The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. On perusal of the aforesaid Sub-Rule 2 of Rule 8 and also on perusal of record, it appears that in the given case, the appellant-plaintiffs did not obtain the consent from all the members of the SMC of the school before filing the suit. Even, no leave of the Court was obtained at the time of filing of the suit. Furthermore, no public notice was given by the appellant-plaintiffs before filing of the suit. So, in such a situation, it appears that although the Learned Trial Court below decided issue Nos.3, 4 and 5 in favour of the appellant-plaintiffs but decided the issue Nos.1 and 2 against the appellant-plaintiffs and ultimately, dismissed the suit. Similarly, the Learned First Appellate Court also after elaborate discussions concurred the finding of the Learned Trial Court below, for which I do not find any scope to interfere with the findings of the Learned First Appellate Court in this present appeal. The substantial question of law is accordingly answered against the appellant of this appeal.
17. In the result, the appeal filed by the present appellants is hereby dismissed on contest with costs. The judgment and decree dated 17.08.2022 and 22.08.2022 respectively, passed by Learned District Judge, Unakoti District, Kailashahar in T.A. 02 of 2020 affirming the judgment and decree dated 02.12.2019 and 06.12.2019 respectively delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Kailashahar, Unakoti District in connection with case No. TS 2 of 2019 is hereby affirmed and accordingly, it is upheld. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands disposed of. Prepare decree accordingly and send down the LCRs. 2024.04.02 18:16:05 BHATTACHARJEE Date: +05'30' Purnita
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA NO.53 of 2022
1. Sri Pradip Chanda,
S/O Lt. Probodh Kr. Chanda,
R/O-village-Bhabatarini Mandir Road, Kumarghat,
P.O & P.S- Kumarghat, District- Unakoti Tripura
2. Sri Indu Bhusan Majumder,
S/O- Lt. Jamini Kr. Majumder,
R/O-village-Nidevi, Kumarghat,
P.O & P.S- Kumarghat, District- Unakoti, Tripura
… The Appellants
Versus
1. Sri Jadu Lal Roy,
S/o Lt. Chitta Ranjan Roy,
R/O-village & P.O- Kanchanbari,
District-Unakoti, Tripura,
PIN-799288
2. Sri Bimal Kanti Dhar,
S/O- Lt. Bonomali Dhar,
R/O-Nidevi, Kumarghat (Near Nivedita Children school),
P.O & P.S- Kumarghat,
District-Unakoti, Tripura (Asstt. Teacher of Nivedita Children
School)
3. Sri Sumon Chanda,
S/O- Lt. Subodh Chanda,
R/O-Vill-Kumarghat (Near S.E Office Complex),
P.O & P.S- Kumarghat,
District-Unakoti, Tripura (I/C Principal of Nivedita Children
School).
4. Smt. Aparna Paul,
W/o- Sri Ashit Deb,
R/O-Village-Kumarghat (near Municipal Council Office),
P.O & P.S- Kumarghat,
District- Unakoti, Tripura (Assistant Teacher of Nivedita
Children School)
5. Sri Rabindra Debnath,
S/O- Sri Nirode Debnath,
R/O-Village- Halaimura, Kumarghat,
P.O & P.S- Kumarghat,
District- Unakoti, Tripura (Assistant Teacher of Nivedita
Children School).
… The Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H. Laskar, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
14.03.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
28.03.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred challenging the judgment
and decree dated 17.08.2022 and 22.08.2022 respectively,
passed
by
Learned
District
Judge,
Unakoti
District,
Kailashahar in T.A. 02 of 2020. By the said judgment, the
Learned District Judge upheld the judgment and decree of
the Learned Trial Court.
02.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. P. Roy.
Barman assisted by Mr. Samarjit Bhattacharjee, Learned
Counsel for the appellant and also heard Mr. H. Laskar,
Learned Counsel for the respondent-defendant.
03.
