Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA NO.19 of 2022
1. Sri. Nitai Lal Saha,
S/o. Sri. Hari Mohan Saha,
2. Smti. Soma Saha, Age-50 years,
W/o. Sri. Nitai Lal Saha,
Both are Resident of Village: Ashampara,
P.O. Aurangabad, P.S. Suti,
District: Murshidabad,
Pin: 742201, West Bengal.
……Appellant-plaintiffs
Versus
Sri. Gour Gopal Saha,
S/o. Sri. Hari Mohan Saha,
Resident of Badar Mokam,
Badar Saheb Bari Road,
P.S. Radhakishorepur, P.O. Radhakishorepur,
District-Gomati Tripura, Tripura.
Pin: 799120
…..Respondent-defendant
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B.N. Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S.C. Sen, Adv,
Mr. S. Dasgupta, Adv
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv,
Mr. S. Noatia, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
15.02.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
23.02.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
By means of this appeal under Section 100 of
CPC, the present appellants have challenged the judgment
dated 23.02.2022 and decree dated 02.03.2022 passed by
Learned Additional District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur in
connection with Title Appeal No.26 of 2017, reversing the
judgment and decree dated 28.08.2017 passed by Learned
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Gomati District, Udaipur in T.S.
18 of 2016.
02.
Before entering into the merit of the case, let us
discuss the subject matter of the dispute. The present
appellants as plaintiffs filed a suit before the Court of
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Gomati District, Udaipur
for eviction, recovery of khas possession, for damages and
for mesne profits. The case of the appellant-plaintiffs was
that the suit land was originally belonged to one Smt. Sikha
Rani Saha and said Sikha Rani Saha on 17.04.2009 gifted
the suit land in favour of the appellant-plaintiff No.1, Nitai
Lal Saha and delivered possession and accordingly, the Gift
was accepted by the appellant-plaintiff No.1 and which was
duly acted upon and thus, the appellant-plaintiff No.1
became the owner of the suit land and after that, on
18.03.2013 the appellant-plaintiff No.1 executed a Gift Deed
in favour of his wife i.e. the appellant-plaintiff No.2, in
respect of part of the suit land and thus, both the appellantplaintiffs became the owners of the suit land. The appellantplaintiffs allowed Gour Gopal Saha to reside over the suit
land with his family members as licensee and thereafter, the
appellant-plaintiffs requested the defendant to vacate the
suit property but failed and after that on 18.01.2016, the
appellant-plaintiffs issued demand notice to the respondent-
defendant to vacate the suit land but as he refused to do the
same, so, the appellant-plaintiffs filed the suit.
03.
The
respondent-defendant
contested
the
suit
denying the claim of the appellant-plaintiffs and took the
plea that Sikha Rani Saha was the original owner of the suit
land, where she has been staying with her old and ill
husband and the contesting defendant was also residing over
the suit property and in the month of June, 1986 said Sikha
Rani Saha verbally allowed the respondent-defendants to
occupy land measuring 0.158 acres of the suit property and
permitted the respondent-defendant to construct permanent
dwelling house therein and accordingly, the defendant
constructed building there in and staying therein with
separate electric connection and ration card.
Further, according to the respondent-defendant,
the appellant-plaintiffs did not acquire any right, title and
interest over the suit land by dint of Gift Deed bearing
No.676 and on 12.01.2015, said Sikha Rani Saha appeared
before the Deputy Collector and Magistrate, Udaipur in the
mutation proceeding of appellant-plaintiff No.1 and stated
that she did not execute any such Gift Deed and the alleged
Gift Deed caused to be executed by plaintiff No.1 without
informing her in details about the transfer of property and
she was unable to read the contents of the Deed as it was
written in English and she intends to distribute the property
amongst
her
all
legal
heirs
and
thus,
the
mutation
proceeding was rejected. So, the contesting respondent-
defendant prayed for dismissal of the suit of the appellantplaintiffs.
04.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Trial
Court framed the following issues:
(i) Whether the suit is maintainable?
(ii)
Whether
identifiable?
the
suit
land
is
(iii) Whether the Gift deed No. 676
dated 17-04-2009 is valid or caused to
be executed by misrepresentation or
otherwise illegally?
(iv) Whether the plaintiffs are owners
of the suit land?
(v) Whether the defendant is the
licensee of plaintiffs or permissive
possessor of one Smt. Sikha Rani
Saha?
(vi) Whether plaintiffs are entitled to
the relief as prayed for and/or any
other relief or reliefs in this case?
To substantiate the issues both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidences on record.
APPENDIX
(A) Plaintiffs’ Witnesses:P.W.-1 Sri. Nitai Lal Saha.
P.W.-2 Smt. Soma Saha.
P.W.-3 Sri. Ratan Chakraborty.
(B) Plaintiffs’ Exhibits:Ext.-1:- Gift deed No. 1-676 dated
17.04.2009 executed by Smt. Sikha
Rani Saha.
Ext.-2:- Gift deed No. 1-449 dated
18.03.2013 executed by Nitai Lal
Saha.
Ext.-1/1:- Signature of Nitai Lal Saha
on Ext. 1.
Ext.-3:- Notice dated 18.01.2016.
Ext.-3(i):- The signature of Nitai Lal
Saha on the notice(Ext.3).
Ext.-4:- Envelope of speed post.
Ext.-5:- A.D. Card.
Ext.-6:-Postal
18.01.2016.
receipt
dated
(C) Defendants’ Witnesses:D.W.1- Sri Gour Gopal Saha.
D.W.2- Sri Subrata Roy.
D.W.3- Sri Raghunath Saha.
D.W.4- Smt. Sanjushree Roy.
D.W.5- Smt. Anjana Roy.
D.W.6- Smt. Sikha Rani Saha.
(D) Defendants’ Exhibits:Ext. A series(in ten sheets)- Certified
copy of orders passed in proceeding
u/s 46 and 81 of TLR & LR Act.
Ext. B(in two sheets)- Certified copy of
notice dated 08.01.2015.
Ext. C- Certified copy of application
dated 29.01.2015.
Ext. D- Certified copy of report of
Tahashildar.
