Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.18 of 2021
Sri Satyajit Saha,
M/S. Hara Sundari Stores, 71/4,
Central Road, P.S. West Agartala,
P.O. Agartala, District: West Tripura
Authorised Importer of Cement of M/S. Premier
Cement Mills Limited, T.K. Bhawan (4th Floor), 13
Kuwaran Bazar, Dacca- 1215, Bangladesh
---- Appellant (s)
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Joint Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Civil Secretariat, Agartala
2.
The Principal Secretary,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, Agartala,
West Tripura
3.
The Chief Engineer,
Rural Development Department,
Government of Tripura, Agartala,
West Tripura
The Executive Engineer,
Rural Development Store Division,
Pandit Nehru Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura
---- Proforma-Respondent (s)
4.
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. C. Sen, Adv.
Mr. B. Paul, Adv.
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Date of Hearing
: 14.03.2024
Date of delivery
of Judgment
and Order
: 04.04.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
: YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment
dated 25.03.2021 and decree dated 07.04.2021 delivered
by Learned District Judge, West Tripura District, Agartala in
Title Appeal No.39 of 2016. By the said judgment Learned
District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala has uphold the
judgment dated 21.03.2016 and resultant decree thereof
passed by Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No.1,
Agartala, West Tripura in Title Suit No.05 of 2011.
02.
Heard Mr. B. N. Majumder, Learned Senior
counsel assisted by Mr. S. C. Sen, Learned counsel for the
appellant and Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharya, Learned G.A.
representing the state-respondents. Before entering into the
merit of the appeal let us project the subject matter of the
dispute for which the appellant-plaintiff has filed the suit
before the concerned civil court.
03.
The appellant as plaintiff filed one suit before the
court of Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No.1,
Agartala, West Tripura claiming him to be the authorized
importer of cement of M/S. Premier Cement Mills Limited,
T.K.
Bhawan
(4th
Floor),
Kuwaran
Bazar,
Dacca,
Bangladesh hereinafter referred as the cement mills and
according to him in pursuance of the tender issued by the
respondents the said Premier Cement Mills Limited got
selected as L1 bidder and entered into the agreement with
the Executive Engineer, Rural Development Department
Store Division, Agartala for supply of 16,550 M.T. cements
for an amount of Rs.8,48,57,823/-. The security deposit of
the said agreement was fixed to Rs.5,00,000/- (deposited
by the plaintiff with the said Executive Engineer, i.e. the
defendant No.3). In course of supply of cements some
problem arose with the allegation that the defendants did
not make part payment against the supply of cements and
more so, there were labour problem in Bangladesh for which
the total quantity of cements could not be supplied. Part bill
as was payable to said company was Rs.2,29,21,886/-. But
the Chief Engineer, RD Department (the defendant No.2 of
the main suit) issued a show cause notice to said M/S.
Cement Mills on 11.05.2010 and it was stipulated that if
required quantity of cement was not supplied by the said
cement company/supplier then punitive action as per clause
27(8) of the agreement would be applied for realizing the
additional expenditure form the said company which would
be required for collection of those quantity of cement from
other sources. The appellant-plaintiff thereafter met the
Chief Engineer and expressed their inability due to labour
problem as well as non-payment of part bill by the
department. It was further asserted that the Chief Engineer
had no authority to issue such show-cause notice to the
party as he was not party to the contract and more so, the
show-cause notice was issued to the party when period of
agreement had already expired. However, the concerned
Executive
Engineer
issued
another
memorandum
on
03.06.2010 proposing penalty for excess amount incurred
by the department in acquiring the balance quantity of
supply order through alternative arrangement. Said penalty
was
proposed
deposit/pending
to
be
bills.