Before proceeding with the merit of the appeal, let
us discuss the subject matter of the dispute cropped up
amongst the parties for which the suit was preferred by the
appellant-plaintiffs before the Learned Trial Court.
The short campus of the case of the appellantplaintiffs before the Learned Trial Court was that one
‘Nivedita Children School’ has been running by the School
Management Committee of the appellant-plaintiffs and the
plaintiffs No.1 and 2 are the President and Secretary of the
SMC of the said school and one Gouri Shankar Majumder,
the then president of that school used to maintain the
custody of materials of the school and he also used to
maintain the management of the school. But on his death, a
meeting was held on 26.12.2017 and in the said meeting
temporary responsibility was given to the defendants for the
custody of the material and for management and running of
the school with a condition to return the custody of the
material and management of the school by 31.03.2018 to
the plaintiffs, SMC, but on demand by the plaintiffs SMC on
31.03.2018, 21.05.2019 and 10.09.2019 the respondentdefendants failed to return the same and started to deny and
avoid the running and activities of plaintiffs SMC. Hence, the
appellant-plaintiffs filed the suit before the Court of Learned
Civil Judge, Senior Division, which was numbered as T.S.02
of 2019.
04.
That the respondent-defendants contested the
suit by filing written statement denying the plea of the
appellant-plaintiffs and pleaded that the appellant-plaintiffs
No.1 and 2 falsely claimed themselves as the Secretary and
President of SMC of Nivedita Children School and the
plaintiffs have no right to file the suit as they were not the
Secretary and President and also the appellant-plaintiffs had
no right to represent the SMC. Further, it was also denied
that, on 26.12.2017 a meeting was held of SMC on the death
of Gouri Shankar Majumder and temporary arrangement was
made and defendants were entrusted with the duty and
responsibility for temporary period as claimed by the
appellant-plaintiffs.
Rather,
the
respondent-defendants
pleaded that in the year 2012, a new School Managing
Committee was formed and one Gouri Shankar Majumder
was
appointed
President
and
Pradip
Chanda,
i.e.
the
appellant-plaintiff No.2 became the Secretary but the said
committee was not formed as per Right To Education Act,
2009 and as cashier Ranu Singha resigned, in his place one
Sudipta Sinha became cashier and Pradip Chanda, the
Secretary used to come regularly for collection of cash
money from the school and the account of the school was
maintained properly. But in the year 2014, President Gouri
Shankar Majumder expelled the Cashier and Secretary and
Gouri Shankar Majumder himself took the responsibility of
Secretary and Cashier of the school and on 23.12.2017 said
Gouri Shankar Majumder died and as per decision of the
guardian, Teacher’s Council and well wishers, the teachers of
the school took the responsibility of admission of the
students and accepting the tuition fees
etc. and the
defendant No.1 was appointed administrator of the school
w.e.f. 16.01.2017 and as per deputation of the guardian and
parents of the students, a resolution was taken in the
meeting held under the President-ship of the administrator,
i.e. the respondent-defendant No.1 and thereafter under RTE
Act 2009 on 07.08.2018 a general meeting was held with the
guardian of the students, members of the Teacher’s Council,
well-wishers and the people’s representatives and an SMC
was formed and one Paban Paul (guardian of a student) was
appointed chairperson, Dipankar Goswami (parent of another
student) was appointed vice chairperson, Rabindra Debnath
(senior teacher) appointed convener, defendant No.1 was
appointed member and more members were appointed from
the parents, teachers and students and a copy of the
resolution
was
sent
to
District
Education
Officer
who
recognized the said SMC and according to the respondentdefendants, that same SMC had the authority to run the
school and finally they prayed for dismissal of the suit with
costs.
05.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, the following
issues were framed by the Learned Trial Court:
(i) Whether the suit is maintainable?
(ii) Whether the suit is bad for nonjoinder of necessary party?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff No.1 & 2 are
president and secretary of the school
managing committee (SMC) of the
Nibedita Children School, Kumarghat,
English Medium?
