Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.20 of 2022
1. Sri Sisir Das,
S/O. Late Manasha Charan Das
Resident of Bordowali, Agartala,
P.S. Arundhutinagar,
District - West Tripura.
2. Sri Subal Sarkar,
S/O. Late Haralal Sarkar.
3. Sri Nitai Das,
S/O. Shri Phani Bhusan Das.
4. Sri Krishna Gopal Saha,
S/O- Late Ramesh Ch. Saha
All are resident of Bhattapukur, Agartala,
P.S.- Arundhutinagar,
District - West Tripura
………..Plaintiff Appellants(s)
Versus
1. Sri Anjurai Debbarma.
2. Sri Judhamani Debbarma.
3. Sri Ramesh Debbarma.
4. Sri Magrai Debbarma.
5. Sri Abhiram Debbarma.
All are sons of Late Ananta Debbarma.
6. Smti. Hirapati Debbarma
W/O. Sri Anjurai Debbarma.
7. Smti Papari Debbarma
W/O. Sri Judhamani Debbarma
All are resident of Vill- Ramgati,
S.K. Para, P.O. S.K. Para,
P.S. Sreenagar,
District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799004.
8. (a) Smti. Alo Rani Das
S/O. Late Haradhan Das.
8. (b) Sri Sudip Das
S/O. Late Haradhan Das.
8. (c) Sri Ranjit Das
S/O. Late Haradhan Das.
All are resident of Laxmi Tilla,
Ward No. 2, South Anandanagar,
P.O. S.K. Para, P.S. Sreenagar,
District- West Tripura,
Pin – 799004.
9. Sri Manoranjan Paul
S/O. Krishnadhan Paul
Resident of Netaji Nagar
ONGC Colony, P.S. Amtali,
District- West Tripura,
Pin-799014.
………..Defendant Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Adv,
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Deb, Adv,
Date of Hearing
:
07.08.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
16.08.2024
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment
and decree dated 07.02.2022 and 17.02.2022 respectively
delivered by Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala
in connection with case No.T.A.42 of 2017. By the said
judgment, the Learned First Appellate Court has affirmed the
judgment and decree dated 22.06.2017 and 06.07.2017
respectively
delivered
by
Learned
Civil
Judge,
Senior
Division, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in T.S.136 of
2012.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. P. Chakraborty for
the appellants and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. K. Deb
for the respondent-defendants herein.
03.
In
course
of
hearing
of
argument,
Learned
Counsel for the appellants first of all drawn the attention of
the Court referring para No.25, 26 and 27 of the judgment
delivered by Learned First Appellate Court and submitted
that Learned First Appellate Court and the Learned Trial
Court came to an observation that the allotment of the suit
land was given as per Allotment of Land Rules, 1980 in
favour of the original vendors of the appellants and thus,
came to an erroneous finding that the suit land was
transferred without permission of the Collector of the district
which was totally erroneous and perverse and thus, the
judgment
of
the
Learned
Courts
infirmities.
Learned
Counsel
for
below
the
suffers
appellants
from
further
submitted that before the Learned Trial Court, three deeds
were exhibited by the appellants which were marked as
Exhibit-1, Exhibit-2 and Exhibit-3 and those were exhibited
and admitted into evidence without any objection from the
respondent-defendants herein, but the Learned Trial Court
below at the time of delivery of the judgment did not
consider the same and dismissed the suit which was affirmed
by the Learned First Appellate Court and submitted that
since the judgment and decree of the Learned Courts below
suffers from infirmities, so, the interference of the Court is
required and urged for setting aside the judgment and
decree of the Learned First Appellate Court and to grant
decree in favour of the appellants herein.
