The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. Furthermore, as already stated on the basis of purchase vide mutation case no.73/94 the purchased land of the appellant-plaintiff was mutated by the appropriate authority. The appellant-plaintiff also did not challenge that order of mutation and as per mutation, he got land measuring 0.38 acres i.e. the land purchased by him from Sukhamoy Paul and from the contents of the deed, it appears that the vendor in the deed has clearly given the boundary of the land sold to the appellant-plaintiff which contained different plot nos. i.e. old CS plot no.213 corresponding to R.S. plot no.-396, old CS plot no.380 part corresponding to R.S. plot no.1300, old CS plot no.300 part corresponding to R.S. plot no.1301/4066 and I do not find any ambiguity to the recording of aforesaid land on the basis of boundary description in favour of the appellant-plaintiff. So, in my considered view, the Learned First Appellate Court rightly delivered the judgment and furthermore, Learned First Appellate Court specifically mentioned in the judgment that as the decree was executed and if it is found that any land of the respondent-defendant is given in possession to the appellantplaintiff beyond the suit land then through the Survey Commissioner, land be identified and if required, excess land be restored to the respondent-defendants. So, on perusal of the judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court, I do …
20. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-plaintiff stands dismissed being devoid of merit. The judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court dated
27. 08.2021 and consequential decree dated 24.09.2021 is hereby upheld and accordingly it is affirmed. Prepare decree accordingly. Send down the LCRs along with the copy of this judgment. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. Deepshikha
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.4 of 2022
Sri Sailesh Paul
Son of Late Surendra Chandra Paul
Resident of village Deolia Tilla,
Dhalabil, P.O. – Khowai Tea Garden,
P.S.- Khowai, District – Khowai, Tripura.
------ Appellant-plaintiff
Versus
1. Sri Ranjit Paul @ Moran Paul,
2. Sri Sanju Paul
3. Sri Samarjit Paul,
All sons of Late Radha Govinda Paul
and all are residents of village village Deolia Tilla,
Dhalabil, P.O. – Khowai Tea Garden,
P.S. – Khowai, District – Khowai, Tripura.
------Respondents-defendants
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv,
Mr. S. Das, Adv,
Mr. S. Saha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
01.04.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
23.04.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment dated
27.08.2021 and decree dated 24.09.2021 delivered by Learned
District Judge, Khowai District, Tripura in connection with T.A.
No.9 of 2019. By the said judgment, Learned District Judge
partly modified the judgment of the Learned Trial Court dated
20.03.2019 in connection with Case no. T.S. No.39 of 2016.
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. D. Bhattacharya
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. Samar Das for the appellant
and also heard Learned Counsel Mr. S. Lodh for the respondent.
3.
Before coming to the conclusion of this appeal, let us
project the subject matter of dispute amongst the rival parties
for which this present appeal cropped up.
4.
The present appellant as plaintiff has filed a suit before
the Court of Learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Khowai, Tripura
for declaration of right, title and interest, recovery of khas
possession and also for decree of permanent injunction.
5.
The gist of the case filed by the appellant-plaintiff, in
short,
is
that
the
appellant-plaintiff
purchased
suit
land
measuring 0.38 acres under Mauja Dhalabil, Khowai vide
registered
sale
deed
no.1-324
dated
23.02.1993
and
accordingly got his name mutated and the said land was
purchased by him from one Sukhomoy Paul on consideration
amount of Rs.15,000/- and after purchase, the appellantplaintiff constructed his dwelling house or in the said land. The
respondent-defendants requested the plaintiff to allow them to
reside therein as permissive possessor since 1994 and on
21.02.2016, the appellant-plaintiff requested the defendants to
vacate for his own need when they sought for two months time
but ultimately they did not vacate the same and thereafter, on
22.04.2016, when the appellant-plaintiff again asked the
respondent-defendants to vacate the same that time they
refused to do the same and finally the appellant-plaintiff filed
the suit.
6.
