The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
03. 09.2019 and 03.10.2019 and on both the dates as well the present petitioners were absent without step in the original suit. [26] Finally on 16.12.2019 the present petition was filed by the petitioners. [27] The above chronology of events would clearly show that the plea of the petitioners that they were unaware about the existence of the exparte order dt. 16.05.2018 cannot be accepted by this Court and therefore the cause shown by them to set aside the exparte order dt. 16.05.2018 cannot be dubbed as a good cause within the meaning of Order IX Rule 7 of CPC. [28] On perusal of the original record I also find that summons upon the present petitioners in the original suit had been served in the year 2018 and therefore the statutory limit of 90 days for filing the written statement imposed by Order VIII Rule 1 CPC is over long ago. [29] In any case it is well settled by now that the Court cannot enlarge the statutory limit of 90 days for filing WS but can accept a belatedly filed WS if sufficient cause is shown for the delay. [30] In the case at hand, even after more than three years of receipt of summons in the original suit, the present petitioners have not yet prepared or presented their written statement and in fact seek further opportunity to present the same which cannot be countenanced in law. [31] The sole point for determination is thus decided accordingly in the negative…
16. 05.2018, the respondents should have filed a petition under Order IX Rule 7 CPC. Instead, it was mistakenly filed as Order IX Rule 13 CPC. But the trial Court should not have rejected their petition on this mere technical ground without examining the merit of the petition. It is also argued by learned senior counsel that admittedly the respondents are the co-sharers of the suit property and without their participation, it would be difficult for the trial Court to adjudicate the partition suit. Counsel, therefore, urges the Court to set aside the impugned order passed by the learned trial Court. [9] Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior advocate submits that for fair ends of justice, the petitioners may be asked to file appropriate petition under Order IX Rule 7 CPC and the trial Court may be requested to decide the petition on merit. [10] Considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties by their respective senior advocates. Perused the materials available before this Court. [11] Since the matter is pending before the trial Court from the year 2017, it would not be appropriate to ask the petitioners to approach the trial Court by filing a fresh petition under Order IX Rule 7 CPC because a recourse to such means will cause further delay in the disposal of this long pending matter. [12] It is true that there was inordinate delay on the part of the defendant petitioners in appr…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No. 73 of 2022
Shri Sanjit Kr. Saha & Ors.
. . . . . Petitioners
Versus
Md. Mustafizur Rahman & Ors.
. . . . . Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. A. De, Adv.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Order
23/11/2022
The petitioners have challenged the order dated 09.12.2021 passed by
the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Sonamura in Sepahijala Judicial District in case
No. Civil Misc. (Condonation) No. 02 of 2019 arising out of TS (P) No.121 of 2017.
[2]
Heard Mr. S. Deb, learned senior advocate appearing for the petitioners
along with Mr. A. De, learned advocate. Also heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned
senior advocate appearing for the respondents along with Mr. K. Nath, learned
advocate.
[3]
Mr. Deb, learned senior advocate submits that in TS (P) No.121 of 2017
in the Court of the Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.) in West Tripura at Agartala, the present
petitioners were the respondents and the present respondents were the plaintiffs. It
is submitted that the present respondents being plaintiffs instituted the partition suit
before the trial court seeking relief under the Specific Relief Act. They prayed to the
trial court to pass a preliminary decree declaring the shares of the plaintiff and the
defendants over the suit property and thereafter, issue a final decree on the basis of
report to be obtained from the Survey Commissioner. Mr. Deb, learned senior
counsel refers to various orders passed by the trial Court during the proceedings of
the said partition suit. Learned counsel has drawn the attention of this Court to the
order dated 16.05.2018 passed by the trial Court in the partition suit whereby the
learned trial Court decided to proceed ex parte against respondents No.1,2,3,4 and 5
since there was no step on behalf of the said defendants on 16.05.2018. By the
same order, trial Court directed the plaintiffs of the suit who are the respondents in
the present petition to file requisites afresh for issuing notice upon defendants No.6
and 7 since the first notice was not reported to have been served on defendants
No.6 and 7. It would be appropriate to reproduce the brief order passed by the
learned trial judge on 16.05.2018 which reads as under:
“Today was fixed for SR/step by the plaintiff side.
Ld. Counsel Sankar Bhattacharjee is present on behalf of the
plaintiff side.
No step on behalf of defendant No. 1 , 2 , 3, 4 and 5.
Hence, the instant suit will proceed ex parte against them.
Summons upon defendant No.6 is not yet returned service.
Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff side is directed to file fresh
requisites for issue of fresh summons upon defendant NO.6.
Ld. Counsel for the plaintiff is also directed to file fresh
requisites for issue of fresh summons upon defendant No. 7.
Issue fresh summons upon defendant No 6 and 7 if requisites
are filed and found proper.
