Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA NO. 27 OF 2019
1. Sri Subir Saha,
S/o Late Jatindra Ch. Saha, resident of Abhoynagar,
Behind BOC (Petrol Pump),
P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura.
2. Smti Bulan Saha,
W/o Late Jatindra Ch. Saha,
Resident of Abhoynagar, behind BOC (Petrol Pump),
P.S. East Agartala,
District-West Tripura
---- Appellants.
Versus
M/S. Ramthakur Trading Co., represented by its Proprietor
Sri Bapi Datta, S/o Sri Sankar Ch. Datta, resident of
Bhattapukur, near Modern Club, P.S. A.D. Nagar,
Agartala, District-West Tripura.
---Respondent.
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Das, Advocate.
Date of hearing &
delivery of Judgment and order : 11.03.2022
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
Judgment & Order (Oral)
(Arindam Lodh, J)
This first appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil
Procedure,1908 is directed against the judgment and decree dated
12.06.2019 and 17.06.2019 respectively, passed by learned Civil Judge, Sr.
Division, Court no.1, West Tripura, Agartala in Money Suit No.43/2016
decreeing the suit of the plaintiff-respondent.
2.
The plaintiff [respondent here-in] had filed a suit for realization
of money from the defendants [the appellants here-in], primarily, the
defendant no.1 for a sum of Rs.10,40,000/- (Rupees ten lakh forty thousand)
only along with an interest @ 6% per annum till satisfaction of the decree.
The facts as narrated by learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division may be
reproduced here-in-below:“The plaintiff is a proprietor firm dealing with
construction items like iron rod, cement, sand etc. and has his
shop at Nagerjala. The defendant No.1 is an Engineer and is a
Central Government Employee. The defendant No.2 is his mother.
Said defendant No.1 on several occasions purchased iron rod
from the shop of the complainant. He took rod worth Rs.
10,40,000/- (Rupees Ten lacs Forty thousand) only. He purchased
those rods in the last week of May 2015, but on credit. The
defendant No.1 assured the plaintiff to pay the amount by first
week of July 2015. Thereafter, on 19.06.2015 the said defendant
came to the shop of the plaintiff and issued a cheque bearing No.
802782 in favour of the plaintiff of the same amount drawn up
from Tripura Gramin Bank Vide SB A/C No.8004010005593. At
the same time the defendant No.1 made a request to the plaintiff to
deposit the cheque in the month of June 2015. Accordingly, the
plaintiff presented the cheque on 20.06.2015. But the said cheque
was returned without being honoured due to insufficient fund. On
being informed, the defendant No.1 requested to deposit the same
in the first week of October 2015. But again on being presented
on 05.10.2015, the cheque was again dishonoured due to the same
reason. On the third occasion, the defendant No.1 requested the
plaintiff to deposit the cheque on 1st week of December 2015.
Regrettably on this occasion also the cheque got bounced due to
insufficient fund. Defendant No.2 being the mother of defendant
No.1 on several occasions came to the shop of the plaintiff and
made a promissory note to pay the said amount, but none of the
defendants could pay the money due to the plaintiff.
The defendants contested the suit by filing written
statement stating that the suit is not maintainable on the ground
of cause of action and to be barred by Priciples of estoppels,
waiver etc. It is also the case that the defendant No.1 purchased
some materials from the plaintiff and for making payment of the
same issued a cheque drawn of Tripura Gramin Bank, Abhoy
Nagar, Branch in favour of the plaintiff. The defendant further
admitted that the said cheque on presentation got dishonoured
due to insufficient fund. In addition, the defendants further stated
that the defendant No.2 gave three non-judicial stamp papers
signed by them which were blank for satisfaction of the plaintiff.
The defendant most importantly, stated that defendant No.1 paid
the entire suit money in cash though did not mention the date and
place of such payment further stating that even after making the
payment the plaintiff did not return the original cheque and the
blank non-judicial stamp paper. The defendants narrated that the
plaintiff did not return back the cheque and the stamp paper on
the excuse that those cheque and stamp paper got damaged by
water. In short the defendants claimed that the money due has got
satisfied by them in cash and hence this suit is liable to be
dismissed.”
3.
