Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.11 of 2018
Sri Subrata Chowdhury,
Son of late Rasha Raj Chowdhury, resident of North
Joynagar, PS- West Agartala, P.O.- Agartala, District- West
Tripura, PIN-799001
…………… Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Amaresh Chandra Debnath,
Son of late Pran Chaitanya Debnath, resident of Joynagar,
Madhya Rasta, PS- West Agartala, P.O.- Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura, PIN-799001
…………… Respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Appellants(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. S. Deb(Gupta), Advocate,
Ms. S. Nandy, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
3rd February, 2022.
Date of Judgment & Order :
7th April, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
NO
:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(S. G. Chattopadhyay,J)
This is an appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 from the decree dated 11.05.2018 drawn in Title Suit No. 77 of 2015
pursuant to judgment dated 27.04.2018 passed by the Civil Judge (Sr.
Division), West Tripura, Agartala directing the appellant (defendant in the trial
court) to execute a sale deed in favour of the respondent (plaintiff in the trial
court) in respect of the suit land within a period of two months from the date
RFA No. 11 of 2018
Page - 2 of 13
of judgment towards specific performance of the agreement dated 02.03.2015
(Exbt.1) executed between the parties to the lis.
[2]
The seminal facts which are relevant for disposal of this appeal
are as under:
The appellant who was the defendant in the trial Court held title
over the land measuring 0.034 acres which has been described in the schedule
of the plaint. The parties entered into an unregistered written agreement on
02.03.2015 whereby the appellant(defendant) who was in need of cash agreed
to sell out the suit land to the respondent(plaintiff) for a consideration price of
Rs.66,00,000/-(rupees sixty six lakhs) out of which Rs.15,00,000/-(rupees
fifteen lakhs) was paid in advance by the respondent(plaintiff) in two cheques
dated
02.03.2015
drawn
on
SBI,
Agartala
Branch
appellant(defendant) had agreed to execute a sale deed in
and
the
favour of the
respondent(plaintiff) after receiving the balance of Rs.51,00,000/- (rupees fifty
one lakhs) within 31st July, 2015. The respondent(plaintiff) by filing the suit at
the trial Court alleged that despite his readiness and willingness to pay the
agreed amount of money, the appellant(defendant) did not execute a sale
deed in his favour in respect of the suit land within stipulated period of time.
The respondent(plaintiff) then sent notice dated 19.02.2015 followed by notice
dated 16.07.2015 urging the appellant(defendant) to execute the sale deed
after accepting the balance of Rs.51,00,000/-(rupees fifty one lakhs) in terms
of their contract. Having received no response from the appellant, respondent
being plaintiff filed the suit at the
trial court seeking direction to the
appellant(defendant) to execute a registered deed of sale in his favour in
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 3 of 13
respect of the suit land after accepting the remaining amount of the
consideration price i.e. Rs.51,00,000/-(rupees fifty one lakhs).
[3]
The appellant who was the defendant at the trial court contested
the suit by filing a written statement. He admitted that he entered into a
written agreement with the respondent to sell out the suit land and for this
purpose he also received Rs.15,00,000/- in advance on 02.03.2015. According
to the appellant(defendant) the price of the land was actually settled at
Rs.70,00,000/- (rupees seventy lakhs) and, therefore, after payment of
advance
of
the
sum
of
Rs.15,00,000/-
(rupees
fifteen
lakhs),
the
respondent(plaintiff) was supposed to pay to him a sum of Rs.55,00,000/- and
that too for the price of the land only. According to the appellant, it was agreed
between the parties that price of the building would be settled separately after
proper valuation of the building. Accordingly, the appellant was urging the
respondent for valuation of the building so as to enable him to execute the sale
deed in favour of the respondent after accepting the price of the building as
well as the remaining sum of Rs.55,00,000/- as the price of the land. But the
respondent(plaintiff) played a fraud by altering the figure of Rs.70,00,000/- for
Rs.66,00,000/- in the agreement dated 02.03.2015 by interpolation. The
appellant(defendant) therefore, pleaded at the trial Court that the balance
amount of the price of the land minus the advance would be Rs.55,00,000/and moreover, the agreement was rendered unenforceable due to the fraud
played by the respondent.
