Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 19 of 2023
1. Sri Sekhar Chandra Das
son of Late Anil Chandra Das,
Proprietor of M/S Sekhar Chandra Das
2. Sri Janmejoy Das,
son of Late Anil Chandra Das,
care of Sri Sekhar Chandra Das,
both are resident of Village,
P.O. & P.S. Panisagar,
District-North Tripura, PIN-799260
Versus
----Appellant(s)
1. Smt. Nandita Debnath,
wife of Late Ranjit Debnath
2. Sri Ratnajit Debnath (Minor),
son of Late Ranjit Debnath
(represented by his natural guardian mother
Smt. Nandita Debnath, respondent plaintiff No.1)
both are resident of Village-P.O.& P.S. Panisagar,
District-North Tripura, PIN-799260
----Respondent(s)
_______________________________________________
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Saha, Adv.
Mrs. R. Purkayastha, Adv.
Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Mr. S. Noatia, Adv.
03.09.2024
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
12.09.2024
Whether fit for reporting:
YES
___________________________________________________
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred under Section 96 read with Order 41 Rule
1 of CPC challenging the judgment dated 26.03.2019 and decree dated
28.03.2019 delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar in connection with Case No.M.S.06 of 2017. By the said
Judgment, the Learned trial Court below has awarded compensation
amounting to Rs. 7,42,831/- and Rs 40,018/- as cost of the suit in favour of
the plaintiffs
[2]
Heard Mr. R. Saha, Learned counsel appearing for the appellant
defendants as well as Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel appearing
for the respondent-plaintiffs.
[3]
Before proceeding with the merit of the appeal, let us discuss
about the subject matter of the suit filed by the respondent-plaintiffs before
the Learned Court below. The respondent as plaintiffs before the Court of
Learned Civil Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar filed one suit for granting a
decree of damage and for compensation. The crux of the suit filed by the
plaintiffs was in short is that the husband of the plaintiff No.1 le. the
predecessor in interest was the teacher of Ananda Marga Primary School,
Panisagar which was a private school run by a committee as per norms of
the committee. According to the plaintiffs, while working as a teacher in the
said school, the deceased husband of the plaintiff No.1 was entrusted with
some of the extension and renovation work of the said school and
accordingly, on 17.06.2016 he went to the shop of the defendant No.1 1.e.
the appellant herein at Panisagar bazaar for purchasing of some GCI sheets
for the purpose of said school. While said Sekhar Chandra Das ie. the
defendant No.1 was going to take out the tin (GCI sheet) from the stack
inside the shop premises, then all on a sudden, the bundle of tins stack had
down upon the body of the deceased Ranjit Debnath and the predecessor in
interest of the plaintiffs was went under the bundle of GCI sheets and the
deceased received serious injury on his person.
[4]
It was further submitted that the defendants along with other
workers with shabal and other instruments tried to bring out the injured
from the bundles of tin which caused more injuries upon the person of said
Ranjit Debnath without seeking any help from the nearby shop owners and
thereafter, they took the injured to the Panisagar Hospital without informing
any relatives of said Ranjit Debnath and from where he was referred to
Kailashahar District Hospital and as his condition was critical, so the doctor
referred him to G.B. Hospital at Agartala. On 18.06.2016, he was admitted
in ILS Hospital but the cost of ILS Hospital was very much expensive so it
was not possible on their part to arrange for his treatment keeping under
ventilation support in the said hospital due to their financial stringency.
Thereafter, when said Ranjit Debnath was taken back to Panisagar, that time
on the way near Panisagar his condition became deteriorated and he was
taken to Panisagar Hospital accordingly when the doctor declared him as
dead. According to the plaintiffs, Ranjit Debnath expired in between 10.30
a.m./11.00 a.m.
[5]
The plaintiffs further submitted that the Doctor of Panisagar
Hospital informed the matter to Panisagar Police Station and accordingly, the
Panisagar Police Station registered one Case vide PNS PS U/D Case No. 2016
PNS 010 under Section 174 of Cr. P.C. According to the plaintiff the accident
occurred due to the fault of the defendants and it was occurred inside the
shop of the defendants where he stacked the GCI sheets in a horizontal
position carelessly without any system and support and when the deceased
tried to bring out the samples of tin sheets the bundle fell down him. It was
further asserted by the plaintiffs that the injury occurred due to wrongful
act, neglect and default on the part of shop owners. Moreover, the
defendants negligently and carelessly without informing to the nearby show
owners and people tried to drag out him from the bundle of GCI sheets using
shabal and thus, he sustained additional injuries on his person. According to
the plaintiffs to conceal the illegal activities of the defendants, they did not
call upon anybody for which Ranjit Debnath succumbed to his injuries.
[6]
As already stated, the deceased was a teacher of Ananda Marga
Primary School, Panisagar and he used to get salary at the rate of Rs.
7,700/- per month and from private tuition he also used to earn Rs.
10,000/- per month and thus, his total income per month was Rs 17,700/and by that income, he used to maintain his family consisting of three
members. At the time of death, the age of the deceased was 51 years and
due to that incident, the plaintiff No.1 lost her husband and the plaintiff No.2
lost his father So, the plaintiffs filed the suit due to premature death of their
predecessor in interest for a decree of realization of money amounting to
Rs.49,78,000/- with interest at the rate of Rs.18% p.a. w.e.f. 18.06.2016 till
realization.
[7]
The defendants i.e. the appellants herein contested the suit by
filing written statement denying the entire assertions of the plaintiffs.
According to them, there was no negligence and fault on the part of the
defendants in connection with the said incident inside the shop premises of
the defendant No. 1. It was submitted that at that time, the defendant No. 1
was busy with nearby shop owners for some important discussions. That
time, the answering defendants requested him to wait for a while but the
customer was in a hurried mode and on his own way wanted to see the
quality of GCI sheet and entered into the store room. He tried to pull out one
of the GCI sheet from the bundle from upper rack of the store room and
thus, the entire bundle of GCI sheet fell upon him on the head of the said
customer and thus, he sustained injury and cried out in a big sound. The
defendant No.1 rushed to the spot from nearby shop and shifted the injured
at once to the Panisagar hospital with the help of others. As the condition of
the customer was serious, so he was shifted to ILS Hospital, Agartala and
succumbed to his injury and on humanitarian ground the defendants paid
transportation cost for shifting the injured to the hospital and they also paid
Rs. 2,00,000/- to the wife of the deceased namely Smt. Nandita Debnath for
performing shradha/funeral ceremony on humanitarian ground and the
answering defendants denied the liability to give any compensation because
the post mortem examination report established that the death was occurred
due to accident and they had no negligence. Finally, they submitted that the
police enquiry ended in final report and due to filling of the suit, their public
image was lost in the eye of local people along with their reputation. So, the
defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit with exemplary costs.
[8]
Upon the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were
framed by the Trial Court :
ISSUES
(i) Whether the suit is maintainable ?
(ii) Whether defendants No.1 & 2 were the owners of a shop
of tine sheets at Panisagar market?
(iii) Whether on 17.06.2016 at 3 p.m. Ranjit Debnath
(deceased) went to the shop of defendants at Panisagar
market to purchase tin for his school?
(iv) Whether on the relevant date, time and place defendants
were negligent in keeping the tin sheets in their shop ?
(v) Whether on the relevant date, time and place Ranjit
Debnath sustained severe injuries due to any rash and
negligent act of defendants?
(vi) Whether on 18.06.2016 Ranjit Debnath succumbed to his
injuries received due to the negligent act of defendants ?
(vii) Whether Ranjit Debnath was earning monthly income of
Rs.17,700/-on the relevant date of incident?
(viii) Whether defendants paid Rs.2 lacs to the plaintiff No.1
during the feneral ceremony of deceased Ranjit Debnath ?
(ix) Whether plaintiffs entitled to get compensation of
Rs.49,78,000/- along with interest 18% per annum w.e.f.
18.06.2016 from defendants?
(x) Whether defendant suffered any legal injury due to loss of
good will and reputation of their business and they are
entitled to get compensation of Rs.50 lacs?”
[9]
In order to prove the case, the plaintiffs have adduced 6(six)
numbers of witnesses and relied upon some documents which were marked
as Exhibits in the suit and the defendants have adduced one witness and
relied upon some documents which were also marked as Exhibits:
(A)Witnesses of the Plaintiffs:
1) P.W.1, Smt. Nandita Debnath
2) P.W.2, Sri Pranab Debnath
3) P.W.3, Smt. Shila Nath
4) PW.4, Samiran Deb
5) PW.5, Sri Anil Das
6) P.W.6, Sri Mnindra Chandra Das
(B) Plaintiffs Exhibit :1. Exibt.1- Original Power of Attorney of Sl. No. 10092 dated
30.09.2011 Certified copy of post mortem report dated
20.06.2016 (2 sheets).
2. Exbt.2- Original discharge summary report along with other
documents including examination report, medical expenses
prescription etc.(12 pages).
