Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No. 11 of 2023
Sri Sajal Datta,
S/O- Late Srimanta Datta,
A resident of Village-Motai
P.S. Belonia, District-South Tripura
..…….Appellant(s)
Vs.
1.
Smt. Kajal Datta,
W/O Shri Dhananjaoy Baidya,
D/O Late Srimanta Datta,
Resident of Village-Motai,
P.O. Motai, P.S. Belonia, District South Tripura,
2.
Smt. Bijal Datta,
W/O_Sri Sambhu Mallik,
D/O- Late Srimanta Datta,
A resident of Village-Sonapur, Barpathari,
P.S.-P.T. Bari, District-South Tripura
3.
Sri Samir Datta,
S/O- Late Srimanta Datta,
4.
Sri Amir Datta,
S/O- Late Srimanta Datta,
5.
Sri Mihir Datta,
S/O- Late Srimanta Datta,
All are resident of Village-Motai, P.O.-Motai, P.S.-Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura.
…. Respondent(s)
Sri Hemanta Kr. Datta,
S/O-Late Aswini Kr. Datta,
6.
7.
Legal heir of Late Sudhir Ch. Datta:
a)
Smt. Dipali Datta,
W/O-Sudhir Ch. Datta,
b)
Legal Heirs of Late Mridul Datta:
i.
Smt. Sampa Datta,
Late Mridul Datta,
ii.
Sri Sanjoy Datta,
S/O-Late Mridul Datta
iii.
Sri Ajoy Datta,
Late Mridul Datta,
(ii) & (iii) are minor and their natural guardian is Smt. Sampa
Datta.
All are residents of Village-Motai, P.O.-Motai, P.S.-Belonia, DistrictSouth Tripura.
… Pro-forma Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. BN Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. B Paul, Adv.
Mr. S Chandra Sen, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
None.
Date of hearing
:
9th February, 2024.
Date of delivery of Judgment
:
12th February, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The Judgment dated 29.08.2022 passed by the learned
District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in Title Appeal No. 04/2021 and
consequent decree thereof are under challenge in the second appeal on
the following substantial question of law:
A. Whether a legal heir can be denied the share of the
ancestral undivided property, left behind by the late
father, only on the ground that he had purchased a
portion of the land from his father during the life time of
the father.
B. Any other substantial question of law may be framed at
the time of hearing.
2.
Originally one Sri Srimanta Kumar Datta (original plaintiff
i.e. predecessor of present appellant and respondents), Sri Hemanta
Kumar Datta (Proforma respondent No.6), and Lt. Sri Sudhir Chandra
Datta (predecessor of proforma respondents 7(a), (b)(i-iii), were three
brothers. Said original plaintiff filed the involved suit bearing TS(P)
No.50/2014 against his said brother Sri Hemanta Kumar Datta and legal
representatives of his deceased brother Sri Sudhir Chandra Datta and
also impleaded one of his sons, i.e. the appellant, as defendant therein,
praying for partition of the suit land consisting of five numbers of plots
of total area 1.77 acre (emphasis laid).
3.
legal
During pendency of the suit, Srimanta Kr. Datta died and his
representatives
excluding
the
present
appellant
were
also
substituted in his place. His source of claim over the suit land was that
he along with his other two brothers were in possession of the entire
suit property of 1.77 acre and proper management and development of
the land required partition of the same and therefore the suit.
4.
The allegation against the present appellant as made in the
plaint was that he had also been possessing certain portion of the suit
land and on asking he told his father that he had purchased about 7
gandas of land from the suit land on consideration and therefore, he was
impleaded as defendant so that he could explain his status in the suit
land, if so desired.
5.
In the written statement the appellant along with legal
representatives of deceased brother of original plaintiff namely Lt.
Sudhir Chandra Datta contested the suit and their claim was that joint
property was consisting of an area of 1.67 acre under Khatian No.466
and the appellant did not possess any land of said Khatian No. 466.
Rather he possessed an area of 0.10 acre of another Khatian bearing
No. 1780 of the same Mouja Motai and Khatian was finally published in
his name. They also further disclosed that the appellant got about 7
gandas of land from his father about 20 years ago i.e. the original
plaintiff from the suit Khatian No.466 to build up his dwelling house
when his relationship with his father was good.
6.
