The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. 11.2019 passed in WP(C) No.604 of 2019. [3] The grievance of the appellant falls within a short compass. The appellant was appointed to the post of skilled worker subsequently, it is renamed as Production Assistant. Few persons raised the dispute which refer to the Industrial Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala and registered as labour case No. 01 of 1998 demanded that for their training in ITI. The must be given the scale of pay of Rs.240-440/- with admissible allowance w.e.f. 01.04.1979 and the corresponding scale of pay of Rs.430-850/- with admissible allowance w.e.f. 01.01.1992 and in the revised scale Rs.970-2170//- plus admissible allowance w.e.f.01.01.1986. [4] The Government filed their counter statement but the Tribunal passed the judgment and award on 14.12.2000 directing the respondent to allow the petitioners of the labour case the scale of pay Rs.240-440/- with admissible allowance w.e.f. 01.04.1979 and their corresponding revised pay scale as made time to time. Some of the similarly situated were filed writ petitions for granting the benefit of order dated 17.03.2005 issued by the respondents. the appellant is not only similarly situated like Sri Chanbanmoy Das Gupta and others who got the benefit of the aforesaid award of the learned labour Court but, he is also equally situated like Sri Uttam Kanti Sru and 56 others who ahd preferred WP(C) No.490 of 2005 and also l…
04. 09.1982 and in the revised scale of pay Rs.970-2170/- and other admissible allowances w.e.f. 01.01.1986 and corresponding scale under the Tripura Government Services (Revised Pay) Rules from time to time the respondents already implemented the aforesaid judgments in favour of the petitioners. [6] The appellant by an application has demanded the same but, there has been no positive response. The appellant filed a writ petition praying same relief but, subsequently which was withdrawn. The said judgment is already implemented by the respondent. This Court on 14.03.2017 allowed the said writ petition. On 09.11.2017, the respondent No.2 issued an order to implement the said judgment and order dated 14.03.2017. The learned Single Judge without appreciating the various judgments of this Court dismissed the writ petition of the appellant who is as similar as those of the petitioners. [7] Mrs. Deb Gupta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the impugned judgment and order suffer from non-application of mind both in fact and laws. The learned Single Judge did not consider that the post namely Junior Production Assistant was earlier named as Skilled worker and some of the labourers appointed as Skilled workers raised a labour dispute in the Industrial Tribunal which was registered as Labour Case No. 1 of 1998 and that was decided in their favour by the Tribunal …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WA. No.272 of 2021
1.
1.
2.
Sri Pradip Kumar Roy (58 years), son of late Mati Lal Roy, resident of
Madhya Banamalipur, P.O. Agartala, P.S. East Agartala, District: West
Tripura. Pin-799001.
.....Appellant
V-E-R-S-U-S
The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Department of Industries & Commerce, Government of
Tripura, Khejur Bagan, P.O. Agartala, District: Tripura (W).
Director of Handloom, Handicrafts & Sericulture, Government of
Tripura, represented by Director, Pt. Nehru Complex, Gurkhabasti
Kunjaban, Agartala-799006, District: Tripura(W).
.....Respondents.
For Appellant(s)
: Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order : 08.12.2022.
Whether fit for reporting: YES
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
08/12/2022
Chief Justice, Acting)
Heard Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for the
appellant also heard Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A. appearing for the
respondents.
[2]
This present appeal has been filed under Article-226 of the
Constitution of India against the impugned judgment and order dated
20.11.2019 passed in WP(C) No.604 of 2019.
[3]
The grievance of the appellant falls within a short compass. The
appellant was appointed to the post of skilled worker subsequently, it is
renamed as Production Assistant. Few persons raised the dispute which refer to
the Industrial Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala and registered as labour case
No. 01 of 1998 demanded that for their training in ITI. The must be given the
scale of pay of Rs.240-440/- with admissible allowance w.e.f. 01.04.1979 and
the corresponding scale of pay of Rs.430-850/- with admissible allowance
w.e.f. 01.01.1992 and in the revised scale Rs.970-2170//- plus admissible
allowance w.e.f.01.01.1986.
[4]
The Government filed their counter statement but the Tribunal
passed the judgment and award on 14.12.2000 directing the respondent to allow
the petitioners of the labour case the scale of pay Rs.240-440/- with admissible
allowance w.e.f. 01.04.1979 and their corresponding revised pay scale as made
time to time. Some of the similarly situated were filed writ petitions for
granting the benefit of order dated 17.03.2005 issued by the respondents. the
appellant is not only similarly situated like Sri Chanbanmoy Das Gupta and
others who got the benefit of the aforesaid award of the learned labour Court
but, he is also equally situated like Sri Uttam Kanti Sru and 56 others who ahd
preferred WP(C) No.490 of 2005 and also like Sri Anil Kumar Sarkar and 4
others who had preferred WP(C) No.07 OF 2006.
