Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Review Petition No.07 of 2024
Sri Sailesh Paul,
son of Late Surendra Chandra Paul,
resident of Village-Deolia Tilla,
Dhalabil, P.O. Khowai Tea Garden,
P.S. Khowai, District-Khowai, Tripura
----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Sri Ranjit Paul @ Moran Paul,
2. Sri Sanju Paul,
3. Sri Samarjit Paul,
all are sons of Late Radha Govinda Paul
and all are residents of Village- Deolia Tilla,
Dhalabil, P.O. Khowai Tea Garden,
P.S. Khowai, District-Khowai, Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Dhar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. R. Debnath, Adv.
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
Mr. Subham Majumder, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of Hearing
:
23.08.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
28.08.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This application under Section 114 read with Order XLVII
Rule 1 of CPC is preferred seeking review of the judgment and order and
decree dated 23.04.2024 passed by this High Court in RSA No.04 of
2022. By the said judgment of the High Court, the judgment and decree
delivered
by
Learned
District
Judge,
Khowai
District,
Tripura
in
connection with First Appeal No. T.A.09 of 2019 which arose out of the
judgment and decree dated 20.03.2019 passed by Learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Khowai, Tripura in connection with Case No.T.S.39 of
2016 was affirmed by this High Court.
[2]
Heard Mr. P.K. Dhar, Learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
R. Debnath, Learned counsel appearing for the review petitioner as well
as Mr. S. Lodh, Learned counsel assisted by Mr. Subham Majumder,
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[3]
In course of hearing of argument, Mr. P.K. Dhar, Learned
senior counsel appearing for the review petitioner submitted that the
Learned First Appellate Court in the judgment committed an error which
was over looked by this High Court at the time of delivery of judgment in
RSA No.04 of 2022. According to Learned senior counsel, the Learned
First Appellate Court in the last part of the judgment dated 27.08.2021
gave the following observation which has caused grave injustice to the
petitioner and the same is also error apparent on the face of record
which needs to be set aside for the sake of justice. As submitted by
Learned senior counsel, the said last operative portion of the judgment
of the Learned First Appellate Court runs as follows :
―10. It is stated by the parties that already decree of Ld. Trial Court
was executed, however, liberty is granted to the defendants to pray
for restitution of possession of the suit land in their favour in the
proper Forum, if at all any property was taken out from their
possession beyond the suit land as decreed today, and in that case
said Ld. Court will appoint a Survey knowing Commissioner to locate
the suit land by its boundary description and possession of excess
land, if any, taken out from the possession of the defendants will be
restored to them. Needless to say, the cost of Survey Commissioner
will be borne by the defendants.‖
Referring
the
same,
Learned
senior
counsel
further
submitted that the review petitioner has satisfied with the judgment and
decree delivered by this Court but if that part of the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court is not modified to the extent of their
possession then, the petitioner would suffer irreparable loss. It was
further submitted that admittedly one Sukhamoy Paul was the original
owner of 41 decimals of land and out of that, he transferred 38 decimals
of land to the petitioner vide registered deed bearing No.1-324 dated
23.02.1993. But thereafter, said Sukhamoy Paul further transferred land
measuring 0.12 acres (6 gandas) to the respondent-defendants in the
year 2006 for which he had no authority to transfer the said quantum of
land after disposal of 38 decimals of land to the petitioner. Now, by the
said judgment, the respondents are claiming ownership for the land
measuring 12 decimals for which said Sukhamoy Paul was not illegally
authorized/permitted to sell as he had no right to transfer the said
quantum of land to the respondent/Ops, after disposal of 38 decimals of
land to the petitioner. Now, with the strength of that judgment, the
respondents are claiming the land of the review petitioner for which the
relevant portion of the judgment of the First Appellate Court which was
affirmed by this Court needs to be modified to the extent that the OPrespondents cannot claim more than 3 decimals of land for which
Learned senior counsel sought for interference of this Court by invoking
review jurisdiction.
[4]
On the contrary, Mr. S. Lodh, Learned counsel appearing for
the respondents in course of hearing submitted that this present petition
is not maintainable which is liable to be dismissed with costs. According
to Learned counsel for the respondents, in a review proceeding, it is the
duty of the petitioner to draw the attention of the Court that there was
error apparent on the face of record which the petitioner has failed to
show in this case and until and unless the error apparent on the face of
the record is shown by the petitioner then there is no scope to entertain
the review petition because by invoking the review jurisdiction, the
petitioner cannot claim for the relief of appeal over the judgment passed
by this Court in second appeal.