04.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the
respondent-defendants
first
of
all
submitted
that
the
submission made by Learned Counsel for the appellants is
beyond pleadings because before the Learned Trial Court,
the appellants could not prove their possession over the suit
land. So, the Learned Court below rightly came to the
observation that the appellants herein could not prove their
possession over the suit land and as such they were not
entitled to get any decree of permanent injunction. Learned
Counsel for the respondent-defendants further submitted
that the appellants before the Learned Trial Court below
could not prove the exhibited documents i.e. Exhibit-1,
Exhibit-2 and Exhibit-3 in accordance with the provisions of
Section 67 and 68 of the Indian Evidence Act and as such the
appellants could not prove their right, title and interest and
possession
over
the
suit
land
by
adducing
any
oral/documentary evidence on record and the Learned
Courts below rightly and reasonably dismissed the suit of the
appellants herein, which was affirmed by the Learned First
Appellate Court.
So, at this stage, according to Learned Counsel
for the respondent-defendants, the present appeal is liable to
be dismissed with costs.
05.
Now, before coming to the conclusion of this
appeal, let us discuss the subject matter of the suit filed by
the appellants before the Learned Trial Court. According to
the appellants, they filed the suit for declaration of title,
confirmation of possession and perpetual injunction before
the Learned Trial Court. The case of the appellants before
the Learned Trial Court was that the suit land measuring
5.24 acres appertaining to Khatian No.2014 and 1776 under
Mouja Madhuban was originally belonged to one Sukhendu
Datta and Prafulla Kumar Majumder and after the death of
said Sukhendu Datta his wife, Smt. Raimanjuri Dutta and
others by a Sale Deed dated 15.06.2011 sold/transferred
land measuring 1.84 acres appertaining to Khatian No.2014,
surveyed in Old C.S. Plot No.4535/5772 corresponding to
Revisional C.S. Plot No.5936 in favour of the appellants.
Similarly, on 15.06.2011 Prafulla Kumar Majumder by
another Sale Deed transferred land measuring 3.36 acres
appertaining to Khatian No.1776 surveyed in Old C.S. Plot
No.4535/5752 corresponding to Revisional C.S. Plot No.5935
under said Mouja in favour of the appellant-plaintiffs.
Thereafter, said Prafulla Kumar Majumder by another Sale
Deed transferred further land measuring 0.04 acre of present
C.S. Plot No.5935 of Khatian No. 1776 to the appellants.
Thus, the appellants became the owners in possession of the
said land measuring 5.24 acres i.e. the suit land. It was
further submitted that thereafter, appellant-plaintiffs erected
boundary fencing to do rubber garden but the respondentdefendants started disturbing possession of the appellantplaintiffs over the suit property. After that, the appellants
approached Deputy Collector & Magistrate, Dukli, Revenue
Circle for demarcation of the suit land but due to disturbance
caused by the respondent-defendants, which could not be
done by the Survey Team. After that on 05.08.2012 the
respondent-defendants forming a group tried to enter into
the suit land but failed due to resistance caused by the
respondent-defendants.
Thereafter, also the respondent-defendants made
several attempts to dispossess the appellant-plaintiffs from
the suit land but failed. Hence, the appellant-plaintiffs filed
the suit for granting decree. The respondent-defendants
contested
the
suit
by
filing
written
statement.
The
respondent-defendant Nos.1 to 5, 7 and 8 by filing their
written statement denied the assertions of the appellantplaintiffs in the plaint and they further took the plea that
they are in possession of the suit land more than 100 years
by doing cultivation and also denied the possession of the
appellant-plaintiffs over the suit land at any point of time.
The respondent-defendants Nos.9 and 10 also contested the
suit by filing written statement denying the entire assertions
of the appellant-plaintiffs and they also took the plea that
the suit land was allotted to Prafulla Kumar Majumder and
Sukhendu Datta (since dead) beyond their knowledge and
the same was illegally sold to the appellant-plaintiffs in
violation Rule 12(1) of TLR & LR (Allotment of Land) Rules
1980.
