Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.33 of 2024
1. Sri Ranjan Singha, Age-52 years
S/O Late Shakti Singha,
2. Sri Amiya Singha, Age-59 years
S/O Late Shakti Singha,
Both are resident of Panchasi,
P.S.-Kamalpur, District-Dhalai Tripura
------ Appellants
Versus
1. Sri Amal Singha
S/O Late Surendra Singha
Resident of Panchasi, P.S. Kamalpur,
District-Dhalai, Tripura.
At present residing at village Chandrapur
(Near Manipuri Nat Mandir), P.O. Reshambagan,
P.S.-East Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799008.
------ Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Ashutosh De, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Adv,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
24.07.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
31.07.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 100 of CPC is preferred challenging
the judgment dated 09.08.2024 and consequential decree dated
13.08.2024 delivered by Learned Additional District Judge, Dhalai
Judicial District, Kamalpur in connection with T.A. No.1 of 2019. By
the same judgment and decree, Learned 1st Appellate Court has been
pleased to dispose the appeal by setting aside the judgment dated
04.12.2018 and consequential decree dated 13.12.2018 delivered by
Learned Civil judge (Junior Division) Kamalpur in connection with TS
No.4 of 2014.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. Ashutosh De appearing on behalf
of the appellant-defendants and also heard Learned Senior Counsel
Mr. Purusuttam Roy Barman assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. Samarjit
Bhattacharjee and Learned Counsel Mr. Kawsik Nath appearing on
behalf of the respondent-plaintiffs.
3.
The factual aspect of the case runs as follows:
The suit property as described in the schedule of the
plaint is recorded under khatian No.125 appertaining to C.S. plot
Nos.132, 133, 134(p) corresponding to R.S. plot Nos.198, 199 and
200 measuring 0.72 acres of land which has been purchased by the
respondent-plaintiff
Shri
Amal
Singha.
The
respondent-plaintiff
purchased the said land as mentioned in the schedule of the plaint
from his father-in-law Sri Dhani Singha who executed a Power of
Attorney in favour of Smt. Tarudini Singha, wife of Shri Amal
Singha(respondent-plaintiff) as his lawful attorney for transferring of
the suit land. Accordingly, on the strength of Power of Attorney, the
wife of the respondent-plaintiff transferred the suit land in favour of
the respondent-plaintiff by virtue of a registered deed bearing No.-I264 dated 16.05.2011. After purchase of the suit land, the same was
mutated in the name of the respondent-plaintiff by the revenue
authority and finally published Khatian No.125 was created in his
favour. According to respondent-plaintiff, at the time of purchase of
the suit land he got possession of the same and boundary pillars were
posted therein and in course of possessing the suit land on
25.07.2013 the appellant-defendants forcefully tried to dispossess the
respondent-plaintiff from the suit land but failed. Thereafter, the
respondent-plaintiff lodged a complaint to SDM, Kamalpur and a
proceeding under section 145 of Cr.P.C. was accordingly instituted
vide
case
No.Misc./5/2014
before
the
Court
of
Executive
Magistrate(SDM, Kamalpur) on the basis of said complaint but during
the pendency of the said proceeding, the appellant-defendants
illegally entered into the suit land and dispossessed the respondentplaintiff therefrom on 10.08.2014. It was further submitted by the
respondent-plaintiff that by virtue of sale deed, he acquired right title
interest over the suit land but the appellant-defendants dispossessed
him from the suit land on 10.08.2014. In such a situation, the
respondent-plaintiff filed the suit before the Learned Trial Court with a
prayer to grant a decree declaring his right, title, interest over the suit
land as mentioned in the schedule of the plaint and also to evict the
appellant-defendants from the suit land and to grant permanent
injunction over the suit of the land with cost of the suit.
After registration of the suit, notices were issued upon
the appellant-defendants and accordingly they appeared before the
Court and contested the suit by filing a written statement. In the
written statement, the appellant-defendants categorically denied all
the averments made by the respondent-plaintiff in the plaint rather
they took the plea that the father of respondent-plaintiff, Surendra
Singha(since dead) and the father of appellant-defendants, Shakti
Singha(since dead) were brothers of each other and both of them
were jointly possessing their lands along with the suit land of the
case. To the Western side of the suit land, one pond was excavated
by them for water and it was used by the local people. Later on,
Surendra Singha surrendered his portion of land in favour of Shakti
Singha(since dead) in exchange of some land besides his residence.