[5]
Furthermore,
according
to
Learned
counsel
for
the
respondents, the decree for which the suit was filed has already been
executed and now there is no scope to entertain this petition filed by the
petitioner for which this petition is liable to be dismissed with costs.
[6]
Both the parties in course of hearing of argument referred
few citations which would be discussed later on. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the relevant provision of
Order XLVII Rule 1 of CPC regarding exercise of review jurisdiction which
is as follows :
―1.Application
for
review
of
judgment.-(1)
Any
person
considering himself aggrieved—
(a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from
which no appeal has been preferred,
(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed, or
(c) by a decision on a reference from a Court of Small Causes, and
who, from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence
which, after the exercise of due diligence was not within his
knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the
decree was passed or order made, or on account of some mistake or
error apparent on the face of the record or for any other sufficient
reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree passed or order
made against him, may apply for a review of judgment to the
Court which passed the decree or made the order.‖
[7]
In the given case, the review petitioner as plaintiff filed the
suit before the Court of Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Khowai for
decree of right, title and interest and for decree of permanent injunction
over the suit land and in the said suit after conclusion of trial, Learned
Trial Court below by judgment dated 20.03.2019 decreed the suit in
favour of the plaintiff. For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the operative portion of the judgment and decree of the
said Learned Trial Court in T.S.No.39 of 2016 which runs as follows :
―9. As a result it is declared that the plaintiff has right, title and
interest over the suit land and it is directed that the defendants be
evicted therefrom and also perpetual injunction is granted preventing
the defendants and their men and agents from disturbing the
peaceful possession of the plaintiff upon the suit land.
10. Hence, the suit is decree on contest with cost.
11. Prepare decree accordingly and put up the signature within
fourteen days from today, latest on 03.04.2019.
12. The judgment is given under my hand and seal of this Court on
this the 20th of March, 2019.‖
[8]
Challenging
that
judgment,
the
respondent-defendants
preferred an appeal before the Court of Learned District Judge under
Section 96 of CPC and the Learned District Judge by judgment dated
27.08.2021 and decree dated 24.09.2021 partly modified the decree of
the Learned Trial Court in Title Appeal No.09 of 2019. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the operative portion of
the judgment and order of the Learned First Appellate Court which runs
as follows :
―10. On the basis of the discussion made above, the right, title and
interest of the plaintiff in the suit land is declared according to its
boundary description, and the survey plots as mentioned in the
Schedule of the plaint will have no bearing in the decree.
The plaintiff is entitled to recovery of possession of the suit land
based on its boundary description from the defendants through due
process of law.
It is stated by the parties that already decree of Ld. Trial Court
was executed, however, liberty is granted to the defendants to pray
for restitution of possession of the suit land in their favour in the
proper Forum, if at all any property was taken out from their
possession beyond the suit land as decreed today, and in that case
said Ld. Court will appoint a Survey knowing Commissioner to locate
the suit land by its boundary description and possession of excess
land, if any, taken out from the possession of the defendants will be
restored to them. Needless to say, the cost of Survey Commissioner
will be borne by the defendants.‖
[9]
Thereafter, the original plaintiff being dissatisfied with the
decree of the Learned First Appellate Court further preferred the second
appeal under Section 100 of CPC before this High Court which was
numbered as RSA No.04 of 2022. This High Court by judgment by dated
23.04.2024 dismissed the appeal by upholding the order of the Learned
First Appellate Court :
―20. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-plaintiff stands
dismissed being devoid of merit. The judgment of the Learned First
Appellate Court dated 27.08.2021 and consequential decree dated
24.09.2021 is hereby upheld and accordingly it is affirmed.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs along with the copy of this judgment.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.‖
[10]
Challenging the judgment of the High Court, this application
for review of the judgment is preferred by the original plaintiff as review
petitioner. In course of hearing of argument, Learned senior counsel for
the review petitioner fairly submitted that the petitioner is satisfied with
the judgment and decree but the last part/para of the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court is error apparent on the face of record as
because the same has caused undue hardship to the petitioner and if
this Court does not exercise the review jurisdiction in that case, the
petitioner would suffer irreparable loss. Learned senior counsel for the
petitioner further submitted that if that part of the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court is modified to the extent, that, the
respondent-defendants cannot go beyond 3 decimals of land out of 41
decimals of land owned by one Sukhamoy Paul and also after selling 38
decimal of land to the petitioner-plaintiff, then the very purpose of
justice would suffice.