Further allegations of contesting defendants were that the
original plaintiff had driven out the legal representative of Lt. Sudhir
Chandra Datta from their share of land where they were residing by
constructing dwelling hut. Therefore, they started residing later on in
the house of the appellant. However, they did not oppose the partition
of the land under Khatian No.466.
7.
Learned trial court decreed the suit in respect of 1.67 acre of
land of Khatian No.466 as its stands presently, in spite of the fact that
the suit land as described in the plaint and as was claimed by the
original plaintiff was of 1.77 acre of Khatian No.466. The reasoning for
said deviation as given by the learned Trial court in the relevant
paragraph, is extracted below:
“From the above discussion it is found that
10 satak of land is under the possession of
defendant no.3. In the plaint the plaintiff sated
regarding 1.77 acrs of land vide Khatian no.466 and
the documents which were exhibited is of 1.67 acrs
vide khatian no.466.
Ld. Counsel on behalf of the plaintiff
submitted that during the pendency of the suit the
land was purchased by defendant no.3 but from the
deposition as well as from the documents it shows
that before filing this suit 10 satak of land was
purchased by defendant no.3 which shows in Exbt. 2
and it is clear that defendant no.3 has already
purchased the land measuring 10 satak before the
partition from the joint property. Regarding land
measuring of 1.77 acrs and 1.67 acrs the
subsequent R.O.R. will prevail and in this
circumstances the land measuring 1.67 acrs vide
Khatian no.466 published in a later stage. Therefore,
considering this measurement I am of the view that
the partition will be done by considering the land
measuring of 1.67 acrs. Lastly, it is to be mentioned
here that though defendant no.3 is one of the legal
heirs of Lt. Srimanta Kr. Datta, but he will not get
any share as he is already taken share from his
father by way of purchasing the land. Now, the
plaintiffs no.01 to 06 will get one share from the
suit land.”
8.
The First appellate court in the impugned judgment confined
the relief within 1.67 acre of land with the following observations“[9]
This court finds that learned trial Court has
rightly decided the Issue Nos.(ii) and (iii), but the
observation given by learned trial Court on the point
that the defendant appellant will not get any share
as he has already taken his share from his father by
way of purchasing the land, cannot be accepted as
the plaintiff has denied to sale the land in favour of
defendant-appellant in his plaint and the defendantappellant has also not admitted that he has
purchased any land from his father. Rather, he has
admitted in his written statement that his father
gave him approximately 7 gandas of land to build up
his dwelling hut before 20 years back and he is
possessing the same. So, the defendant-appellant
has already taken his share from his father and
accordingly got the Khatian No.1780 in his favour.
Hence, he is not entitled any further share from the
suit land.”
Being aggrieved by the said decision of the learned District
Judge, South Tripura, the defendant-appellant has come up with this
second appeal.
9.
Learned Sr. counsel, Mr. B N Majumder, canvassing the
aforesaid facts argued that both the learned courts below illegally
excluded the appellant from his entitlement to the joint property. The
decision of Learned Trial Court suffers from perversity for holding that
he had purchased 0.10 acre of land from his father. Learned District
Judge also, according to learned Sr. counsel, has erroneously came to
the conclusion basing on the written statement that his father had given
him approximately 7 gandas of land to build his dwelling hut 20 years
back and accordingly, Khatian was also opened in his name.
10.
Learned Sr. counsel fairly admits that no document of title
was proved by the appellant in the suit to justify such mutation of land
in his name. According to learned Sr. counsel, even if for argument sake
it is presumed that the father of the appellant had given him 0.10 acre
of land, still he cannot be excluded from his legitimate share in the joint
property confining his entitlement only 0.10 acre without equal division.
Learned Sr. counsel, therefore, presses for upsetting the judgments of
both the courts below.
11.
On consideration of the records, apparently some gross
irregularities are found to have taken place during trial of the suit. The
original plaintiff submitted only two documents at the initial stage viz.,
(i) photocopy of certified copy of Khatian No.466 (which reflects total
area as 1.77 acre) and (ii) photocopy of one notice of mutation.
Simultaneously, from the side of contesting defendants, certified copies
of Khatian No.466 concerning area of 1.67 acre, certified copy of
mutated Khatian No. 1780 acre consisting of area of 0.10 acre standing
in the name of the appellant and one trace map were submitted. Later
on, at the time of recording of evidence, from the side of plaintiff, the
original copy of the said notice of mutation, certified copy of Khatian
No.466 (concerning land area of 1.77 acre) were also further submitted.
