The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. In my opinion, this is not a case where the petitioner had to treat and admit his wife Smt. Lipika Das Datta in an emergent situation. The exigency was not at that level that the petitioner could not obtain referral certificate from the standing Medical Board. According to me, since the wife of the petitioner had been suffering from this illness for about 8 years and for the last 3 months before his visiting to Hyderabad there was pain off and on at her abdomen, she could have easily contacted with the Doctors of the Government Hospitals at Agartala for her treatment. The Government instructions regarding reimbursement of petitioner as a Government employee should strictly follow the Government guidelines for medical reimbursement bills. More so, the petitioner could have applied for leave on medical ground but he applied for granting leave on personal affairs w.e.f. 17.12.2019 to 28.12.2019.” [6] Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the order of the learned Single Judge, the appellant has preferred this appeal mainly on the following grounds: (i) The learned Single Judge did not appreciate the fact that due to urgency the appellant could not obtain approval of the standing Medical Board for treatment of his wife in a hospital at Hyderabad. (ii) This Court in the case of Sri Uttam Pal(supra) and in the case of Sri Subal Das(supra) allowed the claim of the petitioners for medical …
25. 10.2013 issued from the Health and Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Tripura claim of the appellant is not admissible and therefore, respondent No.2 under the impugned order dated 08.07.2020 returned the medical reimbursement bill of the appellant. Under the premises aforesaid, the State counsel has urged for dismissing the appeal. [9] We have examined the law laid down by this Court in the case of Sri Uttam Pal(supra) and in the case of Sri Subal Das(supra) which have been cited by the counsel of the appellant in order to nourish his contention. In the case of Sri Uttam Pal(supra) the petitioner was serving as an Executive Engineer in PWD who suffered from stroke twice on
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 10
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A No. 01 of 2022
Sri Pradip Datta
Son of late Manindra Chandra Datta, Vill- Chhanban, P.O.
Rajarbag, Udaipur, Gomati District, Pin- 799120,
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary-cum-Commissioner, Education
Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura.
2.
The Director of Secondary Education,
Government of Tripura, P.O. Agartala, West Tripura, Pin799001
3.
The District Education Officer,
Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura
4.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary-Cum-Commissioner to
Government of Tripura, Finance Department, New Capital
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, Agartala, Dist-West Tripura.
----- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. A. Acharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. K. Deb, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
ORDER
07/03/2022
(S.G. Chattopadhyay, J)
The present appeal has been preferred against the judgment
and order dated 26.07.2021 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P(C)
Page - 2 of 10
No.234 of 2021 whereby the learned Single Judge declined to interfere
with the order dated 08.07.2020 (Annexure-C) of the State respondents
refusing to entertain appellant’s claim for reimbursement of the medical
expenses incurred by him for treatment of his wife at Hyderabad. The short
question which arises for our consideration in this appeal is whether the
appellant in the given fact situation is entitled to reimbursement of medical
expenses incurred by him for undertaking the treatment of his wife in a
hospital of his choice at Hyderabad without being referred by the standing
Medical Board, AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala.
[2]
The factual backgrounds of the case are as under:
Appellant who is a Headmaster in Murapara High School in
Gomati District visited Hyderabad in two spells along with his wife,
Lipika Das (Datta) and daughter, Ms. Sanchalika Datta for treatment of
Sanchalika following medical advice and incurred huge expenses for
undertaking the to and fro air journey between Agartala and Hyderabad
and treatment of his daughter. He had undertaken the first journey to
Hyderabad on 05.10.2019 along with his daughter for her treatment in
Asian Institute of Gastroenterology and returned to Agartala on 13.10.2019
after her treatment. He again visited Hyderabad along with his wife and
daughter on 19.12.2019 for review of the health condition of her daughter
and follow up treatment. They had also booked return tickets in flight for
their return journey to Agartala but suddenly his wife fell ill. She was
Page - 3 of 10
immediately admitted in the Asian Institute of Gastroenterology at
Hyderabad where she was diagnosed with calculus in her right kidney.
