Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.216 of 2022
1. Sri Sanjit Sil, Son of Sri Jahar Lal Sil, resident of Poangbari, P.O.Melaghar, P.S. Melaghar, District- Sepahijala Tripura
2. Smt. Papiya Ghosh, D/O- Sri Harisankar Ghosh, R/O - Sarashima, P.O Sarashima and PS- Belonia , District- South Tripura.
………Appellant(s);
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Department of
Panchayet, Government of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Complex,
P.O- Secretariat Complex, P.S. New Capital Complex, Pin- 799010,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2. The Secretary, Employment Services Manpower Planning, Government
of Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Complex, P.O - Secretariat
Complex, PS.- New Capital Complex, Pin-799010, Agartala, West Tripura.
3. The Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Rural Development
(Panchayet) Department, Government of Tripura, having his office at
Secretariat Complex, P.O - Secretariat Complex, PS.- New Capital
Complex, Pin-799010, Agartala, West Tripura.
4. The Secretary Cum Commissioner, Finance Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Complex, P.O - Secretariat
Complex, PS.- New Capital Complex, Pin-799010, Agartala, West Tripura.
5. The Director, Panchayet Department, Government of Tripura,
Gorkhabasti, Pandit Nehru Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. NCC. Agartala,
West Tripura.
6. Sri Haribindu Biswas, C/O - Jaharlal Biswas, R/O- Vill - Laxmipur,
Machmara, PO- Machmara, PS- Pecharthal, Sub-Div- Kumarghat, DistUnakoti,Pin-799263.
7. Smt. Alaka Debnath, C/O- Sri Haridas Debnath, Vill- West Lalcharri, POKulai Bazar, PS- Ambassa, Sub-Div- Ambassa, Dist- Dhalai Tripura, Pin799204
8. Sri Bijay Debnath, C/O, Bimal Debnath , Vill- Kamal Nagar, POChampak Nagar, PS- Jirania, Dist-West Tripura, PIN-799045.
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. D. Sarkar, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.,
Mr. K. Debnath, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Whether fit for reporting: YES / NO
Order
23/05/2023
Heard Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel for the appellants and Mr.
Somik Deb, learned senior counsel representing private respondents
No.6 to 8. Also heard Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned Additional
Government Advocate appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioners are the appellants herein aggrieved by the common
impugned Judgment and Order dated 20th July, 2020 passed in a batch of
writ petitions wherein the selection and appointment to the post of Rural
Programme Manager (RPM) under the Department of Panchayet,
Government of Tripura pursuant to the notice of employment dated
4th October, 2015 was under challenge.
3.
Willing candidates were asked to appear for a walk-in interview
on different dates at different places as provided in the notice with their biodata along with their original testimonials of their educational qualification
and the testimonials relating to Indian Citizenship.
4.
By the impugned Judgment and Order, the learned Writ Court
has refused to interfere in the selection and appointment of the non-official
respondents to the post of RPM and except WP(C) No.334 of 2018 [Smt.
Sarmistha Chakraborty v. State of Tripura and others] where the
distinguishing facts where in relation to the marks obtained by the said
petitioner who despite being an Honours Graduate, had been allotted
14(fourteen) marks instead of 28(twenty eight) marks. Rest of the writ
petitions were dismissed. In the case of Smt. Sarmistha Chakraborty, the
learned Writ Court directed the respondents to verify if the said petitioner
was awarded 28(twenty eight) marks for qualification on considering her
Honours degree or not; and if it was found so, they shall make necessary
amendment in the tabulation sheet, if required. The grounds of challenge
were multifold in all the writ petitions and one of the grounds related to
allocation of marks depending upon the marks obtained in the qualifying
exam, i.e. the Graduation Examination.
The present writ petitioners’ case was dealt with at Paragraph 37 of
the impugned Judgment and Order which is extracted hereunder:
“[37]
Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel has appeared for the
petitioners and Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned GA has appeared for
the official respondents, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior
counsel along with Ms. P. Sen, learned counsel have appeared for the
non-official respondents No.6 to 8.