After that, Shakti Singha(since dead) started possessing the said
surrendered land and constructed a Shiva temple therein in the
middle portion and adjacent a small portion of the suit land was used
as
courtyard.
On
25.05.1998,
the
appellant-defendants
have
constructed a pucca dwelling hut and cowshed and started living over
the suit land continuously with others without any disturbance or
objection or obstruction from any corner not even from Dhani Sinha
or the respondent-plaintiff. It was submitted by the appellantdefendants in their written statement that Shakti Singha (since dead)
was possessing the land to the southern side of the suit land and to
the northern side of the landed properties of one Dinesh Das recorded
under Khatian Nos.506 and 442 were situated. The appellantdefendants have pointed out in their written statement that the
description of the landed properties in the Power of Attorney executed
by Dhani Singha in favour of Tarudini Singha do not match with the
description of landed properties mentioned in the sale deed No.I-264
dated 16.05.2018 and due to that reason the plaintiff intentionally
suppressed the boundaries of the suit land in the schedule of the
plaint. It was further submitted by the appellant-defendants that the
suit land was never owned and possessed by Dhani Singha and as
such Khatian No.125 has been prepared illegally with the help of
settlement
staff.
The
appellant-defendants
have
specifically
mentioned in the written statement that since 25.12.1998 they are
possessing the suit land adversely denying the right, title, interest and
possession of Dhani Singha and as such there was no merit in the suit
filed by the respondent-plaintiff. Hence, by their written statement the
appellant-defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit.
It is to be noted here that initially the then Learned Civil
Judge(Junior Division), Unakoti District, Kamalpur by the judgment
dated 08.08.2016 and decree dated 11.08.2016 in connection with
T.S. No.4 of 2014 dismissed the suit of the respondent-plaintiff and
challenging that judgment, the present respondent-plaintiff preferred
one first appeal under section 96 of CPC before the Court of Learned
Additional District Judge, Unakoti District, Kamalpur which was
registered as T.A. No.6 of 2016 and the then Learned Additional
District Judge by the judgment dated 23.06.2017 remanded back the
suit to the Learned Trial Court with directions to re-admit the suit in
its original number and to give opportunities to both the parties to
lead evidence afresh on the additional issues framed by the Learned
Trial Court on 08.08.2016 and thereafter to take into account all the
evidences together and to decide the issues afresh. Accordingly, the
matter
was
reheard
and
thereafter
Learned
Civil
Judge(Junior
Division), Dhalai District, Kamalpur further dismissed the suit by
another judgment dated 04.12.2018 and challenging that judgment,
the plaintiff as appellant has further preferred appeal and the Learned
First Appellate Court by subsequent judgment dated 09.08.2024 has
been pleased to allow the appeal and set aside the judgment dated
04.12.2018 and decree dated 13.12.2018 of the Learned Trial Court
and after that the original defendants as appellant have preferred this
second appeal before this Court which is now taken up for
consideration.
4.
However, before the Learned Trial Court below, upon the
pleadings of the parties following issues were framed:
i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form
and nature?
ii) If so whether plaintiff is entitled to for declaration
of the right, title and interest and also for
permanent injunction over the suit land in his
favour being owner of the suit lands?
iii) Whether plaintiff
relief/releives?
is
entitled
to
any
other
In order to prove the issues both the parties have adduced
oral/documentary evidence on record. For the sake of convenience,
let this Court mention herein below the names of the parties and their
exhibited documents which are as follows:
(A) Plaintiffs' Exhibits :i) Ext.1(as a whole):- Registered sale deed
dated 16.05.2011 in five sheets proved by
PW1.
ii) Ext.2:- Certified copy of finally published
khatian No.125 proved by PW1.
(B) Plaintiffs' Witnesses :i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
PW.1- Sri Amal Singha, the plaintiff himself.
PW.2-Sri Gangadhar Debnath.
PW.3-Sri Samar Debnath.
PW.4-Smt. Tarudini Singha.
