Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
RSA. No. 40 of 2018
1.
Sri Samarjit Kr. Majumder, son of late Barada Kanta
Majumder, resident of Gangail Road (behind Rest House),
Town Bardowali, Agartala, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District: Tripura West, PIN-799003.
…..Defendant No.4-Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Sri Debabrata Majumder, son of late Ranjit Kr. Majumder,
***as per Hon’ble Court’s order dated 29.01.2019 passed
in connected I.A. No. 01 of 2019, the present address of
the respondent No.1 is incorporated in the cause title as
follows:
Presently residing at Banglow-8, Road No.5, Riverside
Township, Barnpur, District: Bardhaman, West Bengal,
Pin-713325
2.
..... Plaintiff-respondent
Smt. Minati Majumder, wife of late Dilip Kumar
Majumder,
3.
Sri Subrata Majumder, son of late Dilip Kumar Majumder,
4.
Smt. Manidipa Majumder, daughter of late Dilip Kumar
Majumder
All are residents of Gangail Road (behind Rest House),
Town Bardowali, P.O. Agartala, District: Tripura West,
Pin-799001.
5.
Sri Ajit Kumar Majumder, son of late Baroda Kanta
Majumder,
6.
Sri Sujit Kumar Majumder, son of late Baroda Kanta
Majumder
Both residents of Gangail Road (behind Rest House),
Town Bardowali, P.O. Agartala, District: Tripura West,
Pin-799001.
7.
Smt. Jyotsna Deb Majumder, wife of late Ranjit Kumar
Majumder,
8.
Smt. Ratnadeepa Majumder, wife of Sri Dilip Majumder,
daughter of late Ranjit Kumar Majumder,
Both residents of Chandralaya Apartment, Flat No.4,
Srirampur, North Road, Garia, Kolkata-84, West Bengal
[***as per Hon’ble Court’s order dated 15.05.2019,
passed in connected I.A. No.02 of 2019, the address of the
respondent Nos.7 and 8 are inserted in the following way:
Presently residing at C/O Sri Dilip Kr. Majumder, 2nd
Floor, SHIVAM APARTMENT, 100, BRIJEE, West
Road, Garia, Kolkata-70084, West Bengal]
9.
Smt. Niharkana Majumder (Baidya) wife of late Rabindra
Baidya, P.O. & P.S. Hriswamukh, Belonia, District: South
Tripura,
10.
Smt. Latika Majumder (Baidya), wife of Harihar Baidya,
Opp. To Belonia Hospital, P.O. & P.S. Belonia, District
South Tripura.
.....Defendant Nos. 2, 3, & 5-8 respondents.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. D. Deb, Advocate.
Mr. T. D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. T. Halam, Advocate.
04.02.2022
10.02.2022
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted
by Mr. D. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellant. Also heard
Mr. T. D. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. T. Halam,
learned counsel and Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the CPC against the
judgment and decree dated 30.07.2018 passed by the learned Additional
District Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with the
case No. Title Appeal No. 18 of 2017 allowing the appeal of the appellantplaintiff by modification partly setting aside the judgment and decree dated
20.02.2017 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court
No.2, Wet Tripura, Agartala in case No. T.S. (P) 150 of 2012 granting
partition of the suit land in 1/8th share except the land of the WILL
(Exbt.C) bequeathed to the defendant No.4, the appellant herein by his
mother. At the time of admitting the appeal, the following substantial
question of law was formulated by this Court:
“Whether the finding that the execution of Will is full of doubt and
visited with suspicious circumstances is testament and the evidence
as led by the beneficiary?”