3. Exbt.3- Copy of death certificate of Ranjit Detinath
(C) Witnesses of the Defendant :
1) DW-1, Sri Sekhar Chandra Das
(D) Defendant's Exhibits:
1) Exbt.A- Medical report regarding cause of death.
2) Exbt. B-Police report and surothal report.
[10]
Finally, on conclusion of trial, Learned Court below decreed the
suit in favour of the plaintiffs, le the respondents herein, For the sake
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the operative portion of the
Judgment and order of the Learned Trial Court dated 26.03.2019 which runs
as follows:
"In the result, the suit stands decreed on contest with cost.
Plaintiffs have been able to prove the sheer negligence by
shop owners on the alleged day and time. There was lack of
preventive measures to place the GCI tins in the shop in
horizontal position in a dangerous condition prone to accident.
The defendants owed to Ranjit Debnath a specific legal duty to
take care, of which they had made a breach and so they are
liable to pay compensation to the plaintiffs who are legal heirs
of deceased.
We can award the pecuniary loss in favour of plaintiffs would
be Rs.5 lakhs. We also can award the medical expenses equal
to Rs.36,831/- The conveyance expenses/transportation cost
from Panisagar to Kailashahar and Kailashahar to Agartala
and return journey will be Rs.6,000/-. We can award the loss
of consortium due to the untimely death of Ranjit Debnath as
Rs.1 lakh. There will be certainly loss of love and affection by
the wife and son of the deceased and it will be Rs.1 lakh. The
medical expenses are awarded considering the bills of hospital
reflected in Exbt.2 series.
Thus,
in
total
plaintiffs
are
entitled
to
get
compensation/damage from the defendants for a sum of
money of Rs.5 lakh + 36.831/- + 6,000 + 1 lakh 1 lakh =
Rs.7,42,831/.
No
award
is
given
to
the
funeral
expenses/sharadh ceremony because defendants already paid
Rs.2 lakhs in this respect to the wife of the deceased and it
was not disputed by the plaintiff side.
This suit accordingly stands decreed on contest with cost.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Enter the result in Trial Register."
[11]
In course of hearing of argument, Mr. R. Saha, Learned counsel
appearing for the appellants submitted that the suit was not maintainable
the Learned Trial Court under the Fatal Accident Act because there was no
willful negligence on the part of the contesting defendants i.e. the appellants
herein for the alleged incident but the Learned Court without appreciating
the legal position has granted the decree in favour of the plaintiffs le the
respondents herein. It was further submitted by the Learned counsel for the
appellants that under the Fatal Accident Act compensation can be awarded
only against any statutory authority, not against any private individual.
Furthermore, Learned counsel for the appellants drawn the attention of the
Court referring para-4 of the examination-in-chief in affidavit of PW-1, Smt.
Nandita Debnath and submitted that the deceased himself attributed to the
negligence without adhering to the request of the defendant No.1 i.e. the
appellant No.1 herein and thus, the accident took place for which the
defendants were in no way involved with the alleged incident. Furthermore,
Learned counsel for the appellants again drawn the attention of the Court
referring para Nos.6 & 7 of the examination-in-chief in affidavit of the said
witness and submitted that ignoring the advice of the Medical Officer, the
respondents arranged for release of the deceased victim from the ILS
Hospital and on the way, he expired and as such, they were totally
responsible for the alleged incident.
[12]
Learned counsel for the appellants further drawn the attention of
the Court referring the discharge summary (Exbt.2 series) wherein the
concerned hospital observed as follows:
"Poor prognosis of the patient was explained to the
attendants and need for hospital stay and ventilator support.
However, attendants are not willing to continue the treatment
over here. So, he is being discharged against medical advice
(DAMA)."
Referring the said observation, Learned counsel for the appellants
submitted that had the victim be admitted in the hospital, in that case, there
was every possibility of his survival but the family members did not adhere
to the advice of the Medical Officer, rather they of their own accord arranged
for his release and on the way he expired.
[13]
It was further submitted that before the Learned Trial Court, the
plaintiffs Le the respondents herein both by adducing oral/ documentary
evidence on record failed to establish that due negligence of the defendants
e. the appellants herein the incident took place and as such, the judgment of
the Learned Trial Court suffers from infirmities and urged for allowing this
appeal by setting aside the judgment and decree of Learned Trial Court.
[14]
On the other hand, Mr. Sankar Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel
appearing for the respondent-plaintiffs submitted that before the Learned
Trial Court there was no such defence from the side of the appellants herein
to brush aside the story of negligence because the defendant-appellants by
the act of cross-examination of the witnesses of the plaintiffs could not raise
any doubt to disbelieve the story of the plaintiffs and finally, on conclusion of
trial, Learned Trial Court after considering all the aspects rightly and
reasonably delivered the judgment in favour of the appellants for which
there is no scope to interfere with the judgment of the Learned Trial Court
and urged for dismissal of this appeal with costs.
[15]
Admittedly, there is no dispute on record regarding death of the
deceased on the alleged day i.e. on 18.06.2016 and also regarding the fact
of sustaining injury by the deceased victim due to sudden falling of GCI
sheets over his body inside the shop of the defendant No.1 l.e. the appellant
No.1 herein.
[16]
In course of hearing of arguments both the sides have referred
few citations which would be discussed accordingly.
[17]
Now, to elucidate the truth, let us discuss about the evidence on
record of the parties before the Learned Trial Court. As already stated, to
substantiate the issues both the parties have adduced oral/documentary
evidence on record. The plaintiffs as already stated have adduced 6(six)
numbers of witnesses.
[18]
PW-1. Smt. Nandita Debnath in her examination-in-chief in
affidavit in paras Nos.3 to 9 have mentioned the following facts:
"3. That, my husband Late Ranjit Debnath here in after called
predecessor in interest was the Teacher in Ananda Marg
Primary School situated at Panisagar and it was a private
School is being run by a committee as per rules and norms of
the committee.
My husband Late Ranjit Debnath joined in service of said
Ananda Marg Primary School in short School on 01-03-1988
and had been continuing in service till his death on 16-062016 and prior to his death he was drawing salary of
Rs.7,700/- (Rupees seven thousand seven hundred) only per
month increasable time to time as per norms of said School.
4. That, while he was working as teacher in the said School he
was entrusted with some of the extension and renovation
work of the School and accordingly he on 17-06-2016 at about
3 p.m. went to the shop of the defendant No.1 Sekhar Chandra
Das at Panisagar bazar for purchasing tin for the School.
Sekhar Chandra Das asked the deceased Ranjit Debnath to
wait said Sekhar Chandra Das going to take out the tin sheets
from the staged within the shop premises (kept in a horizontal
position) and then and there all the staged tin had fallen down
upon the deceased Ranjit Debnath and the predecessor in
interest of we the plaintiffs was weighted down on the ground
under the all bundles of the tin and received serious injury on
his person.
5. That, the defendants with other workers with shabal and
other instruments tried to bring out the injured Ranjit
Debnath following which caused more injuries upon the said
Ranjit Debnath without seeking any help from the nearby shop
owners. Not only that they even did not call for the Fire
Brigade and somehow removing bundle of tins causing more
injury to the predecessor in interest of we the plaintiffs. They
took him to the Panisagar Hospital without informing any
relatives of Ranjit Debnath where from he was taken to
Kailashahar District Hospital.
6. Getting the information from the people the plaintiff No.2
had gone to Kailashahar Hospital and seeing his grievous
condition he was referred to G.B. Hospital. His condition was
very critical and accordingly he was admitted on 18-06-2016
ILS Hospital as indoor patient wherein he was put incubated
and put on mechanical ventilator in view of poor GCS. As per
the doctor the condition of the patient is very poor and there
is no chance for survival, the relatives of the patient was
decided to bring him at home as the cost of the ILS Hospital
was so high and it was not possible to treat him and kept him
stay in the Hospital in ventilator support for as per doctor the
patient could be survived for few years only by ventilation
support.
7. That, unfortunately when injured Ranjit Debnath was taken
to Panisagar on the way near Panisagar his condition was
detoriated miserably and he was taken to Panisagar Hospital
and wherein the doctor of Panisagar Hospital declared that he
had died. It was on 18-06-2016 at about 10.30 a.m. /11.00
a.m.
8. That the Doctor of Panisagar Hospital informed the
Panisagar Pance Station and the Panisagar Police registered
case being PNS PS U/D Cave No.2016 PNS 010 U/5 174 of
Cr.P.C. and investigation was made by the PNS Police Station
regarding the occurrence.
On 19-06-2016 Post Mortem Examination of the deceased was
done by 3 nos of Doctor wherein it is opined that "the cause of
death in this case is intracranial haemorrhage caused by head
injury due to heavy blunt force. Accidental in nature It is also
mentioned there are two cut present over right leg.
9. That, surprisingly the 1.0. of the PNS PS submitted final
report of the case vide his report dated 29-06-2016 without
proper inquiry mentioning that the cause of death is head
injury due to heavy blunt force accident in nature most for the
reason best known to them."
