Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No. 1/15
GAHC010202132016
2026:GAU-AS:9268
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Intest.Cas./2/2016
SRI SHIBU THAKUR
S/O LATE JOTAI THAKUR, R/O BARPETA ROAD TOWN, WARD NO. 2, P.O.
BARPETA ROAD,MOUZA GOBARDHANA, DIST. BARPETA, ASSAM.
VERSUS
KANTI DEVI
W/O SRI PREM THAKUR
2.1:ON THE DEATH OF DILIP THAKUR
HIS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES/HEIRS REEMA THAKUR
W/O LATE DILIP THAKUR
2.2:SUBHAM THAKUR
S/O LATE DILIP THAKUR
2.3:DEV THAKUR
S/O LATE DILIP THAKUR
RESPONDENT No. 2.2 AND 2.3 & MINOR
REPRESENTED BY THEIR MOTHER
RESPONDENT No. 2.1.
ALL ARE RESIDENT OF BARPETA TOWN
WARD NO.2
P.O BARPETA ROAD
MOUZA - GOBARDHANA
DISTRICT - BARPETA
ASSAM
Page No. 2/15
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
: Mr. N. Haque, Advocate
For the Appellant
For the Respondents : Mr. S. K. Ghosh, Advocate
Date of Hearing
: 07.04.2026
Date of Judgment
: 22.06.2026
JUDGMENT
1.
Heard Mr. N. Haque, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Mr.
S. K. Ghosh, the learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
This appeal under Section 299 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925,
has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 4/8/2015, passed by
the Court of learned District Judge, Barpeta in Title Suit (P) No. 1/2012,
whereby the probate in respect of Will executed by late Jotai Thakur was
granted in favour of the respondents.
3.
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant appeal, in brief, are
that the present respondents along with one Ganesh Thakur, approached the
Court of learned District Judge Barpeta, by filing an application under Section
276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 for grant of probate of the will executed
by late Jotai Thakur, who had expired on 4/5/2010. It was contended by the
respondents before the Probate Court that the deceased Jotai Thakur executed
his last will bequeathing a plot of land measuring 2 kathas, 10 lechas out of
total land of 3 bighas, 4 kathas 6 lechas, covered by Dag No. 539 under Periodic
Page No. 3/15
Patta number 400 of Village-Barpeta Road Town, at Ward No. 2, MouzaGobardhana the district of Barpeta, in favour of the present respondents and
the Ganesh Thakur. It was also contended that the last will executed by the
deceased Jotai Thakur was also registered before the Office of Sub-Registrar,
Sarbhog. It is pertinent to mention herein that at the time of filing of the
application under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act before the Probate
Court, the original will was not submitted along with the petition, and it was
mentioned in the application itself that since the original will, i.e. Will No.
296/2010 dated 17/04/2010, was lying in the Office of Sub-Registrar, Sarbhog at
the time of filing of the aforesaid petition, same could not be annexed along
with the probate application.
4.
After receipt of the notice, Shibu Thakur (present appellant) and
Prem Thakur filed a written objection taking general defence like belated filing
of the application under Section 276 after more than 2 years of the execution of
the said will and certain other general defences. The opposite parties also
contended that they being Class 1 heirs of the deceased Jotai Thakur, cannot be
debarred from inheriting the properties left by Jotai Thakur after his death. On
the basis of Pleadings of both the parties, the Probate Court framed following
issues:
i) Whether there is any cause of action for this case,
instituted by the petitioners for grant of probate of will?
ii) Whether the petitioners can be the executors of the
purported will by excluding the opposite parties who are the
class-1 heirs of deceased being his sons?
iii) Whether the petitioners are entitled to get probate of will
as prayed for?
5.
In support of their respective cases, the petitioners (present
Page No. 4/15
respondents) adduced evidence of 6 (six) witnesses, whereas, the opposite
parties (appellant) adduced evidence of only 1 (one) DW. Both the parties
exhibited certain documents as documentary evidence. However, ultimately, by
judgment and order dated 4th August 2015, passed in Title Suit (Probate) No.
1/2012, the Court of learned Additional District Judge (FTC), Barpeta, granted
probate of the Will of late Jotai Thakur in favor of the present respondents,
namely Smti Kanti Devi and Dilip Thakur only, since, during the pendency of the
Probate case, the other petitioner namely, Ganesh Thakur had expired. The
aforesaid judgment and order passed by the Probate Court has been impugned
in this appeal.
