Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/sri-sadhan-chandra-chanda-and-anr-vs-sri-binode-shil-and-ors-20220913/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Civil

Sri Sadhan Chandra Chanda and Anr. vs Sri Binode Shil and Ors.

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Tripura High Court
Date
13 September 2022
Case No.
RSA 1/2020
Result
Dismissed
Bench
T. Amarnath Goud
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

21. In view of the above discussions and observations made, this Court is of the opinion that the judgment and decree passed by the lower Courts dated

16. 07.2018 & 18.07.2018 and 30.08.2019 & 02.09.2019 respectively in T.S. No.21 of 2017 and T.A No.07 of 2018 are just and proper and needs no interference. Accordingly, the concurrent finding is affirmed and this instant second appeal stands dismissed.

22. Consequently, pending application(s), if any, also stand closed. Send back the LCRs. Suhanjit

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA AGARTALA RSA NO.01 OF 2020 1. Sri Sadhan Chandra Chanda, Son of late Upendra Ch. Chanda. 2. Smt. Sefali Chanda, Wife of Sri Sadhan Chandra Chanda, Both are residents of North Chandrapur(Rajbari Ward), P.S.- R.K. Pur, Sub-Division- Udaipur, District-Gomati Tripura. ………Plaintiff-Appellant(s) Vs. 1. Sri Binode Shil, Son of Late Raj Kumar Shil. 2. Sri Subhas Shil, Son of Late Rajkumar Shil. 3. Sri Ratan Shil, Son of Late Krishna Kumar Shil, All are resident of North Chandrapur (Rajbari Ward), P.S.- R.K. Pur, Sub-Division-Udaipur, District-Gomati Tripura. ……..Defendant Respondent(s) For the Appellant(s) : Mr. S.K. Deb, Sr. Advocate Mr. B. Debnath, Advocate. For the Respondent(s) : Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, Sr. Advocate. Mr. S. Das, Advocate. Date of hearing : 06.09.2022 Date of delivery of Judgment & Order : 13/09/2022. Whether fit for reporting : NO. HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD JUDGMENT AND ORDER This present second appeal has been filed under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, read with Order XLII Rule 1 for reversing the impugned Judgment and Decree dated 16.07.2018 & 18.07.2018 respectively passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura in Title Suit No.21 of 2017 and the impugned Judgment and Decree dated 30.08.2019 and 02.09.2019 passed by the learned District Judge, Gomati Tripura, Udaipur in Title Appeal No.07 of 2018 and thereupon, for decreeing the suit, filed by the plaintiff-appellants. 2. The facts of the case, in brief, are that the subject matter of the present suit is land measuring 0.07 acre under allotted-khatian No.815, Hal Plot No.1613/2762 situated at Mouja – Uttar Chandrapur appertaining to Hal Plot No.1613 of area 0.20 acres, i.e., total 0.27 acres described in ―A‖ schedule of the plaint. The plaintiff-appellants herein asserted that considering their possession over "A‖ Schedule land the competent authority allotted the entire ―A‖ Schedule land in the names of the plaintiff-appellants herein vide Allotment Order No.40 dated 26-04-1991. Accordingly, the allottee Khatian No.815 was prepared in their name on 07-08-1992. Subsequently, the computerized printed Khatian No.815 was generated in respect of the said allotted land of the plaintiffs. But in the said Khatian, erroneously, in Column No.6 the name and father's name of the plaintiff-appellant No.1 was wrongly typed as Sadhan Chandra Dey, S/o Upendra Chandra Dey instead of Sadhan Chandra Chanda, S/o Upendra Chandra Chanda and also the name of plaintiff No.2 as Sefali Dey instead of Sefali Chanda. Accordingly, the plaintiffs made a prayer before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Udaipur for correction of the said error in Column No.6 of the computerized printed Khatian No.815. The said matter is pending for disposal. According to the plaintiffs, in the last part of November 2011 the defendants dispossessed them from the entire land of Hal Plot No.1613/2762 of an area measuring 0.07 acres which is described as Schedule ―C‖ in the plaint and which is part of the ―A‖ schedule land. Since then the defendants have been illegally possessing Schedule "C" land by constructing dwelling huts and have been residing with their family members. The remaining land of Schedule ―A" of the plaint, i.e., the land of Plot No.1614, an area measuring 0.20 acres is described as Schedule ―B‖ land in the plaint. According to the plaintiff-appellants they have been possessing the Schedule ―B‖ land as owners to the knowledge of the local people including the present defendants to date. The defendants have illegally possessed the ―C" Schedule land since the last part of November 2011, and, they need to be evicted. The defendants on 02-06-2017 attempted to dispossess the plaintiffs from the Schedule ―B‖ land by cutting mud from the part of the said land but failed due to resistance put up by the plaintiffs. 