The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. 1.2014. It is also the plea of the defendant that plaintiff is friend of the son of defendant and the defendant talked with the plaintiff about her land in possession of the sons of Prafulla Ch. Sen and plaintiff advised the defendant to file a suit for recovery of possession against the sons of deceased Prafulla and if the defendant has any problem the defendant may give power of attorney in favour of the plaintiff to file the suit for recovery of possession and accordingly, the defendant agreed with the proposal of plaintiff and asked the plaintiff to prepare power of attorney and thereafter, the plaintiff asked the defendant in presence of his son in law to put signature on the said written document for filing suit against the son of deceased Prafulla Ch. Sen and on good faith the defendant signed on that document and the son in law of the defendant also put his signature and after receiving summons from this Court when the defendant met with her counsel she came to know that the plaintiff made false deed where the plaintiff signed being illiterate considering the same as power of attorney. Therefore, it was the plea of the defendant that the plaintiff created forged deed/ agreement for sale and prayed for dismissal of the suit of the plaintiff. [5] The details of the scheduled suit land is given below: Schedule of Suit Land With in sub-division Udaipur, Mouja – Gakulpur, R.…
19. Resultantly the appeal is allowed and the Judgment and Decree dated 16.02.2017 and 02.03.2017 respectively passed the Court of Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division)cum-Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in TS-03 of 2016 decreeing the suit of the plaintiff-respondent is set aside. [10] For ready reference the text of Exbt-5 is reproduced herein under: Exbt- 5(I) to 5 (V) Agreement of Sale This is a Bainapatra )Agreement of sale ) for the sale of total ara f land measuring 0.08 decimal at a consideration of Rs.5000.00 (Rupees five thousand) situated within mouja- Dhwajanangar. Shri Rupak Dey, S/o Shri. Debendra Chandra De, Village: NO.2 Fulkumari (Poultry Road), PS: R. K. Pur, Pg- Udaipur, Dist: Gomati Tripura, Caste- Hindu, Occupatoin – Business, Citizen of India. -----First Party Smt. Niyati Debnath, W/o Shri Nibash Debnath, VillageChatariya, PS: R.K Pur, Pg- Udaipur, Dist: Gomati Tripura, Caste- Hindu, Occupation- domestic works, Citizen of India -----Second party This „Bainapatra‟ (Agreement of sale) for the sale of land with rayati jote title is executed to the following effect: That the second party have been remaining as owner and possessor over total area of land measuring 0.08(eight) decimal appertaining to dag no. 2489, recorded in Khatian No.3077, situated within mouja- Dwajanagar, within Tehshil – Dwajanaagar. Presently for the purpose of daught…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 50 of 2018
Sri Rupak Dey
S/o- Sri Debandra Dey
No: 2 Fulkumari (Poultry Road)
PS: RK Pur, Udaipur, District: Gomati
----The Appellant
Versus
Smt. Niyati Debnath
W/o: Nibash Debnath
R/o: Chataria, PS: R.K. Pur.
Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura
----The Respondent
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing & date of
Judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. P Roy Barman, Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
: Ms. P. Dhar, Adv.
Mr. H. Debbarma, Adv.
: 24.02.2022.
: No
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the CPC against the
judgment dated 17.07.2018, passed in Title Appeal No.04/2017 by the
Ld. Additonal District Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur.
[2]
For the sake of brevity the parties are referred to as in the
title suit 03 of 2016. The brief fact of the plaintiff's case is that the
defendant is the owner and possessor of the suit land and in the middle
part of the year 2014 in the urgent need of money the defendant
proposed the plaintiff to sell the suit land and accordingly, the plaintiff
has agreed to purchase the same and accordingly, both the plaintiff and
defendant met with the deed writer in the office chamber of Deed writer
and a unregistered deed (Bainapatra) was made on 12.5.2014 and
plaintiff paid Rs.5000/- to the defendant as part payment and
accordingly plaintiff and defendant has put their signatures on the every
page of unregistered deed and thereafter, the witnesses also signed in
the said deed including the Deed writer and, thereafter, the defendant
did not make any contact with the plaintiff and did not and failed to
comply with the terms and conditions of the Bainapatra and on
7.2.2014 plaintiff requested the defendant to execute registered sale
deed and deliver vacant possession of the suit land and the defendant
demanded more Rs.25,000/- excess from the settled consideration
money of Rs.1,90,000/- and thereafter, the plaintiff issued notice upon
the defendant on 7.3.2015 but the defendant refused to receive the
said notice and thereafter plaintiff met with the defendant and
requested to register the deed and hand over the possession in favour
of the plaintiff but the defendant failed to do so even though the
plaintiff is ready and willing to perform his part of contract.
