The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Situated thus, in my considered view the matter needs to be remanded back to the Learned Trial Court with a direction to the appellant-plaintiff to adduce evidence in respect of damages mentioned by him to enable the Learned Trial Court below to give a specific finding on this point.
16. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant- plaintiff is hereby allowed. The suit is remanded back to the Learned Trial Court with a direction to the appellant-plaintiff to adduce fresh oral/documentary evidence on record, if any, in support of his claim for damages claimed in the suit to enable the Court to give a specific finding on this point. The plaintiff-appellant is further directed to appear before the Learned Trial Court on 27.08.2024. The Learned Trial Court shall make endeavour to dispose of the suit within a period of three (03) months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment after affording the appellant an opportunity to adduce evidence.
17. Since, there was no other separate prayers challenging the judgment and part decree granted by the Learned Trial Court by judgment dated 02.02.2024 and decree dated 08.02.2024, so, the same is hereby upheld and accordingly, it is affirmed. With these observations, the appeal is disposed of. Prepare decree accordingly. Send down the LCRs along with copy of the judgment for immediate compliance. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. Purnita +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.13 of 2024
Sri Subhash Chakraborty,
S/O. Sri. Nimai Chakraborty,
Resident of South Badharghat,
Charipara, P.O. & P.S.- A.D. Nagar,
District- West Tripura.
….The Plaintiff Appellants(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Sandhya Deb,
W/O. Lt. Rakhal Chandra Deb,
2. Sri Amiya Deb,
S/O. Lt. Rakhal Chandra Deb,
Both residents of H.G.B. Road,
Agartala, P.S.- West Agartala,
Near Battala Market,
Dist.- West Tripura,
Pin-799001.
3. Smt. Soma Deb (Saha)
W/O. Sri. Tapan Saha
Resident of Town Pratapgarh,
Agartala, P.S.- East Agartala,
District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799004.
….The Defendant Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D. Deb, Adv,
For Respondent(s)
:
None.
Date of Hearing
:
12.08.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
16.08.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal challenging the judgment and
part decree dated 02.02.2024 and 08.02.2024 respectively
delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2,
West Tripura, Agartala in connection with case No.T.S.62 of
2022.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. D. Deb for the
appellant-plaintiff.
None
appeared
on
behalf
of
the
respondent-defendants inspite of receipt of notice.
03.
Before coming to the conclusion of this appeal, let
us discuss the subject matter of the dispute filed by the
appellant as plaintiff before the Learned Trial Court. The
appellant-plaintiff filed the suit before the Learned Trial Court
for declaration, perpetual injunction and also for recovery of
the amount of loss suffered by the plaintiff and for
mandatory injunction.
04.
The genesis of the case of the plaintiff-appellant
before the Learned Trial Court was that the plaintiff-appellant
is the owner of the hotel Anjana in 3rd floor and a part of the
4th floor of the multi-storied building situated at H.G.B Road
near Battala Bazar. The appellant-plaintiff constructed the
said multi-storied building including the 3rd floor and the 4th
floor in pursuance of a Developer Agreement entered with
the respondent-defendants. After completion of construction
of the said building on the
land of the respondent-
defendants, as per agreement, three rooms on the ground
floor were distributed to the developer, i.e. the plaintiff
herein by following the terms and conditions of the developer
agreement
dated
25.07.2013.
The
said
multi-storied
construction was constructed on the land of the defendants
situated at Mouja-Agartala, Sheet No.-6 under Revenue
Circle-Sadar, Tehsil-Agartala, West Tripura, under Touji
No.2468, Khatian No.495 under Old C.S. Plot No.4653/P,
4654/P, 4653, 4654 and 4655/P corresponding to Hal C.S.
Plot No.256, 257 and 328 for land measuring 0.048 acre. It
was the further case of the appellant-plaintiff that the
defendants in addition to the developer agreement had to
make some payment of Rs.63,00,000/- (sixty three lakhs
only) for the purpose of initial work demolition of the old
structures and building, cutting of the trenches, obtaining
Municipal Permission for construction, payment of taxes etc.
The construction work was done by obtaining loan, but
unfortunately, the defendants on the assurance of payment
of said amount to the plaintiff-developer failed to make such
payment even after completion of the construction of the
said multi-storied building. Only an old room in the ground
floor of the multi-storied building could not be reconstructed
which was under the occupation of a tenant namely, Sri
Ratan Debnath of Bardowali, Agartala on monthly basis for
which said room could not be demolished. It was further
asserted that as the respondent-defendants failed to make
payment of Rs.63,00,000/- to the appellant-plaintiff, so, it
was decided and settled that two rooms covering the rent in
the ground floor of the said building to be transferred/sold by
the respondent-defendants to the developer plaintiff. For
that a registered agreement for sale of two rooms in the
ground floor was executed between the plaintiff and the
defendants on 26.11.2018, which was registered before the
Sub-Registrar,
Sadar,
vide
no.I-6828.