Ext. E- Application of Smt. Sikha Rani
Saha, dated 02.02.2015.
Ext. F- Photo copy of Ration Card of
Smt. Sikha Rani Saha.
Ext. G- Photo copy of Ration Card of
Gour Gopal Saha (defendant).
Ext.H- Electricity bill dated 16-072016 with bill payment receipt dated
21-07-2016.
Ext. I- Another Electricity bill dated
16-08-2016 with bill payment receipt
dated 22-08-2016.
05.
Finally, after hearing both the sides, Learned Trial
Court delivered the judgment on 28.08.2017. The operative
portion of the judgment of the Learned Trial Court runs as
follows:
―In the result, the suit of the plaintiffs
is decreed on contest with costs and
defendant is directed to vacate the
suit land and hand over the khas
possession of the suit property of the
plaintiffs within 60(sixty) days from
today.
The suit is disposed of on contest with
cost.
Make necessary entry in the relevant
Trial Register.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up
before
me
for
signature
within
15(fifteen) days from today latest on
12-09-2017.‖
06.
Challenging
the
judgment,
the
respondent-
defendant preferred first appeal under Section 96 of C.P.C.
before the Court of Learned District Judge, Gomati District,
Udaipur and thereafter the case was endorsed to Learned
Addl. District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur and Learned
First Appellate Court after hearing arguments of both the
sides, by judgment dated 23.02.2022 reversed the finding of
the Learned Trial Court by setting aside the judgment and
decree. The operative portion of the order of the Learned
First Appellate Court runs as follows:
―In view of the aforesaid discussions,
this Court finds that the learned trial
Court was in error and guided by some
misconception of law and thereby
decreed the suit of the plaintiffs i.e.
the present respondents-plaintiffs vide
decree dated 12.09.2017 in TS-18 of
2016. Accordingly the judgment and
decree dated 12.09.2017 passed by
the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.),
Gomati District, Udaipur in TS-18 of
2016 is hereby set aside being devoid
of merits. Thus the appeal is hereby
allowed.
Parties are directed to bear their own
costs.
Hence, the appeal is hereby disposed
of on contest.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send back the L.C. Record along with a
certified copy of this judgment and
decree.‖
07.
Challenging that judgment, the original plaintiffs
as appellant-plaintiffs have preferred this appeal before the
High Court under Section 100 of C.P.C. At the time of
admission of appeal following substantial question of law was
framed by order dated 11.05.2022:
―Whether the deed of gift executed by
Smt. Sikha Rani Saha in favour of
plaintiff appellant No.1 in respect of
the suit property was complete in
terms of Section 123 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 and passed title
over the suit property in favour of
plaintiff-appellant No.1?‖
08.
Heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
Mr.
B.N.
Majumder, assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. S.C. Sen and
Mr. S. Dasgupta for the appellant-plaintiffs and also heard
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty assisted by
Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Bhattacharjee and Mr. S. Noatia
representing the respondents. At the time of hearing of
arguments,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
appellant-
plaintiffs submitted that the present appellant-plaintiffs have
filed one suit before the Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Gomati District, Udaipur which was numbered as T.S. 18 of
2016 for granting a decree of recovery of khas possession,
for damages, for mesne profits and after going through
pleadings, taking evidence and also after hearing arguments
of both the sides, Learned Court decreed the suit in favour of
the
present
appellant-plaintiffs
and
challenging
that
judgment, the present respondents preferred an appeal
before the Learned District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur
which was later on consigned to Learned Additional District
Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur and after hearing both the
sides, Learned First Appellate Court was pleased to set aside
the judgment and decree passed by Learned Trial Court
which was perverse, without application of proper mind and
also not based on any legal reasoning. According to Learned
Counsel for the appellant-plaintiffs, the suit property was
originally belonged to one Sikha Rani Saha, Wife of Hari
Mohan Saha of Badar Mokam, Badar Saheb Bari Road, P.O.
and P.S. Radhakishorepur, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura and said
Sikha Rani Saha gifted the suit land in favour of his younger
son Sri. Nitai Lal Saha i.e. the appellant-plaintiff No. 1, which
was accepted by the appellant-plaintiff No.1 and the Gift was
acted upon. Thus, he became the absolute owner of the suit
property and after that the appellant-plaintiff No.1, being the
absolute owner of the suit property executed and registered
a Deed of Gift in respect of 0.174 acres of bastu land in
favour of the present appellant-plaintiff No.2.
09.
Further, according to Learned Senior Counsel for
the appellant-plaintiffs, the respondent was residing in the
suit property as a licensee without any license fee and the
appellant-plaintiffs,
on
several
times
requested
the
defendant to vacate the suit property but he did not pay any
heed to the request. Thereafter, he served one eviction
notice but inspite of that he did not deliver khas possession
of the suit property and ultimately, the appellants as
plaintiffs filed the suit before the Learned Trial Court. The
contesting respondent denied the case of the appellantplaintiffs and further submitted that in the month of June
1986,
said
Sikha
Rani
Saha
verbally
permitted
the
respondent to occupy the portion of suit land by constructing
dwelling
hut
therein
and
accordingly,
the
respondent
constructed permanent dwelling building made of bricks with
RCC roof consisted of bedrooms, dining room, kitchen and
toilet and veranda etc. and since then he has been
possessing the suit land peacefully and the appellants as
plaintiffs have/had no right to evict the respondent from the
suit land.
10.