(C) Defendant's Exhibits :i) Ext.D/1:- Certified copy of the petition filed
in the court of SDM, Kamalpur proved by
DW1.
ii) Ext.D/2:- Certified copy of map of Mouja
Panchasi, Tehsil-Barasurma proved by DW1.
iii) Ext.D/3:- Certified copy of khatian No.125.
iv) Ext.D/4:- Certified copy of inquiry report in
connection of case No.Misc 5 of 2014 under
section 145 of CrPC.
v) Ext.D/5:- Certified copy of order sheet dated
27.09.2014.
vi) Ext.D/6:- Certified copy of notice issued in
connection of case No.Misc 05 of 2014.
vii) Ext.D/7:- Certified copy of khatian in the
name of Dinesh Chandra Das.
viii) Ext.D/8:- Certified copy of another khatian in
the name of Shakti Singha.
ix) Exbt.D/9:- Certified copy of a deed dated
16.05.2011.
x) Ext.D/10:- Certified copy of power of
attorney dated 05.06.2010 in the nam of
Smt. Tarudini Singha.
xi) Ext.A:- Certified copy of the field inquiry
report dated 22.10.2017 prepared and
proved by DW-6.
xii) Ext.A(a) & Ext.A(b):- Signature of DW-6 on
the field inquiry report dated 22.10.2017.
xiii) Ext.B & Ext.B(a):-Certified copy of the
certificate issued by DW-7 and his signature
on it.
(D) Defendant's Witnesses :i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
vi)
vii)
DW.1 Sri Amiya Singha.
DW.2 Sri Madhumangal Singha.
DW.3 Sri Bimal Chandra Das.
DW.4-Sri Ranjan Singha.
DW.5-Sri Nirmal Singha.
DW.6-Sri Shyamal Debbarma.
DW.7-Sri Anil Das.
Finally, on conclusion of trial Learned Trial Court by judgment
dated 04.12.2018 dismissed the suit with the following observation:
ORDER
33. In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is dismissed
on contest with cost being devoid of merits.
34. Draw up the decree accordingly and place before
me for signing within 15 days from today.
Challenging that judgment, the present respondent-plaintiff
again preferred first appeal before the Learned First Appellate Court
under section 96 of CPC and the Learned 1st Appellate Court by
subsequent judgment dated 09.08.2024, as stated above, reversed
the findings of the Learned Trial Court. The operative portion of the
judgment runs as follows:
ORDER
13. a) In view of the above findings, the T.A. 01 of
2019 is decreed on contest and the judgment dated
04.12.2018 and decree dated 13.12.2018 passed by
Ld. Civil Judge, (Junior Division), Kamalpur, Dhalai
Judicial District arising out of case No.T.S. 04 of 2014
is not sustainable in law and liable to be interfered
with and set aside.
b) The Appellant/Plaintiff has right, title and
interest as described in the scheduled of the suit
land. It is also directed the Defendant/Respondent
and his men or agents are permanently injuncted
and restrained to disturb the peaceful possession of
the Appellant/Plaintiff over the suit land. It is also
directed that the Defendants/Respondents shall
vacate the suit land within 30(thirty) days failing the
Appellant/Plaintiff is given liberty to take steps for
recovery of the possession of the suit land in
accordance with law.
(c)No order as to costs.
(d) Prepare decree.
(e) Send the L.C. Record along with a copy of
this judgment.
(f) This appeal stands disposed on contest.
Challenging that judgment, the defendants as appellants have
preferred this appeal. At the time of admission of appeal, following
substantial questions of law was formulated by this Court vide order
dated 07.02.2025:
“Whether the judgment of Learned First Appellate Court is
perverse for not taking into consideration the provision of
Order VII Rule 3 of CPC.”
5.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the appellant-
defendants first of all has drawn the attention of the Court that
although according to respondent-plaintiff, his father-in-law, Dhani
Singha was the owners-in-possession of the suit land but in support of
title of said Dhani Singha, the respondent-plaintiff could not adduce
any documentary evidence on record before the Learned Trial Court.
Furthermore, the wife of the plaintiff being the constituted attorney of
Dhani Singha transferred the suit land to the respondent-plaintiff but
if the schedule of land as mentioned in the Power of Attorney is tallied
with the schedule of land as mentioned in the deed of the respondentplaintiff dated 16.05.2011(Exhibit-1), it will transpire that both the
schedules are different in respect of northern and southern side. It
was further submitted that according to respondent-plaintiff, this suit
land was vacant but from the evidence on record, it will transpire that
there is one Shiv temple, homestead, cowshed, etc over the said land
and furthermore, the responding-plaintiff did never possess the suit
land as alleged. Even said Dhani Singha being the father-in-law of the
respondent-plaintiff also had no title over the suit land and even he
also did never possess the suit land at any point of time. More so, the
report of SDM will clearly transpire the possession of the appellantdefendants over the suit land since long back. It was further
submitted by Learned Counsel for the appellant-defendants that
intentionally the respondent-plaintiff did not mention the boundary of
the suit land in the plaint. So, in summing up, Learned Counsel for the
appellant-defendants
submitted
that
considering
the
oral/documentary evidence on record, the Learned Trial Court below
rightly dismissed the suit of the respondent-plaintiff but the Learned
First Appellate Court without appreciating the evidence on record
reversed the judgment of Learned Trial Court which is required to be
interfered with.