[3]
The facts that would essentially be required for appreciating
the substantial questions of law may be introduced at the beginning. Sri
Debabrata Majumder, the respondent herein has instituted a suit for
partition and declaration of right, title and interest in respect of their
respective equal shares which they are entitled to. He has claimed that he
defendant No.4, the appellant herein, has undertaken a construction work
whereby, the huts where he along with his family members used to reside
have been totally guarded creating serious obstructions to their ingress and
egress to go out of their hut and also to enter into their hut. He has further
claimed that the appellant has no right to undertake any fresh construction
works without the suit land being partitioned in equal shares amongst the
co-sharers. As such, he has prayed to remove/demolish the building which
the appellant, the defendant-4 has constructed during the pendency of the
suit by way of granting mandatory injunction. After hearing the parties,
vide judgment & decree dated 09.02.2018, the learned Appellate Court
allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit observing as under:
“The plaintiff and the defendants to the suit are directed to make amicable
partition of the suit land as mentioned above within two months from the
date of this judgment. If the parties to the suit fail to make partition of the
suit land amicably as indicated above, each party to the suit shall be at
liberty to approach the Court for partition by metes and bounds with the
help of Survey Commissioner to be appointed by the competent court, with
a prayer for passing final decree.
Accordingly, the judgment and decree dated 20.02.2017 and 08.03.2017
respectively passed by the learned Civil Judge (Sr.) Division, Court No.2,
Agartala, West Tripura in connection with T.S.(P) 150 of 2012 is hereby
set aside and the instant appeal filed by the plaintiff-appellant is allowed.
The instant appeal is thus disposed of.”
[4]
It reveals from record that when the plaintiff has instituted the
suit, he had no knowledge of any WILL executed by his grandmother in
favour of the defendant No.4, the appellant herein and has came to learn
about the fact of the WILL after going through the contents of the written
statement filed
by the appellant which led the plaintiff to file an
application for amendment wherein the plaintiff has challenged the
genuineness of the WILL and he has prayed for declaring the said WILL
void ab initio.
[5]
The factual matrix which are evident from the plaintiff, the
respondent herein, are that one Barada Kanta Majumder, the grandfather of
the plaintiff was the original owner of the suit land measuring 19 gandas, 3
karas and 2 krantas described in detail in the schedule of the plaint. Lt.
Barada Kanta Majumder has left behind his wife Smt. Subhasini
Majumder and five sons. The plaintiff has stated in the plaint as well as in
the examination-in-chief that before filing of the suit for partition there
were several attempts to partition the suit land amicably but, all attempts
failed and that invited the cause of action of the present suit. He has further
stated that Lt. Subhasini Majumder who was bed ridden was in a state of
precarious health and for that it was impossible for her to execute any
WILL. It has been further stated that his grandmother was literate lady and
was able to read and write when she was in good health. So he has prayed
for declaring the said WILL as void ab initio.
[6]
During his cross-examination, the plaintiff has denied the fact
of execution of WILL as his grandmother lost total memory power in her
last 5/6 years till her death. In his evidence, he has stated that despite order
of injunction passed by the learned trial Court the defendant No.4, the
appellant has constructed a building which is totally obstructing their free
ingress and egress as aforestated. No consent was taken by the defendant
No.4 not only from him but also from the other evidence. He has further
stated that there was/is no permission taken from the Agartala Municipal
Council and the building was constructed in utter disregard to the
municipal rules and is liable to be demolished by way of granting
mandatory injunction.
[7]
During cross-examination, he has denied that his grandmother
used to visit the market frequently and she was physically and mentally fit
till her death. The appellant has filed his written statement and stated that
he has no objection to the partition of the suit land in equal shares but he is
entitled to the share of his mother Lt. Subhasini Majumder, who according
to him, during her life has executed a WILL dated 16.07.1997. He has
admitted that the construction of the building in his share of land including
the share of his mother. He has pleaded that the WILL is genuine and there
are attesting witnesses also. He has categorically pleaded that the
plaintiff’s suit for partition and declaration of right, title and interest,
confirmation of possession and permanent injunction as well as mandatory
injunction is totally misconceived and is without any basis of law.
[8]
The defendant Nos. 1(a), 1(b), 1(c), 2, 3, 7 and 8 by filing
their joint written statement specifically admitted the maintainability and
cause of action of the suit. In their pleading they have stated that Lt.