During cross-examination by the defendants le, the appellants
herein said PW-1 stated that her husband was a private school teacher but
she did not submit any documentary evidence in this regard nor filed any
salary certificate of her deceased husband. She also failed to submit any
adjustment paper for renovation work in the school by her husband. She
further stated that she filed the case after the said incident. Nothing more
came out relevant from her cross-examination
[19]
PW-2, Sri Pranab Debnath in his examination-in-chief in affidavit
in para Nos.2 to 11 has asserted the following facts:
"2. That, the husband of the plaintiff No.1 Late Ranjit Debnath
here in after called predecessor in interest was the Teacher in
Ananda Marg Primary School situated at Panisagar and it was
a private School is being run by a committee as per rules and
norms of the committee.
The predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs joined in
service of said Ananda Marg Primary School in short School on
01-03-1988 and had been continuing in service till his death
on 18-06-2016 and prior to his death has was drawing salary
of Rs.7,700/- (Rupees seven thousand seven hundred) only
per month increasable time to time as per norms of said
School.
3. That, while he was working as teacher in the said School he
was entrusted with some of the extension and renovation
work of the School and accordingly he on 17-06-2016 at about
3 p.m. went to the shop of the defendant No.1 Sekhar Chandra
Das at Panisagar bazar for purchasing tin for the School.
Sekhar Chandra Das asked the deceased Ranjit Debnath to
wait said Sekhar Chandra Das going to take out the tin sheets
from the staged within the shop premises (kept in a horizontal
position) and then an there all the staged tin had fallen down
upon the deceased Ranjit Debnath and the predecessor in
interest of the plaintiffs was weighted down on the ground
under the all bundles of the tin and received serious injury on
his person.
4. That, the defendants with other workers with shabal and
instruments tried to bring out the injured Ranjit Debnath
following which caused more injuries upon the sald Ranjit
Debnath wititout seeking any help from the nearby shop
owners. Not only that they oven did not call for the Fire
Brigade and somehow removing bundle of tins causing more
injury to the predecesser in interest of the plaintiffs. They
took him to the Panisagar Hospital without informing any
relatives of Ranjit Debnath where from he was Kailashahar
District Hospital taken to
5. Getting the information from the people the plaintiff No.2
had gone to Kailashahar Hospital and seeing his grievous
condition he was referred to G.B. Hospital. His condition was
very critical and accordingly he was admitted on 18-06-2016
ILS Hospital as indoor patient wherein he was put incubated
and put on mechanical ventilator in view of poor GCS. As per
the doctor the condition of the patient is very poor and there
is no chance for survival, the relatives of the patient was
decided to bring him at home as the cost of the ILS Hospital
was so high and it was not possible to treat him and kept him
stay in the Hospital in ventilator support for as per doctor the
patient could be survived for few years only by ventilation
support.
6. That, unfortunately when injured Ranjit Debnath was taken
to Panisagar on the way near Panisagar his condition was
detoriated miserably and he was taken to Panisagar Hospital
and wherein the doctor of Panisagar Hospital declared that he
had died. was on 18-06-2016 at about 10.30 a.m. /11.00 a.m.
7. That, the Doctor of Panisagar Hospital informed the
Panisagar Police Station and the Panisagar Police registered
case being PNS PS U/D Case No.2016 PNS 010 U/S 174 of
Cr.P.C and investigation was made by the PNS S Police Station
regarding the occurrence.
On 19-06-2016 Post Mortem Examination of the deceased was
done by 3 nos. of Doctor wherein it is opened that "the cause
of death in this case is intracranial haemorrhage caused by
head injury due to heavy blunt force. Accidental in nature." It
is also mentioned that there are two cut injury present over
right leg.
8. That, surprisingly the 1.0. of the PNS PS submitted final
report of the case his report dated 29-06-2016 without proper
inquiry mentioning that the cause of death is head injury due
to heavy blunt force accident in nature most arbitrarily for the
reason best known to them.
9. That, the accident was occurred due to the fault of the
defendants and it was occurred within his shop premises. He
staged the tin sheets (heavy numbers) in a horizontal position
carelessly without any system and support to keep them in a
protected position for which when he tried to bring out the
sample of a tin sheets it fell down over the deceased who
went there for purchase and as a result of this the deceased
succumbed to injury on 18-06-2016. The injury was occurred
to deceased Ranjit Debnath due to wrongful act, neglect and
default of the shop owners. He carelessly without any
protection and system kept the tin sheets carelessly unlike a
prudent shop owner. Moreover they negligently and carelessly
without informing nearby shop owners and peoples tried to
drag out the deceased Ranjit Debnath under the tin sheets
bundles using shabal (an instrument with pointed edge)
unlike a prudent man and in this way he caused additional
injuries upon the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. The
defendants did not call any one just to conceal his illegal
activities following which said Ranjit Debnath had succumbed
to injuries.
10. That, the deceased had died leaving behind the following
surviving legal heirs.
SL No
NAME
RELATIONSHIP
AGE
i.
Smt. Nandita Dennath wife, plaintiff No.1
ii.
Sri Ratnajit Debnath
son, plaintiff No.2
11. That, the deceased Ranjit Debnath was the teacher in
Panisagar Ananda Marg School (Primary). He joined as
teacher in the said School on 01-03-1988 and he got salary Rs
Rs.7,700.00 per month increasable time to time as per
decision of the committee. For maintaining his family he used
d to do private tuitions from which he earned about Rs.
10,000.00 per month and accordingly his total monthly income
was Rs. 17,700.00 (Rs.7,700.00 Rs. 10,000.00) and with this
income he maintained his family consisting three members. At
the time of death he is aged about 51 years and as it is a
private School he has opportunity to continue his service till
his death or till the date of his working capability. His wife is
aged about 48 years and his son is aged about 16 years and
studying in Class XII.”
During cross-examination by the defendants 1.e. the appellants
herein he admitted that at the time of accident he was not present. Again
submitted that there was a meeting in between the plaintiffs and the
defendants but they could not submit the minutes of the meetings before
the Court. Nothing more came out relevant from his cross-examination.
[20]
Similarly, PW-3, Smt. Shila Nath in her examination-in-chief in
affidavit in para Nos.2 to 11 has asserted the following facts:
"2. That, the husband of the plaintiff No.1 Late Ranjit Debnath
was the Teacher in Ananda Marg Primary School situated at
Panisagar and it was a private School is being run by a
committee as per rules and norms of the committee.
Late Ranjit Debnath joined in service of said Ananda Marg
Primary School in short School on 01-03-1988 and had been
continuing in service till his death on 18-06-2016 and prior to
his death has was drawing salary of Rs.7,700/- (Rupees seven
thousand seven hundred) only per month increasable time to
time as per norms of said School.
3. That, while he was working as teacher in the said School he
was entrusted with some of the extension and renovation
work of the School and accordingly he on 17-06-2016 at about
3 p.m. went to the shop of the defendant No.1 Sekhar Chandra
Das at Panisagar bazar for purchasing tin for the School.
Sekhar Chandra Das asked the deceased Ranjit Debnath to
wait said Sekhar Chandra Das going to take out the tin sheets
from the staged within the shop premises (kept in a horizontal
position) and then and there all the staged tin had fallen down
upon the deceased Ranjit Debnath and the predecessor in
interest of the plaintiffs was weighted down on the ground
under the all bundles of the tin and received serious injury on
his person.
4. That, the defendants with other workers with shathal and
other instruments tried to bring out the injured Ranjit
Debnath following which caused more injuries upon the said
Ranjit Debnath without seeking any help owners Not Not only
that they even did not call for from the nearby shop the Fire
Brigade and somehow removing bundle of tins causing more
injury to the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. They
took him to the Panisagar Hospital without informing any
relatives of Ranjit Debnath where from he was taken to
Kailashahar District Hospital.
5. That, on the relevant date at about 3.30/4.00 p.m. I came
to Panisagar from Fatikroy where I am working as Lecturer in
Fatikroy Collage and hearing the information from various
persons at Panisagar Bazar I had gone to Panisagar Hospital
and then had gone to Kailashahar District Hospital with the
injured. And seeing his grievous condition he was referred to
G.B.Hospital. His condition was very critical and accordingly
he was admitted on 18-06-2016 ILS Hospital as indoor patient
wherein he was put incubated and put on mechanical
ventilator in view of poor GCS. As per the doctor the of the
patient. is very poor and there condition is no chance for
survival, the relatives of the patient was decided to bring him
at home as the cost of the ILS Hospital was so high and it was
not possible to treat him and kept him stay in the Hospital in
ventilator support for as per doctor the patient could be
survived for few years only by ventilation support.
6. That, unfortunately when injured Ranjit Debnath was taken
to Panisagar on the way near Panisagar his condition was
detoriated miserably and he was taken to Panisagar Hospital
and wherein the doctor of Panisagar Hospital declared that he
had died. It was on 18-06-2016 at about 10.30 a.m. /11.00
a.m.