Learned Senior Counsel also asserted that in para
21 of the written statement, the respondent submitted that
the appellant-plaintiffs did not acquire any right, title and
interest over the suit land by dint of Gift of Deed in the year
2009 because said Sikha Rani Saha, by appearing before
Deputy
Collector
&
Magistrate,
Udaipur,
Gomati
on
12.01.2015 in connection with the Mutation Proceeding
stated that she did not execute any such Gift Deed and
alleged Deed was caused to be executed by her son, Nitai Lal
Saha, plaintiff No.1, without informing her in details about
the transfer of the property and that she was unable to read
the contents of the Deed as it was written in English and she
had intention to distribute her property amongst her all sons
and daughters. So, Learned Senior Counsel, in course of
hearing of argument submitted that the Learned Trial Court,
at
the
time
of
delivery
of
judgment,
after
elaborate
discussions in respect of issue No.3, came to the finding that
the suit Deed was a valid one and the contesting respondent
failed to prove that the Gift Deed was caused to be executed
by misrepresentation or otherwise illegally. Learned Senior
Counsel, in addition to his submission further submitted that
the contesting respondent in the pleading has failed to
mention the allegation of fraud or misrepresentation as
required under Order VI, Rule 4 of C.P.C and apart from that
he has also relied upon the provision of Section 122 and 123
of the Transfer of Property Act and submitted that the Gift
Deed was duly executed and registered and in respect of
Gift, according to Learned Senior Counsel, question of
handing over of possession was not required at the time of
execution of Deed and further submitted that in this case,
the appellant-plaintiffs did not pray for any other relief
excepting recovery of khas possession, since the appellantplaintiffs had a valid title. So, in view of Section 8 of the
Transfer of Property Act, no separate relief was required to
get
the
decree.
Furthermore,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that the appellants as plaintiffs have complied
with the provision of Section 68 of the Evidence Act and he
also drawn the attention of the Court the relevant provision
of Section 91 of the Evidence Act but the Learned First
Appellate Court did not consider all those aspects and
ultimately came to an erroneous finding. Finally, Learned
Senior Counsel drawn the attention of the Court that the
Learned Trial Court below after considering everything
delivered the judgment in favour of the present appellantplaintiffs and urged for setting aside the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court and relied upon some citations.
11.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr.
S.M. Chakraborty assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee
and
Mr.
S.
Noatia,
representing
the
respondent submitted that the appellants as plaintiffs failed
to comply with the provision of Section 67 of the Evidence
Act. The scribe of the document was not produced to prove
the contents of the documents. So, legally there was no
scope to place any reliance upon Exhibit-1. Learned Senior
Counsel further submitted that although the appellantplaintiffs took the plea of licensee but Section 52(A) of the
Easement Act is not adopted in the State of Tripura. So,
there was no scope on the part of the appellant-plaintiffs to
take this plea that the respondent was a licensee. Learned
Senior Counsel further submitted that the appellant-plaintiffs
ought to make said Sikha Rani Saha as a party. But the
appellant-plaintiffs did not do so. So, the suit was bad for
nonjoinder of necessary party. More so, since Exhibit-1 was
questioned, so, no separate relief was sought for by the
appellant-plaintiffs
and
as
such
the
appellant-plaintiffs
were/are not entitled to get any decree and in this case, no
substantial question of law was framed. Since, Sikha Rani
Saha as DW-6 denied the execution of any Gift Deed but the
Learned Trial Court without referring the same to the hand
writing expert gave finding which was erroneous and
submitted that Order VI Rule 4 of C.P.C. was not applicable
for the respondent as the appellant-plaintiffs did not come
before
the
Court
with
clean
hands.
Furthermore,
the
appellant-plaintiffs have failed to comply with the provision
of Section 67 of the Evidence Act. There was no valid
acceptance of the Gift by the appellant-plaintiff No.1. Even
no possession was handed over as the respondent-defendant
was all along in possession of the suit land, which the
Learned Trial Court below did not consider. But the Learned
First Appellate Court, after considering all aspects, have
rightly and reasonably delivered the judgment by setting
aside the judgment of the Learned Trial Court and prayed for
dismissal of this appeal for want of substantial questions of
law and also Learned Senior Counsel referred few citations.
12.
I have heard detailed arguments of both the sides
and gone through the records of the Learned Court below.
Here, in this case, we are to decide whether Exhibit-1 was
valid or not. Learned Trial Court, at the time of delivery of
judgment, in deciding issue No.3 came to the observation
that suit Deed (Gift Deed No. 1-676 dated 17.04.2009) i.e.
Exhibit-1 was a valid one and decreed the suit. But the
Learned First Appellate Court, at the time of delivery of
judgment came to an observation that the Deed was
executed under suspicious circumstances and came to an
observation that the judgment of the Learned Trial Court was
perverse in respect of determination of issue No.3 and
ultimately, set aside the judgment of the Learned Trial Court.
In course of hearing, both the parties of this appeal to
substantiate the genuineness of the Exhibit-1 made their
submission and counter-submissions.
13.
Learned
plaintiffs,
to
Senior
substantiate
Counsel
his
for
the
contention
appellant-
referred
the
provisions of Section 122 and Section 123 of the Transfer of
property Act and Section 3, 8 of the Transfer of Property Act
and Section 68 and 90 of the Evidence Act and also relied
upon Order VI and Rule 4 of C.P.C and further referred Para
No.21 of the written statement filed by the respondentdefendant and submitted that Learned Trial Court at the time
of deciding issue No.3, after considering everything, rightly
came to the conclusion that the Gift Deed was valid one and
accordingly, decreed the suit.
14.
To the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent-defendant
submitted
that
the
respondent-
defendant denied the execution of Gift Deed by Sikha Rani
Saha in favour of appellant-plaintiff No.1 and also before the
Revenue Officer, in course of mutation proceeding, she
denied that she executed any Gift Deed in favour of
appellant-plaintiff No.1 and during her evidence before the
Court also, she specifically denied the said fact that she
executed any Gift Deed. So, according to Learned Senior
Counsel,
Learned
Appellate
Court
rightly
reversed
the
judgment of the Learned Trial Court and furthermore, that
the respondent-defendant was not a licensee as alleged by
the appellant-plaintiffs, because the Easement Act is not
applicable in our State and the said Easement Act has not
been adopted in our State. So, the stand of the appellantplaintiffs that the respondent-defendant was a licensee was
nothing but a concocted story. Because the respondentdefendant all along possessed the suit land with the
permission of said Sikha Rani Saha and constructed his
permanent structure therein and further submitted that there
is no evidence on record that possession of the suit property
at any point of time was handed over to the appellantplaintiff No.1 by said Sikha Rani Saha and prayed for
dismissal of this appeal. Now, I would like to refer herein
below the relevant provisions of Section 122 and 123 of the
Transfer of Property Act:
Section 122:
―122.―Gift‖ defined.―Gift‖ is the
transfer of certain existing movable or
immovable property made voluntarily
and without consideration, by one
person, called the donor, to another,
called the donee, and accepted by or
on behalf of the donee.