Learned Counsel further referred the provision of Order VII
Rule 3 of CPC and submitted that in absence of specific boundary of
suit land, the suit was not maintainable which the Learned Trial Court
could consider and that is why, the Learned Trial Court below after
elaborate discussions of the evidence on record rightly dismissed the
suit. It was also submitted that by the long standing possession, the
appellant-defendants have acquired right of adverse possession over
the suit land.
6.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Purusuttam
Roy Barman appearing on behalf of the respondent-plaintiff first of all
has drawn the attention of the Court that the appellant-defendants
have taken different stands in the suit. According to Learned Senior
Counsel, firstly the appellant-defendants took the plea that they are
possessing the suit land since long back and again the appellantdefendants took the plea that they have acquired right of adverse
possession over the suit land. It was further submitted that the
appellant-defendants in the written statement did not took the plea of
adverse possession and furthermore, no specific averments were
mentioned by the appellant-defendants in their written statement
regarding application of Order VII Rule 3 of CPC. Learned Senior
Counsel again submitted that Learned Trial Court below failed to
appreciate the evidence on record and the legal position thus
dismissed suit of the respondent-plaintiff but the Learned First
Appellate Court after considering the materials on record, reversed
the judgment of the Learned Trial Court.
Further, Learned Senior Counsel in course of hearing has
drawn the attention of the Court regarding the substantial question of
law formulated by this Court on 07.02.2025 and referred the last part
of para No.10 of the judgment dated 09.08.2024 delivered by Learned
First Appellate Court which is reproduced as under:
“10. …... The present suit land Plot Nos. 198, 199
and 200 measuring 72 sataks of land (1 kanni 16
gandas). The Defendant relied on Exbt. D/4 (records
of rights). There are three Plot Nos.202/1452, 203,
204/1454 measuring 25 sataks of land. On the
northern side of the land Exbt.D/4 there are plot
Nos.198 and 199 (which is the plot number of the
Appellant/Plaintiff).
The
description
of
the
boundaries of the suit land in the Sale Deed (Exbt.1)
indicates the northern side for the plot nos.196 and
197 which belongs to Dinesh Das. The Exbt.D/7 is
the Record of Right of one Dinesh Das which further
confirms the fact that the boundaries of the suit land
are not mismatched to the documentary evidence
adduce by the Appellant/Plaintiff. There is no case of
discrepancy between the plot nos and boundaries.
Though the boundaries has not been mentioned in
the schedule of the suit land. However, for
identification of the suit land, under the prior issues
of VII rule 3 of CPC where the subject matter of the
suit is immovable property, the plaint shall contain a
description of the property sufficient to identify, and,
in such case such property can be identified by
boundaries or numbers in a record of settlement or
survey, the plaint shall specify such boundaries or
numbers. The Plots numbers are rightly tallied with
the documentary evidence and there no inherent
defects.
Based on the above principles of law the
Defendant/Despondent even if in the possession of
the suit land the Appellant/ Plaintiff has a better
title.
Ld. Advocate for the Defendant/Respondent has
challenged the Sale Deed as it has not been proved
in accordance with the Indian Evidence Act. I concur
with the submission of the Ld. Advocate representing
the Defendant/Respondent but the registration of
the Sale Deed can be considered and admissible in
evidence as held by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a
case of Damodhar Narayan Sawele (D) Through L.Rs
Versus Shri Tejrao Bejirao Mhaske and Ors. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court of Indian observed that
"there could be no doubt will respect to the position
where deed of sale had been duly executed and
registered and its delivery and payment of
consideration was endorsed thereon, it would
amount to a full transfer of ownership so as to
entitle its purchaser to maintain a suit for possession
of the property sold."
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in a case reported in
(2008)15 SCC 673 held in Para 38 "Section 16 of the
Contract Act provides that any transaction which is
an outcome of any undue misrepresentation,
coercion or fraud shall be voidable. If, however, a
document is prima facie valid, a presumption arises
in regard to its genuineness."
