The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
03. 05.2024 before consulting his counsel, is also not explained. While it was open to the applicant to consult lawyers for deciding on the future course of action, he ought not to have wasted almost four months’ time and filed the application for review with a delay of 87 days. 28) It appears that though the applicant was fully aware that the matter has commercial implications, he adopted a casual and negligent attitude. Therefore, he is not entitled for condonation of delay in filing the Review Petition. 29) Also, no serious prejudice is caused to the applicant, since the matter is remitted back to the Arbitrator for fresh consideration to decide after giving reasons. 30) Therefore, I.A. 01/2024 in Review Pet. No.18 of 2024 is dismissed. Consequently, Review Pet. No.18 of 2024 is also dismissed. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. (S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J) Munna (M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
IA No.01 of 2024 in/and Review Pet. No.18 of 2024
Sri Ratan Datta, S/o Sri Maran Chandra Datta, resident of Road No.8,
Ramnagar, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, District – Tripura, Pin-799002.
......... Applicant/Petitioner (s);
Versus
1.
State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner,
Public Works Department (Rig Division), PN Complex, Gurkhabasti,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2.
The Executive Engineer, PWD (Rig Division), PN Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, West Tripura.
.........Respondent (s);
For Applicant/Petitioner (s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Ms. Simpee Saha, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Karnajeet De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
Date of hearing
: 10.09.2025
Date of Judgment & Order
: 26.09.2025
Whether Fit for Reporting
: YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao, C.J.)
1)
Heard counsel for the applicant as well as counsel for the
respondents.
2)
The applicant is a contractor who had entered into an agreement
on 30.07.2012 with the Executive Engineer, PWD (RIG Division), Agartala,
for Drilling & Development of 25 nos. of Small Bore Deep Tube-Wells
(SBDTW) with Departmental Direct Rotary (hydraulically operated) MINI
Rig and other machineries & equipments in different locations of West
Tripura District during the year 2011-2012 under NRDWP Schemes in
Tripura. The value of the work was Rs.80,82,294/-.
3)
Disputes arose between the parties and ultimately the contract
was rescinded. The respondents also imposed levy of compensation under
Clause-2 of the agreement for an amount of Rs.3,74,180/- stating that
extension of time for the completion of the work was granted by the Engineerin-Charge up to 31.05.2014 without prejudice to the right of the Government
to recover liquidated damages in accordance with the provision of Clause-2 of
the agreement.
4)
The matter was referred to arbitration and the Arbitral Tribunal
rendered an award on 20.04.2018 as under:
"In view of the findings and decisions arrived at Issue-wise
in the preceding paragraphs of the Award it is hereby declare that the
Petitioner is entitled to get in total Rs. 8,98,226/-(Rupees eight lakhs
ninety eight thousand two hundred and twenty six) only from the
Respondent. In addition to the aforesaid amount he is also entitled to
get interest at the rate of 9% per annum over the awarded amount
with effect from the date of Prayer before the Respondent for settling
the dispute, i.e.10-09-2015 within three months from today failing
which the Respondent shall have to pay at the rate of 12% per annum
with effect from 10-09-2015 till the date of payment. Interest over the
awarded amount under Issue No 'F' will not carry interest.
The Stamp duty is charged Rs.75/- only in respect of this
award have been borne by the Petitioner. As the Stamp paper of
Rs.75/- is not available the Petitioner filed Stamp Paper of Rs. 100/only."
5)
Challenging the said award of the Arbitrator, the respondents
filed an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996 before the District Commercial Court, West Tripura, Agartala.
6)
By order dt. 05.04.2022, in Civil Misc. (Arbitration) No.16 of
2018, the Commercial Court upheld the arbitral award passed by the
Arbitrator and dismissed the application filed under Section 34 of the
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
7)
Challenging the same, the respondents filed an appeal under
Section 37(1)(c) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 read with
Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015.
8)
When the respondents had filed said appeal, there was a delay of
134 days in filing the appeal, and the respondents had filed an I.A.
No.01/2022 to condone the said period of delay in filing the appeal under
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
9)
On 11.01.2023, the said delay has been condoned subject to
payment of costs of Rs.1,000/- by the respondents to the High Court
Employees’ Association.
10)
The said appeal was numbered as Arb. A. No.14 of 2022 by this
Court.
11)
After hearing both the parties, this Court opined that reasons had
not been assigned by the Arbitrator before arriving at a finding that the
Superintending Engineer had no power to interfere into the affairs of the
performance of the contractor. It held that the finding of the Arbitrator that the
notice issued by the Engineer-in-Charge was illegal and arbitrary because it
was not issued for and on behalf of the Governor of Tripura, and his finding
that while implementing any provision of the agreement the same must be for
and on behalf of the Governor of Tripura, is perverse and patently illegal. It
held that the view of the Arbitrator that the Engineer-in-Charge is not
empowered to rescind the contract is a patent error of law. Certain other
findings are also recorded in the order, and it was concluded that the award of
the Arbitrator was not sustainable in law as it was against the public policy
doctrine and suffered from patent illegality.
12)
This Court also held that the Commercial Court, in exercise of its
power under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, has not
properly dealt with the finding and views expressed by the Arbitrator in his
award.
13)
It declared that the Arbitrator had decided the disputes/claims
raised by the parties most mechanically without assigning any reasons; that
non-assigning of reasons amounts to fundamental breach of natural justice
under Section 34 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and is contrary to
basic notion of morality and justice which renders the award perverse, and
liable to be set aside on the ground of patent illegality.
14)
The Division Bench of the High Court therefore allowed the
appeal on 03.04.2024, and remitted the matter back to the Arbitrator for fresh
decision by assigning reasons and fixed a time limit of six months.
