The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
AB No.59 of 2024 Siddhartha Ghosh ---Appellant(s) Versus The State of Triupra ----Respondent(s) For Appellant(s) For Respondent(s) : : Mr. A. Bhaumik, Adv. Mr. Raju Datta, P.P. Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT Order 30/11/2024 This bail application under Section 483 Cr.P.C is filed for granting pre-arrest bail to the accused petitioner Sri Siddhartha Ghosh in connection with Airport PS Case No.2023 ARP 050 under Section 120(B)/447/468/471/506 of IPC. Heard Learned counsel Mr. A. Bhaumik representing the accused petitioner and also heard Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta along with Mr. R. Saha, Learned Addl. P.P. representing the staterespondents. Taking part in the hearing Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that this is the second pre-arrest bail application filed by the petitioner before this High Court and this court by order dated 25.10.2024 in connection with AB No.55 of 2024 was pleased to reject the earlier pre-arrest bail application filed by this accused-petitioner. Learned counsel at this stage submitted that in the meantime the other accused persons who were FIR named have been released on bail from the court. This petitioner being a deed writer having a good repute if at this stage is sent to custody then his entire career would be doomed. It was further submitted that on the same subject matter a civil suit is pending before t…
15. 12.2009 in Crl. A. No.2406 of 2009 reported in (2010) 1 SCC 684 wherein in para No.12, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under: “12. In our opinion, the High Court erred in not considering the application for anticipatory bail in accordance with law. The defence put forward by the appellant cannot be obliterated at this stage itself. We are also of the opinion, that the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that the dispute herein is purely of a civil nature cannot be brushed aside at this stage. We, therefore, grant anticipatory bail to the appellant in the case pending on the basis of FIR No. 107 of 2007 registered at Police Station Vidhyadhar Nagar, Jaipur City under Sections 420, 467, 468, 120-B IPC now pending only under Sections 420 and 120-B IPC. It is directed that in the event of arrest the appellant shall be released on bail to the satisfaction of the investigating officer. It is also directed that the appellant shall join investigation as and when required.” Referring the same Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that since there is a civil dispute going on amongst the rival parties so there is no scope to disallow the application filed by the petitioner at this stage. Learned counsel Mr. Bhaumik further referred another citation in Dilip Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr. dated 19.01.2021 in Crl. A. No.53 of 2021 reported in (2021) 2 unde…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
AB No.59 of 2024
Siddhartha Ghosh
---Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Triupra
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Adv.
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
Mr. R. Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
30/11/2024
This bail application under Section 483 Cr.P.C is filed for
granting pre-arrest bail to the accused petitioner Sri Siddhartha
Ghosh in connection with Airport PS Case No.2023 ARP 050 under
Section 120(B)/447/468/471/506 of IPC.
Heard Learned counsel Mr. A. Bhaumik representing the
accused petitioner and also heard Learned P.P. Mr. Raju Datta
along with Mr. R. Saha, Learned Addl. P.P. representing the staterespondents.
Taking part in the hearing Learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner submitted that this is the second pre-arrest bail
application filed by the petitioner before this High Court and this
court by order dated 25.10.2024 in connection with AB No.55 of
2024 was pleased to reject the earlier pre-arrest bail application
filed by this accused-petitioner. Learned counsel at this stage
submitted that in the meantime the other accused persons who
were FIR named have been released on bail from the court. This
petitioner being a deed writer having a good repute if at this stage
is sent to custody then his entire career would be doomed. It was
further submitted that on the same subject matter a civil suit is
pending before the Civil Court for adjudication amongst the rival
parties and in the said civil suit the present petitioner has not
been made party even the District Registrar on the allegation of
forgery has initiated a proceeding wherein the present petitioner
was asked to appear and submit his written contention and
accordingly he appeared. But no adverse order either from the
Learned Civil court or by the District Registrar has been passed
against the present petitioner. Learned counsel further submitted
that since the process of online registration as initiated so the
entire process was proceeded through online system and the
petitioner being a Deed Writer prepared the deed on the
requisition of the interested parties based on their documents.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that although the
case has been registered under Section 120(B)/447/468/471/506
of IPC but none of the aforesaid provisions is applicable against
the present petitioner and Learned counsel also submitted that
this present petitioner being a reputed person is a law abiding
person will definitely abide by the terms and conditions if bail is
granted to him and there is no chance of absconding and he will
not temper any evidence on record of the prosecution since the
case was registered about a year back. Even from the Civil Court
also there was no order passed against this present petitioner
showing his involvement with the alleged offence and he referred
few citations and urged for granting the pre-arrest bail.