3. On the said premises, the plaintiffs prayed for a decree of declaration of the right, title, and interest over Schedule "A‖ land along with a perpetual injunction restraining the defendants from entering into the Schedule ―B‖ land and for recovery of possession of the Schedule ―C‖ land. 4. On the other hand, defendants Nos.1 and 2 contested the suit by filing the written statement. According to the defendants, their father was residing at Uttar Chandrapur from the year 1979 by purchasing some lands adjacent to the CS Plot No.1174/1658 which was a khas land measuring 0.07 acres. They constructed dwelling huts on 0.07 acre of khas land in the year 1979 and in the lifetime of their father, they also constructed a pucca wall with pucca roof with GI sheet roof and a dwelling house. According to the defendants, the plaintiff Sadhan Chandra Chanda was a Government employee and was a resident of Kalaban where he has been residing with his second wife Smti. Kiran Chanda. His first wife Smti. Sefali Chanda left him in the year 1990 for Kolkata. Sadhan Chandra Chanda was the permanent resident of Kalaban with Kiran Chanda and he had other landed property at Kalaban. Sadhan Chandra Chanda managed to get allotment order in his and his first wife, Sefali Chanda's name, in violation of the Allotment Rules, 1980. The distance between North Chandrapur and Kalaban is 15 Kms. The defendants‘ father Late Raj Kumar Shil filed a case for cancellation of the allotment order in the year 1992 before the SDM and Collector, Udaipur, and the case was enquired by the Revenue Inspector as per direction of the SDM and Collector, Udaipur. Subsequently, the predecessor of the defendants came to learn that the entire inquiry report and the petition for cancellation of the allotment order were missing from the office of the SDM. In the year 2000, the defendants‘ father Raj Kumar Shil filed another petition for cancellation of the allotment order for Plot No.1613/2762 of land measuring 0.07 acre before the Court of the DM and Collector, South Tripura District. The petition was sent for inquiry to the SDM, Udaipur, and based on the inquiry made by the SDM Udaipur, the ADM and Collector registered Case No.13 of 2005 under Section 96 of the TLR and LR Act and notice was issued to Sadhan Chandra Chanda, the second party to the proceeding. In the said revenue proceeding it transpired that the land measuring 0.07 acre under RS Plot No.1613/2762 was being possessed by Raj Kumar Shil. But, the said case record was again found missing from the office of the SDM and Collector, Udaipur. According to the defendants, Sadhan Chandra Chanda is a politically influential person and he was also convicted in a Criminal Case and he managed to remove the case record in connivance with the staff of the SDM's office, Udaipur on two occasions. The father of the defendants died in the year 2015 and the answering defendants have been residing in the "C‖ Schedule land from their childhood along with their parents. Subsequently, after their marriage, they have also been residing in the ―C‖ schedule land with their family members. According to the defendants, the plaintiffs never possessed the ―C" Schedule land though they managed to get the allotment order in their name. The plaintiffs tried to enter into the suit land many times but failed. On the said premises, the defendants prayed for the dismissal of the suit of the plaintiffs. 5. The trial court frame the following issues in the suit :―(i) Whether the plaintiffs have right, title and interest over the suit land mentioned in the Schedule “A” of the plaint? (ii) Whether the plaintiffs have fulfilled all the criterion of the Allotment Rule regarding allotment of suit land in their favour? (iii) Whether the defendants are in wrongful possession of the suit land mentioned in the Schedule “C” of the plaint? (iv) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get a decree as prayed for along with any other relief or reliefs?” 6. In support of their case the plaintiffs examined one witness namely Shri Sadhan Chandra Chanda and adduced the following documentary evidence:• Original allotment order No.40 dated 26-04-1991 marked as Exhibit-1. • Allottee Khatian No.815 of Mouja – Uttar Chandrapur standing in the name of the plaintiffs marked as Exhibit-2 (SO). • RS Map of Mouja – Uttar Chandrapur relating to suit plots marked as Exhibit-3. 7. On the other side, the defendants examined three witnesses namely- D.W.1 – Shri Binod Shil, D.W.2 – Shri Pradip Das, and D.W.3 – Shri Ratan Shil, and adduced the following documents:- • Certified copy of Revenue Case No.13 of 2005 in connection with Cancellation of Allotment order by the SDM, Udaipur dated 10-03-2006 marked as Exhibit- A. • Field Enquiry Report of Raj Kumar Shil in connection with reference No.1003 dated 21-10-2005 marked as Exhibit-B (SO). • Prayer for cancellation of allotment record of seven decimal of land pertaining to Dag No.1613/2762 of Khatian No.815 marked as Exhibit- C. • Certified copy of Ordersheet in Revenue Case No.13 of 2005 in 2 sheets marked as Exhibits-D/1 and D/2. • Petition by Raj Kumar Shil to the SDM, Udaipur marked as Exhibit-E. 8. After hearing both sides, the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura passed the Judgment and Decree dated 16.07.2018 and 18.07.2018, thereby dismissing the suit. 9. impugned Being aggrieved Judgment and and decree dissatisfied dated with the 16.07.2018 and 18.07.2018 respectively, passed in T.S.21 of 2017, the plaintiffs preferred a First Appeal marked as Title Appeal No.07 of 2018 before the learned District Judge, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura. After hearing both the side, the learned District Judge passed the impugned Judgment and Decree dated 30.09.2019 & 02.09.2019 respectively, thereby dismissing the appeal in the following terms:“In the result, the appeal I dismissed being devoid of merit. Judgment dated 16.07.2018 and decree date 18.07.2018 passed by the learned Civil Judge(Sr. Division), Court No.1, Udaipur in Title Suit No.21 of 2017 is hereby upheld..” 