Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Arb.P. No.14 of 2023
Sri Salil Acharjee
.........Petitioner(s);
Versus
The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner and Secretary & others
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s) :
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. H. Sarkar, Advocate.
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, G.A.,
Ms. Kahina Reang, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
17/05/2024
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner
and Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate for the
respondents-State.
2.
Petitioner approached this Court for appointment of an
independent Arbitrator in connection with the agreement [Annexure-1] between
the parties under Section 11(6) read with Section 12 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended.
3.
The case of the petitioner is captured in the order dated 15.03.2024
which is extracted hereunder:
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. H. Sarkar,
learned counsel appearing for the petitioner and Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya,
learned Government Advocate appearing for the respondents-State.
2.
Petitioner approached this Court for appointment of an independent
arbitrator under Section 11(6)(a) read with Section 12 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 to adjudicate the dispute arising out of and in connection
with the agreement entered into between the parties. The case of the petitioner as
pleaded was captured in the order dated 15.12.2023 which reads as under:
"Learned senior counsel for the petitioner is allowed to make
necessary corrections in the designation of respondents No.4 and 5 during
course of the day in the array of parties.
Petitioner seeks invocation of Clause 22.2 for appointment of an
independent arbitrator in connection with the work order dated 12.11.2010
and the agreement at (Annexure-1). Earlier the petitioner had approached
this Court in WP(C) No.372 of 2023 which was disposed of by order dated
31.07.2023 with liberty to the petitioner to approach the Executive
Engineer PWD (R&B), Kailashahar, Unakoti, respondent No.5 in respect of
his claims for payment of price escalation, refund of security deposit along
with interest from due date. The representation was attended by the
respondent No.5 but only a sum of Rs.4,99,143/- was found payable to the
petitioner by communication at Annexure-10 dated 17.08.2023. Respondent
No.5 disputed the admissibility of the price escalation under Clause 44.1 as
the work had been delayed for more than 4 years due to fault and on failure
on the part of the agency. It was further stated that liquidated damages
under clause 46 of the agreement for Rs.39,62,475/- were yet to be
deposited by the petitioner. Since the grievances of the petitioner remain
unredressed and the dispute relating to claims subsisted, he approached the
Executive Engineer PWD (R&B), Kailashahar, Unakoti respondent No.5 by
letter dated 23.08.2023 Annexure-11 for payment of the admissible dues
against price escalation, security deposit and final bill. Thereafter, the
petitioner approached the Superintending Engineer, 1 st Circle, PWD(R&B),
Kumarghat, respondent No.4 through letter dated 05.09.2023 Anneuxure-12
and on failing to elucidate any response, he has also represented before the
Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B), New Secretariat, Agartala, respondent No.3
through letter dated 28.09.2023 clearly requesting him to appoint an
independent arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute within 30 days from the
date of receipt of the letter failing which he would be compelled to proceed
further as per the arbitration clause.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits
that by memorandum dated 20.08.2023 issued by the Chief Engineer,
PWD(R&B), Tripura which has been received by the petitioner only two
days back, the Chief Engineer, respondent No.3 has appointed a retired
Grade-I Officer of Tripura Judicial Service Sri Subrata Pal as an
Arbitrator. It is submitted that in terms of Section 12, the Chief Engineer,
respondent No.3 is disqualified to appoint an independent arbitrator since
he heads the very department with which the dispute is existing. The
petitioner has not waived of such condition in the agreement or the
Arbitration Clause 22.1 and 22.2 for the respondent-Chief Engineer to
make such an appointment after coming into force of the amendment in the
year 2015 to the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996. Learned senior
counsel for the petitioner has relied upon a decision of the Apex Court in
case of TRF Limited versus Energo Engineering Projects Limited
reported in (2017) 8 SCC 377. As such, the jurisdiction of the Court to
appoint an arbitrator has not been ousted because of appointment of an
arbitrator by the respondent No.3 vide memorandum dated 20.08.2023.