15)
On 29.07.2024, Review Pet. No.18 of 2024 has been filed by the
applicant seeking review of not only judgment & order dt. 03.04.2024 in Arb.
A. No.14 of 2022 but also the prior order dt. 11.01.2023 in I.A. No.01 of 2022
arising out of Arb. A. No.14 of 2022, condoning the delay of 134 days in
filing the appeal.
16)
Since the Review Petition was not filed within time, he filed IA
No.01/2024, under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, to condone the delay
of 87 days in presenting the Review Petition.
17)
No explanation is offered as to why the applicant did not seek
review of the order dt. 11.01.2023 in I.A. No.01 of 2022 arising out of Arb. A.
No.14 of 2022 within 30 days from the said date.
18)
There cannot be a single review petition to review (a) the order
passed on 11.01.2023 in I.A. No.01 of 2022 and (b) the judgment & order dt.
03.04.2024 in Arb. A. No.14 of 2022. Both being distinct and separate orders,
separate review petitions ought to have been filed by the applicant to review
them.
19)
Moreover, there is inordinate delay in filing the Review petition
challenging the order dt. 11.01.2023 in I.A. No.01 of 2022 till 29.07.2024.
Since the litigation is commercial litigation, the filing of the Review Petition
for review of the said order with a long period of delay of almost 18 months,
cannot be countenanced and the said period of delay is not liable to be
condoned.
20)
As regards the delay of 87 days in filing the Review Petition
seeking review of the judgment & order dt. 03.04.2024 in Arb. A. No.14 of
2022 is concerned, it is stated by the applicant that on 04.05.2024 i.e., one
month after the judgment was delivered in Arb.App.14 of 2022 on 03.04.2024,
the applicant had consulted his lawyer for enquiring the steps to be taken and
he was informed that he has to appear before the Arbitrator for fresh/further
hearing; and the applicant decided to seek opinion from other counsel for the
steps to be taken in furtherance of judgment & order dt.03.04.2024 in Arb. A.
No.14 of 2022. He stated that the other counsel asked him to give the entire
case record for determining the next course of action; thereafter, after securing
the file from the previous counsel on 19.05.2024, it was handed over to the
other counsel being consulted by the applicant.
21)
The applicant states that on 24.05.2024, he met the newly
engaged counsel for exploring the next course of action, that they sought
further ten days’ time and the matter was again fixed on 04.06.2024 for a fresh
discussion.
22)
The applicant claims that on account of having a high fever, he
did not meet the said advocates on 04.06.2024 and met them on 12.06.2024,
and on that day it was suggested to him that he should take the opinion of
another Senior advocate.
23)
The applicant claims to have then met the Senior advocate on
19.06.2024, and it was initially decided to file a Special Leave Petition in the
Supreme Court challenging the judgment dt. 03.04.2024; but the Senior
advocate said it was only a tentative opinion and that final opinion would be
given only after a meticulous study of the case records and fixed a conference
on 30.06.2024.
24)
It is stated that on that day the Senior Advocate was preoccupied
with other cases and the conference was postponed to 09.06.2024, and it was
decided to file a Review Petition and thereafter, the Review Petition was filed
on 29.07.2024.
25)
In Government of Maharashtra (Water Resources Department)
represented by Executive Engineer Versus Borse Brothers Engineers and
Contractors Private Limited1 the Supreme Court emphasised that both under
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, and the Commercial Courts Act,
(2021) 6 SCC 460
2015, the object is speedy resolution of disputes. The Supreme Court
considered the scope of the expression ‘sufficient cause’ in the context of
condoning delay in filing appeals under Section 37 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996. It held that the expression ‘sufficient cause’ was not
itself a loose panacea for the ills of pressing negligent and stale claims. It
reiterated that the statute no doubt grants the Courts with discretionary powers
to condone the delay, but at the same time, it also places an obligation upon
the party to justify that he was prevented from abiding by the same due to the
existence of ‘sufficient cause’. The Courts must not only take into
consideration the entire facts and circumstances of the case but also the
conduct of the parties and they must weigh in the rights and obligations of
both the parties. When a right has accrued in favour of one party due to gross
negligence and lackadaisical attitude of the other, discretionary power to
condone the delay ought not to be exercised as this would defeat the object of
speedy resolution of disputes.
26)
Applying this test to the instant I.A. No.01 of 2024, and the
pleadings therein we may point out that, even application for issuance of
certified copy of the judgment in Arb. A. No.14 of 2022, was made on
12.07.2024, three months after the judgment was pronounced in the
Arbitration Appeal. Whether the applicant was intending to file an SLP or a
Review Petition, the applicant has to obtain the certified copy of the judgment
in Arb. A. No.14 of 2022. Therefore, the applicant ought to have immediately
applied for the issuance of certified copy of the judgment of the Division
Bench dt. 03.04.2024 in Arb. A. No.14 of 2022. No explanation is offered for
the delay in applying even for the certified copy of the judgment by the
applicant in the application for condonation of delay.
27)
Moreover, why the applicant kept quiet from 03.04.2024 to
03.05.2024 before consulting his counsel, is also not explained. While it was
open to the applicant to consult lawyers for deciding on the future course of
action, he ought not to have wasted almost four months’ time and filed the
application for review with a delay of 87 days.
28)
It appears that though the applicant was fully aware that the
matter has commercial implications, he adopted a casual and negligent
attitude. Therefore, he is not entitled for condonation of delay in filing the
Review Petition.
29)
Also, no serious prejudice is caused to the applicant, since the
matter is remitted back to the Arbitrator for fresh consideration to decide after
giving reasons.
30)
Therefore, I.A. 01/2024 in Review Pet. No.18 of 2024 is
dismissed. Consequently, Review Pet. No.18 of 2024 is also dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J)
Munna
MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2025.09.26 13:31:53 +05'30'
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review