Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 29 of 2018
1. Sri Satya Ranjan Acharjee
S/O. Lt. Sudhir Ranjan Acharjee,
2. Sri Sabinay Acharjee
S/O. Lt. Sudhir Ranjan Acharjee,
3. LRs of Lt. Sushital Acharjee,
(i) Smt. Bedashri Acharjee
W/o. Lt. Sushital Acharjeee,
(ii) Smt. Dwipinnita Acharje (Minor)
D/o. Lt. Sushital Acharjeee,
4. Smt. Khela Rani Acharjee
D/o. Lt. Sudhri Ranjan Acharjee,
5. Smt. Sandhya Rani Acharjee
D/o. Lt. Sudhir Ranjan Acharjeee,
6. Smt. Padma Rani Acharjee
D/o. Lt. Sudhir Ranjan Acharjee,
7. Smt. Sabitri Acharjee
W/o. Sri Pranabesh Acharjee,
All are residents of Vill. - Dalugaonbazar,
P.S. - Kailashahar, District - Unakoti, Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1(a) Smt. Pratibha Paul
W/O. Late Gouranga Ch. Paul,
1(b) Shri Narayan Paul
S/o. Late Gouranga Ch. Paul,
1(c) Smt. Anju Paul
daughter of Late Gouranga Chandra Paul,
1(d) Smt. Mousumi Paul alias Mani
daughter of Late Gouranga Chandra Paul,
1(e) Smt. Mitali Paul alias Mitu
daughter of Late Gouranga Chandra Paul,
All resident of Dalugaon Market,
P.O.& P.S. and Sub-Division - Kailashahar,
District - Unakoti Tripura.
-----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of Pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
: Ms. A. Pal, Adv.
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Adv.
: Mr. Raju Datta, Adv.
: 15.02.2022.
: 17.02.2022.
: No.
HON‘BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the CPC, 1908
against the Judgment dated 18.05.2018 by the District Judge, Unakoti
Judicial District, Kailashahar in Title Appeal No.16 of 2017 dismissing
the appeal, affirming the judgment and decree by the Civil Judge
(Senior Division) Unakoti, Kailashahar in T.S. No. 17 of 2016.
[2]
The brief fact of the plaintiff's (the appellant herein) case
inter-alia is that the suit land originally belonged to the father of the
plaintiffs namely Sudhir Rn. Acharjee(now deceased). The suit land is
homestead ('bastu')class of land & has a drain running from east to
west for the purpose of drainage on the suit land. After the death of
said Sudhir Rn. Acharjee, the plaintiffs and defendant No. 2 inherited
the property and their name also got mutated in the khatian No. 634 of
MoujaBirchandranagar. Subsequently, on 03-09-1997 the plaintiffs and
defendant No. 2 sold 0.10 acres of land to the defendant No. 1 vide
registered sale deed No. 1-1413 of 1997. Accordingly, the possession
was also handed over. Eventually at one point of time the defendant
No. 1 started construction on the suit land which as per the plaint, got
competed in the year 2012. On 25-12-2012 the plaintiff came to know
about this forceful encroachment of the suit land by the defendant No.
1 and on 03-05-2016 the defendant further occupied 0.01 acres of land
on the southern side of 'A' schedule which is a drain and described in
'C' schedule of the plaint. Thereafter the plaintiffs requested the
defendant to hand over the possession of the suit land but, to no result.
[3]
Thereafter, the appellant (the plaintiffs in TS 17 of 2016)
instituted a title suit against the respondents (the defendants in TS 17
of 2016) praying for a decree declaring right, title and interest and
recovery
of
possession
of
the
suit
land
pertaining
to
Mouja-
Birchandrnagar, Khatian (record of rights) No.634, C.S Plot Nos.
3356/3913, measuring -0.04 acres which is a part of land pertaining to
the sam khatian No.634, C.S. Plot NOs. 3355, 3356/3919, 3369, 3370
and measuring -1.01 acres. The suit land is described explicitly in
schedule ‘B’ of the plaint. There are two more schedules ‘A’ & ‘C’. The
‘A’ schedule of land is the total land of the plaintiff whereas ‘B’ & ‘C’ are
part of it. The ‘C’ schedule of land pertains to the same khatian and is a
drain of one feet length and measuring 0.01 acres of land. The plaintiff
sought recovery of possession of land described in ‘B’ & ‘C’ schedule
also.