Acceptance when to be made.—Such
acceptance must be made during the
lifetime of the donor and while he is
still capable of giving.
If the donee dies before acceptance,
the gift is void.‖
Section 123:
―123. Transfer how effected.- For the
purpose of making a gift of immovable
property,
the
transfer
must
be
effected by a registered instrument
signed by or on behalf of the donor,
and
attested
by
at
least
two
witnesses.
For the purpose of making a gift of
movable property, the transfer may be
effected
either
by
a
registered
instrument signed as aforesaid or by
delivery.
Such delivery may be made in the
same way as goods sold may be
delivered.‖
From the aforesaid provisions, it appears that for
the purpose of making a Gift of immovable property, the
transfer must be effected by a registered instrument signed
by or on behalf of the donor and attested by at least two
witnesses.
15.
Here in the given case, through Exhibit-1 the suit
property was transferred to the appellant-plaintiff No.1,
according to the appellant-plaintiffs. But Sikha Rani Saha,
the mother of the parties denied the execution of any such
Gift Deed in favour of appellant-plaintiff No.1 through
Exhibit-1. Said Sikha Rani Saha, although during her
evidence, denied the execution of any Gift Deed by her in
favour of appellant-plaintiff No.1. But the respondentdefendant in the pleading took a different stand in para
No.21 of the written statement, wherein it was mentioned
that “the alleged Deed was caused to be executed by her
son, Nitailal Saha, Plaintiff no-1 without informing her in
details about the transfer of the property and that she was
unable to read the contents of the deed as it was written in
English and she intends to distribute this property amongst
her all sons and daughters.”
16.
On bare perusal of the pleading, as aforesaid, it
appears
that
the
respondent
took
the
plea
of
misrepresentation, but it was not mentioned that Sikha Rani
Saha did not execute any Exhibit-1 in favour of plaintiffappellant-plaintiff No.1. Now, the question comes since said
Sikha Rani Saha stood as witness on behalf of the contesting
respondent denying the execution of Deed, so, whether the
appellant-plaintiffs have been able to prove the Exhibit-1, as
per law or not. In this regard, I would like to refer herein
below the relevant provisions of Section 67 and 68 of the
Evidence Act which provides as under:
Section 67:―67.
Proof
of
signature
and
handwriting of person alleged to have
signed
or
written
document
produced.- If a document is alleged to
be signed or to have been written
wholly or in part by any person, the
signature or the handwriting of so
much of the document as is alleged to
be in that person's handwriting must
be proved to be in his handwriting.‖
Section 68:―68. Proof of execution of document
required by law to be attested.--If a
document is required by law to be
attested, it shall not be used as
evidence until one attesting witness at
least has been called for the purpose
of proving its execution, if there be an
attesting witness alive, and subject to
the process of the Court and capable
of giving evidence:
[Provided
that
it
shall
not
be
necessary to call an attesting witness
in proof of the execution of any
document, not being a will, which has
been registered in accordance with the
provisions of the Indian Registration
Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), unless its
execution by the person by whom it
purports to have been executed is
specifically denied.]‖
17.
In course of hearing, further Learned Senior
Counsel for the appellant-plaintiffs has drawn the attention
of
the
Court
referring
the
definition
of
‘attested’
as
prescribed in Section 3 of Transfer of Property Act and
submitted that the present appellant-plaintiffs had complied
with the requirements of law in proving the Deed of Gift. He
also in support of his contention referred the provision of
Section 91 of the Evidence Act, regarding this matter and
further submitted that since the appellant-plaintiffs have/had
got valid title over the suit property, so, in view of Section 8
of the Transfer of Property Act, no further relief regarding
title was required to be sought for at the time of filing of this
suit before the Learned Trial Court. Now, for the sake of
convenience, I would like to mention herein below, the
relevant provisions of Section 3 and Section 8 of Transfer of
Property Act and Section 91 of Evidence Act:
Section 3 of Transfer of Property Act:
―3. Interpretation clause.—
In this Act, unless there is something
repugnant in the subject or context,—
―attested‖,
in
relation
to
an
instrument, means and shall be
deemed
always
to
have
meant
attested by two or more witnesses
each of whom has seen the executant
sign or affix his mark to the
instrument, or has seen some other
person sign the instrument in the
presence and by the direction of the
executant, or has received from the
executant
a
personal
acknowledgement of his signature or
mark, or of the signature of such other
person, and each of whom has signed
the instrument in the presence of the
executant;
but it
shall
not be
necessary that more than one of such
witnesses shall have been present at
the same time, and no particular form
of attestation shall be necessary;‖
Section 8 of Transfer of Property Act:
―8. Operation of transfer.- Unless a
different intention is expressed or
necessarily implied, a transfer of
property passes forthwith to the
transferee all the interest which the
transferor is then capable of passing
in the property, and in the legal
incidents thereof.‖
Section 91 of Evidence Act:
―91. Evidence of terms of contracts,
grants and other dispositions of
property reduced to form of document.
–– When the terms of a contract, or of
a grant, or of any other disposition of
property, have been reduced to the
form of a document, and in all cases in
which any matter is required by law to
be reduced to the form of a document,
no evidence shall be given in proof of
the terms of such contract, grant or
other disposition of property, or of
such matter, except the document
itself, or secondary evidence of its
contents in cases in which secondary
evidence is admissible under the
provisions hereinbefore contained.‖
18.
The appellant-plaintiff No.1, in course of his
examination
relied
upon
Gift
Deed
No.1-676
dated
17.04.2009, executed by Sikha Rani Saha in favour of him,
which was marked as Exhibit-1 and he identified the
signature on said Exhibit-1 as a Donee which was marked as
Exhibit-1(i). PW3, in course of his examination-in-chief,
before the Court below stated that Sikha Rani Saha signed in
the Exhibit-1 in his presence in the house of Sikha Rani Saha
and this witness identified her signature on the Gift Deed
marked as Exhibit 1(ii) series and his signature on Exhibit-1
marked Exhibit-1(iii). Further deposed that by the said Gift
Deed, Sikha Rani Saha gifted the household land to Nitai Lal
Saha and one Siraj Ahamed Khadim read over the Gift Deed
to Sikha Rani Saha and thereafter, said Sikha Rani Saha has
signed the Gift Deed. Further deposed that at the time of
execution of Exhibit-1, Nitai Lal Saha was present and at first
Sikha Rani Saha signed on Exhibit-1, therefore, the witness
himself and other witnesses including Nitai Lal Saha signed.