Subhasini Majumder, lost her memory totally since 5/6 years before her
death and she was completely unfit physically and mentally. They also
have stated that several initiatives were taken to partition the suit land
amicably but yielding no result. The plaintiff-respondent has deposed
before the trial Court and also cross-examined as stated above. He has
supported his case made in the plaint and he has denied the execution of
the WILL dated 16.07.1997.
[9]
In the cross-examination he has stated that “it is also not a
fact that she was physically and mentally fit till her death, after the death
of her husband.” It is not a fact that she used to visit the market
frequently.” From his evidence, it is clear that there is no dispute in regard
to the title of the original owner, Lt. Baroda Kanda Majumder and of the
legal heirs of Lt. Baroda Kanta Majumder are entitled to get their
respective shares. He in his evidence has stated that taking the advantage
of their absence the defendant No.4, the appellant herein illegally started
construction on the vacant space despite his serious objection. He has
relied upon the documents submitted by the appellant which are marked as
Exbt. A, B and C, namely, (i) Original Death Certificate of Lt. Subhashini
Majumder (Exbt.A), (ii) Original Survival Certificate of Lt. Subhashini
Majumder (Exbt.B), (III) Original registered WILL vide No. III-199 dated
16.07.1997 (Exbt.B), (iv) Signature of DW2 in the WILL (Exbt.C/1), (v)
Signature of DW3 in the WILL (Exbt. C/2), (vi) Signature of DW6 in the
WILL (Exbt.C/3) and (vii) Original ration card in the name of Samarjit
Majumder & Others (Exbt.D).
[10]
The defendant No.4, the appellant herein in his examination in
chief has deposed that he is the son of Lt. Barada Kanta Majumder. He has
stated that his father Lt. Barada Kanta Majumder was the absolute owner
of the suit land who died on 28.12.1970 without making any partition of
the suit land amoung his legal heirs and after the death of his father, his
mother Subhashini Majumder stayed with him till her death i.e. up to
28.12.1998. He also stated that hit mother Lt. Subhashini Majumder being
one of the co-sharers of the property left behind by his father, executed a
WILL (Exbt.C) for her share in his favour on being satisfied with his
service. The learned trial court did not discuss anything about the
statement of DW-1 which he made during his cross-examination.
[11]
A very important and significant aspect has come out in his
statement that the executants of the WILL never gave any thumb
impression during her life time, whereas the WILL dated 16.07.1997
reveals that the testatrix Subhashini Majumder has put her thumb
impression on the said WILL (Exbt.C). The said statement made by the
defendant No.4 himself arises suspicious circumstances in the due
execution of the WILL. He has denied the fact that his mother was almost
blind during the fag end of her life but in his cross-examination he has
admitted that he received show cause notice from the Agartala Municipal
Council in connection with the sanction of plan of the building. He has
admitted that he did not receive the sanction plan from the AMC for
construction of building. He has further admitted the fact that the suit land
was not portioned amongst the co-sharers of the suit land.
[12]
DW-2, Pabitra Chandra Datta, one of the attesting witnesses
of the WILL deposed that he put his signature in the WILL executed by the
mother of the appellant in the year 1997. He identified his signature in the
WILL marked as Exbt. C/1. He has stated that he put his signature after
registration of the.
[13]
The said DW-2 is one of the attesting witnesses and it is very
strange and surprising that he being the attesting witness has put his
signature in the deed after registration of the WILL. Another important
aspect has come out from his evidence that he has supported the claim of
the plaintiff that the moment the defendant, the appellant undertaken
construction works, the appellant approached the learned court with a
prayer for grant of temporary injunction and also with a petition for police
help. The learned court very reasonably has passed the order restraining
the plaintiff-respondent from undertaking any construction works.