Mr. K. De, learned Additional Government Advocate is allowed
4(four) weeks’ time to seek instructions and file counter-affidavit.
List the matter on 19.01.2024.
Petitioner, if so advised, may file rejoinder in the meantime.”
3.
The respondents have thereafter filed a counter affidavit. It has been
averred that as per the Government records and as per the agreement, the work in
question was supposed to be completed on 26.11.2013. The agency completed
the work on 31.12.2017. After a lapse of 5 years 5 months, the agency
approached this Court which is unexplained. Therefore, the application deserves
to be dismissed.
4.
Under this agreement, any grievance has to be settled under Clause-22
which provides for an alternative dispute resolution mechanism. Petitioner has
intentionally bypassed this provision to avoid the limitation part. Further
statements have been made in relation to the order dated 31.07.2023 delivered in
WP(C) No.372 of 2023 whereunder the Executive Engineer, Kailashahar
Division, PWD(R&B) vide his letter dated 17.08.2023 communicated to the
claimant that as per official records the total amount payable to him for final bill
is Rs.71,519/- and security deposit of Rs.11,00,592/- whereas payment required
to be recovered from the claimant is to the tune of Rs.6,72,968/- as cost of
material issued to the claimant. After deduction of the cost of material, the net
amount payable to the claimant is Rs.4,99,143/-. The claimant was requested to
confirm receiving of the payment within 7 days from receipt of the letter. The
respondents have further stated that the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B) has vide
memorandum dated 20.10.2023 already appointed Shri Subrata Pal, Grade-I
Officer TJS (Retired) as an independent and impartial arbitrator to adjudicate the
dispute from the recommended panel issued by the High Court as per notification
dated 03.04.2023. Further averments from paragraphs-5 to 10 relate to the
answers on merits of the dispute between the parties. The respondents state that
the claimant/contractor failed to complete the work even within the extended
period of time and as such, the price escalation is not admissible to him. The
security deposit could not be released due to non-finalization of the prayer for
granting extension of time. The work was stated to have been completed on
31.12.2017 with provisional time extension granted by the office. The total value
of work done was of Rs.3,77,19,054/- out of which an amount of
Rs.3,76,47,535/- has already been paid. The balance amount of Rs.71,519/- could
not be paid due to non-finalization of the prayer for granting extension of time
and non-approval of the deviation statement. An amount of Rs.11,00,592/- is
lying in the books of their office which could not be released due to nonfinalization of final deviation statement. Further averments have been made
regarding the handing over of the site of the work to the claimant on 15.10.2010.
The Hindrance Register would show that the contractor had suspended the work
from 28.04.2013 to 08.10.2014 and as such, price escalation claimed by him is
not admissible.
5.
Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate
appearing for the State, submits that in terms of Clause-22.2(b) of the agreement
since the claim amount was above Rs.50,000/-, another Chief Engineer or
arbitrator could be appointed by the Chief Engineer of the same department to
settle the dispute in accordance with the Act of 1996 or any statutory
modification thereof. Since an appointment of an independent arbitrator has
already been made on the request made by the petitioner through his letter dated
28.09.2023, on 20.10.2023 the application for appointment of an independent
arbitrator invoking Section 11(6) of the Act does not deserve to be allowed.
There is no question on the independence and impartiality of the appointed
arbitrator who has submitted his declaration in terms of Section 12(1)(a) and
(1)(b) on 20.11.2023. The bona fide of the petitioner has been questioned.
6.
From the averments made in the counter affidavit, one thing is clear that
the respondents acknowledge the existence of a dispute as they have proceeded to
appoint an arbitrator. Therefore, it appears that the plea of delay also stands
waived. The agreement is pre 2015 amendment. However, in view of proviso to
Section 12(5) of the amended Act, there has been no express agreement in
writing between the parties to waive of the requirement under Section 12(5) of
the Act and permit the designated authority to appoint an arbitrator for
adjudication of the dispute between the parties.
