Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
Review Pet.No.30 of 2025
along with
Review Pet.No.35 of 2024
Review Pet.No.30 of 2025
Sri Pinaki Samanta,
son of Sri Jogendra Chandra Samanta,
resident of Ramkrishna Ashram Road,
Town Bordawali, Agartala, Tripura
..........Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura
2. The Deputy Secretary,
Finance (Establishment Branch) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura
3. Secretary to the General Administration
(Personnel & Training) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura
..........Official Respondent(s)
4. Smt. Sarmistha Laskar(Das), 34, Azad Hind Road,
Dhaleswar, Agartala, Tripura [The Next-of-kin, Legal Heir
And W/o Late Nalini Ranjan Das, Ex-Officer of Tripura Police
Service]
..........Proforma Respondent(s)
Review Pet.No.35 of 2024
Sri Pinaki Samanta,
son of Sri Jogendra Chandra Samanta,
resident of Ramkrishna Ashram Road,
Town Bordawali, Agartala, Tripura
..........Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Finance Department, Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura
2. The Deputy Secretary,
Finance (Establishment Branch) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura
3. Secretary to the General Administration
(Personnel & Training) Department,
Government of Tripura, New Secretariat Complex,
Gurkhabasti, Agartala, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division-Sadar, District-West Tripura
..........Official Respondent(s)
4. Smt. Sarmistha Laskar(Das), 34, Azad Hind Road,
Dhaleswar, Agartala, Tripura [The Next-of-kin, Legal Heir
And W/o Late Nalini Ranjan Das, Ex-Officer of Tripura Police
Service]
..........Proforma Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. J. Samed, Advocate.
Mr. Mangal Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
Date of Hearing & Judgment : 27/02/2026
Whether fit for reporting : NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, C.J.)
These two Review Petitions have been filed challenging the
common judgment of the Division Bench of this Court on 02.07.2024 in
W.A.No.30 of 2023 and W.A.No.53 of 2023.
2.
The Petitioner in the Review Petition was appointed to the post
of Deputy Superintendent of Police in Grade-II cadre of Tripura Police
Service through proper selection process and after completion of necessary
training, he joined to the post of Deputy S.P. on 31.10.1998 in the pay scale of
Rs.2,100-3000-5000/-.
3.
Subsequent thereto, the Tripura State Civil Services (Revised
Pay) Rules, 1999 were introduced by the Government of Tripura revising the
pay structures of the employees w.e.f. 01.01.1996.
4.
The said Rules stated that the entry level scale of pay for the
directly recruited TPS Grade-II Officers was revised to Rs.7,800-15,100/-,
whereas the entry level scale of pay for the promotee TPS Grade-II Officers
was revised to a higher scale of pay of Rs.10,000-15,100/-. The said Rules
also stated that the pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,100/- was prescribed for Direct
Recruit TPS Grade-II Officers after four years of service as a matter of scale
advancement in terms of clause (d) of Rule 10 of the ROP Rules, 1999.
5.
The Petitioner filed WP(C)No.426 of 2021 before this Court
contending that there was a clear distinction as regards fixation of pay scale
between direct recruits and promotes, that such difference in pay scales of
persons in the same cadre is discriminatory, and that his pay scale should be
at par with his junior (the proforma respondent) who was drawing higher pay
of Rs.10,000-15,100/- w.e.f. 28.03.2000.
6.
The Learned Single Judge allowed the said Writ Petition on 20-
2-2023. He accepted this contention of the Review Petitioner and held that
under the ROP Rules, 1999, separate pay scales were prescribed i.e. Rs.780015000/- for the direct recruits and Rs.10,000-15,000/- was for the promotee
Officers; that there was a clear anomaly and the respondents must removed
this anomaly allowing the pay scale to the petitioner, being a direct recruit in
the post of Deputy S.P., TPS Grade-II at par with the pay scale of the
promotee Officer i.e. the proforma respondent of Rs.10,000-15,100/-.
He held that the pay scale of the Petitioner has to be
upgraded/stepped up to Rs.10,000-15,100/- with effect from the date the
proforma respondent had joined i.e. from 28.03.2000 being a promotee
Officer, in the revised scale of pay of Rs.10000-15,100/-.
He relied also on Rule 9(A) of ROP Rules, 1999 and held that it
would come into play for equalization of the scale of pay of the petitioner
with that of the proforma respondent to bring parity in the pay scale as revised
under ROP Rules, 1999 by way of removing the anomaly as regards the
fixation of two distinct and separate scales of pay for direct recruitee Officers
and promotee Officers holding similar and identical posts in the same cadre in
the performance of similar and identical duties and responsibilities.
However, while allowing the Writ Petition, the Learned Single
Judge stated that all financial benefits to which the petitioner would be
entitled to under the ROP Rules, 1999 and the subsequent revision of pay
Rules should be fixed notionally till the date prior to one year of the date of
filing of the Writ Petition, i.e., that relief of payment of arrears is restricted to
only one year before the date of filing the Writ Petition and such payment
would not carry any interest.