recovered
But
before
from
the
issuance
security
of
such
memorandum, according to the appellant-plaintiff, no show
cause notice was issued by the Executive Engineer. After
that the appellant-plaintiff issued one notice under Section
80(1) of CPC seeking redress to the department and in reply
the
concerned
Executive
Engineer
vide
letter
dated
28.10.2010 regretted the representation of the appellantplaintiff. So the appellant-plaintiff filed the suit before the
Learned Trial court with the following reliefs:
(i) to declare that the show-cause notice issued by
the Chief Engineer, Rural Development Department,
Agartala vide No.F.3(10)-EE/RDSD/2009-10(P) dated
11.05.2010 was illegal, malafide, without jurisdiction
and void;
(ii) to declare that the memorandum bearing No.3(10)EE/RDSD/2009-10 dated 03.06.2010 of the Executive
Engineer, RD Store Division, Agartala was illegal,
arbitrary, malafide, without jurisdiction and void;
(iii) to pass a decree canceling/quashing the show
cause
notice
issued
bearing
No.F.3(10)EE/RDSD/2009-10 dated 11.05.2010 of the Chief
Engineer, R.D. Department, Agartala and memorandum
bearing No.F.3(10)-EE/RDSD/09-10 dated 03.06.2010
of the Executive Engineer, RD Store Division, Agartala;
(iv) pass a decree of perpetual injunction restraining
the defendants in taking any action in any manner
what-so-ever on the face of the said illegal, arbitrary
and perverse order of penalty as indicated above;
(v)pass such further or other order or orders as seem
fit and proper having regard to the circumstances of
the matter;
(vi) to grant cost and incidental to the plaintiff;
04.
The respondents as defendants contested the
suit by filing the written statement wherein they totally
denied
the
assertions
of
the
appellant-plaintiff
and
submitted that the suit was not maintainable. It was further
submitted that in the agreement there was no such
condition that in the event of any dispute the same shall be
referred to Chief Engineer whose decision will be final and
he also shall at the liberty to refer the matter to the
arbitration.
It
was
also
admitted
by
the
answering
defendant that the appellant-plaintiff was the authorized
importer of said cement mills who participated in the tender
for supply of ISI mark PVC cement and accordingly supply
order was issued and agreement was made between the
parties on 19.12.2009. It was further submitted in the
written statement that as per clause 31 of the agreement
the answering respondent-defendants were not under any
legal obligation to make any advance payment and rather it
was agreed that the payment only be made after successful
execution of the supply order. However, it was also
mentioned that the running bill would be entertainable if the
fund is available with the department and payment was
made to the supplier i.e. M/S. Hara Sundari Stores,
Agartala, i.e. the establishment of appellant-plaintiff based
on the availability of the fund. It was further referred that
as per clause-31 of the agreement the Chief Engineer was
authorized to issue show-cause notice and according to
them the supply order was issued on 09.12.2009 to supply
16550 M.T. cements within 31.03.2010, but they failed to
supply the materials as per said agreement. Therefore,
crisis of the cement continued and hindrance took place in
executing the government works in the rural areas. Even
according to the answering defendants inspite of extension
of time for 25 days was also allowed without any penalty to
supply the materials within 25.04.2010. But despite the
same, they supplied only 36% of the required quantity and
according to the answering respondents as the supplier
failed to supply 100% of the materials. So as per clause27(8) of the agreement they were liable to pay penalty. The
clause 27(8) further stipulates that in the event of failure to
supply the cement by the supplier the same will be procured
through alternative management and the security money or
the difference of cost of subsequent purchase whichever is
higher will be recovered from the supplier. Therefore,
penalty was imposed by the Executive Engineer vide
memorandum dated 03.06.2010 and prior to that a showcause notice was issued by the authority on 11.05.2010. So
the contesting defendants through their written statement
prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
05.
Upon the pleadings of the parties the Learned
Trial Court framed the following issues:
(i)Whether the show-cause Notice issued by the Chief
Engineer, Rural Development Department, Agartala
vide.,
No.F.3(10)EE/RDSD/2009-10(P).
dated
11.05.2010 was illegal, malafide without jurisdiction
and void;
(ii)Whether
the
memo
bearing
No.3(10)EE/RDSD/2009-10. Dated 03.06.2010 of the Executive
Engineer, RD concerned Division, Agartala was illegal,
Arbitrary, malafide without jurisdiction and void;
(iii)Whether the Plaintiff is entitled for decree
cancelling/quashing the show-cause notice dated
10.05.2010 issued by the Chief Engineer R.D.
Department and the memo bearing No.F.3(10)EE/RDSD/2009-10, dated 03.06.2010 issued by
Executive Engineer, R.D. Department, Agartala;
(iv)Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree of
perpetual injunction restraining the defendants;
(v)Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get any other
relief/reliefs, as prayed for.