The contesting respondent by the trend of cross-examination
could not raise any doubt to discard the evidence on record
of the appellant-plaintiffs.
19.
In Renikuntla Rajamma(D) by LRs. v. K.
Sarwanamma dated 17.07.2014 reported in AIR (2014)
SC 2906 wherein in para no.15, Hon’ble the Supreme Court
observed as under:
―15. The matter can be viewed from
yet another angle. Section 123 of the
T.P. Act is in two parts. The first part
deals with gifts of immovable property
while the second part deals with gifts
of movable property. Insofar as the
gifts of immovable property are
concerned,
Section
makes
transfer by a registered instrument
mandatory. This is evident from the
use of word ―transfer must be
effected‖ used by Parliament in so far
as immovable property is concerned.
In contradiction to that requirement
the second part of Section 123 dealing
with gifts of movable property, simply
requires that gift of movable property
may be effected either by a registered
instrument signed as aforesaid or ―by
delivery‖. The difference in the two
provisions lies in the fact that in so far
as the transfer of movable property by
way of gift is concerned the same can
be effected by a registered instrument
or by delivery. Such transfer in the
case of immovable property no doubt
requires a registered instrument but
the provision does not make delivery
of possession of the immovable
property gifted as an additional
requirement for the gift to be valid
and effective. If the intention of the
legislature was to make delivery of
possession of the property gifted also
as a condition precedent for a valid
gift, the provision could and indeed
would have specifically said so.
Absence of any such requirement can
only lead us to the conclusion that
delivery of possession is not an
essential prerequisite for the making
of a valid gift in the case of immovable
property.‖
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel for
the appellant-plaintiffs submitted that as alleged by the
respondent-defendant, delivery of possession is not an
essential prerequisite for making of a Deed of Gift valid in
case of immovable property.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that
since the plaintiffs have been to prove Exhibit-1 as per law,
so, there is/was no scope to disbelieve Exhibit-1.
20.
In
Surendra
Kumar
v.
Nathulal
dated
02.05.2001 reported in AIR (2001) SC 2040 wherein in
para no.12, Hon’ble Supreme of India further observed as
under:
―12. Section 123 of the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 provides:
―123. Transfer how effected.- For the
purpose of making a gift of immovable
property,
the
transfer
must
be
effected by a registered instrument
signed by or on behalf of the donor,
and
attested
by
at
least
two
witnesses.‖
In the present case there exists a
registered deed of gift signed by the
donor and attested by two witnesses.
Therefore, the requirement of the law
as incorporated in the Section is
satisfied. Section 68 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 makes a provision
regarding proof of execution of a
document required by law to be
attested. Therein it is laid down that:
―If a document is required by law to
be attested, it shall not be used as
evidence until one attesting witness at
least has been called for the purpose
of proving its execution, if there be an
attesting witness alive, and subject to
the process of the Court and capable
of giving evidence.‖
The proviso to the section, which is
relevant for the present purpose,
reads:
―Provided that
it
shall not
be
necessary to call an attesting witness
in proof of the execution of any
document, not being a will, which has
been registered in accordance with the
provisions of the Indian Registration
Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), unless its
execution by the person by whom it
purports to have been executed is
specifically denied.‖
(Emphasis supplied)
On a plain reading of the proviso, it is
manifest that a registered deed of gift
can be received in evidence without
examining one of the attestors if the
person who has executed the deed of
gift has not specifically denied its
execution. In the present case, the
donor Chand Bai has specifically
admitted execution of the deed of gift
in favour of the appellant. Therefore,
the lower appellate Court was in error
in holding that the deed of gift has not
been duly proved since one of the
attestors has not been examined as
witness. Indeed the certified copy of
the registered deed of gift was
produced in the trial Court along with
an application filed by the plaintiff in
the
previous
suit,
Suit
No.69/70(4/76) that the same may be
called for. The trial Court, being
satisfied about the reason for nonproduction of the original document,
marked the certified copy of the deed
of gift as Exhibit-3.‖
21.
In V. Prabhakara v. Bas avaraj K.(Dead) by
Legal Representatives and another dated 07.10.2021
reported in (2022) 1 SCC 115, Hon’ble the Supreme Court
of India in para No.16 observed as under:
―16. Section 68 of the Evidence Act,
1872 speaks of a requirement of
proving the execution of a document
required by law to be attested. This
provision being mandatory as the
word employed is ―shall‖, meaning
thereby it shall not be used as
evidence unless one attesting witness
at least has been called for to prove its
execution. When it comes to proving a
Will, Section 68 of the Act is
mandatorily to be followed. This
provision has to be seen and read
along
with
Section
of
the
Succession
Act
which
not
only
mandates a compulsory attestation
but reiterates compliance of section
68 of the Evidence Act.‖
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel for
the appellant-plaintiffs submitted that to prove the Deed of
Gift (Exhibit-1) Section 67 of evidence Act would not be
applied in this case rather Section 68 of the Evidence Act
would be applied and the present appellant-plaintiffs have
been able to prove the Gift Deed in accordance with the
provision of Section 68 of the Evidence Act.
22.
Further, Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant-
plaintiffs relied upon another judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Brij Raj Singh (dead) by L.Rs. and
others v. Sewak Ram and another dated 22.04.1999,
reported in AIR (1999) SC 2203 wherein Learned Apex
Court in para No. 17, 18, 25, 26 observed as under:
―17. The High Court, however, has
rightly noticed that the gift deed was
executed by Kanwar Chander Raj
Saran Singh. However, the High Court
held that the gift deed has not been
duly attested as required under
section 123 of the Transfer of Property
Act. The High Court in the course of
judgment observed as follows:―From the perusal of the gift deed, it is
quite evident that this was executed
by Kanwar Chander Raj Saran Singh
on 18.1.1961. No one has signed as a
witness to the document. The scribe
Ram Saran Dass has written "dated
18th January, 1961 Bakalam Ram
Saran Dass". Later on, on 9th of
February, 1961, the said document
was presented for registration by one
Janardhan
Sharma
who
claimed
himself to be the Mokhtiar-a-Aam of
donor Kanwar Chander Raj Saran
Singh.
