The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In the light of the above discussions, the judgments and decrees passed by both the Courts below stand set aside and quashed.
16. Consequently, the second appeal preferred by the plaintiff/appellant stands allowed. Resultantly, the plaintiff/appeallant along with proforma defendant no.4, 5 and 6 are entitled to get 2(two) kanis of the suit land; legal heirs of Jogendra Chandra Debnath i.e. proforma defendant nos.7-16 are entitled to get 2(two) kanis of suit land; the legal heirs of Binanda Debnath i.e. proforma defendant nos.18-25 will get 2(two) kanis of land and the legal heirs of Radhaballab Debnath, i.e. Defendant/respondents nos.1, 2, 3 and proforma defendant/respondent no.26 will get their shares of 1(one) kani i.e. 14,665 share out of 1,00,000 unit share.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.28 of 2021
Sri Niranjan Chandra Nath
S/O.- Lt. Nibaran Ch. Nath
Vill. Nayagaon
P.O. Tilthai, P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
…. Appellant(s)
Versus
1.
2.
3.
Smt. Nirmala Debi
W/O-Lt. Radhaballab Debnath
Smt. Sabitri Nath
W/O-Lt. Rameswar Nath
Sri. Rahul Nath
S/O-Lt. Rameswar Nath
Being minor represented by his natural guardian mother
Smt. Sabitri Nath, W/O-Lt. Rameswar Nath.
All resident of Vill. Nayagaon
P.O. Tilthai
P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
….Principal Respondent(s)
4.
Smt. Joymati Nath
W/O-Lt. Nibaran Chandra Debnath
Vill. Nayagaon
P.O. Tilthai
P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
5.(a) Sri. Sukhamoy Nath (Husband)
S/O- Lt. Ramesh Nath
(b) Sri. Pijush Nath (Son)
S/O- Sri. Sukhamoy Nath
(c) Sri Sukhen Nath (Son)
S/O-Sri. Sukhamoy Nath
All are resident of Vill. Nayagaon
P.O. Tilthai P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
(d) Smt. Suniti Rani Nath (Daughter)
W/O-Sri. Kishalay Nath
Resident of Vill. Laxminagar
P.O. Kherengjuri
P.S. Churaibari
Dist. North Tripura.
6.
Smt. Prabati Nath
W/O-Sri Durga Chandra Nath
D/O-Lt. Nibaran Chandra Nath
Vill. Rowa
P.O. Rowa Bazar
P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
7.
Smt. Sarojini Nath
W/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
8.
Sri Sunil Debnath
S/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
9.
Sri Sushil Ch. Debnath
S/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
10.
Sri Ajit Debnath
S/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
11.
Smt. Sandhaya Rani Nath
W/O-Sri Iswar Nath
D/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
All are the resident of Vill. Purba Haripur
P/O. Laljuri Bazar
P.S. Kanchanpur
Dist. North Tripura
12.
Smt. Kalpana Nath
W/O-Lt. Pramode Nath
D/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
Vill. Subhasnagar
P.O & P.S-Kanchanpur
Dist. North Tripura
13.
Smt. Anjana Nath
W/O- Sri Sukhamoy Nath
D/O-Lt. Jogendra Ch. Debnath
Vill. Rabindranagar
P.O/P.S-Kanchanpur.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
North Tripura
Lt. Anita Nath, W/O-Sri. Narayan Nath, D/O- Lt.
Jogendra Chandra Debnath having died leaving behind
His surviving legal heirs namely:
Sri Narayan Nath
S/O-Lt. Nilmani Debnath
Sri Amar Debnath
S/O-Sri Narayan Nath
Smt. Supriya Nath
D/O-Sri Narayan Nath
Being minor represented by her natural guardian father
Sri Narayan Nath
S/O-Lt. Nilmani Debnath
All are the resident of
Vill. Subhasnagar (Southern side of Fire Service)
P.O/P.S-Kanchanpur
Dist. North Tripura
Deleted as per order dated 07.03.2022.
Sri Biswamitra Debnath
S/O-Lt. Binanda Debnath
Sri Gopal Debnath
S/O-Lt. Binanda Debnath
All are the resident of Vill. Nayagaon
P.O. Tilthai P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
Sri. Haripada Debnath
S/O-Lt. Binanda Debnath
Vill. East Huplong
P.O. Tilthai
P.S. Panisagar
Dist. North Tripura
Smt. Maya Rani Debi
W/O-Sri Gopi Debnath
D/O-Lt. Binanda Debnath
Vill. Rajnagar
P.O. Laxmipur Ananda Bazar
P.S. Dharmanagar
Dist. North Tripura
Late Radhapada Debnath, S/O-Lt. Binanda Debnath having died leaving behind
his surviving legal heirs namely:
22.
