The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 07.2023 YES/NO HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD _F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_ Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant also heard Mr. P. Shil, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. [2] This appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against the impugned judgment & award dated 11.02.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in connection with TS (MAC) 36 of 2017 for enhancement of the compensation. [3] The brief facts of the claimant-petitioner, the appellant’s case are that on 29.02.2016 at about 1600 hours while the appellant was talking to one Parimal Dey at Bagma near the School Boarding on the roadside of UdaipurAgartala National Highway, that time one Maruti van bearing No. TR-03G-0742 coming from Udaipur side with an abnormal high speed and in rash and negligent manner dashed upon the appellant. As a result the claimant received injuries over chin, right ear, right thigh, left knee, left foot and on other parts of his body. Immediately the claimant was taken to District Hospital at Tepania but considering the gravity of injuries he was referred to Tripura Medical College & Dr. B.R.Ambedkar Memorial & Teaching Hospital, Hapania, Agartala wherein he received treatment as an indoor patient up to 06.04.2016 and discharged on that date with an advi…
16. 12.2015 to 15.12.2016. The alleged accident was occurred on 29.02.2016 i.e., at the time of accident the vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van) was under insurance coverage and on that day the vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van) was driven by the driver of OP No. 1 having valid driving licence, so the liability for payment of compensation is fixed upon the OP No. 2 Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., the insurer of the offending vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van). [15] In view of the evidence of PW-3 and the medical report Exbt.6, it is a permanent disability of 33% is considered and accordingly, under the head of disability the amount is increased. Due to pain and sufferings as a result of the accident, the learned tribunal has awarded Rs.20,000/-. Since there is no hard and fast rule or specific yardstick with regard to the pain sufferings, this Court feels that the amount can be increased to Rs.50,000/- instead Rs.20,000/- as awarded by the learned tribunal because for number of times he was underwent surgery and Rs.10,000/- is more added to the total award as assessed by the tribunal for the transportation. [16] In view of above modification, the present appeal stands partly allowed. The insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount as assessed by the learned tribunal and the modified amount as discussed above…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC. App. No.59 of 2022
Sri Parimal Ghosh
.....Appellant
V_E_R_S_U_S
Sri Mithan Roy & Another
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and delivery
Of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. P. Shil Advocate.
19.07.2023
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant also
heard Mr. P. Shil, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 against the impugned judgment & award dated 11.02.2022 passed by
the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2, Gomati
Judicial District, Udaipur in connection with TS (MAC) 36 of 2017 for
enhancement of the compensation.
[3]
The brief facts of the claimant-petitioner, the appellant’s case are
that on 29.02.2016 at about 1600 hours while the appellant was talking to one
Parimal Dey at Bagma near the School Boarding on the roadside of UdaipurAgartala National Highway, that time one Maruti van bearing No. TR-03G-0742
coming from Udaipur side with an abnormal high speed and in rash and negligent
manner dashed upon the appellant. As a result the claimant received injuries over
chin, right ear, right thigh, left knee, left foot and on other parts of his body.
Immediately the claimant was taken to District Hospital at Tepania but considering
the gravity of injuries he was referred to Tripura Medical College & Dr.
B.R.Ambedkar Memorial & Teaching Hospital, Hapania, Agartala wherein he
received treatment as an indoor patient up to 06.04.2016 and discharged on that
date with an advice to attend the OPD. On 09.04.2016 the claimant again admitted
in the said hospital and treated there up to 11.05.2016. On 12.05.2016 he again
admitted in the said hospital and treated there up to 23.05.2016 and discharged
with an advice to attend the OPD regularly. It is also stated by the claimant that
after prolong treatment also he did not recover fully from the injuries and became
disabled due to such injuries. It is alleged by the claimant that such accident was
occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of the offending vehicle
bearing No. TR-03G-0742.
[4]
Due to such RTA a written complaint was lodged to the O/C of R. K.
Pur PS on that date itself which was registered vide R. K. Pur PS Case No. 18 of
2016 under Section 279/338 of IPC and u/s 184/187 of MV Act against the driver
of the offending vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03G-0742.
[5]
The owner of the vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742
(Maruti Van) contested the case by filing written statement denying the averments
made in the claim petition and denied the facts that on 29.02.2016 at about 1600
hours the accident was occurred on Udaipur-Agartala road near School Boarding
at Bagma by the vehicle bearing No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti Van) which was
coming from Agartala to Udaipur with an abnormal high speed and in rash and
negligent manner dashed the claimant for which the claimant sustained grievous
injuries on various parts of his body. It is also denied that immediately after the
accident the claimant was taken to District Hospital at Tepania and considering the
gravity of injuries he was referred to Tripura Medical College & Dr. B. R.
Ambedkar Memorial & Teaching Hospital, Hapania, Agartala wherein he received
treatment as an indoor patient from 29.02.2016 to 06.04.2016. It is admitted by the
OP No.1 that the vehicle bearing Registration No. TR 03 G 0742 (Maruti Van) is
owned by him and it was duly insured with the Oriental Insurance Company
Limited covering the period from 16.12.2015 to 15.12.2016 and one Narayan
Debnath, S/O Jadu Gopal Debnath of Baspadia, PS Belonia, South Tripura drove
the said vehicle having a valid driving licence as such if the prayer of claimant is
allowed that should be indemnify by the Oriental Insurance Company Limited.
