable the appellant to adduce documentary evidence for
deciding the appeal. The correct GD entry number would be 1268 dated
23.08.2015 of East Agartala PS whereas it has been erroneously mentioned as
GD entry No.1268 of 23.01.2015. That entry had no relevance with the accident
suffered by the appellant. As such, the learned Tribunal took into consideration
irrelevant material to record a finding that the petitioner had not been able to
show any relationship of employer and employee with the opposite parties. As
such, the impugned order may be set aside.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant has suffered amputation of both
legs in course of discharge of his duties while working under the respondents
and as such, he is entitled to compensation under the Employees Compensation
Act, 1923.
10.
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, learned Central Government Counsel
for the respondents, has opposed the prayer and submits that this is the second
round of litigation. The only issue which was required to establish by the
petitioner i.e. the claimant was the employer-employee relationship with the
O.P. No.1 to impose any liability for compensation in his favour on grounds of
suffering amputation of both legs by electrocution. However, the appellant
himself adduced PW4, an S.I. who produced the GD book of East Agartala
Police Station containing entry No.1268 dated 23.01.2015 [Exbt.17] and entry
No.518 dated 08.06.2011 [Exbt.16]. These documents adduced by the appellant
have been examined in depth by the learned Court which not only found that
these entries were not only non-readable but nothing much could be inferred
about the incidents from the GD entry dated 23.01.2015. The petitioner himself
adduced PW4 who produced these GD entries and nothing prevented him from
adducing any other material during course of trial upon remand to establish the
employer-employee relationship. As such, appellant/petitioner does not have
any case.
11.
Learned counsel for the appellant has also sought to press IA
No.03/2023 which is a petition for adducing additional evidence in support of
his case at the appellate stage that none of the pay bills/salary register of March,
2010 maintained in the Directorate shows that the appellant was in the list of
officers and staff of this Directorate. However, this Court at this appellate stage
is not inclined to allow such prayer for adducing additional evidence.
12.
The appeal is being heard and decided on the basis of the materials
produced before the learned Tribunal alone which in the opinion of the Court
are sufficient to decide upon the challenge.
13.
The impugned award has been rendered after remand by the High
Court in MFA (EC) No.01/2019 vide order dated 07.03.2019 on the limited
issue of the extent of employer-employee relationship between the petitioner
and the respondent. Though opportunity was granted to the petitioner to adduce
evidence, the very evidence of PW4, an S.I. of East Agartala Police Station
adduced by him along with the GD entries No.1268 dated 23.01.2015 [Exbt.17]
and GD entry No.518 dated 08.06.2011 [Exbt.16] both have been duly
considered by the learned Tribunal which failed to establish any semblance of
employer-employee relationship between the parties. No other material
evidence have been placed on record which could demonstrate that the
petitioner was on the rolls of the respondent No.1 when the incident took place.
Even in the grounds of appeal, appellant has only taken a plea that instead of
the GD entry No.1268 dated 23.01.2015, the relevant GD entry No.1268 dated
23.08.2015 ought to be called for to establish the relationship of the petitioner
as an employee of the respondent No.1. However, a GD entry could not be in
the first place an evidence of employer-employee relationship. Petitioner has
not been able to bring on record any record of attendance register or payment of
salary through the office of respondent No.1 or any appointment letter to
substantiate that at the relevant point of time, he was on the rolls of the
respondent.
14.
As such, upon proper scrutiny of the materials adduced before the
learned Tribunal available on the trial Court records, this Court is of the
considered view that no grounds for interference in the impugned award is
made out. There is no perversity in the findings of the learned Tribunal.
Accordingly the present appeal is dismissed.
15.
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that appellant may be
allowed to pursue any other legal remedy as is permissible in law.
16.
It is open for the appellant to do so, if permissible in law.
17.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
Stay order, if any, stands vacated.
Send down the Trial Court Records forthwith.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
SIDDHARTHA
LODH
Pijush/
Date: 2024.02.21 18:00:25 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review