Since, it is proved that the Plaintiff was in possession
of the suit land and entitled to get protection of
possession and perpetual injunction can be granted
to him. As the plaintiff could prove his possession
when he filed the present suit, it can be said that the
Defendants/Respondents have dispossessed the
Appellant/ Plaintiff on 10.08.2014. Thus, on the said
facts and evidences as discussed above it is proved
that the Appellant/Plaintiff has right, title and
interest upon the suit land. This Issue is decided in
favour of the Appellant/Plaintiff.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that as
Learned First Appellate Court already addressed the issue regarding
application of Order VII Rule 3 of CPC at the time of delivery of
judgment, so, no further substantial question of law on the same
point is required to be decided in this case and asked for dismissal of
this appeal upholding the judgment of the Learned First Appellate
Court.
7.
Now, for the sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein
below the relevant provision of Order VII Rule 3 of CPC which
provides as under:
“3. Where the subject-matter of the suit is
immovable property.- Where the subject-matter of
the suit is immovable property, the plaint shall
contain a description of the property sufficient to
identify it, and, in case such property can be
identified by boundaries or numbers in a record of
settlement or survey, the plaint shall specify such
boundaries or numbers.”
From the above provision, it appears that where the subject
matter of the suit is immovable property, in that case, the plaint shall
contain a description of the property sufficient to identify and in such
case property can be identified by boundaries or numbers in a record
of settlement or survey, the plaint shall specify such boundaries or
numbers. Meaning thereby, on the basis of boundary or survey plot
numbers, description of property can be given in the plaint.
Here in the case at hand based upon Exbt.-2 i.e. the mutated
Khatian standing in the name of respondent-plaintiff for land
measuring 0.72 acres was reflected in the schedule of the plaint which
comprises of land measuring 0.19 acres against old CS plot No.132
corresponding to RS plot No.198 classified as nal, land measuring
0.22 acres against old CS plot No.133 corresponding to RS plot
No.199 classified as viti(nal), land measuring 0.31 acres against old
CS plot No.134p corresponding to RS plot No.200 classified as
chara(nal), and considering the provision of Order VII Rule 3 of CPC,
Learned First Appellate Court came to the observation that the
respondent-plaintiff has/had a better title then the present appellantdefendants of the instant appeal.
8.
In this regard, Hon'ble Gauhati High Court in Monoranjan
Dutta Vs. Narayan Dhar reported in 2006 SSC OnLine Gau 221
wherein in para No.14 observed as under:
“14. A reading of Order VII, Rule 3 (as amended by
High Court), it is clear that where the subject matter
of the suit is immovable property, although, it is
provided that the plaint shall contain a description of
the, property. The basic requirement of the rule is
that the plaint shall contain the description of the
suit property, which is sufficient to identify it by
giving the description and in that event, it may not
be necessary in all cases for providing a boundary or
numbers in a record of settlement or survey, which is
left to the option of the party. The said amendment
provides that in case any area is mentioned, such
description shall further state the area according to
the notation used in the record of settlement or
survey with or without, at the option of the party.
Thus, Order VII, Rule 3 as amended by the High
Court the option is left with the party whether such
description is to be provided or not. The rule also
does not provide the consequence of such omission
and in terms of the decision in Pratibha Singh
(supra) the decree, even if it lacks description of the
decretal property, the said defect can be cured at the
executing stage by filing necessary application. Thus,
it is abundantly clear that for failure on the part of
omission to give a description of the suit property by
giving boundaries etc. in the plaint is not fatal that
can be cured at a later stage. Thus providing those
descriptions are only optional to the plaintiff and not
obligatory one.”
Similarly, in another case in Pratibha Singh and another
Vs. Shanti Devi Prasad and another reported in (2003) 2 SSC
330 wherein in para No.17, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India
observed as under:
“17. When the suit as to immovable property has
been decreed and the property is not definitely
identified, the defect in the court record caused by
overlooking of provisions contained in Order 7 Rule 3
and Order 20 Rule 3 CPC is capable of being cured.
After all a successful plaintiff should not be deprived
of the fruits of decree. Resort can be had to Section
152 or Section 47 CPC depending on the facts and
circumstances of each case – which of the two
provisions would be more appropriate, just and
convenient to invoke. Being an inadvertent error, not
affecting the merits of the case, it may be corrected
under Section 152 CPC by the court which passed the
decree by supplying the omission. Alternatively, the
exact description of decretal property may be
ascertained by the executing court as a question
relating to execution, discharge or satisfaction of
decree within the meaning of Section 47 CPC. A
decree of a competent court should not, as far as
practicable, be allowed to be defeated on account of
an accidental slip or omission. In the facts and
circumstances of the present case, we think it would
be more appropriate to invoke Section 47 CPC.”
