Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.No.75 of 2025
Sri Subrata Mallik
S/O Hira Lal Mallik
Of Mallik Para, Sarma
P.O.- Sarma, P.S. Gandacherra,
Dist.- Dhalai Tripura.
(Petitioner on behalf of the in-custody
accused persons)
---- Applicant (s)
On behalf of1.
Sri Dipak Chandra Saha(52),
S/O. Lt. Nakul Chandra Saha
Of Durgapur, Gandacherra
P.S.-Gandacherra,
District- Dhalai Tripura.
2.
Smt. Debika Saha (46),
S/O: Sri Dipak Chandra Saha
Of Durgapur, Gandacherra
P.S.- Gandacherra.
Dist.- Dhalai Tripura.
---- Accused Persons-in-custody(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
[---
_________________________________________________________
For Applicant (s)
:
Mr. Subrata Sarkar, Sr. Adv,
Ms. Ayesha S. Hirawat, Adv,
Ms. Megha Sarkar, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Sankar Lodh, Spl. P.P.,
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.,
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
_________________________________________________________
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
03/11/2025
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023
is filed for granting bail to the accused persons-in-custody namely,
Sri Dipak Chandra Saha and Smt. Debika Saha. Heard Learned
(2)
Senior Counsel, Mr. S. Sarkar assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr.
Ayesha S. Hirawat and Learned Counsel, Mr. Megha Sarkar
appearing on behalf of the accused persons-in-custody. Also heard
Learned Spl. P.P., Mr. S. Lodh assisted by Learned P.P., Mr. Raju
Datta appearing on behalf of the State-respondent.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr.
Sarkar first of all drawn the attention of the Court referring the
contents of the FIR and submitted that these present two accused
persons are not FIR named. However, in course of investigation
their names revealed and referring the different forwarding
reports of the I.O. annexed with the bail application, Learned
Senior Counsel submitted that on perusal of the said relevant
prosecution papers, it will clearly be transpired that the present
accused persons in custody are in no way involved with the
alleged murder of the deceased rather only to the extent they had
carried the trolly bag to Agartala to Gandacherra which contained
the alleged dead body of the deceased. Furthermore, Learned
Senior Counsel also submitted that though the present case has
been
registered
under
Sections
140(1)/103(1)/238(a)/
238(b)/61(2)/3(5) of BNS but from the relevant prosecution
papers the involvement of accused persons only attracts Section
238(a) and Section 238(b) of BNS which are bailable in nature as
such they cannot be held responsible for the alleged murder of the
deceased. Learned Senior Counsel, thereafter, submitted that
these accused persons-in-custody are lodging in fail for last 142
days and by this time, the I.O. has submitted chargesheet against
all the accused persons. So, at this stage, there remains no
(3)
ground to detain the accused persons-in-custody furthermore and
there is also no chance of tampering the evidence on record on
their part, since, they are the residents of Gandacherra. So, in
summing up, Learned Senior Counsel urged for releasing the
accused persons on bail in any condition to enable them to
conduct their defence properly in this case. In this regard, Learned
Senior Counsel relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Sanjay Chandra vs. Central Bureau of
Investigation reported in (2012) 1 SCC 40, wherein in para
Nos.10 and 21, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“10. Shri Jethmalani submitted that there is not even a
prima facie case against the accused and would make
references to the charge-sheet and the statement of
several witnesses. He would emphatically submit that
none of the ingredients of the offences charged with were
stated in the charge-sheet. He would further contend that
even if, there is a prima facie case, the rule is still bail, and
not jail, as per the dicta of this Court in several cases.
21. In bail applications, generally, it has been laid down
from the earliest times that the object of bail is to secure
the appearance of the accused person at his trial by
reasonable amount of bail. The object of bail is neither
punitive nor preventative. Deprivation of liberty must be
considered a punishment, unless it is required to ensure
that an accused person will stand his trial when called
upon. The courts owe more than verbal respect to the
principle that punishment begins after conviction, and that
every man is deemed to be innocent until duly tried and
duly found guilty.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted
that in view of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court and considering the facts and circumstances of the case and
also the nature of involvement of the accused persons with the
alleged crime they may be granted bail in any condition.
