Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.64 of 2023
1. Sri Rajat Kanti Dey, S/O. Late Rakesh Ranjan Dey, resident of VillageLaxmipur Para, G.P. & P.O.-Masauli, P.S.-Fatikroy, Sub-DivisionKumarghat, District-Unakoti Tripura.
2. Smt. Chaya Rani Dey, W/O. Late Rakesh Ranjan Dey, resident of VillageLaxmipur Para, G.P. & P.O.-Masauli, P.S.-Fatikroy, Sub-DivisionKumarghat, District-Unakoti Tripura.
3. Sri Rathindra Kr. Dey, S/O. Late Rakesh Ranjan Dey, resident of Vill. &
P.O.-Moirani, District-Jorhat, Assam.
4. Smt. Indrani Dey, D/O. Late Rakesh Ranjan Dey, W/O. Ajit Deb, resident
of Krishnanagar, Lake Chowmuhani, P.O.-Agartala, District-West Tripura.
(Petitioner No.1 is the lawful attorney of Petitioner Nos.2, 3 & 4).
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. NER-II Transmission Limited, registered office at C/O. Tripura Furniture,
2nd Floor, Math Chowmuhani, Opposite Iskon Temple, Agartala-799001,
District-West Tripura represented by its DGM & Project Head Sri Narottam
Chakraborty.
2. The Deputy General Manager, Transmission Division, Tripura State
Electricity Corporation Limited (A Govt. of Tripura Enterprise), Kumarghat,
Unakoti Tripura.
3. The DM & Collector, Office of the District Magistrate & Collector, Unakoti
District, Kailashahar.
………Opposite Party-Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Koushik Datta, Advocate,
Mr. Kushal Deb, Advocate,
Mr. Samrat Sarkar, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
CAV reserved on
: 21.11.2025.
Judgment delivered on
: 17.12.2025.
Whether fit for reporting : YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. Kundan Pandey, counsel appearing for the petitioners
and Mr. Koushik Datta, counsel appearing for the respondents.
2.
This Revision is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India challenging the judgment dt.30.06.2023 in Civil Misc.(Telegraph) No.
01 of 2021 passed by the District Judge, Unakoti District, Kailashahar.
The background facts:
3.
The petitioners are owners and possessors of the subject land.
They had filed the said case under Section 8 of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885
seeking compensation of Rs.14,10,550/- towards damages to trees and crops
and Rs.40,00,000/- for damage to land measuring 4(four) kani with interest @
12% per annum from the respondents who had laid a 132 KV LILO (AMBPK Bari) Transmission Line NER-II over their land which is described in the
schedule to the said application.
4.
They contended that in the said land there were trees bearing
lemons, bamboo, drumstick, paddy, betel nut, banana, coconut, mango, beans,
gourd, kathal (jackfruit), Shimul, blackberry, Teak etc.
5.
According to them, they received notices on 30.07.2020 and
08.11.2020 from the NER-II Transmission Limited (respondent No.1) under
the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 informing them that a proposed 132 KV line
would be run through their land and under the process trees belonging to them
and standing on the land would require clearance, and so would be cut and
they would compensate the petitioners for the loss and value of the land and
trees and construction as assessed by the Revenue Department of the State
Government.
6.
They contended that without any assessment and inquiry by the
Revenue Department, the respondents forcefully cut the above mentioned
trees; land also was affected by way of earth filling, by a conductor line, by
using vehicle/transportation and by erecting a leg of a tower in the land and
about 4(four) kani of land was damaged and the said land cannot then be
utilized in future for any purpose.
7.
They contended that on 11.08.2020 they approached the Sub-
Divisional Magistrate, Kumarghat, Unakoti Tripura for necessary assessment
of damage and on 12.10.2020 the Revenue Inspector attached to the said
office assessed the yield component of the trees, vegetables and plants, which
was inadequate and not proper.
8.