(iv) Whether the plaintiffs have right
to maintain, guide and control the
Nibedita Children School?
(v) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled
to the mandatory injunction against
the defendants to hand over and
return the materials to the plaintiffs as
described in the schedule of the
plaint?
(vi) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled
to the decree as prayed for and/or any
other relief/reliefs in this suit?
06.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record:
(A) Plaintiffs' Witnesses :PW.1 Sri Pradip Chanda.
PW.2 Sri Swapan Mitra Talukdar.
PW.3 Sri Indu Bhushan Majumder.
PW.4 Sri Bikasendu Deb.
PW.5 Sri Ranu Sinha.
PW.6 Sri Aswini Sinha. .
PW.7 Sri Rajib Chakraborty.
PW.8 Sri Churachand Sarma.
PW.9 Sri Sunil Chandra Dey.
(B) Plaintiffs' Exhibits :Ext.-1:- Khatian No.98/2.
Ext.2:- Map.
Ext.3:- Resolution dated 02.08.2010.
Ext.4:-
Copy
of
resolution
dated
01.06.2012.
Ext.5:- Letter of appointment dated
28.02.2004.
Ext.6:-
Form
filled
by
Bimal
Kanti
Dhar.
Ext.7:- Letter of appointment dated
01.03.2004.
Ext.8:- Letter by Rabindra Debnath to
the
Secretary,
Nibedita
Children
School.
Ext.9:-
Letter
dated
07.06.2014.
Ext.10:- No objection certificate dated
07.06.2014.
Ext.11:- Certificate dated 07.06.2014.
Ext.12:-
Letter
dated
09.06.2014.
Ext.13:-
Letter
dated
09.06.2014.
Ext.14:- Certificate dated 09.06.2014.
Ext.15:-
Letter
dated
09.06.2014.
Ext.16:-
Letter
dated
18.06.2012.
Ext.17:-
Letter
dated
30.08.2013.
Ext.18:-
Notice
dated
04.08.2014.
Ext.19:-
Recognition
memo
dated
08.07.2008.
Ext.20:- Resolution dated 02.08.2010.
Ext.21:- Application dated 30.11.2010.
Ext.22:-
Letter
of
appointment
of
appointment
of
Suman Chanda.
Ext.23:-
Letter
of
Suman
Chanda
dated
Ext.24:-
Bank
Pass
Deposit
Slip.
Ext.25:-
Bank
Pass
Book
A/C
10.03.2003.
of
No.8085012206665.
Ext.26:- Another Bank Pass Book of
same account number.
Ext.27:-
Sale
deed
No.1-328 dated
01.03.2002.
Ext.28:-
Letter
dated
21.05.2018.
Ext.29:- Letter of instruction dated
10.09.2018.
Ext.30:- Resolution dated 26.12.2017.
Ext.31:- Code of conduct.
Ext.32:- Resolution dated 25.06.2016.
Ext.33:- Resolution dated 06.01.2019.
Ext.34:-
Letter
dated
31.03.2018.
Ext.35:- Khatian No.1703.
Ext.36:- Sale deed No.1-1532 dated
02.11.2010.
Ext.37:-
Advocate
notice
and
its
enclosure dated 03.01.2019.
Ext.38:- Postal receipts and AD card.
Ext.39:-
Letter
dated
25.01.2019.
Ext.40:- Trust deed No.IV-0007 dated
21.01.2019.
Ext.41:- Resolution book of SMC of
Nibedita Children School.
Ext.42:- Resolution book of SMC of
Nibedita Children School.
(C) Defendant's Witnesses :DW.1 Sri Rabindra Debnath.
DW.2 Sri Jadulal Roy.
DW.3 Sri Paban Paul.
DW.4 Smt. Sima Dey.
DW.5 Sri Dipankar Goswami.