[3]
Aggrieved thereby the plaintiff approached the court of the
Civil Judge Senior Division, Gomati, Udaipur, Tripura (in short the trial
court) for specific performance of contract for passing a direction upon
the defendant to execute and register a sale deed in favour of the
plaintiff.
[4]
The suit of the plaintiff is contested by defendant by filing
written statement denying all the plea of the plaintiff and interalia
pleaded that one Aswini Kr. Debnath, son of Bishnu Charan Debnath the
father of the defendant was the owner in possession of a land under
Khatian No.168/1 of Mouja Dhajanagar under plot No.2489 measuring
0.0 acre and during his life time the said Aswini Kr. Debnath requested
one Sri Prafulla Ch. Sen to look after and to manage the suit land in his
favour and while said Prafulla ch. Sen used to look after the said land,
the said Aswini Kr. Denmath died on 12.2.1993 leaving the defendant
as his only legal heir as daughter and the defendant also allowed the
said Prafulla Ch. Sen to stay over the suit land till his death who died in
the year 2010 and, thereafter, legal heirs of deceased Prafulla Ch. Sen
were allowed to possess the said land till 2013 and, thereafter, in the
year 2013, the defendant asked to hand over the vacant possession of
the suit land but the sons of Prafulla Ch. Sen failed to hand over the
possession and ultimately refused to hand over the possession lastly on
12.1.2014. It is also the plea of the defendant that plaintiff is friend of
the son of defendant and the defendant talked with the plaintiff about
her land in possession of the sons of Prafulla Ch. Sen and plaintiff
advised the defendant to file a suit for recovery of possession against
the sons of deceased Prafulla and if the defendant has any problem the
defendant may give power of attorney in favour of the plaintiff to file
the suit for recovery of possession and accordingly, the defendant
agreed with the proposal of plaintiff and asked the plaintiff to prepare
power of attorney and thereafter, the plaintiff asked the defendant in
presence of his son in law to put signature on the said written document
for filing suit against the son of deceased Prafulla Ch. Sen and on good
faith the defendant signed on that document and the son in law of the
defendant also put his signature and after receiving summons from this
Court when the defendant met with her counsel she came to know that
the plaintiff made false deed where the plaintiff signed being illiterate
considering the same as power of attorney. Therefore, it was the plea of
the defendant that the plaintiff created forged deed/ agreement for sale
and prayed for dismissal of the suit of the plaintiff.
[5]
The details of the scheduled suit land is given below:
Schedule of Suit Land
With in sub-division Udaipur, Mouja – Gakulpur,
R.S. Khatian No- 3077, the land appertaining to: Sabek
No
112(P)
Dag
Hal Dag No.
Nature
Area
Bastu (tilla)
0.08 acres
The land butted and bounded by :North : Road
South: Dwelling house of Prafulla Sen Now Sanjib Sen
Legal heirs of Prafulla Sen
East: Road
West: Tilla
With in this boundary land measuring – 0.08 acres.
[6]
After considering the pleadings and submission of both
sides, the trial court has framed the following issues for discussion:
(i) Whether the suit maintainable?
(ii) Whether the agreement for sale dated 21.05.2015 in
between the plaintiff and defendant is executed by
plaintiff by exercising fraud, misrepresentation and undue
influence?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the relief as prayed
for and/ or any other relief or reliefs in this suit?
[7]
To prove the plaintiff's case, the plaintiff has examined as
many as 05 (five) witnesses and produced 05(five) documents. On the
contrary the defendant has examined 02(two) witnesses and produced
no documents
[8]
The trial court after having examined all the records so
placed in the plaint and also after examining the written statement filed
by the defendant-appellant, depositions of PWs and DWs in support of
the claim, has observed by the order dated 16.02.2017 as herein
under:
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is allowed on
contest with cost with a direction upon the defendant to
execute the sale deed in favour of the plaintiff in respect
of the suit land and deliver possession of the suit land to
plaintiff and the plaintiff is to pay the balance
consideration money of Rs.1,85,000/- to the defendant
and bear other cost and fees of registration and failing to
which the Court will execute the sale deed in favour of
plaintiff as per law and would deliver possession of the
suit land to the plaintiff.”