They contended that these lands are their only source of income
and they have been permanently damaged by the respondents and they have
been deprived of present and future earning from the trees on the land.
9.
They contended that the respondents paid meager compensation
on the basis of an assessment of damage and loss made by the Tehshildar,
Kanchanbari T.K., Revenue Inspector attached to the office of the SubDivisional
Magistrate,
Kumarghat
and
Deputy
General
Manager,
Transmission Division, Kumarghat, which was not satisfactory and adequate.
10.
Counter affidavit was filed by the respondents disputing the
above allegations.
11.
It was contended that the respondent No.1 is an Authorized
Person/Licensee under the Electricity Act, 2003 granted to it by the
Government of India, Ministry of Power for placing the electric line for
transmission of electricity and is entitled to invoke the provisions of the Indian
Telegraph Act, 1885.
12.
The respondents denied that they had deprived use of 4(four)
kanis of land of the petitioners though they admitted that the main electric line
had gone through their land. They denied that:
(a) the land had become totally damaged and that the
compensation awarded was inadequate;
(b) that the land was affected in any way by earth filling or by
placing a conductor line or by using vehicle/transportation or by
posting of leg of the tower and affected by alignment of wire.
(c) that the assessment of damage and loss made by the Revenue
Officials was not adequate and proper.
They also contended that there is no provision in the Indian
Telegraph Act, 1885 for payment of compensation for the land and that
petitioners are entitled only to damages to the property under Section 10(b) of
the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885. They also contended that they are only liable
to pay compensation for damages to the surface and cost to the existing
standing properties only and not for any future loss etc.
13.
The Trial Court framed the following issues:
(i)
Whether the instant suit is maintainable in its present
form and nature?
(ii)
Whether there is cause of action to file the instant
case?
(iii)
Whether 4 kani of land of the petitioner became
damaged due to transmission of electric line over the land?
(iv)
Whether
the
petitioners
are
entitled
compensation under Indian Telegraph Act, 1885?
to
get
(v)
Whether the petitioners are entitled to get any other
relief/ reliefs?
14.
Both parties examined witnesses and marked documents.
The judgment of the trial Court:
15.
The
trial
Court
in
its
judgment
dt.30.06.2023
denied
compensation for the land allegedly utilized by the respondents for laying the
leg of the tower in it . It also held that compensation given to the petitioners
for the damage to the trees and crops was just and they are not entitled to any
additional compensation for trees and crops which are allegedly damaged
because of laying of the Transmission Line.
16.
It held that the petitioners could not prove by adducing any
cogent documentary evidence that they are entitled to more compensation for
the trees and crops beyond the rate which was given to them by the opposite
parties. It also held that the petitioners had filed some vague papers showing
existence of some trees over their land but they are not concrete and it cannot
be inferred that there were more trees or crops beyond what was listed by the
Revenue Authorities and for which compensation was given.
17.
Challenging the same, this Revision is filed.
18.
The counsel for the petitioners contended that the judgment of the
Court below is perverse and suffers from illegality and material irregularity
inasmuch as though 5(five) issues have been framed, but no findings have
been recorded on all the issues framed. It is contended that the finding of the
trial Court that no compensation can be given for land under the Indian
Telegraph Act is not correct in view of the guidelines dt.15.10.2015 issued by
the Ministry of Power, Government of India and the Government of Tripura
regarding compensation towards damages in regard to the Right of Way for
transmission lines. They contended that as per the said guidelines, they are
entitled to receive 100% of the land value for the tower base area (between the
four legs) impacted severely due to installation of tower/pylon structure.
19.
They contended that the trial Court did not consider the question
as to whether the land of the petitioners had been rendered useless on account
of the installation of the electric tower and laying of transmission lines to the
extent of 4(four) kani, i.e. 1.6 acres.
20.