Later
on,
on
08.02.2019 another agreement was made without any
registration
between
the
appellant-plaintiff
and
the
respondent-defendants being continuation of the earlier
agreement before the Notary Public.
It was further asserted by the appellant-plaintiff
that as said Ratan Debnath did not vacate the room after
being requested by the defendants. So, an eviction case was
filed under RCC Act against said Ratan Debnath by the
defendants before the Rent Control Court bearing case
No.RCC 07 of 2014, with the supervision and financial
assistance given by the appellant-plaintiff. It was the further
case of the appellant that as the defendants failed to comply
with the terms and condition of the Agreement for the Sale
of two rooms in the ground floor to the plaintiff, so, the
appellant-plaintiff filed a civil suit vide No.T.S.102 of 2021 in
the Court of Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Court No.1, West
Tripura, Agartala for specific performance of contract against
the defendants for getting the sale deed registered and for
taking possession of the said two rooms in the ground floor
of the said multi-storied building, as per Agreement of Sale.
The said Civil Suit filed is still pending for adjudication. It
was also the case of the appellant ithat the defendants after
institution of the said Civil Suit No.T.S.102 of 2021 have
become more vindictive to cause harm and harassment to
the plaintiff and started disturbing the plaintiff in different
manners like disturbances in running the hotel business in
the rooms of 3rd floor and a part of 4th floor of the said multistoried building as the appellant-plaintiff has got lease
agreement for ten years with option for further extension of
period. The defendants have been creating obstruction to the
boarders, staff and manager of the plaintiff’s hotel by
unnecessary disgraceful comments since long. Even the
defendants did not abstain from making such disturbance
after several objections and requests of the plaintiffs.
On 13.03.2022 at about 10.30 to 11.00 p.m., the
defendant Nos.1 and 2 in presence of manager, staff and
other customers of Hotel Anjana locked the door of room
No.2 of 3rd floor of the said multi-storied hotel, which was
taken by the appellant-plaintiff from the defendants with few
other rooms, under the Monthly Lease Agreement.
The subject matter of the instant suit was the
Room No.2 situated at 3rd floor of multi-storied building of
hotel Anjana which is located at H.G.B. Road, Agartala. It
was further contented by the appellant-plaintiff that the
defendant No.1, being influenced by other defendants, has
been disturbing the plaintiff, the staff and the boarders of
hotel Anjana, even after giving the 3rd floor (including suit
premises i.e. Room No.2) and part of the 4th floor to the
plaintiff for ten years on lease. It was further asserted that
after receipt of notice in connection with case No.T.S.102 of
2021, the respondent-defendants have become more violent
and just to take revenge they have forcefully locked the
Room No.2 of 3rd floor of the said hotel.
It was also submitted that the manager and other
staff and the boarders, after hearing hot altercation between
the manager of the said hotel and the defendant No.1
appeared and resisted the defendant No.1 from locking the
door of Room No.2 but that was in vain.
Thereafter, on the same night, the manager
informed the matter to the Battala outpost but no action was
taken. The appellant-plaintiff further submitted that due to
disturbance
caused
by
the
respondent-defendants,
he
suffered a lot in normal and regular use of the stair case of
the said multi-storied hotel and also suffered loss for the
illegal act of locking the door of the Room No.2 of the 3 rd
floor of Hotel Anjana. Hence, the appellant-plaintiff filed the
suit seeking the following reliefs:
“(i) decree for declaration that the plaintiff
has right and interest over the suit
premises i.e. the Room no.2 of 3rd floor of
Hotel Anjana as per the registered monthly
Lease
Agreement
entered
with
the
defendants dated 17.04.2015 vide No.I323;
(ii) decree for recovery of the amount of
Rs.5,00,000/- (rupees five lakhs only) with
interest @6% per annum since date of
locking the door till the realization from the
defendant for the loss caused due to illegal
locking of the suit premises;
(iii) decree for permanent injunction
restraining the defendants and their agents
from disturbing the peaceful use of the
staircase of the Hotel and possession of the
rooms of the 3rd floor and part of 4th floor
of Hotel Anjana by the plaintiff and his
staffs in and
(iv) decree for mandatory injunction
directing the defendants to open the door
by unlocking the Room No.2 of the 3rd floor
of Hotel Anjana.”
05.