He further referred another citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in State of Kerala vs. Raneef reported
(4)
in (2011) 1 SCC 784, wherein in para No.15, Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
“15. In deciding bail applications an important factor
which should certainly be taken into consideration by the
court is the delay in concluding the trial. Often this takes
several years, and if the accused is denied bail but is
ultimately acquitted, who will restore so many years of his
life spent in custody? Is Article 21 of the Constitution,
which is the most basic of all the fundamental rights in our
Constitution, not violated in such a case? Of course this is
not the only factor, but it is certainly one of the important
factors in deciding whether to grant bail. In the present
case the respondent has already spent 66 days in custody
(as stated in Para 2 of his counter-affidavit), and we see
no reason why he should be denied bail. A doctor
incarcerated for a long period may end up like Dr. Manette
in Charles Dicken's novel A Tale of Two Cities, who forgot
his profession and even his name in the Bastille.”
Referring the said citation, Learned Senior Counsel
further submitted that in this case, 42 nos. of witnesses have
been cited as witness in the chargesheet by the I.O. and if the
entire process is to exhausted in that case, a considerable period
will be required for conclusion of trial and here in the case at
hand, considering the materials on record, so far collected by I.O.,
during the course of investigation, it appears that there is every
possibility that on conclusion of trial, the accused would be
acquitted. So, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that since the
accused
persons-in-custody
are
languishing
in
jail
for
a
considerable long period and no purpose would be served by
detaining them in jail, so, Learned Senior Counsel, at this stage
urged for released the accused persons on bail in any condition.
On the other hand, Learned Spl. P.P., Mr. Sankar Lodh
strongly opposed the bail application and submitted that this is a
planned murder of the deceased and from the materials on record,
so far collected by I.O., during investigation, their knowledge with
the alleged crime cannot be ruled out. Admittedly, these two
(5)
accused persons-in-custody directly did not participate in the
commission of murder of the deceased, but from the facts and
circumstances the case and the materials on record, their prima
facie involvement cannot be ruled out and furthermore, they are
the close relatives of the two prime witnesses of this case and if
they are released on bail, they will try to influence the witnesses
since they are their relatives and furthermore, if they are released
on bail the entire trial would be frustrated. So, for proper trial of
this case, their further detention is required. So, Learned Spl. P.P.
strongly opposed the bail application filed by the accused persons.
It was further submitted that there are sufficient
materials showing their implications with the alleged offence in the
case diary and in support of his contention, Learned Spl. P.P.
relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India In
State of Karnataka vs. Sri Darshan Etc. reported in (2025)
SCC OnLine SC 1702, wherein in para No.20.4.1, Hon’ble the
Apex Court observed as under:
“20.4.1. It is well settled that the mere filing of a chargesheet does not confer an indefeasible right to bail.
Likewise, the mere prospect of a prolonged trial cannot, by
itself, outweigh the gravity of the offence, the
incriminating material gathered during investigation, or
the likelihood of tampering with witnesses.
He further referred para Nos.22(a) and (b) of the said
citation. 22:
(a) Nature and Gravity of the offence
22.1. The seriousness and heinous nature of the
alleged
offence
is
a
significant
factor
for
consideration, while evaluating a plea for cancellation
of bail.
22.1.1. In Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh
(2002) 3 SCC 598, this Court held that “the nature of
the offence is one of the basic considerations for the
(6)
grant of bail - the more heinous the crime, the
greater the chance of refusal of bail, though the
exercise of judicial discretion in such matters cannot
be exhaustively defined.”
22.1.2. Similarly, in Panchanan Mishra v. Digambar
Mishra (2005) 3 SCC 143, the Court observed that
“the object underlying the cancellation of bail is to
protect the fair trial and secure justice being done to
the society by preventing the accused who is set at
liberty from tampering with the evidence in heinous
crimes.”