The
necessary
power
of
attorney in his favour dated 18th of
February, 1953 was also produced
before the Sub-Registrar as is evident
from his endorsement made on 9th of
February, 1961. He was identified
before the Sub-Registrar by Ram
Saran Dass the scribe and one Shabha
Ram. According to the learned Counsel
for the appellant, since Janardhan
Sharma, the Mukhtiar-a-Aam of the
donor Kanwar Chander Raj Saran
Singh admitted the execution of the
document before the Sub-Registrar
and Ram Saran Dass, the scribe and
Shabha Ram attested the same before
Sub-Registrar it
will amount to
attestation as required under section
123 of the Transfer of Property Act. In
support of this contention, he relied
upon Girja Datt Singh v. Gangotri Datt
Singh, AIR 1955 SC 346 and Narain
Singh v. Parsa Singh alias Parsu, 1971
Cur LJ 195.
After the hearing the learned Counsel
for the parties at a great length, as
observed earlier, it appears that
before the trial Court no such
objection was taken specifically either
at the time of admission of the
document Exhibit P.W.5/1 or at the
time of the arguments. It was only at
the appellate stage that this objection
was taken on behalf of the defendant
that the gift deed on the basis of
which the plaintiff claimed himself to
be owner of the site in dispute, is not
a valid document as it was never
attested by any of the witnesses as
required
under
the
Transfer
of
Property Act. This objection prevailed
with the lower appellate Court. The
argument of the learned Counsel for
the appellant that the admission made
by Janardhan Sharma, Mukhtiar-aAam of the donor and signed by the
scribe Ram Saran Dass and Shabha
Ram before the Sub-Registrar, will
amount to attestation, has no merit.
The document was required to be
attested at the time when it was
actually executed on 18.1.1961 by
Kanwar Chander Raj Saran Singh.
Since no one attested the document at
that time, the subsequent signatures
of the scribe and Shabha Ram who
identified
the
Mukhtiar-a-Aam
Janardhan Sharma before the SubRegistrar, could not fill up the lacuna.
Under sub-section (2) of Section 35 of
the Registration Act, the registering
officer may, in order to satisfy himself
that the persons appearing before him
are the persons
they represent
themselves to be or for any other
purpose contemplated by this Act,
examine any one present in his office.
Thus Ram Saran Dass and Shabha Ram
only identified the Mukhtiar-a-Aam
Janardhan Sharma in order to satisfy
the registering officer. In Timavva
Dundappa
Budihal
v.
Channava
Appaya Kanasgeri, AIR 1948 Bom 322,
it has been held that signatures made
by the Sub-Registrar while he made
endorsement
on
the
document
admitting it to registration and the
signatures of the identifying witnesses
made by them when they identified
the
executant
before
the
SubRegistrar cannot be regarded as the
signatures of attesting witnesses.
Moreover, at the time of registration,
the donor himself did not appear. It
was
only
his
Mukhtiar-a-Aam
Janardhan Sharma who presented the
same for registration on his behalf.
The authorities relied upon by the
learned Counsel for the appellant, are
not at all applicable to the facts of the
present
case
and
are
clearly
distinguishable. Since, there was no
attestation witness at the time of the
execution of the document on 18th of
January, 1961, the lower appellate
Court rightly came to the conclusion
that the gift deed, if is taken away as
not duly executed, the plaintiff cannot
be held to be the owner of the suit
land because he claimed his title on
the basis of the gift deed alone.‖
―18. At this stage, let us extract the
relevant
section
in
Transfer
of
Property Act and Evidence Act.
Transfer of Property Act:S. 3. In this Act, unless there is
something repugnant in the subject or
context, "Attested"
in
relation
to
an
instrument, means and shall be
deemed
always
to
have
meant
attested by two or more witnesses
each of whom has been the executant
sign or affix his mark to the
instrument, or has seen some other
person sign the instrument in the
presence and by the direction of the
executant, or has received from the
executant
a
personal
acknowledgement of his signature or
mark, or of the signature of such other
person, and each of whom has signed
the instrument in the presence of the
executant;
but it
shall
not be
necessary that more than one of such
witnesses shall have been present at
the same time, and no particular form
of attestation shall be necessary. [only
relevant portion is set out]
"S.123. For the purpose of making a
gift of immoveable property, the
transfer must be effected by a
registered instrument signed by or on
behalf of the donor, and attested by at
least two witnesses.
For the purpose of making a gift of
moveable property, the transfer may
be effected either by a registered
instrument signed as aforesaid or by
delivery.
Such delivery may be made in the
same way as goods sold may be
delivered."
The Indian Evidence Act
"S. 68. Proof of executing of document
required by law to be attested - If a
document is required by law to be
attested, it shall not be used as
evidence until one attesting witness at
least has been called for the purpose
of proving its execution, if there be an
attesting witness alive, and subject to
the process of the Court and capable
of giving evidence :
Provided that it shall not be necessary
to call an attesting witness in proof of
the execution of any document, not
being
a
will,
which
has
been
registered in accordance with the
provisions of the Indian Registration
Act, 1908 (16 of 1908), unless its
execution by the person by whom it
purports to have been executed is
specifically denied.‖
―25. We do not want to add the
citation except to refer a judgment of
the Guwahati High Court in Dhiren
Bailung v. Bhutuki, AIR 1972 Gauhati
44, wherein the Court held as follows:"All that Section 68 demands before a
document requiring attestation can be
used as evidence is that one attesting
witness at least should be called "for
the purpose of proving its execution".
It has been stated above that one
attesting witness was called in the
present case and he testified that
Sashi and Paniram had executed the
mortgage deed Ex. 1 in his presence
by placing their signatures on it and
that he had attested the document.