23.
24.
25.
Sri. Subhadra Debnath
W/O-Lt. Radhapada Debnath
Sri Gautam Debnath
S/O- Lt. Radhapada Debnath
Smt. Mousumi Debnath
D/O- Lt. Radhapada Debnath
Sri Ranjit Debnath
S/O-Lt. Radhapada Debnath
All are the resident of
C/O-Ranadhir Deb
Ashram Road
P.O. Chandrapur
P.S. Dharmanagar
Dist. North Tripura
26.(I) Smt. Ratna Nath,
Wife of Lt. Ranu Nath, Care of Sri. Lal Mohan Nath,
Resident of Vill-Noagaon, P.O-Tilthai, P.S- Dharmanagar,
Pin-799260, Dharmanagar, North Tripura
(II) Sri Ramen Debnath, age about 17 years
(III) Sri Raajdip Debnath, age about 3 years,
(both are sons of Lt. Ranu Nath) being minor represented by their
mother and next friend Smt. Sumati Nath, (Second wife) of Lt. Ranu
Nath, resident of Tangi Bari, P.O-Lalcherra, P.S- Dharmanagar,
North Tripura, Pin-799260.
….Proforma Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
None
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
:
28.03.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (Oral)
This is a second appeal filed against the judgment dated
03.09.2021 and decree dated 07.09.2021 passed by learned First
Appellate Court in Title Appeal No.06 of 2019 whereby and whereunder
the learned Appellate Court confirmed the judgment dated 21.01.2019
and preliminary decree dated 01.02.2019 passed in Title Suit (P) 14/2017
by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
2.
Briefly stated, the plaintiff/appellant had instituted a suit for
partition and declaration of his right title and interest over the suit land.
According to the plaintiff, the suit land measures about 2.87 acres i.e.
7(seven) kanis. From the facts it is elucidated that the predecessors of the
plaintiff/appellant and defendant/respondents, namely Nibaran Chandra
Nath, Jogendra Chandra Debnath, Radhaballab Debnath, Binanda
Debnath have jointly purchased a land measuring 8(eight) kanis. It is the
case of the plaintiff that out of 8(eight) kanis one of the purchasers
namely Radhaballab Debnath had sold 1 kani of land to some other
person. To partition the balance land, measuring 7(seven) kanis, the
plaintiff/appellant
had
approached
the
defendants,
mainly
the
defendant/respondents nos.1 and 2, but, they paid no heed to such request
of the plaintiff/appellant compelling him to institute the present suit for
partition.
3.
The plaintiff/appellant in his suit has sought for partition of
7(seven) kanis of land, i.e. 2.87 acres since 1(one) kani of land was sold
by Radhaballab Debnath during his lifetime. Defendant/respondents
nos.1, 2 and 3 and proforma defendant/respondent no.26 are the legal
heirs of Lt. Radhaballab Debnath. None of the defendants except one of
the legal heirs of Jogendra Chandra Debnath, namely Proforma
defendant/respondent no.9 appeared, contested the suit and filed written
statement. Thereafter, on the basis of pleadings, following issues were
framed:
“i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and
manner?
ii) Whether there is any cause of action for filing of the suit?
iii) Whether the plaintiff is a joint share holder of the suit property
with the defendants?
iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get decree of partition of the
suit land to the extent of 25% share of his deceased predecessor in
interest of the suit land?
v) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to any other relief(s)?”
4.
Evidences were adduced by both the parties. After completion of
recording evidences, arguments were heard. Thereafter, the learned Civil
Judge, Senior Division, North Tripura, Dharmanagar had passed
judgment decreeing the suit of the plaintiff over 7(seven) kanis of land,
wherein the learned Civil Judge directed to distribute the land amongst
the plaintiff/appellant and the defendants/respondents in equal shares
having taken into account the original land measuring 8(eight) kanis. The
plaintiff/appellant became aggrieved by the judgment and decree passed
by the learned trial Court for the reason that he had sought for partition of
the suit land, which measures 2.87 acres, and thus, preferred first appeal
before the learned District Judge, Dharmanagar, North Tripura. Learned
District Judge upheld the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court.
Hence, this second appeal.
5.
At the time of admission of this appeal, following substantial
questions of law were formulated:
“ Whether the findings of both the Courts below are perverse in
decreeing the suit for partition amongst the purchasers of 8(eight)
kanis of land in equal shares irrespective of the fact that one of the
purchasers had sold one kani of land out of his total share of two
kanis?”