So,
the
contesting
defendants
by
their
written
statement prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
06.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, following issues
were framed by the Learned Trial Court:
“(1) Is the suit maintainable in its present
form and nature ?
(2) Have the plaintiffs any right, title and
interest over the suit land ?
(3) Have the plaintiffs ever been possessed
the suit land ?
(4) Have the defendants been possessing
the suit land for last 100 years peacefully
without any obstruction from any corner ?
(5) Are the plaintiffs entitled to get a
decree as prayed for ?
(6) To what other relief/reliefs the parties
to this suit are entitled to get?”
07.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record:
Witnesses of PWs:
PW-1: Sri Krishna Gopal Saha
PW-2: Sri Jatan Mallik
Witnesses of DWs:
DW-1: Sri Anjurai Debbarma
DW-2: Sri Sibu Dey
DW-3: Sri Sudhir Debbarma
Exhibited documents of PWs:
Exbt.1 – Original registered Sale Deed vide
No.1-988 dated 15.06.2011.
Exbt.2 – Original registered Sale Deed vide
No.1-990 dated 15.06.2011.
Exbt.3 – Original registered Sale Deed vide
No.1-986 dated 15.06.2011.
Exbt.4 – Certified copy of Khatian No.2014
of Mouja-Madhuban.
Exbt.5 – Certified copy of Khatian No.1776
of Mouja-Madhuban.
08.
Finally, on conclusion of trial, the Learned Trial
Court below by judgment dated 22.06.2017 dismissed the
suit. The operative portion of the judgment/order of the
Learned Trial Court runs as follows:
“In the result, the suit is dismissed on
contest without costs.
The plaintiffs have no right, title and
interest over the suit land as well as their
possession over the suit land is also not
confirmed. The plaintiffs are also not
entitled for perpetual injunction over the
suit land since they failed to establish their
exclusive possession over the same.
With the above observation the suit is
disposed of on contest without costs.
Prepare decree accordingly.”
09.
Challenging that judgment, the appellant-plaintiffs
preferred appeal under Section 96 of C.P.C. before the Court
of Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala which was
numbered as T.A.42 of 2017 and the Learned District Judge
after hearing both the sides also dismissed the appeal
upholding the judgment and decree of the Learned Trial
Court below. For the sake of convenience, I would like to
refer herein below the operative portion of the judgment and
order dated 07.02.2022 of Learned First Appellate Court
which is as follows:
“In the result, I find no infirmity in the
finding of the Judgment arrived at by the
Learned Trial Court. Accordingly, this Title
Appeal is dismissed on contest with cost.
The Judgment passed by the Learned Trial
Court in Title Suit No.136 of 2012 is upheld
and affirmed.
Prepare Appellate Decree accordingly.
Send down the L.C. record along with a
copy of this Judgment.”
10.
Being aggrieved with the judgment, the appellant-
plaintiffs further preferred this appeal under Section 100 of
C.P.C. before the High Court. At the time of admission of the
appeal by order dated 11.05.2022 the following substantial
question of law was formulated:
“(i) Whether the finding of the First
Appellate Court returned by the impugned
judgment is perverse because under the
relevant Tripura Land Revenue & Land
Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules; no prior
permission of the Collector was required for
transfer of the allotted land ?”
11.
I have heard argument of both the sides and gone
through the records of the Learned Court below. The
appellants as plaintiffs filed the suit before the Learned Trial
Court for granting decree of declaration of right, title and
interest and for confirmation of possession and also for
perpetual
injunction.
The
Learned
Trial
Court
below
dismissed the suit on the ground that the appellant-plaintiffs
could not establish their right, title and interest over the suit
lands both by adducing oral/documentary evidence on record
and also came to the observation that the appellant-plaintiffs
could not prove the Exhibits- 1, 2 and 3 in accordance with
law and ultimately dismissed the suit and the Learned First
Appellate Court also came to the observation that the suit
land was transferred in violation of Rule 12(1) Allotment of
Land Rules, 1980 without the permission of the Collector and
also Exhibits-1, 2 and 3 were not proved in accordance with
the provisions of the Evidence Act and as such Learned First
Appellate
Court
dismissed
the
appeal
upholding
the
judgment and decree of the Learned Trial Court below. Now
at this stage, we are to examine whether the judgments of
the Learned Courts below suffers from any infirmities or not.
