Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA NO.262 OF 2021
Sri Rajdev Singh Yadav,
son of late Kamta Yadav, permanent resident
of village- Keshawpur, Mohammdabad, P.O., P.S. & SubDivision-Mohamadabad, District- Ghazipur, Uttar Pradesh,
presently residing at 21 Assam Rifles, C/O 99 APO, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, 799001.
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. The Union of India,
represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs,
Government of India, having his office at North Block
Secretariat, New Delhi- 110001.
2. The Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, having his office
at North Block Secretariat, New Delhi- 110001.
3. The Director General,
Assam Rifles, having his office at Head Quarter, Director
General Assam Rifles, Shillong (Laitkor), Meghalaya.
4. The Inspector General,
Assam Rifles, having his office at Head Quarter, Inspector
General Assam Rifles (East), Srikona, Silchar, Assam.
......Official Respondent(s)
5. Commandant G.R. Pillai,
having his office at Head Quarter, 10th Sector, Assam Rifles,
Ukhrul, Manipur.
6. Commandant Rampal Singh,
having his office at Head Quarter, 5th Sector Assam Rifles,
Chieswema, Nagaland
For the Petitioner(s)
……..Respondent(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 04.10.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
(Justice T. Amarnath Goud)
The present writ appeal is presented against the
impugned Judgment and Order(Oral) dated 16.09.20212, passed
in WP(C) No.370 of 2021.
2.
The brief fact of this case is that the appellant is
holding the post of Second-in-Command in Assam Rifles. On
31.07.2015 Assam Rifles issued a "tentative charge sheet" in
which, it is alleged that while working in the Directorate General
of Assam Rifles at Shillong between 6th December 2012 to 14th
January 2015 the appellant failed to establish the source of cash
deposits of Rs.17,43,994/- in his bank account which was done
during the period between 10th December 2011 to 3rd March 2014.
It is also alleged that the appellant failed to establish the source
of two fixed deposits of Rs.11,83,861/- and Rs.10,82,233/- in his
bank
accounts
during
the
same
period.
Subsequently,
on
29.07.2019, the first information report was also lodged against
the appellant in Shillong for offence punishable under Section
13(2) read with Section 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption
Act. In this complaint, it was alleged that the appellant was
holding assets to the extent of Rs.1,19,59,865/- disproportionate
to the known source of income. A detailed account of the
appellant’s known sources of income, his reasonable expenditure,
and the assets of the petitioner detected by the department were
also listed. The CBI submitted a charge sheet in connection with
the said criminal case on 30.03.2021. The criminal case is
pending.
3.
According to the appellant, two persons in his cadre
who are junior to him namely, Shri G.R. Pillai and Sri Rampal
Singh i.e., the private respondents in this appeal have been
promoted to the next post of Commandant ignoring the claim of
the appellant. The appellant, therefore, made representations to
the department for grant of promotion. But his requests were
refused. In one communication dated 02.07.2020, it was stated
that the criminal case is still under investigation and, therefore,
the appellant cannot be promoted for want of vigilance clearance.
At that stage, the appellant has filed WP(C) No.370 of 2021
before this Court. In this said writ petition he requested that he
should be promoted to the post of Commandant since when his
turn arrived for consideration for promotion, neither departmental
charge sheet was issued nor charge sheet was filed in the criminal
case. The respondents filed counter affidavit inter alia contending
that the disciplinary proceedings were initiated against the
appellant by the Department. Vide Order dated 16.09.2021, the
said WP(C) No.370 of 2021 was dismissed by the learned Single
Bench of this Court. Hence this appeal has been filed by the
appellant herein seeking to quash/set aside
the impugned
Judgment & Order(Oral) dated 16.09.2021 passed in WP(C)
No.370 of 2021.
4.
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned Sr. counsel assisted
by Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant as well as Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI
appearing for the respondents.
5.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the
petitioner submits that Hon'ble Single Judge failed to appreciate
the chronological facts and circumstances of the case. The
tentative charge sheet was filed against the petitioner on
31.07.2015, the CBI registered a criminal case against the
appellant
on
29.07.2019,
and
on
01.10.2020,
the
private
respondents who were the Juniors to the appellant were promoted
to the post of Commandant in the Assam Rifle, thereby
superseding
the
appellant.