The respondent-defendants contested the suit by filing
written statement and submitted that the description of a
purchased land as reflected in the deed of the appellant-plaintiff
was erroneous due to incorporation of different plot nos.
including the land of the respondent-defendant’s father Radha
Gobinda Paul and the same was done by the appellant-plaintiff
by instructing the scribe/deed writer and the appellant-plaintiff
deceitfully/applying fraud obtained the signature of vendor
therein. It was further submitted that originally the suit land
along with other lands was belonging to one Sukhamoy Paul
and their father was possessing the suit land for last 40years by
purchasing the same from one Sukhamoy Paul against payment
of Rs.50,000/- as consideration price though formal deed was
executed on 24.01.2006. The contesting defendants denied the
plea of permissive possession on the suit land rather they
stated that after the death of Radha Gobinda Paul, the
respondent–defendants have possessing the same as their own
land having title therein through inheritance. It was further
submitted that after getting summons of the suit, they had sent
one notice to Sukhamoy Paul. When Sukhamoy Paul, in turn,
informed them in writing that actually he had sold out the land
of CS plot no.-213 to the respondent-plaintiff and CS plot
no.380 to Radha Gobinda Paul(since dead).
7.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Court below
framed the following issues:
i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form
and nature?
ii) Has the plaintiff cause of action to institute
this suit?
iii) Has the plaintiff right, title and interest over
the suit land?
iv) Is the story of possession of the plaintiff over
the suit land and his dispossession therefrom
true? If so, is the plaintiff entitled to keep
possession of the suit land?
v) Is the plaintiff entitled to get a decree as
prayed for?
vi) What other relief or reliefs the plaintiff is
entitled to?
8.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary
evidence on
record
which are
reproduced hereinbelow:
Plaintiff’s witness:
i) PW-1 : Sri Sailesh Ch. Paul
ii) PW-2 : Sri Sailen Ch. Paul
iii) PW-3 : Sri Sukhamoy Paul
Plaintiff’s Exhibits:
i) Ext.-1 : Certified copy of finally published
khatian bearing no.568 of Mouja-Dhalabil,
Tehsil-Dhalabil
and
Sub-division
and
Revenue Circle-Khowai.
ii) Ext.-2 : Certified copy of map of MoujaDhalabil no 27 sheet no1
iii) Ext.-3 : Certified copy of old khatian bearing
no 568 of Mouja-Dhalabil, Tehsil-Dhalabil
and Sub-division and Revenue Circle-Khowai
iv) Ext.-4 : Original registered sale deed no 1324 dated 23.02.1993
v) Ext.-4/1(series) : Signature of the vendor
Sri Sukhamoy Paul (PW 3) on the original
registered sale deed no 1-324 dated
23.02.1993
vi) Ext.-5 : Original revenue payment receipt
dated 15.02.1993 for the suit land
Defendant’s witness:
i) DW-1 : Sri Ranjit Paul
ii) DW-2 : Sri Jiban Biswas
iii) DW-3 : Sri Manik Kr Biswas
iv) DW-4 : Sri Jogesh Ch Debnath
Defendant’s Exhibits:
i) Ext.-A : Original sale deed bearing no. 1-209
dated 24.01.2006
ii) Ext.-A/1 : Signature of the Sri Manik Kr.
Biswas (DW 3) on the original registered
sale deed no 1-209 dated 24.01.2006
iii) Ext.-A/2 : Signature of the Sri Jogesh Ch
Debnath (DW 3) on the original registered
sale deed no 1-209 dated 24.01.2006
iv) Ext.-B : Certified copy of the Khatian no 364
of Mouja-Dhalabil, Tehsil, Revenue Circle
and Sub-Division-Khowai
v) Ext.-C(i) : Original death certificate of Lt.
Radha Gobinda Paul
vi) Ext.-C(ii) : Original survival certificate of the
deceased Radha Gobinda Paul
vii) Ext.-D : Original survival certificate of the
deceased Shefali Paul
viii) Ext.-E : Reply dated 11.11.2016 by the
vendor of the suit land of notice by Ld
Advocate of the defendant side to the
vendor
9.
Finally on conclusion of trial, Learned Trial Court
decreed the suit in favour of the appellant-plaintiff by judgment
dated 20.03.2019. For the sake of convenience, I would like to
refer hereinbelow the operative portion of the judgment/order
of the Learned Court below:
ORDER
“As a result it is declared that the plaintiff has
right, title and interest over the suit land and
it is directed that the defendants be evicted
therefrom and also perpetual injunction is
granted preventing the defendants and their
men and agents from disturbing the peaceful
possession of the plaintiff upon the suit land.
