The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 07.2009 is hereby dissolved and, (ii) The defendant No.3 is directed to render correct accounts of the partnership firm to the plaintiff for the period 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12 within 03(three) months from the date of judgment. [51] Thus, the suit is disposed of. [52] Prepare decree accordingly and put-up for signature before me within 14(fourteen) days from today, latest on 20th June, 2022. [53] The judgment is given under my hand and seal of this court on this the 7th June, 2022. [54] Make necessary entry in the relevant trial register and as well as CIS.” [6] The decree was prepared in the following terms: “It is ordered and decreed that*** “In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is hereby decreed on contest with cost with the following decrees: i. The partnership firm under the name and style of “M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks Industries” the defendant No.1, constituted by the plaintiff and the defendant Nos.2, 3, 4 and 5 by a registered Deed of Partnership vide No.IV-134 dated
10. 07.2009 is hereby dissolved and ii. The defendant No.3 is directed to render correct accounts of the partnership firm to the plaintiff for the period 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12 within 03(three) months for the date of judgment. Thus, the suit is disposed of. Prepare decree accordingly and put-up for signature before me within 14(fourteen) days from today, latest on 20th June, 2022.” [7] Petitioner was aggrieved as the findings in relation to issue Nos. (iv) & (viii) relating to proportionate share of fixed/immovable assets and movable assets of the Firm and the share of the plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 5 in the capital, assets and liabilities of the Partnership Firm on the date of the dissolution were not incorporated in the decree. The learned court rendered its findings on the issue Nos. (iv) & (viii) in the judgment dated 7th June, 2022 but in the operative part of the judgment it only held that the partnership firm under the name and style of “M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks Industries” the defendant No.1, constituted by the plaintiff and the defendant Nos.2, 3, 4 and 5 by a registered Deed of Partnership dated 10.07.2009 was dissolved. Further, defendant No.3 was directed to render correct accounts of the partnership firm to the plaintiff for the period 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12 within 03(three) months from the date of judgment. The suit was disposed of with a direction to pr…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.39 of 2023
Sri Nirode Chandra Das
.………Petitioner(s)
Versus
M/s Rajlaxmi Bricks Industries and others
……Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Abir Baran, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Kawsik Nath, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
04/01/2024
Heard Mr. Abir Baran, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Kawsik Nath,
learned counsel for the respondents No.1 to 8.
[2]
The petitioner has approached this Court after rejection of his
application under Section 152 of the Civil Procedure Code for correction of
decree vide impugned order dated 6th June, 2023. The judgment in Title Suit
No.05 of 2014, was delivered on 07th June, 2022 by the Court of the learned
Civil Judge (Senior Division), South Tripura, Belonia. The suit was for
rendition of accounts and dissolution of partnership between the plaintiff and
the private parties who are respondent Nos.1 to 8 in the present petition. The
plaintiff had prayed before the court for the following reliefs:
“A. Directing the defendant No.3 to render accounts of the partnership firm
for the period from 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12 within a period as directed
by the learned Court during proceeding of the suit.
B. For decree for dissolution of Partnership Firm under the name and style of
“M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks Industries”, the defendant No.1, constituted by the
plaintiff and the defendant Nos.2, 3, 4 & 5 by a registered Deed of
Partnership dated 10.07.2009.
C. An interim order directing the defendants Nos. 2 & 3 to liquidate the
outstanding loan lying with S.B.I, Santirbazar Branch, so that the lands of the
plaintiff are not taken over by the said Branch.
D. Any other relief/reliefs to which the plaintiff is entitled according to law,
justice, equity and good conscience and for full cost of the suit.”
[3]
The following issues were framed upon completion of the
pleadings for adjudication by the learned trial court:
i. “Is the suit maintainable in its present form and nature?
ii. Whether the plaintiff is liable to liquidate the outstanding loan amount Rs.