12.
Admittedly, in this case, the appellant-plaintiffs
could not produce and prove any order of allotment on the
basis of which the suit land was allotted in favour of the
original
vendors
of the
appellant-plaintiffs
namely, Sri
Prafulla Kumar Majumder and Sukhendu Datta (since dead).
In order to prove the case, the appellant-plaintiffs have
adduced two witnesses and also relied upon some documents
which were marked as Exhibit-1 to Exhibit-5. Exhibits-1, 2
and 3 are the registered Title Deeds, on the basis of which
the suit land was transferred to the appellant-plaintiffs by
the original vendors and Exhibit-4 is the certified copy of
Khatian-2014 standing in the name of Sukhendu Datta (since
dead) bearing No.2014 for land measuring 1.84 and Exhibit5 is the certified copy of Khatian bearing No.1776 standing in
the name of Prafulla Majumder for land measuring 3.40
acres. On perusal of Exhibits-1, 2 and 3, it appears that by
the
aforesaid
Title
Deeds
the
appellant-plaintiffs
have
purchased the suit land from the original vendors i.e. the
entire land of Khatian No.2014 and 1776. Exhibits-4 and 5
are the certified copies of Khatians and as such being a
public
document,
it
was
admissible
in
evidence
and
accordingly, admitted into evidence by the Learned Trial
Court. Now, in respect of Exhibits-1, 2 and 3, it appears that
the Learned Trial Court below at the time of recording
evidence of PW1 i.e. one of the appellant-plaintiffs, namely
Krishna Gopal Saha admitted those documents into evidence
and marked as Exhibits-1, 2 and 3 without any objection
from the side of contesting respondent-defendants. But
surprisingly, at the time of delivery of judgment, Learned
Trial Court below came to the observation in middle portion
of para No.6 that those are not admissible in eye of law. This
part of observation in my considered view was not in
accordance with law because once the document is admitted
into evidence and marked as exhibits without any objection
from the other side by the Learned Trial Court below, later
on, cannot be discarded by another observation that the
same are/were not admissible in the eye of law. At the time
of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for the appellants
submitted that those documents were exhibited without any
objection
by
the
contesting
respondents
cannot
be
subsequently raised in the Appellate Court that the same was
not admissible. In this regard, Learned Counsel for the
respondent-defendants could not submit anything to discard
the submission of Learned Counsel for the appellant.
13.
In Lachhmi Narain Singh (Dead) Through
Legal Representatives and Others vs. Sarjug Singh
(Dead) Through Legal Representatives and Others
dated 17.08.2021 reported in (2022) 13 SCC 746,
wherein in para Nos.22 to 24 Hon’ble the Supreme Court
observed as under:
“22. A similar view was taken by George
Rankin, J. in the decision of Privy Council in
Gopal Das v. Sri Thakurji:1943 SCC OnLine
PC 2 where it was held that objection as to
the mode of proof must be taken when the
document is tendered and before it is
marked as an exhibit. It cannot be taken in
appeal. Objection as to mode of proof
should be taken before a document is
admitted and marked as exhibit. In the
present case the probate applicant never
raised any objection in regard to mode of
proof of cancellation deed before the trial
court, as is evident from perusal of records
and this must be held against him.
23. In support of our above conclusion, we
may usefully refer to the ratio in R.V.E.
Venkatachala
Gounder
v.
