The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Apparent it is that in the new provisions [after amendment] in Sub-Section 1 of Section 28 “All decrees and orders” has been substituted by “All decrees”. In SubSection 2 of Section 28 [after amendment] it has been provided that the orders made by the court in any proceeding under this Act, under Section 25 of Section 26 shall, subject to the provisions of Sub-Section 3 of Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, be appealable, if they are not interim orders. The remaining part of the said sub-Section is not relevant for our purpose. Therefore, by the amendment, all decrees made by the court in any proceeding under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, shall be appealable. But the orders passed only under Sections 25 and 26 if not in the nature of interim orders, shall as well be appealable. Thus, excluding all orders as referred in sub-section (2) of Section 28 passed in any proceeding under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 are not appealable under Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act. It is apparent that the purpose of the said amendment was to restrict appeals from all orders made by the court in a proceeding under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. Therefore, the proposition of law in Madhukar Trimbakrao Ghisad (supra) was the correct exposition of law as the said decision was taken in consideration of the preamended provisions of Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act as noted before. The decis…
28. 06.2021, this distinction was not placed before the court and hence, the court had allowed the prayer for withdrawal of CRP 33 of 2021. As the withdrawal does not create any bar for the appellant, he may file a fresh Civil Revision Petition challenging the order dated 25.03.2021 or may institute any other action as available in law. Draw the decree accordingly. Send down the LCRs.” [5] Pursuant to the liberty granted under the judgment aforesaid, petitioner-husband again approached this Court by filing this fresh civil review petition challenging the order dared 25.03.2021 passed by the learned District Judge in case No. Civil Misc. 05 of 2020. [6] Heard Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned advocate representing the respondent-wife. [7] It is not disputed by the counsel of the petitioner that monthly salary of the petitioner-husband is around Rs.50,000/including all allowances. Learned counsel submits that out of this income, the husband maintains his old and ailing mother and his 18 years’ old son besides discharging other liabilities. Counsel contends that it was also submitted before the trial Court that the respondentwife maintains illicit relationship and to pursue such relationship, she left home for Bangaluru on 14.05.2019 where she stayed for few days upto 24.05.2019. Counsel submits that the facts were als…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP 70 of 2022
Shri Shyamal Das.
……….Petitioner(s)
Vs.
Smt. Manika Majumder.
……Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Bhaumik, Adv.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
ORDER
09/12/2022
This civil revision petition has been filed by Shri Shyamal Das,
petitioner against the order dated 25.03,2021 passed by the learned
District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in case No. Civil Misc. 5 of
2020 whereby the learned District Judge has directed the petitioner
husband of Smt. Manika Majumder, respondent herein to pay a
monthly sum of Rs.15,000/- as maintenance pendente lite
under
Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act with effect from the date of
filing of the petition along with a lump sum amount of Rs.5,000/- as
litigation cost.
[2]
Being aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner-
husband initially filed an application under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India before this Court which was registered as CRP
33 of 2021. The said petition was disposed of by this Court as
withdrawn by an order dated 28.06.2021. While disposing CRP 33 of
2021 as withdrawn, it was also observed by this Court that in view of
the decision in Dulal Shil vs. Smt. Dolly Shil reported in (2015) 2
TLR 764, this Court does not have any jurisdiction to entertain the
revision petition. The petitioner was therefore, granted liberty to file
an appeal. Accordingly, the petitioner filed an appeal against the
impugned order aforesaid, which was registered as MAT. APP.05 of
2021. In the said appeal, the petitioner-husband questioned the
determination
of
the
quantum
of
maintenance
pendente
lite
inasmuch as, no specific documentary proof of income of the
petitioner-husband was submitted before the trail Court by the wife
where she was the petitioner.
[3]
In the course of hearing of Mat. App. 05 of 2021 before
this Court, Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-wife raised preliminary objection in respect of the
maintainability of the said appeal in view of Section 28(2) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
[4]
Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel representing the
appellant-husband in the said appeal, contended that pursuant to the
liberty granted by this Court in CRP 33 of 2021, the petitionerhusband filed MAT. APP. 05 of 2021 and in the judgment rendered in
MAT. APP. 05 of 2021, this Court categorically held that appellant
may file a fresh Civil Revision Petition challenging the order dated
25.03.2021 or may institute any other action as available in law. At
this juncture, it would be appropriate to reproduce the relevant
extract of the judgment passed in MAT. APP. 05 of 2021:
“…….11. Madhukar Trimbakrao Ghisad (supra) has been
referred by Ms. R. Purakayastha, learned counsel appearing
for the appellant to contend that this appeal is maintainable,
even though it challenges an order passed in a proceeding
under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act. The decisions of
Himachal Pradesh High Court and Bombay High Court are
not required to be reconciled inasmuch as both the decisions
are correct disposition of law at the relevant time. Madhukar
Trimbakrao Ghisad (supra) was pronounced on 25.07.1972
whereas Narayan Singh (supra) was pronounced on
15.06.1977. In the year 1976, by the Marriage Laws
Amendment Act, 1976 [vide Section 19] the original Section
28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 was amended. The said
amendment has caused a change which has serious
ramification in the present controversy. The un-amended
Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act provided as under:
“28. Enforcement of, and appeal from, decrees
and order. All decrees and orders made by Court in any
proceeding under this Act shall be enforced in like
manner as the decrees and order of the Court made in
the exercise of the original Civil jurisdiction are
enforced, and may be appealed from under any law for
the time being in force.
Provided that there shall be no appeal on the
subject of costs only.”
