The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
03. 04.2024. Whether fit for reporting : Yes HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL) [T. Amarnath Goud, J] Heard Ms. R. Guha, learned counsel appearing for the appellant. Also heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel appearing for the unofficial respondent No.9. Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy.SGI is present on behalf of the respondent Union of India and Mr. D. Sarma, learned Addl. GA is present for the State respondents. [2] This present writ appeal is preferred against the impugned Order dated 30.03.2023 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) 910 of 2021 seeking the following reliefs: “(i) Issue Notice to Opposite Parties; (ii) Admit the instant Writ Appeal; (iii) Set aside the impugned Order, dated 30.03.2023, passed by the Hon‟ble Single Judge, High Court of Tripura, in W.P.(C) 910 of 2021. (iv) Accept the prayers of the W.P.(C) 910 of 2021, made by the Appellant herein, i.e., to set aside the name of the Opposite Party No.9 listed in Serial No.11 in the impugned Notification No.F.11(36-46)/RECTT./ TPSC/2020 (VOL-1), dated 01.12.2021 and to appoint the Appellant herein in the post of Assistant Professor, Government (General) Degree Colleges in Tripura, Group-A Gazetted and/or to formulate a medical Board and evaluate the Disability of Opposite Party No.9 and/…
14. In the light of the above discussions, I do not find any merit in the present writ petition and, accordingly, the same stands dismissed………………………..” [6] Ms. R. Guha, learned counsel for the appellant submits that learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate the fact that the respondent No.9 is not qualified with benchmark disability under the guidelines published by the Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Acts and Rules of Central Government as well as State Government. She further contends that the appellant is suffering from about 60% disability which is much higher than the unofficial respondent No.9. According to her, the doctors committed an error in issuing certificate reflecting 50% disability towards the respondent No.9. Learned counsel, therefore, urges this Court to declare the respondent No.9 as unqualified for the post of Assistant Professor (Bengali) and also to declare the appointment of the said respondent as null and void. She further prays to appoint the appellant in the said position. [7] On the other hand, Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. D. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the unofficial respondent No.9 opposes the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant. He submits that learned Single Judge observing all the relevant facts by order dated 30.03.2023, rejected the reliefs as sought for by the petitioner and the …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.57 of 2023
Sri Ranjib Nath (35),
Son of Sri Raicharan Nath, resident of South Nayapara, near
Indian Oil Quarter, College Link Road, Ward No.-12, P.O.
Dharmanagar, P.S. Dharmanagar, District-North Tripura, PIN799250
---Appellant.
Versus
1. Union of India
Represented by Secretary of Department of Empowerment of
Persons with Disabilities, Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Government of India, having its main office at
Room No.524 (B-III), Antyodaya Bhawan, New Delhi-110003.
2. The Secretary
Department of Empowerment of Persons with Disabilities,
Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of
India, having its main office at, Room No.524 (B-III),
Antyodaya Bhawan, New Delhi- 110003.
3. The State of Tripura
Represented by Directorate of Education (Higher), having its
office at Directorate of Secondary Education, 1st Floor,
Shiksha Bhavan, Agartala, Tripura, PIN:799001.
4. The Director,
Directorate of Education (Higher), having his office at
Directorate of Secondary Education, 1st Floor, Shiksha
Bhavan, Agartala, Tripura, PIN: 799001.
5. Tripura Public Service Commission,
Represented by the Chairman, Tripura Public Service
Commission, having his office at Akhaura Road, Agartala,
Tripura, PIN-799001.
6. The Chairman,
Tripura Public Service Commission, having his office at
Akhaura Road, Agartala, Tripura, PIN-799001.
7. The Member(s),
Tripura Public Service Commission, having his office at
Akhaura Road, Agartala, Tripura, PIN-799001.
8. The Secretary
Tripura Public Service Commission, having his office at
Akhaura Road, Agartala, Tripura, PIN-799001.
9. Sri Liton Mia,
Son of late Rafik Mia, Resident of Khilpara B.O, near Udaipur,
Gomati, Tripura, PIN-799114.
---Opposite parties/Respondents
For the Appellant(s)
:
Ms. R. Guha, Advocate.
Mr. MS Dey, Advocate.
Mr. M. Debnath, Advocate.
Ms. Sudipa Nath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. R. Datta, Advocate.
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
delivery of Judgment
& Order
:
03.04.2024.
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Ms. R. Guha, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant. Also heard Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel appearing for the
unofficial respondent No.9. Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy.SGI is
present on behalf of the respondent Union of India and Mr. D.