Fix 12.07.2018 for SR/WS.”
[emphasis supplied]
[4]
Aggrieved with the said order, the present petitioners who were the
defendants in the trial Court filed two petitions at the trial Court on 16.12.2019. Both
the petition were supported by affidavit dated 16.12.2019. By one of those petitions
filed under Order IX Rule 13 read with section 151 CPC, the petitioners who were
defendants at the trial Court pleaded that the order to proceed ex parte against the
defendant petitioners passed by the trial Court on 16.05.2018 was required to be set
aside for fair ends of justice since they wanted to contest the title suit. Since such
petition was filed belatedly, the said defendant petitioners filed a separate petition
under section 5 of the Limitation Act for condoning the delay of 605 days in filing the
petition for setting aside the said order dated 16.05.2018.
[5]
Learned counsel of the petitioners has contended that the petition for
condonation of delay was registered as Civil Misc. (Condonation) No.02 of 2019 and
the petition for setting aside the ex parte order dated 16.05.2018 was registered as
Civil Misc. (J) No.05 of 2019. The genesis of both these petitions was rooted in the
order dated 16.05.2018 passed in TS (P) No.121 of 2017.
[6]
Mr. S. Deb, learned senior advocate appearing for the petitioners have
argued that the learned trial Judge has decided Civil Misc. (Condonation) No.02 of
2019 and Civil Misc. (J) No.05 of 2019 by separate orders dated 09.12.2021 passed
in the respective files. Counsel has pointed that both the orders are identical and by
the order passed in Civil Misc. (Condonation) No.02 of 2019, the learned Civil Judge
(Sr. Divn.) held that the respondent petitioners should not have quoted Order IX
Rule 13 CPC in their petition for the relief claimed by them. Instead, they should
have quoted Order IX Rule 7 CPC and according to the trial Court, the limitation
period for filing such petition was 3 years. The Court held that the need of filing a
petition for condonation of delay would not have arisen had it been a petition under
Order IX Rule 7 CPC. The trial Court accordingly dismissed the petition. The relevant
extract of the order passed by the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.) in Civil Misc.
(Condonation) No.02 of 2019 reads as under:
“[22]
It is well settled that no specific period has been
prescribed by the Limitation Act, 1963 or by any other statute for
preferring an application under Order IX Rule 7 of CPC and such
application can therefore be made within 03 years in view of the
provision contained in Article 37 of Limitation Act, 1963.
[23]
This position law has been reiterated in Delhi
Development Authority vs. Shanti Devi reported in AIR 1982 Del
159.
[24]
In the case at hand the order declaring that the
original suit bearing No. TS (P) 121 of 2017 shall proceed exparte
against the present petitioners was passed on 16.05.2018 and
therefore the petition for setting aside the said order which was
filed on 16.12.2019 was filed well within the period of limitation of
3 years.
[25]
From the above discussion it is clear that the present
prayer for condonation for delay is infructuous and it has been
filed under the mistaken assumption of the petitioners that their
remedy against the order dt. 16.05.2018 passed in the original suit
lies in the provision of Order IX Rule 13 of CPC instead of Order IX
Rule 7 of CPC.
[26]
The sole point for determination is thus decided
accordingly.
ORDER
[27]
On the strength of the reasons discussed in the body of
the order, the present prayer is dismissed on the ground of being
infructuous.”
[7]
Learned counsel has also referred to the order dated 09.12.2021 passed
by the learned trial Judge in Civil Misc. (J) 5 of 2019 whereby the learned trial Judge
dismissed the petition for setting aside the order passed by the trial Court to
proceed ex parte against the respondent petitioners. The said order reads as under:
“[18]
The petitioners also wish to be relegated back to the
position of the original suit as on 16.05.2018 and seek opportunity
to file written statement in the original suit.
[19]
However, strangely the petitioners have filed the
prayer under Order IX Rule 13 of CPC in the original suit which is
not at all appropriate as the said provision deals with setting aside
exparte decree against the defendants but in the original suit no
such exparte decree has been passed by the Court.
[20]
In fact, the proper petition which should have been
filed by the petitioners would have been under the provision of
Order IX Rule 7 of CPC which states that where the Court has
adjourned the hearing of the suit exparte, and the defendant, at or
before such hearing appears and assigns good cause for his
previous non-appearance, he may, upon such terms as the Court
directs as to costs or otherwise, be heard in answer to the suit as if
he had appeared on the day fixed for his appearance.
[21]
In the case at hand on perusal of the original record of
TS (P) 121 of 2017 I find that on 16.05.2018 no step was filed on
behalf of the present petitioners before the Court of Ld. Civil Judge
(Sr. Divn) Court No.4, Agartala and therefore on that date the
Court was pleased to declare that the original suit would proceed
exparte against the present petitioners.