[14]
DW-3, Dhirendra Debnath, another attesting witness of the
WILL (Exbt.C) in his examination in chief has stated that on 16.07.1997
he put his signature as attesting witness. It was executed in favour of the
defendant-appellant by his mother. The said witness during his cross
examination has stated that he does not know the number of share holders
in the partition suit he has stated that he put his signature on the last page
and he also could not say the page number of the WILL. He has
specifically stated that the maker put her signature on the WILL first and
then he put his signature. Later on, the witness has stated that the maker
gave thumb impression in the WILL. He has categorically stated that he
did not go through the sheets of the WILL.
[15]
DW-4, Sishir Das stated in his examination in chief that in the
first quarter of the year 1997 the mother of the appellant expressed that she
wanted to execute a WILL in favour of the appellant bequeathing her share
in the suit land. In his cross-examination he has stated that he could not say
when the will was executed but he has stated that it could have been
executed. He has stated that 5 years back the appellant undertook
construction works. This Statement is not supported by any of the
witnesses including DW-1 himself. It was constructing the building
illegally.
[16]
DW-5 Somesh Debbarma is the witness of the office of Sub-
Registrar and he has stated that he has no personal knowledge about the
execution of the WILL. Importantly, the said witness has stated that he did
not even receive the thumb impression of Subhashini Majumder. It also
raises a suspicious circumstance in the due execution of the WILL
(Exbt.C).
[17]
DW-6, Narayan Paul, is the deed writer of the WILL and he
has stated that the attesting witnesses put their signatures in the said WILL
and he wrote the WILL as per the dictation of the maker Lt. Subhashini
Majumder. He has further stated that at the time of registration, Lt.
Subhashini Majumder appeared before the Sub-Registrar but, during his
cross-examination he has stated that he does not know the quantum of
share of Lt Subhashini Majumder though the WILL was written as per
dictation of the maker.
[18]
DW-7, Sujit Kumar Majumder, is one of the sons of Lt.
Barada Kanta Majumder. He has stated that the said land was not divided
and demarcated. The health condition of his mother was very bad before 2
years of her death. He has further stated that Lt Subhashini Majumder lost
her mental balance and also absent mindedness and loss of memory prior
to the making of the WILL. The precarious condition of her health was
extended up to five years of her death. His mother was literate and she was
able to write her signature. He has made a specific statement that his
mother never put her thumb impression during her life time. The said
statement has received support from the statement of DW-1. He has stated
that his brother, the appellant herein, constructed the building for which
the jut of the latest brother i.e., father of the plaintiff-respondent has badly
been affected by ingress and egress. He has further stated that no consent
was taken from them before construction of the pucca building by the
appellant herein. He also stated that he had never seen any deed writer to
visit their house for writing the WILL.
[19]
DW-7, Sujit Kumar Majumder, in his examination-in-chief
has deposed that all the witnesses and the signatories in the deed of WILL
are the relatives and friends of the appellant and neither his family
members nor the local people of the places where they reside are the
witnesses to the said WILL dated 16.07.1997. he has further stated that Lt.
Subhashini Majumder was a literate lady and she could write her name
both in English and Bengali. But, in the WILL it is found that his mother
put her thumb impressions which itself proves that the said WILL is a false
and fabricated one.
[20]
DW-8, Smt Minati Majumder also supported the statements of
DW-7. Mentionably, Minati Majumder is the eldest daughter in law of Lt.
Subhashini Majumder who is the wife of Lt. Dilip Kumar Majumder.
[21]
From the above discussion it reveals that all the defendants
and their witnesses have stated including the defendant No.4, the appellant
herein that their mother in law was literate and she could write both in
English and Bengali. The entire notion of pleadings and evidence of
defendant No.4, the appellant and his witnesses i.e. Des 2, 3, 4 and 5, till
her last breath she was physically fit and was in full state of mind and
reasons of understanding which was controverted by DWs-7 and 8 who are
one of the sons and daughter in law of the Lt. Subhashini Majumder that
since 5/6 years before her death she was suffering from total imbalance of
mind and was almost blind.