Hence, the suit is decreed on contest with
cost.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up for
signature within fourteen days from today,
latest on 03.04.2019.
The judgment is given under my hand and
seal of this Court on this the 20th day of
March, 2019.”
10.
Being
dissatisfied
with
the
judgment,
the
respondent-defendants preferred an appeal under Section 96 of
CPC before the Court of Learned District Judge, Khowai Tripura
and the Learned District Judge vide judgment dated 27.08.2021
and decree dated 24.09.2021 partly modified the judgment of
the Learned Trial Court. For the sake of convenience, I would
like to refer hereinbelow the operative portion of the judgment
of Learned First Appellate Court:
ORDER
“On the basis of the discussion made above,
the right, title and interest of the plaintiff in
the suit land is declared according to its
boundary description, and the survey plots as
mentioned in the Schedule of the plaint will
have no bearing in the decree.
The plaintiff is entitled to recovery of
possession of the suit land based on its
boundary description from the defendants
through due process of law.
It is stated by the parties that already decree
of Ld. Trial Court was executed, however,
liberty is granted to the defendants to pray
for restitution of possession of the suit land in
their favour in the proper Forum, if at all any
property was taken out from their possession
beyond the suit land as decreed today, and in
that case said Ld. Court will appoint a Survey
knowing Commissioner to locate the suit land
by its boundary description and possession of
excess land, if any, taken out from the
possession of the defendants will be restored
to them. Needless to say, the cost of Survey
Commissioner
will
be
borne
by
the
defendants.
In view of distinctive nature of dispute, no
cost is awarded to any of the parties.
Appeal is disposed of on contest.
Prepare
decree
stipulated period.
accordingly
within
the
Send down the L.C. Record along with a copy
of this judgment and decree.
Enter the result in the relevant register.”
11.
First
Being dissatisfied with the judgment of the Learned
Appellate
Court,
the
plaintiff
as
appellant
again
preferred this appeal under Section 100 of CPC before this
Court. At the time of admission of appeal vide order dated
17.02.2022, the following substantial questions of law were
formulated:
i) Whether the findings of the Ld. Appellate Court that
no decree should be passed based on the survey
plot as given in the purchased deed is sustainable?
ii) Whether the modification of the decree of the Ld.
Trial Court made by the Ld. Appellate Court is
sustainable in law as the same is based on
misreading of the evidence (especially Exhibit 3 and
Exhibit 4) on record?
12.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned Senior
Counsel, Mr. D. Bhattacharya referred para 9 of the judgment
of the Learned First Appellate Court and submitted that the
observation of Learned First Appellate Court compelled the
appellant-plaintiff to prefer this appeal before this Court
because the appellant-plaintiff purchased the suit land through
Exhibit-4 from one Sukhamoy Paul wherein it was mentioned
that the appellant-plaintiff purchased land from old CS plot
nos.213/380/300/
corresponding
to
hall
CS
plot
nos.396/1300/1301/1298. The settlement authority without any
basis omitted said plot no.380 at the time of mutation and the
Learned First Appellate Court at the time of delivery of
judgment
came
contradictions
to
an observation that
regarding
survey
plot
when
nos.
and
there are
boundary
descriptions then it is the settled position of law that decree can
be passed on the basis of boundary description but according to
Learned Senior Counsel that was not the prayer of the
appellant-plaintiff in the plaint. Rather the appellant-plaintiff on
the basis of his title deed sought for declaration of right, title
and interest along with recovery of possession and permanent
injunction but Learned First Appellate Court misconstrued the
factual position and came to an erroneous finding. Learned
Senior Counsel further submitted that by this time, the decree
has been executed and the respondent-defendants have filed an
application for appointment of Survey Commissioner. Now, the
respondent-defendants are trying to grab the land of the
appellant-plaintiff since Old CS plot no.-380 was omitted from
the Khatian of the appellant-plaintiff. So, Learned Senior
Counsel prayed for allowing this appeal by setting aside the
judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Senior
Counsel Mr. D. Bhattacharya also referred the evidence of said
Sukhamoy Paul (vendor) who stood as witness PW-3 on behalf
of the appellant-plaintiff and in his deposition he stated that he
did not sell any plot from plot no.380 to the appellant-plaintiff
which was nothing but a false statement because in the deed,
the said plot no. was clearly mentioned. So, Learned Senior
Counsel urged for setting aside the judgment of the Learned
First Appellate Court for the observation made in para 9 of the
judgment.