7. That, the Doctor of Panisagar Hospital informed the
Panisagar Police Station and the Panisagar Police registered
case being PNS PS U/D Case No.2016 PNS 010 U/S 174 of
Cr.P.C. and investigation was made by the PNS Police Station
regarding the occurrence.
On 19-06-2016 Post Mortem Examination of the deceased was
done by 3 nos, of Doctor wherein it is opened that "the cause
of death in this case is intracranial haemorrhage caused by
head injury due to heavy blunt force. Accidental in nature. It is
also mentioned that there are two cut injury present over
right leg.
8. That, surprisingly the 1.0. of the PNS PS submitted final
report of the case vide his report dated 29-06-2016 without
proper inquiry mentioning that the cause of death is head
injury due to heavy blunt force accident in nature most
arbitrarily for the reason best known to them.
9. That, the accident was occurred due to the fault of the
defendants and it was occurred within his shop premises. He
staged the tin sheets (heavy numbers) in a horizontal position
carelessly without any system and support to keep them in a
protected position for which when he tried to bring out the
sample of a tin sheets it fell down over the deceased who
went there for purchase and as a result of this the deceased
succumbed to injury on 18-06-2016. The injury was occurred
to deceased Ranjit Debnath due to wrongful act, neglect and
default of the shop owners. He carelessly without any
protection and system kept the tin sheets carelessly unlike a
prudent shop owner. Moreover they and carelessly without
informing nearby shop owners and peoples tried to drag out
the deceased Ranjit Debnath under the tin sheets bundles
using shabal (an instrument with pointed edge) unlike a
prudent man and in this way he caused additional injuries
upon the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. The
defendants did not tall any one just to conceal his illegal
activities following which said Ranjit Debnath had succumbed
to injuries.
10. That, the deceased had died leaving behind the following
surviving legal heirs.
SL No
NAME
RELATIONSHIP
AGE
i.
Smt. Nandita Dennath wife, plaintiff No.1
ii.
Sri Ratnajit Debnath
son, plaintiff No.2
11. That, the deceased Ranjit jit Debnath was the teacher in
Panisagar Ananda Marg School (Primary). He joined as
teacher in the said School on 01-03-1988 and he got salary
Rs.7,700.00 per month increasable time to time as per
decision of the committee. For maintaining his family he used
to do private tuitions from which he earned about Rs.
10,000.00 month and accordingly his total monthly income
was Rs.17,700.00 (Rs.7,700.00 Rs.10,000.00) and with this
Income he maintained his family consisting three members. At
the time of de death he is aged about 51 years and private
School he has opportunity to as it is a continue his service till
his death or till the date of his working capability. His wife is
aged about 48 years his son is aged about years and studying
in Class XII."
During cross-examination by the defendants i.e. the appellant
herein, she stated that at the time of accident she was at Fatikroy. She
further stated that there was a meeting in between the plaintiffs and the
defendants but they could not submit the minutes of the meetings before
the Court. Nothing more came out relevant from her cross-examination.
[21]
PW-4, Sri Samiran Deb in his examination-in-chief in affidavit in
para Nos.2 to 6 has asserted the following facts:
"2. That, I know deceased Ranjit Debnath teacher of the
Ananda Marg Primary School, Panisagar, North Tripura.
3. That, I have working as worker at Ananda Marg Primary on
the basis of no work no pay. It is a private school is being run
by a committee and as per the decision of the committee I
have been working in the school as worker since long.
4. That, while he was working as teacher in the said School he
was entrusted with some of the extension and renovation
work of the School and accordingly he on 17-06-2016 at about
3 p.m. went to the shop of the defendant No. 1 Sekhar
Chandra Das at Panisagar bazar for purchasing tin for the
School. Sekhar Chandra Das asked the deceased Ranjit
Debnath to wait said Sekhar Chandra Das going to take out
the tin sheets from the staged within the shop premises (kept
in a horizontal position) and then and there all the staged tin
had fallen down upon the deceased Ranjit Debnath and he was
weighted down on the ground under the all bundles of the tin
and received serious injury on his person.
5. That, the defendants with other workers with shabal and
other instruments tried to bring out the injured Ranjit
Debnath following which caused more injuries upon the said
Ranjit Debnath without seeking any help from the nearly shop
owners. Not only that they even did not call for the Fire
Brigade and somehow removing bundle of tins causing more
injury to the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. They
took him to the Panisagar Hospital without informing any
relatives of Ranjit Debnath where from he was taken to
Kailashahar District Hospital.
6. That, the accident was occurred due to the fault of the
defendants and it was occurred within his shop premises. He
staged the tin sheets (heavy numbers) in a horizontal position
carelessly without any system and support to keep them in a
protected position for which when he tried to bring out sample
of a tin sheets it fell down over the deceased who went there
for purchase and as a result of this the deceased succumbed
to injury on 18-06-2016. The injury was occurred to deceased
Ranjit Debnath due to wrongful act, neglect and default of the
shop owners. He carelessly without any protection and system
kept the tin sheets carelessly unlike a shop owner. Moreover
they negligently and carelessly without informing nearby shop
owners and peoples tried to drag out the deceased Ranjit
Debnath under the tin sheets bundles using shabal (an
instrument with pointed edge) unlike a prudent man and in
this way he caused additional injuries upon the predecessor in
interest of the plaintiffs. The defendants did not call any one
just to conceal his illegal activities following which said Ranjit
Debnath had succumbed to injuries."
During cross-examination by the defendants i.e. the appellants
herein he stated that he used to work in the Ananda marga Primary School
and at the time of incident he was at Panisagar market.
[22]
PW-5, Sri Anil Das in his examination-in-chief in affidavit in para
Nos.3 to 8 asserted the following facts:
"3. That, on 17-06-2016 at about 3 p.m. Ranjit Debnath went
to the shop of the defendant No.1 Sekhar Chandra Das at
Panisagar Bazar for purchasing tin for the School. I was along
with him with my card (Thela). I was accompanying him to
bring the purchased tin.
4. That, on 17-06-2016 at about 3 p.m. went to the shop of the
defendant No.1 Sekhar Chandra Das at Panisagar bazar for
purchasing tin for the School. Sekhar Chandra Das asked the
deceased Ranjit Debnath to wait said Sekhar Chandra Das
going to take out the tin sheets from the staged within the
shop premises (kept in a horizontal position) and then and
there all the staged tin had fallen down upon the deceased
Ranjit Debnath and the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs
was weighted down on the ground under the all bundles of the
tin and received serious injury on his person.
5. That, the defendants with other workers with shabal and
other instruments tried to bring out the injured Ranjit
Debnath following which caused more injuries upon the said
Ranjit Debnath without seeking any help the nearby shop
owners. Not only that they even did not call for the Fire
Brigade and somehow removing bundle of tins causing more
injury to the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. They
took him to the Panisagar Hospital by the Sekhar Chandra Das
& others without informing any relatives of Ranjit Debnath
where from he was taken to Kailashahar District Hospital.
6. That, the victim was then taken to Agartala for treatment
and ultimately he had died.
7. That, the accident was occurred due to the fault of the
defendants and it was occurred within his shop premises. He
staged the tin sheets (heavy numbers) in a horizontal position
carelessly without any system and support to keep them in a
protected position for which when he tried to bring out the
sample of a tin sheets it fell down over the deceased who
went there for purchase and as a result of this the deceased
succumbed to injury on 18-06-2016. The injury was occurred
to deceased Ranjit Debnath due to wrongful act, neglect and
default of the shop owners. He carelessly without any
protection and system kept the tin sheets carelessly unlike a
prudent shop owner. Moreover they negligently and carelessly
without informing nearby shop owners and peoples tried to
drag out the deceased Ranjit Debnath under the tin sheets
bundles using shabal (an instrument with po pointed edge)
unlike a prudent man and in this way he caused additional
injuries upon the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. The
defendants did not call any one just to conceal his illegal
activities following which said Ranjit Debnath had succumbed
to injuries.
8. That, the deceased Ranjit Debnath was the teacher in
Panisagar Ananda Marg School (Primary)."
During cross-examination, he stated that he appeared before the
Court as per request of Nandita Debnath and he could not say the exact date
of the incident.
[23]
PW-6, Sri Manindra Chandra Nath in his examination-in-chief in
affidavit in para Nos. 3 to 13 has asserted that:
3. That, deceased Ranjit Debnath was entrusted to purchase
tin from Panisagar Bazar for the School.
4. That, on 17-06-2016 at about 3 p.m. he went to the shop of
the defendant No. 1 Sekhar Chandra Das at Panisagar bazar
for purchasing tin for the School.
5. That, the husband of the plaintiff No.1 Late Ranjit Debnath
was the Teacher in Ananda Marg Primary School situated at
Panisagar and it was a private School is being run by a
committee as per rules and norms of the committee.
