The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. We are of the view that the question of limitation is not merely a technical consideration. The rules of limitation are based on the principles of sound public policy and principles of equity. We should not keep the „Sword of Damocles‟ hanging over the head of the respondent for indefinite period of time to be determined at the whims and fancies of the appellants.” -8- [15] Again in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Ramkumar Choudhury,[Special Leave Petition(C) Diary No.48636 of 2024 decided on 29.11.2024], above said principle has been reiterated by the Apex Court. It is also further observed that the discretion to condone the delay has to be exercised judiciously based on facts and circumstance of each case and that, the expression „sufficient cause‟ cannot be liberally interpreted, if negligence, inaction or lack of bonafides is attributed to the party. [16] The reasons appellant in the for instant delay as projected case, as discussed by the earlier in paragraph no. 13, appears to be not at all satisfactory, rather the negligence and lack of diligence of the appellant are evident in his conduct. Therefore, the Court is not inclined to condone the delay as prayed for. [17] Accordingly, the petition for condonation of delay is rejected. Saikat Sarma RUDRADEE Digitally 2025.09.11 P BANERJEE Date: 16:04:19 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
IA 01 of 2025
In RSA No.12 of 2025
Shri Rajani Kanta Debnath, S/o-Lt. Rajeswar Debnath, R/oTown Indranagar, P.O.-Dhaleswar, P.S.-East Agartala, Dist.-West
Tripura
….Applicant/Appellant(s)
Versus
Shri Haripada Acharjee, S/o- Lt. Upendra Ch. Acharjee, R/oTown Indranagar, P.O.-Dhaleswar, P.S.-East Agartala, Dist.-West
Tripura.
….Respondent(s)
For Applicant/Appellant(s) :
Mr. Ashish Nandi,Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Chakraborty,Advocate.
Ms. S. Debnath,Advocate.
Date of Hearing &
Delivery of Order
:
9th September,2025.
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes No
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
-O-R-D-E-RHeard Ld. Counsel of both sides.
[2]
The second appeal has been preferred against the
judgment dated 24.04.2024 passed by Ld. District Judge,
West Tripura, Agartala in Title Appeal No. 55 of 2017 and
related decree thereof whereby the appeal was allowed by
setting aside the judgment passed by Ld. Trial Court. The
right, title and interest over the suit land was declared by the
-2-
first appellate court with the relief of recovery of possession
of the same. The appeal is filed with a delay of 275 days by
the appellant defendant.
[3]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Ashish Nandi representing the
appellant, submits in respect of the petition filed u/s 5 of the
Limitation Act that after the passing of the appellate
judgment
and
decree
on
24.04.2024
and
26.04.2024
respectively, the neighbours and well wishers of both the
parties intervened in the matter and a meeting was held on
26.06.2024 amongst them wherein it was resolved that
respondent would not file any execution petition for recovery
of possession from the defendant appellant. Though, the
written resolution was agreed to be reduced into writing, but
same was not done because the plaintiff respondent had to
leave the venue of the meeting for his urgent work.
Thereafter, from time to time the petitioner attempted to get
the said resolution signed, but the respondent was found
reluctant in signing the same. Thereafter the petitioner left
for Bangladesh to attend a marriage ceremony on 25th
December, 2024 and returned after 3 months therefrom and
this way the time rolled on.
[4]
It is further stated that the petitioner appellant
visited Bangladesh without any passport. Thereafter, on
28.03.2024
the
petitioner-appellant
contacted
with
the
-3-
respondent for finalization of the settlement of their land
dispute and at that time the respondent intimated that he
had already filed one execution petition for execution of the
appellate decree and thereafter, again on 05.04.2024 all the
well wishers and neighbours of the respondent for honoring
the earlier terms of settlement to which the respondent
strongly opposed. Thereafter, the appellant filed the present
appeal with a delay of 275 days.
[5]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Ashish Nandi earnestly prays for
condoning the delay submitting that there were no latches or
negligence on the part of the appellant in preferring the
appeal and taking some lenient view, the delay may be
condoned.
[6]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Nandi also submits that the claim
of the plaintiff was based on a registered „Will‟ and in the trial
court,
the
attesting
witnesses
of
the
„Will‟
were
not
examined. Though in the first appellant court both the
attesting witnesses were allowed to be examined by said Ld.
Court, still the content of the said „Will‟ were not proved and
therefore, there is merit in the appeal.
[7]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Nandi relies on a decision of the
Hon‟ble
Supreme
Court
in
case
of
Collector,
Land
Acquisition, Anantanag and another v. Mst. Katiji and
-4-
others [AIR 1987 SUPREME COURT 1353] wherein it was
observed that the legislature had conferred the power to
condone delay by enacting Section 5 of the Indian Limitation
Act of 1963 in order to enable the Courts to do substantial
justice to parties by disposing the matter on „merits‟. The
expression “sufficient cause” employed by the legislature is
adequately elastic to enable the Courts to apply the law in a
meaningful manner which subserves the end of justice that
being life purpose for the existence of the institution of
Courts.