13.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel Mr. S. Lodh
appearing on behalf of the respondent-defendants submitted
that on the basis of title deed and on the basis of ROR, Learned
Trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the appellant-plaintiff
and similarly, the Learned First Appellate Court on the basis of
title deed affirmed the decree of the Learned Trial Court with
certain modification but the Learned First Appellate Court
decreed the suit land on the basis of boundary description in
place of survey plot nos. and there is no anomaly in this regard
but according to Learned Counsel, the appellant without any
basis has preferred this appeal and by this time, the decree has
been executed and furthermore, the present respondentdefendants are not claiming the land of the appellant-plaintiff.
Rather the appellant is trying to grab the land of respondentdefendants. So, Learned Counsel finally urged for dismissal of
this appeal with costs.
14.
In
course
of
hearing,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent referred one citation. In Chumar v. Narayanan
Nair dated 25.10.1985 reported in 1985 SCC OnLine Ker 246
at para 4 Hon’ble High Court of Kerala observed as under:
“4. *** *** *** *** *** *** *** *** *** **
It has to be remembered that where on a
construction of a document transferring title
to hold a property, it is clear that the
intention of the parties was to transfer a
parcel of land within well defined boundaries,
any erroneous statement or omission to state
survey number, should be rejected as falsa
domenstratis.”
15.
I have heard arguments of both the sides and gone
through the records of Learned Courts below including the
exhibited documents relied upon by the parties. It appears to
me that one Sukhamoy Paul, son of Thakurdhan Paul was the
owners in possession of land measuring 0.41 acres of khatian
no.364 jote no.361 under Mauja-Dhalabil and the aforesaid land
measuring 0.41 acres was recorded in the name of said
Sukhamoy Paul in the following manner in the ROR:
Old CS plot nos.
213 part
380 part
300 part
Revisional CS plot nos.
Classification
Lunga
Vastu(tilla)
Bhita(tilla)
Quantum
0.22
0.12
0.05
Lunga
0.02
part
Now,
from
the
aforesaid
land
measuring
0.41
acres/shataks of land said Sukhamoy Paul sold land measuring
0.38 acres to the appellant-plaintiff vide registered deed
bearing
no.1-324
convenience,
I
dated
would
23.02.1993.
like
to
For
mention
the
sake
of
hereinbelow
the
description of land sold by said Sukhamoy Paul in favour of the
appellant-plaintiff as mentioned in the schedule of the deed:
Description of Land:
Pargana-Birchandrapur,
PS-Khowai,
Tehsil-Dhalabil,
Khatian no.-364, Jote no.-361 within this CS plot
nos.-213/380/300/
corresponding to hall CS plot
nos.396/1300/1301/1298
bounded
by
north-
Rajendra Deb, South Rabi Naik East Nagendra
Biswas West Ashwini Banik within this boundary
land measuring 0.38 shataks(19 gandas).
On the basis of the title deed, the appellant-plaintiff
applied for mutation. Accordingly, vide mutation case no.73/94,
the mutation authority allowed mutation in favour of the
appellant-plaintiff and a separate ROR was prepared in his
name in khatian no.568 under Mouja-Dhalabil, Tehsil-Khowai
with the following following descriptions of land:
Old CS plot nos.
213 part
380 part
300 part
Revisional CS plot nos.
Classification
Lunga
Vastu(tilla)
Bhita(tilla)
Quantum
0.22
0.12
0.04
Thus, from the above, it appears that the mutation
authority at the time of allowing mutation, on the basis of
physical possession omitted mutation from old CS plot no.
part corresponding to hall plot no.1298 and finally, on
conclusion of trial, Learned Trial Court decreed the suit in
favour of the appellant-plaintiff which was challenged by the
respondent-defendants.