(D) Defendant's Exhibits :Ext.A:- Letter dated 25.05.2018 along
with
enclosure
28.03.2018.
letter
dated
Ext.B:- Letter dated 10.08.2018 along
with enclosure.
Ext.C:-
Letter
dated
Ext.D:-
Resolution
28.01.2019.
book
of
SMC
Nibedita Children School, Kumarghat.
07.
Finally after hearing argument of both the sides,
Learned Trial Court
below delivered the judgment on
02.12.2019. The operative portion of the order of the
judgment runs as follows:
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiff
is dismissed on contest with cost.
The suit is disposed of on contest with
cost.
Make necessary entry in the relevant
Trial Register.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up
before me for signature within 15
(fifteen) days from today latest on
17.12.2019.”
08.
Challenging that judgment of Learned Trial Court,
the appellant-plaintiffs preferred an appeal under Section 96
of CPC before the Court of Learned District Judge, Unakoti
District, Kailashahar which was numbered as T.A. No.02 of
2020 and after hearing argument of both the sides, Learned
First
Appellate
17.08.2022
and
Court
by
judgment
22.08.2022
and
respectively
decree
dated
dismissed
the
appeal of the plaintiff-appellants and uphold the judgment of
the Learned Trial Court.
09.
For the sake of convenience, I would like to
mention herein below the operative portion of the order of
Learned First Appellate Court which is as follows:
“In the result, the plaintiff-appellants
are not entitled to get any relief.
Hence, the appeal is dismissed.
The judgment and decree passed by
the learned trial court is upheld.
Prepare appellate decree accordingly.
Send down the LCR along with a copy
of this judgment.
The
case
stands
accordingly.”
10.
disposed
of
Being dissatisfied with the judgment and decree
delivered by the Learned First Appellate Court in T.A.02 of
2020, the appellant-plaintiffs again preferred this appeal
under Section 100 of CPC before the High Court. At the time
of admission of the appeal by order dated 05.04.2023
following substantial question of law was framed:
“Whether the suit is barred by the principle of nonjoinder of necessary parties?”
11.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned
Senior Counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman for the appellants drawn
the attention of the Court that both the Courts below have
committed serious error in dismissing the suit and appeal on
the ground of non-joinder of necessary parties, which
according to Learned Senior Counsel was nothing but a clear
misconception of fact and law, because the appellantplaintiffs in the plaint had narrated the entire assertions but
the Learned Court below considering the evidence on record
could not appreciate the evidence properly and came to an
erroneous finding that the suit was bad for non-joinder of
necessary parties and there was no valid reasons to dismiss
the suit on the issue of non-joinder of necessary party.
12.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
Learned First Appellate Court also without remanding back
the case to the Learned Trial Court below for proper
adjudication in accordance with law uphold the judgment of
the Learned Court below on the same ground for which
according to Learned Senior Counsel there are serious
perversity to the judgments of the Court below and prayed
for allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgments of the
Learned Courts below.
13.
Per contra, Learned Counsel for the respondent-
defendant submitted that the Learned Trial Court below after
considering the evidence on record dismissed the suit on the
ground that the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary
party and was not maintainable. Similarly, Learned First
Appellate Court also dismissed the appeal on the same
grounds. So, Learned Counsel for the respondents, at the
conclusion of argument urged for dismissal of this present
appeal and to uphold the judgment of the Learned First
Appellate Court as well as the Learned Trial Court. Since the
crux question in this appeal is regarding dismissal of suit for
non-joinder of necessary party, so, here we are to see as to
whether the judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court
upholding the judgment of the Learned Trial Court is
perverse or not.
14.
I have gone through the records of the Learned
Court below and also perused the evidence on record both
oral/documentary. It appears that, the Learned Trial Court
below came to an observation that the leave of the Court
was not obtained by the appellant-plaintiffs as required
under Order 1, Rule 8 of C.P.C. Even, according to the
Learned Trial Court, no public notice was given by the
appellant-plaintiffs before filing of the suit and more so, as
the appellant-plaintiffs did not obtain leave of the Court prior
to filing the suit, so, the suit was not maintainable. The
Learned First Appellate Court also took the similar view.