Sarma, learned Addl. GA is present for the State respondents.
[2]
This
present
writ
appeal
is
preferred
against
the
impugned Order dated 30.03.2023 passed by the learned Single
Judge in WP(C) 910 of 2021 seeking the following reliefs:
“(i) Issue Notice to Opposite Parties;
(ii) Admit the instant Writ Appeal;
(iii) Set aside the impugned Order, dated 30.03.2023, passed by
the Hon‟ble Single Judge, High Court of Tripura, in W.P.(C) 910 of
2021.
(iv) Accept the prayers of the W.P.(C) 910 of 2021, made by the
Appellant herein, i.e., to set aside the name of the Opposite Party
No.9 listed in Serial No.11 in the impugned Notification
No.F.11(36-46)/RECTT./ TPSC/2020 (VOL-1), dated 01.12.2021
and to appoint the Appellant herein in the post of Assistant
Professor, Government (General) Degree Colleges in Tripura,
Group-A Gazetted and/or to formulate a medical Board and
evaluate the Disability of Opposite Party No.9 and/or to cancel
and/or quash and/or revoke the Disability Certificate of the
Opposite Party No.9.
(v) Cost of and incidental to this proceeding may be directed to be
borne by Opposite Party Nos.1 to 9……..”
[3]
The case of the appellant in brief is that Tripura Public
Service Commission (TPSC for short), respondent No.5 herein
published one advertisement in their website and various other
newspapers inviting online application from citizens of India for
selection of candidates to fill 40 vacancies of Assistant Professor in
various
subjects.
The
appellant
herein
applied
for
the
post
submitting copy of his documents and according to the API score of
the applicants, subject wise name of the candidates was listed. In
the
aforementioned
list
of
candidates,
total
number
of
candidates were selected to appear in the interview in „Bengali‟
subject. It is contended that among those 11 candidates, only 4
candidates were physically handicapped and were competing for
only one post. It is contended that on 26.01.2021, the appellant
along with the unofficial respondent No.9 appeared in the interview
under physically handicapped category in Bengali subject, wherein
respondent No.9 was selected in the UR Physically Handicapped
Category.
[4]
Aggrieved thereby, the appellant preferred a writ petition
being WP(C) 910 of 2021 before the learned Single Judge, seeking
following reliefs:
“(i).
Admit the instant writ petition;
(ii).
Issue Rule NISI
(iii).
A Rule be issued out of and under the seal of this Hon‟ble
Court commanding the Respondents and each one of them
to show cause why a writ of or in the nature of Certiorari,
shall not be issued directing the Respondents and each of
them to strikeout the name of Respondent No.9, listed in
Serial No.11 in the impugned Notification No.F.11(3646/RECTT./TPSC/ 2020 (VOL-1), dated 01.12.2021.
(iv).
A Rule be issued out of and under the seal of this Hon‟ble
Court commanding the Respondents and each one of them
to show cause why a writ of or in the nature of Mandamus
shall not be issued, to include the name of the Petitioner
and recruit him in the post of Assistant Professor,
Government (General) Degree Colleges in Tripura, Group-A
Gazetted.
(v).
A Rule be issued out of and under the seal of this Hon‟ble
Court commanding the Respondents and each one of them
to show cause why a writ of or in the nature of Mandamus
shall not be issued, directing the Respondents and each
one of them for formulate a medical Board and evaluate
the Disability of Respondent No.9.
(vi).
A Rule be issued out of and under the seal of this Hon‟ble
Court commanding the Respondents and each one of them
to show cause why a writ of or in the nature of Certiorari,
shall not be issued directing the respondents and each of
them to cancel and/or quash and/or revoke the Disability
Certificate of the Respondent No.9.
[5]
(vii).
A Rule be issued out of and under the seal of this Hon‟ble
Court commanding the Respondents and each one of them
to show cause why a writ of or in the nature of Mandamus
shall not be issued, directing the Respondents and each
one of them to protect the right of the Petitioner
guaranteed under Article 14, 16, 21 and 309 of the
Constitution of India.
(viii)
A Rule be issued out of and under the seal of this Hon‟ble
Court commanding the Respondents and each one of them
to show cause why a writ of or in the nature of Certiorari,
shall not be issued directing the respondents and each of
them to produce all the records and/or documents in
relation to the instant matter.
(ix).
Be kind enough to pass an Ad-interim order in terms of
Prayer (iii);
(x).
To make the Rule absolute if no cause or sufficient cause
is shown or made in regard to prayer (ix);
(xi).
Cost and incidentals of this application be borne by the
Respondents…….”