[4]
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial
Court framed six issues in all which are reproduced hereinunder:
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 4 of 13
“I S S U E S
(i)
Is the suit maintainable in its present form
and nature?
(ii)
Has the plaintiff any cause of action to
institute the instant suit?
(iii) Has the plaintiff entered into an agreement
for sale dated 02.03.2015 to purchase the suit
land?
(iv) Are the averments in respect of readiness
and willingness to perform a part of the contract in
their true construction are sufficient to enforce
Specific Performance?
(v)
for?
Is the plaintiff entitled to a decree, as prayed
(vi) What other relief/reliefs the plaintiff is
entitled to?”
[5]
It is relevant to note that in order to establish his claim, the
respondent (plaintiff) examined five witnesses including himself and introduced
five documents which were taken into evidence and marked as Exbt.-1 to
Exbt.5. The appellant (defendant) on the other hand examined two witnesses
including himself and relied on the statements of his bank accounts which were
taken into evidence by the trial court and marked as Exbt.A1 and Exbt.A2.
[6]
On due appreciation of the pleadings of the parties and the
evidence on record, Issue No.1 with regard to the maintainability of the suit,
Issue No.2 with regard to cause of action and Issue No.3 pertaining to the
execution of the agreement for sale dated 02.03.2015 were answered in the
affirmative and in favour of the respondent(plaintiff). Among the rest of the
issues,
Issue
No.4
pertaining
to
readiness
and
willingness
of
the
respondent(plaintiff) to perform his part of the contract was also decided in
favour of the respondent (plaintiff) and following the decision of Issue No.4,
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 5 of 13
the suit came to be decreed by judgment and order dated 27.04.2018 followed
by a decree drawn on 11.05.018 directing the appellant (defendant) to execute
a sale deed in favour of the plaintiff-respondent after accepting the balance
amount as per agreement(Exhibit-1). The concluding paragraph of the
judgment, impugned, reads as under:
“10. In the result, the suit stands decreed on
contest with cost of the suit.
The defendant is directed to perform his part
of the contract and take necessary step for
facilitating the execution of a sale deed in favour of
the plaintiff over the suit land, within the period of
two months from the date of this order, after
receiving the balance amount as agreed in the
agreement for sell(Exbt.1).
[7]
The Sheristadar
accordingly.
is
to
prepare
decree
Thus the
contest.***”
stands
disposed
of
on
learned
Sr.
Heard
Mr.
suit
Debalaya
Bhattacharjee,
Advocate
appearing for the appellant along with Mr. Samar Das, learned Advocate and
heard Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), learned advocate appearing for the respondent.
[8]
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant contends that respondent (plaintiff in the trial Court) obtained the
decree by fraud and therefore, he cannot be allowed to enjoy its fruit. Counsel
contends that the consideration price of the decreetal land was actually settled
at Rs.70,00,000/- and it was so written in the agreement (Exbt.1) but the
respondent(plaintiff) made it Rs.66,00,000/-(rupees sixty six lakhs) by
interpolation beyond the knowledge of the appellant(defendant). Though the
fact was brought to the notice of the trial court, the learned trial judge ignored
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 6 of 13
it and decreed the suit in favour of the respondent (plaintiff). Counsel contends
that the decision of the trial court is thus vitiated by fraud and the same should
be set aside by allowing this appeal. Counsel contends that fraud vitiates
everything and therefore, the respondent (plaintiff) who approached the trial
Court with unclean hands and obtained a relief by playing fraud on the court
should not be allowed to take the benefit of such decree. To nourish his
contention, counsel has relied on the decision of the Apex Court in S.P.