Learned counsel referred one citation in Rajender alias
Rajesh alias Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi) reported in (2019)
10 SCC 623 wherein para No.10, Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“10. It is well-settled that in cases where the
prosecution relies on circumstantial evidence to
establish its case, such circumstances should be
duly proved and the chain of circumstances so
proved should be complete. This means that the
chain formed must unerringly point towards the
guilt of the accused and not leave any missing
links for the accused to escape from the clutches
of law. Further, with respect to conspiracy, it is
trite law that the existence of three elements
must be shown-a criminal object, a plan or a
scheme embodying means to accomplish that
object, and an agreement or understanding
between two or more people to cooperate for the
accomplishment of such object.”
Referring the same Learned counsel submitted that herein
the case at hand there is no circumstance showing involvement of
the accused with the alleged crime.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further referred another
citation in Ravidra Saxena v. State of Rajasthan dated
15.12.2009 in Crl. A. No.2406 of 2009 reported in (2010) 1 SCC
684 wherein in para No.12, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“12. In our opinion, the High Court erred in not
considering the application for anticipatory bail in
accordance with law. The defence put forward by
the appellant cannot be obliterated at this stage
itself. We are also of the opinion, that the
submission of the learned counsel for the
appellant that the dispute herein is purely of a
civil nature cannot be brushed aside at this stage.
We, therefore, grant anticipatory bail to the
appellant in the case pending on the basis of FIR
No. 107 of 2007 registered at Police Station
Vidhyadhar Nagar, Jaipur City under Sections
420, 467, 468, 120-B IPC now pending only under
Sections 420 and 120-B IPC. It is directed that in
the event of arrest the appellant shall be released
on bail to the satisfaction of the investigating
officer. It is also directed that the appellant shall
join investigation as and when required.”
Referring the same Learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted that since there is a civil dispute going on amongst the
rival parties so there is no scope to disallow the application filed
by the petitioner at this stage.
Learned counsel Mr. Bhaumik further referred another
citation in Dilip Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh & Anr.
dated 19.01.2021 in Crl. A. No.53 of 2021 reported in (2021) 2
SCC 779 wherein para No.4, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“4. It is well settled by a plethora of decisions of
this Court that criminal proceedings are not for
realisation of disputed dues. It is open to a court
to grant or refuse the prayer for anticipatory bail,
depending on the facts and circumstances of the
particular case. The factors to be taken into
consideration, while considering an application
for bail are the nature of accusation and the
severity of the punishment in the case of
conviction and the nature of the materials relied
upon
by
the
prosecution;
reasonable
apprehension of tampering with the witnesses or
apprehension of threat to the complainant or the
witnesses; reasonable possibility of securing the
presence of the accused at the time of trial or the
likelihood
of
his
abscondence;
character,
behaviour and standing of the accused; and the
circumstances which are peculiar or the accused
and larger interest of the public or the State and
similar other considerations. A criminal court,
exercising jurisdiction to grant bail/ anticipatory
bail, is not expected to act as a recovery agent to
realise the dues of the complainant, and that too,
without any trial.”
Referring the same Learned counsel submitted that in view
of the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court
considering the nature and gravity of the offence the petitioner
may be released on bail as prayed for.