06.
To substantiate the issues the appellant-plaintiff
examined
as
PW-1
and
he
also
relied
upon
some
documentary evidence in support of his case before the
Learned Trial court which were marked as exhibits as under:
(A) Plaintiff-Appellant’s Witness:PW-1:- Satyajit Saha
(B) Plaintiff-Appellant’s Exhibits:(1) Certified copy of agreement, dated 19.12.2009
in 67 pages [Exbt.1 (series)].
(2) Original copy of show-cause notice, dated
11.05.2010 (Exbt.2).
(3) Original letter, dated 13.05.2010 in two pages
(Exbt.3 series).
(4) Original memorandum, dated 03.06.2010
(Exbt.4).
(5) Original letter, dated 27.01.2010 in two pages
(Exbt.5)
(6) Original Letter, dated 09.07.2010 in two pages
(Exbt.6, series)
(7) Copy of Notice, dated 18.09.2010 issued as per
provisions of Section 80 (c), CPC in five pages
(Exbt.7) and
(8) Copy of reply dated, 28.10.2010 in three pages
(Exbt.8, series)
The
contesting
respondent-defendants
also
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record which are as
follows:
(C) Defendants Witnesses:DW-1:- Smt. Maiytrayee Deb
(D) Defendants Exhibits:(1)Original agreement, dated 19.12.2009 in 67
sheets (Exbt.A series).
(2)D. NIT dated 14.10.2009 in 33 (thirty three)
sheets (Exbt.B series).
(3) Supply Order, dated 09.12.2009 (Exbt.C),
(4)
Show-cause
Notice,
dated
11.05.2010,
(Exbt.D),
(5)Memo dated 03.06.2010 (Exbt.E),
(6) Reply dated 13.05.2010 (Exbt.F),
(7) Letter dated 06.04.2010 issued by the
Executive
engineer,
R.D.
Store
Division,
Gorkhabasti, Agartala (Exbt.G),
(8)Show-cause Notice, dated 16.03.2010 (Exbt.H),
(9)letter, dated 27.01.2010 issued by the
Executive Engineer, R.D. Store Division, Agartala
(Exbt.I) and
(10) Reply, dated 28.10.2010 against Notice under
Section 80, CPC, three sheets (Exbt.J, series).
07.
Finally after conclusion of trial the Learned Trial
court by judgment dated 21.03.2016 dismissed the suit of
the
appellant-plaintiff.
The
operative
portion
of
the
judgment of the Learned Trial court runs as follows:
“In the result the suit stands dismissed on contest with
cost.
This suit stands disposed of accordingly on contest.”
08.
Challenging
that
judgment
the
plaintiff
as
appellant has preferred the appeal before the court of the
Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala and the
Learned District Judge by a judgment dated 25.03.2021
delivered in Title Appeal No.39 of 2016 dismissed the appeal
of the appellant-plaintiff and uphold the judgment and
decree of the Learned Trial court below. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the
operative portion of the order of the Learned First Appellate
court which runs as follows:
“The appeal is accordingly dismissed with cost in favour
of the respondents.
The appeal is disposed of on contest.
Prepare decree accordingly within stipulated time.
Re-consign the lower court record with copies of this
judgment and decree.
Enter the result both in CIS and in relevant register.”
09.
Being dissatisfied with the judgment and decree
the plaintiff as appellant has preferred this appeal before
the High court. At the time of admission of appeal following
substantial question of law was formulated by order dated
16.11.2021 as under:
“Whether the First Appellate Court was correct in holding
that the plaintiff appellant had no authority in filing the
suit in spite of expressed authorization made by M/S.
Premier Cement and when the Respondents had
acknowledged the capacity of the Plaintiff appellant as an
authorized/local agent?”
10.
