Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
FA NO.03 OF 2021
Sri Pintu Deb,
Son of Late Pabitra Chandra Deb,
Resident of Bishalgarh, P.S.- Bishalgarh,
District- Sepahijala, aged about-47 years,
By profession- Business, by faith Hindu,
Citizen of India
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Smt. Basana Bala Deb,
Wife of Late Pabirta Chandra Deb,
Resident of Bishalgarh, P.S.- Bishalgarh,
District- Sepahijala.
2. Sri Biplab Deb,
Son of Late Pabirta Chandra Deb,
C/o Partha Roy, Resident of Santipara,
P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura.
3. Smt. Ajanta Deb(Banik),
Wife of Sri Jantu Banik,
Daughter of Late Pabitra Chandra Deb,
Resident of Ashram Road, P.S.- East Agartala,
District- West Tripura.
4. Smt. Sumanta Deb,
Wife of Ratan Deb(Banik),
Daughter of Late Pabitra Chandra Deb,
Resident of Konaban, P.S.- Bishalgarh,
District- Sepahijala.
……. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. N. Chowdhury, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
CO(FA) NO.3 OF 2022
1. Sri Biplab Deb,
S/o- Late Pabirta Chandra Deb,
Flat No.1, Bastu Infrustructure, Old
Motorstand, Annapurna Goli, P.S.- East Agartala,
District- West Tripura.
2. Smt. Ajanta Deb(Banik),
W/o Sri Jantu Banik, D/o- Late Pabitra Chandra Deb,
Resident of- Jail Ashram Road, P.S.- East Agartala,
District- West Tripura.
……… Respondent-Cross Objector(s)
Vs.
1. Sri Pintu Deb,
S/o Late Pabitra Chandra Deb,
P.O & P.S. Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala.
………Plaintiff-Appellant-Respondent(s)
2. Smt. Basana Bala Deb,
W/o- Late Pabitra Chandra Deb,
P.O. & P.S. Bishalgarh, District- Sepahijala.
3. Smt. Sumanta Deb, W/o Sri Ratan Deb(Banik),
D/o Late Pabirta Chandra Deb,
Resident of Kunaban, P.S.- Madhupur,
(Previously- Bishalgarh P.S.) District- Sepahijala.
………..Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N. Chowudhury, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
19.04.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 27.04.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Both this appeal and cross objection are tagged,
heard, and taken up together for disposal since they arise from
a common Judgment and Award dated 08.07.2020 passed in
T.S. (Probate)02 of 2015
2.
The brief fact of the case is that the
appellant
herein Sri. Pintu Deb filed an application under Section-276 of
the Indian Succession Act, 1956, praying for granting Probate of
Registered WILL No.III - 13 of 2012 dated 21.02.2012 executed
by his father Pabitra Ch. Deb (since deceased) S/o Late. Prafulla
Chandra Deb, resident of Bishalgarh, P.S. Bishalgarh, SubDivision-Sepahijala and Sub- Registry – Bishalgarh. It is stated
in the said petition that Lt. Pabitra Ch. Deb was a Hindu and
governed by Hindu Succession Act. In that petition, the
appellant herein has made Smt. Basana Bala Deb, W/o. Lt.
Pabitra Ch. Deb, Sri. Biplab Deb, S/o. Lt. Pabitra Deb, Smt.
Ajanta Deb (Banik), D/o. Of Lt. Pabitra Ch. Deb and Smt.
Sumanta Deb, as respondents. It is stated in the petition that
Pabitra Ch. Deb, S/o. Lt. Prafulla Ch. Deb was his father and
died
on
13.07.2013,
leaving
the
appellant
and
opposite
parties/respondents as his legal heirs. Prior to his death, Pabitra
Ch. Deb (since deceased) S/o. Lt. Prafulla Ch. Deb, the resident
of Bishalgarh, executed the registered WILL No.III-13 of 2012
dt.21.02.2012, being in sound mind by which, 21 satak of land
classified as ―vitti (Naal)‖ & ―Dokan (Naal), appertaining to
Sabek daag nos.3565/ 15539 (P), 3565/15539 (P) & 7864,
corresponding to R.S. plot nos.5709, 5710/12876 & 6666,
recorded under khatian No.331, Touji No.3519 of MoujaBishalgarh, Sub- Division Bishalgarh, District Sepahijala, was
bequeathed in favour of the appellant herein i.e. Sri Pintu Deb.
It was also stated in the petition that property contained in the
WILL is within the jurisdiction of the Court and likely to be
valued at Rs.10,00,000/- and that no application was made in
any other Court for grant of Probate and that at the time of his
death, the deceased had a fixed abode within the jurisdiction of
Court below. The appellant herein, therefore, prayed to grant a
certificate of the Probate in respect of the WILL.
3.
On receipt of the petition, the same was
registered as Misc.(Probate)05 of 2013. Notices were served
upon all the opposite parties/respondents and in response to the
said notices, except opposite party no.1, Smt. Basana Bala Deb,
all other opposite parties have made their appearance before
the Court and the case proceeded ex-parte against the opposite
party
Smt.
Basana
Bala
Deb
vide
this
Court's
Order
dt.27.04.2019.