[22]
It is very noticeably that the appellant who has deposed who
has deposed as DW-1 in whose favour the WILL was made, has himself
stated that his mother never gave thumb impression during her life time
and she was a regular reader of religious books of Sr. Sri Swarupananda
Maharaj. But, it is not explained in his evidence why his mother put thumb
impression on the body of the WILL i.e. Exbt. C. This fact also has been
supported by DWs-7 and 8. DW-3 has stated that Lt. Subhashini
Majumder put her signature in the WILL at the first instance, later on; he
has stated that the maker gave thumb impression in the WILL. This type of
answer definitely casts a doubt in the mind of this Court and according to
this Court the said witness is not at all credible and thus this evidence is
bereft of any merit about the execution of the WILL.
[23]
In the light of the aforesaid evidence and discussion, this
Court is constrained to find that the very execution of the WILL is
doubtful.
[24]
Another important aspect which is necessary to be discussed
is that DW-3 has stated that he could not participate at the time of
execution of the WILL at house of the appellant as he was out of station.
He has further stated that probably before “Durga Puja” of 1997 the
testatrix went to him and handed over the registered WILL to him to keep
it in the safe custody with a request that after her death the said WILL
might be handed over to the executor of the said WILL, namely, Pabitra
Chandra Dutta who is the known to this witness. Said Pabitra Chandra
Dutta in his evidence has never stated that the WILL was handed over to
him at any point of time by said DW-3. Further, it has been revealed that
they have suppressed the execution of the alleged WILL. According to
them, the WILL was executed in the year 1997 but, till the filing of the
written statement neither, the appellant nor any of the witnesses ever
divulged the existence of the said WILL to any of the legal heirs of
Subhashini Majumder. This has raised a serious doubt about the genuinity
of the WILL.
[25]
The question falls for consideration, had the WILL been
executed in the year 1997 why it was not executed after a reasonable
period of the death of the testatrix, there is no explanation by way of
pleadings or in the written statement filed by the appellant.
[26]
I have perused the pleadings of the appellant. He has nowhere
stated when and how the WILL was registered and the place where the
testatrix and the attesting witnesses have put their signatures. In my
opinion, the propounder, i.e. the appellant should make a clear statement as
to how he gained the knowledge of the WILL, when and how. In my
considered opinion, such requirements are not a mere formality and in
absence of such averments and evidence, it is very difficult to believe the
genuineness of the WILL even if it is a registered WILL.
[27]
It is also noticed that when it was a definite case of the
appellant that the testatrix was physically and mentally fit then it is not
understood why she put her thumb impression in the WILL. The
propounder has failed to discharge his burden that under what
circumstances she had to put her thumb impression instead of signature in
the WILL. It also raises serious suspicious circumstances to the genuine
execution of the WILL. The appellant is totally silent who brought the
testatrix to the office of the Sub-Registrar.
[28]
In view of the above discussion, I hold that the execution of
the WILL is full of doubt and suspicious circumstances have not been
removed by the appellant. Hence, the WILL is required to be declared null
and void. Accordingly, I declare that said WILL dated 16.07.1997 void ab
initio and as cancelled. The proper entry be made in the office of the SubRegistrar, in view of this judgment. Accordingly, the issue whether the
appellant entitled to get the share of his mother by virtue of the registered
WILL bearing No. III-199 is decided against the appellant.
[29]
The next point required to be decided is whether the
construction done by the appellant during the pendency of the suit is
required to be demolished by way of granting a mandatory injunction. It is
found that the appellant has himself admitted that he has undertaken
construction works which is also support by his brother in law as well as
DWs7 and 8.