[4]
For ready reference the Schedule ‘A’, ‘B’ and ‘C’ are
reproduced herein under:
(‗A‘ Schedule)
District- Unakoti, Sub-Division – Kailashahar, MoujaBirchandranagar, Khatian No.634, C.S Plot NOs, -3355,
3356/3919, 3369, 3370. Total Land measuring – 1.01
acres.
(‗B‘ Schedule)
District – Unakoti, Sub-Division- Kailashahar, MoujaBirchandrangar, khatian No. 634, C.S Plot Nos.
3356/3919, Total Land measuring 0.04 acres ( Suit land
under illegal possession of the defendant).
Bouded by- North – defendant
South – Plaintiffs
East- Plaintiffs
West – Kailashahar, Fatikroy Road.
(‗C‘ Schedule)
District- Unakoti, Sub-Division- Kailashahar, MoujaBirchandranagar, khatian No.634, there is a drain 1 fit
length and running from East and West.
Bounded by –
North – Bhuvan Singh
South - Defendant
East- Plaintiff
West- Kailashahar, Fatikroy Road
Within this boundary 0.01 acres of land. (In the sale deed
bearing No. 1-1413 of 1997 it is mentioned that this drain
will exist for passing water.)
[5]
The defendants the (respondent herein) herein filed the
written statement. In the written statement so filed, it has been
categorically stated by the respondents that the suit land along with
other lands were originally belonged to Sudhir Ranjan Acharjee, the
predecessors of the present defendant and others. After the death of
Sudhir Ranjan Acharjee, the land was mutated in the name of heirs of
Lt.
Sudhir
Ranjan
Acharjee
vide
khatian
No.634,
Mouja-
Birchandranagar. The defendants have also mentioned in their written
statement that on 03.09.1997, the defendants sold out 0.10 acres of
land vide Sale Deed No.1-1413 to the plaintiff and accordingly, the land
was in his name vide Khatian no.1347. It has been also stated in the
written statement that the plaintiff constructed a pucca building over
the present suit land in the year 2012 and on 25.12.2012, the
defendant came to know that the plaintiff forcefully enter into the suit
land in the year 2012. On 03.05.2016, the defendant forcefully
occupied 0.10 acres of land which is situated in the Southern side of
the defendant’s land.
[6]
On the basis of the rival pleadings, the Civil Judge (Sr. Div),
Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar hereinafter referred to as the trial
judge, framed the following issues in TS 17 of 2016:
I. Whether the suit is maintainable ?
II. Whether there is any cause of action ?
III. Whether the plaintiff is in possession of the suit land
since 03-091997 ?
IV. Whether the plaintiff and defendant No. 2 sold 0.10
acres of land to defendant No. 1 on 03-09-1997
appertaining
to
khatian
No.
of
MoujaBirchandranagar ?
V. Whether the defendant forcefully entered and took
possession of 'B' schedule of land ?
VI. Whether on 03-05-2016 the defendant forcefully
occupied 0.01 acres of land on the southern side of
schedule 'A' and described in schedule 'C' of the plaint ?
VII. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the decree as
prayed for ?
VIII. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for any other relief /
reliefs ?
[7]
The trial judge while deciding the issue No. I & II has
observed that the defendant raised the defence of 'adverse possession'.
Adverse possession is when the true owner of a property loses his/her
ownership rights owing to inaction on his/her part to remove a
trespasser within a statutory period from the property. After lapse of
the statutory limitation period for eviction, the true owner is barred
from initiating any legal proceeding to repossess his/her property and
the trespasser acquires title to that property by adverse/hostile
possession. This means that the true owner is to file a suit for recovery
of possesses within 12(twelve) years from the date of dispossession.
The plaint speaks that the plaintiff was dispossessed on 25.12.2012
and the suit is filed on 09-06-2016 which means that the suit is not
barred by limitation. Accordingly, I find that the suit is filed within time
and is not barred by limitation.
[8]
The suit is accordingly, maintainable in its present form and
nature and is not barred by limitation. The issues are answered
accordingly.
[9]
While deciding the Issue No.III, the trial court has observed
that the suit of the plaintiff is standing on one pillar that in the year
2012 the defendant no 1 completed construction of his shop and
included the suit land within it. This is certainly a factual aspect which
needs to be proved by evidence. There is no documentary evidence in
this regard. Now considering the evidence which is discussed above it is
found that the plaintiff could not make his such assertion probable. In
fact one of the witness totally contradicted by plaintiff stating that for
the last 16/17 years the defendant did no construction of his shop.