6.
Notices were served upon the defendant/respondents, but, they did
not turn up despite receipt of notices. As such, I have taken up the matter
for hearing in their absence.
7.
I have heard Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for
the plaintiff/appellant. None appeared for the respondents without step.
8.
Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel has drawn my attention to the
schedule of the plaint to point out as regards the quantum of the suit land
to which the plaintiff/appellant had sought for partition. I have found that
the
suit
land
measures
2.87
acres
i.e.
7(seven)
kanis.
The
plaintiff/appellant in his plaint also has stated as to how the distribution of
the shares of the parties to the suit be declared at para 15 of the plaint.
According to him, Nibaran Chandra Debnath will get share of land,
measuring 28,445 (unit taken as 1,00,000); Jogendra Chandra Debnath
also will get 28,445; Binanda Debnath will get 28,445; Radhaballab
Debnath will get 14,665, since he had sold one kani of land out of his
2(two) kanis during his lifetime. The plaintiff/appellant has specifically
stated at para 16 of the plaint that the principal defendant/respondent
nos.1, 2, and 3 and proforma defendant/respondent no.26 being the legal
heirs of Radhaballab Debnath are entitled to the shares of 14,665 jointly.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant has further submitted that both
the Courts below have miserably erred on facts in not considering the fact
that Radhaballab Debnath during his lifetime had sold one kani of land
out of his total share of 2(two) kanis which has been reflected in two
Khatians in favour of all the legal heirs of the four original purchasers.
These two khatians were brought into record and marked as Exbt-1 and 2
and non-consideration of such material evidence renders the judgments
and decrees passed by both the Courts below as perverse.
10.
The above submissions of learned counsel appearing for the
appellant leads me to go through the evidence adduced by the plaintiff
(PW.1) and the answering defendant, who deposed as DW.1. PW.1 has
specifically stated in his cross-examination that he has no objection if the
suit land is partitioned in conformity with the quantum of land as
recorded in the khatians created in respect of the plaintiff and defendants
after proper physical enquiry of the possessions of the respective parties
over the suit land, which are in consonance of the original purchase deed.
11.
I have perused the khatians wherein the total quantum of land
recorded in favour of the legal heirs of Radhaballab Debnath i.e.
defendant/respondents nos.1, 2, and 3 and proforma defendant/respondent
no.26 to the extent of 14,665 i.e. 1(one) kani. DW.1 during his deposition
has stated that he has no objection if the suit land is partitioned in
accordance with law.
12.
At this juncture, I have perused the judgment of both the Courts
below. I find that both the Courts below have taken into account total
purchased land measuring 8(eight) kanis, irrespective of the fact that
Radhaballab Debnath, one of the four purchasers had sold one kani of
land from his share of 2(two) kanis. The legal heirs of Radhaballab
Debnath did not contest the suit. They did not even file written statement
and there is no denial on the part of the legal heirs of Radhaballab
Debnath that their predecessor had sold one kani out of his share of
2(two) kanis.
13.
In view of this, both the Courts below have erred on facts in
partitioning the suit land considering the entire land measuring 8(eight)
kanis and distributing the said originally purchased land of 8(eight) kanis
equally amongst the plaintiff/appellant and the defendants/respondents.
14.
Situated thus, in my considered view, the findings of both the
Courts below are perverse as both the Courts misconstrued the facts
apparent on the face of the records i.e., ignoring the suit land mentioned
in the schedule of the plaint as well as the shares of the parties to the lis as
are recorded in khatians, Exbt.-1 and Exbt.-2.
15.
In the light of the above discussions, the judgments and decrees
passed by both the Courts below stand set aside and quashed.
16.
Consequently,
the
second
appeal
preferred
by
the
plaintiff/appellant stands allowed. Resultantly, the plaintiff/appeallant
along with proforma defendant no.4, 5 and 6 are entitled to get 2(two)
kanis of the suit land; legal heirs of Jogendra Chandra Debnath i.e.
proforma defendant nos.7-16 are entitled to get 2(two) kanis of suit land;
the legal heirs of Binanda Debnath i.e. proforma defendant nos.18-25 will
get 2(two) kanis of land and the legal heirs of Radhaballab Debnath, i.e.
Defendant/respondents nos.1, 2, 3 and proforma defendant/respondent
no.26 will get their shares of 1(one) kani i.e. 14,665 share out of 1,00,000
unit share.
17.
Draw the preliminary decree as per the aforesaid distribution of
land.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review