[5]
The appellant has stated that the aforesaid WP(C) No.490 of 2005
was decided by this Court by a judgment and order passed on 29.04.2014.
Similarly situated persons like the appellant filed a writ petition being No.
WP(C) No.201 of 2014, which was disposed of on 08.04.2015 by giving
similar benefits. The appellant equally situated with the petitioner of those writ
petition inasmuch as, the time of appointment he was also having identical
qualification. The petitioner is entitled to get his pay fixed in the pay scale of
Rs.240-440/- which is revised to Rs.430-850/- vide notification dated
04.09.1982 and in the revised scale of pay Rs.970-2170/- and other admissible
allowances w.e.f. 01.01.1986 and corresponding scale under the Tripura
Government Services (Revised Pay) Rules from time to time the respondents
already implemented the aforesaid judgments in favour of the petitioners.
[6]
The appellant by an application has demanded the same but, there
has been no positive response. The appellant filed a writ petition praying same
relief but, subsequently which was withdrawn. The said judgment is already
implemented by the respondent. This Court on 14.03.2017 allowed the said
writ petition. On 09.11.2017, the respondent No.2 issued an order to implement
the said judgment and order dated 14.03.2017. The learned Single Judge
without appreciating the various judgments of this Court dismissed the writ
petition of the appellant who is as similar as those of the petitioners.
[7]
Mrs. Deb Gupta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the impugned judgment and order suffer from non-application of
mind both in fact and laws. The learned Single Judge did not consider that the
post namely Junior Production Assistant was earlier named as Skilled worker
and some of the labourers appointed as Skilled workers raised a labour dispute
in the Industrial Tribunal which was registered as Labour Case No. 1 of 1998
and that was decided in their favour by the Tribunal on 01.04.1979. That order
ultimately was implemented by the respondent Director. Subsequently, there
were several writ petitions seeking similar relief by the similarly situated
persons and the writ petition No.07 of 2006 was disposed of allowing the claim
of the petitioners on 08.10.2013.
[8]
The learned Single Judge did not consider that the Industrial
Tribunal pleased enough to declare in the labour case being No.1 of 1998 that
the persons who are similarly situated as the appellant, entitle to get scale of
pay Rs.240-440/- with admissible allowances w.e.f. 01.04.1979 and in the
corresponding revised scale of pay Rs.430-850/- with admissible allowances
w.e.f. 01.01.1982 and the revised scale of pay of Rs.970-2170/- and other
admissible allowances w.e.f. 01.01.1986.
[9]
Subsequently, the appellant file a review petition for reviewing
the judgment and order dated 20.11.2019 passed in WP(C) No.604 of 2017.
The State Government filed counter affidavit of the said review petition. This
Court while dismissing the review petition held that the pay scale given to the
appellant at the time of initial appointment as a skilled worker should be
applicable to the appellant which was also reflected in his appointment letter.
For the purpose of reference, the operative portion of the order dated
20.11.2019 passed in WP(C) No.604 of 2017 may be reproduced herein below:
“.....Having situated thus, at this point of time Mr. Datta, learned
counsel under the instruction has prayed for withdrawal of the instant
writ petition. Accordingly, the instant writ petition is dismissed as
withdrawn and thus disposed of.”
[10]
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents has submitted that
the appellant has not been engaged under ROP, 1975. He has been engaged as
skilled worker on 21.03.1986 when ROP, 1975 was repealed and ROP, 1982
was in force. Further when the ROP, 1988 was made from 01.01.1986. So, the
appellant cannot claim equality in pay in terms of pay scale under ROP, 1975
because the effect of ROP, 1975 has ceased to exist. Further the fixation of pay
in the pay scale of Rs.370-650/- under ROP, 1982 in respect of skilled worker
is also at par with the pay scale prescribed in ROP Rules, 1982.
[11]
He has further contended that it is wrong on the part of the
appellant to seek pay parity with other Skilled Workers who were engaged
under different ROP. Since the appointment of the appellant has been made
under ROP, 1982 therefore, it may be examined whether the appellant is
getting any less pay than the pay prescribed for the post of skilled worker under
ROP, 1982. But in no case pay scale of skilled workers who have been
appointed on two different periods under two different ROPs can be compared.