[9]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree passed in the original suit, the respondnet herein preferred an
appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.04 of 2017 in the court of the
Additional District Judge, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur. The said
court while allowing has observed in its order dated 17.07.2017 in the
following manner:
“18. In view of the aforesaid discussion I find and hold
that the respondent failed to prove his readiness and
willingness within the stipulated time towards part
performance of the agreement, which was a necessary
requirement as per Ext.5.
As the respondent failed to prove his readiness and
willingness so, he was not entitled to a decree for Specific
Performance of Agreement and so, I hold that the decision
of the Learned Trial Court was not correct and the same
cannot be allowed to be sustained.
19. Resultantly the appeal is allowed and the Judgment
and Decree dated 16.02.2017 and 02.03.2017 respectively
passed the Court of Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division)cum-Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur in TS-03 of 2016 decreeing the suit of the
plaintiff-respondent is set aside.
[10]
For ready reference the text of Exbt-5 is reproduced herein
under:
Exbt- 5(I) to 5 (V)
Agreement of Sale
This is a Bainapatra )Agreement of sale ) for the sale of
total ara f land measuring 0.08 decimal at a consideration
of Rs.5000.00 (Rupees five thousand) situated within
mouja- Dhwajanangar.
Shri Rupak Dey, S/o Shri. Debendra Chandra De, Village:
NO.2 Fulkumari (Poultry Road), PS: R. K. Pur, Pg- Udaipur,
Dist: Gomati Tripura, Caste- Hindu, Occupatoin – Business,
Citizen of India.
-----First Party
Smt. Niyati Debnath, W/o Shri Nibash Debnath, VillageChatariya, PS: R.K Pur, Pg- Udaipur, Dist: Gomati Tripura,
Caste- Hindu, Occupation- domestic works, Citizen of
India
-----Second party
This „Bainapatra‟ (Agreement of sale) for the sale of land
with rayati jote title is executed to the following effect:
That the second party have been remaining as owner and
possessor over total area of land measuring 0.08(eight)
decimal appertaining to dag no. 2489, recorded in Khatian
No.3077, situated within mouja- Dwajanagar, within
Tehshil – Dwajanaagar.
Presently for the purpose of daughter‟s marriage
ceremony, when (I) proposed to make a sale of total area
of land measuring 0.08 (eight) decimal described in the
schedule, the first party agreed to purchase the same and
accordingly the second party have agreed to sell the land
described in the schedule at a valuation of Rs.1,90,000.00
(Rupees on lac ninety thousand)
Accordingly, today the first party paid an amount of
Rs.5000.00 (Rupees five thousand) to the second part as
„baina‟ (advance payment) and the second party also
received the said amount of „baina‟ (advance payment) in
cash from the first party and within 1 month on any day
after making spot measurement of the land described in
the schedule shall hand over the possession of the land
and make the registration of the out and out sale deed of
the land described in the schedule below and the first
party shall pay the valuation of the land described in the
schedule below to the second party and shall make the
registration of the out- and –out sale deed.
The End- 21.05.2014 A.D.
Witnesses
1) Sd/- Sajal Debnath
Village- Gakulpur
Sd/- Rupak Dey
Sd/- Niyati Debnath
2) Sd/- Shri Nepal Chandra
Chakraborty, D.W.
Scribe and witnesses:
3) Sd/- Habib Ahamed
Khadim, D.W.
[11]
Sd/- Shri. Anjan Karmakar
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree of the
first appellate court dated 17.07.2017, the appellant/plaintiff herein has
preferred this instant appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. At the time
of admitting this appeal, the following substantial question of law was
framed by this court by the order dated 21.01.2019.
(i) Whether the findings of the learned appellate court is
perverse being based on no evidence?
(ii) Whether time is the very essence for enforcement of
specific performance of contract?
(iii) Whether compliance of section 16(c) of the Specific
Relief Act, 1963 is to be by latter and spirit or it can be
inferred from the pleadings and circumstances pertaining
to the conduct of the parties to the specific performance
for contract?
(iv) Any other substantial question of law that may be
framed at the time of
hearing?