In course of hearing of argument Learned Senior
counsel Mr. B. N. Majumder assisted by Mr. S. C. Sen,
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellantplaintiff submitted that both the courts below without
application of proper mind dismissed the suit. Learned
Senior counsel further submitted that the Learned Trial
court and the First Appellate court came to an observation
that the appellant-plaintiff was a stranger to the suit. But in
this regard no such issue was framed by the Learned Trial
court. Even there was no such plea taken by the contesting
respondents that the appellant-plaintiff was a stranger and
furthermore
the
contesting
respondents
also
did
not
challenge the authority of the plaintiff to file the suit. Even
in the pleading of the contesting respondents nowhere it
was pleaded that State of Tripura was a necessary party to
the suit. Learned senior counsel further submitted that
Section-8(2) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act was not
followed by the contesting respondents and referring the
documents submitted by the appellant-plaintiff along with
the plaint Learned Senior counsel fairly submitted that the
appellant-plaintiff being the lawful agent of the bidder i.e
Premier Cement Company Limited, Dacca, Bangladesh did
all the acts on behalf of the company but the Learned courts
below without determination of the issues properly came to
an erroneous finding that the appellant was a stranger to
the suit and most arbitrarily dismissed the suit and the
Learned First Appellate court also followed the same
principle and without appreciating the subject matter of the
dispute uphold the judgment of the Learned Trial court for
which the intervention of the court is required.
11.
Learned
attention of the
Senior
counsel
further
court the original
drawn
tender
the
document,
agreement, the Power of Attorney and also the terms and
conditions of tender, show-cause notice and also some other
documents. Referring those documents Learned Senior
counsel further submitted that the judgment of the Learned
courts below are suffers from infirmities and perversities for
which the Learned Senior counsel urged for setting aside
the judgments passed by both the courts below and prayed
for granting decree in favour of the appellant-plaintiff.
12.
Per
contra,
Learned
G.A.
Mr.
Kohinoor
N
Bhattacharya appearing on behalf of the state-respondents
submitted that at this stage there is no scope to reappreciate/re-assess the evidence on record. Since both the
courts below gave concurrent findings and the appellantplaintiff could not produce and prove any document to
substantiate that he was duly authorized to file the suit on
behalf of the supplier. As such there is no merit in the
appeal and submitted that the appellant is not entitled to
get any decree or relief.
13.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides
and gone through the records of the court below including
the documents relied upon by the parties. Admittedly in the
case Learned Trial court to determine the suit in total
framed five numbers of issues. But surprisingly without
discussing anything in respect of any of the issues came to
an observation that the appellant-plaintiff being a stranger
and he had no right to sue the defendants dismissed the
suit. The Learned First Appellate court also in the same
manner
dismissed
the
appeal
rather
came
to
the
observation that the State of Tripura was not made a party
in the suit as required under Order XXVII Rule 5A of the
CPC. Before the High court by way of amendment the
appellant made State of Tripura as a party. In the case at
hand from the records of the Learned court below it appears
that Learned Trial court as already stated framed five issues
but finally dismissed the suit without deciding the issues
only on the ground that the appellant-plaintiff was a
stranger to the suit. In this regard I would like to refer the
relevant provision of Order XIV Rule 2 of CPC which
provides that:
“(1) Notwithstanding that a case may be disposed of on
preliminary issue, the Court shall, subject to the
provisions of sub-rule (2), pronounce judgment on all
issues.
(2) Where issues both of law and of fact arise in the same
suit, and the Court is of opinion that the case or any part
thereof may be disposed of on an issue of law only, it
may try that issue first if that issue relates to(a) the
jurisdiction
of
the
Court,
or
(b) a bar to the suit created by any law for the time being
in-force,
and for that purpose may, if it thinks fit, postpone the
settlement of the other issues until after that issue has
been determined, and may deal with the suit in
accordance with the decision on that issue.”
From the aforesaid provisions it appears that if
the suit is not disposed of on a preliminary issue then court
is to pronounce judgment on all issues. The Learned court
below at the time of delivery of judgment only written that
all the issues are taken up for decision. But on bare perusal
of the judgment it appears that there was not a single
whisper
by
the
Learned
Trial
court
below
regarding
discussions and decisions in respect of determination of any
issues which in my considered opinion Learned Trial court
below committed serious illegality in dismissing the suit and
the Learned First Appellate court also without giving any
observation on this matter simply on the ground that the
appellant-plaintiff was a stranger dismissed the appeal and
uphold the judgment of the Learned Trial court.
14.
Before the Learned Trial court both the parties
have adduced oral/documentary evidence. For the sake of
convenience, I think it would be prudent if some references
of the exhibited documents are reflected in the judgments.