[10]
The vital part to be noticed is the khatian No. 634 which is
in the name of the plaintiffs. As stated above the comment column of
the khatian reflects the name of the defendant No. 1 to be permissive
possessor. The said khatian has reference of mutation No. 17/96, 204,
190/03, 123/04. These references gives an idea that the khatian is
prepared in the year 1996 & subsequently reviewed in 2003 and 2004.
The plaintiff in his cross-examination admitted that he knows that the
name of the defendant No. 1 has been shown as permissive possessor
in his khatian further admitting that he did not approach the revenue
court for correction of it. This throws serious doubt on the stand of the
plaintiff making it improbable that since 1997 up to 2012, the plaintiff
was in possession of the suit land.
[11]
Situated thus, I am of the opinion that the plaintiff could
not establish or rather could not make it probable that they are
possessing the suit land since 1997 and got dispossessed in the year
2012. The issues is answered accordingly.
[12]
The trial judge after having examined all the records so
placed in the plaint, has observed as herein under:
―In the result, the suit of the plaintiffs is dismissed
with cost.
The plaintiffs are found to be not entitled for any
decree of right, title interest along-with recovery of
possession over the suit land.
With the above said observation this instant suit
stands disposed of on contest.‖
[13]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree passed in the original suit, the appellant herein preferred an
appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.16 of 2017 in the court of the
District Judge, Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar. The said court by
its judgment dated 18.05.2018 has observed with regard to the date of
dispossession as under:
―In our case in hand admittedly no specific date of
dispossession mentioned by the appellant-plaintiffs in the
plaint rather from the evidence adduced by the plaintiffs
side it appears that the witnesses deposed for last 16/17
years the present respondent no.1 did no construction in
the suit land. On my perusal of the judgment passed by
the trial court I find that the trial court elaborately
discussed this matter in her judgment. The khatian stands
in the name of respondent no.1 also indicating that the
respondent no.1 is a permissive possessor and on the
basis of this entry in the khatian he initiated a proceeding
under section 95 of the TLR and LR Act before the
Revenue Authority with his claim for correction of entry in
the ROR and it was also in the knowledge of the present
appellants. By the passage of time after selling the land of
10 decimal and creation of aforesaid khatian no steps
taken by the present appellants prior to institution of
their title suit bearing no.17 of 2016.‖
The
lower
appellate
court
by
the
judgment
dated
18.05.2018 has dismissed the appeal preferred by the appellants.
[14]
Being aggrieved by the said judgment dated 18.05.2018,
the appellant herein has preferred this instant appeal under Section
100 of the CPC. At the time of admitting this appeal, the following
substantial question of law was framed by this court by the order dated
28.08.2018.
―No one witness on behalf of the present appellants
deposed how and in which manner the present
respondent applied force in dispossessing the present
appellant and thereby the learned trial court arrived at a
findings that the present appellants could not establish
that the present respondent No.1 forcefully occupied the
‗B‘ and ‗C‘ schedule land of the plaint.‖
[15]
It is the case of the appellant that he is the owner and in
possession of the suit schedule property and since the defendant has
dispossessed and raised construction in 2012, the plaintiff filed the suit.
Admittedly, the defendant did not deny the said allegation and claim
adverse possession upon the property and also admitted, title of the
plaintiff.
The
trial
court
on
the
ground
of
cause
of
action,
maintainability, limitation has opined in the favour of the plaintiff. But
on the point of adverse possession, since the date of dispossession is
not proved, the same has been held against the plaintiff and the suit
has been dismissed.
[16]
The defendant also filed another suit with regard to the suit
schedule property which is schedule B in earlier suit filed by the
plaintiff.
Schedule
B
has
already
been
reproduced
above.
The
defendant filed another suit seeking relief which is Schedule B property
in the court below and the court below has dismissed the said suit since
the plaintiff in suit has not made any case in support of his contention.
[17]
Thus, both the suits filed by the plaintiff and the defendant
in respect of the suit schedule property were dismissed. It is has been
reported by the counsel for the parties that their respective suits were
dismissed separately on the same date but they were not clubbed. It is
not known as to why both the suits were not taken up together as one
suit for claimant and another suit towards counter claim by the plaintiff
of the other suit.
