Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.01 of 2023
Sri Pran Hari De,
S/o Late Sachiram De, resident of village Kanchannagar, P.S. Amtali,
P.O. A.D. Nagar, District West Tripura.
……… Appellant(s)
–Versus–
Sri Khagendra Chandra Dey,
S/o Late Sachiram Dey, Resident of village Kanchannagar, P.S. Amtali,
P.O. S.D. Mission, District West Tripura.
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P.K. Dhar, Senior Advocate.
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. R. Debnath, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D.C. Roy, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
16th August, 2024.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
13th December, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The appeal arises out of the judgment dated 19.11.2022
passed by the learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in Title
Appeal No.16 of 2021 whereby the appeal was dismissed and
judgment passed learned Civil Judge (Jr. Divn.), Court No.7,
Agartala on 15.09.2021 dismissing the original suit bearing No.T.S.
110 of 2015 and the related decree thereof were affirmed.
[2]
The
appellant
(plaintiff
of
the
original
suit)
and
respondent (defendant of the original suit) are two full brothers.
According to plaintiff, he and his brother and mother were residing
at Bangladesh having their immovable property therein in joint
stock and the suit land situated at Mouja Charipara under SubDivision-Sadar was purchased jointly by both the brothers by
selling their lands at Bangladesh and both the brothers resided
under jointness inside the suit land till their mother expired in the
year 2002. Khatian of the land was accordingly recorded jointly in
the names of the plaintiff and the defendant showing 50% share
each therein but suddenly the defendant submitted a petition to the
DM & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala under Section 95 of the TLR
& LR Act, 1960 for correction of the record producing some
purchase deeds in his name based on which the DM & Collector
passed order for rectification of the record by mutating Khatian in
the name of the defendant for major portion of the land. In that
background, the plaintiff instituted the suit for partition of the suit
land claiming 50% share therein. According to him, those purchase
deeds were executed during the period 1991 to 1993 and at that
time the defendant had no such financial capacity to purchase the
same.
[3]
According to the defendant, he purchased those lands
through four nos. of deeds from his own source of income and not
from any joint fund. According to him, he purchased 3 gandas of
land by registered sale deed dated 12.11.1993, 4 gandas of land by
sale deed dated 06.02.1992, 1 ganda 1 kara of land by another
sale deed dated 19.06.1991 and land measuring 0.03 acres vide
sale deed dated 24.12.1992. As further stated, he came to India
long ago and doing business here, he purchased such lands and he
was never in jointness of mess and family with the plaintiff. It was
further stated by him that during revisional survey and settlement
operation, wrongly record was created in his name jointly with the
plaintiff. Thereafter, he filed petition under Section 95 of the TLR &
LR Act, 1960 before the DM & Collector, West Tripura and the DM &
Collector ordered for correction of record by way of recording of
0.19 acre of land solely in the name of the defendant, 0.02 acre of
land in the name of plaintiff and 0.01 acre of land both in the name
of
plaintiff
and
defendant
showing
their
equal
share
and
accordingly, Khatians were also corrected as per said direction of
the Collector.
[4]
The plaintiff during trial examined himself and other two
witnesses namely, Smt. Durga Datta [PW-2] and Sri Rupan Datta
[PW-3] on his behalf. The plaintiff also proved some documents
into evidence. The defendant examined himself as DW-1 and
proved certain documents on his behalf but he did not examine any
other witness further.
[5]
Learned trial court dismissed the suit observing that as
per order of the DM now, three separate Khatians were in existence
and plaintiff failed to produce any documentary evidence to show
that by disposing the joint property at Bangladesh, the suit land in
India was purchased. Learned trial court also observed that the
plaintiff could not prove his right, title and interest in the suit land.
Those findings were endorsed by learned First Appellate Court with
further observation that the suit land was not a joint family
property of the plaintiff and the defendant.
[6]
Mr. P.K. Dhar, learned senior counsel for the plaintiff-
appellant argues that after exhausting different phases and inviting
objection etc. ultimately the record was finally published by the
settlement authority during revisional survey and settlement
operation recording the suit land jointly in the names of both the
brothers in equal share and the defendant never objected to such
recording so long as his mother was alive. But after the death of his
mother, he submitted an application before the DM & Collector for
correction of such record which was ultimately allowed by the DM &
Collector. According to Mr. Dhar, learned senior counsel, such
revenue record can only be corrected under Section 45 of the TLR &
LR Act, 1960 after same is finally published and the Collector has
no jurisdiction to order for such correction under Section 95 of the
said Act but said point was not decided by learned Courts below.