12. Apparent it is that in the new provisions [after
amendment] in Sub-Section 1 of Section 28 “All decrees and
orders” has been substituted by “All decrees”. In SubSection 2 of Section 28 [after amendment] it has been
provided that the orders made by the court in any
proceeding under this Act, under Section 25 of Section 26
shall, subject to the provisions of Sub-Section 3 of Section
28 of the Hindu Marriage Act, be appealable, if they are not
interim orders. The remaining part of the said sub-Section is
not relevant for our purpose. Therefore, by the amendment,
all decrees made by the court in any proceeding under the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, shall be appealable. But the
orders passed only under Sections 25 and 26 if not in the
nature of interim orders, shall as well be appealable. Thus,
excluding all orders as referred in sub-section (2) of Section
28 passed in any proceeding under the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955 are not appealable under Section 28 of the Hindu
Marriage Act. It is apparent that the purpose of the said
amendment was to restrict appeals from all orders made by
the court in a proceeding under the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955. Therefore, the proposition of law in Madhukar
Trimbakrao Ghisad (supra) was the correct exposition of law
as the said decision was taken in consideration of the preamended provisions of Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act
as noted before. The decision of the Himachal Pradesh High
Court is also correct exposition of law as that was taken in
the wake of the amendment as carried out in 1976. In the
present case, the order that has been challenged has been
passed in the proceeding under Section 24 of the Hindu
Marriage Act, 1955. Therefore, no appeal can be maintained
against the said order under Section 28 of the Hindu
Marriage Act. It may not be out of place to state that Section
19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984 is pari material to the
unamended section 28 of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, not with
the amended Section 28 of the said Act.
Hence, this appeal is not maintainable and accordingly
the same stands dismissed.
It appears that while passing the order dated
28.06.2021, this distinction was not placed before the court
and hence, the court had allowed the prayer for withdrawal
of CRP 33 of 2021. As the withdrawal does not create any
bar for the appellant, he may file a fresh Civil Revision
Petition challenging the order dated 25.03.2021 or may
institute any other action as available in law.
Draw the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs.”
[5]
Pursuant to the liberty granted under the judgment
aforesaid, petitioner-husband again approached this Court by filing
this fresh civil review petition challenging the order dared 25.03.2021
passed by the learned District Judge in case No. Civil Misc. 05 of
2020.
[6]
Heard Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner. Also heard Mr. A. Bhaumik, learned advocate
representing the respondent-wife.
[7]
It is not disputed by the counsel of the petitioner that
monthly salary of the petitioner-husband is around Rs.50,000/including all allowances. Learned counsel submits that out of this
income, the husband maintains his old and ailing mother and his 18
years’ old son besides discharging other liabilities. Counsel contends
that it was also submitted before the trial Court that the respondentwife maintains illicit relationship and to pursue such relationship, she
left home for Bangaluru on 14.05.2019 where she stayed for few
days upto 24.05.2019. Counsel submits that the facts were also
recorded by the trial Court in the impugned order and such conduct
of the respondent-wife led to her separation from her petitionerhusband.
[8]
The son also left the company of his mother and started
living with his father. It is therefore, contended by Ms. Purkayastha,
learned advocate that borrowing the principle from Sub-Section (4)
of Section 125 Cr.PC, the respondent-wife who is living in adultery,
shall not be entitled to receive any maintenance allowance from her
husband. Counsel further contends that for argument’s shake even if
it is conceded that respondent-wife should be given maintenance
pendente lite, a sum of Rs.15,000/- per month is too exorbitant in
view of the income and liabilities of her husband. Counsel, therefore,
urges the Court to reduce the amount to a reasonable extent.
[9]
Mr.
A.
Bhaumik,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
respondent-wife still holds the view that a revision petition against
the impugned order is not maintainable. This apart, Mr. Bhaumik,
learned counsel contends that the amount has been determined by
the trial Court after taking all relevant aspects into consideration
which should not be disturbed. According to learned counsel, even if
one-fourth of the monthly income of the petitioner-husband is given
to the wife, she will be entitled to more than Rs.15,000/-. Counsel,
therefore, urges the Court to maintain the order passed by the
learned District Judge and dismiss the challenge against it.
[10]
I have considered the submissions made by learned
counsel representing the parties. I have also perused the whole
record. The dispute between the parties centers around the quantum
of the maintenance pendente lite. It is not denied that the petitionerhusband had borrowed a loan of Rs.15 lacs for construction of their
dwelling house when his respondent-wife was with him. Towards
repayment of the loan, he is paying an EMI of Rs.21,873/-. With the
rest of his income, he is maintaining his old and ailing mother and his
18 years old son who is prosecuting his studies besides shouldering
his personal expenses. This apart, as a result of his posting in a
different station away from home, the petitioner-husband is also
paying house rent and bearing the ancillary expenses for living
outside home.
[11]
In these circumstances, the pendente lite maintenance
allowance determined by the trial Court should be reduced. In the
given circumstances of the case, this Court is of the view that a
monthly sum of Rs.8,000/- towards pendente lite maintenance for
the respondent-wife would be the appropriate amount. The amount
determined by the trial Court is therefore reduced to Rs.8,000/- per
month from Rs.15,000/- per month. There shall be no change in the
amount of litigation cost. The petitioner-husband is therefore directed
to pay a sum of Rs.8,000/- per month to his respondent-wife as
maintenance pendente lite under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage
Act with effect from the date of filing of the petition before the trial
Court. He will also pay a sum of Rs.5,000/- litigation cost to his wife
as ordered by the trial Court. As agreed, the petitioner is given
liberty to pay the arrear together or in ten equated monthly
installments by transferring the same to the individual bank account
of his wife or by any other mode as the parties may settle.
In terms of the above, the revision petition stands disposed of.
Interim order(s), if any, stands vacated.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review