Chengalvaraya Naidu(dead) by Lrs. Vrs. Jagannath(dead) by Lrs. and
Others: reported in (1994)1 SCC 1 wherein the Apex Court held as under:
“5. The High Court, in our view, fell into patent
error. The short question before the High Court was
whether in the facts and circumstances of this case,
Jagannath obtained the preliminary decree by
playing fraud on the court. The High Court,
however, went haywire and made observations
which are wholly perverse. We do not agree with
the High Court that "there is no legal duty cast
upon the plaintiff to come to court with a true case
and prove it by true evidence". The principle of
"finality of litigation" cannot be pressed to the
extent of such an absurdity that it becomes an
engine of fraud in the hands of dishonest litigants.
The courts of law are meant for imparting justice
between the parties. One who comes to the court,
must come with clean-hands. We are constrained to
say that more often than not, process of the court is
being abused. Property-grabbers, tax- evaders,
bank-loan-dodgers and other unscrupulous persons
from all walks of life find the court - process a
convenient lever to retain the illegal-gains
indefinitely. We have no hesitation to say that a
person, who's case is based on falsehood, has no
right to approach the court. He can be summarily
thrown out at any stage of the litigation.
6. The facts of the present case leave no manner of
doubt that Jagannath obtained the preliminary
decree by playing fraud on the court. A fraud is an
act of deliberate deception with the design of
securing something by taking unfair advantage of
another. It is a deception in order to gain by
another's loss. It is a cheating intended to get an
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 7 of 13
advantage. Jagannath was working as a clerk with
Chunilal Sowcar. He purchased the property in the
court auction on behalf of Chunilal Sowcar. He had,
on his own volition, executed the registered release
deed (Exhibit B-1S) in favour of Chunilal Sowcar
regarding the property in dispute. He knew that the
appellants had paid the total decretal amount to his
master Chunilal Sowcar. Without disclosing all
these facts, he filed the suit for the partition of the
property on the ground that he had purchased the
property on his own behalf and not on behalf of
Chunilal Sowcar. Non-production and even nonmentioning of the release deed at the trial
tantamounts to playing fraud on the court. We do
not agree with the observations of the High Court
that the appellants-defendants could have easily
produced the certified registered copy of Exhibit B15 and non-suited the plaintiff. A litigant, who
approaches the court, is bound to produce all the
documents executed by him which are relevant to
the litigation. If he withholds a vital document in
order to gain advantage on the other side then he
would he guilty of playing fraud on the court as
well as on the opposite party.”
[9]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned Sr. Counsel has also relied on the
decision of the Apex Court in Hamza Haji Vrs. State of Kerala and
Another; reported in (2006) 7 SCC 416 wherein the Apex Court reiterated
the law laid down in the case of S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu (supra) and held
as under:
“20. It is not necessary to multiply authorities on
this question since the matter has come up for
consideration before this Court on earlier occasions.
In S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu (Dead) by LRs. Vs.
Jagannath (Dead) by LRs & Ors. [(1993) Supp. 3
SCR 422], this Court stated that:
"It is the settled proposition of law that a
judgment or decree obtained by playing fraud
on the court is a nullity and non est in the
eyes of law. Such a judgment/decree --- by
the first court or by the highest court --- has
to be treated as a nullity by every court,
whether superior or inferior. It can be
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 8 of 13
challenged in any court even in collateral
proceedings."
The Court went on to observe that the High Court in
that case was totally in error when it stated that
there was no legal duty cast upon the plaintiff to
come to Court with a true case and prove it by true
evidence. Their Lordships stated:
"The courts of law are meant for imparting
justice between the parties. One who comes
to the court, must come with clean hands. We
are constrained to say that more often than
not, process of the Court is being abused.
Property-grabbers, tax-evaders, Bank loandodgers, and other unscrupulous persons
from all walks of life find the court process a
convenient lever to retain the illegal gains
indefinitely. We have no hesitation to say that
a person, whose case is based on falsehood,
has no right to approach the Court. He can be
summarily thrown out at any stage of the
litigation."