16.
Now,
according
to
respondent-defendants,
said
Sukhamoy Paul through Exhibit-B, Exhibit-A sold out 0.12
shataks of land to Radha Gobinda Paul, son of Late Mahananda
Paul
being
the
predecessor
of
the
present
respondent-
defendants. On perusal of Exhibit-A, it appears that the vendor
at the time of transfer of land measuring 0.12 acres of land in
the year 2006 narrated the description of land as follows:
Description of land purchased by predecessor of the
respondent-defendants:
Paragana-Birchandranagar,
P.S
–
Khowai,
T.K.-
Dhalabil, Khatian no.-364, touji-217 within CS plot no380 bounded by north-R. Deb, South-Sukhomaoy
Paul east Ranjit Paul West – Rasta.
Thus, from the contents of the deed, it appears in the
year 2006 said Sukhamoy Paul sold out land measuring 0.12
acres(6
gandas)
to
the
predecessor
of
the
respondent-
defendants. Now, whether said Sukhamoy Paul have had any
authority to sell any land from CS plot no.380 is a different
matters in issue which was not the case of the appellantplaintiff and the respondent-defendants herein. Further, it
appears that the boundary descriptions of both the purchased
lands are/were totally different.
17.
Furthermore, if said Sukhamoy Paul transfers any land
beyond his ownership from old khatian No.364 after disposal of
0.38 acres of land in favour of the appellant in the year 1993
then the respondent-defendants shall have the liberty to take
proper recourse of law against Sukhamoy Paul if they so desires
and furthermore, said Sukhamoy Paul in the year 2006
transferred 0.12 acres of land to the predecessors of the
respondent-defendants. There is no any evidence on record that
they sought redress in any forum against said Sukhamoy Paul.
18.
Here, in the suit, we are only confined to the suit land
and it appears that the appellant-plaintiff has been able to
establish his valid right, title and interest over the suit land and
for that the Learned Court below rightly decreed the suit in
favour of the appellant-plaintiff and the Learned First Appellate
Court also confirmed the decree in favour of the appellantplaintiff on the basis of boundary description not on the basis of
the CS plot nos.
To counter the case of the appellant-plaintiff, the
respondent-defendants
could
not
adduce
any
cogent
oral/documentary evidence on record before the Learned Trial
Court.
19.
Furthermore, as already stated on the basis of purchase
vide mutation case no.73/94 the purchased land of the
appellant-plaintiff was mutated by the appropriate authority.
The appellant-plaintiff also did not challenge that order of
mutation and as per mutation, he got land measuring 0.38
acres i.e. the land purchased by him from Sukhamoy Paul and
from the contents of the deed, it appears that the vendor in the
deed has clearly given the boundary of the land sold to the
appellant-plaintiff which contained different plot nos. i.e. old CS
plot no.213 corresponding to R.S. plot no.-396, old CS plot
no.380 part corresponding to R.S. plot no.1300, old CS plot
no.300 part corresponding to R.S. plot no.1301/4066 and I do
not find any ambiguity to the recording of aforesaid land on the
basis of boundary description in favour of the appellant-plaintiff.
So, in my considered view, the Learned First Appellate Court
rightly delivered the judgment and furthermore, Learned First
Appellate Court specifically mentioned in the judgment that as
the decree was executed and if it is found that any land of the
respondent-defendant is given in possession to the appellantplaintiff
beyond
the
suit
land
then
through
the
Survey
Commissioner, land be identified and if required, excess land be
restored to the respondent-defendants.
So, on perusal of the judgment of the Learned First
Appellate Court, I do not find ambiguity in the judgment
rendered by the Learned First Appellant Court and furthermore,
before this Court also, the appellant has failed to satisfy the
grounds for allowing the appeal showing any infirmity and
perversity in the judgment of Learned First Appellate Court. The
substantial questions of law are accordingly answered.
20.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-plaintiff
stands dismissed being devoid of merit. The judgment of the
Learned
First
Appellate
Court
dated
27.08.2021
and
consequential decree dated 24.09.2021 is hereby upheld and
accordingly it is affirmed.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs along with the copy of this
judgment.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
Deepshikha
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.04.24 18:26:43 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review