4.
In response, the opposite party no.2 to 4 therein
have submitted written statement raising their objection against
granting Probate to the appellant by taking the plea that the
petition is not legally maintainable and averments made in the
petition are denied in the objection. It is stated in the written
statement that the contents of the WILL is not genuine. It is also
stated by the opposite parties therein that Lt. Pabitra Ch. Deb
was their father and no WILL has been executed by their father
as
alleged,
whereby
he
bequeathed
his
landed
property
measuring 21 Sataks in favour of the appellant by depriving
them and without their consent as he loved them very much.
Hence, the opposite parties pray for the dismissal of the suit
with cost.
5.
It appears from the record that no issues were
framed in that case, but the witnesses were examined and
cross-examined
accordingly.
So,
for
the
convenience
discussion, the following issues were formulated:-
of
“(i) Whether the Probate proceeding is maintainable in
law?
(ii) Whether the Will dt.21.02.2012 registered on the
same date was only executed by Pabitra Ch. Deb with sound mind and
health?
(iii) Whether the petitioner is entitled to get Probate of
the aforesaid Will dt.21.02.2012?”
6.
In the course of the trial, to prove his case, the
petitioner-appellant has examined three witnesses including
himself, and exhibited some documents. They were duly crossexamined by the opposite parties. On the other hand, the
opposite parties did not adduce any evidence either oral or
documentary in support of their Case.
7.
The learned Court below heard the arguments of
both the parties and held that the appellant-petitioner has
sufficiently proved the execution of WILL by the testator in his
sound mind and health. The Court below found the evidence of
P.W.2 and P.W.3 reliable and trustworthy, so far as the
signature made by the deceased Pabirta Chandra Deb is
concerned, the learned Court below opined that the respondents
fail to bring out any suspicious circumstance surrounding the
execution of the WILL by the testator and the issues were
answered in affirmative and in favour of the appellant. But the
Court below dismissed the prayer of the appellant for grant of
probate in view of the findings of issue no.(i). The operative
portion of the said Judgment and Order dated 08.07.2020 is
given as under:“In the written statement, the opposite parties took the plea
that the Will is not genuine, rather no Will has been executed by
their father as alleged and that he never did any act without
consulting with them. In spite of the pleadings above, the opposite
parties did not come up in the witness box to support the plea taken
in their written statement. On looking at the evidence of PW-2 and
PW-3 appear that so far the fact of execution of the Will by Pabitra
Ch. Deb is concerned, the opposite parties failed to create any doubt
over the same. The evidence of PW-2 and PW-3 are found reliable
and trustworthy, so far as the signature made by deceased Pabitra
Ch. Deb is concerned. The opposite parties failed to bring out any
suspicious circumstances surrounding the execution of the Will by
the
testator.
Considering all these aspects, I have hold that the petitioner has
sufficiently proved the execution of the Will (Exbt.1) by the testator
in his sound mind and health. As such, the present issue is
answered in affirmative
and in favour of the petitioner.
Issue no.(iii) : I have taken into consideration the discussions
made above and the findings of both the issues and is of the opinion
that the petitioner is not entitled for grant of probate in view of the
findings of the issue no.(i).
The issue no.(iii) is decided accordingly.
ORDER
8. In the result, the petitioner’s prayer for grant of Probate is
hereby dismissed.
8.
Aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree dated 08.07.2020 passed in Title Suit(Probate) No.02 of
2015, the appellant of FA No.03 of 2021 has filed the said
appeal praying to set aside the Judgment and Decree dated
08.07.2020, passed in Title Suit(Probate) No.02 of 2015 and
allow the present appeal.
9.
CO(FA)03 of 2022 has been filed under Order 41
Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the respondent cross
objectors against the Judgment and decree dated 08.07.2020 in
Title Suit(Probate)02 of 2015 passed by learned Addl. District
Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura Agartala.
10.
The
respondents
cross
objectors
are
aggrieved by the findings in Issue No.2 by the Court below,
wherein the Court below held that ― Considering all these
aspects, I have hold that the petitioner has sufficiently proved
the execution of the will (Exbt-1) by the testator in his sound
mind and health." According to the respondents' cross objectors,
the learned Court below should have decided issue No.2 against
the Plaintiff-petitioner-appellant.
11.
Heard
Mr.
N.
Chowdhury,
learned
counsel
appearing for the appellant in F.A. No. 03 of 2021 and for
respondents plaintiff-appellant-respondent in CO(FA) No.03 of
2022. Also heard Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned Sr. counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents in F.A. No.03 of 2021 and respondent cross
objector in CO(FA) No.03 of 2022.
12.