In obedience to the notice issued the respondent-
defendants although appeared but did not contest the suit
for
which
the
suit
proceeded
ex-parte
against
the
respondent-defendants. Thereafter, to substantiate the case
the appellant-plaintiff adduced four witnesses including the
appellant himself and relied upon some documents which
were marked as Exhibit-1 to Exhibit-3:
APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE
(A) Plaintiff's Exhibits :1. Exbt.1 – computerized Khatian No.495 of
Mouja- Agartala Sheet No.6;
2. Exbt. 2 (As a whole) - Original Lease
Deed b/n I-3231 dated 17.04.2015; And
3. Exhibit-3 (As a whole) - Certified copy of
Order
dated
29.01.2022
passed
in
connection with CM (Injunction) 66 of 2021
arising out of TS 102 of 2021.
(B) Plaintiff's witnesses :1. P.W. 1:- Sri Subhash Chakraborty ;
2. P.W. 2:- Sri Prabir Chandra Saha ;
3. P.W. 3:- Sri Suman Ghosh Chowdhury
and
4. P.W. 4:- Sri Ajit Deb.
(C) Defendant's Exhibits :- Nil.
(D) Defendant's witness :- Nil.
(E) Court's Exhibits :- Nil.
(F) Court's witness :- Nil.
06.
As the case proceeded exparte, so, to determine
the suit Learned Trial Court below determined the following
points for decision of the suit:
“(i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its
present form and nature?
(ii) Whether the suit has been instituted
with a valid cause of action?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff has any right and
interest over the suit premise i.e. Room no.
2 of Hotel Anjana?
(iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a
decree for recovery of possession and
permanent
injunction
restraining
the
defendants from disturbing the peaceful
use of the staircase of the Hotel and
peaceful possession of the rooms of the 3rd
floor and part of 4th floor of Hotel Anjana?
(v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get
the decree for recovery of the amount of
Rs.5,00,000/- (rupees five lakhs only) with
interest @6% per annum since date of
locking till the realization from the
defendants?”
07.
Finally on conclusion of trial, the Learned Court
below partly decreed the suit. For the sake of convenience, I
would like to refer herein below the relevant portion of the
judgment and order of the Learned Trial Court which runs as
follows:
“Hence, in the light of the afore-mentioned
discussion, the suit filed by the plaintiff is
hereby partly decreed in his favour against
the defendants.
The right and interest of the plaintiff over
the suit premises is hereby declared as a
lessee w.e.f 15.06.2016 to 14.06.2026 as
per the terms and conditions of the lease.
The defendant is hereby directed to hand
over possession Room no. 2 of 3rd floor of
Hotel Anjana to the plaintiff after unlocking
it within 45 days from the date of decree.
The defendants are also hereby restrained
from disturbing the peaceful use of the
staircase and peaceful possession of the
plaintiff in respect of Room no.2 and other
rooms of the 3rd floor and part of 4th floor
of Hotel Anjana till the expiry of leasehold
period i.e. till 14.06.2026.
Prepare the decree accordingly and put up
for signatures within 14 days from today.
The suit is thus disposed off accordingly
without contest.”
08.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned
Counsel for the appellant submitted that although the
Learned Trial Court below partly decreed the suit but the
Learned Trial Court below did not consider the damages
sustained by the appellant for illegally shut down the Room
No.2 of 3rd floor of the suit premise.
09.
Learned Counsel submitted that Exhibit-2 was
executed for a period of ten years and there was breach of
condition by the respondents in compliance of the said terms
and conditions of the Lease Agreement. But inspite of that
the respondent-defendants without any authority caused
disturbance to the appellant-plaintiff in running the business
of hotel and illegally locked the door of the Room No.2 for
which he was sustaining loss at the rate of Rs.15,00/- per
day.
Accordingly
to
the
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant, although the Learned Trial Court below granted
other reliefs but failed to appreciate the evidence on record
regarding allowing of damages sustained by the appellant
due to illegal locking of the Room No.2, so, Learned Counsel
finally urged for allowing this appeal and to grant decree for
recovery of compensation of amount of loss and sufferings
which the Learned Trial Court failed to consider at the time
of granting part decree in favour of the appellant.
Learned Counsel further submitted that in the
prayer portion of the plaint, specific averment was made
regarding sustaining of loss at the rate of Rs.15,00/- per
day.
10.
The Learned Court below in determining point
No.5 came to the observation that no actual loss could be
proved by the plaintiff, so, no relief was granted. It appears
that before the Learned Trial Court, required Court fees was
deposited by the appellant before filing of the suit. The
contesting
respondent-defendants
inspite
of
receipt
of
summons although appeared but did not contest the suit
either
by
filing
WS
or
by
adducing
oral/documentary
evidence on record.