On
the
other
hand,
Learned
P.P.
representing
the
prosecution/State strongly opposed the bail application and
submitted that this bail application is not maintainable as the
similar bail application was earlier rejected by this court as
referred by the petitioner and there is no new ground in the
present petition to consider his bail application. Learned P.P.
further submitted that the present petitioner identified a fake
person and at his instance the subsequent forged deed was
registered and he deprived the purchaser of the disputed land in
question and furthermore the report of SFSL also clearly indicates
that there was fabrication of document. He further referred few
citations in support of his contention.
In Srikant Upadhyay and Others v. State of Bihar &
Anr. dated 14.03.2024 reported in (2024) SCC OnLine SC 282
wherein para No.25, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“25. We have already held that the power to
grant anticipatory bail is an extraordinary power.
Though in many cases it was held that bail is said
to be a rule, it cannot, by any stretch of
imagination, be said that anticipatory bail is the
rule. It cannot be the rule and the question of its
grant should be left to the cautious and judicious
discretion by the Court depending on the facts
and circumstances of each case. While called
upon to exercise the said power, the Court
concerned has to be very cautious as the grant of
interim protection or protection to the accused in
serious cases may lead to miscarriage of justice
and may hamper the investigation to a great
extent as it may sometimes lead to tampering or
distraction of the evidence. We shall not be
understood to have held that the Court shall not
pass an interim protection pending consideration
of such application as the Section is destined to
safeguard the freedom of an individual against
unwarranted arrest and we say that such orders
shall be passed in eminently fit cases. At any rate,
when warrant of arrest or proclamation is issued,
the applicant is not entitled to invoke the
extraordinary power. Certainly, this will not
deprive the power of the Court to grant pre-arrest
bail in extreme, exceptional cases in the interest
of justice. But then, person(s) continuously,
defying orders and keep absconding is not
entitled to such grant.”
Referring the same Learned P.P. submitted that since in this
case on the prayer of I.O. the Learned court below has issued
warrant of arrest against him. So at this stage there is no scope to
release him on bail.
Learned P.P. referred another citation reported in Pratibha
Manchanda and Another vs. State of Haryana and Another
reported in (2023) 8 SCC 181 in para No.29 Hon’ble the
Supreme Court observed as under:
“29. Land scams in India have been a persistent
issue, involving fraudulent practices and illegal
activities related to land acquisition, ownership,
and transactions. Scammers often create fake
land titles, forge sale deeds, or manipulate land
records to show false ownership or an
encumbrancefree status. Organized criminal
networks often plan and execute these intricate
scams, exploiting vulnerable individuals and
communities, and resorting to intimidation or
threats to force them to vacate their properties.
These land scams not only result infinancial
losses for individuals and investors but also
disrupt development projects, erode public trust,
and hinder socioeconomic progress.”
Referring the same Learned P.P. Mr. Datta submitted that
considering the nature and gravity of the offence this present
anticipatory bail application has got no merit and accordingly the
same is liable to be rejected.
Considered.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused the Case
Diary produced by I.O. through Learned P.P.
It is the admitted position that earlier the similar bail
application was disallowed by this court. It is also the admitted
position that a civil dispute is going on amongst the rival parties.
It is also the admitted position that by this time the principal
accused and other accused have already been granted by bail by
the court. From the Case Diary it appears that by this time on the
prayer of I.O. warrant of arrest is issued against the present
petitioner and also it appears that at the instance of the present
petitioner the subsequent deed in question was prepared and this
petitioner identified a person who was not the original executant
of the land in question. So in view of the principle of law laid down
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court as aforesaid this court finds no
scope to consider bail application filed by the accused petitioner.
Hence, the anticipatory bail application filed stands rejected
being devoid of merit. The accused may surrender to the Learned
court below who shall dispose of the bail application if filed, in
accordance with law on merit.
Let a copy of this order be sent to I.O. through Learned P.P.
along with the case diary and also a copy of this order be
communicated to the Learned Jurisdictional Magistrate.
With this observation, this bail application stands disposed
of.
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.12.02 02:37:14
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review