The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
31. 03.2023 has passed a detailed order and for the purpose of reference, the same may be extracted hereunder: “The case record is put up today on a put up petition filed on behalf of plaintiff respondent Bashana Khatun and by a separate petition makes a prayer for correction of the decree before passing the judgment so fixed on 12.04.2023 as otherwise the purpose of this suit will be frustrated. Perused the same. Heard and considered. At the time of hearing Ld. Counsel Mr. Chakraborty appearing for respondent no. 1 Bashana Khatun has submitted that in the original suit i.e. TS(P) 83 of 2009, one of the co-sharer Smt. Shyamala Khatun was made a party as defendant no. 6 but subsequently during the pendency of the suit she died leaving behind defendant no. 3 and 4 as her legal heirs who are entitled to get the shares of defendant no. 6. Accordingly, they made a petition before the trial court for striking out the name of defendant no. 6 Shyamala Khatun from the plaint as well as preliminary decree and her share be distributed/ allotted equally to the plaintiff and defendant no. 3 and 4 in addition to their respective share and accordingly, the Ld. Trial Court by an order dated 26.08.2016 allowed such petition and also directed to struck off the name of the defendant no. 6 from the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree and also directed to distribute the one each share of defendant …
4. in addition to their one-ninth share. But it appears from the case record that, after passing of that order dated 26.08.2016, the office of the Ld. Trial Court did not correct the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree accordingly and as such the name of defendant no. 6 has also reflected in the final decree which are required to be corrected immediately. Hence, office is directed to send back the case record to the Ld. Trial Court through messenger for the purpose of making correction of the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree as well as final decree as per order of the Ld. Trial Court dated 26.08.2016 passed in TS(P) 83 of 2009 and also to send back the case record to this court after such correction on or before the next so fixed. Inform accordingly. Send a copy of the as well as parties to the suit. order to the Ld. Court below To date fixed 12.04.2023 for judgement.” [11] The above quoted order has been passed allowing the correction of the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree and accordingly communicated to the Appellate Court’s order to the original Court. Aggrieved by the same, the present petition has been filed. [12] That without giving any opportunity to the petitioner herein, who was the appellant in the lower Appellate Court and defendant in the suit, the present order is said to be passed without giving any opportunity of personal notice and hearing and th…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
CRP. No.15 of 2023
Sri Raviul Hossain
.....Petitioner
VERSUS
Smt. Basana Khatoon @ Basana Begam and Ors.
.....Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
None.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE [ACTING]
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
12/04/2023
Heard.
[2]
This petition has been filed under Article-227 of the Constitution
of India read with Section-115 & 151 of the code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for
exercising the power of superintendence against TA. No.05 of 2019 by the
learned District Judge, Sepahijala, Sonamura.
[3]
The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:
“In the premises as aforesaid it is prayed that this Hon’ble High Court will
be pleased to admit this petition stay further proceedings of the Title
Appeal No.05 of 2019 pending for passing judgment on 12.04.2023 before
the Ld. District Judge, Sepahijala, Sonamura, call for records, issue notice
as to why the impugned order dated 31.03.2023 in case No. T.A.05 of
2019 passed by the Ld. Court of the District Judge, Sepahijala, Sonamura,
shall not be quashed and after hearing the petition allow the prayer of the
appellant-petitioner and direct the Ld. District Judge, Sepahijala to remand
the matter before the Ld. Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Sepahijala, Sonamura
for fresh trial.”
[4]
The facts in brief are that the plaintiff-respondent No.1 Smt.
Basana Khatoon filed a partition suit on 11.09.2009 before the learned Civil
Judge, Sr. Division Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala, seeking partition of the
property measuring 3.63 acres allegedly left behind her father Abdul Gofur,
which was registered as T.S.(P) 83 of 2009. In the said suit nothing was stated
about the share of Sufia Khatun another wife of Abdul Gafur who died on
12.09.1990 whereas Abdul Gafur died on 01.07.1984.
[5]
However, this fact escaped notice of the appellant-petitioner who
is almost illiterate and can put his signature in Bengali only. After prolonged
contest, the suit was decreed in preliminary form on 19.09.2015 for 3.11 acres
only, wherein, the entire one eight share of the suit land of both wives of Abdul
Gofur vis Sufia Khatoon and Shymala Khatoon, was given to one wife i.e.
defendant No.6 Shymala Khatoon only and this fact escaped notice of the
appellant petitioner and his learned counsel. So, no appeal was preferred
against the preliminary decree.
[6]
Accordingly, a petition was filed for passing final decree by way
of appointing survey commissioner. During pendency of the said petition,
defendant No.6 Shymala Khatoon died on 08.07.2016 and on 26.07.2016 Court
directed to strike-off her name from the preliminary decree and also to give her
alleged one eight share to her legal heirs only. But no correction was made in
the preliminary decree. Accordingly, survey commissioner was appointed, who
submitted his report after about six months of his visiting the suit land in
collusion with the plaintiff respondent No.1 Smt. Basana Khatun, whimsically
dividing the property in such a manner so that the residential house of the
appellant petitioner could be demolished. Though a date was fixed for
submitting objection, if any, against the survey commissioner report, no
objection could be filed by the engaged counsel of the appellant petitioner, as
he was seriously ill and lost his mental balance for a long time.