[22]
On the next date i.e. 12.07.2018 Ld. Counsel Mr. N. Dey
had appeared on behalf of the present petitioners and had filed a
petition praying for time to submit written statement which was
rejected by the Court on the ground that the statutory period for
filing written statement was over. It was also specifically noted in
the said order that the suit was proceeding exparte against the
present petitioners vide order dt. 16.05.2018 which was yet to be
vacated.
[23]
Perusal of the original record also indicates that on
08.08.2018 the original case record was transferred to this Court
from the Court of Civil Judge (Sr. Divn), Court No.4, Agartala on
creation of new Judicial District of Sepahijala.
[24]
Perusal of the original record indicates that on
03.05.2019 this Court issued fresh notice to both the parties and
on 12.06.2019 Ld. Counsel Mr. M.K. Saha appeared on behalf of
the present petitioners and again filed a petition praying for time
to submit written statement which was rejected by this Court after
noting that the original case was proceeding exparte against the
present petitioners vide order dt. 16.05.2018 which was yet to be
vacated.
[25]
The next date fixed was on 16.07.2019 and on that
date no step was filed on behalf of the present petitioners in the
original suit and subsequently the case was deferred to
03.09.2019 and 03.10.2019 and on both the dates as well the
present petitioners were absent without step in the original suit.
[26]
Finally on 16.12.2019 the present petition was filed by
the petitioners.
[27]
The above chronology of events would clearly show
that the plea of the petitioners that they were unaware about the
existence of the exparte order dt. 16.05.2018 cannot be accepted
by this Court and therefore the cause shown by them to set aside
the exparte order dt. 16.05.2018 cannot be dubbed as a good
cause within the meaning of Order IX Rule 7 of CPC.
[28]
On perusal of the original record I also find that
summons upon the present petitioners in the original suit had
been served in the year 2018 and therefore the statutory limit of
90 days for filing the written statement imposed by Order VIII
Rule 1 CPC is over long ago.
[29]
In any case it is well settled by now that the Court
cannot enlarge the statutory limit of 90 days for filing WS but can
accept a belatedly filed WS if sufficient cause is shown for the
delay.
[30]
In the case at hand, even after more than three years
of receipt of summons in the original suit, the present petitioners
have not yet prepared or presented their written statement and in
fact seek further opportunity to present the same which cannot be
countenanced in law.
[31]
The sole point for determination is thus decided
accordingly in the negative.”
[8]
It is submitted by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel that the trial Court
has taken a very technical approach in the matter which would defeat the ends of
justice. Counsel fairly submits that obviously for setting aside the order dated
16.05.2018, the respondents should have filed a petition under Order IX Rule 7 CPC.
Instead, it was mistakenly filed as Order IX Rule 13 CPC. But the trial Court should
not have rejected their petition on this mere technical ground without examining the
merit of the petition. It is also argued by learned senior counsel that admittedly the
respondents are the co-sharers of the suit property and without their participation, it
would be difficult for the trial Court to adjudicate the partition suit. Counsel,
therefore, urges the Court to set aside the impugned order passed by the learned
trial Court.
[9]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior advocate submits that for fair ends of
justice, the petitioners may be asked to file appropriate petition under Order IX Rule
7 CPC and the trial Court may be requested to decide the petition on merit.
[10]
Considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties by their
respective senior advocates. Perused the materials available before this Court.
[11]
Since the matter is pending before the trial Court from the year 2017, it
would not be appropriate to ask the petitioners to approach the trial Court by filing a
fresh petition under Order IX Rule 7 CPC because a recourse to such means will
cause further delay in the disposal of this long pending matter.
[12]
It is true that there was inordinate delay on the part of the defendant
petitioners in approaching the trial Court for setting aside the ex parte order passed
against them. But after they approached the Court, the trial Court seems to have
denied relief to them merely on the ground that they quoted a wrong provision in
their application. This is a mere technical ground for which substantial justice cannot
be denied to any party, particularly when the relief claimed by the respondent
petitioners was available under the law and the Court was competent to grant such
relief. Moreover, the suit being a partition suit and the respondent petitioners being
co-sharers of the suit property, the trial Court should hear them for fair adjudication
of the dispute pending before it. In this view of the matter, the impugned order
passed by the learned trial Court stands set aside and the petition is allowed.
[13]
The trial Court is directed to allow the defendant petitioners to submit
their written statement and proceed to decide the matter in accordance with law.
However, for the delay caused by the petitioners in the progress of the suit, cost of
Rs.2,000/- is imposed on them which shall be paid by them to the plaintiff
respondents through their counsel within a period of 4 (four) weeks from today.
[14]
Supply copy of this order to learned counsel representing the parties.
Also communicate the order to the learned trial Court immediately.
[15]
In terms of the above, the matter is disposed of. Interim order(s), if
any, shall stand vacated.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review