[11]
During the course of argument, Learned senior counsel for
the petitioner referred few citations which are discussed herein below:
In Chairman and Managing Director, Central Bank of
India and Others versus Central Bank of India SC/ST Employees
Welfare Association and Others reported in AIR 2016 SC 326 the
Hon’ble Apex Court in para Nos.13, 14, 15 & 16 observed as under :
―13. We would be candid in our remarks that once an error is found
in the order/judgment, which is apparent on the face of record and
meets the test of review jurisdiction as laid down in Order XLVII Rule
(1) of the Supreme Court Rules, 2013 read with Order XLVII Rule
(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, there is no reason to feel
hesitant in accepting such a mistake and rectify the same. In fact,
the reason for such a frank admission is to ensure that this mind of
patent error from the record is removed which led to a wrong
conclusion and consequently wrong is also remedied. For adopting
such a course of action, the Court is guided by the doctrine of ex
debito justitiae as well as the fundamental principal of the
administration of justice that no one should suffer because of a
mistake of the Court. These principles are discussed elaborately,
though in a different context, in A.R. Antulay v. R.S. Nayak : AIR 1988
SC 1531.
14. We would also like to reproduce the following observations in S.
Nagaraj v. State of Karnataka: 1993 Supp (4) SCC 595 :
―18. Justice is a virtue which transcends all barriers.
Neither the rules of procedure nor technicalities of law
can stand in its way. The order of the Court should not be
prejudicial to anyone. Rule of stare decisis is adhered for
consistency but it is not as inflexible in Administrative
Law as in Public Law. Even the law bends before justice.
Entire concept of writ jurisdiction exercised by the higher
courts is founded on equity and fairness. If the Court finds
that the order was passed under a mistake and it would
not have exercised the jurisdiction but for the erroneous
assumption which in fact did not exist and its perpetration
shall result in miscarriage of justice then it cannot on any
principle be precluded from rectifying the error. Mistake is
accepted as valid reason to recall an order. Difference lies
in the nature of mistake and scope of rectification,
depending on if it is of fact or law. But the root from
which the power flows is the anxiety to avoid injustice. It
is either statutory or inherent. The latter is available
where the mistake is of the Court. In Administrative Law
the scope is still wider. Technicalities apart if the Court is
satisfied of the injustice then it is its constitutional and
legal obligation to set it right by recalling its order. Here
as explained, the Bench of which one of us (Sahai, J.) was
a member did commit an error in placing all the
stipendiary graduates in the scale of First Division
Assistants due to State's failure to bring correct facts on
record. But that obviously cannot stand in the way of the
Court
correcting
its
mistake.
Such
inequitable
consequences as have surfaced now due to vague
affidavit filed by the State cannot be permitted to
continue.‖
15. The argument of public policy pressed by the respondents is of no
avail. We are conscious of the fervent plea raised by the respondent
employees that employees belonging to SC/ST category should be
made eligible for promotion by providing the reservation in the
promotional posts as well, as their representation is abysmally
minimal. However, whether there is any such justification in the
demand or not is for the State to consider and make a provision in
this behalf. This was so recorded in the judgment itself in the
following manner:
―24. In the first instance, we make it clear that there is no
dispute about the constitutional position envisaged
in Articles 15 and 16, insofar as these provisions empower
the State to take affirmative action in favour of SC/ST
category persons by making reservations for them in the
employment in the Union or the State (or for that matter,
public sector/authorities which are treated as State
under Article 12 of the Constitution). The laudable
objective underlying these provisions is also to be kept in
mind while undertaking any exercise pertaining to the
issues touching upon the reservation of such SC/ST
employees. Further, such a reservation can not only be
made at the entry level but is permissible in the matters
of promotions as wells. At the same time, it is also to be
borne in mind that Clauses 4 and 4A of Article 16 of the
Constitution are only the enabling provisions which permit
the State to make provision for reservation of these
category of persons. Insofar as making of provisions for
reservation in matters of promotion to any class or
classes of post is concerned, such a provision can be made
in favour of SC/ST category employees if, in the opinion of
the State, they are not adequately represented in services
under the State. Thus, no doubt, power lies with the State
to make a provision, but, at the same time, courts cannot
issue any mandamus to the State to necessarily make
such a provision. It is for the State to act, in a given
situation, and to take such an affirmative action. Of
course, whenever there exists such a provision for
reservation in the matters of recruitment or the
promotion, it would bestow an enforceable right in favour
of persons belonging to SC/ST category and on failure on
the part of any authority to reserve the posts, while
making selections/promotions, the beneficiaries of these
provisions can approach the Court to get their rights
enforced. What is to be highlighted is that existence of
provision for reservation in the matter of selection or
promotion, as the case may be, is the sine qua non for
seeking mandamus as it is only when such a provision is
made by the State, a right shall accrue in favour of SC/ST
candidates and not otherwise.‖
16. Once we find an error apparent on the face of the record and to
correct the said error, we have to necessarily allow these review
petitions.‖
Learned senior counsel further referred another citation in
State of Tripura and Anr. versus Dr. Shyam Lal Das reported in
(2013) 2 TLR 272 this High Court in para-6 observed as under :
―6. In the above discussion, the Apex Court also noted that there is a
clear distinction between an erroneous decision and an error
apparent on the face of the record. While the first can be corrected
by the higher forum, the latter only can be corrected by exercise of
the review jurisdiction.‖
Referring the same, Learned senior counsel drawn the
attention of the Court that if there is error apparent on the face of record
then there is a scope for exercising review jurisdiction.
