Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
L.A. App. No.57 of 2024
Sri Nripendra Kumar Tripura (Age 57 years)
S/o. Lt. Madhusudhan Tripura,
of Ramji Para, West Jalefa
P.S. – Sabroom, P.O. Jalefa.
Pin - 799145
------ Referring Claimant-Appellant
Versus
1. The Deputy Chief Engineer (CON-2) No.1
North East Frontier Railway,
Badharghat Railway Station
P.O. Siddhi Ashram, P.S. Amtali
Agartala, West Tripura.
2. Land Acquisition Collector
South Tripura, Belonia
Office of the D.M. and Collector
P.O. & P.S. Belonia
Dist. South Tripura
Pin-799155
------ O.P.-Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. T. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing and
Judgment & Order
:
21.09.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
This appeal under Section 54 of L.A. Act, 1894 is
preferred against the judgment and order dated 07.09.2019
delivered by Learned L.A. Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in
connection with case No.L.A.(Ref.) No.196 of 2019.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Ms. P. Chakraborty for the
appellant and also heard Learned Counsel Mr. T. Chakraborty
for the respondent No.1. None appeared on behalf of the L.A.
Collector, South Tripura, Belonia inspite of service of notice.
3.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for
the appellant submitted that mother of the appellant was the
owner of land measuring 1.83 acres of Hal plot No.4798/P
pertaining to Khatian No.1242 classified as Nal under MoujaWest Jalefa, TK-Sabroom under Sabroom Sub-Division. Said
mother of the appellant expired on 06.11.1994 leaving behind
the present appellant as her only legal heir. The aforesaid land
of the appellant was acquired by the L.A. Collector i.e. the
respondent No.2 herein for the purpose of construction of
Agartala
to
Sabroom,
New
Railway
line
vide
declaration
No.F.9(04)-REV/ACQ/XII/2012 dated 31.10.2012.
4.
According to appellant, at the time of acquisition, the
L.A. Collector determined the value of the acquired land @
Rs.1,44,000/- per kani. Being dissatisfied with the award of the
L.A. Collector, the appellant approached to the L.A. Collector,
South Tripura District, Belonia for reference of his matter under
Section 18 of the L.A. Act before the Court of Learned L.A.
Judge and accordingly the matter was referred to L.A. Judge,
South Tripura, Belonia under Section 18 of the L.A. Act.
Accordingly, a reference case was registered before the Court of
Learned L.A. Judge.
5.
The appellant appeared before the Court of Learned
L.A. Judge, South Tripura, Belonia. Before the Learned L.A.
Judge, the referring-claimant i.e. the appellant herein submitted
his claim statement and the L.A. Collector also submitted
counter statement before the said Court. But at the time of
hearing of the reference case before the Learned L.A. Judge,
the appellant-claimant failed to adduce his oral/documentary
evidence in support of his claim. So, for non-production of
evidence both oral/documentary, Learned L.A. Judge finally
affirmed the award made by the L.A. Collector and dismissed
the case with ‘nil’ award.
6.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further submitted
that if the appeal is not allowed and matter is not remanded
back to the Learned L.A. Judge giving opportunity to the
present appellant to adduce his oral/documentary evidence on
record, in that case, the appellant would sustain huge amount
of financial loss because the compensation determined by the
L.A. Collector was too less than the prevailing market price and
by this time, the land value of the adjacent plots of the acquired
land and its adjoining areas have been increased a lot. Learned
Counsel further submitted that the appellant has got a very
good
prima
facie
case
but
due
to
some
compelling
circumstances he could not appear before the Court with his
evidence in time but the Learned L.A. Judge without affording
any opportunity dismissed the case with nil award. So, Learned
Counsel for the appellant urged for allowing this appeal by
setting aside the order of the Learned L.A. Judge.
7.
Learned Counsel for the respondent No.1 submitted
that as the appellant did not have any oral/documentary
evidence in support of his claim statement. So, the appellant
intentionally did not appear before the Learned L.A. Judge for
which the Learned L.A. Judge was pleased to affirm the award
made by the L.A. Collector and dismissed the appeal with nil
award. Learned Counsel further submitted that there is no merit
in the appeal and urged for dismissal of this present appeal with
costs.
8.
As already stated, none appeared on behalf of the L.A.
Collector inspite of service of notice.
9.
I have seen the order dated 07.09.2019 delivered by
Learned L.A. Judge in connection with case No.L.A.(Ref) No.196
of 2019. For the sake of convenience, I would like to mention
herein below the entire part of the relevant order delivered by
the Learned L.A. Judge which runs as follows:
The referring claimant is absent without step
though notice was duly served upon him.
On behalf of the L.A. Collector, learned G.P. is
present.
At the instance of the referring claimant, Sri
Nripendra Kr. Tripura, the present case was
referred by the L.A. Collector under sec.18 of the
L.A. Act in respect of acquired land measuring 1.83
acres of mouja-West Jalefa, TK-Sabroom under
Sabroom Sub-Division, khatian No.1242, plot
No.4798/p and nal class of land.