On
28.06.2020,
the
appellant
presented a representation for consideration of his promotion. On
02.07.2020,
the
prayer
of
the
appellant
tendered
to
the
respondents dated 28.06.2020 was repulsed on the ground that
his case is still under investigation and that he cannot be
promoted until Vigilance Clearance is received. On 21.03.2021,
the
appellant
submitted
a
detailed
representation
seeking
promotion. On 30.03.2021, the CBI submitted charge-sheet
against the appellant. So, it is evident that on the relevant date of
consideration i.e., 01.10.2020, when the Juniors of the appellant
were promoted, the appellant was neither under suspension, nor
any charge-sheet was issued against him in the criminal case nor
any charge-sheet in a Departmental proceeding was issued to
him. As such, the learned Single Judge failed to appreciate the
said crucial fact that on the relevant date, none of the conditions
precedent for invocation of sealed cover procedure was available
to the respondents.
To support his contention that seal cover procedure
is not applicable to the appellant herein, the learned Sr. counsel
referred to Paras-7, 13 and 16 of the Hon’ble Apex Court
Judgment reported in (2007) 6 SCC 704 titled as Union of
India
and
ors.
Vs.
Sangram
Keshari
Nayak
which
is
reproduced here-in-under:“7. The Tribunal as also the High Court proceeded to determine the issue on
the basis that the term "Government Servant under cloud" would be the employees
against whom a chargesheet has been issued, relying on or on the basis of
paragraph 2 of the said circular, the relevant portion whereof reads as under:
"2. At the time of consideration of the case of Government Servants for
empanelment, details of Government Servants in the consideration zone for
promotion falling under the following categories should be specifically brought to
the notice of the Departmental Promotion Committee:
(i) Government Servants under suspension;
(ii) Government Servants in respect of whom a charge sheet has been issued and
the disciplinary proceedings are pending;
(iii) Government Servants in respect of whom prosecution for a criminal charge is
pending"
13. Whereas paragraph 6 of the said circular letter provides for a sealed
cover procedure to be adopted by the DPC, the same has to be taken recourse to
only in the event circumstances mentioned in paragraph 2 thereof arise after the
recommendation of the DPC. The recommendations of the DPC, therefore, can be
refused to be given effect to only inter ala when one or the other conditions
mentioned in paragraph 2 of the said circular stand satisfied which in the instant
case would mean that as against the respondent a chargesheet had been issued or,
in other words, a disciplinary proceeding was pending. Admittedly, a chargesheet
was issued as against him only on 24.09.1999.
16. Serious allegations of financial misdemeanours were made against the
respondent therein. Central Bureau of Investigation took up investigation. He was
suspended on 10.03.1988. Although the said order of suspension was revoked,
investigation continued. The DPC considered his case for promotion on 3.04.1991
and resorted to sealed cover procedure. Only in the aforementioned situation, K.V.
Janakiraman and other decisions following the same stood distinguished opining
that paragraph 7 of the said office memorandum would be attracted, which is in
the following terms( R.S. Sharma case, SCC P.398, Para-11:
"Sealed cover applicable to an officer coming under cloud before promotion . A
government servant, who is recommended for promotion by the Departmental
Promotion Committee but in whose case any of the circumstances mentioned in
para 2 above arise after the recommendations of DPC are received but before he is
actually promoted, will be considered as if his case had been placed in a sealed
cover by DPC. He shall not be promoted until he is completely exonerated of the
charges against him and the provisions contained in this OM will be applicable in
his case also."
It was held(R.S. Sharma Case, SCC . p. 399, Para.15)
" One is that, what the Department did not do is not the yardstick indicated in
para 7 of the Sealed Cover Procedure, what is mentioned therein is that it cannot
apply to the government servant who is not "actually promoted" by that time.
Second is that, the stand taken up by the Department is that in spite of deletion of
clause ( iv ) of the second para, the recommendations of DPC must remain in the
sealed cover on account of the conditions specified in clause ( iii ) of the said
paragraph by virtue of the operation of para 7 thereof. We cannot say that the said
stand was incorrect and, therefore, we are unable to blame the Department for not
opening the sealed cover immediately after 31-7-1991."
Learned Sr. counsel on the same point also referred
to paras-2 to 6 of the Hon’ble Apex Court Judgment reported in
(2013) 4 SCC 161 titled as Union of India and ors Vs. Anil
Kumar Sarkar which is reproduced here-in-under:“2. Anil Kumar Sarkar, the respondent herein, joined the Northern
Railways as a Junior Clerk on 04.11.1977. He was promoted to various posts
and while he was working as senior AFA/T-1 in the office of the Financial
Adviser and Chief Accounts Officer of Northeast Frontier (N.F.) Railway at
Maligaon, a Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) was convened by the
Union Public Service Commission (UPSC) on 26.02.2002 and 27.02.2002 to
consider eligible Group ‘B’ officers of the Accounts Department for their
substantive promotion to Group ‘A’ (Jr. Scale) of Indian Railways Accounts
Service (IRAS) against the vacancies for various Zonal Railways/Production
Units. In the said DPC, the respondent’s name was also considered against
the vacancies in N.F. Railway for the year 2001-2002 and accordingly, his
name was placed in the extended select panel.