[12]
Finally, Learned senior counsel drawn the attention of the
Court that since the Learned First Appellate Court committed error at the
time of delivery of judgment in the operative portion by granting liberty
to the respondent-defendants for claiming restitution of possession of
the land in their favour if their land is taken out from their possession
beyond the suit land in the proper forum, in that case, with the strength
of their title deed of 2006, the respondent-defendants would again cause
disturbance to the review petitioner in peaceful possession/enjoyment of
his purchased land. So, for correction of “error apparent on the face of
record” he urged for allowing this review petition. Learned senior counsel
further submitted that the respondents are only entitled to land
measuring 0.03 acres and this direction is only required for permanent
settlement of the dispute.
[13]
On the other hand, Mr. S. Lodh, Learned counsel for the
respondents as already stated in course of hearing of argument strongly
countered the submission made by Learned senior counsel appearing for
the review petitioner and submitted that this petition is not maintainable
as there is no error apparent on the face of record and further submitted
that this petition is liable to be dismissed with costs. Learned counsel
further submitted that after elaborate discussions this Court by the
judgment dated 23.04.2024 in RSA No.04 of 2022 has upheld the
judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court and now, with a view to
harass the respondents, this petition is filed. Learned counsel further
submitted that the scope of review jurisdiction is very much limited and
at this stage, there is no scope to entertain the application filed by the
petitioner as there is no merit to entertain the same. In support of his
contention, Learned counsel for the respondents referred the following
citations :
In Pandit Dhana Mali versus Bhimabai (Dead) through
LRs reported in (2007) 15 SCC 434 the Hon’ble Apex Court in para
Nos.1, 2, 3 & 4 has observed as under :
―1. An application seeking review of the judgment passed by the High
Court in second appeal has bene dismissed on the ground 'not
maintainable'.
2. The learned single Judge of the High Court has held that as against
a judgment in second appeal "a remedy by way of application of
review is entirely misconceive". This proposition seems to have been
too widely stated by the learned Judge.
3. We clarify that a judgment in second appeal may also be open to
review subject to a ground therefore being available within the
meaning of Order 47 Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code.
4. So far as the present case is concerned, having heard the learned
counsel for the petitioner independent of the view formed by the
High Court, we are satisfied that a case for review of the judgment
was not made out. The special leave petition is dismissed.‖
Learned counsel for the respondents further referred another
citation of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Arun Dev Apadhyaya versus
Integrated Sales Service Limited and Another reported in (2023) 8
SCC 11 in para Nos.29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37 & 45 observed as
under :
―29. A three Judge Bench of this Court comprising of Hon’ble Sri S.R.