Exbt.B series is the GNIT. In column No.2 GNIT dated
14.10.2009 it was mentioned that:
“2. Tender form (Non refundable, cost given above) may
be purchased only from the office of the undersigned on
production of Manufacturing, BIS, SSI unit registration
certificate, STCC (whichever is/are applicable to the
relevant bidder) up to 11.11.09 (office hour and date
only). Tender form will not be sold by post. The copy of
the DNIT may be inspected from the office of undersigned
and the Resident Commissioner Tripura Bhavan Kautilya
Marg, Chanakyapuri, New Delhi- 110021, Joint Resident
Commissioner, Tripura Bhavan, 1, Pretoria Street,
Kolkata-71, Deputy
High Commissioner office of
Bangladesh at Agartala up to 11.11.09 (office date and
hour only), Relevant DNIT can also be inspected at the
official
homepage
www.tenders.gov.in
and/or
www.tripurainfo.com. Tender form, downloaded from the
website or photocopy of original tender form would not
be accepted.”
The said exhibit comprises of few pages. In
special terms and conditions of the cement tender for the
Foreign bidder in column No.2, 7, 8 and 9, the following
conditions were mentioned:
“2. The foreign manufacturer must have agreement with
local (Indian) Importer having registration with the
concerned authority for importing the cement. Rate
should be quoted in Rupees (Indian currency only)
inclusive of import duty, VAT, transportation and other
applicable taxes. Rate once approved by the authority will
be fixed and no impact will be considered due to variation
in dollar rate. For any change in rate of import duty and
VAT percentage that should be on purchaser’s account.
7. The copy of registration certificate of authorization for
import of this item by the importer as well as copy of
agreement between the foreign manufacturer and the
Indian importer must be submitted along with the tender
failing which his tender will be liable to be rejected.
8. Manufacturer will make correspondences directly with
the undersigned. However if he intends to make any
correspondences through his authorized Indian importer,
the importer must be authorized by the manufacturer
through power of attorney as per provision of Indian
Law. Any correspondences/letter received by the
authorized importer from the undersigned will be treated
as received by the original bidder.
9. Bill must be submitted by the bidder in Indian currency
(Rupees) & the submitted bill must be supported by the
documents in respect of clearance of import duty against
the supply made to different district store. Without this
document no bills will be entertained. Foreign based
bidder has the right to receive payment directly or
through their importer. But payment will be made on any
Indian nationalized bank’s branch in their country only.”
As per terms and conditions of tender in column
No.9 about local inspection following condition was written:
“9. Local office/agent: Successful bidder from outside of
Agartala should have local agent/office at Agartala. All
the correspondences related with tender or supply order
will only be handed over to the local office/agent by the
tendering authority i.e. purchaser and once, anything
received by the local office/agent, it will be treated as
received by the bidder/supplier. The details of the local
office/agent may be furnished tin the tender or should be
furnished to the tendering authority before finalization of
the tender. The bidder/supplier shall have to replace the
official of local office or local agent on receipt of any
adverse report from the tendering authority against their
local office/agent. The local agent should be engaged
through power of attorney only. Local office or agent
should attend the office of the tendering authority on call.
Local office/agent should always be aware of latest
development, related with tender/supply order and
apprise the tendering authority always. Any letter receipt
by the local agent of the bidder/supplier will be treated,
as acknowledgement by the bidder/supplier and action
will be taken accordingly.”
In the column No.28 regarding disputes and
litigations following condition was mentioned:
“28. Disputes & Litigations:- Any dispute arising out of
the contracts/purchases orders issued by R.D. Deptt. only
the courts at Agartala in Tripura will have jurisdiction to
deal with the same and decide any legal matter or
disputes whatsoever arising out of the contract/purchase
order or tender.”
In column No.38 following condition was also
mentioned:
“38. Departmental authorities to make correspondence
with the bidder/supplier:- The tendering authority or any
Engineering officers of the establishment of tendering
authority or Department’s Chief Engineer, Superintending
Engineer or department’s district Executive Engineers.”
15.