Arulmigu
Viswesaraswami & V.P. Temple: (2003) 8
SCC 752 where Ashok Bhan, J. while
dealing with the aspect of disallowing
objection as to mode of proof at appellate
stage as a rule of fair play to avoid
prejudice to the other side, said as follows:
(SCC p. 764, para 20)
20. … In the latter case, the objection
should be taken when the evidence is
tendered and once the document has
been admitted in evidence and marked
as an exhibit, the objection that it
should not have been admitted in
evidence or that the mode adopted for
providing the document is irregular
cannot be allowed to be raised at any
stage subsequent to the marking of
the document as an exhibit. The latter
proposition is a rule of fair play. The
crucial test is whether an objection, if
taken at the appropriate point of time,
would
have
enabled
the
party
tendering the evidence to cure the
defect and resort to such mode of
proof as would be regular. The
omission to object becomes fatal
because by his failure the party
entitled to object allows the party
tendering the evidence to act on an
assumption that the opposite party is
not serious about the mode of proof.
On the other hand, a prompt objection
does not prejudice the party tendering
the evidence, for two reasons: firstly,
it enables the court to apply its mind
and pronounce its decision on the
question of admissibility then and
there; and secondly, in the event of
finding of the court on the mode of
proof sought to be adopted going
against the party tendering the
evidence, the opportunity of seeking
indulgence of the court for permitting
a regular mode or method of proof and
thereby removing the objection raised
by the opposite party, is available to
the party leading the evidence. Such
practice and procedure is fair to both
the parties. Out of the two types of
objections, referred to hereinabove, in
the latter case, failure to raise a
prompt and timely objection amounts
to waiver of the necessity for insisting
on formal proof of a document, the
document itself which is sought to be
proved being admissible in evidence.
24. This Court in the opinion written by S.H.
Kapadia, J. in Dayamathi Bai v. K.M. Shaffi:
(2004) 7 SCC 107 has similarly held that
objection as to the mode of proof falls
within procedural law. Therefore, such
objections could be waived. Moreover,
objection is to be taken before the
document is marked as an exhibit and
admitted in Court.”
14.
On perusal of the same, it appears that it was the
duty of the respondent-defendants to raise objection on the
admissibility on documents when the evidence was recorded,
but they failed to do so. So, this plea cannot be taken before
this High Court at this belated stage. Now, regarding transfer
of the suit land through Exhibits-1, 2 and 3 as submitted by
Learned Counsel for the appellants at the time of hearing,
the observation of the Learned First Appellate Court that the
suit land was transferred without any consent of the
Collector was not correct, because the allotment of land was
given to the vendors as per Tripura Land Revenue & Land
Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules, 1962 in favour of the
vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs, not in accordance with the
Allotment of Land Rules, 1980. But the Learned First
Appellate Court, without any basis came to the observation
in para Nos.25 and 26 of the judgment that the suit land was
transferred without written consent of the Collector in view
of Rule 12(1)- Allotment of Land Rules, 1980. In this regard,
I have perused the documentary evidence on record.
15.
On perusal of Exhibits-4 and 5, it appears that the
suit land was allotted in the name of the vendors of the
appellant-plaintiffs as per Allotment Rules, 1960. Now for the
sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein below the
relevant provision of Section 14 of The Tripura Land Revenue
and Land Reforms Act, 1960, Rule 15(1)(i) of The Tripura
Land Revenue & Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules,
1962 and the relevant provision of
Rule 12 of The Tripura
Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules,
1980 which reads as under:
Section 14 of The Tripura Land Revenue
and Land Reforms Act, 1960:
“14. Allotment of Land.- (1) The Collector
may allot land belonging to the Government
for agricultural purposes or for construction
of dwelling houses, in accordance with such
rules as may be made in this behalf under
this Act; and such rules may provide for
allotment of land to persons evicted under
section 15.
(2) The [State Government] shall have
power(a) to allot any such land for the
purpose of an industry or for any
purpose of public utility on such
conditions as may be prescribed, or
(b) to entrust the management of any
such land or any rights therein to the
gram
panchayat
of
the
village
established under any law for the time
being in force.