Das, C.J., M. Hidayatullah and Sri K.C. Das Gupta, J.J. in the case
of Satyanarayan Laxminarayan Hegde v. Millikarjun Bhavanappa
Tirumale: AIR 1960 SC 137 discussed the scope of the phrase 'error
apparent on the face of record'. The challenge before this Court in the
said case was the judgment of the High Court on the ground whether
it suffers from an error apparent on the face of the record. The High
Court had issued a writ of certiorari and had quashed order of the
Tribunal and restored that of the Mamlatdar. In para 8 of the report,
the issue which was to be considered is reflected. The same is
reproduced hereunder :
―8. The main question that arises for our consideration in
this appeal by special leave granted by this Court is
whether there is any error apparent on the face of the
record so as to enable the superior court to call for the
records and quash the order by a writ of certiorari or
whether the error, if any, was ―a mere error not so
apparent on the face of the record‖, which AIR 1960 SC
137 can only be corrected by an appeal if an appeal lies at
all.‖
30. After discussing the relevant material on record, the conclusion
is stated in paragraph 17 of the report. The view was that where an
error which has to be established by a long-drawn process of
reasoning on points where there may conceivably be two opinions,
can hardly be said to be an error apparent on the face of the record.
The view that long-drawn process of arguments to canvass a point
attacking the order in a review jurisdiction, cannot be said to be an
error apparent on the face of record. Relevant extract from
paragraph 17 of the report is reproduced hereunder :
―17.....is the conclusion wrong and if so, is such error
apparent on the face of the record ? If it is clear that the
error if any is not apparent on the face of the record, it is
not necessary for us to decide whether the conclusion of
the Bombay High Court on the question of notice is correct
or not. An error which has to be established by a long
drawn process of reasoning on points where there may
conceivably be two opinions can hardly be said to be an
error apparent on the face of the record. As the above
discussion of the rival contentions show the alleged error
in the present case is far from self evident and if it can be
established, it has to be established by lengthy and
complicated arguments. We do not think such an error can
be cured by a writ of certiorari according to the rule
governing the powers of the superior court to issue such a
writ. In our opinion the High Court was wrong in thinking
that the alleged error in the judgment of the Bombay
Revenue Tribunal, viz., that an order for possession
should not be made unless a previous notice had been
given was an error apparent on the face of the record so
as to be capable of being corrected by a writ of certiorari.‖
31. Another case which may be briefly dealt with is the case
of Parison Devi Vs. Sumitri Devi: (1997) 8 SCC 715 , where, this Court
ruled that under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC, a judgment may be open to
review inter alia if there is a mistake or an error apparent on the face
of the record. An error which is not self-evident and has to be
detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error
apparent on the face of the record justifying the Court to exercise its
power of review. It also observed that a review petition cannot be
allowed to be treated as an appeal in disguise.
32. A series of decisions may also be referred to wherein, it has been
held that power to review may not be exercised on the ground that
decision was erroneous on merits as the same would be the domain
of the Court of appeal. Power of review should not be confused with
appellate powers as the appellate power can correct all manners of
errors committed by the subordinate courts. The following judgments
may be referred:
(1) Shivdeo Singh Vs. State of Punjab; AIR 1963 SC 1909
(2) Aribam Tuleshwar Sharma Vs. Aribam Pishak Sharma;
AIR 1979 SC 1047
(3) Meera Bhanja (Smt.) Vs. Nirmala Kumari Choudhary
(Smt.); (1995) 1 SCC 170
(4) Uma Nath Pandey Vs. State of U.P.; (2009) 12 SCC 40
33. Recently, this Court in a judgment dated 24.02.2023 passed in S.
Murali Sundaram Vs. Jothibai Kannan : (2023) 13 SCC 515, observed
that even though a judgment sought to be reviewed is erroneous, the
same cannot be a ground to review in exercise of powers under Order
XLVII Rule 1 CPC. Further, in the case of Perry Kansagra Vs. Smriti
Madan Kansagra: (2019) 20 SCC 753 , this Court observed that while
exercising the review jurisdiction in an application under Order 47
Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC, the Review Court does not sit in
appeal over its own order.
34. In another case between Shanti Conductors (P) Ltd. Vs. Assam
SEB: (2020)2 SCC 677 this Court observed that scope of review under
Order 47 Rule 1 read with Section 114 CPC is limited and under the
guise of review, the petitioner cannot be permitted to reagitate and
reargue questions which have already been addressed and decided.
It was further observed that an error which is not self-evident and
has to be detected by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be
an error apparent on the face of record.
35. From the above, it is evident that a power to review cannot be
exercised as an appellate power and has to be strictly confined to the
scope and ambit of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC. An error on the face of
record must be such an error which, mere looking at the record
should strike and it should not require any long-drawn process of
reasoning on the points where there may conceivably be two
opinions.