But at the time of recording of evidence of Plaintiff’s Witness no.1, the
following documents were taken into evidence as quoted from the
evidence sheet of PW.1:“(i)
This is the certified copy of computerized
khatian no.466 marked as Exbt.1(two
series).
(ii)
This is the certified copy of computerized
khatian no.1780 marked as Exbt.2.
(iii)
This is the copy of notice of mutation,
dated, 30.04.14 marked as Exbt.3 (2
series)”
But without marking the documents of plaintiffs, the trial
court made the marking of Exbt.1 & 2 in the documents submitted by
the contesting defendants. In fact, the substituted plaintiffs never relied
upon the document under Extb.2, nor they submitted any such
document in the court. Khatian No.466 was relied upon by both the
parties but as stated above, marking of Exbt.1 was done on Khatian
No.466 which was submitted by the contesting defendants, and
therefore, it reflects of total area of 1.67 acres but what ought to have
been marked was Khatian No.466 of area of 1.77 acre i.e. the previous
Khatian No.466 as it would stand before the land of 0.10 acre was
mutated in the name of appellant.
12.
Despite original copy of notice of mutation was submitted by
the plaintiff marking was done on the photocopy thereof. Anyway, as
said document is not much relevant for adjudication of the involved
issues, such irregularity has not affected the interest of either of the
parties. But the marking of Exbt.1 has certainly thrown significant
bearing upon the rights of the parties, specially the plaintiffs. In fact,
the contesting defendants submitted examination-in-chief on affidavit of
two witnesses but ultimately they did not appear to face crossexamination and no document was also taken into evidence on their
behalf.
13.
In the Trial court such defect was detected and accordingly,
the said court vide order dated 05.02.2019 directed for re-examination
of PW-1 and successive dates were fixed for that purpose. But again on
13.07.2020, when another Presiding Officer was in seisin of the matter,
the trial court modified the said order and fixed the next date of
argument without re-examination of PW-1 with erroneous observation
that as the documents submitted from the side of plaintiffs as well as
from the defendants were same, as such there was no need of
exhibiting the documents of plaintiffs further. In continuation thereafter,
the trial court granted decree of partition for 1.67 acre of land instead of
1.77 acre of land and excluded the right of the present appellant in the
suit land. In the pleading, the appellant did not specifically disclose the
source of his title on 0.10 acre of land to justify mutation of such land in
his name, nor he proved any basic document of his title, if any, over
said 0.10 acre of land. Anyway, as already discussed above, these
irregularities go to the root of the case affecting the rights of the parties
which are therefore required to be regularized first by re-examination of
PW.1 with further clarification as to which documents he had actually
intended to put into evidence.
14.
In the result the appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment
dated 29.08.2022 passed by the learned District Judge, South Tripura
and consequent decree thereof as well as the judgment passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia dated 18.12.2020 passed in
TS(P) No.50 of 2014 and related decree thereof are hereby set aside.
The matter is remanded to the Trial court for fresh hearing and decision
with the following directions that:(i)
after receipt of LCRs, the trial court will notify the parties for
their appearances; if despite service of notice they or any of
them do not/does not appear, necessary order may be
passed in accordance with law,
(ii)
the Trial Court will thereafter fix a date for re-examination of
PW-1 Sri Samir Datta and after said re-examination and on
his identification necessary documents shall be taken into
evidence and shall be marked accordingly as exhibits for
him, after expunging all the marking as have already been
done previously. Needless to say, the other side should be
given a scope to further cross-examine him but for the
whole purpose not more than three dates will be given to the
parties.
(iii)
the Trial court shall also give opportunity to the contesting
defendants to lead their evidences, if they so desire, but not
more than three dates shall be given to them for this
purpose including cross-examination of their witnesses.
(iv)
the Trial Court shall hear the arguments of both sides and
finally pass the judgment.
(v)
the entire process should be completed within next six
months after receipt of LCRs.
Reconsign the LCRs.
The second appeal is accordingly disposed of.
Interim application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Satabdi
SATABDI DUTTA DUTTA
Date: 2024.02.13 14:19:38 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review