(3) The rules under sub-sections (1) and
(2) for allotment of land shall provide for
giving preference to the members of the
co-operative farming societies formed by
marginal farmers, landless agricultural
labourers, jumias and members of the
Scheduled Tribes and Scheduled Castes in
allotting land.”
Rule 15(1)(i) of The Tripura Land Revenue
& Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules,
1962:
“15. An allotment of land under sub-section
(1) of section 14 shall be subject to the
following conditions, namely(i) the land shall not be transferred by
the allottee within ten years from the
date of allotment, without the written
consent of the Collector:
Provided that the land may be mortgaged
to a co-operative society, a co-operative
bank or land mortgage bank or the
Government without such consent;”
Rule 12 of The Tripura Land Revenue and
Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules,
1980:
“12. Conditions of allotment.-(1) Any
allotment of land under sub-section (1) of
section 14 and in accordance with these
rules, shall be further subject to the
following conditions and also the conditions
specified in the allotment order which shall
be, as nearly as possible, in the form at
Appendix „B‟:
(i) The land will be heritable but not
alienable without the written consent of the
Collector granted on the recommendation
of the Advisory Committee that may be set
up by the Government.”
16.
From the aforesaid rules, it appears that in The
Tripura Land Revenue & Land Reforms (Allotment of Land)
Rules, 1962, there was a bar that the land under allotment
could be transferred after ten years without any permission
from the Collector, but if the allotment was made as per The
Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment of Land)
Rules, 1980, in that case, there was a clear bar that without
the permission of the Collector, there is no scope to transfer
any land to any person, but here in the given case, it
appears that Learned First Appellate Court in para Nos.25
and 26 observed that the allotment of land was given to the
vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs
as per The Tripura Land
Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980,
which in my considered view was nothing proper but
misconception of law and as such the same cannot be
accepted.
17.
Learned Counsel for the respondent-defendants,
in course of hearing of argument submitted that regarding
confirmation of possession, the appellant-plaintiffs could not
produce any evidence on record to grant decree in their
favour. It is the settled position of law that in a suit for
declaration of right,
title, interest
and for
permanent
injunction, the plaintiffs not only should prove his title over
the suit land but at the same time should adduce evidence in
support of his possession over the suit land from which he or
she is threatened to be evicted. In this regard, I would like
to discuss herein below the evidence on record of the
parties.
18.
From the side of appellant plaintiffs, one Krishna
Gopal Saha, one of the appellants was examined as PW1. In
his examination-in-chief in affidavit said Krishna Gopal Saha
took the plea that they have purchased the land measuring
1.84 acres from the legal heirs of Sukhendu Datta(since
dead) by a Title Deed dated 15.06.2011 and they also
purchased land measuring 3.40 acres from one Prafulla
Kumar Majumder by two separate registered Sale Deeds
dated 15.06.2011 and got delivery of possession of the said
land immediately after purchase and on 05.08.2012, the
respondent-defendants tried to dispossess them from the
suit land and thereafter, on several occasions also, for which
they filed the suit.
Said PW1 in course of his examination-in-chief
relied upon certain documents which were marked as
Exhibits-1 to 5. During cross-examination by the contesting
respondent-defendants Nos.9 and 10, he has specifically
admitted that in the plaint they did not mention when and in
favour of whom the allotment of the suit land was made and
nothing is mentioned in Exhibits-1, 2 and 3 that the suit land
was an allottee land. He also admitted that they did not
make any application for correction of Khatian due to
objection raised.
During cross-examination by defendant Nos.1 to
8, he stated that before purchasing of the suit land, they
have collected all the information in respect of the suit land
and the original owner of the suit land was one Sukhendu
Datta and after his death his legal heirs. He further admitted
that there is a cremation ground on the western side of the
suit land. Nothing more came out relevant from his crossexamination.
19.
