The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. Ms. Purakayastha, learned counsel has submitted that the judgment passed by the Single Judge is unjustified, unreasonable, arbitrary, unwarranted in law and facts and as such, no tenable in the eye of law and liable to be set aside.
9. After hearing the argument as advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as scrutinized the records we are of the opinion that the appellant has made gross negligence in discharge of his duties and failed to supervise his subordinates which enabled three convicts to escape. According to this court, the appellant while attending a workshop which was a part and parcel of his official responsibility was not on vacation. Moreover, when he was attending the workshop it was his responsibility to keep a track with his subordinates about the safety and security in Jail. He was totally negligent in discharging his duty. He has to periodically call up his subordinates to whom he has given the charge and verify what is happening in Jail, whether things are alright, whether the convicts are fine, whether they are provided proper food in right time or not, whether proper security is provided. Keeping a check and issuing instruction and again cross checking with other Officer whether the first caller before whom he has spoken is right or not? It only includes the responsibility. But he has miserably failed to do his responsibility. In terms of the above observation, this appeal stands dismissed. Sabyasachi B CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A.184 of 2021
Sri Santosh Bahadur,
son of Late Harka Bahadur
of Thakurpalli Road, Krishnanagar,
P.O. Agartala, District – West Tripura
……….Appellant(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary cum Commissioner,
Department of Home (Jail), Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala,
West Tripura
2. Chief Secretary,
Government of Tripura, Secretariat Building,
New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
3. Secretary, Department of Home(Jail),
Secretariat Building, New Capital Complex,
P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura, (Disciplinary Authority)
4. Inspector General of Prisons,
Government of Tripura, Prisons Directorate,
Agartala, West Tripura, P.O. Dhaleswar
5. Commissioner of Departmental Inquiries,
Government of Tripura, Secretariat Annexe,
Pandit Nehru Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
……….Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Ms. R. Purakayastha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, G.A.
Mr. S. Saha, Adv.
Date of Hearing of
Judgment & Order
:
05.01.2023
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order(Oral)
[Chief Justice (Acting)]
Heard Ms. R. Purakayastha, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant.
2.
The fact of the case of the appellant is that the appellant had
joined in Kendriya Sanshodhanagar on 31.03.2016 as Superintendent in
Charge. On 21.10.2016, three convict prisoners fled away from Kendriya
Sansodhanagar. In connection with this unwanted incident, a disciplinary
proceeding was drawn against the appellant. On 28.02.2017, the appellant had
submitted his detailed defence statement. On 11.12.2017, the Inquiring
Authority had submitted his finding with the most illegal observation. Against
the finding of the Inquiring Authority, the appellant had submitted his detailed
representation on 30.12.2017. But the disciplinary authority by the impugned
memo dated 20.01.2018 proposed a penalty of reduction of pension by 7.5%
for a period of three years w.e.f. the date of superannuation of the appellant.
Against the memo dated 20.01.2018 proposing the penalty, the appellant had
submitted the representation dated 12.02.2018. But this representation of the
appellant had not been considered and the respondent No.3 has passed the
impugned order of Penalty vide No.F.X-498/IGP/2016(P)/719-21 dated
17.02.2018 issued by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, the
respondent No.3 whereat most illegally a penalty of reduction of pension by
7.5% for a period of three years w.e.f. the date of superannuation has been
imposed upon the appellant.
3.
The contention of the appellant is that he had not exhibited any
negligence in discharge of his duties. The internal inquiry of the department
suggested that there was no involvement of the appellant. But most illegally,
the respondent No.2 without any basis and absolutely on his own whims had
placed the appellant, along with two others under suspension. On perusal of
the note sheet dated 23.10.2016, it would appear that the respondent No.2
had reached to the observation that the appellant is responsible for dereliction
of duty on the basis of the reports submitted by the respondent No.4 and
SDPO but most surprisingly in any of these reports, there is not even a single
word against the appellant in respect of any negligence or fault or dereliction
on his part in connection with this incident. Rather, his prompt action has been
highly appreciated in these reports. However, subsequently, the departmental
charge-sheet came to be filed and the disciplinary authority wrongly concluded
that the appellant was guilty of misconduct. Moreover, the finding of the
Inquiring Authority is highly illegal and not tenable in the eye of law as none of
the witnesses has uttered a single word against the appellant nor none of the
documents so exhibited prove his guilt. The Inquiring Authority had submitted
his finding with the most illegal observation “Hence, Sri Santosh Bahadur, A.O.
is found partially guilt and it is decided accordingly.” This inquiry report is not
at all tenable in the eye of law because the charges so alleged against the
appellant in the articles of charges are not at all of financial nature. So, there
can be no question of the appellant to be „partially guilty‟. Either the appellant
can be guilty or not guilty, there cannot be any mid way to the same.
Moreover, as per the CCS(CCA) Rules and as per judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex
Court witness cannot function as enquiry Officer. Moreover, the Enquiry Officer
must be an official superior to the A.O. But in the instant case in hand, Sri Bani
Kantha Debbarma was the Presenting Officer, who was junior to the appellant
during his service. As such, this entire enquiry procedure has been null and
void in view of violation of the mandate of law.
4.
The memorandum of charge, the enquiry report as well as the
impugned order of punishment is surprisingly vague and not at all as per law.
It is very unfortunate that in the impugned order of punishment, it is simply
stated that the enquiry officer in his findings had hold that the accused Officer
is partially guilty to the charges brought against him. In the said memo, no
where it has been stated that due to violation of which Section or Rule which
specific charge, this penalty has been imposed upon the appellant. It is
pertinent to mention here that no specific violation of any provision has been
made out either in the impugned enquiry report or in the impugned order of
punishment. Moreover, the violation of provisions of law that have been
attracted against the appellant in the memorandum of charge was not even
sustained after submission of the defence statement by the appellant.