They also contended that in Exhibit-P/7, the Revenue Inspector,
Kumarghat Revenue Circle, in his Assessment Report, specifically stated that
their land was affected by earth filling, by conductor line, by using of
vehicle/transportation, and also affected by posting of four legs of the tower
over the land of the petitioners, but the trial Court had not considered the
same.
21.
Counsel for the petitioners also relied on the judgment
dt.09.09.2025 of Division Bench of this Court in CRP No.32 of 2023 titled
"North East Transmission Company Ltd. v. Khalek Mia & another",
wherein the Division Bench held that where the land owner is deprived of use
of land by laying of a transmission line, the respondents are bound to
compensate him/her under Article 300A of the Constitution of India and that a
person cannot be deprived of the use of property unless the same is acquired
and compensation is paid for the land which he is deprived of use.
22.
Counsel for the respondents refuted the said contentions and
supported the judgment of the trial Court.
Consideration by the Court:
23.
I have noted the submissions of both sides.
24.
The record reveals that the Revenue Inspector, Kumarghat
submitted Exhibit-P/7, Assessment Report, clearly mentioning that there was
certain portion of the land affected by earth filling, for using vehicle/
transportation and also affected by posting of four legs of the tower over the
land of the petitioners. Details of the number of trees of different types
existing on the land was also mentioned in the said report.
25.
The petitioners have filed Exhibit-P/13 consisting of two
documents dated 07.08.2020 and also 16.07.2020 indicating the number of
trees existing on their land which is signed by a family member of the
petitioners as well as M/S. Sterlite Power, which was the Agency employed by
the respondents to execute the work in the subject land of the petitioners.
26.
There are also Exhibits-F, H and J, notices issued by the Tripura
State Electricity Corporation Limited to the petitioners on 30.07.2020,
08.11.2020 and 30.12.2020 respectively mentioning the trees which are likely
to be damaged apart from location of the legs of the tower. These three
documents have been marked by the respondents.
27.
No doubt, Exhibits-G, I and K filed by the respondents indicate
the calculation made for determining the compensation for the trees. On what
basis the rate for the trees has been arrived at, is not mentioned anywhere by
the Revenue Inspector therein, who is supposed to have made the calculation
of the compensation payable for the trees which are destroyed. The said
official has also not been examined by the respondents to justify that there was
some rational basis for fixing a particular rate for a particular type of tree.
28.
The only witness examined on behalf of the respondents is an
official, i.e. Deputy General Manager, Transmission Division, Kumarghat,
who merely stated that the Revenue Inspector attached to the Office of the
Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kumarghat had assessed the compensation for the
trees/crops after physical verification. Though he stated that the compensation
was awarded as per the Government approved rate, no document is marked by
the said witness as to how the said rate was arrived at.
29.
It is for the respondents to show that there was rational basis for
the compensation calculated and paid to the petitioners, but they failed to do
so. It is unfortunate that such a casual approach is adopted by respondents in
the matter of determination of compensation for tree and crop loss.
30.
Unfortunately, the trial Court did not consider these documents
and aspects and proceeded to mechanically confirm the action of the
respondents. Thus it has failed to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it which
has caused miscarriage of justice.
31.
Also Exhibits-P/7, P/13 and Exhibit-H undoubtedly show that an
approach road was laid on the land of the petitioners and four legs of a tower
were fixed on the land of the petitioners. Exhibit-P/7 even shows that there
was earth filling on a portion of the land of the petitioners and some portion is
affected by a conductor line, by using a vehicle/transportation and also by
positioning four legs of a tower. It cannot be denied that if there is earth filling
in fertile land on which fruit bearing trees, crops etc. grow, the said area
cannot be utilized for cultivation purposes.
32.