Exbt.2
is
the
show-cause
notice
dated
11.05.2020 issued to the Premier Cement Mills Limited and
Exbt.3 series two sheets are the reply of the show-cause
notice. Exbt.4 is the memorandum dated 03.06.2010
wherein as per clause 27(8) of the DNIT agreement cost of
Rs.28,74,512/- was imposed upon the original cement
company
limited/supplier
with
copy
to
the
appellant-
plaintiff. Similar documents have submitted by both the
parties in the main suit. From the exhibited documents
relied upon by the parties it is crystal clear that the
appellant-plaintiff as an authorized agent of the original
cement company/bidder participated in all the processes
relating to tender and not only that he on behalf of the
company
has
signed
all
the
papers
communications
from
the
side
of
the
and
all
the
respondents
department were also issued in the name of farm of the
appellant-plaintiff. After participating in the tender by the
original company all the relevant documents on behalf of
the company were submitted by the appellant-plaintiff as an
authorized agent of the original company. Even from the
side of the contesting respondents department all the
communications were made to the appellant-plaintiff being
the authorized agent and from the agreement it appears
that the appellant-plaintiff had got valid authority to file any
suit against the contesting respondents. Learned First
Appellate court at the time of delivery of judgment referred
the provision of Sections 228, 229 and 230 of the Indian
Contract Act and opined that the case of the appellantplaintiff would not covered by the aforesaid provisions of
law. For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the relevant provisions of Section-230 of the
Contract Act, 1972:
“230. Agent cannot personally enforce, nor be bound by,
contracts on behalf of principal.—
In the absence of any contact to that effect an agent
cannot personally enforce contracts entered into by him
on behalf of his principal, nor is he personally bound by
them.
Presumption of contract to contrary.—Such a contract
shall be presumed to exist in the following cases:—
(1)where the contract is made by an agent for the sale or
purchase of goods for a merchant resident abroad;
(2)where the agent does not disclose the name of his
principal;
(3)where the principal, though disclosed, cannot be
sued.”
16.
Herein
in
the
given
case
the
original
company/supplier who participated in the tender process
and got selected from the very beginning entrusted the total
authority to the appellant-plaintiff to do all the acts on its
behalf. Thus it is clear that he had all the authority to do all
the
needful.
On
perusal
of
portion
of
Exbt.A
series
(Agreement for Appointment as Agent) in under the heading
of Scope of Work of the Agent in column No.(m) following
condition was mentioned:
“(m) The Agent will also perform such other acts and
deeds incidental and relating to the tender on behalf of
the company when required as its agent.”
But the Learned courts below without proper
appreciation of the oral/documentary evidence on record
came to an erroneous finding that the appellant-plaintiff was
a stranger to the suit. But how the appellant-plaintiff
become stranger there is no whisper in the judgment
delivered by the Trial court, even the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate court is also totally silent in this
regard. It is the admitted position that in second appeal
there is very least scope to re-appreciate/reassess the
evidence on record. Learned Senior counsel referred the
relevant provisions of Section 8(2) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 which provides as under:
“8.(2)The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall
not be entertained unless it is accompanied by the
original arbitration agreement or a duly certified copy
thereof:
[Provided that where the original arbitration
agreement or a certified copy thereof is not
available with the party applying for reference to
arbitration under sub-section (1), and the said
agreement or certified copy is retained by the
other party to that agreement, then, the party so
applying shall file such application along with a
copy of the arbitration agreement and a petition
praying the Court to call upon the other party to
produce the original arbitration agreement or its
duly certified copy before that Court.”
Referring the same, it was submitted that the
state-respondents did not comply with the said provision
and as such at this stage there is no such scope to agitate
the issue before the High court.
17.
Majumder,
During
the
Learned
course
Senior
of
argument
counsel
Mr.
appearing
B.
N.
for
the
appellant has relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India. In Bachhaj Nahar vs. Nilima
Mandal & Ors. reported in 2009 AIR SCW 287 Hon’ble
the Apex court in para-16 observed as under:
“16. The observation of the High Court that when a
plaintiff sets forth the facts and makes a prayer for
a particular relief in the suit, he is merely
suggesting what the relief should be, and that it is
for the court, as a matter of law, to decide upon
the relief that should be granted, is not sound.