11.
The appellant as PW-1, in his examination-in-chief
in affidavit asserted the said facts in para No.11. Similarly,
PW-2 Prabir Chandra Saha in his examination-in-chief in
affidavit supported the said fact that the Room No.2 of 3 rd
floor was locked by the respondent-defendants. Similarly,
PW-3 Suman Ghosh Choudhury also supported the said
version. PW-4 Sri Ajit Deb also in his examination-in-chief in
affidavit supported the version of the appellant-plaintiff
regarding cause of action and for causing damage. From the
evidence
on
record,
it
appears
that
the
respondent-
defendants violated the terms and conditions of the Lease
Agreement, i.e. the Exhibit-2 and accordingly, after hearing
the appellant as plaintiff and also after considering the
evidence on record, Learned Trial Court below partly decreed
the suit in favour of the appellant-plaintiff but refused to
grant decree in respect of damages.
12.
In
course
of
hearing
of
argument,
Learned
Counsel for the appellant although submitted that the
appellant-plaintiff sought relief in the plaint for damages, but
that was not considered by the Learned Trial Court. But on
perusal of the evidence on record, it appears that the
appellant-plaintiff before the Learned Trial Court failed to
give any proper account of the damage, sustained by the
appellants due to wrongful act of the respondent-defendants
and as such Learned Court below could not grant the said
relief in favour of the appellant-plaintiff. The suit was filed for
injunction and also for damages.
13.
It is the settled position of law that in a suit for
injunction the plaintiff also may claim relief for damages. To
determine the issue, assistance of ChatGPT is taken with the
following query:
ChatGPT
In a suit for injunction whether the plaintiff
is entitled to get a decree for damages?
:-In a suit for an injunction, the plaintiff
can indeed seek a decree for damages in
addition to the injunction, but this depends
on the specific circumstances of the case
and the relief sought in the plaint.
Key Points:
Combination of Remedies: In many legal
systems, particularly under common law, a
plaintiff may combine multiple remedies in
a single lawsuit. For instance, the plaintiff
may ask for both an injunction (to prevent
ongoing or future harm) and damages (to
compensate for harm already suffered).
Injunction: An injunction is an equitable
remedy that requires the defendant to do
or refrain from doing a specific act. It is
primarily preventive in nature.
Damages: Damages, on the other hand, are
a legal remedy that aims to compensate the
plaintiff for loss or injury suffered due to
the defendant's actions.
Pleading Both Remedies: The plaintiff must
specifically plead for damages in addition
to the injunction in the plaint. If the
plaintiff only seeks an injunction and does
not plead for damages, the court may not
grant damages unless the plaint is
amended.
Discretion of the Court: The grant of both
an injunction and damages is at the
discretion of the court. The court will
assess
whether
both
remedies
are
appropriate based on the evidence and
circumstances.
Separate Proceedings: If damages are not
sought in the injunction suit, the plaintiff
might need to file a separate suit for
damages, depending on the jurisdiction and
the specific legal procedures.
From the said observation of ChatGPT, it also
appears that in a suit for injunction, the plaintiff also may
seek decree for damages subject to specific circumstances of
the case.
14.
Here in the given case, it is the admitted position
that the appellant-plaintiff before the Learned Trial Court in
addition to the prayer for injunction also sought relief for
damages but could not give any specific account for the
damages sustained by him, just only mentioned the amount
sought for without adducing any specific oral/documentary
evidence on record.
15.
Situated thus, in my considered view the matter
needs to be remanded back to the Learned Trial Court with a
direction to the appellant-plaintiff to adduce evidence in
respect of damages mentioned by him to enable the Learned
Trial Court below to give a specific finding on this point.
16.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
plaintiff is hereby allowed. The suit is remanded back to the
Learned Trial Court with a direction to the appellant-plaintiff
to adduce fresh oral/documentary evidence on record, if any,
in support of his claim for damages claimed in the suit to
enable the Court to give a specific finding on this point. The
plaintiff-appellant is further directed to appear before the
Learned Trial Court on 27.08.2024. The Learned Trial Court
shall make endeavour to dispose of the suit within a period
of three (03) months from the date of receipt of a copy of
this judgment after affording the appellant an opportunity to
adduce evidence.
17.
Since, there was no other separate prayers
challenging the judgment and part decree granted by the
Learned Trial Court by judgment dated 02.02.2024 and
decree dated 08.02.2024, so, the same is hereby upheld and
accordingly, it is affirmed. With these observations, the
appeal is disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs along with copy of the
judgment for immediate compliance.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.08.17 16:57:00
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review