[12]
The points that arose before the learned Single Judge that the
appellant working as Production Assistant in the pay scale of Rs.370-850/- but,
the appellant is entitled to get scale of Rs.430-850/- (as per ROP, 1982) prerevised pay scale of Rs.240-440/- (as per ROP, 1979) which is granted to the
similarly situated persons by this Court. The learned Single Judge decided that
the appellant was admittedly appointed on 21.01.1986 when the ROP, 1982
came into force and in the ROP, 1982, the scale of pay for the said post was
prescribed as Rs.370-650/- which is the corresponding pay scale of Rs. 24040/-.
[13]
The appellant filed writ petition in second time being writ
petition No.WP(C) No.91 of 2020 wherein, he raised a question that whether
the appellant can file writ petition in the same ground without affording the
review jurisdiction. The appellant withdraw the said writ petition by taking
liberty to file review petition. This Court on 06.04.2021 passed an order to
withdraw the said writ petition.
[14]
Having appreciated the submission made by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties, this Court finds that appellant has filed a review
petition seeking review of the order dated 20.11.2019 passed in a writ petition.
It is relevant to point out that the petitioner has preferred a writ appeal against
the said order dated 20.11.2019, which has been withdrawn by the appellant
without any liberty to apply for review. In such circumstances, in my
considered opinion, no case for review is made out and subsequently, that
review petition was dismissed.
[15]
The appellant has withdrawn the writ petition unconditionally
and withdrawal of writ petition unconditionally will lead to relinquishment of
the claim of the appellant in appeal. In other words, it means the acceptance of
the findings recorded by the learned Single Judge. Therefore, once the
appellant has accepted the finding of the learned Single Judge while
withdrawing the petition, he cannot be permitted to challenge the same
impugned order again. We may profitably refer a case of the Hon’ble Apex
Court in Kunhayammed & Others vs. State Of Kerala & Another, reported in
2000 (6) SCC 359, wherein, the Court held thus:
"12. The logic underlying the doctrine of merger is that there cannot be
more than one decree or operative orders governing the same subjectmatter at a given point of time. When a decree or order passed by an
inferior court, tribunal or authority was subjected to a remedy available
under the law before a superior forum then, though the decree or order
under challenge continues to be effective and binding, nevertheless its
finality is put in jeopardy. Once the superior court has disposed of the lis
before it either way -- whether the decree or order under appeal is set
aside or modified or simply confirmed, it is the decree or order of the
superior court, tribunal or authority which is the final, binding and
operative decree or order wherein merges the decree or order passed by
the court, tribunal or the authority below. However, the doctrine is not of
universal or unlimited application. The nature of jurisdiction exercised
by the superior forum and the content or subject-matter of challenge laid
or which could have been laid shall have to be kept in view"
[16]
In a case of Sarguja Transport Service vs. State Transport
Appellate Tribunal M.P., Gwalior and others, reported in (1987) 1 SCC 5, the
Apex Court has considered withdrawal of the writ petition filed before the High
Court itself. The Court has held as under:"9. The point for consideration is whether a petitioner after withdrawing
a writ petition filed by him in the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India without the permission to institute a fresh petition
can file a fresh writ petition in the High Court under that article. On this
point the decision in Daryao case (Daryao Vs. State of U.P., AIR 1961
SC 1457) is of no assistance. But we are of the view that the principle
underlying Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the Code should be extended in the
interests of administration of justice to cases of withdrawal of writ
petition also, not on the ground of res judicata but on the ground of
public policy as explained above. It would also discourage the litigant
from indulging in bench-hunting tactics. In any event there is no
justifiable reason in such a case to permit a petitioner to invoke the
extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution once again. While the withdrawal of a writ petition filed in
a High Court without permission to file a fresh writ petition may not bar
other remedies like a suit or a petition under Article 32 of the
Constitution of India since such withdrawal does not amount to res
judicata, the remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
should be deemed to have been abandoned by the petitioner in respect of
the cause of action relied on in the writ petition when he withdraws it
without such permission. In the instant case the High Court was right in
holding that a fresh writ petition was not maintainable before it in
respect of the same subject-matter since the earlier writ petition had
been withdrawn without permission to file a fresh petition. We, however,
make it clear that whatever we have stated in this order may not be
considered as being applicable to a writ petition involving the personal
liberty of an individual in which the petitioner prays for the issue of a
writ in the nature of habeas corpus or seeks to enforce the fundamental
rignt guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution since such a case
stands on a different footing altogether. We, however leave this question
open".