[30]
The defendant No.4, the appellant herein, in his evidence has
clearly stated that on 09.10.2012 and 10.10.2012 police from the West
Agartala P.S. visited his house. They also visited the house on 12.10.2012
and restrained him from undertaking any further construction works. In his
cross-examination he has stated that there was no sanction plan from the
Agartala Municipal Council. The defendant Nos.7 and 8, the respondents
herein, have stated that despite the instruction of police and as well as in
violation of the order of temporary injunction he has undertaken the
construction works which is totally blocked the ingress and egress of the
plaintiff-appellant and his other family members.
[31]
This Court may gainfully refer a decision in Sant Ram
Nagina Ram vs. Daya Ram Nagina Ram, reported in AIR 1961 PUNJAB
528, wherein, the Division Bench while dealing with the question of
demolition of a structure illegally built on a land jointly possessed by all
the co-sharers has laid the following principle (para-77, 78, 79 & 80):
“77. From the consideration of the decisions of different High Courts on
the subject, it is evident that apart from some cases which are
distinguishable as having been decided on their own peculiar facts, there
is an obvious conflict! which cannot be reconciled.
78. The weight of the authorities and the principles which have been
discussed above, give rise to the following propositions –
(1) A co-Owner has an interest in the whole property and also in every
parcel of it.
(2) Possession of the joint property by one co-owner is in the eye of law,
possession of all even if all but one are actually out of possession.
(3) A mere occupation of a larger portion or even of an entire joint
property does not necessarily amount to ouster as the possession of one is
deemed to be on behalf of all.
(4) The above rule admits of an exception when there is ouster of a coowner by another. But in order to negative the presumption of joint
possession on behalf of all, on the ground of ouster, the possession, of a
co-owner must not only be exclusive but also hostile to the knowledge of
the other, as, when a co-owner openly asserts his own title and denies that
of the other.
(5) Passage of time does not extinguish the right of the co-owner who has
been out of possession of the joint property except in the event of ouster or
abandonment.
(6) Every co-owner has a right to use the joint property in a husband like
manner not inconsistent with similar rights of other co-owners.
(7) Where a co-owner is in possession of separate parcels under an
arrangement consented to by the other co-owners, it is not open to any one
to disturb the arrangement without the consent of others except by filing a
suit for partition.
(8) The remedy of a co-owner not in possession, or not in possession of a
share of the joint property, is by way of a suit for partition Or for actual
joint possession, but not for ejectment. Same is the case where a co-owner
sets up an exclusive title in himself.
(9) Where a portion of the joint property is, by common consent of the coowners, reserved for a particular common purpose, it cannot be diverted
to an inconsistent user by a co-owner; if he does so, he is liable to be
ejected and the particular parcel will be liable to be restored to its original
condition. It is not necessary in such a case to show that special damage
has been suffered.
79. This is a case which attracts the application of proposition No. 4.
From what has been stated above, the question referred by the learned
Single Judge will be answered as follows:
"If, in spite of protests by one co-owner, another co-owner raises a
building on a portion of joint land, not exceeding his own share therein,
the aggrieved co-owner cannot obtain a decree for demolition of that
building without proving special damage or substantial injury to him
unless the other co-owner who has raised the building has done so by
asserting an exclusive title in himself and by denying that of the other coowners."
80. As the entire case is before this Bench for decision, I am of the view
that, as the defendants had openly denied co-ownership and had asserted
their exclusive title on the false plea of previous partition and had
continued to raise the structure despite the protestations of the plaintiff,
and in disregard of the temporary injunction issued, the decree passed by
the trial Court for demolition of the structure and restraining the
defendants from making any structure thereon in future, is manifestly
just.”
[32]
It is an admitted position that the land has not been partitioned
and there is no demarcation of the shares of the co-owners of the land in
question by way of metes and bounds. So the construction which has
illegally been made over the un-partitioned land it is to be declared illegal.
Accordingly, this Court grant a decree of mandatory injunction asking the
defendant No.4, the appellant to demolish the construction he has
undertaken over the un-partitioned land and restore the land in its original
position which was vacant in front of the hut of the plaintiff, the appellant
herein.