6. That, while he was working as teacher in the said School he
was entrusted with some of the extension and renovation of
the School and accordingly he on 17-06-2016 at about 3 p.m.
went to the shop of the defendant No.1 Sekhar Chandra Das at
Panisagar bazar for purchasing tin for the School. Sekhar
Chandra Das asked the deceased Ranjit Debnath to wait said
Sekhar Chandra Das going to take out the tin sheets from the
staged within the shop premises (kept in a horizontal
position) and and there all the staged tin had fallen down
upon the deceased Ranjit Debnath and the predecessor in
interest of the plaintiffs was weighted down on the ground
under the all bundles of the tin and received serious injury on
his person.
7. That, the defendants with other workers with shabal and
other instruments tried to bring out the injured Ranjit
Debnath following which caused more injuries upon the said
Ranjit Debnath without seeking any help from the nearby shop
owners. Not only that they even did not call for the Fire
Brigade and somehow removing bundle of tins causing more
injury to the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. They
took him to the Panisagar Hospital without informing any
relatives of Ranjit Debnath where from he was taken to
Kailashahar District Hospital.
8. That, the victim was taken to Panisagar Hospital and then
to Kailashahar District Hospital and seeing his grievous
condition he was referred to G.B.Hospital. His condition was
very critical and accordingly he was admitted on 18-06-2016
ILS Hospital as indoor patient wherein he put incubated and
put on mechanical ventilator in view of poor GCS. As per the
doctor the condition of the patient is very poor and there is no
chance for survival, the relatives of the patient was decided to
bring him at home as the cost of the ILS Hospital was so high
and it was not possible to treat him and kept him stay in the
Hospital in ventilator support for as per doctor the patient
could be survived for few years only by ventilation support.
9. That, unfortunately when injured Ranjit Debnath was taken
to Panisagar on the way near Panisagar his condition was
detoriated miserably and he was taken to Panisagar Hospital
and wherein the doctor or of Panisagar Hospital declared that
he had died. It was on 18-06-2016 at about 10.30 a.m. /
11.00 a.m.
10. That, the accident was occurred due to the fault of the
defendants and it was occurred within his shop premises. He
staged the tin sheets (heavy numbers) in a horizontal position
carelessly without any system and support to keep them in a
protected position for which when he tried to bring out the
sample of a tin sheets it fell down over the deceased who
went there for purchase and as a result of this the deceased
succumbed to injury on 18-06-2016. The injury was occurred
to deceased Ranjit Debnath due to wrongful act, neglect and
default of the shop owners. He carelessly without any
protection and system kept the tin sheets carelessly unlike a
prudent shop owner. Moreover they negligently and carelessly
without informing nearby shop owners and peoples tried to
drag out the deceased Ranjit Debnath under the tin sheets
bundles using shabal (an instrument with pointed edge)
unlike a prudent man and in this way he caused additional
injuries upon the predecessor in interest of the plaintiffs. The
defendants did not call any one just to conceal his illegal
activities following which said Ranjit Debnath had succumbed
to injuries.
11. That, the deceased had died leaving behind the following
surviving legal heirs.
SL No
NAME
RELATIONSHIP
AGE
i.
Smt. Nandita Dennath wife, plaintiff No.1
ii.
Sri Ratnajit Debnath
son, plaintiff No.2
12. That, the deceased Ranjit Debnath was the teacher in
Panisagar Ananda Marg School (Primary). He joined as
teacher in the said School on 01-03-1988 and he got salary
Rs.7,700.00 per month increasable tim 12. e to time as per
decision of the committee. For maintaining his family he used
to do private tuitions from which he earned about Rs.
10,000.00 per month and accordingly his total monthly income
was Rs.17,700.00 (Rs.7,700.00 Rs.10,000.00) and with this
income he maintained his family consisting three members. At
the time of death he is aged about 51 years and as it is a
private School he has opportunity to continue his service till
his death or till the date of his working capability. His wife is
aged about 48 years and his son is aged about 16 years and
studying in Class XII.
13. That, he was a teacher in a private School and there is no
system of pensionary or any service benefits. Moreover if he
continued service his remuneration could be increased time to
time or the School might be taken by the Government in near
future and in event his salary might be be increased
reasonably and his demand for private tuition would have
been increased.”
During cross-examination by the defendants i.e. the appellants he
stated that he did not issue any memo in writing or adjustment of authority
to the teacher Ranjit Debnath for purchasing of tin from a shop at Panisagar
on last 17.06.2016 for renovation of school building nor he issued any salary
certificate to Ranjit Debnath in respect of his salary Rs 7,700/- per month.
Nothing more came out relevant from his cross- examination
[24]
The appellants have adduced only one witness Le. the evidence of
defendant No. 1, Sri Shekhar Chandra Das. He in his examination-in-chief in
affidavit tried support the version of written statement filed by them before
the Learned Trial Court.
During cross examination by the plaintiffs, he stated that he is
running a valid business and is an Income Tax payee. His shop consists of
two doors. But he could not say in which side of the door the incident
occurred and he found the injured person inside his shop after coming from
house. But he could not say in which side injured person was there. He
along with other villagers shifted the injured to the hospital and injured.
person was dragged out under the bundle of tins by shifting the bunch of tin
The injury was not appeared to be serious. He further stated that the injured
person was lifted from the spot by vehicle for treatment. Also stated that his
shop is nearly 10 cubits in breadth and the doors divided into two parts
nearly 5 cubit and 5 cubit. His shop is connected with hardware and tin in
the sign board his name was written and a verandah was in the front side.
Again he stated that tin was put on the southern portion of the shop. He
could not say the length of the tin in the bundle when the incident occurred.
The sitting table is in the northern side of the shop and the size of the table
is 3x3 ft. The victim was shifted to hospital by him and other villagers but at
that moment no family members were there. They shifted the victim to
hospital urgently on humanitarian ground without informing the family
members. He denied to have any bartakh, the again stated that he was not
present in the shop when the incident occurred.
These are the sum and substance of the evidence on record of
both the parties.
[25]
In course of hearing of argument as already stated Mr. Saha,
Learned counsel for the appellants drawn the attention of the Court that the
plaintiffs Le the respondents herein filed the suit before the Learned Court
below under the Fatal Accident Act but before the Learned Trial Court they
have failed to show the negligence on the part of the present appellants
herein, Even, to substantiate the claim of the plaintiffs, no independent
witness could be adduced by the respondents before the Learned Trial Court
but the Learned Trial Court on the basis of some omnibus statements
decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs ie. the respondents herein. In
support of his contention, Learned counsel for the appellants relied upon one
citation of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Rajkot Municipal
Corporation versus Manjulben Jayantilal Nakum and Others reported
In (1997) 9 SCC 552 wherein in para Nos. 11 to 15 the said Apex Court
has observed as under:
"11, In "Blacks Law Dictionary (6th Edn.) at page 1489, tort is
defined as violation of duty imposed by general law or
otherwise upon all persons occupying the relation to each
other involved in a given transaction. There must always be a
violation of some duty owed to plaintiff and generally such a
duty must arise by operation of law and not by mere
agreement of the parties. "A legal wrong is committed upon
the person or property, independent of contract. It may be
either (1) a direct invasion of some legal right of the
individual; (2) the infraction of some public duty by which
special damage accrues to the individual; (3) the violation of
some private obligation by which like damage accrues to the
Individual. Negligence is failure to use such care.. reasonable
prudent and careful person would use, under similar
circumstances. It is the doing of some act which a persen of
ordinary prudence would not have done under similar
circumstances or failure to do what a person of ordinary
prudence would have done under similar Circumstances.
Negligence also is omission to do something which a
reasonable man, guided by those ordinary considerations
which ordinarily regulate human affairs, would do, or the
doing of something which a reasonable and prudent man
would not do.
12. Negligence and tort have been viewed without elaborately
embarking upon the definition of "tart" applicable to varie ried
circumstances and the scope of negligence in its wider
perspective. Let us proceed to consider the meaning of
"negligence in the context of tort liability arising in this case.
In every case giving rise to tortious liability, tort consists of
injury and damage due to negligence. Claim for injury and
damage may be founded on breach of contract or tort. or tort.
We are concerned in this case with tort. The liability in tort
may be strict liability, absolute liability or special liability. The
degree of liability depends on degree of mental element. The
elements of tort of negligence consist in (a) duty of care; (b)
duty is owed to the plaintiff; (c) the duty has been carelessly
breached. Negligence does not entail liability unless the law
exacts a duty in the given circumstances to observe care. Duty
is an obligation recognized by law to avoid conduct fraught
with unreasonable risk of damage to others. The question
whether duty in a particular situation involves exists involves
determination of law. Negligence would in such acts and
omissions involve an unreasonable risk of harm to others. The
breach and how much is the damage duty causes damage and
how much should be comprehended by the defendant.
Remoteness relevant and compensation on proof thereof
requires consideration. The element of carelessness in the
breach of the duty and those duties towards the plaintiff are
important components in the tort of negligence. Negligence
would mean careless conduct in commission or omission of an
act connoting duty, breach and the damage thereby suffered
by the person to whom the plaintiff owes Duty of of care is,
therefore, crucial to understand the nature and scope of the
tort of negligence.
13. The question in each case whether the defendant has been
negligent. In determining duty of care, public policy involved
in
the
statute
requires
detailed
examination.