Mr. N. Chowdhury, learned counsel appearing for
the appellant submits that Court below has mis-appreciated the
evidence on record and contents of the WILL and thus came to a
wrong and perverse finding which is not tenable in the eye of
the law. The Trial Court below ought to have considered the
registered WILL No.III dated 21.02.2012(Exbt-1) and other
exhibited documents filed by the appellant and ought to have
granted probate of the said registered WILL. The learned Court
below considered that the respondents failed to bring out any
suspicious circumstance surrounding the execution of the WILL
by the testator. But the learned Court below unfortunately
considered that the appellant is not entitled to grant of probate.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned
Sr. counsel assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents in F.A. No.03 of 2021 and respondent cross
objector in CO(FA) No.03 of 2022 submits that none of the
signatures of the impugned WILL allegedly put by testator
Pabitra Chandra Deb, was identified by any of the witnesses and
accordingly, no signature of the testator was marked as exhibit
by the Trial Court. The signature of the alleged second witness
viz. Babul Debnath on the alleged WILL has not been proved
and marked as an exhibit, even in the entire evidence on record,
there is no whisper about the presence of the second witness. In
the alleged WILL, it was stated by the testator that his younger
son( Respondent No.2 Sri Biplab Deb) resides at a distant place
by constructing his own homestead and by running his own
business, leaving peacefully along with his wife, son, and
daughter. But in the cross-examination, petitioner Sri Pintu Deb,
P.W.1 admitted that his younger brother, Biplab Deb is still
residing in a rented house at Santipara at Agartala. So the
averment made in the alleged WILL that younger son staying
along with his wife, son, and daughter at a distant place by
constructing his own house is false. Another false averment
made by the testator is the alleged WILL is that " the scheduled
property is totally free from all encumbrances", which was
however false, P.W.1 Sri Pintu Deb in his cross-examination
admitted that the property involved in the WILL was under
mortgage to the Indian Overseas Bank as his father took loan
from the Bank by way of mortgaging the landed property
involved in the impugned WILL. He also stated that the said loan
was repaid with the amount received from the Life Insurance
Policy of deceased testator Pabitra Chandra Deb and the residue
small amount was repaid by him to the Bank and accordingly,
he received the Mortgage deed from the Bank. All the natural
heirs (wife, son & daughter) except the propounder i.e. eldest
son P.W.-1 Pintu Deb were excluded from having any share of
the impugned property, the present market value of which
would be not less than 7(seven) crores. Neither wife nor any
friend, or any independent person was attesting witness of the
alleged WILL. Hon'ble Supreme Court in several decisions held
that the mere fact of the WILL being a registered document
does not dispel all suspicion about the validity of the WILL.
14.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
15.
The learned Court below dismissed the prayer of
the appellant for grant of probate in view of the findings of issue
no.i. While deciding the said issue No.i, the Court below held
thus:“Issue no.(i) : These issue relates to maintainability of the
Probate petition. In this Case, the petitioner has filed the petition U/S-276
of the Indian Succession Act for grant of probate claiming that he is the
protector and receiver of the Will (Exbt-1). Section 222(i) of the Indian
Succession Act envisages that Probate shall be granted only to an
“Executor” appointed by the Will concerned. Section 222(ii)
of the Act also provides that appointment may be expressed or by
necessary implication. However, on going through the Will (Exbt-1), it
appears that except making bequeath of the property mentioned in the
schedule in favour of the petitioner, there was no specific mention that the
petitioner Pintu Deb was appointed as executor of the aforesaid Will. There
was even no whisper regarding appointing the petitioner as an executor of
the Will either expressly or impliedly.
Under these circumstances, a petition filed U/S-276 of the
Indian Succession Act for grant of Probate is not maintainable in law. I
therefore, answer this issue in negative and against the petitioner.
16.
After proper perusal of the discussion made in
Issue No.1 of the impugned judgment, this Court finds that the
same is just and proper and is based on material evidence and
in accordance with established norms of law and needs no
interference. The same is confirmed.
Accordingly, the present
F.A. is dismissed.
17.
Now for deciding the issue as impugned in the
cross objection let us reproduce Section 232 and Section 234 of
the Indian Succession Act, 1925:―232. Grant of administration of universal or residuary legatees.—
When—
(a) the deceased has made a Will, but has not appointed an executor, or
(b) the deceased has appointed an executor who is legally incapable or refuses
to act, or who has died before the testator or before he has proved the Will, or
(c) the executor dies after having proved the will, but before he has
administered all the estate of the deceased, a universal or a residuary legatee
may be admitted to prove the Will, and letters of administration with the Will
annexed may be granted to him of the whole estate, or of so much thereof as
may be unadministered.
234. Grant of administration where no executor, nor
residuary legatee, nor representative of such legatee.—When there is no
executor and no residuary legatee or representative of a residuary legatee, or
he declines or is incapable to act, or cannot be found, the person or persons
who would be entitled to the administration of the estate of the deceased if he
had died intestate, or any other legatee having a beneficial interest, or a
creditor, may be admitted to prove the Will, and letters of administration may
be granted to him or them accordingly.
18.
In so far as Issue No.ii before the Court below is
concerned, this Court finds force in the submission of Mr. S.M.
Chakraborty, learned Sr. counsel that there is suspicious
circumstance relating to the impugned WILL. Further, in terms
of the of above-mentioned Sections of the Indian Succession
Act, the case of the Cross objectors stands in the eye of the law.
Accordingly, the same is reversed holding the issue in favour of
the respondents-cross objector. As such the Cross-objection as
filed by the respondents-cross objector is allowed.
19.
As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated, pending
application(s), if any also stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review