Therefore, the requirements of Section
68 were evidently satisfied. However,
the two courts below were of the
opinion that it was incumbent upon
the plaintiff to establish before he
could succeed in that suit, the
attestation of the deed by two
witnesses, as enjoined by section 59
of Transfer of Property Act, in the
manner required by section 3 thereof
where the expression "attested" is
defined. I find it difficult to endorse
that opinion. AIR 1932 All 527 (FB)
Lachman Singh v. Surendra Bahadur,
is an authority for the propositions
that Sections 68 and 69 of the
Evidence Act" make a document which
is attested admissible in evidence if
the requirements of those sections are
complied with" and that "if the
documents become admissible in
evidence they become admissible to
prove what they contain. That is to
say, they would become admissible to
prove whether a mortgage had been
executed or a gift had been made".
There seems to be no warrant for an
argument the Full Bench observed that
a deed may be merely admissible and
yet may be incapable of being read as
a document of the kind which it
professes to be. The Full Bench
clinched the issue by stating further
that to make a mortgage deed or a gift
deed admissible in evidence as a deed
of mortgage or gift, as the case may
be, it is enough to comply with the
provisions of section 68 or S. 69 of the
Evidence Act. However, it was added
that if the question raised is whether
the document did create a mortgage
or gift or not, it must be proved that
the requirements of law as contained
in Sections 59 and 123, Transfer of
Property Act, have been complied
with. I respectfully agree with these
observations of the Full Bench.
Therefore, the precise question that
falls for determination in the present
appeal is whether, on the pleadings of
the parties, there arises a question
whether the deed Ext. 1 does or does
not create a mortgage."
..........................................................
…….. "To sum up, I hold that the
defendants had denied only the
execution of the mortgage deed, that
they had not challenged its due
attestation, that the legality of the
mortgage deed was assailed on the
specific
ground
that
Sashi
and
Paniram had no exclusive right to
mortgage the land in dispute, and that
the parties went to trial only on the
specific allegations adopted by them
in their written pleadings. I hold
further that in the context of the
parties’ pleadings the plaintiff was
called upon to prove only the
execution of the mortgage deed, that
the execution is proved by the
testimony of Harakanta Duara, an
attesting witness, and plaintiff's father
Tularam, and that the testimony of the
Harakanta Duara constitutes enough
of compliance with the statutory
requirements set out in the body of
Section 68. Hence the mortgage
pleaded by the plaintiff is proved
beyond doubt."
―26. We are of the view that the above
extracts from the judgments of the
various High Courts do reflect the
correct position in law. In the case on
hand PW 6 has categorically stated
that he has signed as scribe, signed as
witness and signed as identifying
witness. We also find his signatures at
three places. Nothing was elicited
from this witness to disbelieve his
statement in Chief Examination. It is
not denied that the deed was
registered
as
per
the
Indian
Registration Act. Therefore even on
merits the appellant has established
the due execution and attestation of
the gift deed according to law. We find
from the original gift deed at the first
page by the side of signatures of the
donor, two witnesses have subscribed
their signatures. We, therefore, hold
that the lower appellate Court and the
High Court went wrong in allowing the
defendants to raise the plea of noncompliance of Section 123 of the
Transfer of Property Act and in holding
that the gift deed was not proved.‖
Referring the above, Learned Senior Counsel for
the
appellant-plaintiffs
submitted
that
in
view
of
the
principles of aforesaid citation, the appellant-plaintiffs have
been able to prove Exhibit-1 as per law. But the Learned
First Appellate Court failed to appreciate the legal provisions
and came to an erroneous observation that Exhibit-1 was not
valid in the eye of law and it was suspicious.
23.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, for
the respondents as already stated, in support of his
contention drawn the attention of the Court that the
appellant-plaintiffs have failed to comply with the provision
of Section 67 of the Evidence Act. He further submitted that
there was no acceptance of the Gift Deed, as required by law
and further submitted that no possession was handed over to
the appellant-plaintiffs by said Sikha Rani Saha and since
said Sikha Rani Saha denied the execution of Deed. So,
Learned First Appellate Court rightly delivered the judgment
in favour of the respondent-defendant. Furthermore, Learned
Senior Counsel also submitted that the appellant-plaintiffs
did not approach to the Court with clean hands, because he
did not seek any specific relief for title, only sought relief for
khas possession and more so, Exhibit-1 was also not proved
in accordance with law. He further submitted that as alleged
by the appellant-plaintiffs the respondent-defendant was not
a licensee as per Easement Act, because the Easement Act
has not been adopted in the State of Tripura.
24.
In Panchugopal Barua and others v. Umesh
Chandra Goswami and others dated 12.02.1997, reported
in AIR (1997) SC 1041, Hon’ble the Supreme Court in para
no. 13 observed as under:
―13. The approach of the learned
Single Judge in our opinion was
erroneous. Once it was found that
the Easements Act had no application
to the State of Assam, the question of
"clearing the way for Section 60(b) of
the Act to operate" cannot at all arise.
Of course, the principles of "justice,
equity and good conscience" on
which Section 60(b) of the Easements
Act rests may apply in the facts and
circumstances of a given case but that
is
not
to
say
that
though
the Easements Act does not apply,
provisions of Section 60(b) of the
Easements Act still "operate". Since,
the legislature did not intend the Act
to apply to Assam, the learned Single
Judge could not have defeated that
intendment by holding that "the
defendant of the present case was
protected by Section 60(b) of the Act."
It is not permissible to extend the
provisions of an Act, made not
applicable by the legislature to a
State, by a judicial order as it amounts
to enacting legislation by the High
Court, a power not vested in the
judiciary.‖
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that the plea of the appellant-plaintiffs cannot be
accepted.
25.
In Prem Singh and Others v. Birbal and
Others dated 02.05.2006, reported in (2006) 5 SCC 353,
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in para no. 16 observed as
under:
―16. When a document is valid, no
question arises of its cancellation.
When a document is void ab initio, a
decree for setting aside the same
would not be necessary as the same is
non est in the eye of the law, as it
would be a nullity.‖
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further submitted that since Exhibit-1 has been failed to be
proved as per law by the appellant-plaintiffs, so, as alleged
by Learned Counsel for the appellant-plaintiffs no separate
suit was required on behalf of said Sikha Rani Saha to cancel
the Deed (Exhibit-1) in view of the principles of the aforesaid
citations as it was non est.