Upon
examination, they are required to further consider whether its
extension elongates that public policy or retards its
effectuation or frustrates its object and the inevitable effect
thereof on the affected plaintiff as well as general public. No
general or abstract principle is desirable to be laid. The gene
careless breach of duty will vary from case to case and it
should not be unduly extended or confined or limited to all
situations. The attending circumstances require evaluation
and application to particular set of facts of a given case. The
standard of care also varies in a particular factual situation.
fant must be under a Defendant duty of care not to create
latent source of physical danger to the person or property of
third party whom he ought to reasonably foresee as likely to
be effected thereby, Thus the latent defect causing actual
physical damage to the person or property gives the cause of
action and them only the defendant is liable to pay the
damages for tortious liability. It must, therefore, be an
essential element to establish that there is a positive act or a
duty and the defendant is under duty of care not to
create/direct latent source of physical danger to the person or
property of third party whom he ought to reasonably foresee
as likely to be affected thereby.
14. Negligence has been viewed in three ways. Firstly
involving a careless state of mind, secondly, a careless
conduct, and thirdly, a tort in itself. Every case giving rise to
tortious liability, consists of injury and damage may be found
due to breach of contract or tort. We are concerned in this
case with the injury and damage in tort. Therefore, it is
necessary to dwell, in depth, on strict inability, absolute
liability or special liability. In the present case, the omission
alleged is to lake care of periodical check-up of the condition
of the trees. The degree liability depends upon the degree of
mental element. The elements of tort of negligence, therefore,
consist in (a) duty of care (b) duty owed to the plaintiff and
(c) it has been carelessly breached. Negligence does not give
rise to liability unless the law fastens the duty of care in given
circumstances. Duty is an obligation recognised by law to
avoid conduct brought with unreasonable risk of damage to
another. The question whether duty consists in particular
situation involves determination as a question of law.
15. Negligence would include both acts and omissions
involving unreasonable risk of having done harm to another.
The breach of duty must cause damage. How much of the
damage to be compensated by the defendant should be
attributed to his wilful conduct and how much to his wiliful
negligence or careless conduct or remissness in performance
of duty, are all relevant facts to be considered in a given act or
omission in adjudging duty of care. The element of
carelessness or the breach of duty and whether that duty is
towards plaintiff or class of persons to which the plaintiff
belongs are important components in tort of negligence.
Negligence would, therefore, mean careless conduct in
commission or omission of an act, whereby another to whom
the plaintiff owed duty of care has suffered damage. The duty
of care is crucial in understanding the nature and scope of tort
of negligence. The question in case is whether the defendant
has been negligent in the performance of duty or omission
thereof. Determination of duty of care also involves statutory
action which requires detailed examination. Local authority,
when it exercises its public law function, generally owes no
law duty of care. Duty of care must be owed to a person or
class of persons to which the plaintiff belongs and must be to
avoid causing particular type of injury damage to his person
or property. The Court requires to examine the scope ope of
duty of care which the local authority owes to the plaintiff.
The court is required to consider the object, scope and breach
of the Act. Though the statute is of general character, since
the Government or local authority is entrusted with the duty
to implement the law, though at its discretion, and if damage
is done in execution thereof, what requires to be examined is
whether the aforestated elements of tort of negligence stand
attracted. The Court is further required to consider whether
extension of duty of care by the process of interpretation
would elongate the public policy or retard its object or
frustrate public policy behind the statute and the inevitable
effect thereof on the affected plaintiff as well as the general
public. No general principle of law is desirable to be laid down
as an acid test."
Relying upon the aforesaid citation, Learned counsel for the
appellants further drawn the attention of the Court in the given case the
plaintiffs have failed to establish negligence for awarding compensation in
their favour. But the Learned Trial Court failed to appreciate the evidence on
record negligence and decreed the suit which needs to be interfered with.
[26]
On the other hand, Mr. Bhattacharjee, Learned counsel for the
respondents in course of hearing of argument submitted that the Learned
Court below after appreciating the evidence on record rightly and reasonably
decreed the suit in favour of the respondents herein and in support of his
contention, he also relied upon the citation of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India in Gobald Motor Service Ltd. and Another versus R.M.K.
Veluswami and Others reported in AIR 1962 SC 1 wherein the said Apex
Court in para No.5 has observed as under:
"5. Apart from the positive evidence, in the present case the
accident took place not on the main road, but on the off side
uprooting the stone at the drain and attacking a tamarind tree
25 feet away from the said stone with such a velocity that its
bark was peeled off and the bus could stop only after
travelling some more distance from the said tree. The said
facts give rise to a presumption that the accident was caused
by the negligence of the driver. Asquith, L. J., in Barkway v.
South Wales Transport Co. (1) neatly summarizes the
principles applicable as to onus of proof in the following short
propositions:
"(i) If the defendants‟ omnibus leaves the road and falls down
embankment, and this without more is proved, then the res
ipsa loquitur, there is a presumption that the event is caused
by negligence on the part of the defendants, and the plaintiff
succeeds unless the defendants can rebut this presumption.
(ii) It is no rebuttal for the defendants to show, again without
more, that the immediate cause of the omnibus leaving the
road is a tyre- burst, since a tyre-burst per se is a neutral
event consistent, and equally consistent, with negligence or
due diligence on the part of the defendants. When a balance
has been tilted one way, you cannot redress it by adding an
equal weight to each scale. The depressed scale will remain
down. This is the effect of the decision in Laurie v. Raglan
Building Company Ltd., (2), where not a tyre burst but a skid
was involved. (iii) To displace the presumption, the
defendants must go further and prove (or it must emerge from
the evidence as a whole) either (a) that the burst itself was
due to a specific cause which does not connote negligence on
their part but points to its absence as more probable, or (b) if
they can point to no such specific cause, that they used all
reasonable care in and about the management of their tyres."
The same principles have been restated in Halsbury's Laws of
England, at p. 671, paragraph 956, thus:
"An exception to the general rule that the burden of proof of
the alleged negligence is in the first instance on the plaintiff
occurs wherever the facts already established are such that
the proper and natural inference immediately arising from
them is that the injury complained of was caused by the
defendant's negligence, or where the event charged
negligence tells its own story of negligence on the part of the
defendant, the story so told being clear and unambiguous. To
these cases maxim res ipsa loquitur applies. Where the
doctrine applies, a presumption of fault is raised against the
defendant, which, if he is to succeed in his defence, must be
overcome by contrary evidence, the burden on the defendant
being to show how the act complained of could reasonably
happen without negligence on his part. Where, therefore,
there is a duty on the defendant to exercise care, and the
circumstances in which the injury complained of happened are
such that with the exercise of the requisite care no risk would
in the ordinary course of events ensue, the burden is in the
first instance on the defendant to disprove his liability. In such
a case, if the injurious agency itself and the surrounding
circumstances are all entirely within the defendant's control,
the inference is that the defendant is liable, and this inference
is strengthened if the injurious agency is inanimate.
The said principles directly apply to the present case. Here,
the events happened tell their own story and there is a
presumption that the accident was caused by negligence on
the part of the appellants. But it is, said that this presumption
was rebutted by proof that the accident was due to the rear
central bolt of the bus suddenly giving way. The High Court,
after considering the relevant evidence, held that it was not
possible to hold that the accident was caused by the break in
the bolt. We have gone through the evidence and we do not
see any flaw in that conclusion."
In Municipal Corporation of Delhi versus Subhagwanti and Others
reported in AIR 1966 SC 1750 the Hon'ble Apex Court in para No.4 has
observed as under :
"4. The main question presented for determination in these
appeals is whether the appellant was negligent in looking
after and maintaining the Clock Tower and was liable to pay
damages for the death of the persons resulting from its fall. It
was contended, in the first place, by Mr. Bishen Narain on
behalf of the appellant that the High Court was wrong in
applying the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur to this case. It was
argued that the fall of the Clock Tower was due to an
inevitable accident which could not have been prevented by
the exercise of reasonable care or caution. It was also
submitted that there was nothing in the appearance of the
Clock Tower which should have put the appellant notice with
regard to the probability of danger. We are unable to accept
the argument of the appellant as correct. It is true that the
normal rule is that it is for the plaintiff to prove negligence
and not for the defendant to disprove it. But there is an
exception to this rule which applies where the circumstances
surrounding the thing which causes the damage are at the
material time exclusively under the control or management of
the defendant or his servant and the happening is such as
does not occur in the ordinary course of things without
negligence on the defendant's part. The principle has been
clearly stated in Halsbury's Laws of England, 2nd Edn., Vol.
23, at p. 671 as follows:
"An exception to the general rule that the burden of proof of
the alleged negligence is in the first instance on the plaintiff
occurs wherever the facts already established are such that
the proper and natural inference immediately arising from
them is that the injury complained of was caused by the
defendant's negligence, or where the event charged as
negligence tells its own story of negligence on the part of the
defendant, the story so told being clear and unambiguous. To
these cases the maxim res ipsa loquitur applies. Where the
doctrine applies, a presumption of fault is raised against the
defendant, which, if he is to succeed in his defence, must be
overcome by contrary evidence, the burden on the defendant
being to show how the act complained of could reasonably
happen without negligence on his part."