[17]
We find that even in the matter of exercise of an original
jurisdiction, the High Court under Article-226 of the Constitution, it has been
held that the principle underlying Rule 1 of Order XXIII of the Civil Procedure
Code should be extended in the interests of administration of justice to cases of
withdrawal of writ petition also, not on the ground of res judicata but on the
ground of public policy. Still further, in view of the judgment in
Kunhayammed & Others (supra), even a non speaking order leads to merger.
Therefore, the withdrawal of appeal will bar the appellant to challenge the same
order again.
[18]
The dismissal as default can be on account of out of court
settlement or threat by the court to impose cost for abuse or abandonment of
the claim by the party on other grounds. Whatever be, the suit is no longer in
existence as it is withdrawn but a fresh claim cannot be brought in because the
court has not permitted the party file fresh suit, as a condition of withdrawl. But
if the withdrawal is with court’s permission on account of some formal defect,
then the court will allow the party to bring in fresh suit on the same subject.
[19]
It is common knowledge that when the writ petition is being
heard by the Court for some time and the petitioner or his counsel thinks that
the Court is not convinced and the petition is likely to be dismissed, then
request is made for withdrawing the writ petition without seeking permission to
file fresh writ petition. If the Court hearing the petition was of the opinion that
the petition merits dismissal or is not worth admission, normally does not grant
liberty to the petitioner to file a writ petition, but it may agree to permit the
petitioner to withdraw the petition unconditionally or without granting any
leave to file fresh writ petition. There cannot be any doubt that bar to
maintainability of the subsequent writ petition where no leave of the Court was
sought at the time of withdrawal or dismissal of the first writ petition was on
account of public policy and the principles flowing from Order-XXIII, Rule-1
Code of Civil Procedure.
[20]
We are of the considered opinion that if the second writ petition
had been dismissed by the High Court by a non-speaking order or on oral
request or on written request, if the petitioners wants to withdraw the writ
petition, no reason on the merits of the case is required in such a situation.
However, if permission had been granted by the Court to the petitioner to
withdraw the writ petition without granting any leave of the Court to file fresh
writ petition, the third writ petition against the self same order by adding more
reliefs and taking recourse to legal proceedings over and over again, would be
against public policy, and would amount to abuse of the process of the court.
[21]
The point for consideration is whether a petitioner after
withdrawing a writ petition filed by him in the High Court under Art. 226 of
the Constitution of India without the permission to institute a fresh petition can
file a fresh writ petition in the High Court under that Article. But we are of the
view that the principle underlying Rule-1 of Order- XXIII of the Code should
be extended in the interests of administration of justice to cases of withdrawal
of writ petition also, not on the ground of res judicata but on the ground of
public policy as explained above. It would also discourage the litigant from
indulging in bench-hunting tactics. In any event there is no justifiable reason in
such a case to permit a petitioner to invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of the
High Court under Article- 226 of the Constitution of India, once again.
[22]
While the withdrawal of a writ petition filed in High Court
without permission to file a fresh writ petition may not bar other remedies like
a suit or a petition under Art. 32 of the Constitution since such withdrawal do
not amount to res judicata, the remedy under Art. 226 of the Constitution
should be deemed to have been abandoned by the petitioner in respect of the
cause of action relied on in the writ petition when he withdraws it without such
permission.
[23]
In the instant case a fresh writ appeal is not maintainable before it
in respect of the same subject-matter since the earlier writ petition had been
withdrawn without permission to file a fresh petition. The petitioner to get over
the same has filed another writ petition which was disposed of with the
observation that the petitioner is given liberty to take appropriate steps
including filing the petition seeking review. It is unheard in the writ jurisdiction
how the petitioner can make another writ petition once the writ petition has
been dismissed as withdrawn. Further the petitioner has filed the present writ
appeal seeking a direction to set aside the order passed by the learned Single
Judge in WP(C) No.604 of 2019 dated 20.11.2020.
[24]
Since the same is not maintainable against the writ petition,
wherein it was dismissed as withdrawn, this Court finds that no relief can be
granted to the appellant.
[25]
This kind of litigation cannot be appreciated and this Court in the
present circumstances feels that this appeal be dismissed with costs.
Accordingly, the present writ appeal stands dismissed with cost of Rs.10,000/payable to the Tripura High Court Employees Association. Registry to serve
copy to the President, Tripura High Court Employees Association. As a sequel,
miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review