[10]
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned Sr. Counsel had argued that in view of
the law laid down by the Apex Court in the judgments cited to (supra), the
decision rendered by the learned Court by the impugned judgment comes to be
erroneous as the decree was obtained by fraud and, therefore, the said
judgment should be set aside by allowing the appeal.
[11]
Ms. S. Deb(Gupta), learned counsel appearing for the respondent
(plaintiff) on the other hand contended that it was established by the
respondent (plaintiff) at the trial court that the agreement dated 02.03.2015
was duly executed between the parties and the plaintiff was always ready and
willing to perform his part of the agreement. Therefore, the trial Court having
exercised its judicious discretion under Section 20 of the Specific Relief Act,
1963 rightly decreed the suit. In support of her contention, Ms. Deb(Gupta),
learned counsel has relied on the decision of the Apex Court in the case of
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 9 of 13
Sughar Singh Vrs. Hari Singh(Dead) through Lrs. and Another;
reported in 2021 SCC OnLine SC 975 wherein the Apex Court in paragraph46 of the judgment has held as under:
“46. Now, so far as the finding recorded by the High
Court and the observations made by the High court
on Section 20 of the Act and the observation that
even if the agreement is found to be duly executed
and the plaintiff is found to be ready and willing to
perform his part of the Agreement, grant of decree
of specific performance is not automatic and it is a
discretionary relief is concerned, the same cannot
be accepted and/or approved. In such a case, many
a times it would be giving a premium to the
dishonest conduct on the part of the defendant /
executant of the agreement to sell. Even the
discretion under Section 20 of the Act is required to
be exercised judiciously, soundly and reasonably.
The plaintiff cannot be punished by refusing the
relief of specific performance despite the fact that
the execution of the agreement to sell in his favour
has been established and proved and that he is
found to be always ready and willing to perform his
part of the contract. Not to grant the decree of
specific performance despite the execution of the
agreement to sell is proved; part sale consideration
is proved and the plaintiff is always ready and
willing to perform his part of the contract would
encourage the dishonesty. In such a situation, the
balance should tilt in favour of the plaintiff rather
than in favour of the defendant – executant of the
agreement to sell, while exercising the discretion
judiciously.”
Counsel of the respondent (plaintiff) has also contended that the
judgment of the trial court is founded on evidence and based on sound
reasoning which cannot be faulted with. Learned Counsel, therefore, urges the
Court to affirm the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court by
dismissing the present appeal.
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 10 of 13
[12]
Considered
the
submissions
made
by
learned
counsel
representing the parties. Perused the entire record including the documents
adduced on behalf of the parties.
[13]
It is not in dispute that a deed of agreement (Exbt.1) was
executed between the parties on 02.03.2015 whereunder the appellant
(defendant) received an advance of Rs.15,00,000/- from the
respondent
(plaintiff) agreeing to sell the decreetal land to the respondent(plaintiff) by
executing a sale deed within 31st July, 2015 after accepting the balance
amount. It has been pleaded by the appellant that the actual consideration
price was settled at Rs.70,00,000/- and after payment of Rs.15,00,000/- in
advance, the respondent(plaintiff) was required to pay Rs.55,00,000/- which
was so written in the agreement but the figure and words of the consideration
price was made Rs.66,00,000/- and the figure and words of the balance
amount was made Rs.51,00,000/- by interpolation by the respondent(plaintiff).
The respondent (plaintiff), tried to establish this fact at the trial Court by
adducing evidence. The respondent (plaintiff) as P.W-1 admitted in his cross
examination that in the agreement, the amount of Rs.66,00,000/- and
Rs.51,00,000/- in words and figure were overwritten
with pen. He also
admitted that the original agreement was always retained by him. The
appellant (defendant) suggested to him that the consideration money was
Rs.70,00,000/- which was denied by the plaintiff (respondent). However, the
appellant (defendant) nowhere in the cross examination denied the fact that he
did not receive Rs.15,00,000/- in advance pursuant to the said agreement.