On behalf of the L.A. Collector, learned G.P. is
present.
No step is filed by OP No.2, NF Railway.
Counter statements have been submitted by the
Ops earlier.
The referring claimant already submitted claim
statement before the L.A. Collector. But on
receiving the notice, the referring claimant has
failed to appear before this court and adduce
evidence to justify his claim.
Learned G.P. submits that the claimant is not
interested to proceed with this case and they also
express that they are not inclined to adduce any
evidence and prays to confirm the award of the L.A.
Collector.
Since no step is filed by the referring claimant and
the referring claimant has not adduced evidence in
support of his claim, I find no ground as to why the
award given by the L.A. Collector will not be
confirmed.
On perusal of the record, I find that L.A. Collector
had given proper justification in respect of coming
to the compensation. Accordingly, due to want of
evidence on the part of the referring claimant, I do
hereby confirm the award given by the L.A.
Collector.
Hence, the case is disposed of with nil award
confirming the award given by the L.A. Collector.
10.
This present appeal is preferred under Section 54 of
L.A. Act and for the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the relevant provision of Section 54 of the L.A. Act
which provides as under:
54. Appeals in proceedings before Court.- Subject
to the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908(5 of 1908), applicable to appeals from
original decrees, and notwithstanding anything to
the contrary in any enactment for the time being
in force, and appeal shall only lie in any
proceedings under this Act to the High Court from
the award, or from any part of the award , of the
Court and from any decree of the High Court
passed on such appeal as aforesaid an appeal
shall lie to the Supreme Court subject to the
provisions contained in section 110 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908, and in Order XLIV thereof.
11.
On perusal of the order of the Learned L.A. Judge, it
appears that before the Learned L.A. Judge, the present
appellant submitted his claim statement and the respondent
No.2 i.e. the L.A. Collector also submitted counter statement
but no counter statement was submitted by the respondent
No.1 i.e. the requiring department. Further, on perusal of the
order, it appears that Learned L.A. Judge simply on the basis of
submission made by Learned G.P. without affording any
opportunity to the present appellant proceeded to dismiss the
case with nil award confirming the compensation awarded by
the L.A. Collector in the given case.
12.
Thus, in my considered view, Learned L.A. Judge ought
to have allowed an opportunity to the present appellant to
adduce his oral/documentary evidence on record, if any, in
support of his claim statement but on bare perusal of the order,
it appears that no such scope was given to the referring
claimant. Although it is on record that inspite of receipt of
notice, the referring claimant i.e. the present appellant did not
appear before the Learned L.A. Judge.
13.
Since the L.A. Act is a beneficial legislation and the land
belonging to the appellant was acquired by the Government for
the purpose of construction of Agartala-Sabroom Railway line
and considering the land valuation of the State, it appears to
this Court that Learned L.A. Judge could adjourn the case
atleast for one occasion or to inform the Learned Counsel for
the referring claimant to take appropriate step but from the
order, it appears that no such opportunity was given to the
referring claimant by the Learned L.A. Judge which in my
considered opinion was not proper and the same caused
injustice to the appellant.
14.
So, after hearing both the sides, it appears that the
matter needs to be remanded back to the Learned L.A. Judge to
afford
an
opportunity
to
the
appellant
to
adduce
his
oral/documentary evidence on record, if any, in support of his
claim statement. Before the Learned L.A. Judge, if the present
appellant i.e. the referring claimant again fails to adduce
oral/documentary evidence on record, in that case, the Learned
L.A. Judge shall have the liberty to dismiss the reference
confirming the award/compensation awarded by L.A. Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia in the connected case.
15.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby
allowed. The Judgment and Order dated 07.09.2019 delivered
by Learned L.A. Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in connection
with L.A.(Ref) No.196 of 2019 is hereby set aside. The matter is
remanded back to the Learned L.A. Judge with a direction to
give opportunity to the referring claimant i.e. the appellant
herein to adduce his oral/documentary evidence on record and
thereafter to allow the contesting opposite parties i.e. the
requiring department and the L.A. Collector to cross-examine
the witnesses of the referring claimant and also after affording
opportunity to the contesting opposite parties to adduce their
evidence, if any, in support of their contention and thereafter to
deliver a fresh judgment/award. The entire exercise shall be
made by the Learned L.A. Judge, South Tripura, Belonia within
a period of 3(three) months from the date of receipt of copy of
this judgment/order. The present appellant shall appear before
the
Court
of
Learned
L.A.
Judge
on
07.10.2024.
The
respondents are also asked to appear before the Court of
Learned L.A. Judge on that day for further proceeding.
A copy of this judgment/order be sent to the Court of
Learned L.A. Judge, South Tripura, Belonia for information and
compliance. A copy of this judgment/order be furnished to
Learned Counsel for the appellant and Learned Counsel for the
respondent No.1. A copy of this order also be communicated to
the L.A. Collector, South Tripura, Belonia for taking appropriate
step in pursuance of the judgment/order passed by this Court.
16.
With this observation, this appeal stands disposed of on
contest.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2024.09.23
A DATTA Date:
15:49:49 +05'30'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review