3.
It was alleged by the appellants herein that during the year 199495, while the respondent was working as Assistant Accounts Officer in the
Central Stores Accounts (Bills) in the office of the Financial Adviser and Chief
Accounts Officer (Open Line), N.F. Railway, Maligaon, he committed gross
misconduct in the matter of checking and passing the bills of various firms
involved in manufacturing and supplying of cast iron sleeper plates to N.F.
Railways. For the said acts, four memorandum of charges were issued to the
respondent, out of which two were issued on 13.08.2003 and others on
01.09.2003 and 05.11.2003. On the basis of the said memorandums, four
departmental proceedings were initiated against the respondent at three
different places, i.e., Delhi, Kolkata and Gauhati, enquiries were completed
and show cause notices were served.
4.
Based on the similar charges, in the year 2004, the CBI lodged 11
FIRs against the respondent herein on different dates under Section 120B/420
of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and Section 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2)
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and accordingly, cases were
registered against him. Subsequently, 11 cases were amalgamated into 3
cases being numbered as Special Case Nos. 59/04, 60/04 and 62/04.
According to the appellants, on the basis of these charges, the respondent
was not promoted to Group ‘A’ (Jr. Scale).
5. By office order dated 21.04.2003, the batch mates of the respondent
were promoted.
Being aggrieved, the respondent herein filed several
representations to the Department for consideration of his case for promotion
which were duly rejected. Challenging the non-consideration of his case for
promotion, the respondent filed O.A. No. 251 of 2007 before the Central
Administrative Tribunal, Gauhati Bench for a direction to the appellants herein
to promote him to Group ‘A’ (Jr. Scale) of IRAS w.e.f. 05.03.2002 in terms of
the recommendations of the DPC held on 26.02.2002 and 27.02.2002 wherein
his name was figured in the extended panel list.
Vide order dated
21.08.2009, the Tribunal dismissed his application.
6.
Challenging the order of the Tribunal, the respondent herein filed a
petition being W.P.(C) No. 744 of 2010 before the Gauhati High Court. The
High Court, by impugned order dated 27.04.2010, allowed the petition and
set aside the order passed by the Tribunal and directed the appellants herein
to issue appropriate order in favour of the respondent herein for promotion
with all consequential benefits. Challenging the said order, the Union of India
has filed this appeal by way of special leave.
Thereafter, the learned Sr. counsel submitted that
preliminary investigation cannot form the basis for putting the
matter of the petitioner into seal cover and thus urged to allow this
instant appeal.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy
SGI appearing for the Union respondents submits that the matter
related to the appellant herein was referred to the CBI in the year
2016 itself.
7.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record.
8.
The tentative charge sheet issued in the year 2015
by the Assam Rifle contains many serious allegations against the
appellant herein, such as, the appellant failing to disclose the
source of cash and fixed deposits in his bank accounts running
into several lacs of rupees. In the year 2019, the department also
filed a criminal complaint investigation which was handed over to
CBI. CBI issued the charge sheet upon completion of the
investigation in March, 2021 for offence punishable under Section
13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act alleging that the
appellant was holding assets worth over rupees one crore than his
known source of income. The appellant is thus facing serious
allegations of holding large disproportionate assets.
9.
Here it is pertinent to mention that the department
had already taken a decision to proceed against the petitioner for
allegation of undisclosed cash and fixed deposits in his bank
accounts way back in the year 2015. In the year 2019, the
department also lodged a criminal complaint against the petitioner
for possessing vast assets in excess of his known sources of
income and handed over the investigation to the CBI. Both these
events took place before the appellant’s case was ripe for
promotion. The juniors of the appellant were promoted in the year
2020. Therefore by that time, the department had already issued
a tentative charge sheet under the Assam Rifles Act and lodged a
criminal complaint against the petitioner, and handed over the
investigation thereof to the CBI.
10.
In view of the above discussion it is clear that in the
present case, at the time of filing the tentative charge sheet,
substantive investigation was already done. Sufficient information
was already there with the department against the petitioner.
Though it was not the stage of the final filing of the charge sheet,
the tentative charge sheet is to be considered against the
petitioner. Further, the Judgments as referred by the learned Sr.
counsel appearing for the petitioner is not relevant to the fact of
this case.
11.
Accordingly, the Judgment and Order(Oral) dated
16.09.2021 passed by the Hon’ble learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.370 of 2021 is confirmed and this present appeal is dismissed.
12.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT
SINGHA
RAJKUMAR SUHANJIT
SINGHA
Date: 2023.10.07
14:57:55 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review