20,00,000/- along with interest as per terms of the Deed of Partnership,
out of which an amount of Rs.5,00,000/- has already been refunded?
iii. Is the plaintiff entitled to get an amount of Rs.3,50,974/- being the share
of profits on the basis of audited accounts submitted by the plaintiff and
for the balance period ended on 30.03.2014 to be audited fresh?
iv. Is the plaintiff entitled to get proportionate share of fixed/ immovable
assets and movable assets of the Firm as per ratio of the plaintiff after
dissolution?
v. Is the plaintiff entitled to get compensation for submitting the
manufacturing and burning of bricks and keeping the industry idle for the
period from 30.06.2013 till dissolution?
vi. Is the defendant No.3 under obligation to render accounts of the
Partnership Firm for the years 2009-2010, 2010-2011 and 2011-2012?
vii. Among the plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 5 who is/are responsible for
liquidate the loan amount secured by the plaintiff from defendant No.6
giving mortgage of the land belonging to the plaintiff?
viii. Is the Partnership Firm under the name and style as “M/S. Rajlaxmi
Bricks Industries” liable to be dissolved, if so, what shall be the share of
the plaintiff and the defendant Nos. 1 to 5 in the capital, assets and
liabilities of the Partnership Firm as on the date of dissolution?
ix. To what other relief/ reliefs the parties are entitled to?”
[4]
The findings of the learned count on issue Nos. (iv) and (vii) are
at para 40 of the judgment which reads as under:
"[40] It is seen that the business of the partnership firm was closed w.e.f.
30.06.2012 and all accessories relating to manufacturing and burning of bricks
have been lifted by the defendants and there is no possibility of reopening the
partnership business. For the interest of all the partners, both the plaintiff and
defendants wants the partnership firm to dissolve. The DW-1, who is one of the
partner also stated in his examination-in-chief that defendants have no
objection to dissolve the firm as prayed by the plaintiff. The share of the
plaintiff in the profit and loss of the business carried out by the partnership is
20% and that of defendant No. 2 is 44.98%, defendant No. 3 is 25%, defendant
No. 4 is 10%, defendant No. 5 is 0.02% and it has been mentioned in the Deed
of Partnership marked as Exbt. 1 Series. So, the plaintiff and defendants will
have to share the profit and loss of the business of the firm as per the share
mentioned in the Deed of Partnership after dissolution of the firm. The plaintiff
and defendants have placed separate statement of accounts and audit report of
the firm. They have engaged their choice of Chartered Accountant for
preparation of those statement of Account and Audit report. Defendants have
produced computer typed Cash book marked as Exbt. I, J, K, L and Ledger
book marked as Exbt. E, F, G, H, respectively (subject to objection) and those
Cash book and Ledger book have created doubt regarding its authenticity in the
mind of this court. Generally, entries in the Cash books and Ledger books are
made on daily basis showing daily transaction of business. The cashier or any
competent person authorized, put signature after completion of making entries.
But, in this instance case, the Cash books and Ledger books produced by the
defendants does not have entry in the cash books regarding daily business of
the firm. It seems that the defendants have made those Cash books and Ledger
books in a hurry, soon after the dispute erupted between partners to show that
daily business of the firm is maintained properly. So, with this documents in
hand, this court cannot come to conclusion in deciding the share of the
partners. Besides that without dissolution of the firm, it is not wise to decide
and declare the share of the partners in a partnership firm. The business of the
firm came to an end just after three years of start of its business and the
partnership firm could not be dissolve amicable between the partners inspite of
attempt made by the plaintiff for amicable settlement. Thus, from the above
discussion, I am of the considered view that the partnership firm name and
style as “M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks Industries” situated at Ratanpur under Belonia
Sub-Division has to be dissolve and the statement of accounts and audit report
shall be prepared afresh by a competent Chartered Accountant relying on the
actual documents of the firm and on the basis of Statement of Accounts and
Audited Reports, the plaintiff is entitled to get his share in the business of the
firm as per the terms and condition of the Deed of Partnership. So, issue No.
(iv) and (viii) are decided in favour of the plaintiff."
[5]
After conclusion of the trial the suit was decreed on contest
with the following order:
“[50]
In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is hereby decreed on contest
with cost with the following decrees:
(i) The partnership firm under the name and style of “M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks
Industries” the defendant No.1, constituted by the plaintiff and the defendant
Nos.2, 3, 4 and 5 by a registered Deed of Partnership vide No.IV-134 dated,
10.07.2009 is hereby dissolved and,
(ii) The defendant No.3 is directed to render correct accounts of the
partnership firm to the plaintiff for the period 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12
within 03(three) months from the date of judgment.