7.
The Respondents filed W.A.No.53 of 2023 to the extent that the
Learned Single Judge held in favour of the Review Petitioner.
8.
To the extent the Learned Single Judge did not grant arrears for
a period of three years prior to the date of filing of the Writ Petition, the
petitioner filed W.A.30 of 2023.
9.
Both these appeals were heard together and disposed by a
common order dt.7.8. 2023.
10.
The Division Bench noted the principle that classification of
employees based on the method of the recruitment had long been declared
impermissible by the Supreme Court, that there cannot be differential
treatment between an employee directly recruited vis-à-vis another employee
promoted, and that as long as the two employees are part of the same cadre,
they cannot be treated differently either for purposes of pay and allowances or
other conditions of service including the age of superannuation and
birthmarks i.e., how they got the post in the cadre by direct recruitment or
promotion, have no relevance . The Division Bench relied on two decisions
of the Supreme Court in Kamalakar & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.,1 and
Union of India & Ors. vs. Atul Shukla & Ors.,2 in support of the said view.
11.
Thereafter, the Division Bench in para Nos.16 & 17 quoted
Rule 9(A) of the ROP Rules, 1999 which specifically permitted stepping up
of pay of a junior if the revised pay of senior (without stepping up) was lower
than that of a junior employee.
12.
But having agreed in principle with the contention of the
petitioner, in Para-18 the Division Bench held as under :
“[18] In view of the above, we are of the view that the
present writ petitioner is entitled to certain pay protection
without refixing the pay of the writ petitioner by way of
stepping up of his pay to which the pay of said Nalini
Ranjan Das was fixed. Further keeping in view of the
decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Yogendra
Shrivastava‟s case we are also of the view that the actual
benefits of such pay protection should be limited up to
3(three) years.
(1999) 4 SCC 756
(2014) 10 SCC 432
For the foregoing reasons, both the appeals
are partly allowed and are disposed of in the following
terms:
The State-respondents are directed to give
similar financial benefits to the writ petitioner equal to the
gross salary of said Nalini Ranjan Das with effect from the
date when said Nalini Ranjan Das was promoted to the post
of TPS(Grade-II) i.e. from 28.03.2000 for 03 (three) years
next and the difference of the gross salary of Nalini Ranjan
Das and the writ petitioner, Sri Pinaki Samanta as was
during that period should be paid by way of arrear to the
writ petitioner without changing or upgrading his pay scale
by way of stepping up. Such arrear should be paid by the
State respondents within 3(three) months from the date of
receipt of the copy of the order.
The impugned judgment is accordingly
interfered with and both appeals are disposed of with the
above said directions.”
(emphasis supplied)
13.
Seeking review of the common judgment in W.A.No.30 of
2023 and WA.No.53 of 2023, Rev.Petition No.30 of 2025 and Rev.Petition
No.35 of 2024 have been filed by petitioner.
14.
In the 1st portion of para-18 of the common judgment in the
WAs, it was held that the Writ Petitioner need not be refixed by way of
stepping up of his pay to which the pay of said private respondent- Nalini
Ranjan Das was fixed. This is clearly contrary to Rule-9(A) quoted supra
because there is no dispute in the instant case that the revised pay of the
petitioner who was senior (without stepping up) was lower than that of
proforma respondent who was junior to him. In such circumstances, Rule9(A) mandated that the pay of the senior employee should be stepped up to an
amount equal to the pay fixed for the junior employee in the revised scale of
pay from the date, the stepping up is permitted in the existing scale with the
approval of the Finance Department or by the Department as per the existing
orders of the Government.
This is the first error apparent on the face of the record pointed
out by the counsel for the petitioner in the order of the Division Bench in the
Review Petition filed by him.
15.
The other error pointed out by the counsel for the petitioner is
that in the later part of para-18, the Bench directed the State to give similar
financial benefits to the petitioner equal to gross salary of the proforma
respondent with effect from the date when that respondent was promoted to
the post of TPS, Grade-II i.e. from 28.03.2000 for three years next. In other
words from 28.03.2000 to 28.03.2003.
It is contended that what is to be done is the stepping up of pay
of the petitioner to an amount equal to the pay fixed for the proforma
respondent in the revised pay scale, from the date the stepping up was
permitted in the existing scale and the direction to give financial benefit equal
to the gross salary of the proforma respondent is clearly erroneous, more so,
when the benefit is confined to three years from 28.03.2000 instead of three
years prior to the filing of the Writ Petition.
16.
Learned Addl. G.A., however, refuted the said contention and
placed reliance on the schedule to the revised ROP Rules, 1999 while dealing
with Tripura Police Service. Annexure-B to the said Rules states as under :
II
I
2100-3000
7800-15100
II
7800-15100
Entry for direct
recruits. He will
move to CAS 1
after 4 years of
service
(SL)30005000
10000-15100
CAS 1
10000-15100
CAS for direct
recruits and
entry for
promotee
22(a)(i) for direct
recruit and 22(C)
for promotee
3500-5700
11150-18275
11150-18275
On promotion
22(C)
He vehemently contends that the Petitioner being a direct
recruitee can get only the revised pay scale of Rs.7,800-15,100/- and not the
next pay scale of Rs.10,000-15,100/- which he would be entitled to get after
completing four years of service. He also contends that Rule-9(A) cannot be
applied in this situation.
