Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/sri-subhabrata-deb-vs-the-state-of-tripura-and-anr-20220711/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Civil

Sri Subhabrata Deb vs The State of Tripura and Anr

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Tripura High Court
Date
11 July 2022
Case No.
RFA 9/2020
Result
Dismissed
Bench
T. Amarnath Goud
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

11. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and considering the evidence on record, this court is of the view that the letter which is relied by the appellant does not bare any acknowledgment of the defendants with regard to the service of the letter. The judgment of Kerela High Court, as relied by learned counsel for the appellant in Krishna Menon versus Cochin Devaswom Board and Another reported in AIR 1963 Kerala 181 is not applicable in the fact of the case. In so far as another judgment of Supreme Court as relied by learned counsel for the appellant in State of West Bengal versus B.K. Mondal and Sons reported in AIR 1962 SC 779 which deals with regard the acquisition of contract invoking Section 70 of the Contract Act also is not applicable to the fact of the case since the three conditions cannot be read separately and are inseparable. More so, one of the conditions which deals with the gratuitously works done, here is the case where gratuitously cannot be accepted as per the findings given by the apex court. Here is a case of the petitioner which squarely fits in terms of enhancing the unilaterally increasing the price. Hence, above judgment is also not applicable to the facts of the case. In so far as the point of limitation is concerned, this court is not convinced. Hence, the appeal being devoid of merit stands dismissed. Sabyasachi B

Filed under

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 80, Code of Civil Procedure, 1908