Immediate surgical intervention became necessary for removal of the
calculus from her kidney. Accordingly, various diagnostic tests of the wife
of the appellant were done in the hospital and she had undergone surgery
in the said hospital for removal of the calculus from her kidney. Having
returned to Agartala, the appellant submitted his claim for reimbursement
of Rs.1,15,837/- incurred by him for the treatment of his wife at
Hyderabad and a separate claim for reimbursement of the expenses for
treatment of his daughter was also submitted by the appellant. Under
communication No. F.7(2-14)-SE/ACCT/2020/1787 dated 08.07.2020
appellant was informed by the State respondent No.2 that his claim of
reimbursement of Rs.1,15,837/- for treatment of his wife at Hyderabad
was examined in the Health Department and it was found that the claim
was not admissible in terms of G.O No.236/RT/2013 dated 25.10.2013
issued from the Health and Family Welfare Department, Govt. of Tripura
as the appellant had undertaken the treatment of his wife at the Asian
Institute of Nephrology & Urology at Hyderabad without being referred
by the standing Medical Board, Agartala. Appellant pleaded that his wife
required immediate surgical intervention and there was no time for
obtaining a referral certificate from the standing Medical Board, Agartala.
Appellant claimed that as a gazetted officer he was entitled to medical
Page - 4 of 10
reimbursement and TA and DA for undertaking to and fro air journey
between Agartala and Hyderabad for the treatment of his wife and
daughter.
[3]
Counsel appearing for the appellant argued before the learned
Single Judge that appellant’s wife was admitted in the hospital at
Hyderabad in an emergent situation and immediate surgery was advised by
her doctors for removal of her kidney stone to save her life. Counsel
further argued before the learned Single Judge that in similar
circumstances this High Court in the case of Uttam Pal Vrs. The State of
Tripura and others [W.P(c) No.1479 of 2017] and in the case of Sri Subal
Das Vrs. The State of Tripura and others [W.P(c) No.895 of 2018]
allowed the claim of the petitioners for medical reimbursement for
undertaking their treatment outside the State without being referred by the
standing Medical Board. Counsel, therefore, urged before the learned
Single Judge to allow the claim of the appellant and issue direction to the
State respondents to approve the medical reimbursement bill submitted by
him.
[4]
The State counsel on the other hand argued before the leaned
Single Judge that claim of the appellant was not admissible in view of the
notification dated 25.10.2013 issued from the Health and Family Welfare
Department, Govt. of Tripura as the appellant had undertaken treatment of
Page - 5 of 10
his wife in a hospital at Hyderabad without reference from the standing
Medical Board. The State counsel further argued that there was no medical
emergency which necessitated immediate surgery of the wife of the
appellant at Hyderabad because the clinical documents produced by the
appellant would show that his wife was having symptoms of the disease
for the last eight years and her situation aggravated during the last three
months and, as such, the appellant had enough time to obtain a referral
certificate from the standing Medical Board, AGMC and GBP Hospital,
Agartala.
[5]
The learned Single Judge examined the ratio decided by this
Court in the judgments cited by the counsel of the appellant and on
appreciation of the facts and circumstances of the case and the arguments
advanced by the counsel of the parties came to the conclusion that the
appellant failed to justify his claim that due to emergent situation he had
undertaken the treatment of his wife at Hyderabad without obtaining a
referral certificate from the standing Medical Board, AGMC and GBP
Hospital, Agartala. The relevant extract of the findings of the learned
Single Judge is reproduced hereunder:
“6. Mr. Acharjee, learned counsel for the petitioner has
pressed into service as many as two judgments passed by
this Court in WP(C) 1479/2017, titled as Uttam Pal Vrs.
State of Tripura and in WP(C) No.895/2018, titled as
Subal Das Vrs. State of Tripura.
Page - 6 of 10
Having perused those judgments, according to
me, those judgments do not have any relevance to
consider the facts of the present case.
7.
In my opinion, this is not a case where the
petitioner had to treat and admit his wife Smt. Lipika Das
Datta in an emergent situation. The exigency was not at
that level that the petitioner could not obtain referral
certificate from the standing Medical Board. According
to me, since the wife of the petitioner had been suffering
from this illness for about 8 years and for the last 3
months before his visiting to Hyderabad there was pain
off and on at her abdomen, she could have easily
contacted with the Doctors of the Government Hospitals
at Agartala for her treatment. The Government
instructions regarding reimbursement of petitioner as a
Government employee should strictly follow the
Government guidelines for medical reimbursement bills.
More so, the petitioner could have applied for leave on
medical ground but he applied for granting leave on
personal affairs w.e.f. 17.12.2019 to 28.12.2019.”
[6]
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the order of the learned
Single Judge, the appellant has preferred this appeal mainly on the
following grounds:
(i)
The learned Single Judge did not appreciate the fact
that due to urgency the appellant could not obtain approval of
the standing Medical Board for treatment of his wife in a
hospital at Hyderabad.