17.
The counsel for the Review Petitioner refuted the said
contention and placed reliance on both Rule-9(A) and the judgments of the
Supreme Court referred to supra by the Division Bench.
18.
Firstly, we shall refer to Rule-9(A) of the ROP Rules, 1999
which states as under :
“(A) In case of pay of an employee was stepped up on or
before after 01-01-1996 either with the approval of the
Finance Department or by the Department as per the
existing orders of the Government, validity of such stepping
up of pay will depend on the actual necessity while fixing up
of pay in the revised scale of both senior and junior
employees in the same cadre. In such cases, if the revised
pay of both senior employee (without stepping up) is same or
more as that of junior employee in the revised scale, the
benefit of stepping up will not be admissible. However, if he
revised pay of senior (without stepping up) is lower than that
of junior employee, the pay of senior employee will be
stepped up to an amount equal to the pay fixed for the junior
employee in revised scale of pay from the date the stepping
up was permitted in the existing scale with the approval of
the Finance Department or by the Department as per
existing orders of the Government.”
(emphasis supplied)
19.
As can be seen from the above Rule, stepping up of pay would
be done only if there is actual necessity to do so while fixing up of pay in the
revised scale of both senior and junior employees in the same cadre. So if the
revised pay of senior employee (without stepping up) is same or more as that
of the junior employee in the revised scale, benefit of stepping up will not be
admissible. But if the revised pay of the senior (without stepping up) is lower
than that of junior employee, the pay of the senior employee will be stepped
up to an amount equal to the pay fixed for the junior employee in the revised
scale of pay from the date the stepping up was permitted in the existing scale
with the approval of the Finance Department or by the Department as per the
existing orders of the Government.
20.
It is this later part of Rule-9(A) which is attracted in the instant
case as was rightly held both by the Learned Single Judge while deciding the
Writ Petition, and by the Division Bench while deciding the Writ Appeals.
This is because there is no dispute that the Review Petitioner, being a direct
recruit, was appointed on 31.10.1998 and was drawing the lesser scale of
Rs.7,800-15,100/- (without stepping up) compared to the promote/proforma
respondent who was promoted on 28.03.2000 and who was drawing pay scale
of Rs.10,000-15,100/-.
21.
In a situation of this nature, the respondents cannot contend that
the Annexure-B to the ROP Rules, 1999 would prevail over Rule-9(A). The
Annexure-B would apply wholly if Rule-9(A) is not attracted in a given
situation, but will not apply if later part of Rule-9(A) is attracted.
22.
The judgment of the Supreme Court in both Kamlakar’s case
and Atul Shukla’s case referred to above have held that once all persons come
into one cadre whether as direct recruits or promotees, the distinction between
direct recruits and promotees disappears, and they are all entitled to equal
treatment in the same cadre for payment of the given pay scale and the
birthmarks in the service have no relevance.
23.
The Division Bench in its judgment in the Writ Appeals had
also accepted this principle in paras-16 & 17, but in para-18 erred in holding
that there need not be any refixation of pay of the Petitioner by way of
stepping up of his pay. This is clearly an error apparent on the face of record
which warrants interference in the exercise of review jurisdiction by this
Court.
24.
We are also in agreement with the contention of the counsel for
Petitioner that in the later part of para-18, the Division Bench erred in stating
that the State-respondents should give similar financial benefits to the
Petitioner equal to the gross salary of the proforma respondent for three years
w.e.f.28.03.2000.
The proper direction which the Division Bench ought to have
given is that the pay of the petitioner, which was lower to that of the proforma
respondent, has to be stepped up to an amount equal to the pay fixed for the
proforma respondent in the revised scale of pay, and that the financial benefit
should be given for a period of three years prior to 25.06.2021, the date on
which the Writ Petition was filed by the Review Petitioner. It erred in saying
that the benefit is to be given from 28.3.2000 for 3 years.
25.
In our opinion, the Division Bench judgment dt.02.07.2024
clearly suffers from above errors apparent on the face of record and therefore,
the Review Applications are allowed and the order passed by the Division
Bench in the Writ Appeal is modified as under :
“The State-respondents are directed to step up the pay of the
Review Petitioner to an amount equal to the pay fixed for the
proforma respondent notionally in the revised scale of pay,
from the date the stepping up was permitted in the existing
scale i.e.from 28.03.2000; and the arrears shall be paid to
the Review Petitioner from 25.06.2018 till date within three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.”
Both the Review Petitions are allowed as above and the orders
in the Writ Appeals are modified.
(S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J)
signed by
SABYASACHI Digitally
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJ
Date: 2026.03.07 12:17:30
EE
+05'30'
Sabyasachi B
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review