Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
Arb.P. No.08 of 2023
Sri Niroj Kanti Dhar
......... Petitioner(s);
Versus
The State of Tripura & another
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. G.K. Nama, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
25/01/2024
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
Petitioner seeks appointment of an independent Arbitrator in terms
of Clause 22.1 and 22.2 of the agreement and the work order dated 14.09.2016
issued by the Executive Engineer, Kumarghat Division PWD (R&B),
Kumarghat, Unakoti Tripura in respect of the dispute in relation to execution of
“Construction of 1000 seated capacity town hall at Kumarghat, Unakoti
District, Tripura/SH Building and ancillary works. Reference is made to the
order dated 11.01.2024 which is quoted hereunder :
“Heard Mr. G. K. Nama, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. M.
Debbarma, learned additional Government Advocate for the State.
[2]
Petitioner seeks appointment of an Independent Arbitrator in terms of Clause
22.1 and 22.2 of the agreement bearing No.19/CE/EE/KD/2016-17 and the work order
dated 14.09.2016 issued by the Executive Engineer, Kumarghat Division, PWD(R&B),
Kumarghat, Unakoti Tripura in respect of the dispute which has arisen in connection with
the execution of the construction of 1000 seated capacity town hall at Kumarghat,
Unakoti Distric, Tripura/SH: Building portion including acoustic works, internal water
supply, sanitary installations and other miscellaneous works for an estimated cost of
Rs.5,28,42,157/- which was awarded in favour of the petitioner at 11% below the
tendered value.
[3]
According to the petitioner the work was to be completed within a period of 24
months with effect from 29.09.2016 to 29.09.2018. However, the work would not be
completed within the stipulated period due to fault on the part of the Department. The
extension of time was granted lastly up to 07.03.2022 in various stages. By referring to
letter dated 10.02.2022 (Annexure-2) the petitioner contends that the complete drawing
of the work was handed over after 6(six) years of the work order. The cost of materials
and other ancillary expenses including wage of labourers increased substantially.
Therefore, the petitioner vide letter dated 28.02.2022 requested the Department to
consider the issue of price escalation. He made representation on 07.11.2022 (Annexure4) to the Executive Engineer, Kumarghat Division, PWD(R&B), Kumarghat, Unakoti
Tripura with a request to close the agreement and (i) release the payments for the work
done, (ii) finalizing the earth work done in cutting the tilla land, (iii) releasing price
escalation as per clause 10 of the CC, (iv) cost on loss on overhead as per law of land and
(v) loss of profit with interest. However, since the request was not heeded to he made
representation on 16th January 2023(Annexur-5) to the Superintending Engineer, 1st
Circle, PWD(R&B), Kumrghat, Unakoti Tripura under clause 22.2 along with the claims
for early decisions. Having failed to elicit any response he then approached the Chief
Engineer, PWD (Building), Capital Complex, P.O. Knjaban, Agartala, West Tripura,
respondent No.2 for appointment of an Arbitrator under clause 22.2 of the Conditions of
Contract (Anexure-6). On failure to do so he approached this court for appointment of an
independent Arbitrator.
[4]
Mr. G. K. Nama, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the delay in
execution of the work is not on the part of the contractor. Therefore, the dispute may be
referred to an independent Arbitrator to decide the claims.
[5]
Respondents have appeared and filed a counter affidavit. The relevant details of
the execution of the works, the agreement entered into with the petitioner, the relevant
dates for completion of the work are not disputed by the respondents. However, it is
stated that the petitioner vide letter dated 28.02.2017 requested the concerned Executive
Engineer to provide layout of construction and design & drawing so that the work may be
started without further delay. The petitioner had exhausted almost 5(five) months in earth
excavation work by then. Thereafter, the Executive Engineer, vide letter dated
26.04.2017 and 27.02.2018 (Annexure-R/2 and R/3) had asked the petitioner to submit
bar chart so that the work could be completed within stipulated period but the petitioner
did not submit the same. The respondents further referred to Clause-65(1.2) of Section VI
of the Agreement which requires that one set of drawings shall be furnished free of cost
to the Bidder. Drawings for any particular activity shall be issued to the Bidder at least
30 days in advance of the scheduled date of the start of the activity. However, no extra
claims by the Bidder towards any delay in issuance of drawing or change in drawings
shall be admissible. The Superintending Engineer shall intimate the Bidder 7 days in
advance regarding any delay in issuance of drawings, for any particular stage of works.
For any delay due to issuance of drawings, for any particular stage of work the Bidder
shall be granted extension of time. The respondents had further stated that the petitioner
was responsible for not submitting the bar chart of work programme and as such
department cannot be blamed for delay in issuance of drawings without the bar chart. It is
further stated that the petitioner was unable to maintain the steadiness of the work as
because proportionate progress of the work is not satisfactorily and the work may not be
completed within stipulated period of time i.e. 28.09.2018. He was asked to expedite the
work vide letter dated 26.04.2017. The petitioner has a very poor degree of workmanship
& was unable to get an electrical service connection for the worksite. The concerned
Executive Engineer took all initiative and extended all possible assistance by forwarding
his letter dated 04.05.2017 to the Deputy General Manager, Electrical Division No.V,
Kumarghat, Unakoti Tripura regarding installation of service connection at the worksite.