[8]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Nandi also relies on another
decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Pathupati Subba
Reddy(Died)by L.Rs & Ors v. The Special Deputy
Collector (LA)[2024 4 SCR 241] wherein it is observed
that the courts are conferred with discretionary powers to
admit an appeal even after the expiry of the prescribed
period or limitation, provided that the appellant is able to
establish „sufficient cause‟ for not filing it within time. Said
power to condone the delay or to admit the appeal preferred
after expiry of time is discretionary in nature and may not be
exercised even if sufficient cause is shown based upon host
of other factors such as negligence, failure to exercise due
diligence etc. In paragraph 16 of the said judgment, it was
also observed that generally courts adopt a very liberal
-5-
approach in construing the phrase „sufficient cause‟ used in
Section 5 of the Limitation Act in order to condone the delay
to enable the courts to do substantial justice.
[9]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Pradip Chakraborty on the other
hand strongly opposes the prayer stating that there was no
talk of any compromise between the parties and no village
level meeting was also organized on any occasion. Therefore,
the pleas as taken by the petitioner appellant are totally
false.
[10]
Ld. Counsel, Mr. Chakraborty also relies on a
decision of the Division Bench of this Court in case of Dipak
Chandra Kar Vs. Union of India [decided on 04.08.2025
in IA No.01 of 2025], wherein prayer for condoning delay
of 362 days was rejected with the observation that the delay
should not be condoned merely as an act of generosity.
[11]
Mr.
Chakraborty,
Ld.
Counsel
also
relies
on
another decision of Hon‟ble Supreme Court in case of Mool
Chandra Vs. Union of India and Anr. [(2025)1 TLR (SC)
295] wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court observed that if the
cause for delay would fall within the four corners of
“sufficient cause”, irrespective of the length of delay, same
deserved to be condoned, and if the cause as shown was
-6-
insufficient, irrespective of the period of delay, same would
not be condoned.
[12]
Court has considered submissions of both sides
and also perused the materials placed in the record.
[13]
At one place the petitioner asserted that though
the resolution of the participants of the meeting dated
26.06.2024 was agreed to be reduced into writing, but that
was not done as the respondent had to leave the venue of
the said meeting for his urgent work. But in another place he
has asserted that from time to time, he attempted to get the
resolution signed by the respondent but he was found
reluctant. Both the assertions are self contradictory. If no
resolution
was
recorded
in
writing
atall,
question
of
presenting the same for signing doesnot arise and if it was
presented for signing by the respondent, certainly the
resolution of the meeting was written down, but no copy of
any
such
resolution
is
placed
in
the
record.
Such
contradictory versions lead to the inference that both are
doubtful. It is also the case of the appellant that he went to
Bangladesh
to
attend
a
marriage
ceremony
on
25th
December, 2024 (though illegally without any Passport) and
returned to India only on 25th March 2025 i.e. after 3 months
therefrom. Such long stay at Bangladesh without taking any
steps for presenting the appeal, clearly demonstrates his
-7-
lackadaisical and negligent attitude in pursuing his own
cause.
[14]
In a recent decision by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
in case of Union of India & another v. Jahangir Byramji
Jeejeebhoy (D) through his L.R.s, 2024 SCC Online SC
489, it has been held that when it is decided that a party has
lost his right to have the matter considered on merits
because of his own inaction for a long, it cannot be presumed
to be non-deliberate delay and in such circumstances, he
cannot be heard to plead that the substantial justice
deserves
to
be
preferred
as
against
the
technical
considerations. While considering the petition for condonation
of delay, the court must not start with the merits of the main
case. The relevant paragraph nos.26 and 27 of said decision
are extracted below:
“26. The length of the delay is a relevant matter which the
court must take into consideration while considering whether the delay
should be condoned or not. From the tenor of the approach of the
appellants, it appears that they want to fix their own period of limitation
for instituting the proceedings for which law has prescribed a period of
limitation. Once it is held that a party has lost his right to have the matter
considered on merits because of his own inaction for a long, it cannot be
presumed to be non-deliberate delay and in such circumstances of the case,
he cannot be heard to plead that the substantial justice deserves to be
preferred as against the technical considerations. While considering the
plea for condonation of delay, the court must not start with the merits of
the main matter. The court owes a duty to first ascertain the bona fides of
the explanation offered by the party seeking condonation. It is only if the
sufficient cause assigned by the litigant and the opposition of the other side
is equally balanced that the court may bring into aid the merits of the
matter for the purpose of condoning the delay.
27. We are of the view that the question of limitation is not
merely a technical consideration. The rules of limitation are based on the
principles of sound public policy and principles of equity. We should not
keep the „Sword of Damocles‟ hanging over the head of the respondent for
indefinite period of time to be determined at the whims and fancies of the
appellants.”
-8-
[15]
Again
in
State
of
Madhya
Pradesh
v.
Ramkumar Choudhury,[Special Leave Petition(C) Diary
No.48636 of 2024 decided on 29.11.2024], above said
principle has been reiterated by the Apex Court. It is also
further observed that the discretion to condone the delay has
to be exercised judiciously based on facts and circumstance
of each case and that, the expression „sufficient cause‟
cannot be liberally interpreted, if negligence, inaction or lack
of bonafides is attributed to the party.
[16]
The
reasons
appellant
in the
for
instant
delay
as
projected
case, as discussed
by
the
earlier
in
paragraph no. 13, appears to be not at all satisfactory, rather
the negligence and lack of diligence of the appellant are
evident in his conduct. Therefore, the Court is not inclined to
condone the delay as prayed for.
[17]
Accordingly, the petition for condonation of delay
is rejected.
JUDGE
Saikat Sarma
signed by
RUDRADEE Digitally
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
2025.09.11
P BANERJEE Date:
16:04:19 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review