The petitioners have challenged the selection of the nonofficial respondents to the post of RPM and have simultaneously
urged
for
considering
their
appointments
to
the
said post in pursuance to the employment notice dated 05.10.2015.
There is no dispute that the petitioners had appeared in the walk-ininterview
for
selection
to
the
said
post.
The petitioner No.1 secured 44.4% marks in the Graduation and he
had completed the course of Master of Rural Management and
Development [MRMD] from Tripura University. The petitioner No.2
secured
44.96%
in
his
Graduation
[B.Sc.]
and
he had the degree of MRMD from Tripura University. According to
the petitioners, the non-official respondents are less meritorious and
their selection has been done in gross violation of the guidelines
dated 12.01.2015 issued by the respondent No.1. According to them,
all the non-official respondents were awarded 28 marks under the
minimum educational qualification but they were not entitled to so. As
a result, the petitioners have been eliminated wrongfully.
The official respondents and the non-official respondents
filed their reply separately and contested the challenge as raised by
the petitioners. They have stated that the main grievance of the
petitioners is that the non-official respondents have been awarded 28
marks against the educational qualification when they did not deserve
it and awarding of 28 marks in favour of the non-official respondents
is illegal and arbitrary. The official-respondents have negated the
guidelines as laid down for purpose of selection. The respondents
have stated that the petitioners have intentionally suppressed the fact
that the non-respondents were all Honours Graduates. The Selection
Committee which evolved a principle of weightage following the
guidelines of Tripura University has awarded 28 marks against the
Honours Graduate vis-à-vis the Pass Graduate. Since the Graduation
with Honours is indisputedly a higher qualification, according to the
Tripura University guidelines, by awarding the candidates 28 marks
having Honours Degree, no illegality has been committed by the
Selection Committee. As such, there is no infirmity in the appointment
of the non-official respondents and others.”
5.
In the present appeal, Mr. D. Sarkar, learned counsel for the
appellants, relying upon the advertisement dated 4th October, 2015 at Page74 (Annexure-1) and the General Employment Guidelines contained in
office memorandum dated 12.01.2015 issued by the General Administration
(Personnel & Training) Department, Government of Tripura at Page-80,
submits that the petitioners/appellants herein was not allotted 40(forty)
marks despite having a Post Graduation qualification. Learned counsel for
the appellants has further sought to draw the attention of this Court to the
Merit List at Page-85 and specially referred to the candidate at Serial No.326
who has been allotted 40(forty) marks on the basis of his Post Graduate
qualification compared to the writ petitioners/appellants herein who has
been allotted only 14(fourteen) marks.
6.
The illustration appears to be far-fetched on the face of it as
against the same candidate at Serial No.326 at Column containing the
percentage of Graduation marks, it is shown as 60, which as per the
yardsticks applied by the Selection Committee entitled him to get 40(forty)
marks. The criteria as laid down in the General Employment Guidelines also
containing memorandum dated 12.01.2015 under (Category-2) as under :
“(ii) Maximum marks to be allotted to evaluate Educational
Qualifications: 40 Marks.
(a) 30% - 44% Marks obtained in qualifying Exam.
(b) 45% - 59% Marks obtained in qualifying exams.
= 14 Marks
= 28 Marks
(c) 60% and above Marks obtained in qualifying Exams.= 40 Marks”
7.
The only modification that was made by the Selection
Committee in this criteria was to allot 28(twenty eight) marks even to
candidates who had scored more than 40% marks in the Graduation
examination and were having Honours degree. Since this yardstick was
applied uniformly and a reasonable classification was made by the Selection
Committee in a transparent manner, the learned Writ Court refused to
interfere in the award of marks. The marksheets of the 2(two)
petitioners/appellants herein annexed to the writ appeal and the facts of the
present petitioners/appellants herein dealt at Para 37 of the impugned
Judgment and Order also do not leave any room of doubt that both the
petitioners had got less than 45% marks in the Graduation i.e. 44.4% and
44.96% and were not Graduate with Honours.
8.