22.1.3. In the present case, the accused along with
the co-accused, is charged under Sections 120B, 302,
201 and 204 IPC, which relate to conspiracy, murder,
destruction of evidence, and causing disappearance
of evidence. The allegation is of a brutal and custodial
murder of a young man, who was allegedly
kidnapped, tortured, and beaten to death by the
accused for sending objectionable messages to A2.
The victim was a 26-year-old daily wage earner, and
the crime was allegedly committed to protect the
reputation of A1, the partner of A2, a celebrity.
22.1.4. This is not a case of sudden provocation or
emotional outburst. The evidence indicates a premeditated and orchestrated crime, where the accused
not only allegedly took the law into his own hands,
but also engaged in systematic destruction of
evidence, including: deleting CCTV footage, bribing
co-accused to falsely surrender, and using police and
local influence to derail the investigation.
22.1.5. As this Court warned in Jagan Kishore v. State
of A.P., 2003 Crl. LJ 1919, the grant of bail in cases
involving
custodial
torture
and
extra-judicial
execution of an alleged offender erodes public
confidence in the rule of law. Thus, the very gravity
of the offence justifies cancellation of bail, especially
when the liberty granted to A2 is likely to subvert the
integrity of the trial process.
(b) Likelihood of tampering with evidence and influencing
witnesses
22.2. The record reveals concrete acts of interference
with the investigation including:
• A2's role in orchestrating false surrenders by
co-accused (A10, A14);
• Payments made to cover up the crime (as per
co-accused statements);
• Connections with police officials who delayed
and diluted the FIR and postmortem procedures;
• Deletion
residence;
of
CCTV
evidence
from
A1's
•
Continued
influence
over
prosecution
witnesses, as seen from public appearances
after bail.
22.2.1. In Puran v. Rambilas (2001) 6 SCC 338, this
Court categorically held that “Cancellation of bail is
permissible where the order granting bail was
(7)
perverse, or if the accused tampers with evidence or
attempts to influence witnesses.”
22.2.2. In State v. Amarmani Tripathi 2005 (8) SCC
21, this Court stated that “the Court must examine
the likelihood of the accused tampering with
prosecution witnesses or attempting to subvert
justice. Bail should not be granted if the accused is
likely to interfere with the trial process.”
22.2.3. Further, it was held that “even the likelihood
of the accused influencing witnesses or tampering
with evidence is sufficient to deny bail.” In Deepak
Yadav v. State of UP (2022) 8 SCC 559, bail was
cancelled owing to apprehension of tampering with
witnesses.
22.2.4. In P v. State of M.P. (2022) 15 SCC 211, the
Court held that bail can be cancelled if the accused:
• attempts to tamper with evidence;
• influences witnesses;
• induces others to make false statements;
• or even if there is a genuine apprehension of
miscarriage of justice.
22.2.5. The appellant alleged that A2 is not merely
misusing liberty post-bail but is the mastermind of
efforts
to
derail
the
investigation.
In
such
circumstances, the preponderance of probabilities
test applies (as per Sanjay Gandhi v. Delhi
Administration case) and the prosecution need not
prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt at this stage.”
Referring
the
same,
he
submitted
that
filing
of
chargesheet and long list of witnesses cannot be a ground for
granting bail, rather the seriousness and heinous nature of the
alleged offence is to be taken into consideration before granting
bail and finally, Learned Spl. P.P. urged for rejection of the bail
application of the accused persons.
I have heard both the sides at length and gone through
the relevant prosecution papers. In this case, the prosecution was
set into motion on the basis of an FIR laid by one Jahangir Miah to
O/C NCC P.S., Agartala on 11.06.2025 at about 0018 hours
alleging inter alia that he is the uncle of one Sariful Hasan @ Sarif.
