The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. We have also read the statement/deposition of DW-2, the father of the appellant along with the deposition of DW-1 [the respondent]. In the examination-in-chief PW-1 has categorically stated that three years back, he left the rented house where the appellant and the respondent were living to lead their conjugal life and he has also stated that on several occasions he tried to take back the respondent but she refused. In the face of such statement, it is very difficult to believe that the respondent deserted the appellant and left the appellant permanently. PW-2 was brought to corroborate that part but he did not corroborated that part but he has stated vaguely: “Over this issue baithak was also held but all were in vain.” He has not attributed anything against the respondent that for obstinacy of the respondent, the differences could not be reconciled. For purpose of constituting desertion animus deserendi has to be proved that after the formation of animus, meaning total breaking down of marital tie two years has elapsed and despite the efforts from the other spouse, the spouse who is facing allegation of desertion, did not come back to the matrimonial home. There is no such evidence on record. As such, we confirm the finding of the Judge, Family Court that there is no proof of desertion. Finally, when we scrutinized the records we find that the fact of institution of complaint…
12. Be that as it may, this court held that when an accused is acquitted from the charge for absence of evidence beyond reasonable doubt, it cannot be held that the initiation of the prosecution was on the basis of a false complaint. It has been, time and again, observed various courts that an acquittal without any blemish and acquittal for not proving the case beyond reasonable cause are two distinct categories. In the first category, if someone is acquitted without any blemish and the trial court observes that the institution of the complaint was wholly malicious then, of course, the benefit would be garnered by the person who is affected by the prosecution. But in this case, we do not find such evidence. Moreover, on reading of the judgment of the trial court, as referred before, we find that there were some materials against the appellant but for lack of corroboration of each of the materials, the trial Judge has given the benefit of doubt to the appellant. As such, on that ground, we cannot hold that the cruelty has been proved. But most importantly, PW-1 in his examination-in-chief has stated clearly that he does not want divorce. In the face of such record, the judgment of the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur Gomati District cannot be faulted with. As corollary, we affirm that judgment. In the result, the appeal stands dismissed. Draw the decree accordingly. Thereafter, send dow…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAT.APP.14 of 2018
Sri Subrata Das,
son of Sri Swapan Chandra Das
of Village-Dwajanagar, P.S. R.K. Pur,
District – Gomati Tripura
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
Smt. Uma Majumder (Das),
wife of Sri Subrata Das
of Jail Road, Udaipur,
P.O. R.K. Pur, P.S. R.K. Pur,
District – Gomati Tripura
presently residing at
care of Amal Deb
of Dakbangla Road, Word No.9, Udaipur,
P.O. R.K. Pur, P.S. R.K. Pur,
District –Gomati Tripura
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
……….Respondent(s)
: Mr. A. Acharjee, Adv.
: Mr. B. Banerjee, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Judgment & Order(Oral)
10/03/2022
[S. Talapatra, J]
Heard Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant as well as Mr. B. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent.
2.
This is an appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act,
1984. It arises from the judgment dated 03.04.2017 delivered in T.S.(Div.)46
of 2015 by the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura.
3.
The resume of facts which is considered relevant is being
introduced at the outset. The appellant herein filed a petition under Section
13(1)(ia)&(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 seeking dissolution of the
marriage which subsists between the parties and was solemnized on
24.04.2008 as per Hindu Rites and Customs. The allegations as has been made
against the respondent are that the respondent had been avoiding preparation
of food for the family members. The respondent has never accepted the
appellant as her husband. But it has not been denied that in the wedlock, a
female child was born. At present, the said female child is living with the
respondent. Further, it has been stated that a false complaint was filed against
the appellant and his parents, which was registered as R.K. Pur Case
No.263/2012 under Section 498(A) of the IPC corresponding to Case
No.PRC(GR)406 of 2012. It has been elaborated that not only the appellant,
but the parents were implicated in that said case based on the false complaint.
The charge-sheet was filed against the accused persons and the appellant had
to suffer fourteen days in the jail custody as the bail was initially denied to him
on his surrender before the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gomati,
Tripura. But the parents were granted bail on the same day of their surrender
before the court. After trial, the appellant and his mother were acquitted by
the judgment dated 16.06.2014 as delivered in PRC(GR)406 of 2012 on
observing as follows :
“In the result, I find, the prosecution has failed to prove
its case beyond any reasonable doubt of the offence
punishable under Section 498A of IPC against accused
namely Sri Subrata Das and Smt. Marani Bala Paul @ Asha
Das and, therefore, the accused namely Sri Subrata Das
and Smt. Marani Bala Paul @ Asha Das are acquitted from
the liability of the offence punishable under Section 489A
of IPC. The accused persons are set at liberty forthwith.”