In our opinion, the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur applies in the
circumstances of the present case. It has been found that the
Clock Tower was exclusively under the ownership and control
of the appellant or its servants. It has also been found by the
High Court that the Clock Tower was 80 years old and the
normal life of the structure of the top storey of the building,
having regard to the kind of mortar used, could be only 40 or
45 years. There is also evidence of the Chief Engineer that the
collapse was due to thrust of the arches on the top portion
and the mortar was deteriorated to such an extent that it was
reduced to powder without any cementing properties. It is
also not the case of the appellant that there was any
earthquake or storm or any other natural event which was
unforeseen and which could have been the cause of the fall of
the Clock Tower. In these circumstances, the mere fact that
there was fall of the Clock Tower tells its own story in raising
an inference of negligence so as to establish a prima facie
case against the appellant."
Relying upon the same, Learned counsel for the respondents
submitted that the defendants of the original suit i.e. the appellants herein
were negligent in discharging their duties as required by law and there was
want of proper care and caution on the part of the appellants herein and due
to their negligence, the incident took place for which the victim succumbed
to his injuries. According to Learned counsel for the respondents, there was
no error in the judgment of the Learned Trial Court and the Learned Trial
Court after considering the evidence on record both by oral/documentary
allowed the suit and granted decree in favour of the respondents herein.
[27]
Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the
points of argument as raised by Learned counsel for the appellants before
the High Court were not raised by the appellants before the Learned Trial
Court nor they have, adduced proper evidence. Learned counsel for the
appellants in course of hearing also relied upon "volenti non-fit injuri",
‘contributory negligence and res ipsa loquitor’ and submitted that there was
no negligence on the part of the appellants herein for which the suit was not
maintainable. Now, let us examine about Negligence. ‘Negligence' is the
breach of a duty caused by the omission to do something which a prudent
and reasonable man would not do. Actionable negligence consists in the
neglect of the use of ordinary care or skill towards a person to whom the
defendant owes the duty of observing ordinary care and skill, by which
neglect the plaintiff has observing ordinary care and skill, by which neglect
the plaintiff has suffered injury to his person or property. It is the settled
position of law that in an action for negligence, the plaintiffs have to prove
the following factors:
1) That the defendant owed duty of care to the plaintiff.
2) The defendant made a breach of that duty.
3) The plaintiff suffered damage as a consequence thereof.
[28]
Here, in the given case before the Learned Trial Court, the
respondents as plaintiffs have adduced in total 6 numbers of witnesses.
Admittedly, none of the witnesses are/were the eye witnesses of the alleged
incident because none of them were present to the PO at the time of alleged
occurrence. Rather, it appears that the defendant No.1 i.e. the appellant
No.1 herein was present to the PO at the time of alleged occurrence
Admittedly, there is no dispute on record that the appellant No.1 is the
owner of the shop from where the deceased went to purchase GCI sheet on
that relevant day and time. The appellant himself have admitted the said
fact. Now, we are to see to what extent and how the appellants were
negligent in discharging their duties. If we go through the evidence of the
respondents and their witnesses, it appears that on the alleged day i.e., on
17.06.2016 at about 3 p.m when the deceased went to the shop of the
defendant No.1, Shekhar Chandra Das i.e. the appellant herein, that time,
said defendant asked the deceased to wait and thereafter, he proceeded to
take out the GCI sheets from the stack inside the shop premises which
according to the respondent-plaintiffs were kept in horizontal position and
that time, the stack fall down on the person of the deceased for which he
sustained fatal injuries and ultimately succumbed to his injuries. It was the
duty of the plaintiffs to satisfy the Court as to how the tins were kept inside
the shop, at what distance the deceased was waiting/standing, how the GCI
sheets were fallen on his body and furthermore, no neighboring persons or
shop owners came forward to support the case of the respondent-plaintiffs.
Naturally, a question arises that if the defendant No.1 i.e. the appellant
asked the deceased to wait, then, how he entered inside nearby GCI sheets.
In this regard, there was no explanation from the side of the respondentplaintiffs. Furthermore, whether the deceased was standing outside the shop
on the verandah or inside the shop, that point also could not be clarified by
the respondent- plaintiffs before the Learned Trial Court. Also as a normal
parlance, it was the duty of the defendant No.1 to show the GCI sheets to
the deceased as per evidence of the respondent-plaintiffs but surprisingly,
why the deceased went nearby the GCI sheets, that part also could not be
explained by the respondent-plaintiffs before the Learned Trial Court. If the
deceased of his own entered inside without adhering to the caution given by
the defendant No.1 or alternatively if in a hurry the deceased himself went
nearby the bundles of stack of his own, in that case, whether that would be
tantamount of negligence or not could not be explained by the respondentplaintiffs either before the Trial Court and also to the High Court also and if
there is evidence of contributory negligence, in that case, whether that
would be amount to negligence from the side of appellants, that portion also
could not be decided by the Learned Trial Court. More so, there was no
evidence on record from the side of the respondent-plaintiffs to show any
documentary evidence as to how the GCI sheets were supposed to be kept
inside the shop. Whether the same be kept horizontally or vertically in this
regard no clear picture could projected by the respondent-plaintiffs before
the Trial Court below. Even, no technical person or any expert was adduced
by the respondent-plaintiffs before the Learned Trial Court. Rather, if we rely
upon the evidence of DW-1 it appears that the deceased himself attributed
to the incident. Learned Court below at the time of delivery of judgment did
not consider also those aspects, rather, on the oral evidence of the
respondent-plaintiffs and their witnesses came to the observation that the
defendant No.1 i.e. the appellant was negligent for the alleged incident.
Even, from the relevant document of U/D case no material is found to come
to a conclusion that there was negligence on the part of the appellants for
the alleged incident on that day.
[29]
The principle of citation as referred by Learned counsel for the
appellants is very much significant for deciding this appeal. Rather, the
citations as relied upon by the respondents herein, appears to be
distinguishable in facts not appropriate for decision of this present appeal.
Learned Court below while passing the judgment referred different citations
where the Court below has explained the theory of 'negligence'. But, at the
time of appreciating the evidence on record came to the observation that the
appellants were negligent on that relevant date and time which in my
considered view Learned Court below misinterpreted and misconstrued the
theory of 'negligence’ and thus came to an erroneous finding fixing the
liability upon the present appellants for negligence on the alleged day and
thus decreed the suit in favour of the respondents which in my considered
view was not based on any sound footing of law and thus, it appears that
the judgment of the Learned Trial Court below suffers from infirmities for
which the interference of this Court is required.
[30]
The Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Managing Director,
Kerala Tourism Development Corporation Limited versus Deepti
Singh Others reported in (2019) 16 SCC 573 in para Nos 7, 8 & 9 has
observed as under :
7. In Pounam Verma v Aswin Patel (1996) 4 SCC 332, a two
Judge Bench of this Court elucidated on the elements of the
tort of negligence. S Saghir Ahmad, J held thus :
“14. Negligence as a tort is the breach of a duty
caused by omission to do something which a
reasonable man would do, or doing something
which a prudent and reasonable man would not do.”
The Court listed the following elements which constitute
negligence‟: Poonam Verma (supra)
15. …. (1) a legal duty to exercise due care;
(2) breach of the duty; and
(3) consequential damages."
8. In Rajkot Municipal Corporation versus Manjulben Jayantilai
Nakum :(1997) 9 SCC 552, a two judge bench of this Court
characterized the tort of negligence as "carless conduct in
commission or omission of an act." Ramaswamy, J. opined
thus (SCC p. 569, para 12)
12. … The elements of tort of negligence consist in(a) duty of care; (b) duty is owed to the plaintiff;
(c) the duty has been carelessly breached;
Negligence does not entail liability unless the law
exacts a duty in the given circumstances to observe
care. Duty is an obligation recognized by law to
avoid conduct fraught with unreasonable risk of
damage to others. The question whether duty exists
in a particular situation involves determination law.
Negligence would in such acts and omissions involve
an unreasonable risk of harm to others. The breach
of duty causes damage and how much is the damage
should be comprehended by the defendant.
Remoteness is relevant and compensation on proof
thereof requires consideration. The element of
carelessness in the breach of the duty and those
duties
towards
the
plaintiff
are
important
components in the tort of negligence. Negligence
would mean careless conduct in commission or
omission of an act connoting duty, breach and the
damage thereby suffered by the person to whom the
plaintiff owes. Duty of care is, therefore, crucial to
understand the nature and scope of the tort of
negligence.
9. The ingredients of the tort of negligence are : (i) existence
of a duty of care; (ii) a breach of the duty through action or
omission; and (iii) damages arising as a consequence of the
breach."