The petitioners had placed reliance in this revision on
Annexure-8 dt.15.10.2015 issued by the Government of India, Ministry of
Power, New Delhi laying down guidelines for payment of compensation
towards damages in regard to Right of Way for transmission lines. The said
guidelines referred to meeting of a High Level Committee constituted by
senior bureaucrats of the Power Ministry and in paragraph-4, the following
recommendations have been made:
"The GoI may issue following guidelines for determining
the compensation payable towards "damages" as stipulated in
Indian Telegraph Act which will be in addition to the
compensation towards normal crop and tree damages. This
amount will be payable only for transmission Lines of 66 kV and
above, and not for sub-transmission and distribution lines below
66 kV:
i.
Compensation @ 85% of land value as determined by
District Magistrate or any other authority based on Circle
rate/Guideline value/Stamp Act rates for tower base area
(between four legs) impacted severely due to installation of
tower/pylon structure;
ii.
Compensation towards diminution of land value in
the width of RoW Corridor due to laying of transmission line and
imposing certain restriction would be decided by the States as
per categorization/type of land in different places of States,
subject to a maximum of 15% of land value as determined based
on Circle rate/Guideline value/Stamp Act rates;
iii.
In areas where land owner/owners have been
offered/accepted alternate mode of compensation by concerned
corporation/Municipality under Transfer Development Rights
(TDR) policy of State, the licensee/Utility shall deposit
compensation amount as per (i) & (ii) above with the concerned
Corporation/Municipality/Local Body or the State Government.
iv.
For this purpose, the width of RoW corridor shall not
be more than that prescribed in para 1.3 above, and shall not be
less than the width directly below the conductors."
33.
The State of Tripura had also issued a notification on 02.06.2023
(filed as Annexure-9 in the Revision) stating that it has not adopted the
guidelines framed by the Ministry of Power, Government of India but has
framed its own guidelines. These guidelines provide for enhanced
compensation of full land value to the land owner/owners for tower base area
(between four legs) impacted severely due to installation of tower/pylon
structure along with damage cost of trees/crops/structure, if any, in case of
Jote land.
34.
Suppressing the above guidelines which have to be followed by
the respondents, the respondents have taken the untenable plea that they need
not pay any compensation for deprivation of use of land to the petitioners
because they are invoking the Indian Telegraph Act,1885 provisions. Thus
grave injustice has been caused to petitioners.
35.
In the judgment dt.9.9.2025 in CRP No.32 of 2023 titled "North
East Transmission Company Ltd. v. Khalek Mia & another", this Court had
also taken the view that the respondents have to pay compensation to
landowner for deprivation of land use.
36.
In this view of the matter, I am of the opinion that both parties
should have an opportunity to place on record evidence as to the extent of land
for which compensation is payable as per the guidelines issued by the
Government of Tripura in Annexure-9 on 02.06.2023 and also for proving the
value of the trees cut as on the date when the transmission line was laid
through the land of the petitioners between July, 2020 and November, 2020.
This is necessary because the trial Court has simply accepted blindly the
assessment made by the Revenue Authorities of the compensation assessed by
them as regards the trees which have been cut, even though the respondents
have not been able to place any material on record on the basis of which the
said assessment was made by the Revenue Officials.
37.
Undoubtedly, the Horticulture Department of the State would
have experts who can assess the value of the fruit bearing trees etc. and if such
persons are examined, it would help in proper determination of compensation
payable to the petitioners and the fact that the petitioners could not adduce
such evidence cannot be put against the petitioners. Also denial of land
compensation by the respondents cannot be countenanced in view of the
guidelines of the Ministry of Power, Government of India, as modified by the
Government of Tripura as mentioned above.
38.
In this view of the matter, the Revision is allowed. The impugned
judgment dt.30.06.2023 of the District Judge, Unakoti District, Kailashahar in
Civil Misc.(Telegraph) No.01 of 2021 is set aside and the matter is remitted
back to the said Court. Both parties are permitted to adduce evidence on the
above aspects and the Court below shall thereafter proceed to decide the said
matter in accordance with law. This exercise shall be completed by
30.06.2026. No costs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Pulak
PULAK BANIK
Date: 2025.12.17 16:35:51 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review