[12]
Heard Mr. P Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing
for the appellant as well as Ms. P. Dhar, learned counsel for the
respondent.
[13]
The suit has been filed by the appellant herein seeking relief
for specific performance in TS 03 of 2016 before the trial court and the
said suit has been decreed in favour of the plaintiff. Aggrieved thereby
by the judgment and decree dated 16.02.2017 defendant-appellant has
filed for an appeal for the lower appellate court and the same has been
allowed by the order dated 17.07.2018 quashing the judgment and
decree of the trial court. Aggrieved by the order of the lower appellate
court, the present appeal has been filed by the appellant herein.
[14]
During the course of the argument the counsel for the
appellant has placed reliance on the agreement (reproduced above) and
held in between both the parties which is exhibited as Exbt-5(1) to 5(V)
and also the legal notice (Exbt-2) by the advocate on behalf of the
plaintiff to the defendant requesting to come forward for getting the
document for the property registered. Further having received a sum of
Rs.5000/- toward the bina (advance money) of the sale consideration,
the remaining Rs.1,85,000/- which is the balance in the consideration
the plaintiff was about to pay and the defendant has refused and further
demanded Rs.25,000/- extra for concluding the contract. In view of the
said unreasonable demand, the plaintiff approached the court.
[15]
The counsel for the defendant submits that appeal needs to
be dismissed as the lower appellate court’s order is correct and needs
no interference as the order in appeal deals with the time of one month
which is the essence of contract and further relied on a judgment in I.S.
Sikandar versus K. Subramani and Others reported in (2013) 15 SCC
27, wherein the apex court has observed with regard to the concluding
the contract in stipulated period and prayed to dismiss the said appeal.
40. This position of law is well settled by this Court in the
Constitution Bench judgment in Chand Rani : (1993) 1 SCC
519 Vs. Kamal Rani wherein this Court has held that it is
well settled principle of law, that in a case of sale of
immovable property, time is not the essence of the
contract. However, if the parties agreed to a specified
time in the agreement to perform their part of the
contract, then time is the essence of the contract and
parties shall adhere to the same.
The counsel has also disputed with regard to entering into
the agreement with the plaintiff. This court is not inclined to appreciate
the argument of the defendant that the defendant has not entered into
any agreement with the plaintiff in view of the findings of the trial court.
[16]
Heard both sides.
[17]
It
becomes
pertinent
to
draw
the
attention
to
the
agreement of sale the exhibit 5 (I) to 5 (V) wherein it is not denied by
both the parties with regard to the execution of the agreement of sale
and receipt of the part of the sale consideration. Since it is an
undisputed fact now the other issues which for consideration before this
court are that the time of one month which the counsel for the
defendant relied that the plaintiff has no right to seek for specific
performance in view of not fulfilling the obligated duty as contemplated
under the agreement of sale. Further the defendant denied with regard
to the demanding reasonable amount of Rs.25,000/- and has thrown
the responsibility by coming forward to pay the balance amount of sale
consideration as agreed upon and expressing his readiness and
willingness to proceed with the registration in this regard. This court
finds that the agreement of sale with regard to registration does not
indicate
one
month.
It
also
provides
certain
other
bounded
responsibilities on both the parties for making measurement of the land
and then handing over the property and further proceed with the
registration. Though the agreement ends with the registration, it is
silent with regard to at what point the sale consideration needs to be
paid. Further the measurement of land is also indicated. So unless and
until the said defendant (vendor) indicates a convenient day and time
and it may not be possible for the plaintiff (the vendee) to enter into
the property to make measurements. In other words, it would amount
to say that trespassing someone’s property. It is also noticed that to the
said advocates notice which is marked as Exbt- 2, there is no defence
and no denial by way of a reply notice. Nothing prevented the
defendant in issuing a notice calling for the plaintiff to come and the get
the document registered by paying the balance in sale consideration. In
alternative, the defendant has also not issued any notice of cancellation
of the agreement of sale for not paying the balance is sale consideration
and comply with the terms of the agreement of sale.
[18]
Viewed from many angles, this court is not inclined to
appreciate the argument of defendants.
[19]
Accordingly the order dated 17.07.2018 of the lower
appellate court is set aside.
[20]
The appeal stands allowed and the suit is decreed. Costs to
be borne by respective parties.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review