4.
Even, prior to coming to this conclusion, the trial court has
observed that due to non-corroboration in establishing certain facts, he did not
find the evidence beyond all reasonable doubt against the appellant. Now,
since, the appellant has been acquitted, according to him, sending him to the
jail custody for fourteen days and forcing him to gruel through the persecution
of judicial trial, adequately constituted cruelty. That apart, as the appellant and
the respondent have been living separately for more than two years after the
appellant left the respondent in a rented house that constitutes the desertion.
In para 12 of the petition, it has been also asserted that the marital tie in
between the appellant and the respondent has been irretrievably broken.
5.
The respondent by filing the written statement on 04.05.2016
squarely denied the allegations and stated that the complaint that she filed was
based on cruelty that she suffered in the matrimonial life and hence, there is
no question of filing a false compliant to the police. She had however also
stated in para 6 of the written statement as follows :
“But after amicable settlement in between both the
parties afore mention the case was disposed by the Ld.
Judicial Magistrate 1st class, Udaipur (court no.2) on 1606-2014 passed the Judgment and acquitted the
petitioner and his mother. Thereafter the respondent went
her matrimonial house and started conjugal life with the
petitioner as husband and wife.”
6.
The respondent has also stated that on her petition being
Misc/FC/UDP/67/2012 as filed in the Court of the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur,
Gomati Tripura for maintenance under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C., the Judge,
Family Court by the order dated 25.04.2013 directed the appellant to pay the
maintenance at Rs.1000/- per month to the respondent and another sum of
Rs.2000/- per month to the minor daughter. In para 11 of the written
statement it has been stated that since the petitioner was hell-bent to get rid
of marital relation and that is the reason why he has filed the petition for
dissolution of marriage but the allegations that has been made against her in
the said petitions are all false and concocted and hence, she has denied all
such allegations. In para 16, the respondent has given a short detail of the
gifts that her parents had given during her marriage. But she has denied of
taking a sum of Rs.4,00,000/- from the respondent. But she was very
categorical in para 17 that on 10.08.2009, the appellant herein started physical
torture upon her within the knowledge of the in-laws of the respondents.
Under such circumstances, she filed the complaint before the R.K. Pur Police
Station, which was later on registered as a specific criminal case as mentioned
before. Thereafter, the Judge, Family Court framed the following issues for
determining the petition seeking dissolution of marriage :
“1. Whether the respondent committed cruelty upon the
petitioner and permanently deserted the petitioner ?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled to get the decree for
dissolution of marriage ?”
7.
The appellant, as the petitioner, adduced two witnesses including
himself [PW-1]. The respondent had examined herself [DW-1] in regard to the
evidence of the appellant. After the evidence was recorded, the Judge, Family
Court appreciated those evidence and on analysis observed that from the
deposition of PW-1 and DW-1 it is clear that though the petitioner filed this
case for divorce, he does not want divorce from the respondent herein as can
be seen from the examination-in-chief of the petitioner [the appellant herein].
Moreover, the story of PW-1 regarding taking of money by the O.P. from the
petitioner is only self-serving evidence and that part of his evidence has not
been supported even by PW-2. PW-1 and PW-2 came up with two different
stories and did not support each other.
8.
Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the Judge, Family Court has utterly failed to appreciate the
incidence of institution of the criminal case against the appellant and his
mother. Mental cruelty as emanated from the said prosecution has been
omitted to the serious prejudice of the appellant. This omission shows that the
evidence was not properly appreciated. Filing of a false case is itself a cruelty.
The appellant had suffered fourteen days’ jail custody as consequence of that
false complaint and he had lost his social dignity. Mr. Acharjee, learned counsel
had quite emphatically submitted that the acquittal shows the complaint was
false and hence, this evidence is sufficient to constitute the cruelty within the
meaning of Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. That apart, Mr.
Acharjee, learned counsel has contended that since the parties are living
separately for two years, the desertion is evident in the face of the record, no
further proof is required. In addition, Mr. Acharjee, learned counsel has
submitted that the marriage has been broken irretrievably and as such, it
would be wiser to grant the decree of divorce by dissolving the marriage that
subsist between the parties.
9.
Mr. B. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
having drawn out attention to the deposition of PW-1 and DW-1 has submitted
that PW-1 [the appellant] in his deposition on his examination-in-chief has
categorically stated, as under :
“I do not want to get divorced from the respondent.”