The sections, explained

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA RFA 09 of 2020 For Appellant(s) For Respondent(s) : Ms. S. Debgupta, Adv. Mr. B. Paul, Adv. : Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A. Mr. S. Saha, Adv. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD Order 11/07/2022 Heard Ms. S. Debgupta, learned counsel assisted by Mr. B. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned G.A. assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. 2. The plaintiff’s case in a nut-shell is that the plaintiff is the publisher of “AKSHAR” publication and distributor of National Book Trust, India. The defendant issued a supply order for 1119 Nos. of sets of books for READING CORNER for primary schools/sections of South Tripura under SSA to National Book Trust, New Delhi during 2010-2011 vide No.F.2(28-56)EDN(S)SSA/09/2047 dated 21.01.2011. The plaintiff after getting the order from the defendant for supply of NBT, Books for Reading Corner under SSA Project during 2010-11 Financial year placed the same to NBT Authority. It is pleaded that the NBT Authority as was having no sufficient stock of the order of the defendant at that moment planned for fresh re-print of the total order of books and as such NBT Authority informed the plaintiff that due to re-print the revised price of books would be little up. It is pleaded that the NBT Authority also informed the plaintiff that the book would be Rs.2,435/- each. It is pleaded that the plaintiff accordingly proposed the defendant to accept the supply of NBT Books @ Rs.2435/- only which is the sanction amount of the defendant for total 1119 copy each set comprising 74 titles in place of 94 nos. titles. It is also pleaded that the plaintiff also clarified to the defendant that price hike of books by NBT India ensued due to re-printing of books as per their norms. The plaintiff also informed the defendant that the plaintiff thoroughly examined the revised price of books and placed proposal keeping in view the sanction amount of the defendant. It is also pleaded that the plaintiff on 22.03.2011 informed the defendant of all these and requested the defendant if the defendant would not agree the proposal of the plaintiff regarding price hike of the books the defendant should inform the plaintiff in writing and that if the defendant would not inform the plaintiff the plaintiff would presume that the defendant has accepted his proposal and he would supply the books. It is also pleaded that the plaintiff complied the order dated 21.01.2011 for supply of NBT Book, related with reading corner and submitted the bill to the Inspector of School office and raised a bill of Rs.24,52,000/- with the office of the defendant under the bill no.AKH/NBT-2011/SSA/HD/S-UDP/14, dated 20.09.2011. It is further pleaded that on 21.01.2012 the plaintiff received a part payment of Rs.17,00,000/- vide cheque No.054877 on TGB, Udaipur Branch. Subsequently the plaintiff requested the defendant to release the due amount of Rs.7,52,000/against supply of NBT, Book for Reading Corner during 2010-11. The plaintiff waited for a long time for having the bill amount of Rs.7,52,000/-, which was pending for part payment before the defendant, released, however, the defendant did not pay the said amount to him no assigned any reason for the non-payment of the same. It is also pleaded that suddenly on 29.11.2014 a letter was issued to the plaintiff by the defendant whereby the plaintiff was informed that the outstanding amount due to the plaintiff is Rs.54,368/- instead of Rs.7,52,000/-. It is also pleaded that the plaintiff thereafter issued on 22.06.2015, 18.11.2015 & 20.11.2015 demand notice under section 80 of the CPC upon the defendants for the early payment of his outstanding amount of Rs.7,52,000/- to which defendants replied informing that the plaintiff’s claim for an outstanding amount of Rs.7,52,000/- only is quite unjustified, unlawful and unethical and this cannot be entertained by the defendant at any cost due to breach of contract. It is also informed by the defendants that they are ready to make payment of Rs.54,368/instead of Rs.7,52,000/-. The plaintiff pleaded further certain ancillary facts such as about plaintiff having made a communication to the Additional State Project Director who in turn on 21.08.2014 made a communication to the defendant and requested the defendant to expedite payment of Rs.7,52,000/- to the plaintiff and that again on 17.04.2015 Additional State Project Director requested the defendant for payment of the outstanding amount to the plaintiff to which the defendant not paying any heed. 3. Upon institution of the suit summons were issued upon the defendants. The defendants having entered into appearance filed their joint written statements contending inter alia that the instant suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable in its present form and nature and also that it is not maintainable either in law or facts and circumstances of the present case as well as that suit of the plaintiff is bad for mis-joinder & non-joinder of necessary parties. 4. It is contended by the defendants that plaintiff has got no cause of action as well as that the suit of the plaintiff barred by the law of limitation. It is also contended that though the plaintiff served demand notice upon some of the authority of the answering defendants but in fact but no notice was served to the answering defendants as provided under section 80(1) CPC prior to the institution of the present suit and hence the suit is not maintainable against the answering defendants. 5. The vital limb of contention by the defendants as can be traced from the written statement filed is that a supply order was issued to the Regional Manager, NBT India Eastern Regional Office, Kolkata vide communication No.F.2(28-56)-EDN(S)-SSA/09/2047 dated 20.01.2011 through their local distributor Akshar Publication of Agartala. As pr the order, the supplying agency had to supply to 1119 sets to book consisting of 94 titles in each set of books consisting of 94 titles in each set for the reading corner. Total cost of the books after allowing rebate was Rs.24,52,000/- only. Accordingly 1119 sets of books were supplied to 5 nos. of Education Inspectorate of the then South District and a bill amounting to Rs.24,52,000/- was raised before the District Project Coordinator, SSA, South District on 20.09.2011. But it was noticed that supplier supplied only 74 titles in each set instead of 94 sets of books violating the terms and conditions of the order which was a breach of contract and hence a part payment amounting to Rs.17,00,000/- out of actual cost of the books i.e. Rs.17,54,368/- only was made to the supplier vide cheque No.054877 dated 21.01.2012. According to the defendants the plaintiff is not entitled to get any further sum and that the claim of the plaintiff is not sustainable in law. According to the defendants as per supply order dated 21.01.2011 the supplier i.e. NBT had to supply the total 1119 sets of books consisting of 94 titles of books per set and in between there can be no downsizing but they supplied only 74 books per and thus thereby breached the contract. According to the defendants two communication were made with NBT through their local agent vide No.F.2(2856)EDN(S)/SSA/09/1367 dated 19.10.2011 and No.F.2(28-56)-EDN(S)SSA/0506 dated 05.04.2013 to complete the short supply of books against the order but in vain as they did not respond to their communications. 