10. Aggrieved thereby, the plaintiff-appellants herein has preferred this instant second appeal and prayed for the following reliefs:“ i) Admit the second appeal; ii) Issue notice upon the Defendant-Respondent; iii) Call for the records, appertaining to this Second Appeal; iv) After hearing, allow this Second Appeal by reversing the impugned Judgment & Decree dated 16.08.2018 & 18.07.2018 respectively, passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura in Title Suit No.21 of 2017, & the impugned Judgment & Decree dated 30.08.2019 & 02.09.2019 respectively, passed by the learned District, Judge, Gomati Tripura, Udaipur in Title Appeal No.07 of 2018, and thereupon, for decreeing the suit, thereby declaring the right, title & interest of the plaintiffs over the suit land, and directly for recovery of possession; v) The Hon’ble High Court may also pass any further order(s) as may deem fit and proper;” 11. This present second appeal has been admitted on 01.09.2020 and the following substantial questions of law were formed:“ (i) Whether the order of allotment of land issued under Section 14 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 read with Rules 3 and 6 of the TLR & LR Act(Allotment of land) Rules, 1980 can constitute the subject matter of adjudication in a civil suit. In view of the statutory bar, contained in Section 44 and 188 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960? (ii) Whether in the absence of a determination as to the validity of the order of allotment, by the allotting authority in the right of allotee to continue the possession of the allotted land can be interfered with by a Civil Court? (iii) Whether the validity of the order of allotment can be examined, after elapse of a period of three years from the date of such allotment, in view of the settled law in this regard? (iv) Whether in view of this statutory prescriptions, contained in Sections35 and 74 of the Evidence Act, 1872, the enquiry reports(Exbt-C) adduced by the defendants were admissible in evidence, until and unless, the Enquiring Authorities are examined in connection therewith? (v) Any other substantial question of law urged at the time of hearing of the present second appeal.” 12. Heard Mr. S.K. Deb, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. A. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the appellants as well as Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. S. Das, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. 13. Mr. S.K. Deb, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. A. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff-appellants herein submitted that Courts below have committed an error of law in appreciating that long and continuous possession does not create title. On the other hand, the plaintiffs obtained the suit land by way of allotment, and have acquired the right, title, and interest over the same. Hence they were entitled to recovery of possession of ―C” schedule of land, by evicting the defendants therefrom. The Courts below have committed an error in appreciating that a Civil Court has no jurisdiction, to determine as to whether the plaintiffs have fulfilled all the criteria of the Allotment Rules, regarding allotment of the suit land in their favour inasmuch as these matters pertain to the functioning of the Revenue Authorities, under the provisions of the Tripura Land Revenue & Lands Reforms Act, 1960. The competent authorities had rightly allotted the suit land in favour of the plaintiffs, and the allotment order issued in connection therewith had not been canceled till date by the said authority. As such, it is evidently clear that the said allotment order holds good, and the Civil Court had no jurisdiction to interfere with the same. The inquiry report i.e. Exbt-C does not prove the possession of the predecessor of the defendants, prior to the date of the said inquiry. The Court below committed an error in appreciating that an allotment order can be canceled by the competent authority, within 3(three)years from the date of allotment, and not posterior thereto. In the written statement, the defendants have admitted that the allotment order was issued, in favour of the plaintiffs, which very clearly and unambiguously manifests that the suit land was duly allotted, in favour of the plaintiffs, by the competent authority. Stating thus, learned Sr. counsel prayed to allow this instant appeal. 14. Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. S. Das, learned counsel appears for the respondents submits that suit is not maintainable for non-joinder of parties. The plaintiff-appellants herein have not fulfilled the requirement of Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms (allotment of lands) Rule 1980. The plaintiff-appellants did never possess the ―C‖ schedule of land measuring 0.07 acres. The father of the answering defendant, Raj Kumar Shil had been possessing the ―C‖ schedule land from the year 1979 A.D. So the question of dispossession by the defendants does not arise. Paragraph- 5 of the plaint is totally false. The defendants never dispossessed the plaintiff from the ―C‖ scheduled land. As the plaintiffs were not in possession at the time of alleged allotment or prior to or after in the suit land, so the question of dispossession does not arise. The plaintiffs are out of possession of the ―A‖ schedule land and as per TLR & LR(Allotment of Land) Rules 1980, the plaintiffs have no right, title, and interest in the suit land. The plaintiffSadhan Chandra Chanda managed to get an allotment order in his name and in the name of his 1st wife Sefali Chanda violating the Allotment Rules, 1980. The plaintiffs never possessed the ‗C' schedule land in their name. The plaintiffs tried to enter into the suit land many times but failed. The answering defendants and their father now deceased acquired possessory right, title, interest, and possession over the 'C' scheduled land after possessing the same for the last 38 years. 15. Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record. 16. This instant appeal is filed for declaration of right, title, interest, and recovery of possession. It becomes the prima facie duty of the plaintiff-appellants herein to claim right and title. The plaintiff-appellants have to establish the right accrued in accordance with the law. In so far as the plaintiffappellants are concerned, the plaintiffs have claimed the title over the property by virtue of the allotment order, but, they have not chosen to array the revenue officials as party defendants and also have not chosen to summon them as witnesses to speak on the validity of the allotment order. If the plaintiffs are having a valid allotment in their favour, and when there is no dispute on the said allotment and further if there is no claim on the said allotment, seeking of declaration of title on the suit land was not warranted. 17. This Court feels that the plaintiff-appellants have not approached this Court with clean hands. The plaintiffappellants have not proved their case beyond reasonable doubt to say that the plaintiff-appellants were in possession of the land and were dispossessed and, therefore, seeking relief for recovery of possession from the defendants. Under whatever authority, the defendant—respondents are in possession, admittedly, the father of the defendants has claimed that he purchased the impugned property way back in the year 1979 and thereafter constructed the house. They are staying in the said house and after the demise of their father, his grown-up children are continuing their possession upon the said dwelling house which is constructed on their land in an extent of 0.07 acres. The plaintiff-appellants have not placed any evidence on record to show on which date, the defendant-respondents have dispossessed them and in such case, any complaint to the police station or any notice to that effect to show that on that particular date they were dispossessed. The plaintiff-appellants have also not placed any evidence before the Court to show that they were in lawful possession and in the enjoyment of the property under the capacity of the lawful owner. Though there are several conditions to be followed by the plaintiff-appellants in the order of allotment, it is not for this Court to go into the issues as to whether the land is put to use or not for the purpose the allotment was made, whether the installment amount as per the allotment is paid or not etc. But, it is necessary for the plaintiff-appellants to get the Government authorities examined before the Court to say that the allotment made in their favour is valid and subsisting and the same is not canceled and the plaintiff-appellants were the lawful owner. 18. Further as per Rules of the said TLR & LR(Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980, in allotting land for the construction of dwelling house, the Collector shall follow the following order of preference namely :- (i) jhumia, (ii) a landless agricultural worker or an artisan not owning any house or site for a house (iii) an individual evicted under section 15 who does not come in any of the categories mentioned in the foregoing clauses and does not own any house or site for a house and (iv) any other person not owning any house or site for a house or who intends to build the house for personal habitation. But in the instant case, there is nothing on record to show that the plaintiff-appellants fall in any of the aforesaid categories so as to get the allotment of the suit land. Situated thus, this Court is of the view that the Courts below have rightly held that the allotment order in favour of the plaintiffs were not legally tenable and thus liable to be set aside. 19. Further on perusal of the Exbt-1, i.e. the allotment order dated 26.04.1991, it appears that there is stipulated in the order requiring the allotee to make payment of Rs.13,500/- as allotee Najrana. But there is nothing on record to show whether the plaintiff-appellants have made the said payment. 20. Another striking aspect of the case is that though the alleged wife of plaintiff No.1 namely Smt. Shefali Chanda was a co-allottee in respect of the suit land, but, she has not turned up to depose in the case and there is also no explanation from the side of the husband allottee in this regard. That being the position of the case, plaintiff-appellants herein suffers from material lacuna in this regard, in the sense that, had the lady been present in the trial, the defendants would have got a reasonable opportunity to cross-examine her so as to help the Court to adjudicate the matter more comprehensively. 21. In view of the above discussions and observations made, this Court is of the opinion that the judgment and decree passed by the lower Courts dated 16.07.2018 & 18.07.2018 and 30.08.2019 & 02.09.2019 respectively in T.S. No.21 of 2017 and T.A No.07 of 2018 are just and proper and needs no interference. Accordingly, the concurrent finding is affirmed and this instant second appeal stands dismissed. 22. Consequently, pending application(s), if any, also stand closed. Send back the LCRs. JUDGE Suhanjit

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Tripura HC judgments →