At the commencement of trial, the following issues were
framed:
1. Is the suit maintainable in its present form and nature?
2. Is the plaintiff any cause of action to institute the instant suit?
3. Is the plaintiff entitled to get a sum of Rs.10,40,000/- from the
defendant as prayed for? If so, is the plaintiff entitled to get
any interest thereon and from the date as prayed for?
4. Are the plaintiffs entitled to get preliminary decree, as prayed
for?
5. What other relief/reliefs the parties are entitled to?”
4.
To prove the case, the plaintiff has examined one witness and
produced some documents. On the other hand, the defendants similarly
adduced one witness and relied on some documents.
5.
While deciding the issues, learned trial court has held that the
suit is maintainable and there is cause of action and the suit is within
limitation. After recording evidence, adduced by the parties to the lis, on the
basis of the issues framed, learned trial court held that the plaintiff has been
able to prove his case and accordingly, decreed the suit in terms of the
following order:“In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is found to be entitled to get
a sum of Rs.10,40,000/- from the defendant no.1 as prayed for with an
interest of 6% per-annum until satisfaction of the claim by the defendant
no.1.
Accordingly, the defendant no.1 is to pay a sum of Rs.10,40,000/with an interest of 6% per-annum until satisfaction of the claim to the
plaintiff.
The suit is thus decreed and disposed of on contest.”
6.
Heard Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants. Also heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. S. Das, learned counsel appearing for the respondent.
7.
We have perused the evidence and the judgment passed by
learned trial court. It is found that the learned trial court had disbelieved the
documents i.e. the money receipts which were exhibited. It is noticed that
those documents being introduced by the defendants as evidence were held
not to be proved in accordance with the provisions of the Evidence Act.
Learned trial Judge has held thus:“The documents being produced in original necessarily got
admitted. But mere admission of document in evidence does not
amount to its proof. In other words, mere marking of exhibit on a
document does not dispense with its proof, which is required to be done
in accordance with law. Under the Law of Evidence also, it is
necessary that contents of documents are required to be proved either
by primary or by secondary evidence. At the most, admission of
documents may amount to admission of contents but not its truth.
Contents of the document cannot be proved by merely filing in a court.
(Relianc. Life Insurance Corporation of India & Anr Vs Rampal Singh
Bisen (2010)4 SCC491).
The document though produced in original was objected
by the plaintiff during the time of recording of evidence.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of R.V.E.
Venkatachala Gounder v Arulmigu Viswesaraswami & V.P. Temple
and another, (2003) 8 SCC 752, observed :"The objections as to admissibility of documents in
evidence may be classified into two classes: (i) an objection that the
document which is sought to be proved is itself inadmissible in
evidence; and (ii) where the objection does not dispute the
admissibility of the document in evidence but is directed towards the
mode of proof alleging the same to be irregular or insufficient. In the
first case, merely because a document has been marked as "an exhibit",
an objection as to its admissibility is not excluded and is available to
be raised even at a later stage or even in appeal or revision. In the
latter case, the objection should be taken when the evidence is tendered
and once the document has been admitted in evidence and marked as
an exhibit, the objection that it should not have been admitted in
evidence or that the mode adopted for proving the document is
irregular cannot be allowed to be raised at any stage subsequent to the
marking of the document as an exhibit.
In the present case objection was raised by the plaintiff
regarding both the documents produced by the defendant during
presentation of the documents. The documents were marked exhibit
tentatively recording the objection of the plaintiff. It shows that the
plaintiff is denying execution of both the produced money receipt.
Under such circumstances the defendant requires to prove the
documents as per law as the onus lies on them.
As far as the legal requirement (discussed above) is
concerned the defendant did not adduce any evidence to confirm such
execution of money receipt by the plaintiff. None deposed
corroborating payment of the money by the defendant and resultant
issuance of such money receipt. It is further observed that the
defendant did not adduce his bank detail or any source of the money to
make such payment in cash to be probable.
Going deep in to the discussion, at this juncture let us see
what a money receipt is and necessary legal requirement for execution
of a money receipt.
Be it mentioned, at the very onset that, the document in
question is a simple money receipt which is not compulsorily
registrable as per the Registration Act.
But, in view of the amendment of Schedule I, to the Indian
Stamp Act 1899, stamp is required to be affixed on any receipt, the
amount or value of which exceeds Rs 5,000. This amendment has come
w.e.f. 10.09.04. The stamp is required to be affixed in respect of receipt
which has been defined as under in Section 2(23) of the aforesaid Act.