6.
Mr. N. Haque, the learned counsel for the appellant has submitted
that the trial court erred in granting the probate in favor of the respondents
without taking into consideration that even the original Will was not exhibited by
the respondents before the Probate Court during the probate proceeding. He
submits that it is only the certified copy of the will, which was exhibited as
Exhibit-2 in the probate case. He also submits that before exhibiting the certified
copy of the will, the respondents have failed to satisfy the Court that the
circumstances mentioned in Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act, existed to
justify adducing of secondary evidence (in the form of certified copy of the will)
by the respondents. He submits that unless the respondents were able to show
that the Provisions of Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act were complied with,
they could not have been permitted to adduce secondary evidence in the
probate proceeding and the Probate Court erred in relying on the secondary
evidence without the original Will being exhibited in the aforesaid proceeding. In
support of his submission, the learned counsel for the appellant has cited a
ruling of the Apex Court in the case of “H. Siddiqui (dead) by Lrs. –vs- A.
Page No. 5/15
Ramalingam” reported in “2011 (4) SCC 240”.
7.
The learned counsel for the appellant has also submitted that in filing
the application under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 by the
respondents there has been non-compliance of the provision of Section 281 of
the Indian Succession Act, inasmuch as, the Probate application was not verified
by any of the attesting witness to the willas required by the aforesaid statutory
provision. He submits that since the provisions contained in Section 281 of the
Indian Succession Act, 1925 is mandatory in nature, any violation of same could
not have been ignored by the trial court, and thus the trial court had erred in
granting the probate in favor of the respondents by overlooking the violation of
a mandatory requirement as contained in Section 281 of the said Act.
8.
He further submits that As per Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925, it is mandatorily required that the Will has to be attested by at least 2
attesting witnesses, who have seen the testator signing or affixing his
signatures to the will and such signatures have to be put on the will in presence
of the executor by the such witnesses. However, he submits that the attesting
witness examined by the respondents as PWs (more specifically PW-3 and PW4) have deposed that they have only seen the deceased Jotai Thakur executing
the purported Will.
9.
He also submits that the attestation of the Will could not be proved
within the meaning of Section 63(c) of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 or
Section 3 of the Transfer of Properties Act, 1882, by the respondents and the
trial court had erred in granting Probate to the present respondents. In support
of his submission, he has cited following rulings:
(i) “Kashibai –vs- Parwatibai” reported in“(1995) 6 SCC 213”
Page No. 6/15
(ii)“Lalitaben Jayantilal Popat -Vs- Pragnaben Jamnadas Kataria & Ors.”
reported in “2008 (15) SCC 365”
(iii)“Nagulapati Lakshmamma –Vs- Mupparaju Subbaiah ” reported in “AIR
1998 SC 2904”.
10.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the will was
executed on 16/4/2010 and same was registered on 17/4/2010 and thereafter,
within 17 days, i.e. on 4/5/2010, the testator died. He submits the noncompliance of the statutory requirements by the respondents in filing their
application under Section 276 of Indian Succession Act creates suspicion and
serious doubt regarding the genuineness of the will which the respondents have
failed to remove by adducing reliable witnesses. As such, he submits that the
impugned judgment of the Probate Court, may be set aside and this appeal may
be allowed.
11.
On the other hand, Mr. S. K. Ghosh, the learned counsel for the
respondents submits that there is no illegality or infirmity in the impugned
judgment and the trial court correctly granted the probate in respect of the last
will of the deceased, Jotai Thakur in favor of the present respondents after
considering materials on record as well as evidence adduced by the present
respondents in the said proceedings.
12.
He submits that as at the time of filing of the Probate Application
under Section 276 of the Indian Succession Act before the Court of learned
District Judge, Barpeta, the original Will was not in possession of the present
respondents, asthe same was at that point of time still lying in the office of the
Sub-Registrar, Sarbhog, hence, the same could not be submitted at the time of
filing the probate case. He further submits that the mention about the said fact
Page No. 7/15
has been made in the Probate Application filed by the present respondent. He
further submits that at the time of adducing of evidence by the witnesses of the
petitioner (present respondents) before the Probate Court, since the original Will
was not in possession of the present respondents, they could not exhibit the
said will, and instead, they produced a certified copy of the will dated 17-4-2010
which was exhibited before the Trial Court. He submits that the respondents
have later on filed a petition before the Trial Court bearing Petition No.