Such an observation may be appropriate with
reference to a writ proceeding. It may even be
appropriate in a civil suit while proposing to grant
as relief, a lesser or smaller version of what is
claimed. But the said observation is misconceived
if it is meant to hold that a civil court may grant
any relief it deems fit, ignoring the prayer. It is
fundamental that in a civil suit, relief to be granted
can be only with reference to the prayers made in
the pleadings. That apart, in civil suits, grant of
relief is circumscribed by various factors like court
fee, limitation, parties to the suits, as also grounds
barring
relief,
like
res
judicata,
estoppel,
acquiescence, non-joinder of causes of action or
parties etc., which require pleading and proof.
Therefore, it would be hazardous to hold that in a
civil suit whatever be the relief that is prayed, the
court can on examination of facts grant any relief
as it thinks fit. In a suit for recovery of Rs.one
lakh, the court cannot grant a decree for Rs. Ten
lakhs. In a suit for recovery possession of property
`A', court cannot grant possession of property `B'.
In a suit praying for permanent injunction,
court grant a relief of declaration or possession.
The jurisdiction to grant relief in a civil suit
necessarily depends on the pleadings, prayer,
court fee paid, evidence let in, etc.”
Referring
the
same
Learned
Senior
counsel
submitted that the Learned courts below beyond the
pleadings of the appellant-plaintiff dismissed the suit which
was not sustainable in the eye of law.
18.
Per contra, Learned G.A. appearing on behalf of
the state-respondents relied upon one judgment of Hon’ble
the Supreme Court of India dated 12.03.1996 in Ramanuja
Naidu vs. Kanniah Naidu & Anr. In that judgment
Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India observed as under:
“6. In second appeal on re-appreciating the entire
evidence in the case, the learned single judge of
the High Court faulted the judgments of the courts
below to the following effect. The sale deed Ex.B-2,
is dated 5.5.1967 but was registered later, only on
8.6.1967. In view of the above delay, it is
"probable" that the document was not executed on
5.5.1967.
Re-appreciating
the
circumstance
leading to the purchase of stamp papers and other
evidence, it was held that it is not "probable" that
on 10.5.1967, Ex.B-1, usufructuary mortgage
would have been discharged and the first
defendant would not have got possession of the
property, the reason being that there was standing
groundnut crop in the property on that date and
DW-3 may not have parted with possession.
Holding that the judgments of the courts below are
perverse, the learned single judge, on appreciation
of the facts, held that the plaintiff’s document
Ex.A-1 was earlier, that he obtained title to the suit
property and so entitled to a decree of declaration
of title and possession of the property.”
Referring
the
aforesaid
citation
Learned
G.A.
submitted that since there were concurrent findings so at
this stage no relief can be granted in favour of the
appellant.
19.
After going through the documents on record of
the courts below and also the submission made by Learned
counsels it appears that both the courts below committed
serious error in dismissing the suit and appeal on the
ground that the appellant-plaintiff was a stranger in the suit
which in my considered view the Learned Trial court
committed serious error in dismissing the suit without
determining of the issues framed. From the exhibited
documents it is crystal clear that the appellant-plaintiff was
not a stranger to the suit rather he had all authority to file
the suit as an authorized agent of original tenderee/supplier
i.e. the Premier Cement Company Limited. So it would be
prudent if the suit is remanded back to the Trial court with a
direction to decide and determine all the issues framed by
the Trial court earlier with the observation that the
appellant-plaintiff has/had the authority to file the suit. The
substantial question of law is accordingly answered in
affirmative in favour of the appellant-plaintiff of this case.
20.
hereby
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
allowed
on
contest
with
costs
against
the
defendants. The judgment dated 25.03.2021 and decree
dated 07.04.2021 delivered by Learned District Judge, West
Tripura District, Agartala in Title Appeal No.39 of 2016
affirming
the
judgment
dated
21.03.2016
passed
by
Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court No.1, Agartala,
West Tripura in Title Suit No.05 of 2011 is hereby set aside
being devoid of merit. The suit is remanded back to the
Learned Trial court with a direction to decide and determine
all the issues framed earlier on the basis of material
evidence on record and to pass a judgment afresh within a
period of 3(three) months from the date of receipt of a copy
of this judgment. The case is disposed of on contest.
Pending application(s) if any, stands disposed of. Both the
parties are asked to appear in the Learned Trial court on
17.04.2024.
Prepare the decree accordingly and send down
the LCRs along with a copy of the judgment.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
Moumita
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.04.06 03:54:29
-07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review