[33]
In support of the case of the respondent, Mr. S. Bhattacharjee,
learned counsel has relied upon a case in Raj Kumar and Others vs.
Surinder Pal Sharma [Manu/SC/1840/2019] at paragraph-28 of the
judgment, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held thus:
“28. The Will which purportedly makes the bequest, is oddly described as
a Will Deed. This possibly explains why Surinder Pal Sharma had
claimed in his reply, that he was the owner of the tenement even during
the lifetime of the mother Suhagwanti. It is in this context that we have
read the different portions of the testimony of Raj Kumari and Surinder
Pal Sharma; the notice and the reply to hold that there exists grave doubt
whether the “Will Deed” was executed and is a “Will” as it purports to be.
The marriage of Veena Malhotra as per her wish is not challenged. The
testator was an illiterate lady. Even if we are to accept signatures of the
testator and the witnesses, we cannot ignore “other evidence” that
Suhagwanti and her family members did not understand the true nature
of the document executed. There are substantial and good reasons to
legitimately suspect and question execution of the Will, which Surinder
Pal Sharma, as the propounder of the Will, has not been able to repel and
remove so as to satisfy this Court that the Will was validly executed. For
these reasons, we would hold that execution of the Will has not been
proved by “other evidence” in terms of Section 71 of the Evidence Act.”
[34]
This Court constrained to observe that it is the duty of the
learned trial Judge to discuss all evidences and materials on record but, I
find that the learned trial court did not disclose the evidence at all in detail
and there is clear evidence of non-application of mind by the learned trial
court. At present, Subhashini Majumder is no more in this world and since
during her life time no partition was taken place her share will be
distributed amongst the surviving legal heirs of Barad kanta Majumder.
[35]
It is pertinent to discuss here that the WILL is registered in
the year 1997 and it came into light only in 2012 when the suit has been
filed by the appellant, the defendant No.-4. He has filed the written
statement and at that point of time, the fact of existence of this WILL has
been informed. The secrecy of the WILL (witnesses) is the interested
witnesses of the beneficiary i.e. the defendant No.4 who is the appellant
herein. The very existence of the WILL is suspicious and the appellant has
not proved the execution of the WILL beyond reasonable doubt and it
always remains as a suspicion. Many witnesses were examined on behalf
of the defendant who supported the case of the plaintiff.
[36]
In the light of the above weightage as given holding that the
WILL is suspicious and the appellant cannot have the benefit of the WILL.
The WILL which has been executed in the year 1997 came into light in the
year 2012 itself creates a suspicion. It is reasonably presume that if a
WILL is executed and immediately after the demise of the testatrix the said
WILL came into light without any delay, it is also hard to believe that
when the testators is having huge family of sons and daughter in laws,
there was no logical reason to maintain a secrecy about the WILL with the
family members and not obtain their signature as witnesses to the WILL by
the testatrix.
[37]
It is a settled legal proposition that as a rule, relief not
founded on the pleadings should not be granted. Therefore, a decision of a
case cannot be based on grounds outside the pleadings of the parties.
Ordinarily, the reliefs are drawn on the basis of pleadings. Even in some
cases, on the basis of pleadings the court can mould the reliefs. But the
foundation of such relief must have its anchor in the pleadings. It is always
the creditor who has final call in the matter, unless contrary of law and is
provided by lawful agreement. Having observed thus, the impugned
judgment passed in TA No. 18 of 2017 dated 30.07.2018 by the learned
Additional District Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala needs no
interference whatsoever.
[38]
Having appraised the records afresh, this Court is of the view
that there is no infirmity in the findings arrived at by the learned
Additional District Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in TA No.
18 of 2017 dated 30.07.2018 and hence, this Court affirmed the finding of
the learned Addl. District Judge. Accordingly, the appeal being RSA. No.
40 of 2018 stands dismissed.
[39]
Draw the decree accordingly and send down the LCRs
thereafter.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review