Therefore, a fresh issue may be framed on that point and the suit
may be remanded to learned trial Court for fresh decision.
[7]
Mr. D.C. Roy, learned counsel for the defendant-
respondent argues that there were concurrent findings of both
learned Courts below and therefore, there is no scope to interfere
in the second appeal upsetting such findings in absence of any
substantial question of law. Mr. Roy, learned counsel also submits
that the order passed by the DM & Collector under Section 95 of
the TLR & LR Act was not challenged before any higher forum and
therefore, said decision is binding on the plaintiff. Lastly, learned
counsel submits that no evidence could be led by the plaintiff to
establish that the suit land was purchased jointly by both the
brothers by selling any joint property in Bangladesh.
[8]
The second appeal was admitted on the following
substantial question of law:
“Whether the findings of both the courts below are
perverse in dismissing the suit for declaration of right,
title, interest and partition?”
[9]
This Court has considered the submission of both sides
and has meticulously gone through the records. To substantiate the
claim, the plaintiff has proved certified copy of one Khatian No.133
(Exbt.1) which shows that the original suit plot No.3773 created
during revisional survey and settlement operation was recorded
jointly in the name of both the brothers but no document of
purchase in the names of the both the brothers could be produced
by him. Under Exbt.3, the plaintiff also proved one BS Khatian
standing in the names of both the plaintiff and the defendant and
many other persons for land area 7.83 acre under Mouja
Khurushkul of District CoxBazar, Bangladesh. But apart from the
same, he did not prove any document to show that any such land
was sold by them at Bangladesh to accumulate fund to purchase
land in India. PW-2 and PW-3, both in their examination-in-chief on
affidavit stated that the plaintiff, defendant and their mother
disposed of their joint property at Bangladesh and such sale
proceeds were sent to the defendant to purchase land in India. PW2 also stated that on some occasion such amount was sent to the
defendant through him and by said money, the suit land was
purchased by the defendant. In her cross-examination, she stated
that she had come to India about 30 years ago illegally. There is no
document of conversion of any foreign exchange into India. The
plaintiff
in
his
cross-examination
has
given
the
boundary
description of the suit land to be as follows- north-Badal, south
west-Lt. Manu Datta, east-Paddy land but it does not tally with the
boundary description of the suit land given in the plaint.
[10]
The defendant proved the order of the DM & Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala dated 07.02.2014 (Exbt.9) whereby he
directed for recording of 0.19 acre of land from suit plot No.3773 in
the name of defendant, 0.02 acre of land in the name of plaintiff
and 0.01 acre of land jointly in the name of both the brothers in
separate Khatians. Accordingly, Khatian No.3617 (Exbt.5) has been
created solely in the name of defendant for 0.19 acre of land
creating a butted plot from said RS plot No.3773. Admittedly, the
plaintiff did not challenge said order of the DM & Collector before
any higher forum and it stands good and binding on the plaintiff
and out of total 0.22 acre of suit land, 0.19 acre stands solely in
the name of the defendant.
[11]
Though learned senior counsel argues that once the
record of right is finally published that cannot be corrected under
Section 95 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 except the provision of
Section 45 of the said Act but the Court is not convinced with such
submission inasmuch as provision of Section 45 of the Act is meant
for correction of any entry in such record within one year after it’s
final publication, due to any mistake occurred owing to any bona
fide error. It does not affect the power of DM & Collector for
correction of record under Section 95 of the TLR & LR Act in any
manner. The power of the Collector under Section 95 is wider. The
matter has also been discussed earlier in another decision of this
Court in Solanki Roy (Deb) and others vs. Babul Roy and
another, (2014) 2 TLR 1091 and it was held that in exercise of
power under Section 95 of the Act, the Collector has got the
authority to rectify/modify any record of rights at any point of time.
The finding of the Learned Additional District Judge that the
Collector has no power to rectify a record of rights under Section
95 in that case was held to be absolutely contrary to the provisions
of law.
[12]
Considering all these aspect, this Court does not find
any perversity in the judgments of both the learned trial court as
well as the learned First Appellate Court requiring any interference.
The appeal is accordingly dismissed being devoid of merit.
Return the Trial Court’s and First Appellate Court’s
records.
Registry is to prepare the decree accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2024.12.13 17:14:21 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review