5.
The learned Single Judge vide order dated 05.08.2020 delivered
in WP(C)No.259 of 2018 has given the following decision which reads as under:
“9. As noted, the charge against the petitioner was of
negligence in discharge of his duties and failure to supervise
his subordinates which enabled three convicts lodged in the
jail to escape. The Inquiry Officer in his report has discussed
the materials on record at considerable length. The
disciplinary authority has accepted the findings of the Inquiry
Officer and after enabling the petitioner to make a
representation, imposed punishment. It is well settled that
the findings arrived at by the disciplinary authority in a duly
constituted domestic inquiry would not be open to
interference unless they are shown to be perverse. No
perversity is pointed out in the present case. Even otherwise,
it can easily be appreciated that three prisoners were facing
convictions, escaped from jail by devising a plan as simple as
taking out a 20 feet long iron pipe from a kitchen shed and
placing it on the wall of the jail for climbing over and
escaping. It was not an externally intelligent plan devised
which with a minimum of care and vigilance the jail staff
could not have anticipated and prevented. To begin with, why
the fact of a missing iron pipe from the shed of the kitchen not
reported is not clear. Further, the watch and ward staff Sri
Ashu Kr. Jamatia whose duty was to guard a particular watch
tower, was absent when this incident took place. The
petitioner was in-charge of Kendriya Sansodhanagar. He
cannot escape his liability by simply suggesting that it was a
duty of the lower staff to guard the jail and ensure against
any escape of the inmates.
10. Coming to the question of the imposition of a cut in
pension, looking to the proved charges, the same cannot be
stated to be disproportionate, leave alone grossly
disproportionate. The cut in pension is not permanent but
would operate only for a period of 3(three) years.
12. As a result, the petition fails and is dismissed.”
6.
Ms. R. Purakayastha, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
has referred to paras-4 and 5 of the Review Pet.No.12 of 2021 dated
18.03.2021 where it has been stated as follows :
“4. Learned counsel Ms. R. Purakayastha for the petitioner
raised two contentions :
(i) That on the date of the incident of the three convicts
escaping from the jail, the petitioner was not in charge. He
was attending a workshop and had handed over the charge to
the Deputy Jailor and (ii) that the Presenting Officer was
examined as a witness in the departmental inquiry which was
contrary to the Government of India instructions under
CCS(CCA) Rules.
5. She recollects having raised both these contentions while
conducting hearing of the writ petition and points out that
these contentions were not dealt with in the judgment. I am
prepared to go back her recollection. Despite this, I do not
think the petitioner has made out a case for review. Firstly,
there was not even a finding in the departmental proceedings
that on the particular date when the incident took place, the
petitioner was present, was in-charge and that is how he had
exhibited negligence in discharge of his duties. In the
judgment dismissing the writ petition also, what was
observed was that the convicts escaped from the jail by
devising a plan which was as simple as taking out 20 feet long
iron pipe from a kitchen shed, placing it on the wall of the jail
and climbing over and escaping. It was observed that this was
not a very complicated plan and which with minimum of care
and vigilance by the jail staff could have been prevented. The
petitioner as In-charge of the jail cannot escape his liability by
simply suggesting that it was a duty of the lower staff to
guard the jail and ensure against any of the inmates
escaping.”
7.
Ms. R. Purakayastha, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
has submitted that the learned Single Judge has justified the finding of guilt of
the appellant by the disciplinary authority just on the ground that the appellant
at that relevant point of time, has hold the charge of Superintendent in Charge
and not for his negligence in duty. And just because of this post of
entrustment, the appellant has been held guilty. Going by that analogy all the
other officials including the Jailor, and even the IG Prison should have been
charged but unfortunately, the appellant became the scapegoat only. From the
enquiry report, it is revealed it was the stand of the appellant that on the
fateful day, the appellant along with the Jailor had gone to Pragna Bhawan,
Agartala to attend the workshop at 9 a.m. on “HIV/AIDS”, in their respective
official capacity and as such, he had returned to his office in the evening. And
therefore, on that day, the duty of allotment of Watch and Ward Staff of KST
was done by the Deputy Jailor. This stand of the appellant has not been
nullified by the respondents during the enquiry proceedings. According to
learned counsel, the appellant had not exhibited any negligence.
8.
Ms. Purakayastha, learned counsel has submitted that the
judgment passed by the Single Judge is unjustified, unreasonable, arbitrary,
unwarranted in law and facts and as such, no tenable in the eye of law and
liable to be set aside.
9.
After hearing the argument as advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the appellant as well as scrutinized the records we are of the
opinion that the appellant has made gross negligence in discharge of his duties
and failed to supervise his subordinates which enabled three convicts to
escape. According to this court, the appellant while attending a workshop
which was a part and parcel of his official responsibility was not on vacation.
Moreover, when he was attending the workshop it was his responsibility to
keep a track with his subordinates about the safety and security in Jail. He was
totally negligent in discharging his duty. He has to periodically call up his
subordinates to whom he has given the charge and verify what is happening in
Jail, whether things are alright, whether the convicts are fine, whether they are
provided proper food in right time or not, whether proper security is provided.
Keeping a check and issuing instruction and again cross checking with other
Officer whether the first caller before whom he has spoken is right or not? It
only includes the responsibility. But he has miserably failed to do his
responsibility.
In terms of the above observation, this appeal stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi B
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review