Similarly, DW-1 [the respondent] has also stated that she is not
interested in dissolution of marriage as she has a minor child.
10.
For purpose of appreciation of the submissions made by the
learned counsel, we find it apposite to reproduce the entire statement made by
PW-1 [the appellant] in the trial :
“I am the husband petitioner of this case. My marriage
was solemnized with the respondent about 8 years back
but there was no social marriage. After marriage we
started living together as husband and wife in my house
and out of our cohabitation the respondent gave birth of a
she baby who is presently 7 years old. After marriage for
about 2 years I spend my married life happily with the
respondent but thereafter a dispute cropped up in
between me and the respondent over a issue of money. At
that time I had a garments shop at North Chataira and
during this period the respondent borrowed Rs.4,00,000/from me and when I asked the respondent to return me
back the same she started quarreling with me and left my
house and started living in a rented house and later on I
also started residing in the rented house and we stayed
there for about 1 ½ years but there also the respondent
continued her quarrel with me. When I used to come back
to home from work I used to not find the respondent at
home and over this issue a quarrel took place in between
me and the respondent and lastly 3 years back I left the
rented house and started residing in my house. On several
occasions I tried to take back the respondent but she
refused. Since then there is no relation in between me and
the respondent. The respondent is still residing in the
rented house. I do not want to get divorced from the
respondent.
It is not a fact that the respondent did not start quarrel
with me over the issue of money.
It is not a fact that the respondent did not borrow
Rs.4,00,000/- from me and when I asked the respondent
to return the money she did not start quarrelling with me
and did not leave the matrimonial home.
It is not a fact that I committed mental and physical
torture upon the respondent.
It is not a fact that I tortured the respondent for demand
of money of Rs.15,000/- and subsequently another
Rs.1,00,000/-.
It is not a fact that I am deposing falsely in this case.”
11.
We have also read the statement/deposition of DW-2, the father
of the appellant along with the deposition of DW-1 [the respondent]. In the
examination-in-chief PW-1 has categorically stated that three years back, he
left the rented house where the appellant and the respondent were living to
lead their conjugal life and he has also stated that on several occasions he
tried to take back the respondent but she refused. In the face of such
statement, it is very difficult to believe that the respondent deserted the
appellant and left the appellant permanently. PW-2 was brought to corroborate
that part but he did not corroborated that part but he has stated vaguely:
“Over this issue baithak was also held but all were in
vain.”
He has not attributed anything against the respondent that for obstinacy
of the respondent, the differences could not be reconciled. For purpose of
constituting desertion animus deserendi has to be proved that after the
formation of animus, meaning total breaking down of marital tie two years has
elapsed and despite the efforts from the other spouse, the spouse who is
facing allegation of desertion, did not come back to the matrimonial home.
There is no such evidence on record. As such, we confirm the finding of the
Judge, Family Court that there is no proof of desertion. Finally, when we
scrutinized the records we find that the fact of institution of complaint,
investigation and filing of the police report under Section 173(2) of the Cr.P.C.
has been well proved. It has also been denied by the respondent that the
husband suffered fourteen days jail custody for the said complaint for his
criminal conduct and finally, the husband and her mother-in-law was acquitted
from the charge, however, for failure of the prosecution, to prove the case
beyond reasonable doubt. The respondent has also stated in her deposition
that before the trial actually commenced, there was an amicable settlement
and the acquittal was outcome of that amicable settlement. But unfortunately,
we do not find any such statement in the deposition of DW-1 [the respondent].
12.
Be that as it may, this court held that when an accused is
acquitted from the charge for absence of evidence beyond reasonable doubt, it
cannot be held that the initiation of the prosecution was on the basis of a false
complaint. It has been, time and again, observed various courts that an
acquittal without any blemish and acquittal for not proving the case beyond
reasonable cause are two distinct categories. In the first category, if someone
is acquitted without any blemish and the trial court observes that the
institution of the complaint was wholly malicious then, of course, the benefit
would be garnered by the person who is affected by the prosecution. But in
this case, we do not find such evidence. Moreover, on reading of the judgment
of the trial court, as referred before, we find that there were some materials
against the appellant but for lack of corroboration of each of the materials, the
trial Judge has given the benefit of doubt to the appellant. As such, on that
ground, we cannot hold that the cruelty has been proved. But most
importantly, PW-1 in his examination-in-chief has stated clearly that he does
not want divorce. In the face of such record, the judgment of the Judge,
Family Court, Udaipur Gomati District cannot be faulted with. As corollary, we
affirm that judgment.
In the result, the appeal stands dismissed.
Draw the decree accordingly.
Thereafter, send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review