PW2, Jatan Mallik in his examination-in-chief in
affidavit supported the version of the appellant-plaintiffs in
the plaint.
During cross-examination by defendant Nos.9 and
10, he stated that he used to work as a rubber tapper in the
rubber garden of Krishna Gopal Saha. He could not say the
quantum of the suit land. He also admitted that the suit land
was bounded by the East by Pramod Kr. Bhowmik, by West-
Haradhan Das, Manoranjan Das, by North-Supti Sarkar and
Jyoti Prabha Sarkar, by South- Jhandu Debi.
During cross-examination by defendant Nos.1 to
8, he admitted that there is a cremation ground on the
western side of the suit land and the boundary of land of
some tribal people was on the eastern side of the suit land.
20.
To substantiate the defence, the respondent-
defendants have adduced three witnesses.
DW1 Anjurai Debbarma, in his examination-inchief in affidavit supported his version made in the WS.
During cross-examination he stated that he was
not acquainted with the plaintiffs of the case. The suit land is
measuring 12/13 kanis. He was unable to say dag number
and khatian number of the suit land. He also could not say
whose name is incorporated in the khatian during revisional
survey.
21.
Similarly, DW2 Sibu Dey in his examination-in-
chief in affidavit tried to support the version of the contesting
respondents in their WS.
During
cross-examination
by
the
appellant-
plaintiffs he admitted that he was not acquainted with the
plaintiffs of the case and the suit land is comprising 10/11
kani of land and he also could not say the crux of the suit of
the plaintiffs.
22.
Similarly,
DW3
Sudhir
Debbarma
in
his
examination-in-chief in affidavit tried to support the version
of the respondent-defendants in their WS.
During cross-examination he stated that his house
was situated 2 km away from the suit land. He could not say
the description of the suit land also could not say whose
name was recorded in the khatian during revisional survey.
These are the synopsis of the evidence on record
of the parties in respect of determination of issues framed by
Learned Trial Court.
23.
The respondent-defendant Nos.1 to 5, 7 and 8 in
their WS denied the assertions of the appellant-plaintiffs
intheir plaint and the respondent-defendants Nos.9 and 10
took the plea that the suit land was belonging to the
Government of Tripura and since from the year 1970, one
Bishakha Rishi Das and respondent-defendants Nos.1 to 8
took possession of the suit land and since then they have
been possessing the suit land, but beyond their back,
Government of Tripura allotted the suit land in favour of
Sukhendu Datta (since dead) and Prafulla Kumar Majumder
but no possession was given to them. It was further
submitted that said Bishakha Rishi Das and the defendants
Nos.1 to 8 planted rubber trees, collected rubber latex from
the suit land and later on, Bishakha Rishi Das by a
unregistered Deed transferred portion of the suit land to
respondent-defendant No.10, Bhulu Chakraborty who used
to cultivate the same by engaging defendant No.1 as tapper
and used to collect latex from the part of the suit land.
They also took the plea that the transfer was
made without any permission of the Collector, so, it was
barred in view of the Rule 12(1) of The Tripura Land
Revenue and Land Reforms Rules, 1980, but surprisingly in
support of the contention, the respondent-defendants could
not adduce any documentary evidence on record nor proved
any
unregistered
oral/documentary
Deed
also
evidence
on
not
record
produced
any
that
have
they
cultivated rubber plants on the suit land.
24.
I have also gone through the evidence on record
of the parties. According to the appellant-plaintiffs, after
purchase, they got possession over the suit land and posted
pillars for clear identification of the same.
25.
On the other hand, the respondent-defendants in
support
of
their
contention
adduced
three
witnesses,
although in their examination-in-chief, they stated that the
suit land was under their possession i.e. the defendants but
from their evidence, it cannot be conclusively said that they
are possessing the suit land since long back, because the
witnesses of the respondent-defendants, in course of their
cross-examination could not give any proper identification of
the suit land, nor they could give any account from when the
respondent-defendants are possessing the said land, even
they also could not give any account as to how the
respondent-defendants were possessing the suit land.