[6]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
having gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court bellow has
observed as under:
“In the result, it is hereby ordered that the claimant petitioner is entitled to get
compensation of Rs.4,90,291 (Rupees four lac ninety thousand two hundred
ninety one) only. The OP No. 2 Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., the insurer
of the offending vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van)
is directed to make the payment of compensation to the claimant petitioner
within 30 (thirty) days from today along with interest thereon @ 6% per
annum from the date of filing of claim petition, i.e. 29.07.2017 till
payment/realization of the same.”
[7]
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that at the time of computing future loss, the learned tribunal below
assessed compensation holding that the disability is only for 5 years. It is most
humbly submitted that the learned tribunal has failed to consider the disablement
certificate and the nature of disability of the appellant. The disability of the
appellant is not curable and the same should be increased day to day. PW-3, Dr.
Snehasish Datta never said that after five years his disability would be curable. On
the contrary, he shad that the disability of the appellant may or may not be
increased and his working capacity would be reduced. The learned tribunal below
failed to consider the same and hence, assessing compensation for loss of income
for five years is not tenable in law and thus, the impugned judgment and award is
liable to be interfered with.
[8]
He has further contended that the learned tribunal has committed
serious error in not awarding any compensation towards future treatment,
transportation charges, died, nutrition charge and cost of escort. On perusal of the
record, it is revealed that the appellant was a resident of Bagma and he was
admitted in hospital at Agartala. Thus, the appellant has incurred huge expenditure
as transportation charges to attend hospital. Apart from this, when the appellant
was in hospital, two persons must be in the hospital along with him as escorts, but
the learned tribunal below did not award anything towards cost of escorts.
[9]
The learned tribunal also committed serious mistake in not awarding
anything towards diet and nutrition charge. On perusal of the record, it revealed
that on three occasions the appellant was admitted in the hospital as an indoor
patient and one operation was done. It is common place knowledge that if any
operation is done to any patient, doctors must advice for special diet to the patient.
In the present case the learned tribunal has failed to consider the same and did not
award anything towards diet and nutrition charges and hence, the impugned
judgment and award is liable to be interfered with. The learned tribunal has
committed serious mistake in awarding Rs.20,000/- as pain and sufferings of the
appellant. After the accident, within six months he was in the hospital in three
occasions as indoor patient.
[10]
This fact clearly demonstrates that how much suffering the appellant
has faced but, the learned tribunal below failed to consider the same and awarded a
meager amount of Rs.20,000/-. It is most humbly submitted that as the patient
suffered huge mental and physical strain, so the learned tribunal ought to have
awarded Rs.1,00,000/- under the head of pain and sufferings. Thus, the impugned
judgment and award is liable to be interfered with.
[11]
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited, the insurer of the
offending vehicle bearing Registration No.TR-03G-0742 (Maruti Van) in their
written statement denied the narration made in the claim petition the manner in
which the accident was described to have taken place. They also denied the age,
income and avocation as well as the health condition of the injured at the time of
accident and further stated that in case of violation of any terms and conditions of
the insurance policy they would not be responsible to indemnify the owner.
According to the insurance company they were not aware of any criminal case
registered relating to the alleged accident. Further, the owner as well as the driver
of the offending vehicle did not inform them anything about the accident.
[12]
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant
submits
for
adequate
compensation on the materials available with the record. Learned Counsel further
submitted that at the time of alleged accident the injured was a businessman
having monthly income of Rs.10,000/- and due to such accident the injured could
not pursue his normal activities for long time. PW.3 Dr. Snehashish Datta was one
of the members of the District Disability Board, Gomati District, Udaipur who
identified his signature as Exhibit – 6/1 in the disabled certificate of appellant.
Except denial and suggestions no material aspects has been elucidated by the
respondent side during the cross-examination of PW.1, PW.2 and PW.3.
[13]
As the evidence of PW.1 and PW.2 shows that the accident was
occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of vehicle bearing
Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van). So, it is clear that on 29.02.2016 at
about 16.00 hours the injured Parimal Ghosh got injuries following the RTA at
Bagma near School Boarding on NH-44, Udaipur due to the rash and negligent
driving by the driver of offending vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742
(Maruti van).
[14]
It is established that the accident occurred due to the fault on the part
of the driver of the vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van),
owned by OP No. 1 which is insured with OP No. 2, covering the period from
16.12.2015 to 15.12.2016. The alleged accident was occurred on 29.02.2016 i.e.,
at the time of accident the vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03G-0742 (Maruti
van) was under insurance coverage and on that day the vehicle bearing
Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van) was driven by the driver of OP No. 1
having valid driving licence, so the liability for payment of compensation is fixed
upon the OP No. 2 Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., the insurer of the offending
vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03G-0742 (Maruti van).
[15]
In view of the evidence of PW-3 and the medical report Exbt.6, it is
a permanent disability of 33% is considered and accordingly, under the head of
disability the amount is increased. Due to pain and sufferings as a result of the
accident, the learned tribunal has awarded Rs.20,000/-. Since there is no hard and
fast rule or specific yardstick with regard to the pain sufferings, this Court feels
that the amount can be increased to Rs.50,000/- instead Rs.20,000/- as awarded by
the learned tribunal because for number of times he was underwent surgery and
Rs.10,000/- is more added to the total award as assessed by the tribunal for the
transportation.
[16]
In view of above modification, the present appeal stands partly
allowed. The insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount as assessed by
the learned tribunal and the modified amount as discussed above within a period of
one month, from the date of receipt of the copy of this order, if not already
deposited. Consequently, the claimant is at liberty to withdraw the same as per
procedure. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed. Draw the award accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs
forthwith.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
Digitally signed
by ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.07.25
13:00:20 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review