[51] Thus, the suit is disposed of.
[52] Prepare decree accordingly and put-up for signature before me within
14(fourteen) days from today, latest on 20th June, 2022.
[53] The judgment is given under my hand and seal of this court on this the 7th
June, 2022.
[54] Make necessary entry in the relevant trial register and as well as CIS.”
[6]
The decree was prepared in the following terms:
“It is ordered and decreed that***
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is hereby decreed on contest with cost
with the following decrees:
i. The partnership firm under the name and style of “M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks
Industries” the defendant No.1, constituted by the plaintiff and the defendant
Nos.2, 3, 4 and 5 by a registered Deed of Partnership vide No.IV-134 dated
10.07.2009 is hereby dissolved and
ii. The defendant No.3 is directed to render correct accounts of the partnership
firm to the plaintiff for the period 2009-10, 2010-11 and 2011-12 within
03(three) months for the date of judgment.
Thus, the suit is disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly and put-up for signature before me within
14(fourteen) days from today, latest on 20th June, 2022.”
[7]
Petitioner was aggrieved as the findings in relation to issue Nos.
(iv) & (viii) relating to proportionate share of fixed/immovable assets and
movable assets of the Firm and the share of the plaintiff and defendant Nos.1
to 5 in the capital, assets and liabilities of the Partnership Firm on the date of
the dissolution were not incorporated in the decree. The learned court
rendered its findings on the issue Nos. (iv) & (viii) in the judgment dated 7th
June, 2022 but in the operative part of the judgment it only held that the
partnership firm under the name and style of “M/S. Rajlaxmi Bricks
Industries” the defendant No.1, constituted by the plaintiff and the defendant
Nos.2, 3, 4 and 5 by a registered Deed of Partnership dated 10.07.2009 was
dissolved. Further, defendant No.3 was directed to render correct accounts of
the partnership firm to the plaintiff for the period 2009-10, 2010-11 and
2011-12 within 03(three) months from the date of judgment. The suit was
disposed of with a direction to prepare the decree. Two of the issues in
relation to the determination of the share of the plaintiffs and defendant Nos.
1 to 5 in the partnership firm which stood dissolved, though dealt with by the
learned trial court, did not mention in the operative part of the judgment. The
learned trial court passed the decree confining it to the operative part of the
judgment which dealt with only the dissolution of the partnership firm and
for rendering of correct accounts by respondent No.3, for the period 2009-10,
2010-11 and 2011-12 in question. In such circumstances, the decree did not
reflect the findings of the learned trial court. Both the parties would,
therefore, be affected if the share of the dissolved partnership firm is not
proportionately apportioned between the erstwhile partners, which comprises
the plaintiff/petitioner and the respondent Nos. 2, 3, 4 and 5. This could also
amount to denial of effective relief after a duly contested litigation between
the parties.
[8]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel for the respondents
has pointed out that the provision of Section 152 of the CPC may not be the
correct remedy for the plaintiff/petitioner to seek correction of the decree as
this provision confines for clerical or arithmetical mistakes only. Section 152
of the CPC reads as under:
“152. Amendment of judgments, decrees or orders.- Clerical or arithmetical
mistakes in judgments, decrees or orders or errors arising therein from any
accidental slip or omission may at any time be corrected by the Court either of
its own motion or on the application of any of the parties.”
[9]
However, if the impugned order is allowed to survive, the
parties may not get effective relief as determined by the learned trial court on
all the issues. As such, this court is of the opinion that the impugned order
deserves to be set aside. However, this Court leaves it open to the parties to
approach the learned Trial Court under the relevant provision of the CPC for
correction of the judgment and decree in question for incorporating the reliefs
granted by the learned trial court in substance.
[10]
Accordingly, the instant petition is allowed. However, any
observations made hereinabove are limited to the correctness of the
impugned order dated 6th June, 2023 and may not be treated as view
expressed by this Court on the question of apportionment of the proportionate
share of the dissolved firm which of course is to be governed by the findings
rendered by the learned trial court in the judgment dated 07.06.2022.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Munna S MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2024.01.12 14:59:53 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review