[18]
Aggrieved by the judgment of the trial court both the
parties preferred appeal before the lower appellate court and the lower
appellate court dismissed both the appeals confirming the judgment
and decree passed by the trial court. The defendant in the first suit is
also plaintiff in the other suit did not challenge the lower appellate
court order and registered his case by inviting dismissal of the suit and
the appeal. However, the present RSA is filed by the plaintiff in TA 16
of 2017 and TS 17 of 2016 and the defendant therein has not preferred
any RSA.
RSA has been admitted and the substantial question of law
is framed which has been extracted above.
[19]
Mr. S. M. chakraborty, Senior Counsel has argued that the
order of the lower court is perverse since the court below has accepted
the case in favour of the plaintiff with regard to maintainability,
limitation and title and also the adverse possession but dismissed the
suit because
the date of dispossession has not been established and
prayed to allow the appeal and set aside to the order of the court below
and decree the suit.
[20]
Mr. Somik Deb, senior counsel for the respondents has
placed his reliance on Section 65 of Limitation Act,1963 and Section 6
of the Specific Relief Act,1963 and contended that the law of limitation
of 12 years comes into force and the plaintiff-appellant is not entitled
for any relief since the defendant were in the adverse possession. For
ready reference Section 65 of Limitation Act of 1963 and Section 6 of
the Specific Relief Act,1963 are extracted herein under:
Description of suit
Period of limitation
65. For
possession of
immovable property or any
interest therein based on
title.
Explanation.—For
the
purposes of this article—
(a) where the suit is by a
remainderman,
a
reversioner (other than a
landlord) or a devisee, the
possession
of
the
defendant shall be deemed
Twelve years.
Time from which period
begins to run
When the possession of
the defendant becomes
adverse to the plaintiff.
to become adverse only
when the estate of the
remainderman,
reversioner or devisee, as
the case may be, falls into
possession;
(b) where the suit is by a
Hindu
or
Muslim
entitled to the
possession of
immovable
property on the death of a
Hindu or Muslim female,
the possession of the
defendant shall be deemed
to become adverse only
when the female dies;
(c) where the suit is by a
purchaser at a sale in
execution of a decree
when the judgment-debtor
was out of possession at
the date of the sale, the
purchaser shall be deemed
to be a representative of
the judgment-debtor who
was out of possession
Section 6 of Specific Relief Act of 1963
―6. Suit by person dispossessed of immovable property.—
(1) If any person is dispossessed without his consent of
immovable property otherwise than in due course of law,
he or any person claiming through him may, by suit,
recover possession thereof, notwithstanding any other
title that may be set up in such suit.
(2) No suit under this section shall be brought—
(a) after the expiry of six months from the date of
dispossession; or
(b) against the Government.
(3) No appeal shall lie from any order or decree passed in
any suit instituted under this section, nor shall any review
of any such order or decree be allowed.
(4) Nothing in this section shall bar any person from
suing to establish his title to such property and to recover
possession thereof.‖
[21]
Mr. Somik Deb, senior counsel has relied upon the following
judgments:
(i) C. Doddanarayana and Others vs. C. Jayarama Reddy reported in
(2020) 4 SCC 659 where the apex court has observed in the following
manner:
25. The question as to whether a substantial question of
law arises, has been a subject matter of interpretation by
this Court. In the judgment reported as Karnataka Board
of Wakf v. Anjuman-E- Ismail Madris-Un-Niswan8, it was
held that findings of the fact could not have been
interfered within the second appeal. This Court held as
under: (SCC pp. 347-48, paras 12-15)
―12. This Court had repeatedly held that the power of the
High Court to interfere in second appeal under Section
100 CPC is limited solely to decide a substantial question
of law, if at all the same arises in the case. It has
deprecated the practice of the High Court routinely
interfering in pure findings of fact reached by the courts
below without coming to the conclusion that the said
finding of fact is either perverse or not based on material
on record.
13. In Ramanuja Naidu v. V. Kanniah Naidu (1996 3 SCC
392), this court held
"It is now well settled that concurrent findings of fact of
trial court and first appellate court cannot be interfered
with by the High Court in exercise of its 8 (1999) 6 SCC
343 jurisdiction under Section 100 of Civil Procedure
Code. The Single Judge of the High Court totally
misconceived his jurisdiction in deciding the second
appeal under Section 100 of the Code in the way he did."
14. In Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty (1996 6 SCC
166), this Court held :
"Interference with the concurrent findings of the courts
below by the High Court under Section 100 CPC must be
avoided unless warranted by com- pelling reasons. In any
case, the High Court is not expected to reappreciate the
evidence just to re- place the findings of the lower courts.