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 11 of 13
[14]
P.W-2, Santanu Sharma (Bhattacharjee) also supported the case
of the respondent (plaintiff) at the trial court. In his cross examination it was
suggested to him that the consideration price was
never fixed at
Rs.66,00,000/-. The suggestion was denied by him. He also denied the
suggestion of the counsel of the appellant (defendant) that he deposed falsely
in favour of the respondent (plaintiff). P.W-3, Dilip Kr. Chakraborty in his
examination in chief supported the entire case projected by the respondent
(plaintiff). In his cross examination it was simply suggested to him that his
statements made out in examination in chief were not true. He denied the
suggestion. P.W-4, Narayan Datta Gupta also lent support to the case of the
respondent (plaintiff) and in his cross examination he denied the suggestion of
the counsel of the appellant (defendant) that his statements were false. P.W-5,
Bijan Roy is an advocate who stated in his examination-in-chief that the
agreement dated 02.03.2015 was drafted by him under the instructions of the
appellant (defendant). He also stated in his examination in chief that at page 2
of the agreement some corrections were made in presence of the parties.
During his cross examination, the over writings in the agreement was shown to
him. The witnesses stated that those were made in presence of the parties.
[15]
The appellant (defendant) on the other hand examined himself as
DW-1. In his cross examination, he admitted the execution of the agreement
dated 2.3.2015 for sale of the suit land and he also admitted that he received
Rs.15,00,000/- from the respondent (plaintiff) in two cheques. According to
him, the consideration money was fixed at Rs.70,00,000/-. In his cross
examination, he further stated that he did not respond to the notice of the
RFA No.11 of 2018
Page - 12 of 13
respondent (plaintiff) for executing a registered sale deed in favour of the
respondent (plaintiff) because no assessment of building was done. DW-2
came to prove the statements of accounts of the respondent (plaintiff) which
are of no relevance.
[16]
The contention of the appellant that by the agreement dated
02.03.2015 only the price of the suit land was agreed upon and it was agreed
between the parties that valuation of the building would be determined
separately is not acceptable because the agreement (Exbt.1) does not contain
any such stipulation. The appellant (defendant in the trial court) did not also
lead any evidence before the trial court in this regard. Evidently, the agreement
(Exbt.1) is found to be duly executed between the parties and the respondent
(plaintiff) at the trial court was found to be always ready and willing to perform
his part of the agreement by paying the balance amount of consideration.
Admittedly, the appellant (defendant) received Rs.15,00,000/- from the
respondent(plaintiff) as advance
in terms of the agreement and he never
offered refund of money to the respondent(plaintiff).
[17]
In such circumstances, we do not find any infirmity in the findings
of the learned trial judge. We have gone through the judgments which have
been referred to by the counsel of the appellant. The facts of those cases are
completely distinguishable for which the appellant cannot derive any benefit
from those decisions. However, Ms. S. Deb(Gupta), learned counsel of the
respondent (plaintiff) has been fair to submit that since the price of the land
has also gone up with the passage of time, respondent(plaintiff) is ready to pay
Rs.70,00,000/- to the
RFA No.11 of 2018
appellant (defendant) as price of the land.
Page - 13 of 13
Rs.15,00,000/- (rupees fifteen lakhs)
having been paid in advance,
respondent(plaintiff) will pay the balance of Rs.55,00,000/- (rupees fifty five
lakhs) to the appellant(defendant).
[18]
In view of such submission made on behalf of the respondent
(plaintiff), the decree passed by the trial Court is modified as under:
The appellant (defendant) is directed to execute a registered sale
deed in favour of the respondent (plaintiff) in respect of the decreetal land
within a period of three months from today after receiving Rs.55,00,000/(rupees fifty five lakhs) from the respondent(plaintiff).
[19]
In terms of the above, the appeal stands disposed of. The decree
be drawn up accordingly and the LCR be sent down after drawing up the
decree. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Dipankar
RFA No.11 of 2018
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review