Allotment of marks on the basis of a higher qualification was
not the yardstick as per the advertisement and the procedure adopted by the
Selection Committee. While this classification of marks amidst Graduates
without Honours and with Honours have been assailed in the present writ
proceedings, petitioners in any case would not succeed as having scored less
than 45% marks in Graduation without Honours. They would, in any case,
get 14(fourteen) marks only. This issue has also been dealt with by the
Coordinate Bench of this Court of which one of us (Arindam Lodh, J.) was a
member.
9.
In WA No.31 of 2021 and other analogous appeals arising out
of the Judgment rendered by the Writ Court in several writ petitions raising
the same issue. The discussion on this issue has been made at paragraph 13
to 17 which are extracted hereunder:
“13.
The only point which has been contended by the writ
petitioners who are the unsuccessful candidates appear before this
court is on the point of discrimination in adopting the government
issued memorandum in providing selection and appointments to the
post of Rural Programme Manager (RPM) in the Panchayat Raj
Department. The attention of this court has been drawn by the counsel
appearing for the petitioner that the minimum Educational
qualification for the post of RPM was Graduation. Interview Board
divided the homogeneous group of Graduate into 2 Groups i.e.
Graduation with Pass and Graduation with Honours. The Private
respondents who are Graduation with Honours, they were given 28
marks (extra marks of 14), beyond the memorandum 12.01.2015.
Accordingly, the candidates who are not selected are before this
court.
14.
The learned Single Judge has passed an elaborate order
dealing with all contentions. The points which came for consideration
before this court by the counsel appearing for the appellants herein is
on the point of discrimination.
15.
From a fair reading of Article 14 of the Constitution of
India though it deals with regard to maintaining of equality, it needs
to be treated as equality amongst the equals. It is a question of
selection of candidates and providing them employment, this court
considers that the selection committee would give more preference for
highly educated and qualified candidates for the purpose of selection.
16.
During the course of argument, Mr. Roy Barman, learned
senior counsel appearing for the appellant has placed before this
court an information under the RTI Act which was taken with surprise
by learned Advocate General where in the said information it is stated
that there are still 53 vacancies to be filled up and the cases of the
appellants would be considered. It is not for this court to express any
opinion on the same but further, it is needless to say that wherever the
vacancies are available, the welfare State will take pragmatic view
and might consider and fill up the vacancies as per its procedure.
17.
In the light of the judgment of the apex court in Baidyanath
Yadav(supra) and Union Public Service Commission(supra) it is
categorically stated that unless any malafide is attributed and the
same are proved, any allegations made with regard to the selection
process has no weightage. In the present writ appeals at hand, the
petitioners failed to established the point of malafide and with regard
to the awarding of marks, this court feels that no interference needs to
be done, since the selection procedure which has been categorically
dealt by the learned Single Judge needs no inference and the same is
confirmed.
Accordingly, the writ appeal is dismissed.”
10.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the private
respondents and Mr. Mangal Debbarma, learned Additional Government
Advocate for the State respondents, have asserted that the classification
made by the Selection Committee in award of marks to candidates who had
secured Honours in Graduate course vis-à-vis those who were Graduates
with Pass Course is a reasonable classification with a rational nexus to the
objects sought to be achieved and is permissible under Article 14 of the
Constitution of India. It has been applied uniformly and in a transparent
manner. As such, the learned Writ Court refused to interfere in the Selection
Process. The same issue has been squarely discussed and upheld in appeal
by this Court in the case of Sri Saikat Saha v. The State of Tripura and
Others in WA No.31 of 2021 and other analogous appeals vide Judgment
dated 14.12.2022. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed as no
distinguishing features have been made out on the part of the appellants.
11.
On consideration of rival submission of the parties and the
grounds on which the impugned Judgment and Order has been challenged,
we are of the considered view that no infirmity can be pointed out in the
reasonings of the learned Writ Court so far as it refused to interfere in the
selection procedure on the instant criteria of allocation of marks between
Graduates with Pass Course and Graduates with Honours subject. On facts,
we find that petitioners/appellants herein who have obtained less than 45%
marks have been rightly allotted 14(fourteen) marks as per the prescribed
criteria. Since the petitioners had not secured Honours in Graduation this
distinction, in any case, is not going to make good their case any further.
12.
As such, the appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(ARINDAM LODH), J
Pijush
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review