36. In the above backdrop of the scope of review to which these
petitions are confined, we proceed to consider whether a case for
review is made out or not.
37. As many as 18 grounds have been raised in the review petitions,
we have considered not only the oral submissions advanced by Mr.
Salve, learned Sr. Counsel, but have also perused all the grounds
raised in the review petition. A close perusal of the judgment dated
10.08.2021 passed in Gemini Bay Transcription (P) Ltd. v. Integrated
Sales Service Ltd. : (2022) 1 SCC 753 reflects that all the grounds
taken in the review have been discussed in detail and findings
returned not accepting the claim of the Review Petitioner. What is
sought to be argued is basically that the view taken is erroneous and
therefore, impugned judgment deserves to be reviewed.
45. Each and every argument having been considered by this Court in
its judgment dated 10.08.2021, the arguments advanced if accepted
would result in expressing a different opinion on the points raised
and decided, which we are afraid do not fall within the settled
contours of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC relating to error apparent on the
face of record. The other grounds of invoking the review power are
neither existing nor have been raised in the present petitions.‖
Referring the same, Learned counsel for the respondents
submitted that an error which is not self-evident and has to be detected
by a process of reasoning, can hardly be said to be an error apparent on
the face of the record. An error on the face of record must be such an
error which, mere looking at the record should strike and it should not
require any long- drawn process of reasoning on the points where there
may conceivably be two opinions.
[14]
Finally, Learned counsel for the respondents submitted that
in the given case, the petitioner has failed to culminate any error which
is apparent on the face of record in the judgment delivered by this Court
and meanwhile, the decree for which the suit was filed has been
executed by this time, so, at this stage, this present petition is liable to
be dismissed with costs.
[15]
After hearing both the sides at length and after going
through the citations as referred by the parties in dispute it appears to
this Court that this Court at the time of delivery of the judgment in RSA
No.04 of 2022 dated 23.04.2024 in para Nos.15 to 19 have elaborately
discussed all the rival contention of the parties and finally, uphold the
judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the relevant paras of the
judgment of the High Court dated 23.04.2024 in RSA No.04 of 2022
contained in para Nos.15 to 19 which are as follows :
15. I have heard arguments of both the sides and gone through the
records of Learned Courts below including the exhibited documents relied
upon by the parties. It appears to me that one Sukhamoy Paul, son of
Thakurdhan Paul was the owners in possession of land measuring 0.41
acres of khatian no.364 jote no.361 under Mauja-Dhalabil and the
aforesaid land measuring 0.41 acres was recorded in the name of said
Sukhamoy Paul in the following manner in the ROR:
Old CS plot nos.
Revisional CS plot nos.
Classification
Quantum
213 part
Lunga
0.22
380 part
Vastu(tilla)
0.12
300 part
Bhita(tilla)
0.05
381/1509 part
Lunga
0.02
Now, from the aforesaid land measuring 0.41 acres/shataks of land said
Sukhamoy Paul sold land measuring 0.38 acres to the appellant-plaintiff
vide registered deed bearing no.1-324 dated 23.02.1993. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to mention hereinbelow the description of land
sold by said Sukhamoy Paul in favour of the appellant-plaintiff as
mentioned in the schedule of the deed:
Description of Land:
Pargana-Birchandrapur, PS-Khowai, Tehsil-Dhalabil, Khatian no.-364, Jote
no.-361 within this CS plot nos.-213/380/300/ corresponding to hall CS
plot nos.396/1300/1301/1298 bounded by northRajendra Deb, South Rabi
Naik East Nagendra Biswas West Ashwini Banik within this boundary land
measuring 0.38 shataks(19 gandas).
On the basis of the title deed, the appellant-plaintiff applied for mutation.
Accordingly, vide mutation case no.73/94, the mutation authority allowed
mutation in favour of the appellant-plaintiff and a separate ROR was
prepared in his name in khatian no.568 under Mouja-Dhalabil, TehsilKhowai with the following descriptions of land:
Old CS plot nos.
Revisional CS plot nos.
Classification
Quantum
213 part
Lunga
0.22
380 part
Vastu(tilla)
0.12
300 part
1301/4060
Bhita(tilla)
0.04
Thus, from the above, it appears that the mutation authority at the time of
allowing mutation, on the basis of physical possession omitted mutation
from old CS plot no. part corresponding to hall plot no.1298 and finally, on
conclusion of trial, Learned Trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the
appellant-plaintiff which was challenged by the respondent-defendants.