319/2015, praying for allowing the present respondents to submit the original
Will before the court and the said application was allowed by the probate court
by its order dated 29/04/2015.
13.
The learned counsel for the respondents has submitted that the said
order was passed by the Probate Court under Section 267 of the Indian
Succession Act, 1925 which empowers the District Judge to order production of
original testamentary papers. He also submits that the Will, which was
registered on 17/4/2010, was attested by four attesting witnesses, out of whom,
two attesting witnesses, namely Sanjay Shah Sonar was examined by the Trial
Court on 31/7/2013, whereas, another attesting witness namely Nikunja Das
was examined as PW-3 on 11/7/2013. He submits that both the attesting
witnesses have categorically deposed before the trial court that they have seen
execution of the aforesaid will by the deceased Jotai Thakur, apart from the
aforesaid witnesses, one other attesting witness Ram Niwas Mishra was also
examined by the respondent as PW-4.
14.
He further submits that the 4th attesting witness, namely Shankar
Prasad Shah, also deposed that he has seen the deceased Jotai Thakur
executing the aforesaid Will. He also submits that the attesting witness not only
deposed regarding execution of the will by deceased Jotai Thakur, but they have
Page No. 8/15
also deposed that they have seen other attesting witnesses putting their
signatures on the saidWill.
15.
The learned counsel for the respondents further submits that the
procedural requirement of verification by at least one witness to Will, as
provided under Section 281 of the Indian Succession Act, is not mandatory and
same may be regarded as a directory provision, more so, when the attesting
witnesses have been examined by the respondents as petitioner's witnesses
before the Probate Court.
16.
The learned counsel for the respondents also submits that the present
appellant never raised any objection regarding non-compliance of the
requirement of Section 281 of the Indian Succession Act before the Trial Court
in their written objection. Hence, they are stopped from taking the said
objection at this appellate stage. He further submits that the appellant never
raised any doubt regarding genuineness of the Will before the Probate Court.
They only prayed for not granting the probate mainly on the ground that the
appellant being Class-I heir of the deceased, Jotai Thakur, cannot be deprived of
their ancestral property.
17.
He further submits that the prime duty of the Probate Court is to
ascertain the genuineness of the Will, of which probate is sought for. However,
the present appellant neither in their written objection nor while adducing
evidence by the present respondents, before the trial court, have raised any
such objection. Nor they have adduced any evidence suspecting genuineness of
the aforesaid Will. He, therefore, submits that the appeal filed by the present
appellant lacks merit and same may be dismissed.
18.
I have considered the submissions made by the counsel for both sides
Page No. 9/15
and have gone through the materials available on record. I have also gone
through the rulings cited by the learned counsel for the appellant in support of
his submission.
19.
Following points are required to be determined in this appeal:A. Whether the Probate Court was right in granting probate without the
probate application being verified by one of the attesting witnesses as
required under Section 281 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925.
B. Whether the probate court was right in accepting the probate
application without same being annexed along with the original copy of
the will and accepting the certified copy of the will without the petitioner
satisfying the requirement of Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act.
C. Whether the Probate Court was right in coming to the finding that the
execution of the will and attestation thereof by the independent witnesses
have been duly proved.
D. Whether the Probate Court was right in granting the probate of the will
which was registered on 17.04.2010.
20.
As regards the compliance of Section 281 of the Indian Succession
Act, 1925 is concerned a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in the case of “ Bikash
Chandra Prodhani Vs.On the death of Bhupesh Prodhani His legal heir Swapna
Prodhani” reported in “2025 0 Supreme (Gau) 601” has held that the said
provisions are directory in nature. This Court is in agreement with the
observation made by the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court. More so, when the
present appellant have not raised the objection as regards the non-compliance
of the provisions contained in Section 281 of the aforesaid Act in their written
statement. Further, as the petitioner (respondents) have adduced evidence of all
Page No. 10/15
the four attesting witnesses in the probate proceedings, non-compliance of the
provisions contained in Section 281 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 would
not vitiate the proceedings and same shall have to regarded as directory in
nature.
21.