26.
He also relied upon another citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Subhra Mukherjee and Another v.
Bharat Coking Coal LTD. and Others dated 08.03.2000,
reported in (2000) 3 SCC 312 in para no. 12, observed as
under:
―12. There can be no dispute that a
person who attacks a transaction as
sham, bogus and fictitious must prove
the same. But a plain reading of
Question 1 discloses that it is in two
parts; the first part says, ―whether the
transaction in question is a bona fide
and genuine one‖ which has to be
proved by the appellants. It is only
when this has been done that the
respondent has to dislodge it by
proving that it is a sham and fictitious
transaction. When the circumstances
of the case and the intrinsic evidence
on record clearly point out that the
transaction is not bona fide and
genuine, it is unnecessary for the
court to find out whether the
respondent has led any evidence to
show that the transaction is sham,
bogus or fictitious.‖
Referring the same, he submitted that it was the
responsibility of the appellant-plaintiffs to prove the case.
More so, said Sikha Rani Saha was not made party in the suit
by the appellant-plaintiffs and finally, submitted that since,
DW-6 denied execution of Exhibit-1, so, it was the duty of
the Learned Trial Court to take steps for examining the
signatures through Scientific Expert. But the Learned Trial
Court ignoring the legal position by order dated 21.07.2017,
came to an wrong observation that it was not necessary to
take expert opinion and gave a perverse finding but the
Learned Appellate Court, after hearing both the sides, rightly
and reasonably reversed the judgment of the Learned Trial
Court and urged for dismissal of the appeal.
27.
I have heard submission of the Learned Counsels
at length, perused the principles of the aforesaid citations
relied upon by the parties and also gone through the records
of the Learned Court below including the evidence on record
both oral and documentary. After hearing both the sides, it
appears to me that to prove a Deed of Gift valid, and also for
effecting a Gift of Deed, registration is required as per law
and that Deed should be proved as per Section 68 of the
Evidence Act and furthermore, to prove a Gift Deed it is not
required that possession should be given to the Donee by the
donor at the time of execution of Deed of Gift. Here in the
case at hand, it is proved that the appellant-plaintiffs have
been able to prove Exhibit-1 as per law. Although, DW-6,
being the executant of the Deed denied her signature on the
same but on perusal of Exhibit-1 and Exhibit-A series and
also of Exhibit-E, it appears that in those documents she had
given her signatures. But at the time of recording her
evidence by Commission, she gave her thumb impression
and in course of her cross-examination, she specifically
stated that she could not recollect as to whether she put her
signatures or not and although she denied her signatures,
thereafter an application was submitted by the appellantplaintiffs
for
taking
expert
opinion
in
respect
of
her
signatures, but the Learned Trial Court below, after detailed
hearing, by order dated 21.07.2017 came to an observation
that there was no necessity to take any expert opinion and
furthermore, the respondent-defendant, in their pleading did
not deny that said Sikha Rani Saha did not execute the Gift
Deed rather took a different plea that she could not
understand the contents of the Deed as Nitai Lal Saha
without informing her in details took her signatures and
furthermore, challenging the Gift Deed, neither said Sikha
Rani Saha nor the respondent-defendant filed any suit for
cancellation of Exhibit-1.
28.
It is to be noted here that said Sikha Rani Saha is
staying
with
the
contesting
respondent
in
the
same
residence. So, it is quite natural that she would support the
case
of
the
responde0nt-defendant.
Furthermore,
the
Exihbit-1 was executed in the year 2009 but as already
stated, challenging Exhibit-1, said Sikha Rani Saha did not
file
any
suit
in
any
forum.
More
so,
the
contesting
respondent as DW-1, during his cross-examination by the
appellant-plaintiffs stated that in year 2011/2012, for the
first time he had seen the Gift Deed executed in favour of
plaintiff No.1 by his mother. Even after knowing the same,
no step was taken on his behalf to challenge the Gift Deed.
28.
It also appears that the plea of Sikha Rani Saha
was not mentioned in the written statement filed by the
contesting respondent as required under Order VI, Rule 4 of
C.P.C, which provides as under:
Order VI, Rule 4 of C.P.C:4. Particulars to be given where
necessary.- In all cases in which the
party
pleading
relies
on
any
misrepresentation, fraud, breach of
trust,
wilful
default,
or
undue
influence, and in all other cases in
which particulars may be necessary
beyond such as are exemplified in the
forms aforesaid, particulars (with
dates and items if necessary) shall be
stated in the pleading.
There was no explanation in this regard from the
side of the respondent-defendant.
30.
So, after analyzing the evidence on record, it
appears that the Learned First Appellate Court, without
proper appreciation of the legal provisions of law came to an
observation that Exhibit-1 was made under suspicious
circumstances and the appellant-plaintiffs did not comply
with Section 67 of the Evidence Act and thus, came to an
erroneous finding reversing the judgment of the Learned
Trial Court, which in my considered view, Learned First
Appellate Court wrongly passed/delivered. So, after hearing
both the sides, it appears that the substantial questions of
law as formulated leans in favour of the present appellantplaintiffs of this case and Exhibit-1 was executed by Sikha
Rani Saha in favour of appellant-plaintiff No.1.
31.
In the result, the appeal filed by the present
appellant-plaintiffs is hereby allowed on contest with costs.
The judgment and decree dated 23.02.2022 and 02.03.2022
respectively passed by Learned Additional District Judge,
Gomati District, in connection with T.A. No.26 of 2017
reversing the judgment and decree dated 28.08.2017 passed
by the Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division in Title Suit No.
18 of 2016 is hereby set aside. The appellant-plaintiffs are
entitled to get the decree of recovery of khas possession of
the suit property against the respondent-defendant. The
respondent-defendant be asked to handover the possession
of this suit property to the appellant-plaintiffs within a period
of 60(sixty) days failing which the appellant-plaintiffs shall
recover the same by due process of law.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly and send down the
LCRs.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.02.28 18:06:48
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review