(ii)
This Court in the case of Sri Uttam Pal(supra) and in
the case of Sri Subal Das(supra) allowed the claim of the
petitioners for medical reimbursement who had undertaken
treatment in Apollo Hospital outside the State without being
referred by the standing Medical Board and following the
Page - 7 of 10
principle of parity the learned Single Judge should have
allowed the claim of the appellant in the instant case.
[7]
Appearing for the appellant, Mr. A. Acharjee, learned counsel
has argued before us that even though approval of the standing Medical
Board is necessary for treatment outside the State, it is not always possible
due to urgency like in the present case to obtain a referral certificate from
the standing Medical Board. Counsel has argued that appellant’s wife was
admitted in a hospital in Hyderabad in an emergent situation to relieve her
from acute pain and save her life. Counsel submits that in such fact
situation the State respondent should not have denied medical
reimbursement to the appellant for the treatment of his wife at Hyderabad.
Counsel has argued that learned Single Judge did not appreciate the fact
that it was not possible for the appellant to come back to Agartala and take
reference from the standing Medical Board before undertaking the
treatment of his wife whose condition was alarming. Counsel, therefore,
urge the Court to set aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge.
[8]
The State counsel on the other hand reiterated the arguments
which were advanced by him before the learned Single Judge. It is argued
by the learned State counsel that appellant could not produce any material
to justify his claim that due to emergency he failed to take approval from
the standing Medical Board. Counsel argued that the medical documents
Page - 8 of 10
produced by the appellant would clearly demonstrate that his wife had
symptoms of the disease for the preceding eight years and moreover
before proceeding to Hyderabad the appellant did not even make any
intimation to the department that he was going to Hyderabad for medical
purpose. He obtained leave on the ground of personal affairs and
proceeded to Hyderabad. Counsel argued that the appellant had ample
opportunity to approach the standing Medical Board for obtaining a
referral certificate before proceeding to Hyderabad for treatment of his
wife. According to the State counsel, in view of the notification dated
25.10.2013 issued from the Health and Family Welfare Department, Govt.
of Tripura claim of the appellant is not admissible and therefore,
respondent No.2 under the impugned order dated 08.07.2020 returned the
medical reimbursement bill of the appellant. Under the premises aforesaid,
the State counsel has urged for dismissing the appeal.
[9]
We have examined the law laid down by this Court in the case
of Sri Uttam Pal(supra) and in the case of Sri Subal Das(supra) which
have been cited by the counsel of the appellant in order to nourish his
contention. In the case of Sri Uttam Pal(supra) the petitioner was serving
as an Executive Engineer in PWD who suffered from stroke twice on
15.02.2017 during the performance of his duties in office. He was flown to
Fortis Hospital in Kolkata after initial treatment in AGMC and GBP
Hospital in emergent situation and there was hardly any opportunity for his
Page - 9 of 10
family members to obtain a referral certificate from the State Medical
Board. In this peculiar fact situation, this Court interfered with the order
of the State respondents and directed the State respondents to reimburse
his medical expenses with interest. Similarly, in the case of Sri Subal
Das(supra), wife of the petitioner was taken to Apollo Hospital, Chennai
after she complaint of severe chest pain and breathing problem. She was
diagnosed with lung cancer for which she underwent lung operation in the
hospital. Court found that there was no time for the petitioner who was a
member of Tripura State Rifles (TSR) to obtain a referral certificate from
the State Medical Board due to emergent situation. The State respondents
were, therefore, directed by this Court to reimburse the medical expenses
of the petitioner for undertaking the treatment of his wife at Apollo
Hospital, Chennai without a referral certificate from the standing Medical
Board.
[10]
The fact situation of the present case is completely different.
Learned Single Judge has recorded a categorical finding that the exigency
was not at that level that the petitioner could not obtain referral certificate
from the standing Medical Board. We have also examined the medical
documents produced by the appellant in support of his claim. Apparently,
the wife of the appellant had symptoms of the disease for the preceding
eight years which aggravated during last three months. Therefore, neither
the appellant nor his wife was unaware of her problems before proceeding
Page - 10 of 10
to Hyderabad. They could have approached the State Medical Board for
obtaining a referral certificate from the Medical Board for her treatment at
Hyderabad. In this fact situation, we do not find any ground to disagree
with the findings of the learned Single Judge, Resultantly, the appeal
stands dismissed.
[11]
In terms of the above, the appeal stands disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Dipankar
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review