… Even as- suming that another view is possible on a
reappreci- ation of the same evidence, that should not
have been done by the High Court as it cannot be said
that the view taken by the first appellate court was based
on no material."
15. And again in Secy., Taliparamba Education Soci- ety v.
Moothedath Mallisseri Illath M.N. (1997 4 SCC 484), this
Court held: (SCC p. 486, para 5)
"5……The High Court was grossly in error in trenching
upon the appreciation of evidence under Section 100 CPC
and recording reverse finding of fact which is
impermissible."
(ii) Hemaji Waghaji Jat vs. Bhikhabhai Khengarghai Harijan reported in
(2009) 16 SCC 517 where the apex court has observed in the following
manner:
17. The facts of R. Chandevarappa & Others v. State of
Karnataka & Others (1995) 6 SCC 309 are similar to the
case at hand. In this case, this court observed as under:"11. The question then is whether the appellant has
perfected his title by adverse possession. It is seen
that a contention was raised before the Assistant
Commissioner that the appellant having remained
in possession from 1968, he perfected his title by
adverse possession. But the crucial facts to
constitute adverse possession have not been
pleaded. Admittedly the appellant came into
possession by a derivative title from the original
grantee. It is seen that the original grantee has no
right to alienate the land. Therefore, having come
into possession under colour of title from original
grantee, if the appellant intends to plead adverse
possession as against the State, he must disclaim
his title and plead his hostile claim to the
knowledge of the State and that the State had not
taken any action thereon within the prescribed
period. Thereby, the appellant's possession would
become adverse. No such stand was taken nor
evidence has been adduced in this behalf. The
counsel in fairness, despite his research, is unable
to bring to our notice any such plea having been
taken by the appellant."
18. In D. N. Venkatarayappa and Another v. State of
Karnataka and Others (1997) 7 SCC 567 this court
observed as under:"Therefore, in the absence of crucial pleadings,
which constitute adverse possession and evidence
to show that the petitioners have been in
continuous and uninterrupted possession of the
lands in question claiming right, title and interest
in the lands in question hostile to the right, title
and interest of the original grantees, the
petitioners cannot claim that they have perfected
their title by adverse possession."
19. In Md. Mohammad Ali (Dead) By LRs. v. Jagadish
Kalita & Others (2004) 1 SCC 271, paras 21-22, this Court
observed as under:
"21. For the purpose of proving adverse
possession/ouster, the defendant must also prove
animus possidendi.
22. ....We may further observe that in a proper case
the court may have to construe the entire pleadings
so as to come to a conclusion as to whether the
proper plea of adverse possession has been raised
in the written statement or not which can also be
gathered from the cumulative effect of the
averments made therein."
20. In Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Govt. of India (2004)
10 SCC 779 at para 11, this court observed as under:-
"11. In the eye of the law, an owner would be
deemed to be in possession of a property so long as
there is no intrusion. Non-use of the property by
the owner even for a long time won't affect his
title. But the position will be altered when another
person takes possession of the property and
asserts a right over it. Adverse possession is a
hostile possession by clearly asserting hostile title
in denial of the title of the true owner. It is a wellsettled principle that a party claiming adverse
possession must prove that his possession is "nec
vi, nec clam, nec precario", that is, peaceful, open
and continuous. The possession must be adequate
in continuity, in publicity and in extent to show that
their possession is adverse to the true owner. It
must start with a wrongful disposition of the
rightful owner and be actual, visible, exclusive,
hostile and continued over the statutory period."
The court further observed that
―11…plea of adverse possession is not a pure
question of law but a blended one of fact and law.
Therefore, a person who claims adverse possession
should show: (a) on what date he came into
possession, (b) what was the nature of his
possession, (c) whether the factum of possession
was known to the other party, (d) how long his
possession has continued, and (e) his possession
was open and undisturbed. A person pleading
adverse possession has no equities in his favour.
Since he is trying to defeat the rights of the true
owner, it is for him to clearly plead and establish all
facts
necessary
to
establish
his
adverse
possession.‖
(iii) Poona Ram vs. Moti Ram reported in (2019) 11 SCC 309 where the
apex court has observed in the following manner:
―19. The plaintiff has to prove his case to the satisfaction
of the Court. He cannot succeed on the weakness of the
case of the defendant. Even otherwise, there is no
confusion at all regarding the identity of the property in
question and on the basis of material on record, the First
Appellate
Court
has
correctly
ruled
that
the
appellant/Defendant No. 1 has proved his title and
possession over the suit property since the date of his
purchase of the property. Prior to the purchase, his
predecessor-in-interest was in possession of the same.