As regards the second point for determination is concerned, i.e.,
whether the Probate Court was right in accepting the probate application
without the original will annexed with the same, the scheme of Indian
Succession Act, 1925, in Chapter-II of Part- IX of this aforesaid Act, provides for
certain circumstances in Sections 237 to 240 of the aforesaid Act, where even a
copy of the will may be presented along with the application till the original is
produced before the Court. Under the provisions contained in Sections 237 to
240 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 probate may be granted even on the
copy of the original will till the original is produced before the court. The reason
for non-production of the original will before the Court at the timing of filing of
the probate application has been mentioned in the probate petition itself, i.e.,
the original will bearing No. 296/2010 dated 17.04.2010 was with the Office of
Sub-Registrar, Sarbhog and same was not delivered to the petitioner at the time
of the filing of the probate case.Hence, the original will could not be annexed
along with the probate application. The circumstances shown by the petitioner
for not filing the original will along with the probate application are acceptable
and the trial court did no wrong in accepting the certified copy of the original
will under the facts and circumstances of the case. It also appears from the
records of Title Suit No.1/2012 that on 29.04.2015 the respondents submitted
the original will before the Court and the said fact was reflected in the order
dated 29.04.2015.
22.
Though, under certain circumstances as provided in Chapter-II of Part-
Page No. 11/15
IX of the Indian Succession Act, 1925, an application for grant of probate may
be filed even without producing the original copy of the will. However, if the said
copy (it may be a certified copy) is sought to be proved as documentary
evidence, there remains no dispute that same being secondary evidence, the
requirement of Section 65 of the Indian Evidence Act has to be followed before
any such evidence may be admitted.
23.
In this regards, the observations made by the Supreme Court of India
in the case of “H. Siddiqui (Dead) by Lrs. Vs. A. Ramalingam” reported in “(2011)
4 SCC 240” are relevant: “12. The provisions of Section 65 of the 1872 Act provide for permitting the
parties to adduce secondary evidence. However, such a course is subject to a
large number of limitations. In a case where the original documents are not
produced at any time, nor has any factual foundation been laid for giving
secondary evidence, it is not permissible for the court to allow a party to adduce
secondary evidence. Thus, secondary evidence relating to the contents of a
document is inadmissible, until the non-production of the original is accounted
for, so as to bring it within one or other of the cases provided for in the section.
The secondary evidence must be authenticated by foundational evidence that the
alleged copy is in fact a true copy of the original. Mere admission of a document
in evidence does not amount to its proof. Therefore, the documentary evidence is
required to be proved in accordance with law. The court has an obligation to
decide the question of admissibility of a document in secondary evidence before
making endorsement thereon. (Vide Roman Catholic Mission v. State of
Madras [AIR 1966 SC 1457] , State of Rajasthan v. Khemraj [(2000) 9 SCC 241 :
AIR 2000 SC 1759] , LIC v. Ram Pal Singh Bisen [(2010) 4 SCC 491 : (2010) 1
SCC (L&S) 1072 : (2010) 2 SCC (Civ) 191] and M. Chandra v. M.
Thangamuthu [(2010) 9 SCC 712 : (2010) 3 SCC (Civ) 907] .)”
24.
In the instant case, the respondents have not adduced any evidence
before the Probate Court as to why the original will could not be produced before it
at the time of examination of witnesses. Further, after the original will was
produced by the petitioner before the Probate Court, no leave was sought or
nothing was done by the respondents to bring the same on record by exhibiting it
Page No. 12/15
and confronting it to the witnesses. Even same was not confronted to the attesting
witnesses to prove their signatures on the original will. Same was required as the
certified copy of the will which was exhibited as Exhibit-2 did not bear the
signature in original of the attesting witnesses. The documentary evidence is
required to be proved in accordance with law. Mere admission of a document in
evidence and marking the same as Exhibit does not amount to proof thereof. The
court has an obligation to decide the question of admissibility of a document in
secondary evidence before acting on the said document.
25.
In the instant case, though the certified copy of the will was exhibited as
Exhibit-2, however, the circumstances which necessitated the production of
certified copy as secondary evidence was not brought on record in evidence by any
of the witnesses. Moreover, though the original will was also produced before the
Probate Court, however, it was merely submitted along with an application and it
was not exhibited by any of the witnesses neither it was confronted to any of the
witnesses. As such, the signature appearing in the will as well as the will itself
cannot be said to have been proved. The second point for determination is
accordingly decided.