Section 2 sub-section 23 of the Stamp Act defines receipt
as:―receipt includes any note, memorandum or writing—(a)
whereby any money, or any bill of exchange, cheque or promissory
note is acknowledged to have been received, or
(b) whereby any other moveable property is acknowledged to have
been received in satisfaction of a debt, or
(c) whereby any debt or demand, or any part of debt or demand, is
acknowledged to have been satisfied or discharged, or
(d) which signifies or imports any such acknowledgment, and whether
the same is or is not signed with the name of any person.
The document produced by the defendant does not satisfy
the requirement of the Stamp Act not any evidence produced in proof of
its execution.
Coming to the factual aspect, it is observed that there are
two money receipts. No explanation has been given by the defendant as
to why the plaintiff issued two money receipts. One of the money
receipts was given on photocopy of the cheque in question. It is written
on the document 'Received in Cash' and nothing else. No amount is
mentioned. Moreover the defendant narrated in their W.S. that the
plaintiff told them, the original cheque to have been washed away. But,
the defendant did not disclose from what source the photocopy of the
cheque has been obtained.
Exhibit B at the very threshold deserves no consideration.
Whereas Exhibit A is a cash memo appears to be given
from the series of such memos kept for transactions in any business of
selling and buying. The plaintiff denied the said memo to be issued
from his book of memo. The memo has a number on it. The defendant
did not produce that book neither made any prayer at any stage
requiring production of that book of memos or the series of memos to
establish that it was issued by the plaintiff. Moreover in the crossexamination of the plaintiff it was asserted by him that while he sells
any item on credit no cash memo is issued. This statement made during
cross-examination further contradicts the stand of the defendant.
It is surprising that having made no legal paper the
defendant no.1 has paid such an hefty amount of Rs. 10,40,000/(Rupees Ten lacs Forty thousand) to the plaintiff and that too when the
plaintiff did not return back his cheque. It is also to be kept in mind
that the defendant is not illiterate and is an Engineer by profession.
Considering both the legal and factual aspect this Court
finds that the defendant has failed to prove execution of Ex-A by the
plaintiff. Hence the defendant has failed to prove that he has
discharged his liability by making payment of Rs. 10,40,000/-(Rupees
Ten lacs Forty thousand) to the plaintiff in cash.
Accordingly the plaintiff is found to be entitled to get a sum
of Rs.10,40,000/- from the defendant as prayed for with an interest of
6% per annum until satisfaction of the claim by the defendant no. 1.
The issue decided accordingly.”
8.
According to us, the reasoning to arrive at the findings on the
issue of payment of Rs.10,40,000/- by the defendant to the plaintiff had
been well dealt with by the learned trial Judge. We find no error of facts and
law in the aforesaid findings as arrived at by learned Civil Judge. The
learned trial Judge has correctly interpreted the law as regards admission of
document as contemplated under the relevant provisions of the Evidence
Act.
9.
It is surfaced that the defendant had introduced photocopy of
the cheque, which was produced in the form of secondary evidence as
contemplated under Section 63 of the Evidence Act. Before introducing
such document as secondary evidence, it is the mandatory obligation to the
party introducing such secondary evidence so as to satisfy the foundational
facts for which he is forced to introduce the secondary evidence in place of
primary evidence i.e., in the instant case, the defendant has to satisfy the
court about the foundational facts for which he could not produce original
copy of the cheque in terms of Section 65 of the Evidence Act. Furthermore,
it is transpired that plaintiff has raised objection for production of photocopy
of the cheque. The necessity to raise objection is to make alert to the
opposite party to remove the defects in bringing secondary evidence in
proof of a particular fact in issue. In the instant case, by raising the
objection, the plaintiff had alerted the defendant to prove the photocopy of
the cheque in accordance with the provisions of the Evidence Act. But, the
defendant failed to meet the requirements of Section 65 of the Evidence Act.
10.
The offshoot of the aforesaid discussions is that the learned
trial Judge neither has committed any error in interpreting the provisions of
the Evidence Act nor the evidence adduced on facts by the parties to the lis.
Accordingly, having found no infirmity with the judgment and decree
passed by learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, West Tripura, Agartala, as
stated here-in-above, the instant appeal deserves to be dismissed, and
accordingly, the appeal stands dismissed.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review