From the relevant khatian, it appears even in the
column of possession, there is no any entry by the
Settlement or Revenue Authority, which indicates that the
respondent-defendants are/were possessing the suit land
either as permissive possessor or as or as an unauthorized
possessor.
26.
Situated thus, on the face of evidence on record,
it can easily be said that the respondent-defendants in
support of their possession over the suit land failed to
adduce any conclusive oral/documentary evidence on record
to substantiate their defence. Even as alleged by them, they
adversely possessed the suit land. In this account also they
have failed to adduce any cogent evidence on record.
Learned Trial Court below at the time of delivery of the
judgment, failed to consider all those aspects and came to
the conclusion that the appellant-plaintiffs have failed to
establish their right, title and interest and possession over
the suit land, which in my considered view the same was
erroneous.
27.
Admittedly, in the plaint, the appellant-plaintiffs
did not state that their vendors got allotment of the suit
land. Even the Title Deeds i.e. Exhibits-1, 2 and 3 are also
silent
that
the
vendors
of
the
appellant-plaintiffs
got
allotment of the said land from the Government. But for that,
it cannot be said that the appellant-plaintiffs did not acquire
any right, title and interest over the suit land. Further on
perusal of Exhibits-4 and 5, it appears that the suit land was
allotted in favour of the vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs in
view of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms Rules,
1962 not under Allotment of Land Rules 1980. Because if we
go through both the aforesaid allotment rules, it appears that
in Rule 15(1) of the Allotment of Land Rules 1962, there was
a bar that the land shall not be transferred by the allottee
within ten years from the date of Allotment without the
written consent of the Collector.
28.
Thus, it is clear that within ten years from the
date of allotment of land, there was no scope on the part of
the vendor to transfer any land to any other person. Here in
the case at hand, if we assume that the land was allotted
prior to 1980 in pursuance of the Allotment of the Land
Rules, 1962, in that case, within ten years, it was under legal
obligation by the original vendors not to transfer the suit
land within ten years. In this case, on perusal of Exhibits-1,
2 and 3, it is clear that those Title Deeds were executed in
the year 2011 i.e. long after the date of allotment of land to
the vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs.
29.
So, the findings of Learned First Appellate Court
that the vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs have violated Rule
12(1) of the Allotment of Land Rules 1980 was not correct
which cannot be legally accepted and also cannot be
sustained in the eye of law. More so, there is/was no any
contrary evidence on record that the said allotment accorded
in favour of the vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs was
cancelled at any point of time. The substantial question of
law is accordingly answered in favour of the appellantplaintiffs of this appeal.
30.
Thus, in my considered view the vendors of the
appellant-plaintiffs did not violate any provision of the
allotment rules under the Allotment of Land Rules, 1962.
Thus, the findings of the Learned First Appellate Court that
the vendors of the appellant-plaintiffs violated Rule 12(1) of
the Allotment of Land Rules 1980 was not correct and proper
and misconception of law, for which it appears that the
judgment of both the Courts below suffers from perversities
and accordingly, the interference of the Court is required.
31.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby allowed on contest. The judgment and decree dated
07.02.2022
and
17.02.2022
respectively
delivered
by
Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in connection
with case No.T.A.42 of 2017 confirming the judgment and
decree
dated
22.06.2017
and
06.07.2017
respectively
delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2,
West Tripura, Agartala in T.S.136 of 2012 is hereby set
aside. The right, title and interest and possession of the
appellant-plaintiffs over the suit land is hereby declared and
accordingly, it is confirmed. The respondent-defendants and
their men and agents are hereby restrained from entering
into the suit land permanently, until otherwise then in due
course of law.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs along with copy of the
judgment for immediate compliance.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
DATTA
Date: 2024.08.17 16:55:07
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review