7.
Learned counsel for both the parties have placed reliance on the
following decisions:
(i)
TRF Limited vrs. Energo Engineering Projects Limited
reported in (2017) 8 SCC 377;
(ii)
Central Organisation for Railway Electrification vrs. ECISPIC-SMO-MCML (JV), a Joint Venture Company reported in (2020) 14 SCC
712; and
(iii)
The order dated 16.08.2022 passed by the Apex Court in the case
of JSW Steel Limited vrs. South Western Railway and another reported in 2022
SCC OnLine SC 1973, whereby the matter has been referred to a larger Bench
on an apparent conflict between the above two decisions, both by three-Judge
Bench of the Apex Court.
8.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner, has further
drawn the attention of this Court to a recent decision rendered in the case of
Glock Asia-Pacific Limited vrs. Union of India reported in (2023) 8 SCC 226.
He submits that despite being conscious of the conflict in the above two
decisions, the Apex Court in the case of Glock Asia-Pacific Limited (supra) by a
three-Judge Bench has chosen to follow the ratio in the case of TRF Limited
(supra).
Learned Government Advocate Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya
appearing for the State has also placed the order of the Constitution Bench dated
17.01.2024 in the case of Central Organisation for Railway Electrification vrs.
M/S ECI SPIC SMO MCML (JV), a Joint Venture Company [Civil Appeal
No.9486-9487/2019] wherein the matter has been posted for 05.04.2024.
9.
The only legal issue contested between the parties is whether in view of
the provisions under Section 12(5) read with Schedule-V and VII of the
Amendment Act, 2015, the Chief Engineer is ineligible or technically
disqualified to appoint an arbitrator under Clause-22.2(b) of the agreement in
question.
10.
The issue of ineligibility of the designated authority, a party to the
dispute, to appoint an arbitrator was squarely in question in the case of TRF
Limited (supra). The Apex Court held that once the designated authority becomes
ineligible to act as an arbitrator by virtue of the 2015 amendment, the arbitrator
appointed by him also becomes ineligible by operation of law since he cannot
nominate another person as an arbitrator. The Apex Court also held that
ineligibility of appointment of an arbitrator can only be waived in terms of the
proviso to Section 12(5) read with Schedule-V and VII of the Amendment Act,
2015 if the parties have chosen to waive the condition by an express agreement in
writing only after the dispute has arisen between the parties. The principle
embedded in the maxim qui facit per alium facit per se (what one does through
another is done by oneself) gets attracted in such a case.
11.
There has been a divergent opinion by the Apex Court in the case of
Central Organisation for Railway Electrification (supra) wherein it was held
that the designated authority General Manger of the Appellant was not ineligible
to appoint a retired Railway Officer from the panel in terms of modified Clause64(3) of the General Conditions of Contract. The respondent had failed to select
any two railway electrification officers out of a panel of 4 suggested by the
appellant. It, however, appears that noticing the divergence in view between the
two Benches of co-equal strength, the Apex Court in the case of JSW Steel
Limited (supra) referred the matter to a larger Bench. The matter is still sub
judice. However, there is no restraint upon the High Court in the meantime to
appoint an arbitrator in such circumstances under Section 11(6)(a) of the Act as
amended. It further appears that in the case of Glock Asia-Pacific Limited
(supra), a three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court presided by Hon'ble the Chief
Justice of India has found that the arbitration clause in that case enabled a serving
employee of the Union of India, a party to the contract, to nominate a serving
employee of the Union of India as the sole arbitrator. Such an authorization was
clearly distinct from the arbitration clause in Voestalpine Schienen GmbH vrs.
Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. reported in (2017) 4 SCC 665 and Central
Organisation for Railway Electrification (supra). The Apex Court also took note
of the reference to the larger Bench and held that it will have no bearing on the
outcome of the said case. Accordingly, the Apex Court proceeded to appoint an
independent arbitrator, a former Judge of the Supreme Court, as a sole arbitrator
to adjudicate the disputes arising under and in connection with the conditions of
tender entered into between the parties, subject to mandatory disclosures under
the amended Section 12 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
12.
In the present case, the dispute is between the Contractor and the State of
Tripura, in particular the PWD (R&B) Department. Under Clause-22.2(b) the
disputes are referable for adjudication for claims above Rs.50,000/- to another
Chief Engineer or arbitrator appointed by the Chief Engineer of the same
department. The Chief Engineer of the department, i.e. a party to the dispute, has
nominated an arbitrator on the request of the petitioner following the mechanism
prescribed under Clause-22.2. However, he becomes ineligible to appoint an
arbitrator even if the named arbitrator is from a panel constituted by the High
Court vide notification dated 03.04.2023 in exercise of powers under Section
11(3-A) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as amended, in view of the
provision of Section 12(5) read with Schedule V & VII of the Act of 1996 as
amended. The arbitration clause in the first case is in similar terms as in the case
of TRF Limited (supra) where the Managing Director of the Corporation was
named as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties or by
his nominee. Therefore, this Court deems it proper to follow the decision
rendered by the Apex Court in the case of TRF Limited (supra). The terms of the
arbitration clause herein are quite distinct from that in the case of Central
Organisation for Railway Electrification (supra). It is also important to mention
here that a three-Judge Bench of the Apex Court in the case of Glock AsiaPacific Limited (supra) has after noticing the apparent divergence in the two
decisions proceeded to appoint an independent arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties since the arbitrator appointed by the Secretary, Ministry of
Home Affairs, was ineligible to make such appointment. In the present case, the
independence and impartiality of the arbitrator appointed by the Chief Engineer
is not an issue. It is the ineligibility of the designated authority, i.e. the Chief
Engineer of the department, a party to the dispute, to appoint an independent
arbitrator in view of the amended provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 2015, in particular Section 12(5) read with Schedule-V and VII.
13.
As such, this Court proposes to appoint Hon'ble Mr. Justice Tapen Sen, a
former Judge of Calcutta High Court, as an arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties arising out of and in connection with the agreement in
question. The proposed arbitrator is requested to submit his consent along with a
declaration in form Schedule-VI of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended by the Act of 2015. The Registry is directed to communicate this order
to the proposed arbitrator. The matter be placed after three weeks upon receipt of
the consent and declaration by the proposed arbitrator.
List the matter on 12.04.2024.”
4.
Pursuant to the order dated 15.03.2024, this Court proposed to
appoint Hon’ble Mr. Justice Tapen Sen, a former Judge of Calcutta High Court,
as an Arbitrator. However, he conveyed his inability to accept the request.
Thereafter, by order dated 02.05.2024, this Court proposed to appoint Hon’ble
Mr. Justice Subhasis Talapatra, former Chief Justice of Orissa High Court, as
an Arbitrator. The proposed Arbitrator has submitted his consent along with a
declaration under Schedule-VI of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended.
5.
Learned counsel for the parties, therefore, submit that this Court
may appoint him as an arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
6.
In view of the consent and declaration submitted by the proposed
Arbitrator, I, hereby, appoint Hon’ble Mr. Justice Subhasis Talapatra, former
Chief Justice of Orissa High Court, as an Arbitrator to adjudicate the dispute
between the parties. Learned Arbitrator is requested to take into consideration
the Schedule of Model Fee prescribed under Schedule IV and the timeline
prescribed under Section 29-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as
amended.
7.
Registry is directed to communicate the instant order along with a
copy of the entire pleadings of the instant application to the learned Arbitrator
forthwith.
8.
The instant petition stands allowed. Pending application(s), if any,
shall also stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pijush/
MUNNA SAHA SAHA
Date: 2024.05.18 14:14:45
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review