16. Now, according to respondent-defendants, said Sukhamoy Paul
through Exhibit-B, Exhibit-A sold out 0.12 shataks of land to Radha
Gobinda Paul, son of Late Mahananda Paul being the predecessor of the
present respondentdefendants. On perusal of Exhibit-A, it appears that the
vendor at the time of transfer of land measuring 0.12 acres of land in the
year 2006 narrated the description of land as follows:
Description of
defendants:
land
purchased
by
predecessor
of
the
respondent-
Paragana-Birchandranagar, P.S – Khowai, T.K.- Dhalabil, Khatian no.-364,
touji-217 within CS plot no380 bounded by north-R. Deb, SouthSukhomaoy Paul east Ranjit Paul West – Rasta.
Thus, from the contents of the deed, it appears in the year 2006 said
Sukhamoy Paul sold out land measuring 0.12 acres(6 gandas) to the
predecessor of the respondentdefendants. Now, whether said Sukhamoy
Paul have had any authority to sell any land from CS plot no.380 is a
different matters in issue which was not the case of the appellant plaintiff
and the respondent-defendants herein. Further, it appears that the
boundary descriptions of both the purchased lands are/were totally
different.
17. Furthermore, if said Sukhamoy Paul transfers any land beyond his
ownership from old khatian No.364 after disposal of 0.38 acres of land in
favour of the appellant in the year 1993 then the respondent-defendants
shall have the liberty to take proper recourse of law against Sukhamoy
Paul if they so desires and furthermore, said Sukhamoy Paul in the year
2006 transferred 0.12 acres of land to the predecessors of the respondentdefendants. There is no any evidence on record that they sought redress in
any forum against said Sukhamoy Paul.
18. Here, in the suit, we are only confined to the suit land and it appears
that the appellant-plaintiff has been able to establish his valid right, title
and interest over the suit land and for that the Learned Court below rightly
decreed the suit in favour of the appellant-plaintiff and the Learned First
Appellate Court also confirmed the decree in favour of the
appellantplaintiff on the basis of boundary description not on the basis of
the CS plot nos.
To counter the case of the appellant-plaintiff, the respondentdefendants could not adduce any cogent oral/documentary evidence on
record before the Learned Trial Court.
19. Furthermore, as already stated on the basis of purchase vide mutation
case no.73/94 the purchased land of the appellant-plaintiff was mutated
by the appropriate authority. The appellant-plaintiff also did not challenge
that order of mutation and as per mutation, he got land measuring 0.38
acres i.e. the land purchased by him from Sukhamoy Paul and from the
contents of the deed, it appears that the vendor in the deed has clearly
given the boundary of the land sold to the appellant-plaintiff which
contained different plot nos. i.e. old CS plot no.213 corresponding to R.S.
plot no.-396, old CS plot no.380 part corresponding to R.S. plot no.1300,
old CS plot no.300 part corresponding to R.S. plot no.1301/4066 and I do
not find any ambiguity to the recording of aforesaid land on the basis of
boundary description in favour of the appellant-plaintiff. So, in my
considered view, the Learned First Appellate Court rightly delivered the
judgment and furthermore, Learned First Appellate Court specifically
mentioned in the judgment that as the decree was executed and if it is
found that any land of the respondent-defendant is given in possession to
the appellant plaintiff beyond the suit land then through the Survey
Commissioner, land be identified and if required, excess land be restored
to the respondent-defendants.
So, on perusal of the judgment of the Learned First Appellate
Court, I do not find ambiguity in the judgment rendered by the Learned
First Appellant Court and furthermore, before this Court also, the appellant
has failed to satisfy the grounds for allowing the appeal showing any
infirmity and perversity in the judgment of Learned First Appellate Court.
The substantial questions of law are accordingly answered.‖
[16]
So, from the aforesaid paras and also after hearing both the
sides, it appears that the present petitioner has failed to make out any
case to exercise the power of review as contained in Order 47 Rule 1 of
CPC read with Section 114 of CPC showing any error apparent on the
face of record. Thus, the present petition seems to be filed without any
basis for which there is no scope on the part of this Court to interfere
with the judgment delivered by this Court upholding the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court.
In the result, the application seeking review of judgment
passed by this Court dated 23.04.2024 in RSA 04 of 2022 deserves no
consideration and accordingly, it stands dismissed being devoid of merit
with costs.
JUDGE
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.08.29 15:00:57 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review