On 08.06.2025 one Dibakar Saha, son of Dipak Chandra Saha of
Gandacherra presently residing at Bankumari and his friend
(8)
Nabanita contacted over mobile phone of his nephew and asked
Sarif to visit to the location of Joydeep Das located in Indranagar,
Kabarkhala, opposite of Smart Point at about 9.00 PM. That time
Dibakar Saha, Nabanita and others were present to the residence
Joydeep Das. At 11.00 PM mother of Sharif contacted him over
phone but he did not respond and he was called until midnight and
he did not receive any calls. After which his phone was found to be
switched off. From the night itself, searching began with the local
residents and on searching at about 5.00 AM, the bike bearing
No.TR 01 AH 8066 was found at the end of the lane of Joydeep
Das’s house. Thereafter, they all together entered the house
premise of Joydeep Das and found Dibakar Saha was present
therein. After the incident, they all started searching for Sarif and
informed the Police of GBP Outpost verbally. But Sarif could not be
traced out. So, suspecting Dibakar and his associates called him
over phone and from the mother of Sharif, it was learnt that
Dibakar Saha did his MBBS from Bangladesh and about 1.5
months
back
Sarif
was
administered
with
some
poisonous
medicines for which he became unconscious and seriously felt ill.
So, according to the informant, with a premeditated plan said
Dibakar and others called him over phone and abducted him with
a view to kill him. This is the sum and substance of the FIR. It is
the settled position of law that FIR is not a substantive piece of
evidence and on the basis of FIR, the criminal prosecution
generally sets into motion.
Here in the case at hand on the basis of the said FIR
O/C NCC P.S. registered NCC, P.S. case No.32 of 2025 under
(9)
Sections
141(1)/3(5)
of
BNS.
Initially,
perhaps
thereafter,
Sections 103(1)/238(a)/238(b)/61(2)(a) of BNS was added. By
this time, the investigation of the case is completed and Learned
CJM, West Tripura, Agartala by order dated 06.09.2025 has taken
cognizance
of
offence
punishable
under
Sections
61(2)(a)/238(a)/238(b)/127/58/103/3(5) of BNS, 2023 against
the accused person, Dibakar Saha, Nabanita Das, Joydeep Das,
Animesh Yadav, Dipak Chandra Saha and Debika Saha. The case
is yet to be committed to the Court of Sessions.
I have heard detailed arguments of both the sides and
perused the materials so far collected by I.O. during investigation
of this case. It is the admitted position that due to the act of the
alleged accused persons, Sariful Hasan @ Sarif lost his life. I have
also gone through the statement of two witnesses namely,
Souramita Saha and her mother. It is on record that the present
accused
persons-in-custody
are
the
near
relatives
of
said
witnesses. From the statements of witnesses and also the
disclosure statements of the co-accused persons and the other
materials so far collected by I.O., it appears that admittedly, the
present two accused persons-in-custody were not directly involved
with the alleged murder of the of the deceased. But at the same
time, it cannot be said that they had no idea or knowledge about
the alleged commission of offence. Rather they were also part of
the alleged criminal conspiracy for which the deceased had lost his
life by the heinous act of the other accused persons-in-custody.
Situated thus, at this stage, it appears to this Court
that if they are released on bail in that case they may tamper or
(10)
influence the witnesses of the prosecution and there will be every
chance of vitiating the trial of the case. Hence, I did not find any
scope to consider the bail application filed by the accused personsin-custody. Accordingly, the bail application filed stands rejected.
The accused persons are to remain in J/C as before. Since in this
case investigation is completed and chargesheet is submitted by
I.O. and the other accused persons are also in custody, so,
Learned CJM shall make all endeavour for commitment of this
case to the Court of Sessions at an earliest.
With this observation, the bail application filed stands
rejected and thus disposed of. Send down the record to the
Learned Trial Court alongwith a copy of this order. Return back
the Case Diary to I.O. through Learned P.P. along with a copy of
this order.
JUDGE
AMRITA DEB
Purnita
DEB
Date: 2025.11.05 10:48:11
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review