15.
For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the relevant provision of Order I, Rule 8 of
C.P.C. which is enumerated below:
“8. One person may sue or defend on
behalf of all in same interest.—(1)
Where there are numerous persons
having the same interest in one suit,—
(a) one or more of such persons may,
with the permission of the Court, sue
or be sued, or may defend such suit,
on behalf of, or for the benefit of, all
persons so interested;
(b) the Court may direct that one or
more of such persons may sue or be
sued, or may defend such suit, on
behalf of, or for the benefit of, all
persons so interested.
(2) The Court shall, in every case
where a permission or direction is
given under sub-rule (1), at the
plaintiff's expense, give notice of the
institution of the suit to all persons so
interested, either by personal service,
or, where, by reason of the number of
persons or any other cause, such
service is not reasonably practicable,
by public advertisement, as the Court
in each case may direct.
(3) Any person on whose behalf, or for
whose benefit, a suit is instituted, or
defended, under sub-rule (1), may
apply to the Court to be made a party
to such suit.
(4) No part of the claim in any such
suit shall be abandoned under sub-
rule (1), and no such suit shall be
withdrawn under sub-rule (3), of rule
1 of Order XXIII, and no agreement,
compromise or satisfaction shall be
recorded in any such suit under rule 3
of that Order, unless the Court has
given, at the plaintiff's expense notice
to all persons so interested in the
manner specified in sub-rule (2).
(5) Where any person suing or
defending in any such suit does not
proceed with due diligence in the suit
or defence, the Court may substitute
in his place any other person having
the same interest in the suit.
(6) A decree passed in a suit under
this rule shall be binding on all
persons on whose behalf, or for whose
benefit, the suit is instituted, or
defended, as the case may be.
8A. Power of Court to permit a person
or body of persons to present opinion
or to take part in the proceedings.—
While trying a suit, the Court may, if
satisfied that a person or body of
persons is interested in any question
of
law
which
is
directly
and
substantially in issue in the suit and
that it is necessary in the public
interest to allow that person or body
of persons to present his or its opinion
on that question of law, permit that
person or body of persons to present
such opinion and to take such part in
the proceedings of the suit as the
Court may specify.”
16.
On perusal of the aforesaid Sub-Rule 2 of Rule 8
and also on perusal of record, it appears that in the given
case, the appellant-plaintiffs did not obtain the consent from
all the members of the SMC of the school before filing the
suit. Even, no leave of the Court was obtained at the time of
filing of the suit. Furthermore, no public notice was given by
the appellant-plaintiffs before filing of the suit. So, in such a
situation, it appears that although the Learned Trial Court
below decided issue Nos.3, 4 and 5 in favour of the
appellant-plaintiffs but decided the issue Nos.1 and 2 against
the appellant-plaintiffs and ultimately, dismissed the suit.
Similarly, the Learned First Appellate Court also
after elaborate discussions concurred the finding of the
Learned Trial Court below, for which I do not find any scope
to interfere with the findings of the Learned First Appellate
Court in this present appeal. The substantial question of law
is accordingly answered against the appellant of this appeal.
17.
In the result, the appeal filed by the present
appellants is hereby dismissed on contest with costs. The
judgment and decree dated 17.08.2022 and 22.08.2022
respectively, passed by Learned District Judge, Unakoti
District, Kailashahar in T.A. 02 of 2020 affirming the
judgment and decree dated 02.12.2019 and 06.12.2019
respectively
delivered
by
Learned
Civil
Judge,
Senior
Division, Kailashahar, Unakoti District in connection with
case No. TS 2 of 2019 is hereby affirmed and accordingly, it
is upheld.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stands
disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly and send down the
LCRs.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
2024.04.02 18:16:05
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
+05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review