6. It is also contended that a communication with Sri Subhabrata Deb, Pubisher, Akishar Publications was also made vide No.F.2(28-6)- EDN(G)/SSA/2014/1304 dated 29.11.2014 to supply the balance number of books against the supply order but Sri Deb did not reply to that letter, too. Accordingly to the defendants the actual outstanding bill is Rs.54,368/- as per status of the supply made and that the claim for an outstanding amount of Rs.7,52,000/- by the plaintiff is highly untenable and the said claim of the plaintiff as aforesaid is liable to be dismissed and rejected. According to the defendants the demand notice served upon the defendants by the plaintiff was unjust and unlawful without any basis and response was given to the plaintiff informing that the answering defendants is not in a position to pay any outstanding amount to the tune of Rs.7,52,000/- as claimed as the claim was not true and imaginary one. The defendants admitted the fact about having received two communication from the SSA Rajya Mission, Tripura requesting to expedite the payment of outstanding balance of the plaintiff concerned. It is contended that in response to the first letter dated 21.08.2014, their office wrote to Mr. Subhabrata Deb, with a copy to the Additional State Project Director, SSA, to make his stand clear on the short supply of books but he did not bother to revert back. In response to the second letter dated 17.04.2015, letter was addressed to the Additional State Project Director, SSA, Rajya Mission seeking suggestion for the next course of action and permission to make payment to the party concerned but no reply was given as it was unnecessary and the letters of the plaintiff are self explanatory and deserves no answer from the answering defendants. 7. The trial court has framed the following issues : ISSUES i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and nature ? ii) Whether the plaintiff has cause of action for filing the instant suit ? iii) Whether the suit of the plaintiff is barred by the Law of Limitation ? iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get an amount of Rs.7,52,000/- from the defendants for supplying the Books for Reading Corner for primary schools/Sections published by National Book Trust, India ? v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get the decree as prayed for? vi) To what other relief/reliefs parties are entitled ? After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and elaborate discussion on the evidence, the trial court has dismissed the suit. 8. Ms. S. Debgupta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the learned trial court has committed serious illegality while passing the judgment and decree dated 29.02.2020 and 20.07.2020 inasmuch as learned trial court dismissed the suit on the ground of limitation. The appellant submitted his bill for Rs.7,52,000/-. On 29.11.2014 the respondents acknowledged that the outstanding amount is not Rs.7,52,000/- but Rs.54,368/-. As such, the limitation would start on and from 29.11.2014. The suit was filed on 15.03.2016 and was within the period of limitation. 9. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has further submitted that by the letter dated 22.03.2011 the respondent No.2 was informed regarding price hike of books by National Book Trust due to reprint of books but the respondent No.2 did not give any reply. Learned counsel has referred to the following paragraph-36 from the judgment of the trial court which reads as under: “36. In the instant case as it appears the plaintiff vide letter dated 22.03.2011(Exbt.2) informed the defendant No.2 about price hike of Books by NBT India due to reprint of books. As it appears the plaintiff by said letter dated 22.03.2011 has set a deadline, having included a clause there in the said letter dated 22.03.2011, for receipt of written reply from the ends of defendant no.2 and as well as for drawing presumption of acceptance of proposal of the plaintiff by the defendant in the event of non-receipt of written reply from the ends of said defendant.” 10. The respondents have stated that the contention of the appellant regarding information of enhancement of rate by the NBT is false. The office of the respondent No.2 has never received any such communication. They have further stated that out of the 94 sets ordered they have received only 74 sets and as such, the due amount comes to Rs.54,368/-. 11. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and considering the evidence on record, this court is of the view that the letter which is relied by the appellant does not bare any acknowledgment of the defendants with regard to the service of the letter. The judgment of Kerela High Court, as relied by learned counsel for the appellant in Krishna Menon versus Cochin Devaswom Board and Another reported in AIR 1963 Kerala 181 is not applicable in the fact of the case. In so far as another judgment of Supreme Court as relied by learned counsel for the appellant in State of West Bengal versus B.K. Mondal and Sons reported in AIR 1962 SC 779 which deals with regard the acquisition of contract invoking Section 70 of the Contract Act also is not applicable to the fact of the case since the three conditions cannot be read separately and are inseparable. More so, one of the conditions which deals with the gratuitously works done, here is the case where gratuitously cannot be accepted as per the findings given by the apex court. Here is a case of the petitioner which squarely fits in terms of enhancing the unilaterally increasing the price. Hence, above judgment is also not applicable to the facts of the case. In so far as the point of limitation is concerned, this court is not convinced. Hence, the appeal being devoid of merit stands dismissed. JUDGE Sabyasachi B

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Tripura HC judgments →