Having receipt of the notice in connection with the writ
petition, all the respondents including respondent No.9 appeared
and denied the allegations of committing irregularities as averred in
the writ petition. Learned Single Judge, on perusal of relevant
records and after hearing of the learned counsel for the respective
parties, passed the following order on 30.03.2023 in WP(C) 910 of
2021:
“…………13.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the
submissions advanced by learned counsel appearing for both the
parties.
The conversation between the petitioner and respondent
no.9 is a disputed question of fact which cannot be decided in this
writ petition. Keeping in mind the submission of Mr. Debnath,
learned counsel for the petitioner that the doctors concerned of the
State Disability Board have not assessed the extent of disability of
the person following the guidelines issued by the Government of
India, I am of the opinion that this Court has no expertise to
assess the extent of disability. The State Disability Board is
constituted by the Government to make assessment of the extent
of disability of a person. The doctors are experts on this subject.
They had issued the certificate and assessed the extent of
disability after examining the physical condition of respondent
no.9. This Court cannot take a different view than that of the view
expressed by the Board. Moreso, the guidelines issued by the
Government of Tripura, is not meant for the courts, it is for the
doctors to follow the guidelines. There is no evidence that the
doctors did not follow the referred guidelines.
14.
In the light of the above discussions, I do not find any
merit in the present writ petition and, accordingly, the same
stands dismissed………………………..”
[6]
Ms. R. Guha, learned counsel for the appellant submits
that learned Single Judge has failed to appreciate the fact that the
respondent No.9 is not qualified with benchmark disability under the
guidelines
published
by
the
Ministry
of
Social
Justice
and
Empowerment, Acts and Rules of Central Government as well as
State Government. She further contends that the appellant is
suffering from about 60% disability which is much higher than the
unofficial respondent No.9. According to her, the doctors committed
an error in issuing certificate reflecting 50% disability towards the
respondent No.9. Learned counsel, therefore, urges this Court to
declare the respondent No.9 as unqualified for the post of Assistant
Professor (Bengali) and also to declare the appointment of the said
respondent as null and void. She further prays to appoint the
appellant in the said position.
[7]
On the other hand, Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior
counsel assisted by Mr. D. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the
unofficial respondent No.9 opposes the contention of the learned
counsel for the appellant. He submits that learned Single Judge
observing all the relevant facts by order dated 30.03.2023, rejected
the reliefs as sought for by the petitioner and the same should not
be interfered with. Mr. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
contends that it is clear from the certificate issued by the State
Disability Board that the respondent No.9 has been suffering from
disability to the extent of 50 percent and he has been renewing the
certificate from time to time and his disability is in the nature of
„Non-progressive‟ and „not likely to be improved‟. He, therefore,
prays that the instant writ appeal filed by the appellant be
dismissed as devoid of merit.
[8]
Heard the submissions made by the parties. Perused the
record.
[9]
The main case of the appellant revolves around the fact
that whether the disability certificate of the unofficial respondent
No.9 has been issued following all the norms and also the claim of
the appellant that he is having more disability than the unofficial
respondent No.9. It is seen from the record that except on the said
ground of disability, no further argument has been advanced.
[10]
It is the competent authority concerned who can decide
whether the disability certificate of the respondent No.9 has been
issued following all the norms or not. No material evidence is placed
on record to consider whether the appellant or the unofficial
respondent is having more disability. The appellant has never
approached any authority concerned challenging the disability
certificate of the respondent No.9 for cancellation of the same and
the said certificate is valid as on today.
[11]
Since the disability certificate of the respondent No.9 is
not under challenge, this Court feels that the notification dated 1st
December, 2021 issued by the TPSC is proper. This Court cannot go
into the issue of disputed question of facts with regard to decide the
disability of the appellant and the opposite party/respondent No.9
and the same is not within the arena of this writ appeal under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India. We find no merit in the
appeal filed by the appellant herein.
[12]
With
the
above
observation,
since
the
disability
certificate issued in favour of respondent No.9 holds good as on
today and the same has never been under challenge before any
authority concerned, the impugned notification dated 1st December,
2021 issued by the TPSC placing the name of respondent No.9 at
serial No.11 is confirmed. We find no infirmity in the order
impugned passed by the learned Single on 30.03.2023 in WP(C)
910 of 21 and accordingly, the same is also affirmed.
In view of the above, the present writ appeal filed by the
appellant is dismissed. As a sequel, stay if any, stands vacated.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands closed.
B. PALIT, J
Sabyasachi G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2024.04.10 16:21:38 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review