In another case Hon'ble the Supreme Court of India in State of Uttar
Pradesh Through Secretary (Excise) and Others versus Mcdowell and
Company Limited reported in (2022) 6 SCC 223 in para Nos. 68 to 71
further observed as under :
68. “Negligence” is one such class of “wrongs” that leads to
liability. The fundamental jurisprudential principle of
“liability” is crisply defined in Salmond on Jurisprudence thus:
12th edn., p.349 thus :-
“Liability or responsibility is the bond of necessity
that exists between the wrongdoer and the remedy
of the wrong.”
“Liability” arises from breach of duty, which may be in the
form of an act or omission. We need not delve, for the present
purpose, on the classification of liability into civil or criminal
and remedial or penal and various other jurisprudential
features of liability. In the present case, we are primarily
concerned with the question of liability arising out of
negligence. Having regard to the questions involved and the
provisions applicable, it would be appropriate to take into
comprehension the meaning and connotation of the term
“negligence” with reference to the dictionaries, lexicons and
decided cases.
68.1. In Concise Oxford English Dictionary :11th Edn.,p.958,
the term “negligence” is defined and explained as under: “negligence▪n. failure to take proper care over
something. Law breach of a duty of care which
results in damage.”
The adjective of this expression is “negligent” and its adverb
form is „negligently‟. These expressions, for deeper
understanding need to be correlated with the verb „neglect‟
that has been defined and explained in the same dictionary as
under: “neglect ▪ v. fail to give proper care or attention to.
fail to do something. ▪ n. the state or process of
neglecting or being neglected failure to do
something.”
68.2. In Webster‟s Third New International Dictionary:1976
Edn., Vol.II, p.1513 the terms “neglect” and “negligence” are
defined and explained as under: “neglect 1 a : to give little or no attention or respect
to : consider or deal with as if of little or no
importance : DISREGARD, SLIGHT <some of the
most significant issues have been ~ed -Bruce
Payne> <~ed the real needs of the students> b : to
fail to attend to sufficiently or properly : not give
proper attention or care to ….. 2 : to carelessly omit
doing (something that should be done) either
altogether or almost altogether : leave undone or
unattended to through carelessness or by intention :
pass lightly over <~ing their obvious duty> <~ed to
mention that he was a convict –Bernard Smith>.
“negligence 1 a : the quality or state of being negligent b : a
failure to exercise the care that a prudent person usu.
exercises – opposed to diligence;”
68.3 In Black’s Law Dictionary:10th Edn.,pp.1196-1198,
“negligence” and several of its forms and features have been
explained. For the present purpose, we may usefully extract
the relevant parts as under: “negligence, n. (14c) 1. The failure to exercise the
standard of care that a reasonably prudent person
would have exercised in a similar situation; any
conduct that falls below the legal standard
established to protect others against unreasonable
risk of harm, except for conduct that is intentionally,
wantonly, or willfully disregardful of others‟ rights;
the doing of what a reasonable and prudent person
would not do under the particular circumstances, or
the failure to do what such a person would do under
the circumstances…..
active negligence. (1875) Negligence resulting from an
affirmative or positive act, such as driving through a barrier.
Cf. passive negligence.
advertent negligence. (1909) Negligence in which the actor is
aware of the unreasonable risk that he or she is creating;
RECKLESSNESS. – Also termed willful negligence; supine
negligence.
casual negligence. (1812) A plaintiff‟s failure to (1) pay
reasonable attention to his or her surroundings, so as to
discover the danger created by the defendant‟s negligence,
(2) exercise reasonable competence, care, diligence, and skill
to avoid the danger once it is perceived, or (3) prepare as a
reasonable person would to avoid future dangers.
*
*
*
gross negligence. (16c) 1. A lack of even slight diligence or
care. ● The difference between gross negligence and ordinary
negligence is one of degree and not of quality. Gross
negligence is traditionally said to be the omission of even such
diligence as habitually careless and inattentive people do
actually exercise in avoiding danger to their own person or
property. – Also termed willful and wanton misconduct. 2. A
conscious, voluntary act or omission in reckless disregard of a
legal duty and of the consequences to another party, who may
typically recover exemplary damages. – Also termed reckless
negligence; wanton negligence; willful negligence; willful and
wanton negligence; willful and wanton misconduct; hazardous
negligence; magna neglegentia.
*
*
*
inadvertent negligence. (18c) Negligence in which the actor is
not aware of the unreasonable risk that he or she is creating,
but should have foreseen and avoided it. – Also termed simple
negligence.
*
*
*
passive negligence. (18c) Negligence resulting from a
person‟s failure or omission in acting, such as failing to
remove hazardous conditions from public property. Cf. active
negligence.” 49.4. In P. Ramanatha Aiyar‟s Advanced Law
Lexicon13,
various
connotations
of
the
expression
“negligence” are stated, inter alia, in the following terms: “Negligence. Failure to use the care that a reasonable and
prudent person would have used under the same or similar
circumstances.
Negligence in law signifies a coming short of the performance
of duty.
Failure to use the care that a reasonably prudent and careful
person would use under similar circumstances.
Negligence is “the absence of proper care, caution and
diligence; of such care, caution and diligence, as under the
circumstances reasonable and ordinary prudence would
require to be exercised.”
50. Salmond on Jurisprudence refers to a terse exposition in
Grill v. General Iron Screw Colliery Co.: (1866) L.R. 1 C.P., that
negligence is “the absence of such care as it was the duty of
the defendant to use”; and further explains the subtle
distinction of inadvertent and advertent negligence in the
following: “It is to be observed, in the second place, that carelessness or
negligence does not necessarily consists in thoughtfulness or
inadvertence. This is doubtless the commonest form of it, but
it is not the only form. If I do harm, not because I intended it,
but because I was thoughtless and did not advert to the
dangerous nature of my act, or foolishly believed that there
was no danger, I am certainly guilty of negligence. But there
is another form of negligence, in which there is no
thoughtlessness or inadvertence whatever. If I drive furiously
down a crowded street, I may be fully conscious of the serious
risk to which I expose other persons. I may not intend to
injure any of them, but I knowingly and intentionally 13 5th
Edition, Vol. 3, p. 3435 14 Ibid p. 380 expose them to the
danger. Yet if a fatal accident happens, I am liable, at the
most, not for wilful, but for negligent homicide. When I
consciously expose another to the risk of wrongful harm, but
without any wish to harm him, and harm actually ensues, it is
inflicted not wilfully, since it was not desired, nor
inadvertently, since it was foreseen as possible or even
probable, but nevertheless negligently
(c).
Negligence then is failure to use sufficient care, and this
failure may result from a variety of factors…..”
51. Without multiplying the case law on the topic, sufficient it
would be to refer to the connotation of the term “negligence”
explained succinctly by this Court in the case of State of
Maharashtra and Ors. v. Kanchanmala Vijaysing Shirke and
Ors.: (1995) 5 SCC 659 as follows: “9.…„Negligence‟ is the omission to do something
which a reasonable man is expected to do or a
prudent man is expected to do...”
71. Therefore, it could be reasonably summarised for the
present purpose that failure to exercise that care which a
reasonably prudent person would usually exercise under
similar circumstances would amount to negligence; it is not
necessary that negligence would always be advertent one
where the wrongdoer is aware of unreasonable risk being
created but it may be inadvertent or passive too, arising for
want of foresight or because of some omission. However, the
question as to whether the liability because of negligence
could be fastened on the respondent company or not cannot
be determined without dealing with the other aspects related
with exceptions and defence to the allegation of negligence.”
On perusal of the aforesaid citations of the Hon'ble Apex Court on
India it appears to this Court that the respondent-plaintiffs before the
Learned Trial Court could not establish or prove any 'negligence' on the part
of the appellants to award damages in their favour. Even the plaintiffs failed
to show as to how the defendants were negligent on the subject matter in
Issue But the Learned Trial Court below in deciding the suit has failed to
appreciate or ignored the aforesaid principles of law laid down by the
Hon'ble Apex Court. Thus, in the said case, decreed the suit in favour of the
respondent-plaintiffs. So, relying upon the said principles, it can be said that
the Learned Trial Court below misconstrued the legal provisions in awarding
the damages in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs for which the judgment of
the Learned Court below cannot be sustained as per law and the same
requires interference.
[31]
From the record it appears that the appellants on humanitarian
ground paid a sum of Rs 2,00,000/- to the respondents for funeral expenses
and since the appellants have given the money to the respondents herein
and for that the appellants cannot be considered as guilty for negligence.
Furthermore, the respondent-plaintiffs by adducing oral evidence on record
have failed to satisfy the Court that due to the negligence on the part of the
appellants, the incident occurred. So, the Judgment delivered by the
Learned Trial Court cannot be sustained in the eye of law and as such, the
same suffers from different infirmities and is liable to be set aside.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is hereby allowed.
The judgment dated 26.03.2019 and decree dated 28.03.2019 delivered by
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, North Tripura, Dharmanagar in
connection with Case No.M.S.06 of 2017 is hereby set aside but considering
the facts and circumstances of this case, no order is passed as to costs.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJE BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2025.01.08 14:31:15
E
+05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review