Moreover, the petitioner had failed to arrange raw materials like sand, wood etc. for
execution of the work. In that respect also his request was forwarded to the SubDivisional Forest Officer, Kumarghat vide letter dated 03.05.2018. It is thus clear that all
cooperation was made by the Executive Engineer by extending necessary assistance to
the petitioner to complete the work within time. In spite of that progress of the work was
at a snail’s pace. Petitioner had a poor infrastructure for execution of the work. It is stated
that petitioner has vide letter dated 21.01.2020 expressed his inability to continue the
work unless Department paid the outstanding bills as per the running accounts bills which
is in violation of the terms and conditions of the contract which is not expected from a 1st
class contractor like the petitioner. Petitioner had also declared that he will suspend the
work for non-payment of the full amount as per running accounts bills submitted by him
which again a violation of the terms and conditions of the contract. It is submitted that
payments were made regularly to the petitioner as per availability of fund. The stipulated
date for completion of work was 09.03.2021 and thereafter, extension of time was
granted by the competent authority in public interest. The petitioner after elapse of
stipulated date of completion of the work verbally requested to consider the price
escalation for balance work to be carried out and only then he would continue to work.
However, the executive engineer also informed him verbally that time extension will be
granted in due course but other points are to be considered as per clauses of the
Agreement. The petitioner, thereafter, suspended his work vide letter dated 28.02.2020.
The respondents rely upon clause 44.1 of the agreement and submit that there is no
provision for price escalation and price adjustment is not applicable for the work for
which stipulated time for completion is less than or equal to 24 months. At para 4.16 of
the affidavit the respondent stated that on availability of fund Rs.5,86,00,000/- was paid
to the petitioner.
[6]
Mr. M. Debbarma, learned additional Government Advocate for the State
submits that the delay in execution of the work is completely attributable to the petitioner
and not to the Department. The time extension was granted in the interest of the public
service for completion of the work and the petitioner agreed to execute balance work. He
also refers to Clause-54.5(b) of the agreement which provides that cost difference for
balance unexecuted work is recoverable from the petitioner. He submits that the delay is
completely attributable to the petitioner and there is no scope for price escalation/ price
adjustment as per clauses of the agreement. Dispute is, therefore, not amenable to
arbitration.
[7]
Mr. G. K. Nama, learned counsel for the petitioner in reply submits that the
averments made in the counter affidavit do not deny the existence of a dispute relating to
price escalation and price adjustment due to delay in execution of work for which
extension of time was granted by the respondents themselves. This Court in exercise of
the powers under Section 11(6a) of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 is not
required to examine the merits of the dispute between the parties. Instead, if the
arbitration clause provides for appointment of an Arbitrator on the existence of a dispute
arising out of the agreement in question, reference may kindly be made to an independent
Arbitrator since the respondent No.2 has failed to discharge his contractual responsibility
in appointment of an independent Arbitrator in terms of clause 22.2 of the agreement. He
submitted that since the respondents are the employees of the department, therefore in
view of the neutrality principle an independent Arbitrator could only be appointed.
[8]
I have considered the submission of the learned counsel for the parties
and taken note of the material pleadings. The petitioner has prayed for appointment of an
Arbitrator in connection with the agreement (certified copy which has been placed by the
petitioner) and the work order dated 14.09.2016 in respect of the dispute relating to
payment of dues towards the items such as balance outstanding payments for work done
but not measured, price escalation, loss on overhead etc. as per representation made by
the petitioner to the Executive Engineer, Kumarghat Division, PWD(R&B), Kumarghat,
Unakoti Tripura; the Superintending Engineer, 1 st Circle, PWD(R&B), Kumarghat,
Unakoti Tripura and the Chief Engineer, PWD (Bulding), Kinjaban, Agartala,
respondent No.2. The affidavit of the respondents in substance denies the claim of the
petitioner on merits. Statements made by the respondents do not dispute the existence of
an arbitration clause and the disputes raised by the petitioner, though according to them,
substantial payment to the extent of Rs.5,86,00,000/- have already been made in favour
of the petitioner.
[9]
As such, this court is of the view that the petitioner has made out a case for
appointment of an independent arbitrator. I, therefore, propose to appoint Hon’ble Mr.
Justice Subhasis Talapatra, former Chief Justice of Orissa High Court and former Judge
of this Court as an Arbitrator to decide the dispute between the parties. The Registry is
directed to seek consent of His Lordship and a declaration in terms of schedule-VII read
with Section 12(1) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The instant order be
communicated to the learned proposed Arbitrator by the Registry.
Accordingly, list the matter on 25.01.2024 along with the consent and
declaration on the part of the proposed Arbitrator.”
3.
The proposed Arbitrator Hon’ble Mr. Justice Subhasis Talapatra,
former Chief Justice of Orissa High Court and former Judge of this Court has
conveyed his consent for being appointed as an Arbitrator in respect of the
disputes raised by the petitioner referred to herein and also submitted a
declaration in terms of the provisions of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act,
1996.
4.
Learned counsel for the parties, therefore, submit that the proposed
Arbitrator may be appointed to adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
5.
In view of the reasons recorded in the order dated 11.01.2024 and
the consent and declaration submitted by the proposed Arbitrator, I hereby
appoint Hon’ble Mr. Justice Subhasis Talapatra, former Chief Justice of Orissa
High Court and former Judge of this Court, as an Arbitrator to decide the
dispute between the parties. Learned Arbitrator is requested to take into
consideration the Schedule of Model Fees prescribed under Schedule IV and
the timeline prescribed under Section 29-A of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act, 1996 as amended.
6.
Registry is directed to communicate the instant order along with a
copy of the entire pleadings of the instant application to the learned Arbitrator
forthwith.
7.
The instant petition stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
signed by MUNNA SAHA
Pijush/ MUNNA SAHA Digitally
Date: 2024.01.30 11:36:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review