From the aforesaid citations, it appears that even if the
boundary description is not given, still there is scope for correction of
the same and furthermore, it is the choice of the respondent-plaintiff
to give proper description of the suit property by way of description
which is optional and not obligatory.
Here in the case at hand, it appears that the respondentplaintiff after purchase of the suit land by Exbt.-1 applied for mutation
of the same and accordingly, mutation Case vide MR 18/88, MR
No.20110013 was registered and the same was allowed/recorded in
the name of the respondent-plaintiff without any adverse entry in the
column of possession. Meaning thereby, when the land was mutated,
that time, definitely the respondent-plaintiff was in possession of the
suit land otherwise how the revenue authority allowed mutation of the
purchased land in favour of the respondent-plaintiff. Furthermore, the
appellant-defendants challenging that mutation proceeding did not
seek any redress to any forum and there is no evidence in this regard
like that.
9.
More
so,
the
appellant-defendants
in
support
of
their
contention relied upon the enquiry report submitted by one revenue
officer which was marked as Exbt.-D/4 and from the said report, it
appears that the appellant-defendant No.1 was possessing land
measuring 0.09 acres under CS plot No.198/P, and 0.10 acres under
CS plot No.199/P which prima facie does not attract the suit land and
furthermore, in support of their right, title, interest, the appellantdefendants could not produce and prove any documentary evidence
on record in support of their possession over the suit land save and
except the enquiry report.
10.
It was also the case of the appellant-defendants that they
have acquired the right of adverse possession over the suit land. In
this regard, I would like to refer herein below a recent citation of
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2024) 5 SSC 282
[titled as Vasantha(dead) through Legal Representative Vs.
Rajalakshmi
alias
Rajam
(Dead)
through
Legal
Representatives] wherein in para No.40, Hon'ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“40. In Saroop Singh v. Banto:(2005) 8 SCC 330
(two-Judge Bench), this Court observed that Article
65 states that the starting point of limitation does
not commence from the date when the right of
ownership arises to the plaintiff but commences
from the date the defendant's possession becomes
adverse. Further relying on Karnataka Wakf Board v.
Union of India:(2004) 10 SCC 779 (two-Judge
Bench), it observed that the physical fact of
exclusive possession and the animus possidendi to
hold as owner in exclusion to the actual owner are
the most important factors that are to be accounted
in cases related to adverse possession. Plea of
adverse possession is not a pure question of law but
a blend of fact and law. Therefore, a person who
claims adverse possession should show:
(a) on what date he came into possession;
(b)what was the nature of his possession;
(c) whether the factum of possession was
known to the other party;
(d)how long his possession has continued;
and
(e) his possession was open and undisturbed.
A person pleading adverse possession has no
equities in his favour. Since he is trying to defeat the
rights of the true owner, it is for him to clearly plead
and establish all facts necessary to prove his adverse
possession.”
From the aforesaid observation, it appears that to establish
the claim of adverse possession a person is to provea) when he came into the possession?
b) what was the nature of his possession?
c) Whether the factum of possession was known to the
other party?
d) And finally he is to admit the ownership of the true
owner.
Here in the case at hand, it is the admitted position that
Dhani Singha was the original owner of the suit land who through his
constituted attorney transferred the suit land in favour of the
respondent-plaintiff.
But
in
this
case,
the
appellant-defendants
everywhere denied the ownership of the true owner Dhani Singha
over the suit land. Even they also failed to satisfy the Court by
adducing
cogent
evidence
on
record
regarding
the
aforesaid
ingredients in support of their claim of adverse possession.
Thus, it appears that the appellant-defendants have failed to
show any satisfactory grounds before this Court at the time of hearing
to interfere with the judgment delivered by the Learned First
Appellate Court reversing the judgment of the Learned Trial Court.
11.
The substantial question of law is answered accordingly
against the appellant-defendants.
12.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-defendants
fails and accordingly, the same stands dismissed on contest with
costs. The judgment dated 09.08.2024 and decree dated 13.08.2024
delivered by Learned Additional District Judge, Dhalai District,
Kamalpur in connection with T.A. No.1 of 2019 reversing the
judgment
dated
04.12.2018
and
decree
dated
13.12.2018
in
connection with T.S. No.4 of 2014 delivered by Learned Trial Court
below is hereby upheld and the same is accordingly stands affirmed.
With this observation, this present appeal stands disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the records of the Learned Courts below along
with a copy of this judgment and Order.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.08.02
17:39:41 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review