[7]
The appellant had no knowledge about passing of the final decree
accepting the said report of survey commissioner. Accordingly final decree was
passed making the said report as part of the final decree, keeping the name of
deceased Shyamala Khatun as defendant No.6. All those facts came to the
notice of the learned counsel of the appellant and he argued the appeal on
29.03.2012 with a prayer to remand the matter for correction of the decrees and
thereafter to appoint fresh survey commissioner for partition of the decreed
property fixing three months for the said corrections and holding fresh survey
etc. next date was fixed on 12.04.2023 for passing the judgment.
[8]
But, unfortunately, on 31.03.2023 behind the back of the
appellant-petitioner one put-up petition was submitted before the learned
District Judge by the respondent No.1 Basana Khatun and the leanred Disrict
Judge without supplying copy of the said petition to the appellant or his counsel
or hearing the counsel of the appellant, passed the impugned order on
31.03.2023 directing the trial Court to correct the errors made in the
preliminary decree and final decree as well as in the plaint and accordingly,
directed the office to sent the lower court record before the learned Civil Judge,
Sr. Division West Tripura, Agartala for making the above correction.
[9]
Hence, the present petition has been filed before this Court for
proper adjudication.
[10]
Having heard the argument of the learned counsel appearing for
the petitioner as well as after gone through the material evidence on record, it is
seen that an appeal has been preferred and during the pendency of the said
appeal when the matter was due for judgment, a request has been made in
writing by the plaintiff-respondent in the appeal seeking correction of the
decree. Considering the same, the learned Appellate Court below on
31.03.2023 has passed a detailed order and for the purpose of reference, the
same may be extracted hereunder:
“The case record is put up today on a put up
petition filed on behalf of plaintiff respondent Bashana Khatun
and by a separate petition makes a prayer for correction of the
decree before passing the judgment so fixed on 12.04.2023 as
otherwise the purpose of this suit will be frustrated.
Perused the same.
Heard and considered.
At
the
time
of
hearing
Ld.
Counsel
Mr.
S.
Chakraborty appearing for respondent no. 1 Bashana Khatun has
submitted that in the original suit i.e. TS(P) 83 of 2009, one of
the co-sharer Smt. Shyamala Khatun was made a party as
defendant no. 6 but subsequently during the pendency of the suit
she died leaving behind defendant no. 3 and 4 as her legal heirs
who are entitled to get the shares of defendant no. 6.
Accordingly,
they
made
a
petition
before
the
trial
court for striking out the name of defendant no. 6 Shyamala
Khatun from the plaint as well as preliminary decree and her
share be distributed/ allotted equally to the plaintiff and
defendant no. 3 and 4 in addition to their respective share and
accordingly, the Ld. Trial Court by an order dated 26.08.2016
allowed such petition and also directed to struck off the name of
the defendant no. 6 from the plaint, judgment and preliminary
decree and also directed to distribute the one each share of
defendant no. 6 equally to the plaintiff and defendant no. 3 and
4. in addition to their one-ninth share.
But
it
appears
from
the
case
record
that,
after
passing of that order dated 26.08.2016, the office of the Ld. Trial
Court did not correct the plaint, judgment and preliminary
decree accordingly and as such the name of defendant no. 6 has also
reflected in the final decree which are required to be
corrected immediately.
Hence,
office
is
directed
to
send
back
the
case
record to the Ld. Trial Court through messenger for the purpose
of making correction of the plaint, judgment and preliminary
decree as well as final decree as per order of the Ld. Trial Court
dated 26.08.2016 passed in TS(P) 83 of 2009 and also to send
back the case record to this court after such correction on or
before the next so fixed.
Inform accordingly.
Send a copy of the
as well as parties to the suit.
order
to
the
Ld.
Court
below
To date fixed 12.04.2023 for judgement.”
[11]
The above quoted order has been passed allowing the correction
of the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree and accordingly communicated
to the Appellate Court’s order to the original Court. Aggrieved by the same, the
present petition has been filed.
[12]
That without giving any opportunity to the petitioner herein, who
was the appellant in the lower Appellate Court and defendant in the suit, the
present order is said to be passed without giving any opportunity of personal
notice and hearing and thus, it is purely violative of principle of natural justice.
[13]
It is seen from the order dated 31.03.2023 (supra) that a request
has been made for correction of the errors and subsequently, the order has been
passed by the Court below. A fair reading of the request made by the plaintiffrespondent’s counsel in the appeal, it is seen that such request is neither
supported by any evidence or the petition is recognized under any Civil
Procedure Code. It is not understood to this Court as to under what provision
such request is made and without serving any notice on the appellant, the
learned Court below on the same day has passed the order for making
necessary corrections in the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree.
[14]
This kind of action of the lower Appellate Court draws attention
of this Court and this Court is not in a position to accept the same. Hence, this
Court finds that the orders passed by the Court below i.e. on 31.03.2023 cannot
be allowed and also sustained in the eye of law and accordingly, the same
stands set aside.
[15]
It is further clarified that in pursuance of the orders passed on
31.03.2023 by the learned lower Appellate Court, any corrections made by the
learned trial Court to the plaint, judgment and preliminary decree becomes
redundant. In the light of the above, the present petition stands disposed of. As
a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE [ACTING]
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review