26.
As regards the third point for determination is concerned, Section 63 of
the Indian Succession Act, 1925 provides as follows:-
“63. Execution of unprivileged Wills.—
Every testator, not being a soldier employed in an expedition or engaged in actual
warfare, or an airman so employed or engaged, or a mariner at sea, shall
execute his Will according to the following rules:—
(a) The testator shall sign or shall affix his mark to the Will, or it shall be
signed by some other person in his presence and by his direction.
(b) The signature or mark of the testator, or the signature of the person
signing for him, shall be so placed that it shall appear that it was intended
thereby to give effect to the writing as a Will.
(c)The Will shall be attested by two or more witnesses, each of whom has
seen the testator sign or affix his mark to the Will or has seen some other
person sign the Will, in the presence and by the direction of the testator,
Page No. 13/15
or has received from the testator a personal acknowledgement of his
signature or mark, or the signature of such other person; and each of the
witnesses shall sign the Will in the presence of the testator, but it shall not
be necessary that more than one witness be present at the same time,
and no particular form of attestation shall be necessary.”
27.
On perusal of the aforesaid provision, it appears that for proving the
attestation of the will by two or more witnesses, it is required that evidence should
indicate that each of the attesting witnesses has seen the testator sign or affix his
mark to the will or has seen some other person sign the will in the presence and by
the direction of the testator or has received from the testator a personal
acknowledgement that his signature or mark or the signature of such other person.
28.
In addition to above, it is also required tobe established by evidence that
each of the attesting witnesses has signed the will in the presence of the testator,
though it shall not be necessary that more than one witness be present at the
same time and no particular form of attestation shall be necessary.
29.
Similar is the meaning given to the phrase “attested” in relation to an
instrument in Section 3 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, which provides as
follows:-
“3. Interpretation clause.—In this Act, unless there is something repugnant in the
subject or context,—
……………..
“attested”, in relation to an instrument, means and shall be deemed always to have
meant attested by two or more witnesses each of whom has seen the executant sign
or affix his mark to the instrument, or has seen some other person sign the instrument
in the presence and by the direction of the executant, or has received from the
executant a personal acknowledgement of his signature or mark, or of the signature of
such other person, and each of whom has signed the instrument in the presence of
the executant; but it shall not be necessary that more than one of such witnesses shall
have been present at the same time, and no particular form of attestation shall be
necessary;
30.
From above, it appears that apart from proving that the attesting witness
Page No. 14/15
has seen the testator signing or affixing his mark to the instrument what is further
required is that each of the attesting witnesses has signed the will in presence of
the testator.
31.
In the instant case on perusal of the testimony of witnesses for the
respondents’ side, it appears that though there were four attesting witnesses to the
will in question and though all the four attesting witnesses were examined as
witnesses for the petitioners (present respondents), however, none of the witness
has specifically deposed that they have signed on the will in presence of the
testator. All of them have deposed that at the time of execution of the deed of will
they were present. However, there is no evidence to suggest that at the time when
they put their signature on the deed of will, it was done in presence of the testator,
which is an essential ingredient for proving of the due attestation of a will by the
attesting witnesses.
32.
In the instant case, though four attesting witnesses were examined by
the present respondents side before the probate Court, however, they fell short of
giving evidence regarding due attestation of will inasmuch as they failed to depose
that they have signed on the deed of will in presence of the testator. Since, the
consequence of grant of probate of a will may, in some cases, result into
deprivation of a due share to the natural heir of the testator, the probate has to be
granted only upon satisfactory proving of the fact of attestation of the will as
required by law and in this case, the respondents have failed to do so.
33.
This Court is of considered opinion that the attesting witnesses have
failed to satisfy due attestation of the will within the meaning of Section 65 (C) of
the Indian Succession Act, 1925 read with Section 3 of the Transfer of Property
Act, 1882.
Page No. 15/15
34.
In view of the discussions made and reasons stated in the foregoing
paragraphs, the impugned judgment cannot be sustained. Accordingly, same is set
aside.
35.
The appeal is allowed.
36.
However, in the facts and circumstances of this case, there shall be no
orders as to cost, the parties shall bear their own costs.
37.
Let the records of the trial court be sent back to the trial court along with
a copy of this judgment.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review