20. Having regard to the position of law and facts of the
case, we are of the considered opinion that the High Court
was not justified in interfering with the judgment of the
First Appellate Court, which has come down very heavily
on the procedure adopted by the trial Judge in deciding
the matter, more particularly when no fault can be found
on facts with the judgment of the First Appellate Court.
Generally, it is not open to the High Court to interfere
with the findings of fact recorded by the First Appellate
Court when such findings are based on the evidence on
record, and are not perverse or against the material on
record.‖
[22]
Senior counsel for the respondent further argued on the
point of limitation as the suit is barred by the limitation, in view of the
adverse possession the delay in filing the suit is hit by limitation and
the suit is liable to be dismissed. On the point of limitation the plaintiff
is not entitled for any relief for filing of the suit and same is not
maintainable and prayed to dismiss the RSA but whereas the trial court
and the lower appellate court on the point of limitation has already held
in favour of the plaintiff and the suit is also maintainable and answered
accepting the argument on the point of limitation since the same is not
challenged, the said argument on the point of limitation is not
considered.
[23]
Admittedly it is not in dispute with regard to the title,
limitation and maintainability of the suit in favour of the plaintiffappellant. The only point which where the case of the plaintiff
has
been negative is that the plaintiff could not prove his date of
dispossession. The case of adverse dispossession was also not denied
by the defendant. The defendant also accepted the title in favour of the
plaintiff. Having agreed upon the title and the adverse possession which
is undisputed by the defendant cannot be held that the plaintiff is not
entitled for the relief sought for. Once the court comes to a conclusion
and when the defendant has not opposed the right title and interest of
the boundary land, the plaintiff is entitled for protection of his
immovable property. Once the conclusion is in favour of the plaintiff, he
is entitled for all consequential reliefs. It is the case of the plaintiff that
the plaintiff and the defendant know each other for quite some time
and it was open land. The defendant having interest in the adjacent
property has raised construction and in the process land of plaintiff has
been occupied by defendant.
[24]
Till the construction was raised the property was vacant
and the same was in possession of the plaintiff and by raising the
construction in part of the land of plaintiff by the defendant, the
defendant has dispossessed the plaintiff with regard to the schedule B
Property. Since the defendant also has not established his case with
regard to adverse possession of the property and has failed to come
over the judgment of the apex court in Karnataka Board of Wakf vs Govt.
of India reported in (2004) 10 SCC 779 where the court has observed in
the following manner:
―11…Adverse possession is a hostile possession by clearly
asserting hostile title in denial of the title of true owner.
It is a well- settled principle that a party claiming adverse
possession must prove that his possession is 'nec vi, nec
clam, nec precario', that is, peaceful, open and
continuous. The possession must be adequate in
continuity, in publicity and in extent to show that their
possession is adverse to the true owner. It must start
with a wrongful disposition of the rightful owner and be
actual, visible, exclusive, hostile and continued over the
statutory period. (See : S M Karim v. Bibi Sakinal AIR
1964 SC 1254, Parsinni v. Sukhi (1993) 4 SCC 375 and D
N Venkatarayappa v. State of Karnataka (1997) 7 SCC
567). Physical fact of exclusive possession and the
animus possidendi to hold as owner in exclusion to the
actual owner are the most important factors that are to
be accounted in cases of this nature. Plea of adverse
possession is not a pure question of law but a blended
one of fact and law. Therefore, a person who claims
adverse possession should show (a) on what date he
came into possession, (b) what was the nature of his
possession, (c) whether the factum of possession was
known to the other party, (d) how long his possession
has continued, and (e) his possession was open and
undisturbed. A person pleading adverse possession has no
equities in his favour. Since he is trying to defeat the
rights of true owner, it is for him to clearly plead and
establish all facts necessary to establish his adverse
possession.‖
[25]
Since the defendant has failed in proving the adverse
possession in the light of the conditions framed by the apex court in
Karnataka Board of Wakf (supra)this court has no hesitation to say that
the suit needs to be decreed in favour of the plaintiff with all
consequential reliefs.
Accordingly, the appeal is allowed.
The order passed by the trial court dated 30.08.2017 and
the order passed by the lower appellate court dated 18.05.2018 are set
aside.
Accordingly, the suit is decreed with costs.
The registry is directed to prepare the decree accordingly.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review